There are about 6000 different languages and dialects around the world, and English is the lingua franca of the world. Palki is Indian and I am African, and the only way I am able to understand and enjoy her broadcast right now is because she's speaking the global lingua franca which we all understand. Palki wouldn't have this international appeal and outreach if she broadcast only in Hindi. And how many people would understand if I said this in Twi, "Anokwa, Palki asem yi ye nokware. M'ani gye Palki dwumadie ho yie. Nyame nhyira no!"

@neelakantannatarajan3851

Жыл бұрын

You should not kill your language for sake of english Global whatever

@maa6289

Жыл бұрын

Menua, me nso m'enigye Palki adwuma ho paa 😂😂😂. But really, this will end up hurting the Italians themselves. Don't throw your language away but it's also a great advantage to learn another language

@robertjankovic8467

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for saving ,e time perfectly said

@maa6289

Жыл бұрын

@@mpd8633 amen.

@AnootheyLyrics

Жыл бұрын

We can google translate your comment if your language is present in the app

You hit it right on the nose..The limits of our language will be the limits of our world..Thank you, I always love listening to your news.

@dontbeafraidimhere5421

Жыл бұрын

Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages ​​are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"second official language"* in all states of India! (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 5) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. It is better that we accept the reality and equally important to respect all our Indian languages. 🙏🇮🇳

@ridgemondhigh4891

Жыл бұрын

Ironically, many words in English, especially those in academia, science, and government come from Latin. The problem isn't all these English words, but all these migrants from Africa.

@gregorytsapas6622

Жыл бұрын

It’s Greek not latin

@b.m.6457

Жыл бұрын

Nobody is forbidding other languages in Italy. They are just using common sense. Official documents in Italy should be in Italian

@idealicfool

Жыл бұрын

​@@ridgemondhigh4891 ironically many languages throughout Europe were displaced through occupation of the Roman empire and the subsequent romanticisation of those regions

After reading the comments I've noticed that many people did not understand what is going on in Italy. The government is NOT abolishing the use of the English language, nor it's discouraging people from learning and speaking it. The fact is that we have a problem in Italy: there is a tendency of using English words when it's not necessary at all and there are immediate and perfectly understandable Italian translations, just because people want to sound more "international". But the vast majority of Italian people don't understand ONE word of English (only 34% of people can hold a conversation), at best they'll notice a similarity between some English and Italian words, because we started teaching it at a large scale only in the 90's. And in official documents we must make sure that the most people understand what they are reading. There were cases in the past where people could not understand the documents because of too many English words and it brought administrative problems. So yeah, I hope I made myself clear.

@marioprawirosudiro7301

Жыл бұрын

A good explanation, and from the perspective of an Italian. This should have more upvote, instead of these other numerous garbage comments that only serve to muddy the water.

@ROUGHANDREADYweTakeAMERICAback

Жыл бұрын

Very good explanation.

@kwentongmisteryoso

Жыл бұрын

Philippines have the same problem. Filipinos speaks tagalog but mixed with english. The reality today is, English is overtaking Filipino language because, people is now having difficulty understanding pure FIlipino rather than Filipino mixed with english.

@vinpat9

Жыл бұрын

Ok, that makes sense. Thanks for clearing the facts behind their decision. Peace.

The speaker is lying when she says it's about pride, I'm from Italy and the problem is that sometime banks state owned companies and private use english words in italian written agreements or other documents whitout providing translation to people who don't speak english. A big issue because english in Italy it's unknown to a large part of the population expecially older person that often are deceived using english words mixed in italian sentences. Sure there is a nationalism element but compelling by law to make documents agreements or services clear for any citizen and not only for who know a foreign language it's just common sense!

@NailaNails

Жыл бұрын

Appunto! 👍

Think about Northeast India the most linguistically diverse region in the world. If we start demanding for language laws and stick to only mother tongue we will not be able to communicate even with our neighbours. Cultural uniqueness is good but tolerance for other languages is also important. Let's remember that the first and foremost purpose of a language is communication.

@asylum9868

Жыл бұрын

shut up noob atleast in same country everyone should speak hindi

@mr.curious6872

Жыл бұрын

Maybe true for the North East India but not for the whole world.

@krishnakidasi108

Жыл бұрын

@@mr.curious6872 true even I m a northeastern and I agree

@johngarofano7356

Жыл бұрын

English is the new lingua franca that people of all nationality use today to comunicate including italians ,that is a separate issue,what is happening in Italy is that people are replacing italian terms with english ,and is getting worst every year .I Italians do not want to make the language a hybrid one ,that's all .Can you honestly blame them ?

@johngarofano7356

Жыл бұрын

@@mr.curious6872 well said

Indigenous languages are necessary to preserve heritage. At the same time, a’lingua franca’ which is currently English, is what what makes the world connected. The value cannot be be under estimated. The dissemination of information and knowledge, and one’s own life experience is enriched beyond measure. It is advantageous for all cultures to be open to a universal second language. Thank you for your report. ❤️

@ninaotan7811

Жыл бұрын

@Gigi Ghiba what the problem? Unlearn English.

@tartoflan

Жыл бұрын

@Gigi Ghiba time to unplug your internet, I guess?

@reallyreal7630

Жыл бұрын

@@gigighiba look, there is this thing called future. You don't know the future.. whether your country will be at war. We all need international language so someone can understand your need for help, so we can understand each other when we're not in our countries.

@reallyreal7630

Жыл бұрын

@@gigighiba Alright. I will but you'll be needing prayers too. Don't forget that.

@reallyreal7630

Жыл бұрын

@@ixxmsc9663 yep.. I totally get you.

I’ve been working as an English teacher for 15 years and I must say that necessity of studying it remains the same. Currently I have even more students. P.S.: I live in Russia

@firozahossen8307

Жыл бұрын

Great stay blessed

italy is battling exactly what I hate about the current negative habits in speech. people give up on using native language too quickly and just opt for english too easily. I'm not a linguist myself, I don't read books and most of what I write is in english, but I still force myself to remember native phrases as often as possible.

"The limits of our language mean the limits of our world" 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

@ThoughtsWeShare

Жыл бұрын

yes, 1 world one language may tough for 40 years, its blessing for coming generations

@rahulkrishna7041

Жыл бұрын

but in japan many CEO's don't know English but there are very efficient.

@ItIsTheLordWhoKeepsme

Жыл бұрын

​@@rahulkrishna7041I think someone translates stuff for them

@danaustria1056

Жыл бұрын

English the teal invaders look at british and american english.

@stevenschulte1475

Жыл бұрын

Meaningless faux wisdom. All languages have changed and evolved, why stop now. English is a fusion of many languages.

One should be proud of your mother Language, at the same time we should be multi lunguistic.

@cbhlde

Жыл бұрын

In der Tat! :)

@ravirachvik430

Жыл бұрын

Why multi-lingustic? Once India becomes a $10T economy, no economic reasons for learning a foreign Euro language. If Euros or Americans want to trade with India, they better learn one of India's local language. No need to please colonial masters.

@williamcarrington61

Жыл бұрын

What's wrong with using ESPERANTO ?

@kaiserxblue

Жыл бұрын

@@williamcarrington61 esperanto is an easy to learn language BUT is not popular....so this why poeple dont want to learn it.

@cbhlde

Жыл бұрын

@@williamcarrington61 Esperanto, c'est la langue de l'amour, (que) Tout à tout vient à parler Esperanto, et à ce jour l'espoir est née Esperanto! :)

It's hard to learn new languages the older you get. I think I will have to forget my plans to visit Italy in the future because I've learned English only. My native language is Finnish. Italians better speak Finnish language when they come to my country if we have learn their language 😉 They even speak English in North Korea when tourists visit there...

@tooyoungtobeold8756

Жыл бұрын

Its only for official documents, so if you are not an Italian government official it won't affect us.

@makekikkeli2699

Жыл бұрын

Kaikki kunnia englannin aivosyöpää vastaan taisteleville voimille

@mrrey8937

Жыл бұрын

Try not be too judgmental on them. The entire argument they bring is about protecting their heritage and identity from the powerful, violent, hateful, liberal forces of the elite and from the globalization of the WEF which are trying to destroy them and other countries. Celebrate them for the unique, beautiful language and culture, fantastic Italian food, and beautiful architecture. I prefer it over the violent, hateful, divisive liberal forces and from the wealthy and what they are imposing onto humanity.

@JokerJoker-xc7xb

Жыл бұрын

Hey would you belive English is Superior Language in all over Europe????

@unikeko96

Жыл бұрын

@@tooyoungtobeold8756 Oh. The clickbait was strong in this one. It got me 100%. Oops..

I have a feeling this law will backfire very quickly. Particularly because Italy has a big tourism industry and most if not all tourists only speak English as it's the universal language. Plus, a lot of Italy's GDP is from tourism.

@branc2658

Жыл бұрын

This law is against the use of English words in internal affairs, not to communicate with tourists. Recent governments in Italy have done laws named in English and many politicians, as the national tv, use often English words, sometimes in a wrong way, that older Italian people can't understand, even if there are the corresponding Italian words.

Sorry, but as an English teacher who also speaks French, German and Russian, I must say that in business it is necessary to have a common language. Few people are willing to learn 4-5 languages these days. I understand that when English mixes into native languages it is annoying, but banning it will never work.

@cbhlde

Жыл бұрын

Thanks für the comment aus Lübeck in Germany! ;)

@niteshjanghu5774

Жыл бұрын

yess banning it is not correct... your job will be in danger

@oleleo999

Жыл бұрын

it's not problem to learn English. the problem is to mix English words into native language. especially official language. many people in non-english countries can't understand foreign words. big problem for their casual live

@cbhlde

Жыл бұрын

@@LinusWelt Schön zu lesen. :)

@cbhlde

Жыл бұрын

@@oleleo999 That's why English speakers use Kindergarten or Schadenfreude, because language has to be "native"? :)

Everyone has the right to speak multiple languages but no one should give up their local languages, especially in Bharat where there are many languages and dialects. Be proud of it! There are many universal languages and that's okay to use for communication if you have a loved one or a job ... I've seen many Bharatiyon saying they need education in own language, they are right!!! But they don't mind to learn other languages too.

@manumudgal4988

Жыл бұрын

Out courts only use English in official documents. Tells us why it's difficult for people to access justice.

@abelabrahom207

Жыл бұрын

@@manumudgal4988 courts in each state should use local language in that state . That will solve the problem. Regarding supreme courts three language system will be useful Tamil( for south Indians), Hindi( for North) and English( for rest like North East who may have difficulty in understanding both hindi and tamil) Or else common people should be able to speak in their mother tongues in courts and translators should be used

@swati2899

Жыл бұрын

@@abelabrahom207 south has 4 major language so why only tamil . This is not the most spoken language in South

@Jay-dm4id

Жыл бұрын

@@abelabrahom207 stfu with Tamil, South has 4 main languages

@ShivamsinghRajpoot-jc5pd

Жыл бұрын

😂🤣bhai northern part me hi log apne language ko respect nhi dete baaki har jagh sab apna local language bolte hai southern, North East ,west har jagh Me uttar pradesh se hu actually hamare taraf system hi Aisa bana diya hai har jagh english hi thopa jaa rha log Hindi bolne me sharam karte hai 🙂😁 bahar kahi bhi niklo har jagh english hi chipka diya gya hai isme hum logo ki galti nhi hai systems hi bekaar hai northern India me logo ki majboori nhi ban gyi hai English not bad word par itna bhi Mt soch lo ki hindi bolne mtlb uneducated

I’m am far from a linguistics expert. In fact I’m dyslexic, but I’m fairly certain that many “English” words have foreign origins. Arabic, Germanic, French, and of course Greek and somewhat ironically… Latin. I love Italy. It’s a beautiful landscapes, beautiful towns, cities and villages, beautiful and varied culture, rich in history and yet thoroughly modern too. The food and beverage is a delight but most of all it is Italy’s people that makes Italy my favourite destination. The warmest welcome awaits, particularly for families. Yet I have met many Italians living in the U.K. they have without exception said of Italy that it is not a good place to live. The bureaucracy it seems stifling by their accounts. I was once told, “there are two sorts of people in the world. The Italians and those who want to be Italian. This was said by an Englishman. Viva Italia ti amo per sempre per La dolce vita

They are absolutely correct in Italy.

Thing is, I can virtually guarantee the major tech platforms aren't going to optimize for languages with smaller bases, like Italian. The software they use overwhelmingly targets English content.

@Qrayon

Жыл бұрын

All content will be in Dutch.

@frediemane7312

Жыл бұрын

​@@Qrayon denk et niet

@rafaeloreirorodriguez5278

Жыл бұрын

And they will be penalized daily, millions everyday by every country even nations inside countries win in international courts their dignity to use their respective languages after all language rights are protected by international laws.

@rafaeloreirorodriguez5278

Жыл бұрын

Is wath prevents cultural etnocides.Although should be used more often by Sicilians, occitanis etc. Catalans use it all the time.

@palmshoot

Жыл бұрын

@@rafaeloreirorodriguez5278 Are they being fined for doing it now? I doubt it since the algorithms are trade secrets. It's also only possible for a country to sue a company if the company had a physical presence in the country. In principle, the companies could simply block countries where they don't have a physical presence. They could even threaten to pull existing physical presences, taking jobs with them. Anyway, the revenues of these companies dwarf the lines.

While I think it's important to make sure English doesn't overtake your native language, it's also important to acknowledge the importance of a universal language. The alternative would be everyone learning each others language, which is just not possible, so you'd constantly need translators everywhere, reducing global productivity. And the simple reason English is the universal language is because the global dominant power(s) of the last 300 years have been English speakers.

@barnaclelevi

Жыл бұрын

British Empire Era is on its way out... you may as well get your Mandarin language book out ,times have changed

@Steve-rv5mk

Жыл бұрын

In Italy, English is mostly used to interact with tourist or by international firms, when I graduated from high school only a some of us( 2/3 out of 20) were able to understand and speak english. I live in south Italy, and you can afford to do literally nothing in high school and still get promoted, north Italy, on the other hand, provides better education and the English level is a higher. However I believe it will never overtake italian, Italians are very prideful of their culture, current Premier Meloni has to be on some drugs or something, how can one be afraid of another language overtaking their national native language when the majority only knows that language(without taking account local dialects).

@starfighter27990

Жыл бұрын

@@barnaclelevi I would disagree. One reason China is isolating itself from many parts of the world. Plus Mandarin is one of the most difficult languages to learn and not many people move to China to find jobs since its already very competitive with a lot of Chinese people already there.

@oldcat1790

Жыл бұрын

It won't be a problem once AI learns to translate text and speech in real time between any languages.

@Meow99999

Жыл бұрын

I hear telepathy’s a universal language 😂

We can have English (or whatever other language) as a lingua franca without eroding local languages. With tourism being one of the biggest sources of income in Italy, it makes a lot of sense for Italy to embrace English (within reason). Having been to Italy a few times, the love of their culture and language seemed strong. I'm speaking as an outsider, of course. I wonder if this language thing could, to some extent, be a distraction from more pressing issues. As for the French pushing back against English, it seems ironic as they are all in favour of spreading the French language around the world. I learnt French at school and I'm picking it back up again using online resources. I also plan to enroll for a classes at a French cultural centre which has branches around the world and, among other things, promotes the French language...

@jeremybeau8334

Жыл бұрын

France is the country with more tourism in the world and they don’t give a shit about english.

@dr.livesey7595

Жыл бұрын

Language is cultural imperialism. Most people in Europe more and more come to the realitazitation that the US has become a degenerated country which influences europeans why to much.

This lady conveys a lot in just 5 minutes through her effective way of journalism.

I live in USA and I feel like kids here are not as global as those who know more than one in other countries. It does something different to your mind when you learn more than one thing, people even say there is power in words, energy, and so it seems important to know more than one language.

@suezcontours6653

Жыл бұрын

Language shapes your world view: if you don't have gendered words you won't hyperfocus on things lie "pronouns". People were confused by The "Woman" King and why it was called that. African languages tend to have hierarchies according to age instead of gender so people hold "elders" in high esteem hence why you don't see the same level of rebelliousness in Africans as Westerners with Boomer vs Zoomer wars

@Waroncrypto

Жыл бұрын

You can start by ensuring your kids understand that there’s a world outside America.

@onlineempire4204

Жыл бұрын

English is the international language because America is the superpower 🇺🇲 And also Dollar is the international currency because America is the superpower🇺🇲 But India not a superpower 🤣

@dontbeafraidimhere5421

Жыл бұрын

Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages ​​are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"second official language"* in all states of India! (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 5) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. It is better that we accept the reality and equally important to respect all our Indian languages.

@slavicastevin1

Жыл бұрын

Yes, I agree with you as I speak english language that I’ve learned partly at school but then I’ve moved to a english speaking country and had to learn it pretty well. Now I’ve moved back to my country that is Serbia and I can’t understand why do people in entertainment industry using english phrases or just some words? Why are TV series written in such a way that the actors have to use english phrases? Why do politicians feel the need to use english words? Why many products in supermarkets are in english so that elderly people can’t understand what are they buying??? We all have our languages and our languages are beautiful sounding and must be preserved at any cost so I utterly support Italian government new language Law proposal…. All our countries must adopted it too!!! Our Countries in mainland Europe (Great Britain not included) have existed for thousands of years without english language being used and spoken so we must respect our European languages which ever that may be in our respective Countries!!!

I’m American but the way things are looking I’m thinking to start preparing my grandson CHINESE and RUSSIAN he’ll be 4 in August he speak Spanish, English and I’m teaching him some Italian already ( he counts 1-10 in all 3 languages )

@meditationmusicau

Жыл бұрын

You’re preparing for your kids to speak the language of upcoming two powers. I am Viet, Italian and Viet values are similar - we value our country, traditions, values & mother tongue more than money. At end of day we need is shelter & food, anyone can built basic shelter & grow food and these resources are gifted by God.

@Ethan-xf4or

Жыл бұрын

Nobody gives a shit ?

@user-ed9wk3vd2r

Жыл бұрын

That is a good idea. One day he will dominate the world.

@Jay-dm4id

Жыл бұрын

Mandarin is always good to learn keeping in mind the rise of China

@onlineempire4204

Жыл бұрын

English is the international language because America is the superpower 🇺🇲 And also Dollar is the international currency because America is the superpower🇺🇲 But India not a superpower 🤣

The reason why official documents should be written in the local language is for legal reasons. It is not required to be able to speak or understand English. Which means the document should be understandable by everyone even people who don't speak English.

@Tasorius

Жыл бұрын

Now try to explain away the insane proposed fines. And the law being against loan words and mispronunciations...

@GhostSal

Жыл бұрын

@@Tasorius Written language isn’t itself mispronounced, it’s just on paper and online. So there will be no fine for mispronouncing something. I’m sure spelling mistakes will be overlooked, unless they are intentional and try to subvert the law.

@Tasorius

Жыл бұрын

@@GhostSal Either way it's oppression and it's evil. I really hope the law doesn't become a reality.

@GhostSal

Жыл бұрын

@@Tasorius “Oppressíon”? For gøvernment documents to have to be in the country’s own native language?

@Tasorius

Жыл бұрын

@@GhostSal It didn't sound like that was all there was too it, and the extreme fine really says everything. I wonder what kind of real crimes have equivalent fines...

In France, ruling was made a long time ago to ban english in official documents. Radios also have to follow certain quotas of french music on air. That goes for the movies too, I believe. At least that's what it was whenI left that story behind at the time. That didn't change a thing. Cinemas in main cities still show movies in english, menus are french/english in restaurants, people use anglicisms, those who like to use english just do. Just not in official public documents. Quite frankly, that was a non-event.

@izoyt

Жыл бұрын

i realy doubt that ban did really rule out all english based official documents. english is still one f the official eu languages, so it's mandatory to all legislation etc related to state laws or international affairs is multilingual etc. here, let me cop paste their own words: The Council establishes the rules on the use of languages by the EU institutions, acting unanimously by means of regulations adopted in accordance with Article 342 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. The rules are laid down in Regulation No 1, which states that the institutions have 24 official and working languages. English remains an official EU language, despite the United Kingdom having left the EU. It remains an official and working language of the EU institutions as long as it is listed as such in Regulation No 1. English is also one of Ireland’s and Malta’s official languages. Regulation No 1 also lays down rules on the languages in which EU law has to be drafted and published, as well as the languages for documents sent between EU institutions and the public or between the institutions and EU countries. The EU institutions are also entitled to determine how they themselves implement language arrangements internally. also, quotas have nothing to do with banning foreign language, it is about keeping their own. we have that, too.

@marie22213

Жыл бұрын

And to think here in America they're trying to get me to learn French for science 😂 glad I refused.

@ulfurkarlsson5885

Жыл бұрын

The diffrence is France has colonise all over the world, while Italy is isolated and smaller and weaker

@YorranKlees

Жыл бұрын

@@marie22213 Since at least 33% of English comes fom French, you're not too far form speaking it as it is 😂 Though it would make more sense to teach yourself Spanish if you're in the US. If you want to expand your vision of the world, that is. That question is up to you.

@YorranKlees

Жыл бұрын

@@izoyt Well there is a difference between official documents in France and official documents EU-wise. My OP was obviously refering strictly to internal French official laws and stuff. In that area, English is indeed banned. As I stated though, there is no law forbiding to use English at a personal level.

I’m a native English speaker. I’m grateful that it happens to be the dominant world language, because it allows me a certain freedom. But it also saddens and confuses me that so many languages have mixed English in with their own languages. I’ll be listening to someone speak a language I don’t understand when suddenly, a random English word jumps out at me. I always wonder why they don’t have their own words for such things. I think it’s important for every nation to protect and preserve its unique culture. We can appreciate each other and enjoy each other’s food, customs, and language, but it’s important to have those distinctions. I also wish it were more common in my country for other languages to be taught. Sadly, they’re only taught in secondary school, and most do not gain fluency.

@leviturner3265

Жыл бұрын

Unfortunately English has been saturated and diluted with French words as well. This makes English a more difficult language to learn, because of depending on the word needing to adapt the rules of spelling and pronounciation. Examples being depot, ricochet. Adopting foreign words would not be an issue if spelling was changed to match the languages conventions, at least in the case of English. The word tortilla should be changed to be spelled as tortiya, and halepenyo instead of jalepeno for another example because when used in English it breaks English conventions. The same is true in other languages such as German where there is a lot of English, and French words used, but the spelling is often not changed to the German language conventions, and the pronouciation is kept with English, or French convention. Before the Normans arrived in Britain the language used there was much more similar to German. Old English had three genders in speech such as German. The three being feminine, masculine, and neuter the same as modern German, where you have three primary words for the word the, such as der, die, and das. By conquest English was changed and is now simpler in a few ways, but over time has gotten more difficult through foreign influences since the Norman's conquest.

@ladyville3

Жыл бұрын

No one is stopping you from learning another language. Most Americans don’t speak another language because usually don’t have a need to go outside the country for jobs to make money, so logically the need to know another language is not pressing. Most people don’t learn English because they have a love for it. It’s really easy to understand some things if you just take some time to think logical and not emotional. “Saddens” smh, lol.

@curtisthomas2670

Жыл бұрын

Funny, when "English" has one of the highest rates of foreign loan words 🤣😂

@havenbastion

Жыл бұрын

What i've find reality strange is that philosophy videos from India usually start in English then immediately charge to whatever else.

@havenbastion

Жыл бұрын

Or just use Logban.

Italy is a sovereign Nation State and is taking a stand against Globalization. More power to them…

Having an extra language up your sleeve is a bonus in this ever competitive global market. That's why even Koreans and Japanese struggle to learn it later on in life. This is a dumb policy.

Let's be honest, English is a standard nowadays which unites many people in the world. It's more or less easy to learn and pronouncing its words is not so difficult. I speak 4 languages but English is the lingua franca to me

@harmilal8979

Жыл бұрын

English it's not the easiest language to learn

@Southghost5997

Жыл бұрын

@@harmilal8979 it is

@screenname1

Жыл бұрын

@@Southghost5997 It's difficult to learn. You can speak a form of English that gets you by, but to learn the language properly can take a lifetime. It's the same for any other language.

@Southghost5997

Жыл бұрын

@@screenname1 if you want to do a PhD in English, go ahead amigo. But as a fit for purpose language, it is the easiest. If "getting by" is all you need, then just do that.

@lilchoppa7833

Жыл бұрын

@@harmilal8979 Aint no such a thang as "The easiest langue to learn"

Do that in India and notice the world's reaction - 1. Democracy in danger 2. Human rights issue 3. Minority persecution.. etc etc That is the definition of Western bias.

@Himanshu-vz5xe

Жыл бұрын

Exactly

@HrithikSD4368

Жыл бұрын

India can't do it already has many languages

@cass6885

Жыл бұрын

We in India have enough Anglophiles like Khan Market Gang who oppose indian languages. Chinese language Mandarin 800 Million speak. Spanish 500 Million speak. Hindi 600-800 Million speak in the world. English 386 Million speak in the world. These are the figures from World Langue Dictionary.

@cuckoonut1208

Жыл бұрын

Fu____le people don't have to work hard to get what they want.

@blacky4947

Жыл бұрын

You should consider putting Language family together and not just mixing super different ones together. This would be cultural a good start. The majority in Europe wouldn´t want to speak Mandarin or Hindi or Africans because they are to far away and their languages Families are to different and to hard to learn. I´m German and for me it was super easy to learn English because German and English are in a same language family. I would suggest that countries and scientist should develop a new language from all Language Family members. That could be a improvement that would maybe many people help

Thank You - Very informative as usual. Your videos are very useful. Be Safe out there. Peace & Health to Us All.

We’re all circling around the abyss of humanity’s demise as we argue over inconsequential words. Now you tell me if mankind isn’t about to step off a ledge while arguing over the name of an open-faced sandwich. Not healthcare, not climate resolutions, not the suppression of wages but wording. Not meaning just wording. People running governments are suffering from PTSD because they keep getting mired down in stupidity.

English is one common language spoken in almost all the countries which would reduce the translation cost for any business.

@vortex162

Жыл бұрын

That what happens when worshipping the way of America=Globalism!!

@AmoghJamkhandiga

Жыл бұрын

English>>> any lan

@dontbeafraidimhere5421

Жыл бұрын

Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages ​​are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"second official language"* in all states of India! (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 5) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. It is better that we accept the reality and equally important to respect all our Indian languages.. 🙏

@nishant54

Жыл бұрын

@@AmoghJamkhandiga english is very poor

@lalodaniels1388

Жыл бұрын

This needs to change

The more languages you know the more your horizons broaden, the more you are able to accept others' cultures. You become more open and inclusive. That's why Indians are so welcoming and tolerant towards other cultures. On an average an Indian can speak 3 languages. I can speak 6.

@agatastaniak7459

Жыл бұрын

I agree with you. Someone once said " the more languages you speak, the more lives you have". And we know that one person can create a bit different personality in each foreign language spoken. There is even lots of interesting research into this phenomenon. We also know a natural language is the best gymnastics for the brain known to humanity, way better than maths, and each language stimulates entire brain in a different way, changing it's structure and physiology- differen areas of the brain get oxygenated, new neurons grow in completely new areas of the brain with each new phonetic and grammatical system used. So diversity is good. Makes little sense to fight it. What matters is to know moderation with switching between native one and non-native ones. Like with many things in life what is healthiest for the human being is to know how to strike the right balance and approach everything with moderation.

@xevenxaver4759

Жыл бұрын

Yes, and they also shit on the streets...

@jeannebye8153

Жыл бұрын

So an average person minding his/her own business, in England, who only speaks English, is less tolerant towards others? Anddddd, because Indians speak more languages, they are automatically open minded? Sounds narcissistic to me. Oh what about people who are mute/deaf? Do you have judgments about them as well?

@josefinahd3245

Жыл бұрын

Das stimmt, allerdings braucht es sehr viel Zeit um fremde Kultur kennen zu lernen

@101logic

Жыл бұрын

That is not correct! I have met countless individuals that know more than one language and a lot of them were living in a bubble. Italy has every right to safeguard their language therefore their culture.

It's in official documents. They aren't trying to say that you can't speak it on the street or in a store. Stores can even post signs in English if they want. If you apply for an Italian business license or Italian driver's license, it has to be in Italian. Hindi should be the dominant language of India. What's the problem?

@valenrn8657

Жыл бұрын

Blame Latin (Italy's Roman Empire legacy) and Norman French for the near genocide of Old English. Italy's Roman Empire Latin legacy has a record of cultural genocide. LOL Saxon's original alphabet was a rune system that was replaced by Italy's Latin alphabet. Both the French Norman (Latin-based) and Latin alphabet (Italy's Roman Empire legacy) committed cultural genocide.

The truth is: languages are always evolving based on delusions of the current predominant language. Italian, French, Spanish and Portuguese has its roots from Latin that had been deluded with the local language. Had we stifled our original language from the beginning, we would still be speaking Babylonian.

The funny thing is that the English language famously integrates foreign words, words that describe certain phenomena more accurately or describe phenomena from different cultures. It shows creativity. But then their history is one of integrating many cultures.

@JTTW1455

Жыл бұрын

Anyway, I believe the legislation must be in reaction to the recent uproar over Florentine millennials posting too casually online as representatives of the treasured Renaissance institutions of art and culture .. which means the reporters need to do more research into the issue rather than just grab foreign headlines.

@Tasorius

Жыл бұрын

@@JTTW1455 The reason why the lunatic wants to make that law doesn't matter. She wants to ruin people's lives for mispronouncing words, and for using loan words. She needs to be stopped.

@daraorourke5798

Жыл бұрын

Invading is the word you were struggling for....

@JTTW1455

Жыл бұрын

@@daraorourke5798 yes, were the Romans the first to invade I can’t remember.

@landamaika93

Жыл бұрын

When in the past it's the french lang which is use for 25% in English.

With changes in the economy leading to instability in the stock market, some individuals may face a decrease in their investments in an effort to benefit from the current market conditions, I am considering liquidating my $725k portfolio consisting of bonds and stocks. Someone else in the same situation? Please tell me in the comments!..

@JeremyMeador

Жыл бұрын

would suggest you thoroughly evaluate the companies you have invested in and their estimated future performance, as we may expect to see the market decline further. To minimize stress and improve efficiency, it might be wise to seek the assistance of an investment advisor to help restructure your portfolio and identify any underperforming investments to offset. This approach has been successful for me and has reduced my stress levels.

@shellysalters4244

Жыл бұрын

@@JeremyMeador I have been exploring the possibility of utilizing advisors to help navigate the stock market during these uncertain times. However, I am still evaluating their potential effectiveness in providing the support I need.

@JeremyMeador

Жыл бұрын

@@shellysalters4244 Christy Vallen D'souza is an esteemed coach known for her proficiency in her area of expertise. You probably might have come across her. I found her on a CNBC interview where she was featured and i reached out to her afterwards. She has since provided entry and exit points on the securities I focus on. You can carry out a quick internet research on her name for more info. I basically follow her market moves and haven’t regretted doing so...

@shellysalters4244

Жыл бұрын

@@JeremyMeador I was considering changing my investment strategy and planning to sell certain positions. As my retirement is coming soon,I became increasingly stressed. After thoroughly researching Christy Vallen D'souza on internet, I concluded that I had made an informed decision. Thank you for this Pointer. She seems very proficient and flexible. I booked a call session with her too.

@trolojolo6178

Жыл бұрын

Those bots with fake investment bs are just too obvious 🤣

Why can't you use the Canadian model and have both languages in regular use? I agree that each country/culture should have an official national language that is the default, but I also think that having a more globally utilized language (i.e. English) as a secondary available if for no other reason than record-keeping/backup, that'd be fine too. I wouldn't go to Mexico expecting people to speak English, but if there were a number of signs with both languages on them--with Spanish being the first and largest--that would be considerate, useful, and also deferential to the national language of the country/culture. Have parliamentary meetings in said native language, it makes sense. We have subtitles technology, that's a suitable compensation.

I bet the Italians will be relieved by this "PRIDE" Law. While across Europe most people are able to hold a conversion in 2 to 5 languages when you hit the southern parts of Italy you most often find yourself having to use sign language if you can't speak ITALIANO.

Limiting the use of English will make it tough for people to mention some technical terms in official documents and thus limit communication, other than that, promoting one's langauge is a good move.

@stevenhenry5267

Жыл бұрын

You got the first part right. Your second point is just reactionary.

@jasonMB999

Жыл бұрын

I can't imagine what will happen to their aviation industry 😂. Pilots will have to go back to school

@LS.....

Жыл бұрын

So invention of new words is necessary

@agatastaniak7459

Жыл бұрын

It will impede the mobility of professionals between countires. Especially in IT and medicine, that's for sure. If India stops teaching medicine in English professionals from India will have no chance of career outside India. Since Indian languages are very exotic to other continents, multiple, with very exotic looking alphabet. Resources for learners are scarce. Modern terms in science are not included in these publications. So yes, countries can protect against a brain drain effectively in this way offering medical or IT education in their native language only but it's a very short-sighted politics. In case emigration of professionals is needed, without a global language it's going to be impossible. Sometimes such things are the matter of life and death. In my country during WWII many members of Jewish population died since for cultural reasons they never learned any other language than yiddish, so not knowing our national official language they couldn't ask for help or be warned on time before being arrested. They also feared their new non-Jewish neigbours after being forcibly displaced by Germans across our entire country. Jewish population has learned its lesson and in mdern times Jewish people are among most keen and best learners of various foreign languages. Why? They know we we can never predict when and why and which foreign language will be able to save our life. So it's better to know them rather than not to know them. I also exist since one of my grannies didn't dispute why she has to learn German to perfection and thanks to this and her knowledge of French and English she alone managed to save many lives, of her own relatives but not only.

@tabletalk33

Жыл бұрын

Good point. Many of the world's languages simply do not have the technical/scientific vocabulary to compete with English. No way. In that case, if they want to function in that arena, they must borrow the English, just as English has borrowed a great many foreign words to propel its own ascent.

I agree with this. A country has to maintain its culture. Don’t like it then don’t live there.

@karenk3593

Жыл бұрын

The problem, though, is then they become isolated, don't you think? And limit tourism dollars and international business to only those who can speak that particular language that is not common around most of the world. As much as I'd love to see Italy, I sure won't go there now, because I can't speak Italian and it's against their law to communicate with me now. That's pretty severe.

@lucascruze416

Жыл бұрын

@@karenk3593 the PM of Italy has done a diploma in tourism now she is banning English look at the hypocrisy 🤣 this is just to divert attention

@thewhatorwhy

Жыл бұрын

​@@lucascruze416 Incredible. Maybe she specialized in Fascist Tourism with visits to all the concentration camps (to get ideas).

@ClaudiaDiLorenzo-gg8wl

Жыл бұрын

​@@karenk3593 don't worry. the ban only applies to those who work in the public administration, it doesn't apply to all of us Italians. This is on italian media

@ClaudiaDiLorenzo-gg8wl

Жыл бұрын

​@@lucascruze416 no they don't ban English only foreign words in public administration

It did not ban English it just trying to protect Italian grammar. Nothing wrong with it. You can still speak and learn English no problem. USA for example does not have “official language” most people speak and understand English. Because USA is a country of immigrants. Statue of Liberty states “Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”. That is why it’s the greatest country in the world no matter how much you hate it. It will always be the best country for everybody because it always puts people first no matter what color you are or language you speak. People from all over the world bringing their best with them making this country the greatest and population is growing every year.

This law is against the use of English words in internal affairs, not to communicate with tourists. Recent governments in Italy have done laws named in English and many politicians, as the national tv, use often English words, sometimes in a wrong way, that older Italian people can't understand, even if there are the corresponding Italian words

Here's a German joke from the 1960s. An English worker worked his way up and is now businessman. He has good business relationships with German companies. His son is 18 years old and will later inherit the company. The businessman wants his son to experience life as a worker and learn German. He sends him to Germany in one car factory. After three months, the son comes back and speaks perfect Italian.

@andreab7689

Жыл бұрын

The joke is that to make a decent German car it takes an Italian. And yet they're still not as good as a Ferrari or a Lamborghini

@wilhelmmeyer89

Жыл бұрын

@@andreab7689 Ferrari is FIAT and Lambo is VW. Where would the Italian economy be without the Euro. Italian Lira would be far below Turkish Lira.

@andreab7689

Жыл бұрын

@@wilhelmmeyer89 I don't have a precise idea since I'm not an economist or an Italian but it's apparent that I'm a bit less birdbrained than you, because I know that the northern regions of Italy are among the richest in the world thanks to their strong industry and not really the euro. I mean just think fashion and how insanely huge it is. Poor Italy relying on the euro is a funnier story that your lame 60s joke on immigrants. Perfectly good German humour, nobody is saying that it isn't. By the way, did you know that the Germans are possibly the Europeans that emigrated the most? The majority of Americans of European descent are not British, they're Germans. Huge communities of Germans in Brazil and Latin America too. There are Germans immigrants even in freaking Namibia for God's sake. I wonder if Namibian have a 60s joke on how everyone working in Namibian fields speaks German.

@aycc-nbh7289

Жыл бұрын

@@andreab7689 Didn’t Yakov Smirnoff try to learn English by watching American TV only to realize by accident he was learning Spanish?

@jotaere100

Жыл бұрын

@@wilhelmmeyer89 Hey Wilhelm take it easy I thought you liked jokes, even though your joke is a little classist bordering on racist I get it

As an Englishman who visits France regularly I get frustrated at native people who speak to me in English when I’m trying to converse in my not very good French. Very often they will say they don’t mind because they are practicing their English. My French will never improve whilst that continues however.

@lasallsa3480

Жыл бұрын

🤣🤣👍👍💚💛❤️

@caramia4789

Жыл бұрын

I live in Italy and the Italians do the same to me. My Italian is good but they ignore that and speak English.

@tombartram7384

Жыл бұрын

Tu devrais répondre avec "on se trouve en France on parle français!" Moi je sais parler le Català et personne réponde jamais en anglais quand je suis là. Ja, mais.

@markoz673bajen8

Жыл бұрын

Recall that Latin is not Spanish speaker.

@AlistairBalister

Жыл бұрын

I’m also upset that I’m my country (El Salvador) the government is naming everything in English, and people are naming businesses in English, I don’t want that, I’m against using a foreign language to name everything. Just because it's cool, we're losing our identity.

Auhhh nice to see you palki mam , after a long time.. The way you have presented news in weon b4 , Was a big fan of yours. In the mid was busy with my work. Now after a long time saw you here thought to present my views. First post 👍 God bless you mam.

Languages are dynamic. They are constantly changing. Words from other languages are adopted by the local language. A look at the etymology of numerous English words bears this out. Many names in the sciences and technology are consistent from language to language. A world wide culture must have a common language to break down communication barriers. Yet, this move to maintain local languages and cultures can be perceived as stepping back into a more nationalistic outlook which is something that has been demeaned and discouraged for many years now. The dichotomy is interesting.

@donaldmickunas8552

Жыл бұрын

@Red Beard's Racing There appears to be those who attempt to control how a people group think through manipulation of the language. Examples of this abound in the United States. I find it a deplorable attempt at manipulation. Language, IMO, should be allowed to change naturally with the culture in a group of people.

@charlesburfoot1799

Жыл бұрын

Many words in English are derived from overseas including from India

@4666hero

Жыл бұрын

Europe is getting radical day by day.

@daraorourke5798

Жыл бұрын

Who wants a world wide culture though

@ArkLord001

Жыл бұрын

Come to Quebec. It's been here (Language Police) for decades now and it's really not interesting anymore when you're walking down a street talking with a friend or family and some random moron walks up to you and starts screaming at you to speak French because you're in Quebec and Quebec is a French Country (another Delusion they hold). You then have to proceed to let them know Quebec is a Province in Canada and not it's own country and then the fight starts, the police get called, the Non-Francophones get arrested for assault or harassment... and the Police will ignore you if you're not speaking in French (The regular police, not the language Police). Or my favourite, going to a hospital emergency room and getting throw out because you spoke English.

If she was so concerned about preserving Italy's independence, she would throw out NATO and have an Italy-cantered foreign policy, not a US/UK dominated one.

@blackprince4074

Жыл бұрын

And get rid of the euro monetary system.

So to all tourists, if you do not speak Italian, don’t go to Italy anymore. Simple as that. They will miss money from tourists.

English is the lingua franca of all nations. You can promote it to the benefit of the nation and preserve own national language in the meantime. Languages can coexist in harmony just like people. Look at Switzerland, Canada, Dubai and the whole of UAE, and India itself etc. Languages and multilingualism have enriched not weakened these countries in many ways.

Imagine every country bans foreign languages and we are imprisoned in a world where no one nation can understand others’ language! Yes, we would be literally imprisoned within the geographical barrier of a limited place. Love and learn your own language but don’t ever limit yourself to that only. We all are global citizens.

@GrandeCapo_PallaPesante

Жыл бұрын

Yes of course. But it is not the matter.

@johngarofano7356

Жыл бұрын

I don't know how you came to the conclusion that Italy is banning the english languge . It is thought in all the schools in Italy .It is the lingua franca of the world ,it would be like cutting your tongue ,all the italian government wants is that we do not hybrids our language nothing more nothing less ,because what is happening now is that too many english terms are replacing italian ones can you honestly blame us for protecting what is regarded by many as a beautiful languge ,look it up or Google it ,don't take my word for it,we want our language that our ancestors spoke to remain the same and not a mish mash of languages like in the Phillipines and other countries of the world where Britain Or America once ruled and your country is a good example !

@brewcity2317

Жыл бұрын

Did Italy say it was outlawing English? I thought the proposal was restrict government writing to the Italian language? All non-foreign language classes at UW-Milwaukee required class papers be submitted in English. Science courses of course used Latin and Greek words as well.

@GrandeCapo_PallaPesante

Жыл бұрын

@@brewcity2317 the situation in Italy is as follows: after a war made by the Italian state against the more than 25 original dialects, which however were real languages, the original idioms during the centuries, and which were a peculiar characteristic of Italy, thanks to the mass media in the last 50 years the official Italian has now become the language spoken by everyone, not only on official occasions but also in homes, among friends, etc. The problem is that in this period the mass media have begun to mix foreign words, almost always English words, in sentences in Italian language. The reason must be sought especially in the fact that, according to a distorted vision of history, the dominant political class intends to make people believe that by saying many English words one is more "globalist", more "European", more "progressive" while the Italian spoken in the classical way it is characteristic of the "fascists". We have reached a point that in a single page of a mainstream newspaper there can be hundreds or thousends of English words, on TV they say one in every sentence, even in the laws or in the administration English words are continuously used. Unfortunately, people are bombarded every day and slowly but surely are starting to speak in this way, ironically called "itanglese" (itanglish). Where dialects are still spoken, this process proceeds much more slowly, which is why I spoke of dialects, because the true Italian languages, spontaneous, rich and natural, were the dialects. As you can see, the problem is twofold, on the one hand the imposition of a classical but not very spontaneous language, on the other the political drive to use foreign terms. The current government is trying to stop this process at least in the laws and in the public administration, because in these cases there is also a terrible problem of misunderstandings and concealments that arise due to bad or cunning translation. I speak English, many Italians like me, but I speak English with foreigners, English spoken. When I speak with an Italian I speak our native language, I believe this is absolutely normal, and I don't speak "Itanglish", it would be a nonsense.

@markusoreos.233

Жыл бұрын

First of all, children on elementary school areb't choosing to learn English, they're a being forced. No one choses what subject to study at school. Second it's not foreing languageS it's english. English usually prevents people form learning foreign languages other than it.

I love that my country is multilingual, with all languages respected and their speakers protected. Our official documents are almost all in English, and thus accessible to all language groups, as are jobs. English is learned, alongside home languages, from an early age and our indigenous languages continue to thrive.

@carloko08

Жыл бұрын

if you accept the idiocy that you said then england not only colonized and ruined your country but also your mind, now you are an excellent subject of king charles

@lilchoppa7833

Жыл бұрын

@@carloko08 Bro wut drugs U on G?? I need sum 😂😂

@joannaaltena8174

Жыл бұрын

Italy was not a British colony like your country geeeez

@earlmyname4257

Жыл бұрын

It says in official documents...do u understand English?

@baphithi

Жыл бұрын

@@tere3569 neither is mine a small country. We actually have Italians too, as well as every other nationality from this here earth. Imagine if each province insisted on the dominant language being the only language used for everything. Some Europeans often forget that we are in the year 2023, and not 1823.

200 years ago, my family members were speaking Italian, Welsh, Gaelic, Irish and Cornish. We don't really need 6,000 languages.

I am Scottish , and fully agree with protecting local Languages everywhere aswell as dialects and accents . For example a person from Glasgow sounds completely different from someone 40 miles away ' same words ' different accent and sounds foreign to a Londoner . I ❤ your channel and hope to visit India , I have tasted some of your food and met some of your amazing people over here and hope I see your country one day . Thankyou .

@Tasorius

Жыл бұрын

But this method of protecting local languages is insane. It will only stagnate the language.

@weefreedavielittle

Жыл бұрын

@@Tasorius insane ? Has this been repeatedly done with the same negitive outcome ? Will words, local accents language and dialects stagnate in oxygen starved putrid rotting mess ? I think not ' and what about that diversity are we all being programmed for ? Theyll be none everyone will look sound and communicate the same robotic way .. governed controlled enslaved brainwashed . Your statements flawed at best .

@JJaqn05

Жыл бұрын

Classic common Scottish L

@weefreedavielittle

Жыл бұрын

@@JJaqn05 😁🥰

This channel offers another view of the world and Palki Sharma has a beautiful voice!

@geopaulet923

Жыл бұрын

She has a very heavy accent. Sometimes hard to understand

@cass6885

Жыл бұрын

@@geopaulet923 Go get hearing test done. You might need hearing aids.

@deepakkushwaha7411

Жыл бұрын

Bro ur name...pelain

@CosmicCitiZenOfficial

Жыл бұрын

she will leave it soon after 5M subscribers

even France regulates how many English language songs are played on the radio. Here in Germany English terms everywhere and now the German English languages ​​are mixing.

@HrithikSD4368

Жыл бұрын

Here in india we have a term for this Hinglish 😅where we speak Hindi with so many English words because new English words weren't translated in Hindi or translation was too hard to learn

@luciatheron1621

Жыл бұрын

They have common sources...Anglo saxon...languages evolve...

@harrodsfan

Жыл бұрын

@@HrithikSD4368 same in my country, Greece. They call it Greeklish .

@futureisyours3016

Жыл бұрын

Th(d)anke sho(much)en.

@noyota

Жыл бұрын

"Germans" don't even fight back when München is called Mewnick or their National Dog is called Danish. And the Deutsch are called German. Anglophone ineptitude is even blasphemous. They changed Yeshua to Jesus and Miryam to Mary, Cefas to Peter and Yakov to James. Good riddance, build more schools. Nederlanders are called Dutch and a daalder became a dollar, Jantje became Yankee.

👍I am an American and very proud of it but we u.s.a. can't and should not go everywhere around the world trying to impose our language & culture. Sometimes we do it unconsciously and we take it for granted. But that's arrogant. By the same token we would not like a foreigner coming to the USA and telling us (for example): "sorry, I don't speak English, talk to me in Spanish, or Japanese, or Arabic, German,"etc. We would consider it disrespectful. Italians, just like any other nation, have the right to demand to foreigners or visitors to be be addressed to in the native, guest country. Sorry if I offend my American country fellows.

I'm Italian and It Is not what You say here . There Is only an attemp to protect the abuse of anglosaxon terms in the d2d regular use , nothing more than that . In example can not be that the Italians forget their 77.000 own dictionary words by polluting It with foreigners One . This has nothing to do with the MUST to study foreigners languages so to communicate with the rest of the World,as It must to be in this modern Age .

It's always a pleasure to listen to presentations by Palki... she has a good style... 👍

@pcpolice2314

Жыл бұрын

in English :)

@ImagesOfCountries

Жыл бұрын

​@@pcpolice2314 Yes, you're correct 😊... her accent in English appeals especially to Asians... 😊

@AnkitSingh-lu8cj

Жыл бұрын

V😮😮😊😊fyyy😮y😮😢yyy😮😮tt😮ty😮yyry😅ytyttyy😮y😅tyttyyy😅😮😮😮😮t😅tyr😅ttu😅😅r😅ty😮t😮😮😢😮😮😮😮😮😮😮y😮😮t😮ty😅😢😮

@ianstobie

Жыл бұрын

She handles stress in English very well, while still remaining recognisably Indian. Since stress is used to carry emphasis and shades of meaning in English, it's a useful asset to a news anchor.

Palki is such a remarkable news anchor, she's more than an anchor, she's a story teller, excellent 👏

@mi-ndio-ule-dem5458

Жыл бұрын

She's the best!

@saifspetsnaz3737

Жыл бұрын

Bullshit 😂 🤡

When in the Roman Empire there were marble saunas, cities like Rome with giant stadiums, columns in all their buildings, while the barbarians of the north lived on the trees and spoke in monosyllables.

My respect for Italy has now vanished. How can Italy prevent their people to learn the world language? Any government who does that should be punished, depriving people of opportunity, knowledge and connection.

The irony of the French pushing back against English is how many words English has taken from French, some several times, such as "Ward" (Norman French) and "Guard" (Frankish French), meaning that we English have more French words for certain things like "Protector" - Warden, Guardian - than the French do themselves... 🤨

@chaschoune

Жыл бұрын

You think that the French language does not borrow words from English? All languages borrow from other languages.

@Churros1616

Жыл бұрын

@@chaschoune english has borrowed far more words from French than the other way around. French did not take many English words actually and most of these English words in French are actually new words like selfie.

@onlineempire4204

Жыл бұрын

English is the international language because America is the superpower 🇺🇲 And also Dollar is the international currency because America is the superpower🇺🇲 But India not a superpower 🤣

@dontbeafraidimhere5421

Жыл бұрын

Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages ​​are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"second official language"* in all states of India! (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 5) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. It is better that we accept the reality and equally important to respect all our Indian languages.

@Severussnape09

Жыл бұрын

English was created from French during the 1300’s . All royals spoke French or something similar up until the 1300’s.

God help us to protect us from Politicians

@brunomorais9526

Жыл бұрын

God hates materialistic world worshippers.

It's the right thing to do and it has nothing to do with the use of English and other languages by common people. It's just mandatory to use italian words for the official documents, where the silly habit to use english terms instead of existing italian words had no justification. It's something that other countries, like France, have been already doing for years.

Yes good for their culture. Well presented as always Palki.

Dunno how I could have gotten along during my many travels in India, Bangladesh and Pakistan without the pleasure of being able to have quite funny and interesting conversations in proper English with almost anyone I met, from shoe shine boy to CEO. Nobody could or did expect a foreigner to pick up Tamil, Gujarati, Bengali, Urdu, Kannada and God knows what local dialect when frequently changig places and states. Even the locals used English amongst their own compatriats. Banning languages has, so very often, been the beginning of peoples' demise and downfall into obscurity. Not learning less, but more languages is the proper approach, as long as you do not neglect your own native tongue and culture.

@scintillam_dei

Жыл бұрын

The Indian "Sadhgure" refused to learn Sanskrit but I plan to learn Sanskrit, Hindi and Tamil despite being Spanish.

@saloni2244

Жыл бұрын

Why locals were talking in English among each other Acc to me English should be used only when the other person doesnt understand your language and you too dunno know their language

@marie22213

Жыл бұрын

Lol my husband's from there and he speaks all of them. English, Bengal, Hindi, Punjabi. Sometimes I wonder how his brain hasn't popped 🤣

India has 48 languages if not more. How can one manage? All languages and all cultures must be perserved and encouraged. We cannot afford to lose even one.

@cass6885

Жыл бұрын

Learn at least basic Sanskrit level and everyone will learn many other languages in bargain including Tamil.

@HrithikSD4368

Жыл бұрын

​@@cass6885 sanskrit can't be learnt overnight and their is no current syllabus books like science or tech in Sanskrit. So it's impossible to implement sanskrit.

@riteshramanbindra4991

Жыл бұрын

Hey, I don't care about this but what I want is people who speak English should not judge who can't speak it. English in India is still taken as a parameter to decide somebody's intelligence.

@danielmartin7838

Жыл бұрын

Isn't it beautiful English exists to bridge that gap?

@serenangpalaka

Жыл бұрын

i totally agree

I live in Italy and I am bilingual. The use of English words and expressions is common, but they are frequently mispronounced and used inappropriately, a fact which I find irritating and prevents Italians form learning correct English

I'll note that, at least from what this video says, Italy is not trying to ban the use of English words by Italians, but rather is insisting that official govt communications be done in Italian. That seems proper to me, given that Italian is presumably the official language of Italy. I'll note as well that historically, the widespread use of standard Italian was a critical factor in creating the Italian nation a couple of centuries ago. Before the Italians all started speaking Italian, they didn't identify primarily as Italians, but rather as whatever their local region was. I can see how the Italians might view their language as essential glue that keeps their very diverse country together. And part of what allowed standard Italian to act as a unifying force for the nation is that it was NOT the native language of the conquering Piedmont region, but rather was the local dialect of Florence, which was one of the conquered areas. This removed the symbolism of adopting Italian as meaning the submission of one region to another. While I know much less about India than I do about Italy, I suspect that English plays a similar role there. Like Italy, India has many local cultures with different languages, which probably don't get along with each other all that well. By using English as the common language they avoid placing any of these languages above any of the others, which helps reduce tribal conflicts. If they were to replace English with Hindi as the official language, that would communicate strongly that India is a Hindu state, and that the other cultures are subjects rather than equal citizens. That would be disastrous for India.

Hmmmm this is a tough one - may be better to take an approach like Korea’s where your culture is v attractive so young people want to learn more about it etc etc. Anyway am glad that my kids know three languages and have native level fluency in 2 including English. But anyone speaking fluently in any language is a beautiful thing. The beauty of a good communicator is just astounding

Here in Brazil we have no alternative, once our language is from a “colonial power”. So I’m a pragmatic person and use English so I can connect all people all over the world. It is just a mean to an end, no prejudice. Once in Paris I was so badly treated by locals because I don’t speak French, so that they don’t deserve to get my tourist money once they don’t provide a common ground for us to communicate. Have in mind that many countries in the world depends on tourism, and restricting the use of English would be a burden

@alexgodeye3031

Жыл бұрын

I'm from Uruguay, feel the same way, and had the same experience in France.

Hello, I am Italian and I think that this law is not necessary. We can preserve our culture in any other way. English is not the problem, Italian is. The one they are not teaching in school. Now and then, speaking with my daughter I say some words and she just stares at me... She doesn't know the words I am using, so I explain her the words, the Latin or Greek derivation, the meaning. Then she would go at school and use it, and a teacher would tell her those words are obsolete, there is no need in learning them. What the heck? Isn't my daughter going to read some classic book one day? Isn't an obsolete word part of our culture and heritage we need to protect? So, you see... It's not to protect anything. It's so we talk about this silly law and not about the fact that Europe wants to give us money to help us survive, after COVID crisis but our pathetic politicians have no idea about how to use them... So please, this law is just smock in the eyes, don't be blind. Bye

Calm down people! It's only for official documents. No one is taking the "Tee-bagging" from us. Almost all countries do this to some extent

Wow.this is all said in English..I go to Italy once every two years.. amazing place,food,people flooded with so many millions if boat people of late. EU has English as the common language,with not a single member State whose language is English. We all must be very proud,must love,learn our language with pride. English is like the latest Tesla model, a language that has taken and accepted words from all languages. Can be spoken in so many accents,dialects..each street has an accent in England,so also in India. No one talks about Spanish and Portugese that is spoken in many parts of the world. Go to Portugal,Lisbon in particular. English is so widely spoken. We all need a common language to communicate in this multi polar world. English is the only language of ease and convenience and with a big sense of humour

@azzureone78

Жыл бұрын

The Republic of Ireland speaks English and is in the EU.

@stevethecross2727

Жыл бұрын

​@@azzureone78 I know it's insulting but to the rest of the world Irish Scottish and English is the same thing. Not to me though I can spot every different type of Anglo there is but I'm French and I know my historical rivals. Just like Africa is a diaspora we are too.

@ianstobie

Жыл бұрын

Malta is the second EU country where English is an official language and widely taught and spoken. Maltese is the local language, and is the first language of most of the island's population. Maltese has the reputation of being difficult for others to learn. It's based on a medieval version of Arabic, but because of the history of the island it has been isolated from mainstream Arabic for many centuries and so has developed many of its own distinctive features. Maltese is an official language of the EU, which means all treaties and official acts have to be translated into it.

@joe_lubinda

Жыл бұрын

Flooded by indians too

@erics7992

Жыл бұрын

You're right about how English can be spoken with a lot of different accents and it works with all of them. From Cockney to the American South to Australia to India

France past a similar law, years and years ago, trying to limit the use of English in advertizing and such...to no avail. Politicians can not stop the normal evolution of languages, and the use of English does NOT threaten anything, as it will never replace the local language. It is perfectly normal to be influenced by other places and countries. It's been like this for centuries.

@waynepond8748

Жыл бұрын

You are partly right. Languages do have a natural way of evolving even though great effort and laws are put in place to manipulate that evolution, there will always be a certain degree of natural evolution to take place. English as well as the other major world languages do however pose a threat to minority languages. About 41 percent of the world's languages are endangered. Italian is not in a position of being endangered but certainly will continue to absorb more English words and phrases as long as English continues to dominate the economic and cultural global landscape. Coming from the Caribbean island of Dominica, we are English speaking but the majority of our population also speak French Creole. This is also the case on our sister island of St.Lucia, but on Grenada French Creole is now only spoken by a small percentage of older folk and is endangered. In Trinidad there are certain towns where French Creole is spoken but it is also endangerd because of English.

Iceland and others already have very strict controls on loanwords, it is possible to create local variants of English words, it's been done in countries and succeeded. Italy is not out of step for trying the same. In recent years (by historical standards) there has been efforts to present the authentic identity of various peoples. That's in response to globalism. See Iran insisting on being called IRAN, not Persia.

It’s fair enough. Foreign (English)words are creeping in and taking over the Italian language. Something has to be done. The French and Spanish have been doing it for decades. What is so strange?

Never give up your native language but do not stop learning other languages. If we can't communicate with each other we can't grow together. And I'm not speaking about our leaders...

Wittgenstein: "The limit of my language is the limit of my world." Lee Kwan Yu: "The market will determine the language."

@barnaclelevi

Жыл бұрын

Wise :) Haw-la

@tabletalk33

Жыл бұрын

A message for Lee: The market already HAS determined the language: ENGLISH.

Good for them! They have every right to protect their heritage! Every culture does… and should!

I am a American who is old enough to know languages are ever changing. The United States also inherited English from being a colony of Great Britain. But, live in the State of Florida where Spanish is spoken by a large number of Citizens. The further South in Florida you go the more prominent Spanish becomes. Most times when you call to pay a bill or for customer service the first thing the automatic system will ask is “for English press 1, for Spanish press 2”. There was a period that politicians wanted to enshrine English as the native tongue of the United States. Fortunately, that was never passed into law and many countries seem to go through a protectionist period. Languages should be appreciated, for now English is the Universal language. Who knows what tongue will be used in 200 years?

As much as I also love seeing 🇮🇳 Indian languages being promoted, I think it is important that we also realise how much our English-language education is helping Indians abroad becoming CEOs of the topmost Tech companies like Google, Microsoft, Twitter, Adobe, IBM and KZread, etc. in contrast to other nations like China.

@ginad013

Жыл бұрын

They have become perfect product of English education. Language is tool of subversion especially after colonization.

@Shimra8888

Жыл бұрын

China is more proud of its language than India. Shame on India!

@thegreatharborshipofbentus3567

Жыл бұрын

That "other" nation China is about to take over the world. Clearly might is the sole universal language in the human kingdom.

@orientalguy9462

Жыл бұрын

​@paper plane sanskrit is the most suitable language for that purpose.

@orientalguy9462

Жыл бұрын

To become a technology developer, there should be an education system in own language, For example science curriculum in Japan is in Japanese language and in Germany it's in German language, in Israel it's in Hebrew language, in France it's in French language.

What an amazing video and analysis. I wonder if this trend on losing the english will help us to interconnect, looks like everything gets separated this days. Im a native spanish speaker from Mexico and most of my internet content, travel and work is in english.

English is the worlds ECONOMIC language, as well as the technological language, those that don’t speak it cannot easily trade with the world. But, every nation should demand that their own language be mandatory! We are a world of many cultures and that is good. If one wants to visit other countries, they should know that countries language or not go visit it.

"English is the language of commerce." --B5

Local language always ranks first and must be protected, a common language to be a world citizen also must be promoted for world unity and peace , So knowing two languages is always better than only with One language

@lalodaniels1388

Жыл бұрын

That language should not be English. Something new that will unite the world. English and the English people have only oppressed and divided the world.

@sucram1018

Жыл бұрын

Something most Americans don't fit the criteria for statistically speaking.

@kingdomofbird8174

Жыл бұрын

World citizenship is crap!

@leviturner3265

Жыл бұрын

There need not be an official world language for any reason whatsoever. People should be encouraged to learn their native language. Anything they do past that is up to them. If someone wants to that is their own business, but other languages and dialects should not suffer as a result. I think that learning another language does indeed broaden your horizons, but I think you lose something in the process. That may be just some ignorance, and lack of perspective that is lost but I think it is more than that. The more that you learn another language the more you delve into the culture of the people who speak that language, and in the process you lose part of who you were. Someone cannot be everyone. I am not saying to not learn another language. If a person wants to that is their own choice. If someone who was English became more French wouldn't they in turn become less English? That person would have more of a French insight than an Englishman who does not know French, but in finding new perspectives you lose what perspectives you had. I personally am learning German. My great grandmother was the last person in my family that spoke the language. If it was not for two world wars German would likely be a major language in the United States, as more people have German blood than any other group in the states.

@warcrimeconnoisseur5238

Жыл бұрын

"World unity" holy shit

Let people choose the language they want to speak. If a language is worth speaking and writing, you won't need the force of law to enforce its use.

Awsome Italy!! We need more people like her, stay away from trash!!

Like it or not, the hard truth is that English will remain the connecting language across most Indian states for eons. *Hindi will never become the connecting language* The 5 Southern states (accounting for 31% of GDP) and several other states will never allow Hindi to be imposed because of the rich and ancient deep-rooted languages that they already have which predate Hindi by centuries. People should accept the fact that "Indianized English" (Example of Indianized English word - Prepone) is also an Indian language. English albeit Indian English is here to stay. One can debate till the cows come home but *English* will have the last laugh.

They are right. Otherwise their language will dispare

@eswaribalan164

Жыл бұрын

Disappear? What do you want then? Latin?😂

@cry371

Жыл бұрын

what are you on about man...did you know that in Italy all films/shows everything that is on TV is dubbed in italian even when you go to cinema??? now tell me how will the language disappear?

That's what governments would like to happen, because if people could only speak their native language they wouldn't be able to get information about what's happening in the rest of the world, it would make control so much easier for the rulers

@gurnoorsingh4595

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂really I would say they will not be brainwashed by USA and UK

Italy is not banning the English language. The Law in Italy says „ You can not use foreign Language not even foreign words in official documents “

Quebec in Canada has that new Bill 96 which is supposed to be an extra addition to existing Bill 101 which forces businesses to use French first and ideally French only. I don't speak French & I am going on a trip up there from the US this June. I wonder what it will be like vs 2008.

Sounds like keeping people where they are.

This is what politicians come up with when they have no solution for real problems

@sadsul2691

Жыл бұрын

True

@kamaleshroy6608

Жыл бұрын

Abdul, don't think about it. It's ramadan month. Think about j!H@d

@muhammadisaac07

Жыл бұрын

Agree

@JhaokipKuki

Жыл бұрын

This is what happen when fools hold high offices

@gema9835

Жыл бұрын

thank you aahahah i did not find a word to explain it like you ahahahahahahaa

Who said that they banned english? They just banned some english expressions. English is so widespread in some countries it squeezes out many domestic language expressions. It sounds funny sometimes.

English is just a business language. Just get over it.

This is what Putin has been talking about for years

@karinaivankova4099

Жыл бұрын

Russian is wide spoken language in former Soviet Union countries. I am from Ukraine, and I don't even speak Ukranian, I live in Southern Ukraine where for everybody naive language is Russian.