IMO, this voice really recaptures what made the original concept great: explaining the horrible grimdark universe of 40k with a really calm and collected enthusiasm. Really nice

@KanyeWeast

8 ай бұрын

I agree completely. This one is very nice, perhaps even a bit too aggressive imo

@user-wf3nj4ix5e

7 ай бұрын

quite the opposite i believe AI david attenborough is far more superior

@imjustsam1745

7 ай бұрын

I could easily see myself growing to prefer this voice.

@MrGrim

7 ай бұрын

Agreed, it's a well constructed voice and a tempered script

@heatrayzvideo3007

7 ай бұрын

I think it's not anywhere as good

This voice is killer man. I like the soft spoken yet very confident wisdom

@Azubrael

8 ай бұрын

Careful Scholar, I think this guy wants you to whisper sweet nothings into his ear.

@ShermanistDruid

8 ай бұрын

Well Attenborough did do a "whispery" voice often because he was in the field next to the things he talked about, current voice could use some of that.

@richipotes

8 ай бұрын

Great work!!! Love it

@rydekk-4644

4 ай бұрын

@@Azubrael This "guy" is AI.

@neckreth

4 ай бұрын

All hail the Attenborough machine spirit

The voice is perfect for these sort of videos. An elderly man that served his duty for the God Emperor, now teaches the next generation with the sermons and histories of the universe and those that live there.

This voice, is the next best thing to Attenborough's, please keep this one!🥺

@NGorso1

7 ай бұрын

YES! KEEEEP!

Right away, I love that the narrator is in-character. The Imperiums terraforming processes are some of the most advanced technology I've seen them use. The STC with that intel was a big help, for sure.

I expected something closer to a feral world, or at most a continent-sized network of large farms connected by trains. This sounds like the most high tech variant of an Agri-world.

10/10 on the voice, I love it. I don't think you're going to be losing too many feathers from this rebranding!

Im gonna miss Grand magus Attenborough, but these videos are always so digestible. Ive wanted to peak at the fluff for agriworlds and other world types as much as the epic warfronts.

This voice is better than the last one used. The other one was deep to a grating extent. And this voice is closer to Attenborough. Big improvement.

@Ghostgate611

7 ай бұрын

Not even slightly close to Attenborough but it's still cool

Both voices so far have been great. I think if you pick the voices selectively depending on the topics, then they'll be both very effective.

@ckl9390

7 ай бұрын

Where the theme of the subject matter overlaps it may be possible to have a guest lecturer (another voice model) present.

Out of all the crazy stuff in the 40K universe, this seems the most realistic.

@alexandervlaescu9901

4 ай бұрын

Except it seems that author who wrote about agriworlds did literally zero research on how plants actually grow. The most glaring stupidity is how high intensity farming will result in the soil breaking down into sand and dust. On the contrary plant roots tend to hold together soil and the above surface layer of the plant resists air erosion. It's true that high intensity farming can reduce yields and maybe quality but the factors behind that can be easily resolved or are non-existent to these agriworlds. One such example is how microorganisms need enough time to process the ingredients of the soil to a form that a plant can absorb and digest. Similarly certain nutrients are bound in the soil and are gradually dissolved in the water of the soil (nutrients need to be dissolved in water for plants to be able to absorb them). There is no reason for an agriworld to progressively become a deathworld unless you intend to do so. Everything is monitored and supplemented. Literally no reason for the world to die. You would definitely need to constantly import nutrients from nitrogen (which is needed in the largest amounts) to micronutrients like iron. Honestly you don't really want to kill all life on the planet. On the contrary, you would want to introduce certain bioengineered species that would help the plants grow more optimally. You would definitely need certain species to process matter into easily absorbable nutrients for the plant. There are certain organisms that live in a symbiotic relationship with the plant and reside in their roots. They help in absorbing water and nutrients. Proper ventilation is also managed by certain organisms like worms. Lastly, in such a controlled environment it is really hard for insects to be introduced. Even if they were introduced you wouldn't really want to use insectides constantly because they can build up resilience or even immunity. So the smog of insectides, herbicides and fertilizers in general is bullshit. You would also not need pesticides because the plants you use are engineered to grow in certain ways. Thus it would be easy to manage and all previous plants and their seeds should have been exterminated already. Weeds can be any plant that you don't desire to exist in a certain field. In other words, even agricultural corn or wheat or potatoes can be considered weeds if they are not supposed to be in that field.

@theotv5522

3 ай бұрын

@@alexandervlaescu9901 This is one of those cases we call "grim derp", when authors just wanna write the darkest stuff possible and ignore all logic. It's like how Imperial ships need humans to load their guns and even their reactors, resulting in poor efficiency and loss of crew (1 might say humans are abundant, but that's not the case when you're aboard a space ship, you ain't reproducing humans as manpower through the space travel). All this can be avoided by just using auto loaders, since if you invested that much into a massive space ship, you might as well try to keep it running in the long run instead of trying to save the resources (it's like investing in the best tank, but you're stingy and didn't install the breaks) Another example of authors screwing up is when they over-buff 1 of the Necron dynasty Nephrekh, that they literally have a device that can just deletes a planet with a single button, then they have to double down and say "Oh but they can see the future and the future will be bad if they start using it, so they don't use it".

this voice is a banger. the addition of breathing makes it sound super realistic

New voice is working great, I think the contrast between the grimdark of the 40k reality and a soft calm voice like Attenborough is why this works so much

Yeah definitely like this one over the last model. For me it's the cadence and this one is a lot more natural sounding than the god emperor previous one. The last one would be a good one to stand in for the big e. It has an imperious sound to it. Also i think this one fits more as the master scholar character.

Great voice, way better then the last one. Like a gentle yet firm teacher.

This voice model is great. I personaly like it better than the last, though i did like it too. This calm soft voice is just near perfect like the original concept. Good job

Liked both voices, love this one. I think you hit the nail on the head. Not an Attenburough copy, but still brings the same overall tone: calm and informative. That calm really does well to balance the overall grittiness of the content.

Dang it, I was really hoping the new voice would be a valley girl just to surprise everyone. Maybe that will come around come April 1st… In all seriousness, superbly done. 🙂

@patchez058

8 ай бұрын

That would have been absolutely hilarious!

@JackPiLope

8 ай бұрын

April Fools is only a few months/cycles away. All in due time.

@strawpiglet

7 ай бұрын

Good idea! I'd like to hear a variety and the occasional funny voice.

@Dillon1099

7 ай бұрын

This is actually a great idea if this current voice ever has a sick day.

Oh snap. This the one! I know you probably didn't see me asking for more of a bellisarius voice... But the omnisiah did! 🙏

Took me a while to realise the change, good job to keeping it as close as possible! Really captured his style of narrating ❤

@schnittmagier5515

4 ай бұрын

I dont know how far I had to scroll down in this comment section, but it took me quite a while to finally find a si gle comment that would not have the word "voice" in it. Thank you for reconfirming that I am not living in a gliched out simulation.

Yes yes yes! This has a very similar vibe to the original idea. The other one was cool, but felt more epic. This and the Atten-Era (name is up for debate) really capture this scholarly feeling of listening to you favorite professor reading essays in the lecture hall. Edit: It also adds some nice distance. Ican't speak for others, but I enjoy feeling like an actual scholar rather than a cadett being indoctrinated.

@ckl9390

7 ай бұрын

May I propose: Atten Erranos. I double checked and it actually translates into something Latin but not sure if it's the vibe being aimed for, "and yet the errant ones".

@kashbugg97

7 ай бұрын

@@ckl9390 personally just love the idea that your pitch includes the words "translates into something latin". I'm sold

I really LOVE this new voice! Its much more human, and still captures spirit if the Old One that started this channel :3 I think having an rotation of few voices would be really interesting!

I dont know if it will be too much work, but a variety of voices for different topics could be quite fitting, thanks for the content as always dude

@ckl9390

7 ай бұрын

Possibly as a by-product of experimentation and refinement. There is already the dour gravelly voiced general or elder statesman, and now the soft spoken and wise administrator. We'll likely see a retinue of voice models develop, each with their own character.

This is great! Love the new voice, well done!!!

This is truly a scholar's or teacher's voice - keep it!

top notch voice. I watch every video, and probably always will. The quality is always there. appreciate you

This voice is great! Thank you for uploading these with this new voice, im going to binge these while i paint my army.

I really do enjoy this new voice, I think it hits the same vibe and feeling as the original. Well done and thanks so much for your continued work on these :)

Turning brutality into poetry. Well done.

your stuff is great man keep up the good work, you make original stuff that others can't beat

Great narration; I feel the bleakness of these places. Really well done

This voice is so good, keep up the good work!!

Good to see you back, Scholar's Lore.

Shh, you had me at salubrious. Seriously outstanding voice and writing.

10/10 as always. Love the new voice. Your effort is greatly appreciated.

The voice is perfect! Keep up the good work.

I like this one best. It gets what attenborough had that made this concept was aiming for.

Yessssssss !!!!!! Best voice so far. I mean, with one exception.

This voice is fantastic, huge thumbs up!

This is it, this voice is the one.

Your writing is among the best of all 40k youtube channels.

Brutal AF ! This is awsome better than the first with the old AI well done Lore Master.

10/10 - love this new voice!

Very soothing voice! Fits really well

This hit the mark for me. Great stuff.

Good stuff!

Great work as always. I think both voices have their merit: the lower, gravellier one for the (more) war-related topics, and this one for the comparatively domestic ones.

Great voice - really enjoyable listen!

Your writing is fantastic.

I like this voice! Great work as ever!

This voice is way better too listen in my opinion. Keep up the amazing work scholar!! The emporer protects

Sounds great pal, the tone of the voice really suits your writing style.

This voice has a very John Hurt like ring to it, I approve

i like this voice more than the other one! a gentleness in there is a really nice contrast to the horrors of 40k.

New Voice sounds like a true Scholar in the Imperium

11/10, this voice is so much better than the last one.

Nailed it! Thank you 👍🏻

Great voice and I especially love the intro, it sets the scene. If he's an aged and senior administratum official, it would make sense to me that he would have some audible quirks of mechanicicus cognitive upgrades. I think both voices have their place. Great work, very fun to listen to.

Love the new voice!❤

Much better voice then the one you chose to replace the old one. I really enjoyed this video and the voice over! Please don't go back❤

Awesome new voice my man. For what It's worth from a random. I think what you did with Attenborough's voice was incredibly compassionate and respectful to the guy. Since the universe is completely fictional and socially accepted it doesn't matter if he was into it or not. What's important is that his style is really good and we are lucky to live with him now and record his voice for the internet to hear going forward. Copyright can have it's war against this and maybe it's right but I think it's cool!

OOOOoooooo I like the new voice. Very nice.

In agreement with many here - this voice sounds a lot better than the other new one and is much more similar to Attenborough. Keep up the great work!

Thank god you changed the voice man wow this is so much better I’m going to come back to you now

I love this voice better than previous one

Love this voice! Enjoyed this one more

I’m glad the new voice is having such a warm reception. And I agree, it definitely recaptures the magic of AI-ttenborough. However, I’ve also grown quite fond of the previous voice, and would love to see it return for videos that cover military &/or inquisitorial history. Another possible option would be to have it act as a “guest speaker” when discussing the military-focused history of a particular planet, or when discussing sensitive/classified information that wouldn’t be included in sermons that “professor” voice would make for the general public. Even better, you could use the two voices to demonstrate opposing viewpoints in the imperium, almost like a mock “debate” in which professor-AI would make a meeker &/or more knowledge-seeking standpoint, whereas sergeant-AI would make a more ambitious &/or militaristic standpoint. On that note, it’d be nice if the two voices could be given distinct names to go along with their personalities. 😁

i was just listening a short story about a Agri world during the Horus H. time what they go through and how the entire thing was effecting them very interesting stuff they were in a far away sector so the war didnt effect them directly for a long time

I love that Warhammer can turn walking a world devoted to farming into something horrible and nightmarish

This voice is perfect keep this one for sure 100%

Your persistence is much appreciated!

Spot on with this voice

You should convert your convert into full fledged Magos Archivist with all the gravitas of the voice combined with synth.

I have now fallen for the new voice, can relax and sit back good work 👍

Yeeesss, perfect new voice

Holy shit, the new voice Is awesome

Love this voice & tone with this format. Very dystopian future government propaganda (textbook 40k) vibe. Keep up the great work!

Nailed the voice this time. Stick with this. It's awesome.

Awesome voice!

For a lack of Attenborough, this is a suitable surrogate

Excellent voice!

You've pivoted very well with this voice. Its got that dignified tone that you started off with. Sorry about all the copyright strikes, glad you've kept on though 👍🏻

I certainly prefer this new voice. Keep up the good work :)

I take back what I said, this narrator is also perfect. His voice is very soothing. I take back what I said before, this voice is very good at narrating.

THIS. THIS IS THE VOICE I WANT TO REHEAR THE STORY OF GEISTOS IN!

Digging the new voice.

Yeah this is a much softer and awesome sounding voice. The last voice was great too though, like a Primarch parting his wisdom upon us. This voice sounds more like how I'd imagine an Iterator to sound like, easier to listen to late at night too.

I find this very calming

Good choice on this voice. I prefer it over the last. Cheera

I like this voice it could be a couple cents deeper and it would be perfect. Good to hear the channel going onwards!

I'm not gonna say who the voice sounds like, but certainly is not Sir Attenborough. Well done sir!

This voice is much better than the previous one!

This is a good voice. Better than the first of the new ones.

I think this voice works really well! It sounded like a lecture from one of the old Doctors, erudite and familiar. It doesn't have the tinge of sadness or tragedy when talking about the harshness of the labor, and actually sounded a little proud when talking about how the Imperium utterly deforms planets to create agri-worlds which altogether felt more Imperial. "Behold the power of our technology, the exactness of our methods, the grim toil it requires and be thankful."

Like the voice. Keep it .

This voice is great, i did like the other voice during the later videos, but if i had to pick, i would probably pick this one. (Not counting Attenboroughs voice ofc) I listened to all your videos before the purge, i do like these second passes on topics you've already done.

Love the new voice❤

We're back in full swing, baby...

Love this voice! It really fits the topic but I’m not sure it would be great for the more dark warhammer topics

New voice was good, this one is better :D