Justice Athar Minallah Surprise ECP Lawyer..! Sab Hakka Bakka | Reserved Seat
Justice Athar Minallah Surprise ECP Lawyer..! Sab Hakka Bakka | Reserved Seat
Supreme Court (SC) of Pakistan will resume hearing of the case pertaining to Sunni Ittehad Council’s (SIC) reserved seats today (Thursday).
A 13-member SC bench headed by Chief Justice of Pakistan Qazi Faez Isa and comprising justices Syed Mansoor Ali Shah, Munib Akhtar, Yahya Afridi, Amin ud Din Khan, Jamal Khan Mandokhail, Muhammad Ali Mazhar, Ayesha Malik, Athar Minallah, Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi, Shahid Waheed, Irfan Saadat Khan, and Naeem Akhtar Afghan will resume hearing of the case.
During the previous hearing, the CJP observed that the Constitution was sacred and it was necessary to follow it.
If the party concerned had not the list of its candidates for reserved seats of women or minorities (with the Election Commission) then there would be effects, he remarked.
Addressing the SIC’s lawyer, the chief justice said that he would not be asked question if he had submitted documents in support of his arguments.
Justice Munib Akhtar questioned the lawyer that whether (SIC chief) Hamid Raza did not submit his nomination papers on behalf of the SIC. Faisal Siddiqui Advocate replied that Hamid Raza was given the symbol of ‘tower’ while that of the SIC was ‘horse’.
Justice Athar Minallah said that it would be different case if Hamid Raza were proved to be a candidate of the SIC, and that it was an admitted fact that all the PTI candidates were declared as independent.
Justice Mandokhail observed that if anyone got a party’s ticket then it could not be changed.
The chief justice remarked that neither the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) nor any of its elected representative were respondents in the case. As the case before the court was that of the SIC for specific seats, then why the case which was not before them was being discussed, he asked.
Justice Mansoor Ali Shah asked that how the ECP could declare all the candidates as independent as it had no such authority.
Justice Athar Minallah said that the most important thing was the right to vote. As the elections should be clear and transparent, questions had been raised on their procedure, he added.
Justice Ayesha Malik remarked that the reserved seats could be given only on the principle of proportional representation.
Counsel for the Members of National Assembly on reserved seats, Makhdoom Ali Khan said that the SIC did not provide the list for reserved seats. There had never been a case where a party had not contested elections and later demanded specific seats.
He said that the election schedule was issued under the Election Act and nomination papers must be submitted before the date. The date for the submission of list of reserved seats was given, he said, adding that the ECP would confirm that the SIC did not submit the list.
He said the Peshawar High Court upheld the decision of ECP regarding the reserved seats.
On the occasion, the court stopped lawyer Salman Akram Raja from submission of more documents.
ECP’s lawyer Sikander Bashir argued that a political party based on 100 percent independent candidates was not a political party under the Election Act. He said that if a political party did not win a single seat and had 200 independent candidates, it would get zero reserved seats.
#supremecourt #pti #imrankhan
Welcome to the official channel of Dunya News. Pakistan’s Top News Network delivering the latest from around the globe.
Home to some of the most popular Talk Shows and Journalists such as Hasb e Haal, Mazaaq Raat, Dunya Kamran Khan Kay Sath, On The Front With Kamran Shahid, Think Tank, Ikhtalafi Note and, more.
Join our News Alert Group for the Latest Updates: WhatsApp Group Link
Dunya News Live Stream
dunyanews.tv/live
Follow Our Facebook Page: / dunyanews
Follow our Twitter Page: / dunyanews
Пікірлер: 130
جسٹس اطہر من اللہ زندہ باد۔
Excellent sayings about reserved seats by the Respected Judge Atharmi Allah Madam Justice Aaeysha Malik sahiba God bless both of you and whole family Pakistan Zindabad Imran Khan ex priminister Zindabad too.
قاضی صاحب بریف کیس کا دفاع کر رہے ہیں
اللہ ججز کو اور ایمان دے تو جب ہماری عدالتیں ازاد ہوں گی تو ملک اور قوم کا بھلا ہوگا کوئی کرپشن نہیں کر سکے گا نہ ہی پھر کوئی بھوکا سوئے گا بے شک اللہ ہر چیز پر قادر ہے اللہ ججز کے روپ میں فرشتے بھیج کر مدد کریں اور حق و انصاف قائم ہو
@alinarejo1
13 күн бұрын
Not possible!
We stand with Imran khan strongly insha'Allah
یہ جج جتنا وقت دیتے ہیں بولنے کا الیکشن کمیشن کے وکیل کو ۔۔۔۔اس کے مقابلے میں یہ جج سلمان اکرم راجہ کو نہیں دے رھے ، حالانکہ سائل مدعی کی سلمان اکرم راجہ کر رھا ھے
یہی بحت اس چیز کا تعین کرے گی کون کون سے منصف ایک آزادانہ، آئینی اور قانونی موقف رکھتے ھیں اور معاملہ کی تہہ اور حقیقی انصاف کی منازل طے کر سکتے ھیں
Thank you Joudges. Allah will support you
What is the punishment in islam for a biased judge?
@rukhsananaveed6236
11 күн бұрын
How can we call him/her Judge ?
حیرانی کی بات ہے کہ ہماری سپریم کورٹ ڈھونڈ رہی ہے کہ عوام پاکستان نے کون جتایا ہے افسوس ہے ان لوگوں پر ۔۔ ساری دنیا کو علم ہے کہ الیکشن فروری میں کون جیتا ہے ۔صرف PTI
Ayesha malik bravo ❤
pT l deserve these seat as its mandated given by people of Pakistan no law and constitution can bluff people.of pak
Allah pak qazi ko b emaan ki taqat dy
قاضی صاحب وکیل کے منہ میں لقمہ ڈال رہے ہیں کہ جو میں کہہ رہا ہوں اس کو سمجھو
بدقسمت پاکستان میں انصاف00%ھے،
ای سی پی کا وکیل جس طرح تقریر کر رہا ہے کیا دوسرے وکیلوں کو بھی یہ حق دیا جاتا ہے؟ انکو تو یہ بولنے بھی نہیں دیتے!
@nadiazarif2439
11 күн бұрын
He is sharp, fast and rude as boot is on his back
Hum ne apni ankhon se Dekha PTI KO vote dalne Nahi dia ja Raha tha
Supreme court is new comedy circus.
CJ is treating the ECP lawyer Sikandar like his little paper. So disappointed with our judicial galaxy
@qaswarnasir4313
12 күн бұрын
Correction: fior little paper read little pappu
How possible Qazi listen election commission layer with so passions
@user-bn3pw9sn7c
13 күн бұрын
Extension issue
@ammadqureshi1480
12 күн бұрын
Very good English Excellent
Great leader Imran khan ❤❤❤❤❤
Ik ❤❤❤❤❤
Yehto ronay lag gaya
You have taken our right
اطہر من اللہ ببر شیر
Justice Ayesha Malik is lovely Human and very much competent judge and she always stand with merit and justice
PTI leader zindabad Imran Khan ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
عزت مآب جسٹس اطہر من اللہ زندہ باد
The entire confusion is created by Qazi Isa's symbol judgement. Article 6 to apply
قاضی صاحب الیکشن کمشنر کی وکالت بھی کر رھے ھیں اور انصاف کی کرسی پر بیٹھ کر انصاف بھی کر رھے ھیں قاضی غیر جانبدار نہی ھے ان کو اس بنچ میں نہی بیٹھنا چاھئے تھا ۔خدا را پاکستان کے لئے عوام کے لئے آپ اپنے بچوں کے لئے بغیر کسی دباو کے انصاف کریں
If it had not been for the intrepidness ,astuteness and sagacity of some honourable Judges then there was a clear agenda to lead the discourse in a predetermined direction as was evident from the exchange with the ECP’s counsel .
😮open and shut case ha ye supreme court ka time waste kr re hein
ECP should give a date wise sequence of events to incude date of submission of papers, date of judgement symbol, etc etc.
@nadiazarif2439
11 күн бұрын
Same with pti lawyers as everything was happening on last day of submission
We, the public, have spent billions to hear such struggles like an animal farm. This surely is no behaviour of educated and rational people. We the tax payers have waisted our money and time.
Ik zindabad
Allah pak sab ko hadit dae insaf kare
Look at qazi looks like someone passed away 😢
Justice athur minulla Zindabaad ❤
ایک طرف سکندر اور دوسری طرف قاضی ۔۔
ایماندار اور عمراندار غلام ذہنیت والے صاف نظر آ رہے ہیں
قاضی کا سوموار کا فیصلہ الیکشن کمیشن اپنا قبلہ درست کرےالیکشن میں ہونے والی نا انصافیوں کا ازالہ کرے اور رپورٹ کرے شکریہ 25 کروڑ عوام کا جنہوں نے پوری دلجمی سے سپریم کورٹ کی پروسیڈنگ لمحہ بہ لمحہ سنی نتیجہ ٹرک کی بتی کا رنگ اچھا لگا ہو تو اپنے کمنٹس سے آگاہ کریں منجانب رنگباز قاضی اور بغض سے بھرے اداروں کے سربراہان
KHAN sahab zinda'baad
Qazi extension ki jhang lar raha ha intra party par kon election symbol latah ha fine hotah ha
Sari kharabi made by Qazi
Qazi you took the symbol from Pti
Where is the answer to justice Ayesha question. How is this stupid lawyer not in jail for contempt of supreme court
@nadiazarif2439
11 күн бұрын
He has protection from boot walay
Because of the wrong decision of ECP to deprive a party of its symbol …Benefit of doubt should be given to the affected party candidates…
this is very confusing, like muddy water
Though the counsel have no logical arguments to proceed with but still he speaks so loudly to convince the bench members, which shows there is some hidden support which gives him confidence to ignore judges and continue his useless arguments. This is what we general public are observing.
Every question asked by the juges must be answered in written. Mr sikandar is continuously avoiding to give answers and CJ is letting him avoid plus giving him tips.
MAIN MUJRIM IS QAZI ISA CJ….😂😂😂HE TOOK THE SIMBLE FROM PTI …❤❤
PTi ❤
By listening to this guy, someone's saying comes to my mind is that " High voice or loudly speaking doesn't prove that he/she is saying truth"
@nadiazarif2439
11 күн бұрын
Still he is counter them in each sentence not like pti lawyers not even speaking truth
@mustafaanwar8778
11 күн бұрын
@nadiazarif2439 and what is the truth? Let us know your stance..
Simple si baat hai. Tamam PTI candidates ko bulain aur poochain unnse ki kyun unho ne PTI chori aur independent banna pasand kia
@nadiazarif2439
11 күн бұрын
Court is asking after becoming independent and winning why they don’t stay with PTI as PTI was still there so why?
ارشد ڈی جی الیکشن کمیشن پختونخوا کا ریٹائرڈ سیشن جج ایک کرپٹ افسر تھا جسنے ریٹائرمنٹ کے وقت بطور رجسٹعار ھائی کورٹ اہنے آپ کو فائدہ دینے کے کئے جوڈیشیل الاونس کو پینشن میں شامل کروایا جو بعد میں حکومت نے منسوخ کیا -
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Good judges
free imran khan
Anda nizam
Palda balay ka bari hoo gaya ab Lag wahi raha hai Majority of Judges are now on right path except cji
Election commission assumes everything wow 😂😅😂
PTI Zindabad Imran Khan zindabad Pakistan paindabad PDM 2 namanzoor and his Handler's Murdabad we want justice freedom Roll of Law in Pakistan
اگر آئین پاکستان پر عمل کرکے الیکشن ھوتے تو آج ملک کی بڑی اعلی عدالت کا اتنا قیمی وقت ضائع نہ ھوتا؟
I can decide this reserve seats matter ina single day. Hand over sultan skinder raja chairman ECP to punjab police and you will get what ever result you want. Qazi and sultan skinder raja are both from same tree thats why this case is taking so long.
ججوں کو بھی پتہ ہے کیا ہوا کیوں ہوا اب جو مرضی کر لیں قاضی کے پاس انصاف نہیں ہے
Supreme curt Q wapis nhi kr rahi 188 seat Wo Q nhi puch rahi k ECP nay Yaha tak nubat Q laye Kis qanon say faisla liya PTI wale azad he khare hona tha
Look at this ecp clown advocate 😂😂 punch line 😂😂😂 judges remarks he may be working in theatre 😂😂😂. He wasn't expecting this type of arguments from judges. Cause ecp has the backup of establishment. He can't justifys his own orders. Poor advocate how he has reached up to supreme court? Like zardari reached at presidentship and Shabaz reached at prime ministership😂 😂😂 crying badly😂😂😂
کمشنر راولپنڈی کے مطابق دھاندلی میں چیف الیکشن کمشنر اور چیف جسٹس اف پاکستان کا کلیدی کردار ہے
نفرت ہوگئی ہے اس نظام سے اللہ تعالیٰ پاکستان پےرحم فرمائے 😂😂
Can an independent candidate (who isn't sure about victory) file names for reserve seats? Can one PNA file a name for reserve seats? Is filing a name for reserve seats mandatory against contesting an election? In history, no independent candidate has ever filed a name for reserve seats?
Hmna kab socha......hum shuru se hi program banaya hua tha k pti ko nahi aane dena.q k nawaz ,zarrdari ne .....maal diya aur be shumar .......
Can someone answer that who give right to independent candidates to join some party. Surely it is not his voters. He or she bargains his own interests after winning. For me they should not join any party and serve the democracy honestly.
sari anomaly ka zimadar Qazi Faiz Isa hai. sare judges k remarks aur questions ka jawab Qazi Faiz Isa ko dena chahiye. Qazi bohat bari khach hai
Jis insan ko English smjhe naaAa 🤔🤔 Kiya pakistan hai 🤔🤔
Ye sab munir aor kazi ka kiya dhara hay
Ye sara ecp pr daal ry k ap ny ghlt describe kya symbol wali judgment ko justice ayesha ko ignore kr ry answer ni kr ry
India does not have to invest big money in military, just take army chief and chief justice of Pakistan into confidence and rule the country . Most of Pakistani citizens are easily controllable
@nadiazarif2439
11 күн бұрын
Citizens are not controllable as proven in the election, no candidate can win as independent in 3 days
یہ عدالت نہیں بلکے سرکس ہے۔ ایک سوال کا جواب سنتے نہیں اور ججز اگلا سوال پوچھنے لگتے ہیں۔
Qazi pti ka seats walah case meh zabardasti batah ha yeh wrong no ha pehlah kud bat ka nashan lia ab jan kar mazak bna raha ha pti ka pti ko bycot karana chiah
Qazi courropt hai is ko pak ki nahin extension ki fikar hai yeh same nawaz sharif
Wqeel ke sath hmdrdi he be charo Imran ke khoshamdyon me ghir gya
Judjes 12 se 20 lakh mahana lete hain Awaam jaye bhaar men
Faiz Esa had to become a TOUT, FOR HIS LONDON PROPERTIES SAKE.
Qazi muneyr PDM 2 Bajwa Allah ap Ke nslo KO barbad kary Ameen inshallah jalde
qazi has been bought
کیس ٹوٹل الیکشن کمیشن کے حق میں ہے سمجھ آئ آپ کو
Bala neshan q chena Pti ko jalsa q nhae karnadeya Sara hathcanda istemal keya
😂
Jou suprem court ki taraf dekh raha han pagal han supremre court ki wirdic raat 9 bja ayi thi jab azad ka nashan election commision na 4 bja shaam dia its mean election comission ko clear tah ka chief justice bat ka symbol aj har halat meh lay lain ga bahi qazi sab is a part of game sab sa bari party ko election sa out kia ga kionka agar yeh nah hotah tou aj shobaz government meh nah hotah yeh Sysyem ki har hoti awam jeet jati os din qazi agar wordic nah datah tou pir game election commision ka hath sa nikal jati pindi ka commisionor ki statement yad rakho
Seedha bolo uper se order tha
Cartoon lawyer, just trying to muddy the waters to cause more confusion, but the dishonourable chief justice looks bored and the cartoon lawyer keeps looking at him for interference, also why can't the KPK chief minister pardon imran khan, mohsin naqvi pardoned nawaz sharif even as a acting chief minister , just food for your thoughts, free imran khan.
O YAAR NAI JAWAB AONDA TU URDU/PUNJABI VICH AA JAA. HOOR KUCH NAI TIME TE LANGAA.
BEWAQOF BANATEIN HEIN INDEPENDENT.....BALLAH CHEENLIA PIR HRDELS DALTEIIN ....
Jhoouth chla raha hay. Drama kar raha hay.
کیا اونچا بولنے سے غلط بات ٹھیک ہوسکتی ہے
Shut up you have taken the rights of more then 80 / of people of Pakistan ...
الیکشن کمیشن کے وکیل جواب دینے کے بجائے خطبہ دے رہے ہیں ججز کے سوالات کے جوابات کیوں نہیں دے رہا قاضی فائز عیسوی خان پی ٹی آئی کے وکیل کو بات کرنے نہیں دیتے بار بار دالالیل دینے سے روکتے تھے اب کیوں نہیں روکتے
Muneeb Akhtar youthiaa imraandoo judge
Ayesha malik zindha bad
Attar minullah youthiaa imraandoo judge