Irene is really regaining confidence in singing this comeback. Her voice has always been good, very soothing.

@666mafiamongers

6 ай бұрын

White Night by Bae-Chu is one of the most soothing songs to listen to!

@Eachae

2 ай бұрын

Yeah , her voice is really soothing and i lovong it more

Wendy is crazy good 🔥😍

@prismatism

6 ай бұрын

Wendy always slays. Truly their generation’s main vocal.

@eyebrowstj

6 ай бұрын

Fact 👍👍

@rdiasta3629

6 ай бұрын

Yes my queen as always❤

@wanthee

6 ай бұрын

AS ALWAYS

@Eachae

2 ай бұрын

​@@prismatism fact!

Wendy always serve her vocal. She's so good at singing

내가 레드벨벳을 아끼는 이유.. 예상치 못한 1위에 감격, 감동도 있었을텐데 평정 유지하면서 라이브..ㄷㄷ 그리고 아이린 솔로 빨리 나와야겠다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 보컬이 갈수록 더 좋아진다

@user-eq6m720

5 ай бұрын

아이린 솔로 개같이 존버...

Irene’s voice is so clear

Wendy's voice is undeniably the most stable and clearer voice ever during any kpop idols encore, really the best vocalist 💙

@broskiyt12

5 ай бұрын

shes the best gg vocalist in 3rd gen for reasons

Wendy is sick but her voice 😭🫡💯

irene was always this stable but have always had few lines and other register. when she had to cover others part she sounded so gooood

Proof Irene deserves more lines:

@toddpacker867

6 ай бұрын

It’s great to see Yeri and Irene with lots more line this comeback

@Lee_Sohee960

6 ай бұрын

@@toddpacker867yes. it's because they decided to give rap lines to Joy and Wendy, that Irene and Yeri got more singing lines. I wish they would do this more often. Irene has a good singing voice, Yeri is holding her own, and Wendy has a good flow when rapping.

Wendy always making sure that she can sing her lines and adlibs live from the studio to the stages! Our hardworking queen!

irene vocals is actually so good and stable

Irene is singing clearly and loudly. Also Joy's run is so good, it's not easy to sing it

Wendy vocal queen! Her voice so stable even tough she is jumping around not just stand still

Wendy is a vocal goddess 💎💎💎

Seulgi still singing with jumping wow

Wendy stabil voice so Amazing! 😭💙💙💙

2:26 미쳤음

Irene’s vocals 🧎‍♀️

웬디 보컬 말도안된다 들을때마다 놀람

wendy did a great job 🎉💙

This is the 2nd MR remove encore video of chill kill i watched and WENDY is really just slaying studio version and live version even if she is jumping around and having fun.

Wendy ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

Wendy is god ❤

Wendy 💙💙💙💙💙

Wendy always surprising vocally

YERI'S VOCAL IS GREAT

0:01 wtf this is just opening but have sent me to heaven 😭

Irene vocal❤❤

이렇게 들으니깐 너무 신나보여서 더 좋다 ㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋ 아 뿌듯해 ㅠㅠ 1위 축하해 증말….. 신난 강쥐들아..

Wow Wendy!!!

Yeri lower register sounds great 💜

@rissstyles2408

2 ай бұрын

She's always having fun in encore..

Based on this video only, i'll rank from the clearest : 1. Wendy 2. Irene 3. Joy/Seulgi 4. Yeri

I can’t imagine how excited and surprised they still were but they managed to sing and perform for us🥹🥹🥹 they sound so good

Joy wendy and irene ate this

I love yeri’s lower register 🥰

this era is one for the books. love my girls sm!

Wendy the backbone

wendyずば抜けてうまい🫶

Wendy te amo ❤

Irene ❤

I love this 1:40 irene's part

As Wendy bias, I have to say Irene got much much better comparing from the last two comeback, don’t get me wrong she’s always good but the stability in her voice improved a lotttt. After Wendy 2nd solo comeback, I would love to see Irene get her first solo. I cannot wait ❤🎉

Red Velvet always give the best live encore 😘

BEST IDOL GROUP ALIVE

Joy my tone fairy

Still one of the most decent encores in kpop mr removed 🤷‍♀️

Wendy carried as always 🙌

Wenjoyrene 💖💖💖

y'all are acting so weird in the comments they weren't even prepared to sing cuz they thought they weren't gonna win and still did very well

no one should be wondering why Wendy is the main vocalist at this point. she has improved a lot. mind, she was actively dancing and jumping with the rest (irene doesn't jump. please. her majesty cannot jump on stage like that). breath control was at it's peak.

@taeseulrene

6 ай бұрын

Irene didn't jump as much but she was following the steps of the choreography, the other members jumped little, the only one who made an effort jumping is Yeri and that's probably why she also sounds more tired.

@boringsiot

6 ай бұрын

@@taeseulrene Live performance is Yeri's jam. i can see how much she loves it. and her vocals are always on the stable side. Joy jumped too. ahahahahhaah she got out of breath but who can blame her for that bridge. XD they're so cute during the encore

@sophsm9860

6 ай бұрын

why are you so pressed abt irene when she literally didn't do anything wrong

@boringsiot

6 ай бұрын

nope, definitely didn't do anything wrong! as taeseulrene said, she's following choreo. i don't understand why you're mad. i was not mad at her. maybe read it in a different tone. not everyone is a hater.@@sophsm9860

@leallanos-rv3rn

6 ай бұрын

​@@sophsm9860She says this because the majority of Wendy's fans hate it when the other members are praised, the truth is I still don't understand where so much insecurity comes from.

this part, my soul is like flying 2:24

joy our tone fairy🧚🏻‍♀️💚

queens of vocal 🔥💅

Joy ❤❤ yeri ❤❤ Wendy ❤❤❤ Irene ❤❤❤ seulgi ❤❤❤ red velvet real vocals

New gen gurlies should take note on Red Velvet vocals

This is why they are the best

이게 방방 뛰면서 부르는 라이브라고...? 레드벨벳이 롱런 하는 이유가 아닐까.

we trust in red velvet vocal

My girls !! BEST VOCAL!!

RV IS ART

proud of them🤍

woww irene had the most stable vocals amazimg my queen

I mean….Its uhm..thank god for Wendy😃

Wendy really carries the group

All their vocals are perfect examples of what each vocal position should be capable of within Kpop. The sub vocalists give clear vocalisations with a fair amount of stability. The lead vocalist can produce higher quality sounds with greater control and stability. The main vocalist has a fully developed technique that can be implemented with ease, strong breath control, stability and vocal clarity. A perfect display of five good singers performing well at their individual skill level. Red Velvet is the blueprint for vocal positions.

@ardentthoughts9750

5 ай бұрын

Personally, I wouldn't use this as the "perfect example" as they are all pitchy and unstable (notice some of the notes are shaking in a sense) here except Wendy.

wendyyyy ❤🎉

some notes are flat but imagine preforming at 6 o clock in the morning

@CleverUsername69420

5 ай бұрын

Is that when this was filmed? Jesus no wonder. Having to sing that early is brutal

@DTmaster

5 ай бұрын

@@CleverUsername69420 Yes Music Bank is 4am getting together and 6am recording

Irene 1:40

Joy my bias queen

They know they have back ground music but Red Velvet prove us that they have stable and strong voice they ate 💛💜💚🩷💙

2:40 seulgi so stable

mereka bersenang-senang 😄

its encore so they did not try and hear their voice properly, the result is still amazing

❤❤

seulgi sounds tired😅

@Revel_Luvie

5 ай бұрын

She's jumping around, it's normal-

Wendy hard carried as always

Wendy and Irene carried this one, Seulgi, Joy and Yeri weren't that good but it just a normal encore. Things i noticed, 1st, Yerim voice just can't go as deep as the edited/final version, she did it great tho. 2nd, Joy should have started the bridge since she has the softer voice, and then Seulgi and finally Wendy, just like they did in Zimzalabim.

@shou199

5 ай бұрын

Idk I think yeri is still not confident in showing her voice because in chorus when they sing together her voice sounds so nice, but then in her solo she deliberately forces her voice 😔

Is Irene vocal tier is still f+ ?, i think her vocal got developped a lot

@FutusGuda

6 ай бұрын

She's still so tense, push, nasal, high larynx and there is no depp in her voice. You can clearly Differentiate between Red Velvet's vocal line and Irene's singing techniques. Very different.

@leallanos-rv3rn

6 ай бұрын

​@@FutusGudaWhy do you hate other members being praised so much? I usually defend when people criticize Wendy's dance technique but if her fans are going to continue to minimize the efforts of others then they don't make it easy

@FutusGuda

6 ай бұрын

@@leallanos-rv3rn Do I really hate other members when they are praised? I'm just telling the truth, Irene really has to learning about vocal harder, even Taemin can developed from f+ to b-, there is still room for learn for Irene. But for now, Irene is underdeveloped vocalist 🙄🙄

@leallanos-rv3rn

6 ай бұрын

@@FutusGuda Why are you getting defensive? I'm just saying that Irene has constantly improved vocally to the point that many non-fans are asking for her solo album, if you're not able to see her improvement then that's your problem

@FutusGuda

6 ай бұрын

@@leallanos-rv3rn girl, She's stil have so much room to learn. Maybe she improved but not that much. her problem with her nasal, high larynx, breath control, whiny, and push still there. 💜💜

Seulgi still slays her lines even though she's in an excited mood and jumping around casually. The quality of most of her live vocals shows that she's still one of the best vocalists out there (while also being one of the best dancers)

The did really well even though they were jumping around and this song is already really high pitch with uncomfortable parts. I just wanna talk with whoever organized which part goes to who.

@chrissyalapo-calg9748

4 ай бұрын

😂why? What would you change?

All of them eat cds but Joy is so stable, she literally ate the whole studio.

This guy is trynna bring people down!! Even tho it backfires

yeah..😅👍

Wow yeri low register

What even are 1:14 and 2:49 🤦‍♀ Kudos to Irene, ngl. Big improvement from not having a solo song in Monster EP to this.

@ardentthoughts9750

5 ай бұрын

1:00 to 1:04 1:12 😢

@SooyoungParkk

5 ай бұрын

They were jumping a lot there so I think they kind of run out of breath lol

@Revel_Luvie

5 ай бұрын

They were jumping around and moving constantly, it's normal that their voices sound unstable, notice how stable Seulgi sounds in the bridge, it's because she's standing still-

aduuuhh kok gitu suaranyaaa cuma wendy yg OK

they sound good but they’re kinda below the pitch a lot

Is Seulgi sick? She sounds stuffy here

@horizonkyun7203

5 ай бұрын

she’s always a lil stuffy

@rise_zen7

Ай бұрын

Can you sing better than them? They are vocal Queens.

bts could never

god poor joy 😭😭 i almost feel bad for her flopping her high note

@jazzminminjazz5118

5 ай бұрын

She is not the rv member you have to feel bad lmao

@Be.my.chill.kill.127

5 ай бұрын

Even during the recording behind she was struggling, i can't blame her, that part is actually hard.

@devenm1580

5 ай бұрын

@@Be.my.chill.kill.127 yeah, i think if she works on her breath support i think that high note for her is very much achievable. she was able to get the first half of the high not and the end of the high note. she is still my bias in the end ❤❤

@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062

5 ай бұрын

That note was too high for her to begin with, even she was struggling with her highnote in Umpah Umpah

@zink_d1665

4 ай бұрын

She was not bad and sang all notes properly. Seulgi made lots more mistakes, and I was surprised. I guess she was not in her best conditions. They are good in live singing anyway.

huh what funny about that? 4th gen can't even doing this

yeri sounds drunk 😅

@hoangphuongchinh6954

6 ай бұрын

She’s too excited 😂

@JDlupinT5

6 ай бұрын

Yea she's jumping when singing!! So is normal! Jumping raise your heart rate high

@taeseulrene

6 ай бұрын

Yeri, Irene and Joy were sick, not to mention that Yeri was enduring the pain in her back while jumping, we have to be more understanding towards Yeri.

@pillowbakes3199

6 ай бұрын

@@taeseulrene Wendy was sick too. but 3 of them sounds good tho..(for me)

@edanuryilmaz2802

6 ай бұрын

She just posted that she has influenza

BTS could never

ummmm okay😂

so it's not mr removed thing fault, 3 of them just don't sound stable and that good

@sqdcopaechi

6 ай бұрын

This isn't the only encore, we all know how good rv encores are.

@sooyoung6350

6 ай бұрын

lol, they actually doesnt sound “unstable” as u want them to be. More like, their voice gets cut off or get quieter whenever they’re jumping. I keep seeing akgaes everywhere😂

@Aelin38

6 ай бұрын

You can check their killing voice video. Without being emotional and focus on their singing they do better

@ae3040

6 ай бұрын

@@Aelin38 i've checked and it was heavily edited 💀

@ardentthoughts9750

6 ай бұрын

​@@sooyoung6350Nah. From a technical standpoint, they're quite pitchy here except Wendy.

irene off key 😭😭😭

@ardentthoughts9750

5 ай бұрын

Ntm. She actually did better than the others. For this encore, it's Wendy >>>> Irene >> Joy > Seulgi >> Yeri in terms of pitch and stability.

@allenjesrickgonzales4592

2 ай бұрын

Nope. Sit down sis

예리야 다른멤버들 발목잡지 말고 연습좀 더 해라 제발

@user-er7bn4rc6v

6 ай бұрын

이거 앵콜라이브여서 예리는 그냥 흥이 오른채 시종일관 기뻐 날뛰고 있었는데 노래가 제대로 될 리가.... 제대로 무대를 한 거였다면 이해라도 하겠는데 이건 좀 억까지

@JDlupinT5

6 ай бұрын

Yeri is jumping when singing!! Pls take note

@RawrRoar-bl7xf

6 ай бұрын

​@@JDlupinT5Others are jumping too. Pls take note.

@colorsoftae

6 ай бұрын

​@@RawrRoar-bl7xfIgual se escucha bien cuando ya no salta, relájese.

@colorsoftae

6 ай бұрын

​@@RawrRoar-bl7xfIgual se escucha bien cuando ya no salta, relájese.

yeah…….. Wendy is the only good singer in this group 😭💀

@idek9749

4 ай бұрын

Cap

@jasmine-yp3mw

4 ай бұрын

Wendy is my bias but nope rv have 5 vocal queens

bts could never