I need more live singing of liz 😭 she sounds angelic

I love how Liz is very stable on live encore stage. Hoping that Liz will get more appreciation and attention as she is so very talented and very relaxed during that encore stage. Starship should also focus on other members. Also, other members are also talented and gorgeous.

@PuhLiz

Жыл бұрын

Yea she should get the chorus cause all the members are struggling to do the chorus .

@Ruzioxcbk

Жыл бұрын

I THINK ypu are not used to see real singers singing,, the best was wonyoung and yujin.. but even them cant be compared with bp for exampel in encores

@Anlin00

4 ай бұрын

@@Ruzioxcbksorry wony cant sing like liz its a technique she cant hit high notes and cant be stable

Rei’s rap sounds exactly like the studio version! Consistent queen 👑

Wonyoung did this encore so well omg !!!!!!!! Sing so clear and clean

Liz and rei stability is no joke I love how wonyoung is so confident

wonyoung really improved here! liz is so stable as always, gaeul & rei’s rap is rlly good here

Rei and Liz always stable since their debut.

Wonyoung's voice really suits her parts. Yujin, Gaeul, Rei, Liz, and Leeseo also did great

@marieljanenacua2040

Жыл бұрын

btw a big shout out Rei and Gaeul's rap

@jfs348

11 ай бұрын

Wonyoung 💩

i forgot that moonbin would be in this video.. now im sad

2:47 Leeseo saying happy birthday to Wonyo 💞😭 I’m so soft for them

Liz is soo good and theres a reason why shes the main vocal just GIVE HER MORE LINESSSSSS

Rei being a main rapper and most stable

@pinklamborghini6446

Жыл бұрын

She's their 3rd best vocalist tho

@sweetsweet_24

Жыл бұрын

her chorus part is the worst compared to yujin, wooyoung and leesoo

@subliminal5543

Жыл бұрын

@@sweetsweet_24 to you and only for you. Objectively she’s better than wonyoung shaky and cracku mess 2:57

@Useri77u7u7

Жыл бұрын

@@subliminal5543 wonyoung fits the chorus the most, u can cry

@subliminal5543

Жыл бұрын

@@Useri77u7u7 you can cry at the sight of you convincing yourself to think that first

the haters who said wonyoung can't sing are feeling real embarrassed rn

they are getting better and better in each comeback! some groups receive criticism for their dance and vocals but it doesn't get better, in IVE case, they got lots of hate bcs of skills but it got reallyyyy better!! they are ROTY and it's a fact!

@lunab3004

Жыл бұрын

I don’t see any improvement, they just got louder.

@gabi5191

Жыл бұрын

@@lunab3004 this is an improvement! they are singing more chest voice, what makes them louder! their performance also got better, and they aren't skipping louder parts. They are also more stable and aren't cracking that much!

@auvriellie

Жыл бұрын

@@gabi5191 they still can’t sing though 😭😭

@borahaeyo6446

Жыл бұрын

@@auvriellie You must be tone deaf. Go work, and mind your bad life.

@borahaeyo6446

Жыл бұрын

@@lunab3004 IVE didn't ask your zero point of opinion. Know your level.

I'm so happy to see this full encore. I've been supporting since debut and their encores seemed to be lacking confidence and a little empty. Now they're alot more full of sound and they seem so much more confident. IVE 2nd win 🎉

@gwenmloveskpopcecmore

Жыл бұрын

Well now with audiences and groups finally getting to be together again after Covid that’s also why it’s not lacking now

@via45

5 ай бұрын

Well this is only their 7th song

Wonyoung! You did so well! I'm seriously impressed, she didn't seem as energetic in previous encores for the previous singles. I just wish Gaeul had more lines T_T . With that said, I absolutely love this song and can't help but listen to it several times a day.

their rap in live is amazing we need more of rap

Happy birthday to wonyoung and congrats our girls😍

Awww they all improved SOO MUCH IM so proud 😭 happy bday wonyyyy

They all sang so well wow 😭 we can see the improvement

I'm in love with Yujin and Wonyoung singing the chorus, I wish they didn't give it to Leeseo cause it doesn't sound that pleasing maybe could've given to Liz, no hate towards Leeseo btw she's improving

@pinklamborghini6446

Жыл бұрын

Leeseo is just too young, She clearly'isn't ready That's why I am against idols debuting at a young age

@Sidsimplys

Жыл бұрын

Fr

@aimanaqmal7736

Жыл бұрын

Later if give it to Liz, people will complain leeseo get less part, and if leeseo take rei part, people will complain that rei should get more part, It is hard to satisfy everyone fav.. I believe this is fair line distribution and each member sing their part very well. The reason why liz didn’t get the chorus, i think her voice doesn’t fit with chorus part and leeseo yujin and won young give it more taste and attitude into the song. I totally disagree if they pointed out that this line distribution is choose based on favouritism and popularity.

@ivedefender

Жыл бұрын

@@aimanaqmal7736 you are so right, sometimes people need to keep their opinions to themselves

@erifckingchan

Жыл бұрын

no if they took leeseo’s chorus parts she wouldn’t have any lines but wonyoung sang the chorus three times maybe they shouldve given at least one to liz…

wonyoung just keeps winning in her birthdays! Icons!

@watzit4620

Жыл бұрын

Queen!

They definitely improved. They all can sing and carry a tune.

@JiafianaFlopTok

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely no 😂😂😂😂

@InTheSenseThat-

Жыл бұрын

I love them but… to you.

@yudiutama3233

Жыл бұрын

Honesty is not that hard

@borahaeyo6446

Жыл бұрын

@@JiafianaFlopTok How dare you ugly potato rude to these queens?! lol

@borahaeyo6446

Жыл бұрын

@@InTheSenseThat- why do ugly poor people like you always hate highest level people?

Wonyoung and Leeseo improved a lot 👏

I know Rei is a rapper but i would be so happy if she gets a chorus 😭

@saifn.7747

Жыл бұрын

She does..?

gaeul is getting condfident singing live😭😭😃❤️❤️❤️

Wonyoung sang that chorus so well😆 now where are those people saying she can’t sing🤔

Liz Yujin and rei are the most stable And i think gaeul is really confident when she's rapping

Their live vocals are amazing! So happy that Wonyoung is now confident.

Congratulation IVE 💖

@damieon_

Жыл бұрын

tysm ✨

4:07 i repeated it thousand times

congratulationss girlss and happy birthday uri bunny wonyoung

Their live vocals hits different. I'm getting addicted to it!

Leeseo answering your doubt at 4:00 She can sing!

Rei literally eats CD. Even in love dive era her live vocals were amazing

"IVE beat my 2nd favorite 4th Gen rival Newjeans - Attention , top GG of the 3rd Gen Twice - Talk that Talk and BP - Pink Venom 💪 for their 2nd Win

Wonyoung’s vocals 🥹💕 and I’m so happy they won on her birthday

RIP Moonbin😔😢

Moonbin...

900k++ physic album sales Digital chart #1 real time No doubt afterlike Ive win

This group not just pretty faces but talent , all in one

liz deserves more lines omgggg shes so good

Wonyoung be singing that song with so much confidence and stability. Im so proud of her, and in her birthday too. Congrats wonnie and IVE! ❤️

@PuhLiz

Жыл бұрын

Honestly is not that hard bro , she's struggling way too hard in the chorus .

@masakazuhiruko550

Жыл бұрын

@@PuhLiz I mean if we were to argue about that. The group itself is composed of weak singers. YES even the main vocalists has mediocre technique.

nobody talks about Leeseo, her voice is very cute in my opinion

wonyoung vocals this era >>>>

@user-nb5ef8px8m

Жыл бұрын

No

@sparklegowild

Жыл бұрын

@@user-nb5ef8px8m wtf?

@junkyucheeksismynewfavorit8111

Жыл бұрын

@@user-nb5ef8px8m what are u doing here?

bro rei voice is so stable💋

ウォニョンの歌が確実に成長してて本当に泣ける。めちゃくちゃ安定してるし自信もって歌ってて嬉しい、、、

I couldn't stop replaying Gauel singing she sounds so cute!

The rappers being the most stable vocalists is just chef kiss

Lol, not Wonyoung having the most stable and clear vocals here, and then people wonder why she gets the most lines. I don't really like that perfect 'it' girl image that she has (or was created for her), but one thing is for sure - girl will work her ass off to better herself and live up to those expectations.

@louieya9190

Жыл бұрын

So proud of her♥️

@aeriiel

Жыл бұрын

shes just herself be fr

@capabIeofIoves

Жыл бұрын

She’s really grown so much and improved sm… so proud of her, and her lines suit her so well.

@heyitsrosie

Жыл бұрын

K-Pop fans are obsessed with stability. That is not proof of good singing. Anyway wonyoung always indeed good.

@pinklamborghini6446

Жыл бұрын

Rei was the was the one who had the most stable vocals here thought ((No hate))

live vocalss so good😊

They did improve so well.

They can sing.

@damieon_

Жыл бұрын

ng ziệt nè

@nhannguyenang1283

Жыл бұрын

@@damieon_ á á chủ kênh người việt luôn ư.

@damieon_

Жыл бұрын

@@nhannguyenang1283 ya ✨

@anhnguyen-og5fg

Жыл бұрын

nhạc nghe hay thật nma live yếu thấy bà nội. T cx thích nhóm này nên mong tương lai nhóm sẽ cải thiện nhiều hơn

@damieon_

Жыл бұрын

@@anhnguyen-og5fg same

EXCUSE ME????????? THEY ARE FEEDING US VOCALSSSSSSSS. EXCUSE MEEEEEEEEE?????????????

bruh i came here to distract myself after last news and yeah...

Love how everyone agree that all the members singing improved A TON!

They get more confidence with each comeback, good job

Wonyoung did so well here!!!

Me a wonyoung fan still being shocked at how good she sounds here, damn. What an ace

@post718

Жыл бұрын

ace? r u serious

@post718

Жыл бұрын

there is no ace in ive. Yujin is the only allrounder

@zuzukram

Жыл бұрын

@@post718 Rei is kinda asw well she’s growing to be one

@hafidzalqanuni5433

Жыл бұрын

@@post718 mad much? Look how she can sing, dance, rap, writing songs at the age 15, play some instruments, mc-ing, modelling, have an outstanding and jawdropping visual, and also has been so popular before debut and until now. She may be not the best at singing and rapping. But she's definitely an ace material

@post718

Жыл бұрын

@@hafidzalqanuni5433 its obvious you have never seen an ace

4:24 rei please don't be sad 🥺🥺

3:40 wonyoung expression singing “what’s after like?” just made me fall for her harder

Is it just me cuz I think Yujin's eye smile resembles Jung Somin's🤧 I've been trying to figure out what it is that they have in common these past few days now I knowwww

THEY ATE! and hey Wonyoung looks extra endearing here. 🥰

ウォニョンが着実に生歌レベル上げてきてて泣ける パートもらいまくってる分 そこ努力しないとっていう根性と維持を感じるよ

I’m impressed with wonyoung! 🎉 she sang way better than I expected her to considering all the hate she gets.

Wowww wonyoung vocalsss

Their singing improved a lot after eleven

There is a lot of lack of control in their voices, many do not even reach the tone ... It's not a difficult song to sing and they are not able to defend it. Liz is the only one who defends the entire song. I wish the kpop groups of now did not give so much importance to the visual and more importance to the vocal

@soggyspaghetti

Жыл бұрын

Except this is an encore and not "the voice". Watch the bts of the recording of their songs. they can sing.

@ultsojin

Жыл бұрын

Then go and sing it if it’s not difficult

Their vocals very improved

2:27 WONYOUNG COMIÓ DESAYUNÓ ALMORZÓ CENÓ

Wonyoung canta muy bien ❤️

none of them can sing except for liz lol

rei and gauel rap wow wow

Aprendan illit y lesserafim

Gauel is so STABLE! 🔥 ❤😍

everyone did soooooooooooooooooo good i love them sooooooooooo much

wonyoung keren makin bagus deh suaranya

2:13 lol wonyoung is too cute she tucked her hair back and it hit the ear peice causing feedback

4:09 IS MORE THAN LIKE like like like Lmao she’s so cute

I just love the boldness of Wonyoung singing live!!! She's so freaking stableee!! She really has a goddess voice that suit her.

Gaeul barely had any lines yet she doesn't really sing it that well. It's an encore and she just stood their giving her the opportunity to easily sing it but somehow it feels like she's out of it. It's hard to explain, she's not out of tune but like her voice... But, overall, the girls did better on this encore and I'm glad to see them having their moment.

@pyoscheeks6023

Жыл бұрын

i understand what you're trying to say. me too, find gaeul's tone not really good like its flat. but she sings well

Wonyoung main vocalist

ENCORES IS TO HAVE FUN WHILE HAVING WINNER'S MOMENTUM!! THAT IS NOT A SINGING CONTEST TO TRY HARDER AND SING THEIR LUNGS OUT Y'ALL! YOU CAN SING CALMLY IF YOU WANT WHILE ENJOYING!! LET IDOLS ENJOY THERE MOMENT DURING ENCORES COZ IT'S NOT A COMPETITION, IT'S ABOUT CELEBRATING!!! AND TO THE FANS OF OTHER GG WHO COME HERE THEN RANT AND COMPARE , MY GOODNESS! TALENT IT TALENT! AND PEOPLE HAVE DIFFERENT STRENGTHS and WEAKNESSES. YOU KEEP PUSHING YOUR NARRATIVES TO GET VALIDATION BUT IT AIN'T WORKING CAUSE IT COMES OUT LIKE JEALOUSY THAT HAS NO CURE.

THEY CLEARLY DID GREAT

congrats IVE

rei did so well, from hearing her voice you can tell it’s nerves that’s making it not sound quite as good when she sings 💗

wow wonyoung’s vocals!!! 😍

Liz slayyed She had the most stable voice fr💖

Gaeul really did a great job this era. she is the most stable she sounds exactly as the same as the recording one♥️

Wow Wonyoung is really great in this encore

Gaeul is also so good 🤌🏻😘

I won't say they're horrible but Liz and Rei are the only 2 who can sing their lines properly, Yujin is not that bad either but she's inconsistent and often sings high notes off tune. Wonyoung is straight up shouting into the mic, even Leeseo sounds better than her. Gaeul clearly needs a bit more confidence with her singing. Overall they all have hard time hitting higher notes and definitely need more practice, they have potential and have very catchy songs but absolutely lack technique except for maybe Liz who's an average singer. Wish the company invests more into their musical education and practicing!

@soggyspaghetti

Жыл бұрын

LOL if wony is shouting then what do you call jihyo's style of singing?

@kpoppiest

Жыл бұрын

@@soggyspaghetti well Jihyo's singing is quiet chesty and that may sound like shouting sometimes too. But we're not talking about Jihyo here

Their live vocal SLAYED!!!

they win against what group??

YAYYY THEIR 26TH WIN HUHUHU

People are so toxic nowdays.

They did so well wow! Had a lot of fun😄 And they deserve all wins!

SLAY QUEENS

Leeseo so cute

Rei and gaeul’s rap! I meed more