What I don’t understand is why Iran, Egypt, Syria, etc does not want ANY of the Palestine people to shelter there??

@nvrbetrwhoohoo3941

4 ай бұрын

The short story is they have in the past, but they don’t make good houseguests and end up getting asked to leave.

@NiloufarShokouhi

4 ай бұрын

thats exactly that Israel wants, that land without the people. (im not justifying anything)

@Kiarinadia

4 ай бұрын

Egypte who has not open its borders and we know that 80% of gaza people are Egyptians (see their names).

This tragic situation in Gaza is why I was so perplexed when I saw “Free Palestine” supporters dancing in the streets and celebrating all across the West following the Oct 7th massacre. Cuz like…..y’all HAD to know that strikes were coming next, right? Especially if you hold the opinion that the state of Israel is an evil, racist, genocidal government. I’d be interested in speaking to that one Islamic priest who rejoiced, stating at a rally, “I’m happy! I’m ELATED!”…to see if he feels that way now seeing Gaza today.

@FBAagent

7 ай бұрын

Hamas and Netanyahu work together for money and power man. It’s easy these bombs they are not free. And both Netanyahu and Hamas need a reason to exist. There are protests against Netanyahu before oct 7. Hamas? Well their internal enemy is the secular Fatah who negotiates with Israel. Both want power and money and the only way they can get them is by chaos. I think neither Israelis nor Palestinians want this. Hamas is corrupt as hell and so is Netanyahu. Follow the money money money and you will see the « why ». War is business man.

@cjbake3238

4 ай бұрын

Amen

@Kiarinadia

4 ай бұрын

And Egypte who has not open its borders and we know that 80% of gaza people are Egyptians (see their names). I have no words. Another thing, its never hamas fighters who die when they gives numbers, always women and children, you would think there is not even one hamas man in the whole area !!!

I pray for all innocent women and children 🙏🏼🙏🏼

@ZidaneDaMan10

5 ай бұрын

innocent men dying out there too, they're picking these women and children out of the rubble with sandals and barely any food or water in their system

BBC you are doing a service to humanity.THANK YOU.

Click here to subscribe to our channel 👉🏽 bbc.in/3VyyriM

@TheFormula313

6 ай бұрын

👍☪️🇿🇦🐬

This is so horrific Nothing justifies this, How do you expect these people to see the humanity in anyone when they lose their own humanity

@wiredvibe1678

7 ай бұрын

It's hard to see how anyone who celebrated October 7th has humanity. I don't think thr isrelis care about what Gazans think at this point. If you get another hamas israel will respond in the same way. Palestinians need to give up on this dream of lands if they want to live in peace. There is no use fighting someone that can do so much damage.

@SunaAoimori

7 ай бұрын

@@wiredvibe1678 Israelis were celebrating having picnic when gazans were being bombed last year. Israelis call for the extinction for arabs, even numerous israeli politicians have said so, this time the same thing happened. the settlers continuously attack kill palestinins with the help of the militairy . yet people like you only look at the palestinian side. Your inhumanity allows your bias but doesnt let you see the whole truth, you are disgusting

@DodZz666

7 ай бұрын

They have been doing this to them for decades

@DodZz666

7 ай бұрын

@@wiredvibe1678can we stop with the rhetoric of people demanding innocent civilians and children to not be bombed = pro Hamas…. It is not pro Hamas … if you are acting like them then how are you any different?!? Israel has passed all international laws , it has gone beyond seeking justice and now is just seeking vengeance and genocide … which I cannot imagine by any means that would be good for the existence of Israel on the long run as with each bomb they drop on a child … someone in the world is radicalized and will also seek vengeance…. Bibi is writting the demise of Israel with his own hands and USA is funding it and no one is realizing that Israel very existence is now on borrowed time ….

@shumotiislam3507

6 ай бұрын

​​ @wiredvibe1678 if Israel people never interfere gaza people's life , then they lived peaceful . Last some day i saw many video or documentary about this. I saw how stupid israil people treat gaza last 70years before oct 7. Obviously when people would be treat like animal they will be fedup . I m no liking war. Bt pls research about israil gaza. Then u understand how and what situations people would be like this... And sorry for my English. I m not good at it.

My heart hurts for the innocent people. Those that just want live and love. I’m so sorry.

@darklord7069

6 ай бұрын

Stfu you don’t even know what Palestine was until now

@Laallahalaallah123

4 ай бұрын

Remember Israel for this

FREE PALESTINE FROM HAMAS!

@ghostwalk510

7 ай бұрын

What a silly comment...this has nothing to do with Hamas anymore..

@aashishpradhan6355

7 ай бұрын

@@ghostwalk510😂😂 so silly it’s nt Israel aliens are attacking

@travelswithminky246

7 ай бұрын

study some history.

@fatmagabsi7457

7 ай бұрын

Disgracing comment when innocents thousands are dead..

@aashishpradhan6355

7 ай бұрын

@@fatmagabsi7457 🤣😂😂😂they themselves chose to stick with Hamas and die 😂🤣where are you from

I am afraid ,may be it's the beging . One day the whole world look alike gaza .

May the people of Palestine survive til this madness is over.

May God take care of the children, innocent souls...why should there be war😥

I cannot imagine i saw and witnessed this horrible situation of the Palestine... My heart broke 💔 its brutal and devastating... so brutal and scary...I cannot do anything... I have just one wish to end this war. I wish and pray for peace and unity... I manifest about the war end and stop the killing to the Palestine People 🙏...

you know it's fucked when the children playing something like 3:36, they think that kind of stuff is normal.

I thought Gaza had a border with Egypt?

@rafster675

6 ай бұрын

They do but Egypt doesn't want gazans because most of then support Hamas.

@123watc

6 ай бұрын

There must be a good reason behind closing the border with Gaza, by the Egyptian Govt. i.e., dangerous

I could swear this is Al Jazeera

@march11stoneytony

7 ай бұрын

BBC and Channel 4 are pandering to the lawless Muslims in the UK

Welcome to the Blind Broadcasting Corporation where only certain things can be seen

@jamesfox2857

4 ай бұрын

PROPAGANDA IS EASY TO SEE AND YOU ARE ONE !!! BERATING THOSE WHOM BRINGS LIGHT TO THE DARK AND YOUR COMMENT IS ONE WHOM WISHES IT TO REMAIN IN THE DARK = YOU ARE THE PROBLEM !!!

اگر یہ اسلام اس دنیا میں نہ ہوتا تو آج یہ دنیا جنت کی مانند ہوتی۔ دنیا کے کسی بھی ملک میں مسلمانوں جیسی سوچ اور ان کے جعلی قرآن 📗 سے امن ممکن نہیں۔ 🙏

@hedda2022

7 ай бұрын

I thought Hinduism was a peaceful religion. Obviously if you are one of the followers, I am wrong. Very sad 😢

@Raysonmyfeet

7 ай бұрын

All religion causes problems.

@KA0007

6 ай бұрын

How can you get a fake Quran? The destruction youre seeing here is caused by the state of israel not Islam. This war has nothing to do with religion.

I could feel the ptsd from the looks of it

my heart is absolutely broken... how has the world allowed this to happen???

@carlosparedes1556

4 ай бұрын

They support hamass if you ask them if they are for another Oct 7 they say yes

The horror...... the horror.......

No matter where you go or where you’re from : Its always gonna be sane people just different faces!

Heart wrenching situation but who is responsible ????

@idealiamcadory3769

5 ай бұрын

Israel. They been killing Palestine for years before oct 7

The war started the 7th October, not the 9th.

I suggest you start this documentary with the October 7th massacre of Hamas in order to explain how it all started .

@arnoldwilson5377

7 ай бұрын

Terrorism does not excuse terrorism.

@serjeantpepper2986

7 ай бұрын

I suggest you actually watch the documentary before commenting. It covers October 7th in the first 3 minutes of the video. It was terrible. 1400 people were killed including 31 children and 240 people were taken hostage. In the month since then Israel has murdered over 4000 children alone. What's your point? If you're trying to justify killing 10,000 people in retaliation for the killing of 1400 people, what would you say is the appropriate response to the murder of 10,000 people?

@rentoshine2038

7 ай бұрын

👍👌👏🙏🥀

@moshebuchachevsky5650

7 ай бұрын

@arnoldwilson5377 I see , if someone retaliated to an attack on him, he is a terrorist by your definition. Maybe in your values, the one who was attacked should turn the other cheek to get another attack? If you make a documentary without an explanation of what caused all this , you are doing propoganda. For example, if you save an old lady from a bus running over her by pushing her aside , and someone is doing a documentary about how you pushed violabtly an old lady , it's true , but it's also a lie , right ?

@ghostwalk510

7 ай бұрын

Then u clearly did not watch this documentary. Because it starts with exactly what u say is missing... And please stop pretending history started on oct 7

Qatar, turkey, Iran also responsible for this situation

Torturous…. to the heart & mind to see this GENOCIDE ! WTF 😮😢💔🙏

Es increíble ver todo este desastre, desgracia en 2023. Me desgarra el alma, el corazón ver tantos civiles inocentes muertos o terriblemente heridos. Me duele tanto por ambos lados. Mis oraciones con todos ustedes 🙏🏼.

Look at the children! My hurt is broken

@menna7927

6 ай бұрын

All i see are future islamic lunatics.

iam out of words these days... My heart is bleeding

This is horrific… RIP to the ones who are killed 🙏🏻 please blur the decreased, its disrespectful to them. And someone please stop this 🙏🏻

Fault of the USA.

@Truevideoz

7 ай бұрын

if usa is bot tgere middke east itself will be xivil war.. Muslims keep ib fighting egeb for water toll 19th century..its just drama noe... check wars

@travelswithminky246

7 ай бұрын

it was actually the British first but America is also at fault.

@rafster675

6 ай бұрын

Correct. The USA gave 6 Million dollers to Iran which was given to Hamas.

It is rare for BBC to be unbiased, but they have managed to do a good job this time.

@galkin2008

7 ай бұрын

BBC is PRO-HAMAS!!! OF COURSE the are biased!

@rogerjohnson2562

6 ай бұрын

Its rare for BBC to be unbiased, and this video proves it.

Where is your October 7th documentary? Or the genesis of this whole thing is not worth documenting?

@travelswithminky246

7 ай бұрын

study history first

@rafster675

6 ай бұрын

​@@travelswithminky246I did.

Started the war and now facing the consequences

@travelswithminky246

7 ай бұрын

you don't know much about history do you?

@SL-786

7 ай бұрын

@@travelswithminky246 It means you justify what hamas did..Lol

@wiredvibe1678

7 ай бұрын

​@@travelswithminky246its easy to make peace. But easier to make war.

@jackieromo1253

7 ай бұрын

@@SL-786 It means you justify what israel is doing... Lol

@galkin2008

7 ай бұрын

Hamas should be blame for this disgrace, their leaders are enjoying their rich life in Qatar with the money that belongs to the Palestinian people. Shame on them

And these fives told whatever hamas told them to tell the west....

We aren’t allowed to leave comments in Australia for anything controversial……this is just horrific I would have gone mad on the 2nd day with anxiety and sorrow……how are people in “power” allowing this murderous atrocity against mostly women children and little babies and the decent good men of Gaza and there are many. I’m so ashamed and angry

And we have more stories to say .... Pray for Gazans❤❤

@rentoshine2038

7 ай бұрын

Why?

@ghostwalk510

6 ай бұрын

@@rentoshine2038 Because innocent children are drying by the thousands.... How could you ask why?

This is heartbreaking. The 7th of October in Israel and the killing of the innocent in Gaza. Hamas hiding while their people are being slain.

@user-lr5ii5ci4d

2 ай бұрын

partizans were doing a ghetto uprising hitlercalled that terrorism

Cause and effect what do you expect after what hamas did last october 7,

Did BBC ask them if they condemn Hamas?

@jamesfox2857

4 ай бұрын

WHY DOES THAT EVEN MATTER ? SAY = YOU """" ZIONIST NAZI = SPEAK NAZI SPEAK """" !!!

This is so heartbreaking for BOTH sides. I’ve seen Jewish people speak out against the radical settlers and I’ve seen Palestinians that don’t hate Jews, both want to live peacefully yet those on the extreme side will not allow this.

Thank you BBC for showing the truth to the world!!!!!

A stain on humanity's conscience forever

War have no fear atomic energy...... So it have to stop!!! No matter who won or lost 😢😢😢😢😢

Consequences of supporting Hamas.

The girl keeps saying "I don't know where to go" while in fact she got clear instructions to go south of the Gaza Stream. The ones who really didn't know where to go were the kids at the music festival whom Hamas terrorists were shooting like ducks.

@Liv-ie4xl

7 ай бұрын

Pls, educate yourself better. No place is sage in war when you know that even these places are bombed currently. And no country will accpet them as refugees. If they will leave Palestine entirely (its already small), they will have no country. In this refugee crisis tormenting the whole world no one will accept them. And they know this. Edit: and for me it seems that their cute warning is an excuse for them to drop bombs that are almost at the energy level of a nuclear bomb that was dropped in Hiroshima.

@galkin2008

7 ай бұрын

Correct

@mahersaoudi1915

6 ай бұрын

Third of the killed people where in the south

@ghostwalk510

6 ай бұрын

And the south also is getting shelled.... so where is the safety it is milions of people dislocated. The health Situation in the south is unbearable. No place for shelter. no Toilette no water no food. All these Pro israel comments are from people who do not read the FACTS of the news. And are so narrow minded that something like "they were told to go south" is enough for them Please Grab a brain and stop getting your news from IDF or Netanjahu corrupt and criminal officials. Many of them are PROVEN criminals. Military and government involved is never a good Source for news. Yet millions believe all words with zero proof

@AaronLin721

6 ай бұрын

"A number of Palestinian Arab prisoners were executed, some after being paraded in West Jerusalem, where they were jeered, spat at, stoned, looted, and eventually murdered. In addition to the killing and widespread looting, there may have been cases of mutilation and rape." -Deir Yassin 1948

May God Bless Palestine ❤

Hamas Hamas, terror, terror tunnels go everywhere. Using people as human shields so sad.

Thank you BBC at last we c some fairness

Finally BBC showing some truth

Thank you BBC. This needs to be watched. Thank you for your humanity. It’s not about religion at this point. It’s all about conscience in your soul. I’m a Catholic and I proudly yell "free Palestine".

Why do they call them refugee camps? My wife and one of my aunts were in refugee camps and they both say their camps looked nothing like these camps shown here. They also noted the kids are clean and have fresh haircuts as well. No torn clothes and nice shoes. Both my wife and aunt didn’t cut their hair in the camp until there was a lice epidemic, they both got lice, heads were shaved several times and my wife got scabies, everything in the camp was muddy, dirty and filthy. No paved roads either? These refugees shown here look mighty well off. What’s the deal?

Let them live , please leave

03:35 These are the kids of Gaza. Where other kids play hide and seek, slides etc; Gazan kids play such games 😓

I pray for all the innocent women and children on the both side. Ordinary people are paying the price for the war unleashed by Hamas. Playing them like pawns, the leaders fattening abroad, and the rest are like rats in tunnels.

Israel gave warning to Gazan to evacuate before bombing, Hamas did not before attacking unarmed Israel civilians

@SunaAoimori

7 ай бұрын

There are a lot of times times Israel doesnt warn at all, as this footage shows they tell them to go south but even try to attack sputh stop your lies

@travelswithminky246

7 ай бұрын

study the history first

@Hellojsm8823

7 ай бұрын

How ridiculous, it is an impossible task. They had been under siege for 27 days without the water and the food. How can they escape? Where can they go? How can the injured civilians trapped in the buildings be safely transported from one place to another over such a long distance, with military bombing happening everywhere?

@shumotiislam3507

6 ай бұрын

Seriously bro. When israil people warning gaza people, When they bombing 😂😂😂 or in dreams. They did not give electricity or water. If they really concern about gaza civilian they never cut electricity or water.

Its still being bombarded after two months

THIS IS A PRADIGM SHIFT... ALL LIFE IS SACRED.. ALL LAND IS HOLY ALL MASKS ARE FALLING

Yeh Allah....pls stop this War.. innocent people are dying 😢

@wiredvibe1678

7 ай бұрын

The ones who started it fight in the name of Allah

@march11stoneytony

7 ай бұрын

​@@wiredvibe1678Allah vs Allah: 2023

@rogerjohnson2562

6 ай бұрын

martyrs are incense to Allah, read your sacred texts

do not interfer keep untedstaes army in the unitedstaes

Rso quiso hamas y hezbola quien quiere guerra atengase a las consecuencias pir eso es mejor evitar la guerra hablar conversar recibir y dar ..pero guerras he alli las consecuencias ...como en ucrania

My heart breaks for all these people who have been forsaken by the world. Why is this allowed to carry on? It’s beyond harrowing. History will not judge us kindly for the atrocities being inflicted on these people who have no escape.

Blame HAMAS for what has happened. Gaza could have been such a great opportunity but radical HAMAS wouldn’t allow it!

Bbc programma hypothesis and deceptive

They are very cruel, that anyone who sees this film will go live in Gaza for a month and see the barbarism of these people and then decide if there are innocent people there. What Hamas has done is with the support of all the residents of Gaza and they are not sensitive to the slaughter of human beings and the rape of women. This will be the fate of Europe if they do not stend with Israel. I am not jewish but I understand that situation

Question if u warning Palestine before u bomb aren’t also warning Hamas. So how are u killing Hamas if u are warning them before u bomb. Hamas has a better chance of relocating than the citizens because of the tunnels . So explain to me again how are u getting ur targets. Also why would Hamas continue to hide behind civilians if ur bombing civilians.

I don’t recall if the BBC did a “woa is me” documentary in Germany during WWII when Britain and the allies bombed the crap out of them. Oh, of course that was ok because Germany bombed them first.

@rogerjohnson2562

6 ай бұрын

Well said; the only rational commend I could find.

@ghostwalk510

6 ай бұрын

Difference was, that ww2 was a real war. Two armies fighting each other.. And Germany was not going to surrender. Now it's a country bombing innocent people to oblivion that have nothing to do with it and are not even fighting or armed. How narrow minded must one be, to not unverstand the Difference?

@ghostwalk510

6 ай бұрын

To clarify Germany nazi Regime got votes by a large majority. And even at the end of the war, the broad population was for the war and still behind the nazi Regime. In Gaza, there has not been voting, because Israel does not allow them this right. The last vote was from 2006. Hamas did Win. But not with nearly the same approval rate the nazis in Germany had. Nowadays it is less than 1/3 of the men who approve, according to All news report. So from 100% Over 50% are children and therefore can't vote nor Support hamas. Then from the less than 50% there is half of them Women. Who also don't vote nor fighting for Hamas. So 1/3 of the 25% of men Support or vote for hamas. This then equates to about 8% of the Population there actually supporting Hamas. 92% do not have any thing to do with it. This is the difference. So in Gaza capital punishment is being used. This is by international law forbidden. So it is a FACT that Israel is commiting war crimes.

@Kiarinadia

4 ай бұрын

And they were not asked first to move out the place by flyers or sms with maps where to head to. And all those roquets send from Gaza since 2007 for the "who's first" thing ?

@ghostwalk510

4 ай бұрын

@@Kiarinadia if you need to go back 70 years to find your morals, then humanity is lost. Especially interesting because if you go so far in time, It was also absolutely normal to be Antisemitic. Now, should we really go that far back in time to Discuss current issue?

There is someone who is harmas sympathiser within BBC

@travelswithminky246

7 ай бұрын

study the history first

"Is anyone alive" think you saying it to your family

The consequences of supporting Hamasists terrorists 😵

7 october was idf! don't forget.

Thank you're local Palestinian government

I ussualy never comment, but this video just boke me. we are all complicit, especially in the west. ive lost all faith in this inhumane crap of what we call the human race.

I can’t believe I was with Israel

@rafster675

6 ай бұрын

Israel isn't trying to kill civilians, Hamas is. Why wouldn't you be with Israel? The video you are seeing is war, israel told Palestinians to go south. All this that you are seeing is north.

I hate what do the Israel now!

I saw a teacher in this vdo .. I want to ask this Palestine teacher what do u teach your children ..y do u need to teach these children who either join Hamas or come out in full support of Hamas .. its shocking u guys too don’t deserve to live if u think people of other religion don’t have the right to live.. and Hamas is the reason y allah has abandoned u all Palestine.. love and support to Israel from India 🇮🇱🇮🇳🇮🇱🇮🇳🇮🇱

@md_saquib04

7 ай бұрын

A sick mindset was spotted.

@travelswithminky246

7 ай бұрын

study the history and you will know.

@aashishpradhan6355

7 ай бұрын

@@travelswithminky246 I don’t have time to study .. pay me money then will study your useless history.. my question is was simply and one thing if allah was with u all he would hav saved ur all asses in afganastan Syria Palestine etc so think . My advice to u convert to some religion that will motivate u to earn money enjoy life eat pork and drink beer .. the dialogue that is saving u Muslims are ..all Muslims are not terrorists and that is a myth

Посіявший вітер, пожне бурю

BBc is best known for doing propoganda.

@BohoBeads

7 ай бұрын

So is Israel. Really cringy propaganda tho, since 7 Oct

@travelswithminky246

7 ай бұрын

study history first

My heart breaks with sorrow for these people, we pray for Palestine

No internet, then how come these videos are being made? All bollocks and Hamas propaganda if you ask me.

너네가 자초한 일이다 하마스를 탓해라

🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

🙈🙉🙊🇺🇸

They had decades to not be 'cut off from the world', far from it....autonomous they could have with a bit of imagination made it another mediterranean paradise like the famous coastal resorts of Egypt, created jobs, a functioning economy, shipping lines etc..... they didn't, they built tunnels instead.

Israel all of them member of hamas😂

I’m sorry Palestine this would never happen under trumps watch

@EmmaDee

6 ай бұрын

BULLSHIT

🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

Shame on the international community for letting this happen!

I also feel for the Jewish people who are not in support of Israel’s retaliation. Somehow we live in a world governed by a minority of right wing, racist, sociopaths.

Israel diaries

“A non religious commoner could end this war and the suffering of all it’s beautiful victims, in one small move of his eyebrow…” - ibarker👁🫴🏼👽🇺🇸2032

Why are you suply the terrorism Hamas؟

😅

Did BBC ask them if they condemn Hamas?

@user-cy9yn8iz5f

6 ай бұрын

The stupid question that doesn't solve anything

@jamesfox2857

4 ай бұрын

@@user-cy9yn8iz5f EXACTLY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! = But whats More disturbing is Their Channel = they have Posted support FOR Palestine But TALK LIKE A ZIONIST !!!!

@Kiarinadia

4 ай бұрын

@@user-cy9yn8iz5f the stupid questioning that means you dont get it. You should start learning history of the past 2 centuries.

@RedLeb54

3 ай бұрын

@@Kiarinadiawell said. To the people of Gaza you reap what you sow. Or … Karma