Is It Classical Education If It Doesn't Have Latin?

On this episode of the Homeschool Journal, Carrie sits down once again with Tanya Charlton to talk about Latin. We've received a lot of emails since we last talked with Tanya about Latin and whether or not it belongs in classical education. And Tanya is back to share her thoughts on why classical education is not truly classical without the study of Latin!
--[HJL: 113 | Tanya Charlton]--
About the Show
The Homeschool Journal is a multi-season show with host Carrie McGraw and her cohort of homeschooling veterans and first time homeschoolers as they open the book on their personal experiences. Join us as we unpack the joys and journeys of the classical homeschool family.
We at Memoria Press want to support new and veteran homeschoolers in educating their children with truth, goodness, and beauty. If you are struggling, please reach out to our helpful customer service representatives or Carrie McGraw, our homeschool liaison. We wish you the best in your homeschooling journey, and, remember, we are here to help!
Memoria Press Support:
memoriapress.com/support/?utm...
To join the Memoria Press family, subscribe now!
bit.ly/SubMemoriaPress
To view all the episodes of The Homeschool Journal, check out this playlist:
• The Homeschool Journal...
Please leave us feedback about what you think of The Homeschool Journal in the comments below. We'd love to get to know you better!

Пікірлер: 13

  • @jennifermerritt1985
    @jennifermerritt1985 Жыл бұрын

    Great show! My 5 and 7 year old are LOVING Latin! It’s the first and primary subject of our homeschool day.

  • @racheld.8364
    @racheld.83642 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for this podcast. I took 5 years of Latin (8th-12th grades) in my PUBLIC high school. We translated portions of the Aeneid in my 4th and 5th years. I remember wanting to take Spanish and my parents wouldn't let me. I never understood why my dad always said that I had been given a gift. I went on to teach Latin for 7 years because I couldn't find another job. Now, as I am educating my own kids, I need the reminder of why Latin is important for their education. Thank you for the book recommendation.

  • @memoriapress

    @memoriapress

    2 жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much for sharing this experience with us. We are just as encouraged by stories of committed classical homeschoolers!

  • @cholos17
    @cholos172 жыл бұрын

    I think this is great and I have a few criticisms regarding Classical Education. One is that the curriculums do not give enough credit to Ancient Egypt which is far older than Greece. This leads to assumptions that are not accurate. There is plenty of evidence that Greece was influenced by Egypt. Another issue is that the curriculum does not always include a through history of the Americas which also rich, original, and relative. That being said nothing beats a solid education.

  • @Arkansas_Angel
    @Arkansas_Angel2 жыл бұрын

    This was very inspirational! Thank you so much for sharing these insights and passing along Cheryl Lowe’s vision to us. This is our first year going “full in” with Memoria Press Classical curriculum in our homeschool. I’m studying Latina Christiana right along with my kids. So far, we’re really enjoying it! That being said, trying to explain to others why I’m teaching my kids Latin, is definitely challenging at times. This will give me motivation to carry on during the difficult times, and also help when explaining the vision for doing so. These podcasts are extremely educational to me in so many ways as I’m learning what true classical education is. Thank you for taking the time to make them. God bless!

  • @memoriapress

    @memoriapress

    2 жыл бұрын

    Angela thank you so much for sharing! It's great to meet new friends and new people jumping into classical education. Let us know if there's any other way we can help!

  • @alextremodelnorte1905
    @alextremodelnorte19053 ай бұрын

    Question: could it be classical if it has Greek instead of Latin?

  • @am-yd5cp
    @am-yd5cp2 жыл бұрын

    any recommended book for adult who wants to learn Latin?

  • @memoriapress

    @memoriapress

    2 жыл бұрын

    Hey there! First Form Latin is great for children and adults to learn at the same time. Memoria Press employees are actually gathering right now to learn Latin every week from First Form Latin, that's how good it is! check it out here -> www.memoriapress.com/curriculum/latin/first-form-latin-student-text-second-edition/

  • @thebad6246

    @thebad6246

    2 жыл бұрын

    the Lingua Latina Per Se Illustrata book series by Hans Ørberg is also a great way to start learning from what I've heard

  • @trajan5560

    @trajan5560

    3 ай бұрын

    I started out with Wheelock’s, but Moreland & Fleischer’s Latin: An Intensive Course and Lingua Latina Per Se Illustrata are completely comprehensive together.

  • @hyzenthlay713
    @hyzenthlay7132 ай бұрын

    Why is it so important to read those particular classical works in their original languages? Do the messages and themes not translate? If we are to structure 12 years of school around the goal of reading particular primary sources, the most important text to be read is the Bible. Shouldn't we learn/teach Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek? Scripture is the most important primary source, far more important than Plato or Homer.

  • @mada5326

    @mada5326

    2 ай бұрын

    It’s not classical without latin. Those other languages won’t teach you about modern English or other European languages, but okay if you don’t think that’s that important. You get to choose to not teach your children about Plato or Homer if you are eager to put them in a lower importance rate personally, but it’s not really up for debate the importance of classical texts and languages.

Келесі