Thanks to Live Law for bringing out so many insightful precious ideas to the public discussion

Law can't be what a lawyer/lawyers feel about. Judiciary lost its respect by it's interpretation of a written law meaning to the contrary and penchant to stray into executive domain. In a democracy courts are independent but not sovereign. It's must stay at the domain of adjudication of disputes.

Judges must have courage to encourage truth and law abiding lawyers

@litvinajoseph3401

Жыл бұрын

Every kingdom divided against itself will be ruined, and every city or house hold divided against itself will not stand. If Saturn drives out Saturn, he is divided against himself. How then can his kingdom stand.

Lawyers are fully independent till date. But hooligan and fun of law and twisting of law for self motives must be curtailed. Please share more examples as well when lawyers were curtailed. This will be insightful.

Indian judiciary lost its moorings when transgressed primary decency it required in interpretation of wordings of Constitution. When asked point blank, many judges squirm on their seats, that by which stretch of imagination you can take a consultation as a unilateral veto?

Did we have these type of discussions before 2014! Unfortunately we are in that state

@sirajuddinzubair2234

Жыл бұрын

The situation at that time was not vulnerable as it is today.

@gopalsoornahalli7634

Жыл бұрын

Because then situation has not deteriorated this much beyond 2014 👍

Great talk Mr. Sondhi. Very informative. On straight on. !

Common people concern is about getting timely justice, if judiciary not fit to be fulfill the expectation of common people then it would be considered failed judicial system and if collegium is part of the system for appointment of judges, then it's also a failed system. Reform in judicial system is inevitable.

If this is the case with learneded advocates, what will be the plight of ordinary people?

Human rights protection is very important. Advocates rally in each city is required to create legal awareness in the public.

Correct and good topic and need of hour.

Sir golden words that petitioner wants after all relief high regards fm retd lecturer kalburgi karnataka

Last few of CJI have been mute spectators to what’s happening in country, we see a flicker of hope in CJI Chandrachud who looks to take on head on for what is right - hopefully things will change over time and judiciary will again be known for independence

District judiciary is in very deep sleep in disposable of divorce cases. The both male & female are running years together behind family courts.

For a single line of Constitution argued in a division bench of madras high court, 10lacks cost imposed later withdrawn, this is the attitude of judges in mhc

Country must has lost a most intelligent Judge.

We are blessed relation of Desh BandhuChittaranjanDas

Very thoughtful insight. Appreciate it.

Supreme court directions in case of arrest are there.still violations of directions are going on some where and someone. There is need of specific website to receive such incidents by complaints in writings and videos.

Late SRDAS (Daagupta) Mentioned In His Book And In My Biography I have Enclosed Five chapter 1956-1961 And Then Ex vice chancellor of Viswa Bharati Santiniketan And SRDAS Was Very closed Associate Of Rabindra nath Tagore Nobel laureate In Literature

great insight into the situation

Awareness of 30 international human rights , which are declared by united nations in the year of 1948 , is most important

There is need of separate website to receive human rights violation incident.

Independence of judiciary from executive is correct and two independent wings of judiciary is bar and bench but it's not so, the wing of collegium is wanted to independent from bar is incorrect

Very.very.thanks

Comprehensive Judicial Reforms. When is this happening? The same story is continuing since 1947. Modern India, a modern World, need World Class judiciary. But most lawyers themselves don't want this change. Why?

👍

I agree ..it was nice to see all great people...I support collegium system..

@5tyyu

Жыл бұрын

I oppose collegium & entire Sr designation of Advocates system. Both must be abolished

Justice by law is the last straw/resort for common man - today it’s independence is questionable - how judges hold their value systems and avoid political leanings either by self or under pressure/carrot by executive ????!

Amazing man,dr sondhi

Delhi Durbar cannot rule at one stroke. We must go like a system similar to that of European Union so that judiciary will have many windows to breathe in.

Now all most of all have mobiles .All human rights violations incidents are to be received in website and website should be known to every one.There is need of separate website to receive human rights violations incident.

I don't understand what Aditya is suggesting that the govt should not have a say in the appointments? Is that process part of constitution?

"Bar becomes pliant"

Grateful to Advocate Sondhi for highlighting these perils. Hope the relevant members of the judiciary act.

Appointment of judges should only in collègium methodology .political involvement should only that of a watchdog .a subject expert only can select a good quality judiciary not any body else .

Proud of you .

Central government has to bring website to receive complaints and videos in respect of human rights violations incidents happened any where in India .Then there would be first step from the government side for protection of human rights. Human rights protection is continue process .if rights are books in existence that is in constitution ,can not be taken as a protection shield unless these rights are protected in continuing way at least by registering the violations in specific website. Prompt action is required with in short time after registration in the website.

Why Respected u u lalit sir not resigned from his post if he feel so.

@mohanshirali5779

Жыл бұрын

Why does this speaker say that the CAA act would have not passed the Constitution? The CAA was only for those religious minorities ot three countries which declared themselves as Islamic and if these minorities (Hindus,Sikhs and xtians) sought refuge in India to escape persecution. This Act was not for existing citizens of India.

In many cases , it is observed by people that some police or official may not follow supreme guide lines, unless the concerned person's are imprisoned ,who violate directions of supreme Court and concerned persons do , illegal arrests and filing charge sheets with irrelevant sections may continue, in future also,without break

can any one tell how much LAWYERS charge CLIENTs for appearing inSC transparency truth fact FINALLY TRUTH can come out will JUDGES talk about it

Appointment of district judges requires political influence and money in lakhs and crores

All insights are very thought provoking but moot point is how do we make sure judiciary is kept independent and is not pressured /influenced by executive and throwing carrots for quid pro quo arrangements- recent judgements have seen the result of this - look up to justice Chandrachud to hit it hard and ensure independent judiciary

As a practising advocate, I would say that a person should join the bar to become a lawyer and nothing more. No profession offers the kind of independence which legal profession offers. If one is chosen as a judge, it is a bonus. But, if a person joins the bar treating it as a stepping stone for becoming a HC judge, then the problems arise. HC Judges are appointed after consulting the governor of the State, which means the consent of the Chief Minister. I am rather surprised that Mr.Sondhi didn't show awareness of this essentil process of appointment of HC judges. Besides, caste and regional representation in the Court also plays a role. So it is not just the intellectual leaning of the lawyer which counts. There are other factors. So, Mr.Sondhi need not feel like a martyr!

Excuse me, being a common man, I feel some sort of things are missing, not gradually, but very fast, which, in turn,makes a damagingeffect ontheminds and losing trust and confidence.

First remove the paribarbat in judiciary system.

Which one of the two eyes is so important ? Which is more important mind or heart ? That is head or body.

Not upto the expectation level. Just a lobby of few mischievous.

What event is this?

Sudhamoy Rakhit also Has Death sentence order

In our legislation, if Supreme court violate constitution, do not respect democracy and impose poisonous ego on Public, leading anarchy and responsible for jungle Raj

Yes Suresh Das and Abhishek Das Has Death sentence order From Chief justice of India Respected and Honble Justice Dychandrachur

Elevation is also from .. officers.....who rarely speak ....

Nonsense. Corrupt judicial system in India must be purified at all costs

Judges appointment by the executive since 2014.

@pushpakumarimishra556

Жыл бұрын

...

British illegal rulers came to India and declared themselves as a Government. In 1861,with evil intention framed as criminal laws in guise of just to punish the crime committed persons but that British illegal rulers are also criminals because any one cry against British man ,he would be given death penalty that is 124 a indian penal code .They violated human rights and looted all sources but they left weapons in the guise of laws.constitution came with human rights but those weapons are hitting some one this is nothing misuse of law. Those criminal laws are to be studied and maximum amendments are to be made to save democracy and constitutional principles

Hindu rashtra, Khalsa, South India,.... country may split 🙄😲😭

VOX POPULI - VOX DEI 👍 Voice of the people is the voice of God!

Connivance is the bottomline.

*Judiciary has lost spine to stand up against saffron right wing political forces in India*

Judiciary filled with jokers due to nepotism.

*Judiciary is Apolitical is Joke *

First remove collegeum system

Selection of judges should be prohibited having a political law officers or the law officers must be appointed by court itself not by ruling party

Law means nothing but Drama

There is need public rally in each city with supreme Court judgments given on importantl sections in indian penal code and police act and criminal procedure code So that misuse of sections can be reduced. Misuse of law is being done by official on their own and due to pressure from political power.

Absolutely agreed with Adv Sondhi. Young lawyers are afraid of being able to express themselves

Urban naxals

@ashokroy5184

Жыл бұрын

Who are you ?

@bhadwamuhammad979

Жыл бұрын

He is a secular pig..

@kvsrao4249

Жыл бұрын

Your two words aptly describe you....Andh bhakt.

@bhadwamuhammad979

Жыл бұрын

@@kvsrao4249 You are bhadwa namaazi

According to Mr Sondhi the bar is the conscience keeper of the nation as though it is full of upright fair and non aligned persons. I believe that the lawyers are as fallible and partisan as the common man. In no country including democratic countries are judges appointed by judges. The executive does so and the democracy in those countries is thriving. The government has an ideology and its plans and programmes are implemented by legislation and administration. If a politically driven judge opposing the government is to adjudicate most likely he will impede the government’s plans and programmes. It is human nature. The outburst of judges in the Nupur Sharma case is a case in point. They made absolutely unwarranted unsubstantiated and highly offensive observations just because they were politically aligned. In each and every case where the state is involved the judgement is based on the political proclivity of the concerned judges. We cannot separate personal prejudices from the person.

It’s a rant.

First remove collegeum system