"it's not about processing power anymore, CPU's are so powerful these days" _Cries in Acustica_

Regarding the Overloud sounding aggressive there is a trick to reducing the distortion. Turn the two Output knobs at the bottom to the lowest setting (fully counter clockwise) and then use the single Output knob at the bottom right for your output level. That knob is post the emulation so your signal should sound much cleaner. This relates to distortion and not aliasing. I have the Overloud and love it. When I first got it years ago I was floored by the distortion until I learned the trick I just shared.

@LeonardoLima-nk4fv

9 ай бұрын

Absolutly! Came to coment this, also there is the HARM knob to adjust

This was actually one of the first UAD plugins I bought after I got my UAD Apollo interface five years ago, it just adds magic to vocals and acoustic instruments that I can't get any other way

@thestreetdisciple3955

Жыл бұрын

i cant stop using this

UAD one has a bit more clarity and lighter sheen, which is what it was designed to do, be a mastering compressor before it hit the lathe, for lat vert work on the stylus needle. The perfect mastering comp for that application.

Having owned and used several of these units, the UAD vision really does it for me!

To your comment about the UA interface being messy: if you load it as a VST in a DAW, there will be an option in the upper right hand corner labeled "View". If you switch the view from Editor to Controls, you will get a maximally optimized interface with none of the visual hardware replication... just numbers and sliders that can be adjusted for each of the plugin's parameters. Sometimes, I find that useful. A lot of UA plugins are built that way.

This review is golden! I have both UAD version and Overloud but always use the UAD. Works on everything!

technically, the audible level depends on how loud you're listening... 0 dB SPL is the threshold for human hearing. But you could also make the case that something is inaudible when it goes lower than the noise floor of your capturing medium (for example the tape noise, or below -96 dBFS at 16 bit etc etc). In the radio/RF world you'd also have something called Minimal Discernible Signal (MDS), which would be x dBs above noise floor... You also have a masking effect of course, so that would also bring the audibility threshold of some noise/aliasing up a couple decibels... But then you add speaker systems and level etc. So in some cases a signal could be inaudible at -40 dBFS, and in some cases you can still hear -120 dBFS. I'd say a safe bet would be that if a signal is below -120 dBFS (in the final master!) you won't hear it. If you introduce noise at -120 but then compress the signal to smithereens it won't stay that low of course. This is not academically sound, just a rule of thumb for myself. If you're going to CD, -96 would probably be the threshold, or dither level maybe, but sounds louder than that can in a lot of cases be considered inaudible

Thank you as usual for the excellent reviews and content! :) (from Québec/Canada)!

I have and love the UAD. They make some of my favorite plugins. People can complain that they’re expensive or need more frequent updating and all need to be native faster etc. etc. but regardless of all those things, they’re just excellent.

@Art_Of_Sound

Жыл бұрын

I still feel ripped by UAD...I bought a bunch of UAD1 cards originally and luckily 1 was pcie...in 2005...Im still just using that card and basically run the fairchild, 1176 occasionally (still the orig versions going using JBridge). WARNING! In this day and age...DO NOT buy any card based plugs...its just a dongle and once GPUs finally get used, it will be a moot point. Over time, your mix strategy (hopefully matures) and now I use distinct 'fix' as the first part of the chain (pretty much sonible seq and comp)...by this stage the sound stands alone and is devoid of the smear that all these emus impart. THEN for a push/pull for staging and colour, these are just the option...what Im saying is learn to just paint first and then apply the 'effect'...biggest mistake was not doing this up front. Get time at a proper studio, learn and understand why, eg 70s albums still smash the dynamic space and feel of today BUT we now have the bottom end of today which is missing in the old recordings...ie tape and compression just mash it. just my2c but the UAD Fair is the best to my ears on the basis of just a good compressor...but use it judiciously...when Wytse started dialing in right in...just destroyed the space...on my monitors anyway :-) Final point is...can you hear the diff in a mix...especially a dense one? Um for the sake of all the investment...NO. Just get a decent one as its your ears and talent that will make it good just using your stock plugs...seriously.

I believe this is the best video and comparison ever! Also, thanks for revealing what Overloud does with their plugins. I was also looking for a great Fairchild. Thanks!

@alexandereditsvideo

Жыл бұрын

And yet I've seen other reviews on KZread saying they have a pretty great LA2A emulation. All the same, Universal Audio seems to be the gold standard.

I am always amazed that you actually hear all those tiny differences. I don't but I do think those little differences in sound can get lost in the youtube audio compression, I could also be deaf^^

@kutnersuicide

Жыл бұрын

Might be your monitoring too.

A very important (to me) feature that the T-Racks 670 has is the "lat vert" mid-side setting. It was actually the compressor that introduced me to the wonders that mid-side compression can work on a stereo bus

When I was an assistant engineer at a recording studio we would hire a Fairchild every now and again. When I did the recall sheets I would have to write down the serial number of the unit so we would have the same unit for the recall :) (We always hired the same unit. It always felt special. It weighs a lot. 2 man lift.

Great video. I have 16 DSPs from UAD, an Apollo Quad silverface, an Octo satellite and a quad card. I use a LOT of their plugins, but the Fairchild is definitely a go to.

@teddym2808

3 ай бұрын

Do you want to add DSP? I have 2 aud satellites and 2 octo and need to downsize.

There is one problem that does occur when you oversample, which is that you need perform a process that includes a filter, ie, you're going to introduce some kind of delay. If you use an IIR filter which almost all analog filters utilize, it's going to cause a delay, although slight, in the upper frequencies. If you use FIR, it delays the entire signal. Either method also introduces ringing artifacts, which will shape how your compressor reacts to the audio.

Some time ago we compared almost all Fairchild plugins with a drum loop except Slate and Universal Audio as we couldn't get access to them and clearly "Acustica Audio Ultramarine" was the closest to the original hardware (we compare matching the sound as much as possible, since the same parameters in each company almost always sound different) and over compressing to clearly notice the differences. It was impressive to hear how different the plugins sounded from each other (it's really noticeable on drums!)

@sub-jec-tiv

9 ай бұрын

Ultramarine is fantastic. I use it often. Between Ultramarine and UA, you have everything you need. I do have Overloud and like it, but after i got Ultramarine I don’t reach for it much.

You seem so fascinated by the precision of a Fairchild product. You should dig a bit in their history. That were some of the best engineers of our time.

@paulbrymer

Жыл бұрын

that’s fair

@saardean4481

2 ай бұрын

he is not a fair child i guess

@ilyouslug

Ай бұрын

where can i find a video on this?

The klanghelm mjuc is my favorite Fairchild and other mu plugin. Great as always 🤘

@hajianekena6909

Жыл бұрын

oh, mk1 or mk2 or mk3 is the Fairchild version of the mjuc?

@antcall6779

Жыл бұрын

@@hajianekena6909 the first one it's the blue one,2nd is sta lvl that's grey, and the green is a altec if I remember right. The Fairchild is definitely the first one though. It's getting some age on it but it's still a go too for alot of top mixers. I got it from watching Marc Daniel nelson and it's got some magic to it. The Fairchild especially in limit mode with a CPL db of comp adds mojo and depth that no other plugin IV used. Great parallel on drums and is unbelievable on bass and vocals in the other models.for 25 euros it's a must have! The Jr is free I think and it's just the Fairchild but I don't know if it's different than the paid version. Hope this helps 🤘

@VinceWhitacre

Жыл бұрын

The free version is one of the best vst comps I've ever used (another freebie, the Analog Obsession 1776 is another top choice). Incredibly simple interface, kind of a cross between a Fairchild and an Altec - basically what I think they were going for in the free version (they said themselves it's "between version 1 and 2" of the paid) was sort of a middle ground "generic variable mu compressor" but whatever it is they nailed it. I don't have a real Fairchild or Altec to compare it against, as I am but a poor boy, but I have heard a whole lot of records, and I know what compression sounds I like. And I definitely like the MJUCJr. When I get my new computer set up I need to spring for the paid version - I have all their free plugins, and they're all terrific - Klanghelm deserves some of my money.

@antcall6779

Жыл бұрын

@@VinceWhitacre I wish they would make a new version with 3 different vca's ! It's crazy they made one of the greatest plugins in history and nothing new in years 😢

@hajianekena6909

Жыл бұрын

@@antcall6779 thank you 🤙

I'm listening on a very good Class-A valve system and the UAD plugin still has some distortion which maybe the original Fairchild has(?) but it is deep and lush and open, breathy and gorgeous whereas the others where agressive and flat - suddenly my system sounded like it was transistors, ugh! Thanks for the demo, I will have to get this now! LOL

UAD really is good at that stuff - the 670 I just slap it on and do 1-3 GR and on some mixes it's just pure magic.

The UAD Fairchild is by far my favorite

Hey! So my prof at music university was a real audiophile. He never used emulations of analog gear (apart from UAD!). I showed him a lot of plugins from other developers and we often talked about it. Back then I used oversampling whenever it was available. And when we tested plugins with oversampling on transient heavy stuff, most of the time it smeared the transients. So I've become quite cautious of the tradeoffs of all these workarounds. Btw my Prof used a lot of (but not exclusively) analog gear in his studio.

Great Video!!!!! One thing with the Overloud you can control & monitor the distortion with may have helped clean it up a bit.

I've used original Fairchilds and they all sound a little different - depending on age, how well they have been serviced and what has been "updated" over the years. To my ears the UAD and Acustica plugins are good enough to work with ;-)

@Jazzguitar00

Жыл бұрын

Acustica is quickly turning into my favorite company! The plugins all sound amazing (and analog, no matter how much people refuse to acknowledge it!)

@bikesandbeats4693

Жыл бұрын

@@Jazzguitar00 Acustica plugins sound amazing but I have nothing but stability issues when I use mine. So I don’t use them anymore. It sucks because I paid for them.

@RealHomeRecording

Жыл бұрын

When the Ultramarine gets the Hyper update it's going to be quite something!

@AirArtStudiosOfficial

Жыл бұрын

@@bikesandbeats4693 I have the same experience, can only use them for bouncing files. Too many clicks and pops that wreck the speaker

@kimseniorb

5 ай бұрын

@@RealHomeRecording never going to happen, go buy our new fairchild plugin is their awful business philosophy

Yeah, best ignore that company No point making waves 😉❤

@qryph

Жыл бұрын

Especially now .. RIP waves

@flame2fame_music

Жыл бұрын

It's funny, when you say like this! 😅

Do more videos on Scientific testing and aliasing, it's super interesting to know that things!

I'm disappointed we couldn't get this next to the Acustica plugin; they're stuff has impressed me a lot lately and I was thinking about getting it. The UAD Fairchild definitely sounded great though.

I have a Fairchild 670 plugin emulations the Waves PuigChild , the IK Multimedia version, the Tone Empire version and Acustica Audio version and the Klangheim MJUC version

My music college (back in the late 90s) had a Fairchild Limiter, among other great equipment,.. I think we students were spoilt. Edit: Really good comparison video. 😃

Interesting comparison! Been using the Overloud one from time to time and really liking it precisely for it's character and aggressive tendencies. It's been modelled after a tube unit, after all, they sort of almost supposed to do that. And btw messing with the «HARM» knob helps to clean it up a bit. And yeah, OS implementation in their plugins is kinda bad and unintuitive. The UAD one is pretty cool tho, really smoooooooov.

@johnisrael5183

Жыл бұрын

I think overloud is the best one as well.....might not be a popular of a plugin...but UAD faichild lacks the Depth or Overloud and Acustica Audio

@sub-jec-tiv

Жыл бұрын

Overloud one is super underrated. I agree

Regarding the GEM 670: the D.C Threshold setting changes the knee behavior of the unit from soft to hard. The UAD has this feature too, and the default settings most likely are very different. The GEM also features a HARM setting to be adjusted, what regulates the non linear processing, resulting in different harmonics. UAD does not have that. So one might have want to adjust those parameters and them compare... Greetings to Holland!

Greeeeaaat video. Thanks so much!!

The Antelope Fairchild plugin is pretty damn good, definitely one to compare with.

I started boycott waves long time ago. 5-6 years. Because I bought plugin from them and year later they said to continue using it I need to pay again. And claimed I didn’t buy plugin (for full price) only rented it (for full price)…

@BrofUJu

Жыл бұрын

How it normally works is you pay for updates, which sucks, but they typically still work fine even without an update

@psybursonic

Жыл бұрын

@@BrofUJu not if you’re on Mac and you ever update your operating system. Then they just don’t work. I uninstalled all my waves plug-ins because I got sick of forced updates. It’s basically scamming people into a subscription.

@BrofUJu

Жыл бұрын

@@psybursonic ah yeah I'm windows and never thought of that. That is brutal

@psybursonic

Жыл бұрын

@@BrofUJu yeah I heard windows folks don’t have as many issues. But I don’t miss waves at all. So many good plug-ins out there 🙂

@weeschwee

Жыл бұрын

I avoid waves because of their update plan (even though I'm on windows), only one license (I mix on a desktop and record on a laptop), and lack of modern features like oversampling.

Perfect Timing! IKMs VC-670 is currently free for a limited time. Grab it as long as u can and get rid of the noise 😂

@Mansardian

Жыл бұрын

THANKS!!! For the readers here: you have to participate in a survey. Register a customer account, if you haven't done that yet. When you finished the survey you get the license in your account.

@sobasage1958

Жыл бұрын

Wait, seriously? Gotta nab it.

@deadnoises

Жыл бұрын

@@Mansardian im having trouble getting into the survey. I click it and i get into the support section of the website instead. Any ideas? lol

@vecchiuz2143

Жыл бұрын

​@@deadnoises same

@Linguae_Music

Жыл бұрын

@@deadnoises don't worry. It will make like an egg very soon.

10:34 for some weird reson only time constant and threshold controls are being linked in the IK plugin when set to "link" but not the input gain...

To answer your question about when something is audible or not is a good one. I’ve seen a lot of people online say “two plugins null down to -90dB. I can’t hear a -90dB signal so I can’t hear a difference” That just isn’t my experience. Having said that I prefer to not use oversampling when running at 96kHz and wish UAD gave you the option to turn it off. Steep, linear phase low pass filters color the sound and in my opinion can be more destructive than aliasing in a lot of cases. Some plugins use shallower low pass filters for oversampling at higher sample rates and these sound better to my ears.

thanks as always

I find the uad plugins made by uad tend to be very meticulously modeled in a very musical way, maybe its because UA makes hardware of some of the gear they model so they can reference how gear is supposed to work more often.

The fairchild has a vibe. I use it on almost all of my mixes w some exceptions.

I love that your videos are of the best audio quality Ive heard, like ill be watching a professional ass video about audio and the voiceover quality is really trassh, but YOU got that beautiful tone and highend on that lewitt mic? (whatever mic) anyways in short, shoutout to you for not dropping standard lol

I wish the Puigchild was compared in this video too. Searching around online people seem to think the UAD and Waves Fairchild stack up pretty much the same. I did however pick up the UAD in the sale as ive wanted it for a while. Intresting to see the aliasing analyser too.

@natedavid3873

Жыл бұрын

the “company” that he was saying he wouldn’t use cuz they will take legal action if you criticize their products was Waves

Oh, I can answer that :) aliasing is audible when the frequency going into the distortion is high enough to bounce off the sampling rate. So it only happens when you have high frequencies, and low sampling rates, and there are different ways to suppress it. My Console7 which you use, resists aliasing when run at a higher sample rate such as 96k (Console8Lite will resist aliasing even more), and people usually use oversampling which is like resampling everything twice for every plugin you use :) When there IS aliasing, from a sound OR harmonic high enough to reflect off the sample rate and come back down again (sounds like 'birdies'), it will be at the loudness of whatever that distortion harmonic would have been, but it can be at ANY frequency including very audible frequencies like in the midrange, where almost anything is audible :)

What Reaper means is that oversampling can introduce noise at the noise floor from the down-sampling dithering.

The T-RackS Vintage Tube Compressor/Limiter Model 670, they give it away at this moment when answering a survey

Hey wytse, if you get a chance try out the antelope audio ones. You’ll need to borrow one of their interfaces with the dsp. I love the antelope one. Would be amazing to have a shootout!

Please do more shootouts! SSL Comp, LA-2a, 1176, API 2500, Neve 33609...

Hey can you do a video on the new plug-in alliance tape face plug-in I know how you and all of us like tape saturation and it’s interface seems like something you’d enjoy, very functional.

Thank you. I'm a self-taught recording engineer. I work only on my own original music and do basic mixes. I'm retired and considering acquiring a bunch of recording studios all over the world and creating the first truly international audio recording corporation. I'm a retired investment banker and have played and recorded music professionally all my adult life as well. So I have a pretty unique blend of businessperson and music-artist background. This video opened my eyes to lots of technical questions I never before thought about. As I learn more I consider also founding a great audio engineering university! Why not?

@rendilly

7 ай бұрын

What locations are you looking for in the us?

I compared Tone Empire`s Firechild with both from UAD and Firechild wins. But it`s a matter of taste. [Edit:] @Wytse: In your video for Firechild by Tone Empire, you had raised issues that I and many in the comments couldn't relate to. It would have been fair to give this great plugin a second chance in your new video. Especially since you had mentioned this possibility yourself in the first video. But with so much content you create, it's logical that something always falls under the table. I just wanted to point that out. You're doing a great job...keep it up!

Great presentation as always! It would be awesome to compare it with Focusrite's Liquid Mix32 (US VINTAGE TUBE 1) to see the results!

No question. UAD. It is the most transparent. I use the Slate Digital version on my mix bus with good results. But this demo was pretty impressive

For IK Multimedia plugin's you can operate the demo without "hiss" being inserted by running the Custom Shop. Once in the demo period and IK Custom Shop App open then no hiss.

@TheeRocker

Жыл бұрын

NO kiddin'... Great to know lol. THis should be pinned in my o'pin'ion lol.. (attempted pun lol)

I still really like the Overloud version specifically because I like its distorted quality. It's my go-to bass compressor, and when you're putting something on bass, anti-aliasing is really not that important.

My favorite is Overtone FC70. It's highly slept on. Not the most 3D looking but the sound justifies the rest.

@DJAMAYADOTCOM

Жыл бұрын

lowkey great plugin +1

@taviqmasteringonline2754

Жыл бұрын

🤣

All UAD plugins imo really shines on the low end where I feel like other companies kinda drop the ball. You get almost the same tightness and definition that you would in the hardware. Obviously you can get the exact same results from the low end that you get from hardware. But UAD comes damn close.

The UAD does sound VERY nice!......I hadn't heard that they were now offering they're stuff as native. A while back you tested the Tone Empire Firechild, and did not have a good experience with it. I've got it and have struggled to get a sound I really like. I have no experience with and actual Fairchild, other than twiddling the knobs on the one at Capitol 😏. I think it would be revealing to compare the Firechild with the UAD.

Great video. I don't normally subscribe but I did here!

Fantastic work Wytse, UAD is definitely proving the quality of their stuff. Expensive, but right what you're searching for in a plugin. My favorite Mu is the Magic Death Eye Stereo version. I won't probably never buy a hardware Mu considering how good it sounds. Weight, transparency, smoothness, punch.. A dream

What a gorgeous song; "You Took My Breath Away" by Magnus Ludvigsson.

The IK Multimedia 670 compressor is free with a survey in their site so I guess its no bad deal

@jaffasplaffa1

Жыл бұрын

I also got their Distressor plugin like that. Just filled out the survey and got the 670 for free too, thank you for the tip ;) But the install process is a pain and I was forced to install a ton of plugins I didn't have licenses for, when I tried to install the Comprexxor plugin. So now I have 2 plugins I am not using from Ik Multimedia, haha :) When they get their installers updated, so you only have to install the plugins that you have, I will probably try it out.

@neilslade

Жыл бұрын

CAN'T FIND A FREE VERSION WITH SURVEY

@arkarmoethouk2445

Жыл бұрын

Just got it earlier today.

@sobasage1958

Жыл бұрын

@@neilslade Me neither. Just registered a new account just to get it...

Pulsar audio Mu is great too, even if it's not really a "fairchild" emulation, but vari-mu comp anyway !

@alexbreyer6921

Жыл бұрын

Yes, but the Manley Vari Mu is very different from a Fairchild. Even cleaner!

@TransistorLSD

Жыл бұрын

​@@alexbreyer6921 it's slightly slower on the attack and ratio is gentler

@hahdanghongha7810

Ай бұрын

very different sound, but the Pulsar creates a creampy chocolate sound saturation

"aliasing below audibility" makes sense only when it is a last thing in the chain. If you put an eq or compressor after the plugin the inaudible may easily become audible :) And with multiband processor like Gulfoss it may become super-audible :D

@ProjectHMF

Жыл бұрын

Imagine what happens with OTT lmao

The UAD really shines in this comparison.

Got it for 50 and they just started a nice sale through the end of the month

I don't know if somebody said it already but for the IK multimedia you actually unlinked left and right, the knob should be on "link"

Would be great if we could get an honest comparison between UAD, Acustica and Overloud - maybe even the Herchild? I love Acustica's Ultramarine but I've never had the pleasure to experience the hardware.

If you're online with their Custom Shop opened you'll hear no noise!

I personally think the UAD is probably the most faithful (and I've used many real Fairchilds, and used to own a 670). But the runner up for me, and sometimes the better choice in a session, I'm sorry to say, is the Waves Puigchild.

@SmokeM2D6

Жыл бұрын

Puigchild is the goat for me too

@danepaulstewart8464

7 ай бұрын

Jack Joseph Puig is a REAL stickler for correct reproduction. Probably because he has spent SO MANY thousands of hours of his life IN studios using this hardware in very critical circumstances. He has admitted to making WAVES jump through a lot of hoops to get the Fairchild and the Pultec plug-ins accurate. However, I heard from someone I know at the company that in reality, he was EXTREMELY harsh in his judgement and would deny the use of his name entirely until it met the standard he was holding them to. He had little to gain from letting companies slap his name on products for simple licensing fee. He has what they call “fuck you money” when it comes to something like this, so there’s little in it for him unless the product really meets his standards. This is probably why I also find his Puigtec Waves emulations of the EQs to be the most accurate recreations of Pultecs in the digital realm. I worked many hundreds of hours in the 80’s and 90’s hands-on with the 670, and even FAR more with the Pultecs, and I can advise, with confidence, anyone who is interested, that they can use these plugins with a completely reasonable amount of confidence that they are getting a really really close representation with them. 😎👍👍

I actually like the IK Multimedia one - it does have a link on teh left - it's a little weird.

I have the Klanghelm, T-Racks and Waves Puigchild - I often use the Waves, mostly on bass, it's pretty cool - waiting to see about a Softube version? TLA-100A I think - also the T-Racks Vari-Mu could be good

@alexbreyer6921

Жыл бұрын

Summit TLA-100A is nice, however it's an optical tube compressor, not a variable Mu like the Fairchild. Ultimately it only matters if you like the results, but if you are trying to compare Fairchild clone plugins, that isn't one.

@TheGurner1

Жыл бұрын

@@alexbreyer6921 Ah, OK

Waves maybe? Pity about the Ultramarine crashes. Very curious about it in a test of it.

@owlmuso

Жыл бұрын

absolutey waves

@matrixate

Жыл бұрын

Yea. It's them.

@TheeRocker

Жыл бұрын

@Max Milian JUst people that they believe slams them lol... I like Waves have most all... We'll soon be to a point where there will be enough free plugins that are awesome lol. Just a guess...

The TrackS 'Link' functionality is on the right? So you have three options: Left Right (Left) Link (Middle) Lat Vert (Right) Doesn't make the annoying sound go away, but I'm guessing that's it. :)

On the IK Multimedia 670 the link works on the Threshold knobs. I am not sure it was meant for the input gain.

I love the UAD FC a lot. I had the AA one but was hard to set up properly. I really dislike subscription models but only for UAD I made an exception cause their plugins are absolutely awesome. First I was a big AA fan but I moved over to UAD :)

@SkyAvila983

Жыл бұрын

You dont need to use subsription on this plug-in, its native now...just buy it.

Would've been nice to see Analogue Obsession's Varimoon here too. And of course, it's free

hey for the IK multi. you have to go in the app and actually start the demo and you have to keep the custom shop app open too, otherwise it just spits out noise like that. Also im gonna guess Waves ha! so lame they do that.

I love my UA Fairchild.

Great review & comparison, personally I really like the Tone Empire one but didn't try UAD yet. I wonder if TE was the company threatening legal action, i hope not.

@Mansardian

Жыл бұрын

Come on, Tone Empire is far from being a big company😁. He is talking about Waves.

I have the uad Fairchild and the waves Puigchild. There's no comparison side-by-side as far as I'm concerned. I didn't use the Waves one again after getting under the hood of the UAD version.

Top vergelijk. Thanks Wytze. Je weet dat UAD in alle pluginns een backside heeft met alleen sliders en cijfer waardes? Echt handig en zonder vieze plakbandjes en 'uitgehonede' schroeven. Ik geloof rechtboven button in de plugin.

Could it be every Fairchild has it's own character , like a guitar is kind of unique? So having different ones to build the digital clone ?

@TransistorLSD

Жыл бұрын

Tolerances, yes.

@alexandereditsvideo

Жыл бұрын

Yes, that was my first thought while watching Wytse's review, that the different plugin makers are all modeling different unique original hardware units and doing their best to recreate their characteristics in plugin form, hence the massive variation between all the different plugins.

What you link with the "link" control on the IK-Multimedia one is the threshold. There is no option to link the inputs. The boost it does by default on the output-knob is something I took as a hint: Dial in the threshold so that you get that amount of gain reduction - usually (as in: 2 dB of GR is what we intended as the default). There are very different output-values in the presets ranging from 3,5 - 8,5 dBs of gain on the output. I've never used a real fairchild, but the VC-670 from IKM sounds good to me and won many "shootouts" against some of the most expensive and revered plugin-compressors that I own. I agree that the noise in the demo is very unhinging, however there is the option to test it noise-free for (I think 2 weeks) some time, via their "Custom Shop". The UAD version sounded cleaner to me in this comparison, wether that's better will be very audio-scource dependant. I would have preferred that you add pop and rock-examples. We're also comparing a brandnew-plugin (UAD) to older (Overloud) and very old ones (IKM). It honestly would be a shame, if the new plugin didn't outperform the older ones on technical stuff like aliasing. Although in a perfect world they'd all fix these issues in their old plugins (but I don't know how easy it is to "patch" that). I must admit that I didn't notice audible aliasing on the IKM on single scources. I'd be surprised if anyone did without pushing it in an unreasonable manner.

@Tychomusic

Жыл бұрын

While the UA native Fairchild is “new”, it is based on the dsp version which was released in 2013 (iirc). I have used the uad dsp stuff for a long time and to my ear all of the native versions sound and behave exactly the same as their dsp counterparts. I am betting they’re 1:1 ports. You can even copy/paste settings from the dsp version to the native ones.

@alexbreyer6921

Жыл бұрын

UAD's current Fairchild plugin has been around around since 2013, This is just now available in native format. Their original mark I version was from around 2004. So it's not necessarily new code.

@akagerhard

Жыл бұрын

@@Tychomusic To my knowledge both IK and UAD had fairchild emulations for a long time. Going back to at least 2009. Hopefully we can agree, that there is a difference that comes with (re)releasing _and selling_ a plugin today in comparison to providing cost-free patches. There is more budget for polishing the plugin before "rerelease". You wouldn't just release an old plugin, without fixing some of the issues, right?

Good video! Hear, hear, IK and Overloud, god damnit!

Big fan of the new intro. Not sure if you've talked about it, and I know you're a Cockos-Head at the moment, but I'd love to hear your thoughts on Apple buying the head UA engineer. I use Logic so I'm excited, but I'd like to hear your position.

TBH I have used the Fairchild plugins the UAD one and it sounds good on vocals but I seem to always go back to 2A for a certain sound. just got the tr5 670 hopefully that works better

@J77199

Жыл бұрын

Why the 2a is awesome ?

@abash4683

Жыл бұрын

@@J77199 awesome is an understatement very good on vocals

hello, the unnamed company is...waves i think :) i have the puigchild and i dont like it, i was looking today for a fairchild/although (i already have kazrog true dynamics for vari mu style) i understand your point of view about oversampling set as default...but sometimes latency (or cpu in realtime) can be a problem...does the uad fairchild has os/latency by default? regards

I just used the real thing on a mix thanks to mix:analog and OMG. WOW. My life has been changed forever.

You missed the D.C Threshold Controls. Thanks for the video! I never do this kind of thing of commenting in videos but I wanted to point out some stuff that people regularly miss in this lines of unity so called "670" because it may help everyone to use the unities. You have the Di Maria one, the original one and many others, so obviously they will have a different sound, which is great for the industry! There is a control called D.C threshold set to different settings on every plugin in every comparison you did. I'm sorry, but, with this setting set to different positions, the detector circuit should behave very differently, likewise the way the compressors behaved in the video. So you are using, basically slightly different threshold points as well as VERY different knees behaviors in every comparison, what makes the comparisons, in my opinion completely useless, since every characteristics in a "670" compressor will change its compression, harmonic distortion and so fourth. Mainly when they are emulating the original unity that struggles to have enough from its power supply when the tubes are to much requested, (the ones that compress as well as the ones from the amplifier stages) so it changes the frequency response and every behavior when you request more from them. For example, when you compared the Overloud unity with UAD one, the Overloud is using "harder knee" behavior and a slightly higher point of threshold, meaning that it will have a "harder compression feeling", so it will hold a little less the signal, but will be more towards to the "limiting compression" type than the soft knee one, therefore more aggressive, and more perceivable compression. Besides the calibration regards from the plugins, that's why you also felt the gain difference as well. I know you hate the "scrolls controls" on the plugins but this one changes everything. Thanks for the video! Best regards!

Transparent asf

Are Universal Audio plug-ins compatible with VST3?... Tanks a lot.

Really helpful shootout and discussion. You were a bit unfair to Overloud at the end, though, in my opinion. You say that processing is not an issue, but that's just not true. Plugin developers *of course* consider processing power when they develop and optimize their algorithms. Oversampling requires significantly more processing; a developer makes up for that by altering their algorithm (almost inevitably, by simplifying it in some way) when it is oversampling. That is, there is a basic "faithful" algorithm that tries to do what the physical device does to a continuous waveform. Once you discretize the waveform, that algorithm produces aliasing. You can handle that in various ways, one of which is by oversampling, which directly multiplies the processing power required. So keep the processing burden under control, you do less math per sample than if you were not oversampling. What Overloud's dialog box is saying is that they are giving the user a choice here: use the more faithful algorithm (which is in operation with the box unchecked) which will produce aliasing that (they claim) is imperceptible in many situations, or turn on oversampling and use the more computationally optimized but slightly less faithful algorithm (with the box checked). They leave it unchecked by default so that the most faithful algorithm is being used by default. Where you're right is that they really should have provided guidance for when the artifacts could become audible-something about how the settings and the loudness and dynamic range impact perceptibility. -Tom

When demoing IK MM you must leave their Custom Shop open in the background and remain connected to the internet, then you will not get hiss.

Good one... ;)

Wow new intro tune!

Are there any VST’s with a “modern” GUI that emulate old school hardware?

I have the ik multimedia, but i noticed it doesn't have a frequency sidechain which is kind of a deal breaker for my intended usages

damn, i really would have loved to see the acustica emulation in this test

@jansonrawlings8169

Жыл бұрын

Acustica eqs are killer, but I’ve never been impressed by their compression or saturation

@Whiteseastudio

Жыл бұрын

Me too

I would still like to have seen what Slates flavor was compared to those but good job