apa sih yg di ributkan...malu lah kita...kerambit dari sumatra atau dari malaysia..emang nya kenapa...sekarang yg perlu itu siapa yg maumelestarikan kerambit itu sendiri...jangan lah bilang,,,kalo kerambit itu asli minangkabau atau malaysia...tapi tidak turut melestarikanya...tidak mau mempelajarinya...malah orang kulit putih yg getol mempelajarinya...kalo saya pribadi sangat salut dgn prof jack...karna di hari tuanya tak lelah2 dia membperkenalkan kerambit...kita malah ribut dan tidak mau mempelajarinya...bisa jadi kelak anak cucu keturunan melayu kita malah belajar ama orang kulit putih...sangat miris...

@milhamarif9111

5 жыл бұрын

halo saya orang padang panjang minangkabau sumatra barat indonesia di manamana saja banyak karambit tapi SEJARAH ngg bisa di rubah rubah kami orang minang mengenal karambik ada 2 macan 1.kurambik jantan berbentuk mata kali seperti pancing yg dirancang untuk = menebas asalan menyiksa sampai mati 2.kurambik batino seperti tulang rusuk wanita dirancang untuk = membunuh/langsung mati nah, kerambit berasal dari Minangkabau, lalu kemudian dibawa oleh para perantau Minangkabau berabad yang lalu dan menyebar ke berbagai wilayah, seperti Jawa, Semenanjung Melayu dan lain-lain jadi jangan sok tau kao

@gepin1569

3 жыл бұрын

Saya juga orang Minang, gak keberatan dan ikhlas lah pastinya kalo itu karambiak d klaim Malaysia. Lagian masih ada senjata Minang yang kami punya yang lebih mematikan dari Karambiak ini.

@smashinglabu3942

3 жыл бұрын

Mantap gan

@finnesy7326

2 жыл бұрын

Fuhh mantap bro 👍🏻

Buat kawan2 indo pahami lah kata2 "Kerambit senjata tradisional Malay" ini betul. inget kawan kita ini orang Malay walau bukan org Malaysia. seharusnya kita juga berterima kasih sama prof ini sudah memperkenalkan budaya kita (Malay Nusantara). Salam dari Indonesia

@syazwanhusin5243

6 жыл бұрын

Nawra Qory Noor Shofia its about nusantara good sis

@habinul969

5 жыл бұрын

malay enak aja lo itu senjata leluhur saya yg berasal dari minang kabau

@Gaban_FX

5 жыл бұрын

@@habinul969 jadi minang kabau tuh drpd mana?? America kah... jangan bodoh sangat kawan, ngaku kerambit kepunyaan nenek moyang lo tapi diri sendiri diajak silat ngak mauk malu la....

@ilmutanpongelmu5537

5 жыл бұрын

Karambit yg jelas setau saya memang dari Indo. Mungkin dari Sumatra, memang yg populer dari sumatra tapi sukunya gk tau saya.

@ridhoputrapratama8889

4 жыл бұрын

@@ilmutanpongelmu5537 dari suku Minangkabau

Jak Othman patut jadi fight choreographer film action tempatan

Seni pertahanan diri dlm tempur senjata memang prof terbaik la mengajar. seni silat terutamanya senjata, mmg berbaloi belajar utk pertahankan diri, jgn disalahgunakan ilmu nnt lain jadinya.

Let me say I had the privilege to train with the Professor this past weekend and it was mind blowing. I love the history the explaining of why, when, where and how during the class. I look forward to becoming apart of his family. I have been in the Martial science for some time now and his Malay art form blends with my warrior spirit to the T.

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

+Southpaw Gym NJ Awesome! I hope i can meet up with you guys in NJ one day :)

@southpawgymnj4651

8 жыл бұрын

Anytime your in the area just hit me up on Facebook.

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

Thank you! :-)

No need to say or claim whose Kerambit is. But more important is how to maintain and develop the skill of Kerambit. It is my pleasure and honor all over the world finds Kerambit is the best weapon...

I like your style, simple and direct.

Fantastic. first time watching this channel, fan already. Great skills and attitude about combat.

the best tok guru... super friendly , full of ilmu yet so humble n jovial in public

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

+G73 pinz Thank you for your kind words. Yes he is super friendly, very knowledgeable, humble and jovial in public. :D

Grip forward (blade up) is the most vicious. It most closely mimics the tigers natural strike. Neck cuts, blocking, and all other manuvers can be done. Don't forget that your empty hand is where you want to start.

alhamdulillah sye ade kemahiran bermain kerambit dan sejak tgok vidoe ni sye dpt belajar jebih lgi kegunaan yg lain ada pada kerambit seperti cincin kerambit dpt digunekan sebagai penumbuk.share lgi tentang kerambit yg lebih mendalam supaya bole lgo sya memperluaskn ilmu bermain kerambit

@keleminriver6741

2 жыл бұрын

Sya belajar ilmu pengggpanggg jarak dekat blh...jarak jauh pn blh.pengggpanggg ilmu yg jauh lebih hebat drp ilmu kerambit,pedang&keris

great vid thank you just awesome

Wah buat movie best ni 🙌🙌🙌 Silat sangat hebat

you two absolutely definately need to be in a melodramatic movie with a ludicrous story and buckets fake blood! ~

@rikishikato5001

4 жыл бұрын

A smaller karambit, maybe?

Awesomee video...!!

Wow!!!!! Thanks!

I'm so proud of u prof. Ur technique show ur experience. And i'm also thank prof b'cause share the technique to others.

huhuhu......sedih bila saudara melayu dari indonesia mngutuk sesama bangsa dari Malaysia....jak othman ckp karambit tu senjata tradisional malay(BUKAN MALAYSIA....MALAYSIA TU NAMA NEGARA JA BRO)....malay maksudnya melayu....kita org malaysia dan indonesia adlah populasi utama melayu di dunia....dahulu mana ad konsep indonesia atau malaysia ....dahulunya di nusantara hanya ada satu istilah iaitu melayu.....jd jngnlah salah fhm.....kami bknnya nk claim sngt kebudayaan atau apapa.....kami cma nk mnyatakan bahawa kami perlukan pnghormatan kamu saudara serumpun....tp tidak...kamu malah menghina kami yg di seberang sini....sedih tau gk bro....dihina dek bangsa sendiri....disebabkan itu kerajaan bangsa melayu kita tidak mampu brtahan lama....sbb kita melayu ssah nk bersatu malahan saling bercakaran....huhuhu sedih banget bro...wallahu'Alam bissowab

@akeshirohikari5618

6 жыл бұрын

True!

@rahmanahmad4941

6 жыл бұрын

Irfan Hadzrami Betol tu. Kesalahfahaman sering berlaku...mungkin kurang tentang sejarah Melayu agaknya.

@bilqisdamia2334

6 жыл бұрын

Aku pun tak tahu .kenapa kita yg sebangsa tapi beda negara ni macam anjing dan kucing asyik bergaduh.lebih lagi kita sesama muslim sepatutnya saling mengasihi dan bangga sebagai bangsa melayu.sebenarnya berpunca dari apa perselisihan ini

@XBCorn

6 жыл бұрын

Irfan Hadzrami semua gara2 technology dan games.

@antonireinard2773

6 жыл бұрын

Irfan Hadzrami iya, malay/melayu maksudnya itu minang .

Very nice Thanks for sharing!!!!

@ilmkhal

9 жыл бұрын

Thank you Duane Nixon! Show your friends :)

good to see u posting

@ilmkhal

9 жыл бұрын

There are more coming! :)

Kipidap Prof

Terbaek guru.. :)

It’s Dave Gillett from University of Surrey. How are you?? Glad to see you still smiling! 😁

Very .... Brutal weapon

Mana tempat ni..nak masokk jugak..seriusslu

Prof, saya ni visual learner, bila tengok tutorial prof ni saya seperti dapat tangkap setiap teknik kerambit prof dengan hanya melihat video tutorial. Adakah tidak mustahil bagi saya mahir dalam gerak kerambit, walaupun saya tidak ada asas silat?

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

+Shardovan Romanov Jom sertai seminar Kerambit dan senjata silat oleh Prof Jak di gelanggang Silat Harimau Berantai di Subang Jaya pada 25 dan 26 Disember 2015. Untuk maklumat lanjut, kzread.info/dash/bejne/omiiz9OPZ9uWlcY.html

So you would definetly recommend double edged fix blade karambit? I was eyeing the overpriced emerson karambit, which is folding and has only the inner blade

@ilmkhal

9 жыл бұрын

Daniel Tejnický originally designed as a double edged weapon. Certainly, go double edged if you can.

@xXxsparTaNGLORYxXx

8 жыл бұрын

+Daniel Tejnický Most double edged Karambits are illegal to posses, however single edged Karambits are usually good to go! Mine is single edged, I love it and I live in Canada.

@DanielTejnicky

8 жыл бұрын

+Arminestos Of Athens well here in czech republic one could have katana on his back and it is oK... we have very mild knife law and very strict gun law, for some reason. Double edged karambit would be no problem... anyways I went with emerson single bladed, fixed blade... If situation will require, I can always sharpen the other edge...

@xXxsparTaNGLORYxXx

8 жыл бұрын

Well I'm glad you were able to find one that works for you, welcome to the Karambit community, also, I wish we had similar knife regulations in Canada lol

Kerambit itu senjata tradisional Minang kabau wlwpun ada di Malaysia itu dibawa oleh perantau Minang dahulunya yg tepat nya berada di negri 9 ...jangan asal klik klw tidak tau filosofi dari senjata itu karambit dan kurambit beda,senjata ini ada sepasang jantan dan betina karambit bentuk nya seperti kuku harimau sedangkan kurambit lurus,,,cara menain kan senjata ini tidak diperlihatkan seperti itu ,,,mknya nya itu di sebut senjata rahasia

asalamualaikum prof boleh tak tunjuk Cara menumbok dengan betul

yoi brooo

Tok guru boleh tunjuk skill spin kerambit?

Di melakaa dimana tu

the minangkabau traditional blade (kurambik/karambik).

@adikmanis8989

3 жыл бұрын

Karambiak

I will learn one day.

salam one heart/////??? teruskan perjuangan mu prof jak... kami sentiasa menyokong.. mulut manusia kita xbleh nk tutup.. tambahan pula mulut saudara kita indonesia.. berfikiran terbuka la kamu indonesia!! muhasabah diri!!

@mdejoss1311

5 жыл бұрын

I like this coment,..

@rikishikato5001

4 жыл бұрын

Sorry about that. We're just that stupidly ignorant

@abdulbinfatoha2748

2 жыл бұрын

Maksud kau apa bawa bawa Indonesia!!!!! Kita ni serumpun jangan pula kaun mau kecil kan negara ku Indonesia... Datuk aku mati lawan penjajah demi negara ku Indonesia Apa hal kau ni bawa bawa negara pula... Kau menasehati dengan cara bodoh lah.. pikir dulu pakai kepala kau tu ha

very good

kalau mau belajar silat boleh tak

The master

Kalau korang tak pecaya boleh cuba .. Sya dah ada 12 teknik pencak silat kerambit panglima

More videos please.

@ilmkhal

9 жыл бұрын

Khairul-Hakimin Zainuddin kzread.info/dash/bejne/hpaZwah_eNKbeJc.html

Literally Remimds me of the Characters that Trained Ong Bak 3

The guy who is being attacked by professional is a paid actor

Ade kee di melaka belajar tu

NUSANTARA.......LUAR BIASAA INDAH NYA....

Kita sodara salam satu akidah

nice

All look easy when u fight with someone dont know nothing about martial art,but the reality is different..the different between two fighter is training..however this is malay martial art,from minangkabau,kerambit is motif from buffolo horn..malay not malaysia only,many malay in indo thai n philipine,word melayu is from belayu(rsenye sebutan jawa)said my indon fren..this martial art same crazy like other silat..

Poster tomb raider siap frame aku tak tahan tu. haha

@smashinglabu3942

3 жыл бұрын

Ada signature celebrity kot

ED should be the fall guy in movies as he does great pained expressions.lol

@ilmkhal

9 жыл бұрын

We call him one take Ed.. hehe

@BlackScale86

3 жыл бұрын

😅

his silat techniques are as authentic as jake mace' kungfu.

@Bubble23428

6 жыл бұрын

Rusty 369 the best comment ever haha

I think there should be a warning to viewers that this type self defense is extremely dangerous and should only be performed by specialized people, and should not be attempted by any mean especially kids at home or anywhere else ...

@bilbobaggins5815

6 жыл бұрын

ABDULWAHAB BOGES wouldn't work in real life

No karambit it's not malay but is from indonesia in sumatra island

@Khaliffffffffffff

2 жыл бұрын

Tolol , kerambit dari minangkabau mana ada dari sumatra , buatan indonesia adalah seperti barangan modern tapi berbeda dgn alat atau senjata tradisional , alat tradisi di cap sebagai buatan sebuah bangsa yang bikin alat itu

Ka rambut itu senjata tradisional Minangkabau

Dah Lah Karambit tuh Milik Kita Bersama, Sesama rumpun Melayu

@gepin1569

3 жыл бұрын

Minangkabau yang punya itu!

mayoritas silat ada di indonesia dri berbagai daerah memiliki tehnik berbeda

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

+Sudianto Senior Semoga seni silat yang ada dari berbagai kaedah kekal subur sehingga ke akhir zaman.

@notoriousb.i.g3451

6 жыл бұрын

bohong! silat tidak berasal daripada indonesia...

@habinul969

5 жыл бұрын

di indo kesian ada silat di minang ada silek yg menirukan gerakan alam sedang kan silat sangat jauh berbeda dengan silek

Dear sir i know how to use a kerambit. An old indonesian weapon comming from the cucumacaan. For give me my indonesian. I would never want to use this weapon against a person. it is a scary weapon. I was asked to teach wich i never would do so. Others may do so.

5:34

maaf ye..guru jak othman berasal dari mane???

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

+Milo Milo Guru Jak asal dari Pulau Pinang

i just Wang to learn how to use gun and karambit and ill become the best bandit in the worlds

@Bubble23428

6 жыл бұрын

Christian Jack go to the philippines if u say karambit lol

Kerambit bukan milik negara atau negeri atau daerah atau kampung,,.. Kerambit itu adalah milik bangsa melayu..

@gepin1569

3 жыл бұрын

Minangkabau yang punya itu.

kerambit nii tdk bole d ajar oleh org laen...ini kegunaannya bila dlm keadaan terdesak..

Kerambit from minang indonesian

@sv4h22a4

5 жыл бұрын

Minang bkn dikira melayu kah????

@sv4h22a4

5 жыл бұрын

Kalau dah nama indon tak sah kalau tak tunjuk kebodohan dan ketutulan mereka

@mdejoss1311

5 жыл бұрын

Nusantara lebih tepatnya,...

@andhikayounastya5954

3 жыл бұрын

Malay= ID, MY, SG, Brunei. Bukan cuma Indonesia dodol.

@abdulbinfatoha2748

2 жыл бұрын

@@sv4h22a4 bapak kau Malaysia yg bodoh

Who here watched the video to read the comments? (Reading comments while eating chips with the video's audio as the background)

Kerambit berasal dari Minangkabau. Minangkabau bagian dari Nusantara. JANGAN MERUSAK SEJARAH. HORMATILAH DAERAH ASAL KERAMBIT !!! Saya bukan orang Minang. Tapi kita harus adil. Apalagi sebagai muslim.

any which way, that sharpened karambit is gonna skin you. You see anyone with karambit? RUUuuuuunnnnn!

u're pretty good old man ...u're fast ,,,i be death in 3 sec ...

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

+Alip Dungeon Thank you for watching! :)

@ontheroadrun

8 жыл бұрын

I known for a fact that guru jak othman is one of master of kerambit style in malaysia.. n also there are many other style silat that already lost in history bcoz no new student.. (i heard that silat guru is the one who find a student not the student??) mybe bcoz of this most of those secret silat style already gone in history..

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

Ontheroad Runner2.0 I cannot disagree with you. However, through this platform on KZread we hope to pique the interest of our audience to want to learn more about this beautiful and devastating ancient art of combat.

@ontheroadrun

8 жыл бұрын

Yup.. True silat are known worldwide by youtube.. N the one of stye silat is silat suffian from brunei.. Well..some ppl just want to learn silat bcoz they want to have unique stye martial art that they can use in their county to make some money.. Similar ppl learn yoga to open class yoga.. Lol.. Those is the one will never understand why there is buah silat bunga silat tari silat.. They will never know why with those art. Is it just for the show or it meant something?? Well I never learn silat.. But I always be in many gelanggang silat just to see they practicing silat. N none of those guru seem have interested in me. So that why I never learn silat.. Ironic tho. Bcoz my late grandfather was a guru silat.. I never know what style silat he is teaching tho. Bcoz most of his student are more older then my mother so most of them already dead or living in someplace else. Lol. It better to learn silat then to learn magic. Bcoz magic.. Is something else.. (that involve).

@muhammadedowijaya2265

7 жыл бұрын

malaysia suka mengambil kebudayaaan negara lain katek malu

iam not sure his a profesor of silat

@stonemarverick4756

2 жыл бұрын

he is professor,u can found him on martial magazine in 1990s

Buat saudara di Malaysia jangan terlalu memaksakan...ntr ditanya filosofi dari senjata itu Klian tidak tau,dan cara mengguna kan karambit aja kalian salah besar...

Who uses these in real life everyday situations tho?

@rikishikato5001

4 жыл бұрын

I dunno, maybe my cousin's friend when he was about to get mugged by 4 people few months ago?

English is a smart people. i am sure they will find its origin culture than someone's claim on it in this video.

@stonemarverick4756

2 жыл бұрын

who said someone gonna claim this weapon?

**SEJARAH DITULIS OLEH ORANG YG MENANG**

@rikishikato5001

4 жыл бұрын

*ngakak in perang Emu dan perang Vietnam*

All technic not complet this video

I lıke the explanatıon but the attacker looks lıke he never attacked somebody wıth a knıfe. I suppose that thıs guru should traın and dıscuss these kerambıt technıques wıth a eskrımador just for fun

@SpyGaming2002

8 жыл бұрын

ממצב?

@lexxy1579

8 жыл бұрын

Well to be fair it is more of an exhibit than an actual tutorial Im pretty sure there are more variations to it

@lexxy1579

8 жыл бұрын

Well to be fair it is more of an exhibit than an actual tutorial Im pretty sure there are more variations to it

@lexxy1579

8 жыл бұрын

Well to be fair it is more of an exhibit than an actual tutorial Im pretty sure there are more variations to it

Kerambit warriors, 2 guys = 1 population in agd of empires 2 lol

that guy was pretty scary

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

+Dukun Cabul Scary but Friendly :)

@kipakubumi9933

8 жыл бұрын

+ilmi khalid I agree, and I like your videos

@ilmkhal

8 жыл бұрын

Thank you for watching Dukun Cabul. Please share and tell your friends. Salam hormat. :)

Wahai orang indonesia kalian mau tau fakta...hampir keseluruhan melayu malaysia itu nenek moyang mereka berasal dari indonesia....jadi ilmu kerambit itu berasal dari moyang kami melayu dari tanah yang bergelar indonesia....minang itu pun orang melayu...di malaysia ini penuh dengan orang minang bahasa yg diguna pun loghat minang jika ditanya kamu orang apa jawab nya kami orang melayu padahal mereka suku minang...moral nya minang is melayu

ya ampun silat kami d ambil org luar jg senjata kami di pruduksi di sana karambit senjata minang kabau

@stonemarverick4756

2 жыл бұрын

silat org malaysia punya

@abdulbinfatoha2748

2 жыл бұрын

@@stonemarverick4756 sejak bila silat dari Malaysia????

@stonemarverick4756

2 жыл бұрын

@@abdulbinfatoha2748 sejak unesco akui dr malaysia dan perkataan “silat” pertama kali disebut di sulalatus salatin dan hikayat merong mahawangsa, menurut sejarah catatan indonesia, apa bukti nama “silat” dr indon???

@abdulbinfatoha2748

2 жыл бұрын

@@stonemarverick4756 silat pertama kali berasal dari Sumatra barat oleh kaum Minangkabau yaitu silek tuo atau silat tua Kemudian disebarkan oleh perantau Minang ke Jawa,Malaka,Riau,Kedah, Semenanjung Malaya, Sulawesi dan Kalimantan.. Baca sejarah lagi ya Orang Malaysia bodoh semua

@abdulbinfatoha2748

2 жыл бұрын

@@stonemarverick4756 hoax bodoh Aku cek sejarah indo Gada pun Melaysia penipu bodoh haram

Yang bener itu kerambik asal Zimbabwe dan Malaysia itu belajar dari Inggris, Inggris belajar dari Afrika Selatan, Afrika Selatan belajar dari Zimbabwe... Jadi yang betul kerambik itu berasal dari Konoha

@rikishikato5001

4 жыл бұрын

Heh, lawak ee. Dah jelas silat tu dari Takigakure

@goosecouple

2 жыл бұрын

Pigirah

I like silence. Screaming on demo is too me annoying. Is there a real purpose from the receiver to scream??? I can understand to scream when you hit or finishing the opponent …

@ilmkhal

2 ай бұрын

no real purpose. we will do it better next time. thank you for your feedback.

@rodolphedilscher5321

2 ай бұрын

@@ilmkhal I do apologize for my straight comment ; yes it is good to hear the movement, to hear the breath of the guru/practionners. For scenic moves in this case, create a content especially for it if you are looking for a call in a cinema production...

Kenapa pula jangan suka2 spin kerambit.spin tu skill utk tukar cara pegangan..ke tuan guru x pandai spin kerambit...huhu

perbezaan 'Malay' dengan 'Malaysia' pon kau tak boleh bezakan

@rikishikato5001

4 жыл бұрын

Sorry, we're just that stupidly ignorant. Even here in Riau, Sumatra, banyak sangat yang tak senang dengan Malaysia even though we're literally neighbours

udah kris di klaim ini pun juga :v

@elitegamerhackerelitegamer7921

6 жыл бұрын

My Story maaf lah sahabat...tetapi malay bermaksud melayu...melayu termasuklah indonesia dan malaysia...sebabnya dulu tiada istilah malaysia...itulah sebabnya melayu digunakan...maaf saya sekali lagi jika sahabat terasa hati...tsaya amat berharap malaysia dan indonesia dapat bersama...terima kasih...

@mohamadnorhadirashid7668

6 жыл бұрын

+ELITE GAMER HACKER ELITE GAMER HACKER ɨռɖօռ ʍaռɛ քɛʀռaɦ sɛҡօʟaɦ ɖaռ ɨ ռɖօռ tɛʀtɨքʊ sɛʝaʀaɦ

tom raider

Yah, maungkin maksud nya malay dia tu melayu, bisa berarti jadi melayu yg dia maksud itu minang, secara rumpun melayu di indonesia berada di minang SUMBAR. dn minang kebanyakan jg hmpir sama adat, tata dn kultur nya dgn malaysia. Y mgkn krna kesamaan ini lah, makanya jd susah. Terserah lah opini masing2. Salam se lah dari awak, melayu di minang. Salam ntuk sanak saudara melayu ku di negeri seberang. Semoga Elok elok sajo yo.

@salamatothman7094

4 жыл бұрын

Maksud guru tu melayu . Bukan negara . Tolong jgn bodoh

Kerambit berasal dari kaum Melayu Minangkabau Sejak bila kerambit dari Semenanjung Malaya dan Malaka lol

is this a parody?

Kalau pegang kerambut cara tampar muka tu.akan makan tangan balik tuan..cuba buat dgn cara kuat pasti akan makan tgn sendiri blk..salah tu cara tuan ajar

Sudah jangan di publish itu semuanya ilmu warisan. Jangan di ajarkan ke penjajah. Kita tidak butuh pengakuan dari mereka atas kekayaan intellectual Kita.

Silat itu dari indonesia ya ?

@sutanmudokhalifah

9 жыл бұрын

Yulia Nur Afifah ia tepatnya berasal dari sumatra barat karena yang membawanya ialah para perantau minang ke seluruh nusantara pada awalnya kerambit merupakan salah satu senjatamya

@sutanmudokhalifah

9 жыл бұрын

melayu berbeda dengan minang pak cik

@matthunter9562

9 жыл бұрын

Yulia Nur Afifah All roots is from the Shaolin Temple from the Ngo Heng Kun Styles (5 Basic Styles) and Silat or Pencak Silat is from the Snake Styles, such Wing Chun is from the Crane Hybrid with a Snake Styles so the Pencak Silat is from the Snake styles.

@enkryptron

9 жыл бұрын

Arief Makmur nope..you just made some pretty wild accusation. lots of asian nation develop their own sets of martial arts independent of each other. Then later on they influences one another, to say all roots are from shaolin temple is baseless and without facts

@e1raja97

8 жыл бұрын

+Aan Farhan Coba kau sebutkan 10 silat asli original dari semenanjung?ada kah ? DanDan coba kau tengok web pusatcemerlang silat itu web resmi silat malaysia, di situ disebutkan silat asli origin dari tempatan malaysia hanyalah "silat pulut" atau "gayong pulut" atau silat tari,dan ratusan sialt lainnya yg ada di malaysia itu bukanlah asli tenpatan malaysia,tapi majority berasal dari indonesia, tepatnya dari sumatra,bugis dan jawa,guru jak othman ini ajakan ailat asal jawa... Bbrapa silat lainnya di malaysia berasal dari pattani misalnya gayong fattani,tomoi dan silat embo... Jadi tepatlah jika ailat itu di iktirafkan berasal dari indonesia, karena silat tertua pun berasal dari wilayah indonesia...

Kerambit itu senjata tajam tradisional Minang Kabau Sumatera Barat,,, jangan ngaku2 atau di akui senjata tajam daerah lain,, nama aslinya Karambik bukan Kerambit,, hanya saja di bahasa indonesiakan oleh orang menjadi Kerambit,,

@leodavinclavigan6166

6 жыл бұрын

Boy Hendrizal go fuck by yourself... if u think Malay is a small ethic like u have in your country than u are in big mistake.. u should learn n do more research what Malay is and where it comes from..not from you indon sources coz all of them are bullshit, but from all intrnational academic world..

@zarulfire7493

6 жыл бұрын

Biasalah indon bodoh...pasal ,karambit,bugis,songket semua nk gaduh

@nuazharz

6 жыл бұрын

Boy Hendrizal Kerambit adalah senjata asli warisan rumpun Melayu. Yang pasti empayar awal Melayu muncul di Tanah Besar Melayu (Indochina, Seketing Kera, Semenanjung) sebelum wujudnya kerajaan di pulau Jawa atau Sumatera. Jadi lebih logik kerambit berasal dari tamadun awal Melayu di Tanah Besar Melayu spt Funan, Champa, Srivijaya, Langkasuka, Tambralingga, Ligor, Kedah, Gangga Nagara, Patani, ChiTu, PanPan, Kilantan, Pahang, Gilangi, dan byk lagi. Tiada bukti kerambit berasal daripada Minangkabau. Kerana Indonesia hanya muncul pada tahun 1940an. Jadi jangan suka berbohong (dan bersifat tidak tahu malu) mahu klaim kerambit berasal dari Minamgkabau. Hanya orang yang tiada harga diri sahaja yang suka berbohong.

@stonemarverick4756

2 жыл бұрын

@Aldoni Effendy lawak indon claim

@abdulbinfatoha2748

2 жыл бұрын

@@nuazharz kerambit dari Minangkabau bukan dari Melayu mana mana doh....

1. Karambit is from West Sumatra, from Minangkabau culture not Malay 2. Minangkabau =/= Malay 3. Karambit was a farming weapon, it is may be originated from something like Celurit, a tool for cutting rice paddy Are you really a _Professor_ ? Get your facts straight

@leodavinclavigan6166

6 жыл бұрын

Indonesian always idiot and fool in history... you know nothing about Malay history coz you only know about yourself and being blinded by your Pancasila ideology...please do more academic research on Malay world before come and comment here ..

@zarulfire7493

6 жыл бұрын

Satu je indon punya..wak jahid namanya..ko nak malaysia bg free je...kimak punya indon haha

@mataelang9229

6 жыл бұрын

Leodavinc Lavigan wow indo idiot trus Malaysia apa..? Batik di claim rendang di claim angklung di claim so jika indo idiot kalian kenapa mengklaim budaya kami malu mah sama omongan kamu sendiri

@nuazharz

6 жыл бұрын

Kumol Kumel Kerambit adalah senjata asli warisan rumpun Melayu. Yang pasti empayar awal Melayu muncul di Tanah Besar Melayu (Indochina, Seketing Kera, Semenanjung) sebelum wujudnya kerajaan di pulau Jawa atau Sumatera. Jadi lebih logik kerambit berasal dari tamadun awal Melayu di Tanah Besar Melayu spt Funan, Champa, Srivijaya, Langkasuka, Tambralingga, Ligor, Kedah, Gangga Nagara, Patani, ChiTu, PanPan, Kilantan, Pahang, Gilangi, dan byk lagi. Tiada bukti kerambit berasal daripada Indonesia. Kerana Indonesia hanya muncul pada tahun 1940an. Jadi jangan suka berbohong (dan bersifat tidak tahu malu) mahu klaim kerambit berasal dari Indonesia. Hanya orang yang tiada harga diri sahaja yang suka berbohong. Kerambit TIDAK pernah berasal dari Indonesia !

@AntiNonima

6 жыл бұрын

Its too easy to be ignorant and mock people around..."go learn about malay, bla bla bla, indon bodoh bla bla bla" That why he said karambit origin from west sumatra, spesific he said it origin is minangkabau, indeed karabit is a thing in malay world, nothing to argue but where is the origin? Why so shy just say it from minangkabau, sumatra - melayu, indonesia... Also assumption malay origin from semenanjung based on migrate theory is so funny, seriously you need to think again about it, while many group in south philipine, north borneo, west borneo, and semenanjung claimed their ancestry from sumatra, let forget about many group in semenanjung acenstries are from celebes, java, etc....let be sincere, brother and sister in malaysia, how many of you have your origin from semenanjung? If you learn about your ancestry you might find that your ancestor actually came from malay world that now called indonesia, malay isnt exclusively malaysia heritage and when you talk about it culture be honest about it origin....salam

неудобнейшее говно

Kerambit adalah senjata asli warisan rumpun Melayu. Yang pasti empayar awal Melayu muncul di Tanah Besar Melayu (Indochina, Seketing Kera, Semenanjung) sebelum wujudnya kerajaan di pulau Jawa atau Sumatera. Jadi lebih logik kerambit berasal dari tamadun awal Melayu di Tanah Besar Melayu spt Funan, Champa, Srivijaya, Langkasuka, Tambralingga, Ligor, Kedah, Gangga Nagara, Patani, ChiTu, PanPan, Kilantan, Pahang, Gilangi, dan byk lagi. Tiada bukti kerambit berasal daripada Indonesia. Kerana Indonesia hanya muncul pada tahun 1940an. Jadi jangan suka berbohong (dan bersifat tidak tahu malu) mahu klaim kerambit berasal dari Indonesia. Hanya orang yang tiada harga diri sahaja yang suka berbohong. Kerambit TIDAK pernah berasal dari Indonesia !

@AntiNonima

6 жыл бұрын

NouZen so where is the origin? Why malaysian so bias, always said malay world...where is it origin? Are malaysian gonna say 'malay world' is exclusively malaysian? Most you not being honest...thing like culture and anything in it are common things, but sure there is origin, so say where its origin

@AntiNonima

6 жыл бұрын

Example, malaysian rendang origin is malaysia, inspired by randang from sumatra, it origin is minangkabau Or malaysian reog origin is malaysia...inspired and later developed from reog in east java, indonesia There, it is easy being honest and nothing to worry we can share so many thing but be honest about where its origin

@habinul969

5 жыл бұрын

apa rumpun Melayu🤣menyedihkan kan skli anda mengaku! arti karambik itu anda tau gag ?kalo ngak ngak usah ngaku2! karambik itu senjata minang bukan Melayu! minang dan Melayu itu sangat jauh berbeda

@habinul969

5 жыл бұрын

bodo kali anda ngaku2 kerambit punya Malaysia kalo Malaysia punya anda tau arti dari karambik itu apa? karambik itu bahasa minang bro Malaysia orang bodoh mana bisa bikin karambit

@stonemarverick4756

2 жыл бұрын

@Aldoni Effendy perdana menteri malaysia org melayu yah jgn klaim pula

Silat from Malay ? u must be joking sir .. thats Indonesia's culture :)

@mohamadazam4644

7 жыл бұрын

ikanmaskokiaja yaaa...semua benda di dalam ni berasal dari indonesia...MASA UNTUK CLAIM

@azarrhamzah2078

7 жыл бұрын

once upon atime..pentas sunda consist of sumatera,tanah melayu and indon...geographical evolves and seperate them..come on brotha..how we are going to be a strong eastern if we keep claiming the culture..He said its from malay,.not from Malaysia..did u know Srivijaya becaming Malacca..all malayan and javanese came from the same gene n root..just respect and unite..salam

@zarulfire7493

6 жыл бұрын

Bodoh indon dah mai dah

@abubasar477

4 жыл бұрын

terserlah sungguh kebodohan dan kesombonganmu..

@stonemarverick4756

2 жыл бұрын

yea silat is from malay

karambit dan silat tu asal indonesia.bukan malaysia................

@stylofunky

7 жыл бұрын

reza wijaya... lah... ape lagi kau punye??? amek.. semua yg kau rase kau punye kau ambek... yg aku tahu... ilmu tu milik semua...

@rezawijaya6637

7 жыл бұрын

tai itu memang asli indonesia karambit sama silat jangan ngaku2 lo tai

@stylofunky

7 жыл бұрын

reza wijaya hahahaha... aku boleh je komen secare waras tanpe makian... tp kau tengok sndr la kau komen macamane... hahahaha... lawak lah kau... klu mcmtu aku nk ckp sparuh sumatra tu dulu bawah kerajaan Melayu melaka... bawah jajah melaka... kau nk kate ape...

@nuazharz

6 жыл бұрын

reza wijaya Kerambit adalah senjata asli warisan rumpun Melayu. Yang pasti empayar awal Melayu muncul di Tanah Besar Melayu (Indochina, Seketing Kera, Semenanjung) sebelum wujudnya kerajaan di pulau Jawa atau Sumatera. Jadi lebih logik kerambit berasal dari tamadun awal Melayu di Tanah Besar Melayu spt Funan, Champa, Srivijaya, Langkasuka, Tambralingga, Ligor, Kedah, Gangga Nagara, Patani, ChiTu, PanPan, Kilantan, Pahang, Gilangi, dan byk lagi. Tiada bukti kerambit berasal daripada Indonesia. Kerana Indonesia hanya muncul pada tahun 1940an. Jadi jangan suka berbohong (dan bersifat tidak tahu malu) mahu klaim kerambit berasal dari Indonesia. Hanya orang yang tiada harga diri sahaja yang suka berbohong. Kerambit TIDAK pernah berasal dari Indonesia !

@stonemarverick4756

2 жыл бұрын

@@rezawijaya6637 silat dari malaysia lah

Hahahahaha wtf

Kerambit senjata kecil berasal dari minangkerbau berbentuk kuku harimau.itulah kerambit silek harimau.silek harimau yg berasal dari tanah minang kerbau bukan dari mana mana ya sumatra barat..

Karambit asli senjata dari minang kabau, professor gila asal jiplak aj lu.

@wisputeh5705

5 жыл бұрын

Tolong hormati prof yg byk ilmu nya klau Xtahu lbih baik diam

beraninya sebut nusantara.tak indonesia

@rikishikato5001

4 жыл бұрын

Lah, kan emang asal Nusantara. Lu pikir jaman karambit pertama dibuat dulu Indonesianudah resmi ada? Lmao

This maan was so tottaly wrong abaut his claim . . . u know what ? KARAMBIT weapon was inspirations by Harimau Sumatra in Bukit Barisan(Barisan Mountain), so who r lives there ? that is Minangkabau People . . and did u know ? who tell Melayu Malaka are the mother of Indonesian ethnic ? thats wrong, Melayu is a sub ethnic of Piliang and Bodi chaniago of Minangkabau. "Malayu" word it self are originally based from "MALAI = Gunung = Mountain" and it was mention first at Darmasraya Epigraph as a "MALAIUR" that mean "Orang gunung/Mountain People". so what mountain ? if the Melayu people claim they r bassicaly seaman, so why it was called "Mountain people" ? let's think Logically, the Malaka is the sea area, but the people of malaka called "Mountain people" ? are u serious ? FIX !

@namisieiieiriioiddio

6 жыл бұрын

Vergil Nervanus kau ingat nusantara ni macam gunung di nepal/india?

@notoriousb.i.g3451

6 жыл бұрын

kamu jelas salah, silat bukan budaya indonesia...

@notoriousb.i.g3451

6 жыл бұрын

kamu harus sadar! aslinya tidak ada negara yang bernama indonesia atau malaysia. silat telah wujud beribu-ribu tahun sebelum era penjajahan / colonial masuk ke asia tenggara. kamu harus sadar itu.....

@yeahsbhshdbd1234

6 жыл бұрын

Akira Murakami Halah silat itu asal malingsia

@elsawika1477

6 жыл бұрын

Silat itu punya melayu jauh sebelum indonesia dan malaysia ada