Micah is just mad because he doesn't get to finish off high honor Arthur.

@thatguyi919

Жыл бұрын

He's mad because he doesn't get free guns

@jelloman6687

Жыл бұрын

@@thatguyi919 even if he wants to he cant causr hes saliva is poison itself

@-dusty_butterfly-

Жыл бұрын

I think the most satisfying thing in the world is turning a nine into a zero-

@arthurmorgan2906

Жыл бұрын

Medal of honor

@bruh-bn3ni

Жыл бұрын

the only respectable thing Micah has done was not finish off high honor arthur. Micah kills you in low honor because he thinks you are no better of a person than him and that Arthur just wanted revenge on Micah, so he gets the satisfaction of killing him. This is of course supported with the “YOU ARE NO BETTER THAN ME”. However, being good shows that he put others and his own morals above himself.. Thus Micah decides killing Arthur is pointless because he Arthur doesn’t really care and killing him wouldn’t do anything, so he leaves knowing he was defeated, and you can tell how he’s frustrated in that ending compared to his joy in the dishonorable ending. This is one of the rare Micah W's because lets be honest, low honor Arthur is on par or even worse than Micah

"YOU WANNA SEE HOW SOFT IVE GONE!?" LMAO Thats more threatening than all of the antagonize lines combined.

@EyeLabPNiece

Жыл бұрын

Was arthur about to flash him? 👀

@short-shots

Жыл бұрын

lol if I was playing, I would not let him just go and comeback to talk again next time

@ExTAzY101

Жыл бұрын

Sounds a bit sus too

@kaws8778

Жыл бұрын

big floppy donkey

@Journey_to_who_knows

Жыл бұрын

Orthur Orthur you watch too much hentayy

"that heart will be the death of you", while arthur catches the deathly disease BY being a horrible person

@themadtitan7603

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I think lot of people don't see this and go "he's right, Arthur's good heart killed him" but it was actually his most emphasized acts of cruelty that was the death of him.

@RogerCharlamange

Жыл бұрын

@@themadtitan7603 Dude it's incredible how many people will say they have 900+ hours in the game and still not read into all the plot. I get that it's a 60 hour story and it's hard to focus that whole time, but the game lays everything out in front of you. Arthur is supposed to be a good man, the player has the free will to deny that. But one of the VERY first things said to you by Dutch in the game is "We need to get those people fed, and warm, and I'm counting on you Arthur because you're the only one strong enough." All Arthur wanted was to help his family out, it's why he does the debt work for Strauss even though he always hated it. It kept his family alive. His journal makes it painfully obvious who he is as a person

@BababooeyGooey

Жыл бұрын

RIP media literacy, especially in the gaming community.

@cwa728

Жыл бұрын

Technically is was his LUNGS that killed him.

@themadtitan7603

Жыл бұрын

​@@RogerCharlamange It's incredible how people let their biases for a character blind them to what the story is actually presenting to the point they accuse others of misinterpreting it when they analyze the plot as it is and not what they want it to be. Arthur is not a good man in any circumstance, his journal and certain moments show he has the capacity to be one, had he been brought up by the right influence that taught him about morality. Unfortunately, it was a silver tongued sociopath who groomed him to believe in a false ideology that was an excuse to kill, rob and cheat innocents and people doing their job defending society. Arthur disliking Strauss' loan business does NOT excuse him willingly beating a sick, innocent man half to death and then bullying his son after he had just passed away. Him redeeming himself after finding out about TB is a sign of the goodness within him that needed the right motivator to come out, not that he was ALWAYS a good man.

I think a lot of Micah’s antagonism over a player who chooses the high honour play style is coming from the fact that he’s bitter about his brother Amos who cut all ties with him and decided to give up the outlaw life. He wants to believe that he’s right about life being a dog eat dog world and that his brother was just being weak, so he can’t stand it when a high honour player proves that idea wrong

@theguybehindyou4762

Жыл бұрын

High honor player makes it hard to hide from his conscience. Pity he can't just admit he was wrong about that dog-eat-dog business, because as a wise book once said, the truth will set you free (of a tortured conscience, in this case).

@a_loyal_kiwi88

Жыл бұрын

@@theguybehindyou4762 What do you mean wrong about the dog-eat-dog business? As twisted as Micah's worldview can be, he isn't wrong in that instance. If Arthur was living an honest life then that could be up for more debate, but he's an outlaw (with lawmen in 3 different states after him), running around being a goody two shoes would seem like unnecessary danger and risk taking, considering the circumstances.

@theguybehindyou4762

Жыл бұрын

@@a_loyal_kiwi88 I mostly meant people like him.

@pepethefrog6809

Жыл бұрын

@@a_loyal_kiwi88 And yet it's because of one act of cruelty that Arthur's gotten TB. A sentiment that Dutch seem to forget and Arthur lived by, "We shoot fellers as need shooting, save fellers as need saving and feed 'em as need feeding..".

@studio-cultist9622

Жыл бұрын

@@a_loyal_kiwi88 He bullies and fights members of the gang he’s in, he shoots down an entire town just for a pair of guns which also puts his own life at risk. Micah himself is not too concerned with his own safety despite being very self serving. I believe that Micah’s belief in survival of the fittest is just a flimsy excuse to not only feel tough around the camp but to also excuse his shitty behaviour unlike Arthur who even at his lowest honour doesn’t necessarily act out in petty and needless cruelty unless the player chooses to.

Rockstar did a great job making us hate this guy.

@natef1212

Жыл бұрын

Credit to Peter blumquist

@JonathanReichertMusic

Жыл бұрын

He's a pure bastard loll

@PolishGod1234

Жыл бұрын

I liked Micah besides few shit he did. He's badass with guns, has great sense if style and his world views are quite realistic. Agent Ross was the guy I hated the most

@angryinternetperson6629

Жыл бұрын

​@@PolishGod1234 His views on the world aren't "realistic", he's just a narcissist and an asshole. He's literally no better than Ross, if not worse. Willing to betray anyone just to benefit from it.

@ingrobny4111

Жыл бұрын

Lets not forget @Peter Blomquist either, high quality voice acting!

If Micah hates you you know you’re in the right path

In my current play through I'm still in chapter 2 and haven't helped Micah out of strawberry yet. The vibe in camp is just so chill and friendly, I love it, and I'll do his mission as late as possible!

@mjolnirbaldur5770

Жыл бұрын

I'm playing it for the first time atm but I already know what happens so I'm leaving micah in the jail cell for as long as possible. I've just been hunting, doing challenges and exploring for money for the past few hours.

@nbbvvfkjjj1877

Жыл бұрын

You kill Micah as John near the end Arthur dies Grimsaw dies Lenny dies Hosea dies

@fearful684plane9

Жыл бұрын

@@nbbvvfkjjj1877 you must be fun at parties

@Mamuff5

Жыл бұрын

You can left him there until chapter 3, I was doing missions, having fun and then the game stops giving you missions because the next mission would be with Micah involved and then I realize I never helped that chubby fella

@Mamuff5

Жыл бұрын

​@@nbbvvfkjjj1877 what is your problem buddy, feeling a little "Micah" today?

Arthur didn’t go soft. He just saves his anger for those that deserve it.

“That heart will be the death of you.” Actually it was his lungs but I don’t expect Micah to know much about anatomy

Micah would sure as hell love Twitter

@marypalmer00

Жыл бұрын

And reddit. Well I love reddit too, but yeah

@jds8438

Жыл бұрын

@@marypalmer00 hypocrite

@marypalmer00

Жыл бұрын

@@jds8438 that's me, nice to meet you

@megnus3rs

Жыл бұрын

Nah too many lgbt people but i think he'll love reddit

@waffler-yz3gw

Жыл бұрын

@@megnus3rs the point is he wants to make people mad

Ironically enough it was the lack of empathy that got him TB

Love how he's all like "ooo you gone soft!" But the second Arthur implies that he's ready to brawl, he just slinks away. Real tough guy here....

Arthur: "You're just pissed no one ever bought you a new gun."

Micah is the biggest coward, saying stuff then leaving before arthur does something

@Dstreet370

Жыл бұрын

"I'm a survivor" 😂

@justice_of_Youtube

Жыл бұрын

@@Dstreet370 that's all there is, antagonizing and running away

@morgan0__o

Жыл бұрын

@@Dstreet370 ironic, isn't it? because being a "survivor" doesn't involve riling up your own comrades solely for your own amusement, the same people you rely on to fight next to you on the battlefield

@mikeock4961

Жыл бұрын

He had to wait till Arthur was half dead and even then he barely beat him

@LankyLanc03

Жыл бұрын

@@mikeock4961 debatable, Micah kinda toyed with him. If he wanted Arthur Dead that fast, he wouldn’t tackle him, but instead would’ve shot him. Even when fighting, Micah had him choking out, defending on the floor and so on. Micah did get hit with a few but I reckon he already knew what he was doing.

Here in the wild west, if Micah doesn't hate you enough, you ain't doin' it right.

Micah:NoOoOooO you can't just be a good person! Arthur: haha honor go brrrr

@Somedudeonaiphonechilling8971

Жыл бұрын

horse stealers, robbers acting like they need desperate help: haha steal go brrrr

@skeletontamir

Жыл бұрын

@@Somedudeonaiphonechilling8971 Arthur: HAHA Self Defense go brr

I've met people like this in real life that actually demonizes the idea of helping people being a bad thing. The way he frames it as "going soft" when the methods Arthur uses to actually saves people is ironically violent makes me wonder what the hell Micah considers a "strong hard man" then....

@EmptyMan000

Жыл бұрын

A deranged murderous psychopath would be an example.

@Osio1000_5

Жыл бұрын

Micah considers himself a "strong hard man" and nobody else

@GeneralCane

Жыл бұрын

Probably someone who watches exclusively after their own ass.

@KairuHakubi

Жыл бұрын

a lot of those people NEED that to be true.

@killgriffinnow

9 ай бұрын

Micah is like a male feminist: a weaselly little rat.

This is why I believe high honor Arthur is canon cause Micah is low honor Arthur and it creates an extremely great dynamic between the two. It also works with Dutch who starts with high honor then ends with low honor as he progressively loses his mind.

@FirstNameLastName-lg7yz

Жыл бұрын

Not only that but both of their iconic outfits are an inversion of the other, Micah wears a white hat with a black band, black coat, red shirt, white pants. Arthur's a complete inversion, with a black hat with a brown rope band, tan jacket, blue shirt , and black pants. Their weight even comes into play as arthur will always be skinny becaus of his TB while micah will stay fat througout the story.

@lukemorgan6166

Жыл бұрын

Dutch was always a vile person but charasmatic enough to hide it especially when his 'plans' were successful enough

@denises753

Жыл бұрын

@@lukemorgan6166 Dutch was a great person to begin with, offering to wade through snow in the middle of the night to search for John and the rest, calling for Sean to be rescued while Arthur bellyached about cutting him loose, and orchestrating an attack on the Braithwaites when he discovered they had kidnapped Jack. Meanwhile people repeatedly gloss over how imbecilic and selfish Arthur is, even when playing as high honor. He repeatedly fucks up, as with the dynamite cord, and brushes it aside as "one of them things," while antagonizing others for their failures. He speaks up about feeling uneasy about something, and when he is convinced to go along with it and it goes wrong, he immediately starts to boast about how he thought it was a bad idea despite going along with it, himself. He was happy to leave the German family to fend for themselves without their father, until Charles told him, "no, we're going to help them." Arthur is canonically a hypocritical asshole, and his antagonism plays a great part in making Dutch lose his mind. Dutch > Arthur

@coby9282

Жыл бұрын

@@denises753 I think it was Rockstars way to make the dialogues and cutscenes work for both a high and low honor Arthur... He is neither a good guy hero nor and a complete bad guy. On my second playthrough I was going for low honor and was surprised how the things you have mentioned like his sometimes hyprocrisy, his ranting about others when they fuck up, it all works really well for a low honor character.

@thegageinator805

Жыл бұрын

Nah.

He's like people who say "welcome to the internet" when you call them out for being jerks online. They think being decent is a weakness but they are just looking to justify their own actions.

@DuskJoker

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, well you got funny eyebrows.

@magicmanmartinez9367

Жыл бұрын

Lmao you are comparing a killer with internet forum banter. CHRONICALLY ONLINE.

@fredbyoutubing

Жыл бұрын

@@magicmanmartinez9367 He's a well written character with relatable interactions.

@lukemorgan6166

Жыл бұрын

Major cope

@bobbybonboodlessticks5727

Жыл бұрын

​@Frederic Beaudet welcome to the Internet

0:43 - 1:18 “Some survive,others must perish. That’s the world,you can’t save nobody.” *“Well,maybe that’s no longer my world.”* “Sickness must’ve got to the brain.” I see that Micah believes that the good people are supposed to die because they’re weak and too compassionate. To survive you must close your heart to adapt and do whatever is necessary for your owns survival,basically having very low honor and to be strong by being bad and heartless whereas Arthur is taking an advice from sister Calderón: “take a gamble that love exists and do a love in that.”

@codysellers4151

Жыл бұрын

even logically Micah's worldview only wins out for so long. There is always someone bigger, stronger, faster, smarter, more manipulative, just as willing to backstab you, etc. Humans survived as a species because we worked together in groups, not because we played Rambo.

Honestly, the good guy who has the capacity to kill is more terrifying than the bad guy who kills.

@countrygeneral

Жыл бұрын

Why?

@alboorts

Жыл бұрын

@@countrygeneral because i gotta eat doodooo and pee

@beelzebub9138

Жыл бұрын

@@alboorts same

@alboorts

Жыл бұрын

@@beelzebub9138 exactly

@MyViolador

Жыл бұрын

@@countrygeneral cause you dont know if hes there to help you or kill you, with a killed atleast you know its intentions

I'm just speculating, but he seems to be actually concerned for Arthur, in his own Micah way. It just doesn't come off as his usual sarcastic remarks.

“You wanna see how soft I’ve gone?” Coming from Arthur, that’s asking you if you want a death sentence.

Micah: they lead down a false path. Well that's rich coming from Micah

Arthur proved Micah wrong because it was his acts of kind-heartedness that redeemed him and made a change in people's lives while oppositely, it was one of his acts of cruelty that was actually the death of him.

"That heart will be the death of you" Wrong organ, Micah, it will actually be the lungs.

be bad: dutch/susan complains be good: micah complains

@themadtitan7603

Жыл бұрын

If Micah complains that's no problem for most players.

Micah is like your little demon that keeps on whispering in your ears

Ironic how Dutch preached about helping people, But his favorite gang member was completely against it

How does Micah wear that thick-ass leather coat in the humid Lemoyne heat?

@marypalmer00

Жыл бұрын

because ✨fashion✨

@Somedudeonaiphonechilling8971

Жыл бұрын

he built different🗿

@BababooeyGooey

Жыл бұрын

It's especially funny since everyone in the camp always make concerned comments about how hot or cold Arthur's outfits look.

@alnobleman2884

Жыл бұрын

Horseshoe Overlook is in New Hanover, not Lemoyne

@ElPayasoMalo

Жыл бұрын

@@alnobleman2884 I didn't say it was.

At the time when Arthur said “You wanna see how soft I’ve gone?”, Arthur was still in the very early stages of tuberculosis, so he was still strong enough to easily drop Micah like a bad habit considering the fact that he was almost twice Micah’s size, never mind the fact that Arthur is literally the best shot in the gang. Micah made the right call walking away there.

@Veilfire

Жыл бұрын

He only took Late Stage TB!Arthur on because that's the only time he'd be able to beat him. Nasty scum rat

Arthur: Well I'm sorry I thought the plan we were doing is acting like normal folk and not causing trouble, gathering money from jobs so we could escape. Do you wanna see what kind of valuables I've gotten from these "Helping people?"

"The nastiest killer in the whole country has gone soft." No! Don't tell me! You actually found compassion!? Why Micah, I'm proud of you!

lol he gets angry because he does the opposite things

@themadtitan7603

Жыл бұрын

It doesn't seem like he's angry and more like he's just teasing Arthur that he went "soft" because he helps people despite the fact that he's still the gang's muscle and their greatest asset.

"That heart will be the death of you." I felt that deeply and personal. A good heart is one of the greatest treasures to have, but be careful with the people, you share your good heart with. It might get heavily damaged.

@cry0genic423

Жыл бұрын

me when i lend my friend a tener

@professionalgamer6522

Жыл бұрын

True but it's not the heart itself what is the problem. It's just bad people. Working on awareness will help to identify these bad people so they can't take advantage

@captainhydra4291

Жыл бұрын

Get over it

@mariguana7918

Жыл бұрын

At first I thought you were implying you had heart failure.

@wujek7616

Жыл бұрын

he ain't wrong

Some times even the most friendly people can end up kicking your ass

The death of him was an act of cruelty not kindness

"That heart will be the death of you" Something tells me there was an event in Micahs life that made him believe this, and it wasn't just his father beating it into him.

...I kinda wonder what the hell happened in Micah's life to give him that world view. It really is pitiable.

@suleymanbabak1973

Жыл бұрын

nothing in particular. Some people are just like that.

@wellyunnoso3087

Жыл бұрын

@@suleymanbabak1973 upbringing, genetics, and environmental factors

@JRMAV1

Жыл бұрын

Father was a life long outlaw with him and his brother. His brother left the life, Micah didn’t.

@PolishGod1234

Жыл бұрын

@@wellyunnoso3087 trust me, some people are just like that no matter what. Someone might be born into a loving family but still could turn out to be an awful human being in the future

@JThom529

Жыл бұрын

@@PolishGod1234hat’s not a valid explanation

"what are you TaLkInG aBoUt" mans voice went deep as hell

Arthur: (helps people) Micah: Ugh, disgusting! (Vomits)

Micah is extremely cold. His philosophy is just being ruthless and callous to survive and get what he wants. Arthur on the other hand has a heart and helps those that need it (With high honor)

Micah: "That heart will be the death of you." Arthur: "Actually it'll be my lungs but close enough...Okay, I'll catch you later then."

"maybe thats no longer my world" bro put this up there in the top of most underrated Arthur quotes of all time

"That heart will be the death of you." Close, Micah. It's actually my lungs.

“That hearts gonna get you killed” more his lungs than his heart honestly

People in the camp reaction toHigh honor arthur:I couldn't possibly go with Arthur, he done to much for me.

"Wanna see how soft I've gone?" *pulls down pants*

Very cool. I’ve never gotten any of these interactions and I’m always high honor

1:15 such an Harlan Fontaine sentence.

Damn, the man doesn't want you get Good Honor.

As much as I help strangers and keep my honor high I never get Micah to tell me what a good job I'm doing in his antagonizing way.❤

Micah: it’s a nasty world Me: well he isn’t wrong

"That heart will be the death of you!" "Actually, it'll be the lungs"

“That heart will be the death of you” No his lungs would be the death of him.

"That heart will be the death of you" This is the exact reason i like micah. This is nothing but truth and only people like arthur will truly understand (however it will be too late)

Micah: that heart will be the death of you. Arthur: sike! It's my lungs!

I feel like this is Micah being as close to honest as he gets. He's genuinely a bit confused why anyone would bother helping out someone else, and it reminds him of his brother who left the gang life behind. He's really trying to warn Arthur that altruism is pointless (as we know he actually believes).

Damn, Micah is like Twitter

You should see what happens if you bring that Lindsay Wofford bounty to the old guy who thinks the Civil War is still going on. They were on opposing sides during the war and it would be interesting if Rockstar made a little interaction with them. The fort you find Lindsay at isn't far from that guy's place either

How am I only now noticing Micah's trucker hands

"That heart'll be the death of ya." actually it was his lungs, close enough tho.

I remember getting one on Micah calling Arthur the prodigal son once. Let me just do nice things Micah. I know how this ends, we're in a prequel😂

Haven't play in a while, but in both playthroughs I had done high honor and never had these interactions, amazing how people still find these things

"Micah are you complaining that I'm been too nice lately?"

This encapsulates how I talk with pessimistic people tbh.

Can't believe I never got any of these interactions after all these years. What a game

All I can say is Micha seemed pretty soft each time you fought him, physically that is…

I remember hearing Micah say one time, "there's no better feeling than stabbing someone who trusts you in the back" or something along those lines. Not a very good man I say.

Micah really gives me some flowey vibes here

I had a good laughing fit over this one time. Micah came up and said one of those lines, meanwhile I had this random dude tied up on the back of my horse.

I'm very fortunate that I played Arthur with High Honor alright. Even though it killed me inside in the end. It was worth it without doubts.

I think this might be the only time micah cares for Arthur the game doesnt show it but in the 1800's there would be MUCH more ambushes than actual people in need of help

Micah is a villain, and doesn't like do gooders

@scoutmainmybeloved8394

Жыл бұрын

do gooders^

@red_dead_redemption_2_clips

Жыл бұрын

@@scoutmainmybeloved8394 thank you

@AAAAAAAgggg

Жыл бұрын

How could you be a do gooder as a killer?

@red_dead_redemption_2_clips

Жыл бұрын

@@AAAAAAAgggg I don't know, but it's possible to help some people

@AAAAAAAgggg

Жыл бұрын

While ruinin lot more of some

This man is pure evil 😭

Micah couldn't even take on Arthur when he was sick and dying, if these two squared up earlier in the game Arthur would clobber him

You can tell how arthur changed theoughout the whole story at first he was laughing then he made a joke kinda and then he was just tryna be serious

never heard any of these lines before! makes you wonder what other conversations have been missed

Evil cannot comprehend good.

I’m leaving Micah in those damn hills

Interesting if you listen you can hear the progression in Arthur’s voice. Such a damn good game

"hE iS a fInE mAn" -Dutch

These days I always end things with Arthur via going for the money with high honour. I like giving Micah something to remember Arthur by forever.

Micah is like that "your not that guy, pal, your not that guy" dude.

Micah always walks like he's imagining he's pissing on everything he walks past.

I've never wanted to kill someone as much as him.

"that heart will be the death of you" thats called foreshadowing

Its sad hearing sick Arthur at the end. Didn’t realize how different he sounded

0:09 that heart was what ultimately saved Arthur in the end

Micah biggest mistake was taking Arthur's kindess for weakness. It's precisely because Arthur was kind to others that John, Charles and Sadie swear vendetta against Micah and killed him.

This is so cool! I've gotten over 2000 hours into the game but I've never seen this! Nice

you can really hear how different Arthur's voice sounds in chapter 6 here

"That heart will be the death of you." I guest what he said is true

How have I never gotten these?! This game is the only game where I want to stay at home base for an entire day. I should have gotten these at some point. This game has so much hidden dialogue that its mindblowing.

was so proud when he said this to me

micah: "that heart will be the death of you." arthur: "just like that mouth of yours's will be the death of you. now go do something useful."

I usually play low honor until the diagnosis. Even though high honor might make more sense, low honor is just super fun.

This is the only thing I liked about Micah: he actually feels threatened by a high honor Arthur. If you act bad like him and go on murderous sprees yet claim to be better than him he justifiably gets angry which is why he offs a low honor Arthur. If you are good though deep down he knows hes a piece of trash compared to Arthur and doesnt want to face up to it.

In my latest playthrough I didn't let Micah come back to camp until his mission was the only one avaliable to do. Took a long time lmao

Meanwhile in the background Tilly just wants the men to help with the damn laundry.