Purchase Jordan Peterson Book: 12 Rules for Life - amzn.to/3mKusCq

@willettacartermolina3375

Жыл бұрын

Trans are exactly that, they are men who get off thinking of having a vagina.

@benjaminsmith-kn6oy

Жыл бұрын

My guy... Don't allow my response to be posted before your response at the top. It's your channel. I'm just a person with a rant.

@davidsommerfield7739

Жыл бұрын

…because he is not stupid.

It’s so sad that this is even a question. God help us all

@Anastasia-ex7iw

Жыл бұрын

Yes, it's so weird full of mess question

@AmassiveOverLoad

Жыл бұрын

On this issue, God help them all.

@rtaf4206

Жыл бұрын

Nah nah nah…just help that b…h, I’m good !

@plasmanip3998

Жыл бұрын

You’re bound to definitions like they are reality

@jdizle1178

Жыл бұрын

@@plasmanip3998 we are bound to repeat history. The Tower of Babel

He couldn’t have answered any better.

@josemeza7128

Жыл бұрын

A real woman has a period every month, case closed, forget the chromosome, and genitalia no period they can't get pregnant, and that is that

@martynjohnstone6022

Жыл бұрын

@@josemeza7128 so post menopausal women are not real women in your universe?

@b.e.z6831

Жыл бұрын

@@martynjohnstone6022 people don't think before they speak

This isn't a controversial answer at all

@evangelostse2477

Жыл бұрын

It is controversial. That's the sad thing. When he says 'no', instead of treating it like he just said something perfectly ordinary, we started worrying for him. That's the world we live in.

@toddwilson1319

Жыл бұрын

Why do u worry for him? He's absolutely right!!

@ssmbrodies8530

Жыл бұрын

@@toddwilson1319 yes he is right

@toddwilson1319

Жыл бұрын

@@evangelostse2477 That's the world u chose to live n, c I don't and neither does Mr Peterson. That's his argument, f these people who want 2 force u 2 think like them. It's leftist PC crap.

Perfect answer from an intellectual man that doesn’t get tripped up easily by the real haters of truth that biology holds.

HELL NO!!!!! This lady is INSANE!!!!

The interviewer is arrogant and biased and extremely unpleasant to Jordan Peterson. She isn't up to the intellectual job.

@nagaap9953

Жыл бұрын

❤ that's what I think

Love the way he constructed the right answer,to an absurd question.

Woman = adult human female Transwomen = confused man

@pth6060

Жыл бұрын

100% accurate

His answer is only controversial if you're deluded

@the_idiot_eris5029

Жыл бұрын

so what is a real women in your opinion?

@garyschultz883

Жыл бұрын

deluded or an idiot

@alanj9978

Жыл бұрын

A woman is a human born with 2 X chromosomes and, therefore, in the vast majority of cases, with female reproductive organs. It's not complicated.

@devilalastor3320

Жыл бұрын

@@the_idiot_eris5029 an adult, biological female

@the_idiot_eris5029

Жыл бұрын

@@devilalastor3320 so when she hits 18 or period?

Just listen to this man please.

Thank you Mr. Peterson. ♥️

@nrs166

Жыл бұрын

It's Dr., darling.

@linda6987

Жыл бұрын

Oh so like it states in the title of the video? Sorry didn’t see one? Did you?

Hell no!

Jordan Peterson has more class than anybody I've ever seen interview him

100 correct

Love this man

Yes exactly right Jordan. Couldn't of said it better. 🙏

Privileged people have a set of different problems

This is always weird for me when the question is being asked by a woman.

Answer...NO.

I totally agree with his response

Journalists are supposed to be truth seekers not just stirring up factless and indefinable issues to get viewing and therefore earning their paypacket

It's shocking that liberals hate this guy

It’s a gotcha question where your only choices are to join their delusion or to cancel you.

It's not "just for clarity." it's about her trying to showing how strong she thinks she is.

Simply asking that question is very telling. It's a stupid question if I ever heard one.

Wtf is wrong with people? something which was common knowledge for 1000s of year has suddenly became something so complicated. There are obviously a lot of distinguishable characteristics between men and women. And what does she mean by “feel like a women”? you cannot feel like something you have never experienced being. There is a difference in male and female psychology, and a man won’t be able to think or feel the same way a woman does, or the vice versa. Without saying, people who say “i feel like a woman”, “i feel like a man” etc. obviously don’t know how it feels to be a man or a woman.

@TheGreatestMind-JP

Жыл бұрын

good point

@plasmanip3998

Жыл бұрын

There is a fundamental difference between sex and gender. Sorry that’s so hard for you to cope with

@kinghashbrown7998

Жыл бұрын

​@@plasmanip3998you're literally the reason why these stupid questions are asked

I love how they left tries to trick him

No answer is a big fat no, you can call yourself whatever you want but the fact stays the same (differences go beyond looks and genitalia)

@joeburly

Жыл бұрын

I know a person who was born with both female and male genitalia and they gave her surgery to make her female when she was an infant. When she gets older if she says she feels she should have been a boy what should we tell her?

He should have asked her the same question- would love to hear if a trans is a real woman?

Historically if men have their tackle removed then the term used to describe them is "eunuch"😊

No

In 1920s we will have flying cars by 2023 People in 2023 still debating what is a women

I made the same question to ChatGPT and it says the opposite. LOL: thumbs up for Jordan Peterson.

Funny how she doesn't even know what the question means.

Being a woman is not based on feelings.

Brilliant answer. Extremely acutare in all answers.

If you have to put the pronoun trans before woman, then you’re NOT a woman. A real woman doesn’t need a pronouns, because she is a real woman. If you can see a real woman and still wonder what she is, you need therapy. Just like the man who dresses like a woman because he thinks he’s a woman. He needs some serious therapy.

Seems logical. 🤷🏽‍♂️

Hey interviewer; You're not clear what a woman is? 🤦🏻🤦🏻😂😂

He should ask her, are you a real women and if your answer is yes, what make you a reply woman . I’m a man an I know what my definition of a real woman is and it wasn’t a man .

Hell No... the end.

A trans woman is simply a trans woman and NOT a woman. A woman is NOT a trans woman. If a child wants to try to squeeze a square peg into a circular hole, try as they might the square will NEVER become a circle. Trans rights should NEVER override sex based rights.

Clarity?? What a condescending and utterly stupid question 🤦🏻🤦🏻

Legend

@TheGreatestMind-JP

Жыл бұрын

A true legend JP

If anyone can't see it's a game to make people hate each other and if we hate we are going to get hateful to each other, look at how aggressive the so called presenter comes across?

Asking if trans women is a real women already puts them in a category of not being women.

@alanj9978

Жыл бұрын

That's because everyone knows in their gut that they aren't but are no longer allowed to say so.

What happened to this man. Just a few years ago he spoke like this. Clear, intelligent and respectful. But after all the drugs and right wing propaganda he has just become another crazy guy on fox news

What does the title line MEAN ‘ controversial’ there is NOTHING controversial about it, they are NOT women.

No. Because you named two objectively exclusive groups. If you thought they were the same, this question wouldn't exist.

The need for "trans" as a pre-fix means they are NOT women.

I know a person born with both male and female genitalia who had gender assignment surgery to female as an infant. When she grows up if she says that she believes she is trans and is a boy, what should I tell her?

The fact that you have to put "trans" in front of woman means that person isn't a real woman.

Well said, that man.

Is water wet?

What do you mean by real. JP legendary brother

Just so many other's... She tried and up for the job to corner him... Peterson's not that easy. Lol...

Controversial answer by saying the True🤦🏼‍♂️

The end of the development is decadence.

If trans-women were real women then there would be no need for the "trans" identifier it would just be a woman.

The question desires a contradiction. Can A+AB=A+B when (A=B)B=2? How can a woman and a trans woman be the same thing? Either they’re both women or they’re both trans women and words don’t matter.

No. F*ck no. Hell naw to the naw naw naw.

He says, "What do you mean by real?" It's logical that a world renowned psychologist would question a person's definition of a single word because such questions are why all the confusion starts. I grew up me and you grew up you. S0, learn to better define your words so that the quality of your very own soul and spirit are properly conveyed and expressed.

What is with these WOMEN, and their stupid questions.

Why would anyone care if anyone wants to be a Trans am or not? They were bad ass cars at one time. I'd rather be a mustang, but to each his own

Smart man❤

To me, asking "Is a transwoman a real woman?" is like asking "Are decaf & regular coffee the same?" or "Do you think Pepsi & Diet Pepsi taste the same?" Or even, now, thanks to Dylan Mulvaney: "Is Bud Light as good as Budweiser?" Why would I want a pale, weak facsimile when I can have the real thing?

@joeburly

Жыл бұрын

No one is giving you the real thing, incel.

A trans woman is not a women.

I mean she said "trans woman" why not just say.... "woman"? Does she think they are different?

woman by mind or woman by body…. what is that person only accepts the 1/2 of what it is… then how it’s called? By its physiological built or soul set??

no!!!!!!

I will never accept something that is not to be true I don't care if you don't like it. Truth is truth u

Just for clarity 😂

Soooo fkn glad I grew up in the 80's and this stuff was nothing the government developed yet.

@joeburly

Жыл бұрын

There were trans people in the 80s buckaroo.

@ryandunn3170

Жыл бұрын

@joeburly ya, no not like this, how it's being taught to children who haven't even hit puberty you sico

Common sense is controversial

Somtimes he thinks exactly as I do and sometimes I hate what he says

nothing is true, everything is permitted

Do u have to ask that in the first place?! What a confuse people supposedly educated people we have nowadays! It boggles the mind 😮😮😮May GOD guide this people to sanity and morality…ameen.

He is RIGHT

Move on.

Where does this lady come up with all these questions? Use some common sense people!! 😢

No no no no oh ya and no

Nope

They should be in a metal home

best answer I did hear x

Nothing controversial just sense

@TheGreatestMind-JP

Жыл бұрын

lolz high sense levels

She means there has real then there has false.

You can’t accept who you are so I’m not going to either

Spot on. Best answer ever. No, they aren't woman. Period....excuse the pun

I'm sure the interviewer doesn't think that a trans "woman" is a real woman either; it's just that she works for the BBC.

No no no

Simple answer....NO how delusional is the world coming too seriously, Im a piece of wood 🙄

Nothing controversial about his statement. He just talked Biological Science.

@joeburly

Жыл бұрын

I know a person who was born with both male and female genitalia. They performed gender assignment surgery on her as an infant and now she is a girl. If later in life she says she thinks she should have been a boy what would you suggest we say?

@BharaniNath

Жыл бұрын

@@joeburly that is a specific tricky question but we are not talking about those people. We are talking about a proper Biological Male with 23 pairs of XY chromosomes calling himself a female. This in itself is not a problem too. But if you expect to compete in Female Sports, go to female bathrooms with a penis, etc, those are objectionable.

thumbs up!

This stupidity is getting out of hand…smh

I say no

Go uganda

NO

He'll no

No such thing as trans.

@plasmanip3998

Жыл бұрын

Nazi language