(EDIT: The Whites is actually on the 4811 last, not the 55) Boots in this video: -Nicks Builder Pro: bit.ly/3T2FA8f -Jim Green Razorback: bit.ly/3pJrAHc -Wesco: wescoboots.com/ -Whites: whitesboots.com/ -Drews Logger: rebrand.ly/p86t0vl -JK Boots rebrand.ly/hlvnjpj -Red Wing Apex: www.redwingshoes.com/work/mens/safety-toe/Apex-02144.html -Carhartt Force: www.cabelas.com/shop/en/carhartt-force-6-nano-composite-toe-work-boots-for-men

@Dukeofmamucas

4 ай бұрын

Giving up those Wesco’s hurts my soul Carl . To bad I’m a 12 D

One of the original first few pairs of razorbacks to touch down that side. You can tell from the razorback emboss on side, since then we’ve redesigned for clearer logo. Thanks again Carl, glad they staying and many more work days ahead

I work at a Red Wing store and just wanted to say on ALL BOA Boots that Red Wing/Irish Setter makes there is a lifetime warranty on ALL of the BOA system, so if anything breaks its covered for life, and as long as its not an eyelet, we can usually fix it in store within 24 hours or less depending on how busy we are. Love the BOA! APEX is also one of our hottest selling boots!

I am still waiting for the Patriot vs Drew's logger video that was teased several times... I have Patriots and the new Drew's contractor boots in rotation with a couple pairs of Nicks and they are both keepers for me.

One thing I've found is that I've gotta have a boot sized for winter and one sized for summer, because I'm somebody who has to have toe wiggle room. That means something that still gives me this with thick winter socks, and one that fits the same with summer socks.

@DarkFire515

4 ай бұрын

Yep, very good advice. I get my winter boots a half-size larger so I can wear nice thick wool socks with them.

@indy5797

4 ай бұрын

I have a pair of thick flat leather insoles from Wesco. They come out in the winter for thick socks, and go in for the summer and thin socks....but it is more fun to have 2 sets of boots!

The Jim Green Razorbacks are my go-to work boots but mine are permanently banished to the garage. I had trodden through a sulfur separation facility on an audit and so far the stench hasn’t lessened. Fantastic boots though.

@TheNunakun

4 ай бұрын

Try soaking them in a vinegar solution for a day, then air dry outside

"More boots are going to come in, no doubt about it" Man living the high life.

That's it, I'm ordering a pair of Nick's this spring. I was thinking JK's initially but this pushed me over the edge.

@AnthonyGHD

4 ай бұрын

I looooove my nicks! They’re absolute tanks can’t go wrong with them or their awesome customer service

@KitnerT

4 ай бұрын

I have three pairs of JKs and all three are totally awesome, just my two sense

@SeanHOP

4 ай бұрын

@@KitnerTrecommendation on sizing? Ordering my first JK next paycheck!!

@molon_labe_x8064

3 ай бұрын

@@SeanHOP follow the sizing guide and you won’t be disappointed!

My current top rotation as a Gas Pipeline Distribution Technician Drew's 8" logger for heavy work White's 8" Perry Select for light tasks and long days on my feet JK OT as the relief I also have some Red Wing Pecos I keep as my shit kickers

So cool you keep your drews 😎 i love my 10 inch all roughout so much. Thanx to your recommendation! Keep on your good work and rock on Carl

Got my Nicks last August and absolutely love them. Having a high arch means inserts or ridiculous amounts of foam and after getting the Nicks it is hard to look back.

All I wear is whites, Wesco,and Nicks and eventually I will try a pair of Franks most of my boots are going on 20+ years and if you oil them with the OBENAUFS and take care of them. They will last a very long time. My boots at this point owe me nothing but they are in pristine shape. All I do is send them back for resoling to me and my opinion, I only use vibram soles They’re the best in the business and I’ve been using them for over 40 years. And thank you for sharing the info on JK boots they make a nice boot without a doubt, but what you just showed me in your video. The front of the boot doesn’t look right at all and it shouldn’t be at that price. Keep these great videos coming and have a great day. Sincerely, Matt. Also check out Limmer boots they are a great walking boot once you break them in.

@Grandpuba1069

4 ай бұрын

You’d have no soles left in less than 5 months doing my job, believe me I’ve been down that road with nicks and whites, sharp ground concrete after my highway diamond grinder makes a pass eats every sole up but the absolute hardest ones around. And non he reviews are in that class

@MONGO573

4 ай бұрын

@@Grandpuba1069 I believe you in my line of work I was in psych nursing for 40 years, and I did a lot of walking and hiking, you are right a lot of work in the industrial commercial trades work, would probably destroy anything I don’t think there is any leather boot on the face of this earth that will stand up to that type of abuse for long Thank you for bringing up that point.

@BadAssBlackOverlord

2 ай бұрын

Could you explain sending them back for resoling? What service did you use?

Great Vid and thoughts Carl! I am about 2-4 weeks out from getting my Drew’s I ordered back in Nov. after seeing your vid. I can’t wait! I can’t believe more folks haven’t caught on to a Drew’s. You are the only boot review channel I have found who’s reviewed and worn them!

Been rocking the Jim Green Razorback steel toes on a big job for the past couple of months and they are awesome! Go about 5-10 miles a day on rocks, dirt, concrete, steel grating, caged ladders, etc it handles them all very well. Only thing I can might be an issue for some is the insole it comes with is a little hard. I personally like them, but if you don’t then you can easily swap them out for whichever ones you want.

Love your pairing down videos! Nice picks!

I started my quality-boot journey around 8 years ago with a pair of iron rangers. Bougt Wesco Jobmasters, 2 pair of Jim Green chuckas, and a pair of Drews contractors arrived last month. The Drews are on a completely different level than the Redwings, and imo even superior to the Wescos. Drews version of Horween Chrome Excel / Seidel Double Shot is unbelievable. Drews have to be the best quality to value boots in existence today. To top it off they fit better than anything else I own.

Good stuff as always Carl! I foresee a pair of Drew’s loggers in my future.

Those Jim Green's are no brainers... Thanks.

Love the vids lately!

I really like the comparison Carl. Fine job. I'm with ya on the 3-some you chose to keep. A good combination. Keep on bro.!!!

Poor Wesco boots never even got tried out.......I don't work outside for a living but do have some workish type boots.

Absolutely loving my jk climbers. Never noticed the overhang much until ya pointed it out. I may sand front edge down also. But that is a super simple job . Or should be ,for any man with few tools.

My boot journey (like 5 years so take this with a grain of salt; I also work in a warehouse so, maybe take NaCl and that’s it) has ended with Irish Setter’s 8’inch moc toe. Absolutely love them.

Great video. It’s really interesting to see what someone who has access to a wide variety actually wears.

Wish they made those Drew's with composite toes

That is a very fine boot collection! I feel your pain having to get rid of some of them.

Great review and insight

@CarlMurawski

4 ай бұрын

Much appreciated!

I have 3 boots all together nicks urban logger. whites Perry select. and a pair of cowboy boots. I could probably use a more formal pair of boots but cowboy are fine

I’m a commercial plumber so I have my nicks LTT 55 last for underground and nicks moc toe wedge for inside work. Both r awesome

I just got a pair of custom steel toe tire sole razorbacks (the ones featured on the jim green channel a couple weeks ago) and they're probably the only work boots I'll be buying going forward, so comfortable and not even as heavy as I was expecting.

Really appreciate your videos! I don't work in the trades. But I wear boots daily just because I ride motorcycles and need something substantial. Also, I live in Minnesota and (other than this year), there's often snow on the ground. I have narrow feet and got tired of poor fitting boots that didn't last long. Ended up splurging on a pair of custom fitted Whites. I've had them resoled and rebuilt. I got a pair of Nicks for a second pair that I could wear when sending the Whites in, as well as just for variety. I wear them most often now. Occasionally I throw in a pair of sneakers, but I'm very happy with the Nicks, and also like the Whites. Yes they're heavy, but they fit great, very comfy, and durable.

I’m headed back out into the field after 2.5yrs in the office & looking for new boots. I’ve been doing my due diligence & researching daily. For now I’m just going to run with my Thorogood Steel Toe Moc Toes & a pair of Ariat Workhog XT. But going to give Drew’s a look and contemplating on pulling the trigger on some black Thorogood Moc Toes. But I’m going to running on Service & Small Projects, so I’m also leaving light weight & agile but also sturdy. So maybe leaning towards a carbon/comp/alloy toe & yes, a wedge sole. I need comfort at my age & while I love those Thorogood’s, the steel toe weight does catch up with me.

Hey Carl, Funny you mentioned the Whites being a bit tight, mine are actually loose one me lol! Same ones too just in black…. Soft toe Smokejumpers. My all time favorites are my Nick’s Urban loggers though personally 🤙

Nicks over sands the stitchdown to the point of always having to blow the first row of stitches on a re-sole...it would be nice if they left more like JK did on your pair...who cares about the extra stuff sticking out. Jim Green wide toe box...very good stuff.

I swear by the aggressive tread, smooth tread, and super lightweight for my three options.

That's interesting about yout OT's. I followed JK's sizing after they updated it to fall more in-line eith other PNW makers and they're my best fitting boots.

Great choice on the 3 pairs you’re keeping. I know exactly what you mean about boots that don’t breathe, a boot can be outstanding but if my feet sweat and stay wet, then I lose interest in the boots, especially if they start stinking quickly, I’m done lol. I typically do unlined or leather lined now, I’ll just wear super warm wool socks for cold days, I’d rather my feet breathe then be wet all day and stink to high heaven lol!

Can't go wrong with Jim Green. 😉

Need to get Canada West! Amazing boot

Nice picks! Now what about horse ridding, nicks jk or chisos??

Do you still have your Nick's Urban Loggers? ... obviously not in your video but I was curious. Your video of those boots got me started on my first nice boot order of said Urban loggers for myself.

I think those JKs are nice looking.. I have a pair of Drew's arriving today or tomorrow.., same leather combo as yours.., looking forward to it.. otherwise I have some old Nick's Packers and with a cuban heel,, they're not very practical imo

This is good inspiration to trim the fat from my sneaker collection. Impossible for me to get down to three though 😅

What is the leather chair you use in some videos?

Been watching your channel quite a bit lately. Looking for a pair of daily work boots, with a steel or composite toe, for primary warehouse use. 10 to 12 hours on a smooth concrete floor walking an average of 16 miles a day. Any recommendations?

Carl can you please review the best water resistant work boots / shoes. I work in the golf industry and have trouble keeping my feet dry. Thanks

I prefer leather work boots , but I have found during the Pennsylvania humid summers that my feet are less prone to getting Athletes foot , when I wear a lighter pair of the Carhartt boots that allow them to breathe and get the moisture out , I've tried using powders and I'm not organized enough to remember to take and change socks , while they are not a year round wear they do have a place im my wardrobe

Work boots and you did the tecovas. Let’s see a video on work pull ons. Maybe the thorogoods, they are easier to get then red wing pecos.

I love my Wesco’s.

I wish the razorbacks worked for me but I don't like boots with a low height toe box, it was too uncomfortable for me. I have the drews but they are pretty heavy so I only use them with thick socks on cold days and snowy days. My go to boots for work is the Red Wing moc toe, love that they are light weight (compared to the drews) and it has a nice thick leather vamp.

@karls5474

4 ай бұрын

Re: the Razorbacks. Try going up a half size. I bought my normal boot size and they felt small. I realize the toe box was low. Tried a half size up and am quite happy with them

Got the Jim Green Numzaan in Wallnut with frog sole. Now thinking about a custom Jim Green Boot perhaps in reversed out buffalo leather. Like this brand (value)

100% share the Nicks bias, but I had a pair of Redwings Iron Rangers before my Nicks. I just always find myself reaching for them over my Redwings, JKs, or any of the 5 pair of quasi-military/quasi-work boots I had before my Nicks. They break into such a slipper feeling boot it's ridiculous.

Would Jim Greens be a comfortable boot for warehouse work? On concrete daily at a large, popular, warehouse store. I’ved used Tim Pros, Keen, and Merrill, interchangeably so they dry/breathe. I still have lower back pain (I’m over 50 years old and, ahem heavier), I don’t do much heavy lifting, plenty of walking and need toe protection (leather at the least, usually composite to keep them lighter). Suggestions? I’m all ears, thanks.

What brands of t-shirts do you wear, please?

What is a Norwegian Storm welt? And, is there a boot with this design that you'd recommend? Thanks.

What's a good rubber boot I don't like the Dunlop or Alco I am a cement finisher and spend a lot of time in rubber boots

Gotta try out the Danner Power Foreman, a good looking and tough american work boot.

I can't make myself get rid of any boots I have. So, I guess, my 2 Danner's , my 3 pairs of White's and my new Jim Greens are not going anywhere. Pulled the plug and ordered a Nick's Americana boot today. And, still want a pair White's MP Service boots with the cap toe as well.. I hate having this addiction cause I don't have any will power when I see new kind of boot...

Yuuup I like my Jim Green too.. I got 15 pairs of cowboy boots and 12 pairs of Red Wing mostly Iron Rangers but can't beat the comfort of Jim Green

Do you recommend Danner work boots?

Hello! I need help, i wear redwing supersole 2.0. I love the boot, its helped with my back problems from wearing loggers in the past. But i have noticed the quality wears out so fast compared to how they used to hold up. Can anyone recommend another boot similar with the same sole style. I have also worn the redwing iron rangers and enjoy that boot but i need something with a steel toe. Thanks Carl Murawaski team!

The absolute BEST boots I’ve ever had the pleasure to own were a pair of Chippewa waterproof laceups I bought about 30 years ago.

👢I’d like to buy used but what about the cork and leather footbed. How does one reshape it?

I love my Wesco's! I've never heard anyone say that they are too pretty to wear...lol😂 My first pair are 10 years old now. I'm sorry you couldn't bring yourself to put them to work. I love your channels.

Are you still going to get new boots that come out and review them?

I've been thinking about getting the Drew's logger boots; but I'm not sure about the sizing. I've never owned any PNW boots, so I'm not familiar with sizing. The only comparable options that I have experience are Danner and Timberland. I'm not sure about the sizing.

@CB-Lion

4 ай бұрын

The Drew’s are measured to the same linear length as the nicks and whites. Nicks has a foot measuring tutorial somewhere in the website. The only difference is that the standard toe-box for Drew’s is a lot roomier than others.

No steel toe rubber boots in the rotation?

The Jim Greens definitely appeal to me because of the wide toebox, what about their heel though? That’s an area that is not as commonly talked about, my preference would be for a narrow heel/wide toebox combo, kind of like a Munson last.

@omercarrothers7537

4 ай бұрын

The heel isn’t too bad in the 8 inch Ranger boots, it’s the same last used in the Razorbacks.

@88sstraight

4 ай бұрын

So, relatively narrow then?@@omercarrothers7537

@jakepassolt9640

4 ай бұрын

I have some JG's and I feel like the toe box is wide but the heel is standard. Not overly narrow but notable narrower compared to the toe box

@88sstraight

4 ай бұрын

@@jakepassolt9640 right on, thanks

Just wanted to clarify here that Drew's does make boots in the USA. I got a pair a few years ago and they're great but priced similarly to the other PNW boots. I just got mine back from their first rebuild (I used to do a lot of herbicide work and the moisture, surfactants, and terrain were pretty hard on the leather). They've been every bit as good since. If you want Drew's you can still choose some models built in USA, but you're gonna pay for it.

What kind of soles do you recommend for walking on steel, stairs/ladders all day? Work on ships and use blundstone/redbacks because squishey and toe protector caps. Want a nice pnw pair, but I don't think their soles will work between those soles and heels😂

@SlimCogniito

4 ай бұрын

I have builder pros from Nicks with the black vibram soles. I also work on ships. The soles are nice and grippy and have kept me safe through oils, water, and greasy deck plates. They have lasted around a year and a half of daily wear, many miles a day, and will need a resole by the end of this year.

What about your Tanker Pros?

I would bet the builder pro could be cut down to a height that you prefer when you send them in for a re sole

Patriot VS Drew's plzzzzz!!

Shop Pair: Georgia Boot Wellington Slip on Pair for random stuff: Red Wing Rugged Chelsea’s Logging Style Pair: Whites General Work: Whites Perry Select. Carhart Boots hold no place in boot conversations.

My ears pricked up when you mentioned the squeak in your JK OTs. I have a pair of Vibergs that squeak in the layered sole construction, under the ball of my foot. It’s driving me insane. Was that the same thing you had on your JKs?

@crestf2271

4 ай бұрын

Try ballistol on the insole, maybe a few times let it get into the leather it worked for my motorcycle boots.

@techzung

4 ай бұрын

I got some OTs I don’t have an issue with the squeak, they come with spenco insoles. Overall I’m very happy with those.

Let's make some wonder about the urban loggers

1 Franks Rainiers 8” Christy wedge 2 Whites Smokejumpers rebuilt by Franks w/ honey vibram 3 Georgia waterproof Romeos

@amateurstanding

4 ай бұрын

Think I’m goin to have Frank do some Rainiers for me next. You like em? I also had my smokejumpers rebuilt by Frank’s. FrankenWhites

@joshuapopich5215

4 ай бұрын

@@amateurstanding yep. The Rainiers are my daily drivers as a commercial service plumber. I wear the smokejumpers if I need to dig or if I am going to be on a ladder a lot.

I have a Frank's Patriot is EE width and a Drews Contractor in EE and the whole boot is looser, they said the sizing is exactly the same and only the pinky toe is wider.

@orangeruffian

4 ай бұрын

I'm sorry, which boot is the looser EE?...

@thomashardy1851

22 күн бұрын

@@orangeruffian The Drew's, sorry.

I have been looking at Drew's myself. If Carl says they are legit that's all I need to hear. Thanks Carl your knowledge is well received!

@amateurstanding

4 ай бұрын

Only problem is they don’t do many different widths

@CB-Lion

4 ай бұрын

Drew’s are the way to go. For an inexpensive boot with the same build quality as White’s and Nicks. The Drew’s Logger MIM come with pre-molded leather insoles to accelerate the break-in period, a roomy toe-box, and white-cross vibram soles that are meant for extreme weather and are softer than the standard ones. You won’t regret buying them 🤘🏽

What happened to your Franks Patriots?

What about the Patriot? Are you going to keep it?

@colinr4860

4 ай бұрын

"patriot" 😂

🤣🤣 you're so funny. I think I still can wear those boots. It looks universal to me. I often buy at the boys (children's) jeans section. And I know they build men's stuff wayyyyyy stronger/long lasting than women's stuff.

@HappyLife-nf7wb

4 ай бұрын

*they look universal to me. Sorry English isn't my first language

boots a few year ago it was sneakers what will be next???

Adorei

Red Wing Pecos

I thought you had a pair of Frank's Patriots? I have too many boots, also, and the only 3 I wear are Nicks Overlanders in BWF cause they're beautiful, Franks Front Range in walnut cause they're just badass, they feel like an old baseball glove, and uhhh blunnies or African Rangers, but those are barely boots. I have some newish Numzaans in natural and I love the leather but the welt is huge and they're soooo clunky. They're really close to being awesome but they just don't look that great.

@CarlMurawski

4 ай бұрын

I do, but I destroyed them in a comparison video coming soon.

When someone's says "they're too nice to wear", that's a nice way of saying you don't like the way they look. Wesco definitely overhyped.

What about the Tanker Boots? Or are they already gone? 😅

@CarlMurawski

4 ай бұрын

Already gone!

@Snaggitooth

4 ай бұрын

@@CarlMurawski Must have missed that 😅👍

All i wear is White’s and Thursday’s.

🔥🔥🔥

After going with cowboy boots for work, i can never go back to laced

I was hoping to learn more about the OT than just a sizing issue since I'm curious if they are a great hiking option compared to all that extra mid and outsole or whatever. Most guys won't want the high logging heels if they are doing warehouse work and such.

@Highland_Paddy

4 ай бұрын

I don't know why the Wesco aren't the backup pair for the Nick's, then. But we're only three pairs in, so... [and I think the Nick's run small that I shoulda got a wide maybe, BUT apparently they are not the same as walking on the gemming, so we'll see if they break in as instructed.]

@Highland_Paddy

4 ай бұрын

I had no luck getting the Drew's to fit and lost money on return shipping. The OT only come in 8 and only three colors unless willing to wait for more customization.

@orangeruffian

4 ай бұрын

​@@Highland_PaddyJK OT also come in 6"...

@Highland_Paddy

4 ай бұрын

Yes, but not 10.

@techzung

4 ай бұрын

I got some OT Redwood, they are very comfortable for hiking.

You need a pair of KEEN UTILITY WORK BOOTS - MADE IN USA

I’ve had three pairs of JKs and all three were normal sizing, nothing strange about it. They’ve been my favorite boots. Carl I think you’re off on this one

What about the patriots?

That is a sold line up! So serious question do you have more boots then your wife has shoes? lol jkjk

@CarlMurawski

3 ай бұрын

Thank you, and yes... I do.

Thorogood Origin

Giving away boot?? I'm a family or friend 😅

If you want a shorter shaft, just let a leather worker cut them back to 8"?

Where is nicks boots?

@ThePickler745

2 ай бұрын

Washington