“Who needs critical thinking skills when we can have a Large Language Model do the thinking for us?”

@st0n3p0ny

6 ай бұрын

Who needs critical thinking skills? Nobody according to California. They're graduating everybody with no minimum requirements, because the people who run California say it's racist to expect a non white person to have a functioning mind...

These are the people that stopped the kid who asked the teacher for homework

Yeah, screw teaching them anything, let them rely on AI for all of it. Then wonder why they are morons later.

@henrybartholomewdinglenut1178

Жыл бұрын

But then again most of the stuff in school isn’t hard. It’s just time consuming; such as essays for example; I can write a perfectly well essay at the age of 15 if I put my time into it, but why the living fuck do I need to do it 4 times a month every school year sense I hit 10? The only thing changing is the topics and such; like writing a essay on fucking Romeo and Juliet to writing about Harriet Tubman or some shit like that. School doesn’t teach shit it only just repeats and stuff. I understand you point but first we need to get to the level of a good education system before we can be saying what your saying. Edit: I edited this to match the ideal English grammar. As I was taught 5 fucking years ago

@jdubdoubleu

Жыл бұрын

Morons, later? Have you met Gen Z?!

@jasonv.5938

Жыл бұрын

@henrybartholomewdinglenut1178 I will agree that the system sucks. They should be teaching critical thinking but mostly go for rote memorization. The essays, though, are important because writing one requires you to think about the subject, process it, and find an approach to it. It's one of the few times they actually teach. That said, some of the subjects are absolutely stupid. No one needs to write an essay about Romeo and Juliet. Or any other novel or play. It should be reserved for subjects that require deep, personal thought.

@Solidfreeman01

Жыл бұрын

EXACTLY!!! You have to be a millionaire living outside of reality not having to do any shit at all, to be capable of denouncing school as childcare with status games. School is supposed to help people develop. But when you look at this BLOB shrunk together into his small chair you see, how develpment is nothing, that he understands

@claudianreyn4529

Жыл бұрын

What is an essay anyways? A bunch of shit copied from some books? The next generation will be smarter than us, that's the reality. Every prediction about AI Was wrong until now and this is one of it.

This is such a dishonest answer, and watching the student's face as he accepted this absurd reply is a painful thing to watch. This is the first time I have ever commented on a reel. This is how objectionable this reply is. Cheating = dishonesty. Passing off something as your own work is lying. To prepare a child for a world of AI, give assignments designed specifically for it. God bless you and forgive you for the harm you caused to that student's future.

@Anerder772

6 ай бұрын

I have used chat got for many assignments ever since it came out and I feel guilty I’m starting to stop because I want to really learn. Any advice l?

@oozly9114

5 ай бұрын

@@Anerder772 it depends on how you are using it

@oozly9114

5 ай бұрын

Very bad take that will age poorly and already has

It removes thought. And learning. It’s like getting you mum and dad to do your school work.

@claudianreyn4529

Жыл бұрын

Not true, actually by repeating a lot of tasks you learn a lot in the process. It depends how it is used and it depends on individual. Using a tool does not make you dumber, but smarter.

@Prometheus_Alt

Жыл бұрын

Using ChatGPT is similar in process to using a calculator. Sure you cannot work out that 97×103=9991 without a calculator, but does losing the ability to mentally calculate actually worsen your ability to learn other skills?

@The_Lute777

6 ай бұрын

The “learning” in school is just memorization

@khalidcabrero6204

4 ай бұрын

@@Prometheus_Alt Yes. Like a muscle, brains rot without exercise.

An absolutely horrible statement. Schools purpose is to help people grow. Not only teach them how to use the easiest way to a goal. This is why we learn how to add and subtract MANUALLY BEFORE we use the calculator. And it is GOOD! Because it teaches YOU something instead of using Chatgpt to do some stuff. But if you never understood personal growth, you think that school is about status games and childcare.

Gone are the days where children can write cursive and basically write their own essays.

You could argue the same with Google, the only time you can't use Google is during an exam which is very behind the times if you really think about it

@gorillamasterofgaming5525

8 ай бұрын

but most Schools have decent requirements for how you should research on the internet for anything. for chat gpt there cant be because your "research" is dependent on this bot who just makes randomly generated response based on how the programmers made it only.

Being dependent on AI for school and not learning yourself is a horrible idea. AI can make errors and have biases that was coded in accidentally and if u depend on it, it can trick you in important matter. AI will never be a good teacher nor an authority on any matters.

@alexv1a

6 ай бұрын

Do know that A.I is just a smart computer and can be changed in order for students o learn from it. Of course, don’t cheat with it. But Ai has helped me with outlines or references to do homework. I was struggling in algebra really badly during COVID and the references really. Helped me as I’m a visual learner rather than one thats it’s in class and listens to a person talk.

I wonder if the analogy really does fit correctly. Is school really a contest? I never thought of it in the way I do sport (which are contests by their nature), for instance. I think what's really going on is that if students don't get taught how to reason, they won't know if the AI/computer/calculator is incorrect. With calculators, we all fat-fingered before but without number sense we wouldn't be able to tell that something may not be right with a result. Similarly word sense may exist in people who read and write a lot and comes into play when we detect that a word may be misspelt or the wrong version of a word is used. These only come from real-world experience.

I would probably use it, but change the sentences up a lot to make it my own words

I think people who see Chat GPT as cheating or as a tool that stops our critical thinking skills are either not using the tool in a productive creative way or is just stuck in an old view of life that challenges all disrupting technologies. ChatGPT is a great tool for Socratic thinking which is one of the best ways to learn new and challenging information. I love how Emad answers the question- school is not a contest. It’s also time we understand that life is not a contest either

@roadkill8804

7 ай бұрын

"Smart people learn from everything, average people learn from experience, and stupid people already have the answers."-Socrates

We have had four consecutive generations each dumber than the one before. We have not taught Critical Thinking in schools for several decade's, and now we want to let kids use AI to think for them. 👍👍 GREAT IDEA!! 🤪🤪🤪

@dieglhix

Жыл бұрын

I'm 33 and I will have vasectomy this year because civilization is really fucked.

You can put inspirational music in a video. But an uninformed and stupid answer will remain one, no matter the music or applause afterwards.

I think there’s an easy way to fix that problem. If I’m a teacher, I would change the grading system. So for example, 5 percent goes on homework’s and papers 75 percent goes on exams and test and 20 percent on attendance and participation. So if you fail test because your using A.I to do homework’s then you would be in trouble when it comes to exams and test.

I don't think we should be asking tech and finance bros these questions. Let's hear from actual educators

@st0n3p0ny

6 ай бұрын

Actual educators, the people who bring in drag queens and show graphic porn to little kids while we get rid grades and testing because it's not fair to expect a student to learn...

A degree, diploma, certificate or grade promotion is supposed to relect what you've learned. Remember slaves weren't allowed to read and learn. If you give that up voluntarily you will be enslaved.

Oh really? and just how does he propose that this be done? Just dump it on schools to immediately transform into these "critical systems", way to cover your asses

I think it’s cheating because if you were really paying attention you wouldn’t need The Ai

This is not called learning if you’re not actually learning

That's the single stupidest thing I've ever heard. Ur not learning nothing, it's dishonest, and most schools forbid it so yes it's absolutely cheating.

It is no different in using a programmable calculator in Math exams.. It is malpractice and should be reported to your Dean.. You consitidor sir..

Look at all these comments from lazy teachers complaining their job became harder.

You can still have a contest system ffs. Just have a chat gpt powered platform where it keeps giving you the answer as many time they ask it but makes sure they get the the core concept at the end by varying the questions or asking it later. This must be done in a testing room in school with only computers. The test begins in the beginning of the year and they have time till the end of the year to convince the computer that they understand all the concepts for that year.

@snitox

Жыл бұрын

They students are ranked according to how fast they managed to convince it.

Imagine having to rely on ai to pass school. Sounds like a major skill issue. Use it as a tool, not your primary method of problem solving.

What a narc

@AlohaAckbar

Жыл бұрын

😂

Still this will never become popular in Asian schools though

Man I didn’t know they got kids that age doing essays. Fuck the school system man

Spell check is AI generated.

Sure you can use it later in life, but it's not something we as a society should rely on. You should learn how to use critical thinking and learn information DURING school, to build up your fundamentals. Our society is built off the knowledge taught in schools, and even if you don't go on to use calculus or chemistry, that doesn't mean your classmates across the room who are applying themselves won't. Just like the video said, Chat GPT is a tool, but how they're suggesting it sounds like a crutch

Dood made up that school is a contest… its not… its a academic standard and you meet it or you dont… theres no contest that holds back or jumps ahead a kid because they are or arent proficient. A contest would just award you a prize at the end for one person. His first idea is ill and then he basically sells a kid the idea that he should use it because “it will be here from here on out” is a lie to make the kid use it and obey. U dont have to and its only purpose is to guide the masses with data sets added in by people who want it that way or selected reality. Not true reality but again a guide for making it happen later on

exactly!

It is cheating. You are not creating the material.

How to Bullshit all over education system and value addition because u embraced A.I

The education system just gets easier and easier as technology advances, therefore the schools will have to compensate for that by giving tougher questions which can be solved by chat gpt, but still challenges the student in the process. For example if you want the student to submit an essay on a topic, the topic can be a latest event that happened as chat gpt’s cut off date is till september 2021.

@jjmurillo1508

8 ай бұрын

That just wouldnt work as you can assign a prompt that gives it a hypothetical in a world where the event already happened lol

@stealthracerhd

8 ай бұрын

but wont that just be hallucination of the nlp algorithm@@jjmurillo1508