I know it's a late comment but this is blowing up recently so I just wanted to say, I originally saw it in german since that's how it was on Netflix! But for KZread, it was switched to english so people could enjoy it without having to read subtitles :)

@dffhitfrg

Жыл бұрын

no cry baby

@alf3707

Жыл бұрын

Best horror story so far in this decade.

@BlackChungaChanga

11 ай бұрын

Nice reaction, this movie is a masterpiece, I’m planning on buying original book because man… it’s awesome

@maddoxdecena63

11 ай бұрын

If you think this is sad, my grandpa served if Vietnam and the last thing he sad to my mom was "War without casualties is a miracle and a blessing." - Pascal Decena My mom once got a letter in the middle of the day, she opened it and it came out with a letter and a medal. And the letter said "If or once you get this this will be my last stand because they have us on the line, I'm sorry I couldn't be their to see you grow up. I love you and hopefully ill go home." - Pascal Decena I love you grandpa thank you for protecting us.

@williamtheokguy4428

11 ай бұрын

to tatu to tatu to ta du

The book was written by a man who was a German soldier. The main character was inspired by him specifically. And if I recall correctly, the scene with Paul in the hole with the Frenchman was a real thing that happened.

@fiddiehacked

Жыл бұрын

The author had been training to be a teacher, which he finished after the war. Im Westen Nichts Neues was published in 1929, and immediately had a few persons who criticized the novel for being overly sensationalized, including veterans who had been in the trenches and hospitals. It was banned by German & Italian governments in the 1930's, of course. Because of his fame & income from the book, he was able to leave Germany before WWII erupted and eventually passed away in Switzerland in 1970. He was survived by his 3rd wife, actress Paulette Goddard. According to Wikipedia; "On 31 July 1917 he [ER Remarque, the author] was wounded by shell shrapnel in his left leg, right arm and neck, and after being medically evacuated from the field was repatriated to an army hospital in Germany, where he recovered from his wounds. In October 1918, he was recalled to military service, but the war's armistice a month later put an end to his military career."

@crusader2112

Жыл бұрын

Another great WW1 memoir/book is Storm of Steel by Ernst Junger.

@achilloryenrfr_2710

Жыл бұрын

Make this scene more brutal and hard to watch...

@airborngrmp1

Жыл бұрын

It was a true event according to the author. The awful, brutal takeaway was that almost as soon as our eponymous Paul gets back to his trenches and finds his unit and friends he begins to acknowledge that the promises he made to the dying man would go unfulfilled. Paul had promised him(self) that he would deliver the Frenchman's effects and look in on his family when his whole world was just the two men sharing a shell hole, but soon knew he never would. That world didn't exist anymore, and never would again - as ethereal as the promise proved to be. It is difficult to put my finger on exactly what it was about that exchange: a brutal killing, an apology, an honest promise, and it's ultimate dismissal as pointless just seemed to poignantly encapsulate the brutality and impersonality of that war. Just another squalid death, the particulars of which were experienced by two dead men - one on borrowed time.

@fyrdman2185

Жыл бұрын

Storm of Steel was better, not like this doom and gloom bitchy book. It was written by a man who actually volunteered and fought from the start til the end of the war unlike Remarque who was conscripted and fought for only a month and was sent home because he got injured.

It's important to note until more recent wars like the Korean and Vietnam war, people had no idea what war actually looked like, that's why these boys were so excited to go off to war, they saw it as a chance for adventure and all their friends were going so it was part of peer pressure too.

@woeshaling6421

Жыл бұрын

and they are fed stories of heroism and glory. so much so masculinity is linked inseperably from it. being a coward was unthinkable to little boys. they get a constant stream of propaganda. some are outright lies, but most are sanitized and pumped to seem like "super heroes" these days.

@cheebees

Жыл бұрын

I kind of agree. But since war existed, you'd have to know that people are going to die. For them not to even consider it is strange to me. There's not informed, and then there is ignorance to basic human realities.

@petersvillage7447

Жыл бұрын

@@cheebees That's where propaganda comes in, and it's really not like recruitment propaganda around military service has ever gone away. Storytelling around war absolutely tended toward selling it as an adventure, and it still does - even in cases where the story might nonetheless be considered gritty and grim.

@traktitch2364

Жыл бұрын

@@cheebees Big difference between reading about it and letting a boy's imagination run wild, then seeing it on the big screen with the actual violent reality

@Vendetta_s

Жыл бұрын

@@cheebees before today. Back then in ww1 and the previous old wars it was seen as glorious, heroic, powerful, not bloody and gruesome and traumatic. War was for men and it was a man duty to fight and protect the women and children behind him and his land. Come back with awesome war medals and have the ladies. That how war was seen. Death was told but not in ways to horrify, it was just “well the soldier died honourably in battle’ . So death was foreign to boys and well everyone. But basically when ww1 started it was exciting, a chance to grow up so fast for these 16-19 year olds to be like the older men and those that fought in older battles. Time to show off to the ladies in their uniform and confidence and ego. Death? Couldn’t happen to me, would be their thought process. All the stories of fighting on horses with swords and stuff. Destroying the enemy and the victory. You lose the fact death is there. Especially at such an age where you are easily influenced, naive and rebellious and want to go out into the world really. Not to mention the newspaper were all filled with propaganda too.

If you notice, Kat, Tjaden, Albert, and Franz were the only ones keeping him sane throughout the whole movie. Once all of them are gone, Paul becomes vicious and merciless throughout the final battle.

@randomguy-zq8sf

5 ай бұрын

Damm

@synesthesia.aesthetic

3 ай бұрын

It's so brutal cause so many of them are literally kids

@Junowcue

3 ай бұрын

and yet, they basically all died. it was so sad.

@user-xe6xw2rd2w

Ай бұрын

@@synesthesia.aestheticnot kids but like young they’re around like 14-17 i think.

@Mishapher.101

25 күн бұрын

@@user-xe6xw2rd2w Practically they were kids, they were too young and weak to know and face a war. I can't imagine how bloody sad was for them to leave home and once in battlefields notice they likely were never coming back.

This is the first war movie I've ever seen that felt like a horror movie. This one absolutely devastated me, as it should. Its a masterpiece and deserved every award it received.

@Daniel-mw7pu

2 ай бұрын

Yeah… a lot of war movies unintentionally glamorize war. This movie made war feel like what it really is: terrifying. My father served in the military and even though he never saw combat he said life in the military is hell. You’re cold, wet, hungry, and bored all the time.

@NACHOTHEIST

Ай бұрын

Watch “Come and See.” That is a horror/war movie.

You gotta watch it in the original German now! The emotion in the actors’ voices make a huge difference, such as at 22:30, and them speaking in German makes it a more authentic experience.

@MONKECAVEMAN

Жыл бұрын

100% agree I actually never watched it in English

@ThatRedditguy394

11 ай бұрын

true

@Loowee__

9 ай бұрын

@@MONKECAVEMANsame, just chuck on some English subs, I do the same with all foreign films or shows such as money heist back when that was popular

@leonplay9034

9 ай бұрын

Pero llevá subtítulos en inglés?

@RayBetterThanEvilCanival

8 ай бұрын

@@leonplay9034 Si, los subtitulos estan en español tambien

If you notice at the end, the rookie soldier collecting the dog tags didn't grab the main characters due to being distracted by the scarf....it's supposed to represent all the fallen soldiers who were NVR identified

@TheReeelBradPitt

8 ай бұрын

Also distracted because he recognized Paul as the guy who saved him, and realizes he died in his place

@Helldiver111

7 ай бұрын

What means NRV ?

@TheReeelBradPitt

7 ай бұрын

@@Helldiver111 never

@cosmothecourageous4580

7 ай бұрын

@@Helldiver111i guess he meant to put “never”

@Helldiver111

7 ай бұрын

@@cosmothecourageous4580thanks

This is the first movie EVER that I watched that wouldn't let me go. To this day, I sometimes still sit in my room and just think about this movie, especially the scene where Paul was in that hole with the French soldier. It's the perfect depiction of how humanity is both incredibly beautiful and horribly cruel. Paul was terrified for his life, then his instincts and his training kicked in and he stabbed the man. And then he broke down when he couldn't take the gunshots, the explosions and the wheezing and choking from the soldier anymore, so he stuffed dirt into his mouth to silence him. And ultimately, we got a glimpse of the person Paul was before all of this. Kind-hearted, warm, empathatic, caring, nurturing and loving to everything around him, always trying to stay positive and preserve the beauty and life in everything. He tried to undo the damage, he cleaned the man's mouth, he gave him water, cleaned his face, tried to get rid of the blood that would just keep coming, tried to bandage the wound even though it was clear to see that it wouldn't work. We've seen Paul lose everything, but even in his darkest moment, deep down he still kept his humanity. Underneath it all, he was still this pure, innocent and naive boy that went to war with his friends, thinking it was just some vacation spent with pretty girls, good food and songs by the fire until he'd return and be welcomed back a hero. Also, the moment he saved the new recruit was so impactful to me, because the boy is just the same as Paul was at the beginning of the movie. It's a great way of Paul essentially saving himself in the last moments of his life. He saved a boy that was just like him from becoming just another dead body in a senseless war, just like him. He saved the boy, so he can live the life that Paul dreamt of, or atleast hoped for in the end, but never got to have. And the worst scene that always makes me ball my eyes out, is when he stumbles out of the trench, bleeding from his stab wound, and he's looking up, eyes searching...the camera follows his gaze...and he cannot even see the sky in his final moments. Not even the sky. Just ashes and smoke. The sky is usually so symbolic in moments when people die, representing tranquility, serenity and peace. It makes their world stop for a moment, giving them an end where they don't have to worry about anything. Just look at the sky, and the tranquil blue and the fluffy, pure white white clouds. Let the fresh and crisp air fill your lungs and carry your soul and spirit away with the wind, becoming one with peaceful nature and the cycle of life. Even that was taken from Paul. All he was left with was dead bodies, the taste and the smell of blood and gunpowder, screams, ashes and smoke. Even in his final moments, he had nothing that could've brought him peace. Nothing but a scarf, that used to be of a pristine white color and smell like flowers and his friends. Now drenched in his own blood. Beautiful representation of all the people who were lost to time and were never remembered by name, because their tags were never discovered or simply left behind.

"A true soldier does not go to war because he hates what's in front of him, he goes to war because he loves what's behind him"

@aurorapaisley7453

3 ай бұрын

There is no true soldiers. Only young men and beaurocrats permitted to send them to hell

@Foria777

Ай бұрын

Aha, oligarchy, for example.

@fixthefernback8030

24 күн бұрын

you didn't learn a single thing from this movie did you?

The friendship between Paul and Katt is so good.

@BlackShadow-ob7fi

Жыл бұрын

Ikr

@ST4R_luvHearts

7 ай бұрын

My favorite characters in this movie are Paul and katt

@yourgayifyoureplytome8503

3 ай бұрын

*Was

You definitely should have watched the actors perform in their natural language

@zepekit

Жыл бұрын

Indeed. That dub was horrible. Damn...

@abhishekupadhye994

Жыл бұрын

Yeah

@melomesocks

Жыл бұрын

Paul's actor was much better in German. So emotional.

@bwallatube

Жыл бұрын

I agree, though.... I'm normally such a staunch proponent of the original language but as it started I automatically felt understanding and thought to my self "watch it however you feel like.." possibly because it's just so dang heavy.

@TheRetroHippieGirl

Жыл бұрын

I agree the acting would be better in the original language as well as be more realistic, it would have been better to not have British actors do the dubbing. However, I have to mention that I personally prefer subpar dubbing over subtitles for 3 reasons 1) I personally read somewhat slow and I sometimes have to keep pausing and focus mostly on reading and trying to keep up with the subtitles, especially if they are speaking quickly. 2) Sometimes the subtitle fonts colors blend into the background being unreadable (ie. white subtitles on white background, black on a black background, etc.) 3) Sometimes I like to have the movie running on a different tab on my laptop and open a new tab to look up something I want to know more about. For those reasons I personally choose to go with the more subpar dubbed version to enjoy the film without missing out on the visual and with no frustrations. That is just my personal opinion, to each their own.

“1 death is a tragedy. 1,000 deaths are a statistic.” -Joseph Stalin, 2nd leader of the Soviet Union

@Foria777

Ай бұрын

Bullshit. He never said that. Do you know what he could say? He could say: "What other fathers will think? ". After an offer from Nazi army to exchange his son Jacob to fieldamarshal Paulus. Jacob died in concentration camp.

@snipz127

22 күн бұрын

How he felt toward his own people btw

@Foria777

22 күн бұрын

@@snipz127 these are not his words since his son died in this war too.

@snipz127

22 күн бұрын

@@Foria777 I'm referring to the 6-10 million Russians that died from Stalin not WW1

@Foria777

22 күн бұрын

@@snipz127 inform you about Jacob Stalin who died at nazi concentration camp during WWII. As well as some other children of chiefs of USSR government.

I watched the movie to it’s original language, which is German (with subtitles), and it was the most impactful movie I have watched. I feel bad for the men who died on that field.

I am from Germany and my great uncle from my fathers side was a soldier in WW1. He went missing somewhere in the Somme area in France at the beginning of October 1918, about 6 weeks before the end of WW1. He never was found. This movie gets me everytime watching it.

@aarons6935

Жыл бұрын

No he didn't.

@cyberjester777

10 ай бұрын

He probably got blown to bits. Respect.

@Deus1Vult

8 ай бұрын

Mis respetos para tu ancestro, saludos desde México hasta Alemania

@veteranpg3d156

8 ай бұрын

Mine also did, but in Russia and he was Austrian

@veteranpg3d156

8 ай бұрын

@@aarons6935 You’re not the one to say

VKunia: "The thing that I'm really liking about this movie so far is--" Movie: DUN DUN DUUUUN

@roryasrorri701

Жыл бұрын

XD

@codexnecro

Жыл бұрын

I think I know what they were going for with the soundtrack, but those big synths feel so out of place for a WWI movie, to me at least it does.

@adamantiumrage

Жыл бұрын

​@Codexnecro Same. I couldn't stand it, and have NO idea what the hell they were thinking putting it into a WWI film.

@gabrielegenota1480

Жыл бұрын

@@codexnecro It’s not a synth. It’s an organ-like musical instrument from the era (I forgor what it’ called lmao)

@bittybaff3541

Жыл бұрын

​@@codexnecroit's meant to, it represents the stark contrast between expectation and reality of the war. It's jarring because it doesn't belong, it's foreign to everything else on purpose

In any war it doesn’t matter what side you are on. Each side experiences hell

The hardest part of this movie to watch, was when he stabbed the frenchman. He first tried to kill him, and then he was trying to help. So that was the hardest part for me.

First time seeing it in english and I must say in german its way more emotional and everything. A lot is lost in the english Version.

@Johan_Liebert12

Жыл бұрын

Ikr i wish she watched it in german

@jaymessmoyer340

Жыл бұрын

​@@Johan_Liebert12 yeah. Also why does everyone cry when they watch the movie. I have seen lots of bits and pieces of it and it tbh just looks like your typical war film. Idk if its just me but blood, guts and stuff in movies is tbh not a big deal in my mind like I know what I pay to watch which is about war.

@pspublic13

Жыл бұрын

@@jaymessmoyer340 Why does it bother you that others cry about the movie?

@jaymessmoyer340

Жыл бұрын

@@pspublic13 cause if you know your watching a film that involves war, murder, mystery, horror, or any other type of movie like that you know there is gonna gore, blood, death and other stuff like that. Idc if you cry a bit at it but when ppl legit have breakdowns it's kinda annoying to be honest. Like I get this is based on real events but this happened over 100 years ago and this movie is showing day to day life of a german soldier in ww1. You'd legit expect people to die, get exploded, gassed, burnt to a crisp cause its a *War* film.

@houjisaifeddine5524

Жыл бұрын

@@jaymessmoyer340 probably coz not everyone is a souless sociopath like you and me. not saying any camp is wrong, just giving the most likely explanation

The boy at the end wasn't a friend of Paul's. He was a raw recruit who was new and scared and Paul in that last battle was the grizzled vet like how Kat was when Paul was the new guy, it was the story coming full circle hence why the boy started collecting dog tags like how Paul did, Paul saved that boy's life so he could live the life that Paul himself became an empty shell of.

@monkiii2769

3 ай бұрын

oh you are right thats crazy

“It’s the old powerful men that declare war, but it’s the youth that fight in it”

war is war: you cant escape it if you try your dead or set to prison you have live or death war is the place where you die or survive but lose a limb i watched this film with me grampa he had flashbacks i fell sorry for him

This film deserves its 4 Oscars (including Best international film and Cinematography)

@jayplay1273

Жыл бұрын

Thought the same as she said she doesn't know why it's not more popular ;-)

@Cliohna

Жыл бұрын

Too bad for you, David. Volker Bertelmann's peers disagree with you. They voted to say, he definitely does deserve this Oscar.

@jayplay1273

Жыл бұрын

@@Cliohna This commen proves again: the brightest and most beautiful women hail from Germany

@Soco0504

Жыл бұрын

@@jayplay1273 simp

@christianwise637

Жыл бұрын

@@dawkosvk Should've been Babylon

On the topic of Anti-War films, especially ones where the cast is German, I HIGHLY suggest "Das Boot" from 1981. The best, in my opinion, submarine movie ever made. Since you have a fear of boats and sunken ships, it'd be amazing to watch you react to a movie that's all about claustrophobic underwater operations. If you do end up watching it, please do so with subtitles instead of the English dub. The dub is by no means bad, as almost all of the actors dubbed their own lines in English, but it doesn't capture the same feeling as the original German dub.

@Moorhuehnchen

Жыл бұрын

either das boot (directors cut) oder stalingrad (1993). best anti war movies out there imho. for both please take the english subbed version and not the english dub, not bad but cannot capture the feeling.

@petersvillage7447

Жыл бұрын

What, even better than U-571??? (Sorry, joking!)

@sifumagoo1776

Жыл бұрын

Das Boot is AWESOME. I 1000% agree with this recommendation. There's an amazing mini-series version that's 7 hrs long, and a modern (2019) HBO TV series set in the U-Boat base at La Rochelle. It feels like it was made at the same time, in the early 80's. It's also awesome.

@sifumagoo1776

Жыл бұрын

@@petersvillage7447 Until I read the (sorry, joking) part........I was ready to explode.

@Moorhuehnchen

Жыл бұрын

@@sifumagoo1776 not a fan of the new series, the 7 hours mini series would be too heavy for a reaction tho and she might end up claustrophobic if binging xd

I think this excerpt from battlefield one can sum up a lot of the ambition the youth had to fight in the war, and the grim reality of it all too “We came from all over the world. The innocent, the arrogant, and the brave. We thought the war was to be our right of passage, a grand adventure that would make us all equal in our quest for glory. But instead of adventure we found fear, and in war, the only true equalizer, is death.”

The german helmets are so well shaped it literally looks the best out of all

The blonde boy that took the handkerchief in the end was not one of his friends. He was one of the new recruites. Paul directed him from their arrival until the charge. He probably otherwise would have been shot for objecting too.

A little note: while tanks had been designed in 1915, they didn’t truly see combat until 1916 and even then in smaller numbers. From 1917 onwards the production numbers finally allowed them to be used on a large scale. So even at the beginning of 1917, and the war ended in November 1918, unless you were at the real big battles you probably didn’t see many tanks if any. Many german soldiers were horrified having to confront a metal monster like that and some were so terrified that they surrender at the mere sight of tanks on occasions.

@TKDragon75

4 ай бұрын

Technically the Germans were able to make some tanks, the A7V, but only like 2 dozen and were only used occasionally, they also had a few captured Mark 4 tanks.

thats why he put his friend mask on before him because he was struggling and when they are in the under ground bunker 1 or 2 have shell shock It is a reaction to the intensity of the bombardment and fighting that produced a helplessness, which could manifest as panic, fear, flight, or an inability to reason, sleep, walk or talk. Shell shock. Other names. Bullet air, soldier's heart, battle fatigue, operational exhaustion.

That is a really great reaction. Another anti-war movie I wholeheartedly can recommend is "Das Boot" (The boat), about a german submarine crew in the second war. It is... tense and an equally unusual perspective maybe. There exist multiple versions, but recommendable are the 1984 BBC miniseries (300 minutes) ideally, or the 1997 "Director's Cut" (208 minutes) as second best pick. But missing 100 min of impression really makes a difference in atmosphere and depth of impression.

I watched this when it first came on Netflix and it was a horrible masterpiece. It really showed what people went through and it was just magnificent and horrifying at the same time. I hate that we are the “smartest” entity on earth, but yet this is the sh*t we have put people through.

@ii-ti9xt

Жыл бұрын

:)

@C.H.K.N_tenders

8 ай бұрын

Smart yet dumb*

@insultlk

6 ай бұрын

Well everyone is greedy and desires power and wealth. Empires are forged through war

After watching the german version, the english syncro seems weirdly calm."Gettin' shot at, best keep your noggin' down bruv" is the general idea.Not horrible, but odd.

@onyx747

5 ай бұрын

Yeah, the English dub is so calm while the original German is so intense

As someone who wants a career as an AFSOC (air force special operations command) Combat Controller this stuff makes it a really hard choice for me knowning im volunteering for the worst horrors of any war I am involved in but I think it's the right choice for me. Humanity has fought each other for centuries. It will never change. I think it's good to prepare for war but to try and keep peace. Peace through superior firepower.

Loved this great reaction ty👍🏻

Most war movies about the German perspective are made in German language, only with subtitles or a mostly not that good english dubbing. But great movies overall. Some even nominated for Oscars in the past. Some movies come to my mind who had international success. Downfall was a masterpiece, same for Das Boot or Stalingrad(1993). Generation War was a three movie series about German soldiers on the eastern front in Russia. With that said, All Quiet on the Western front often makes me think about my own families past. My great grandfather died in France late october 1918, two weeks before the end. Survived the entire war since 1914, just to die so close to the end.

@petersvillage7447

Жыл бұрын

Intriguingly - though not surprisingly, I'm sure - much of the German account of the Western front mirrors the tone and mood of the British accounts. Since the 1960s, anyway, when the British depict the Great War, the overall villain is more likely to be a cold-blooded British General than a German soldier...

@alpaka8437

Жыл бұрын

@@petersvillage7447 The German soldiers themselves were indoctrinated and were victims of politics.

@Chewie1802

10 ай бұрын

Another good German anti-war film (more precisely: co-produced by Germany, USA and Yugoslavia) is "Steiner - Das Eiserne Kreuz" ("Cross of Iron").

As for the German raid right before 11 o'clock on November 11... I think most nations did something simillar (trying to gain terrain/honour/prestige in the last hours of the war). I know for a fact that the Canadian Corp (then part of the British Empire) raided (and re-captured) the town of Mons, Belgium a few minutes before 11 o'clock. The British army had their first defeat of the war at Mons in 1914, so the Canadian commanders tought it would "clean Imperial honour" to retake it before the war ended. So they requested the "honour" to attack... And British Field Marshal Douglas Haig was way to happy to allows it. Giving the British (or even Allies ?) their last victory of the war. War is hell... Sometimes it is needed to protect your country/freedom (like WWII or the Falkland War) some other times it is useless (like WWI, the Vietnam War or the Afghanistan War) but it always leaves deep traces on a generation... and thousands of dead bodies.

@stevencass8849

Жыл бұрын

Wilfred Owen, the great British Poet, was killed in the last week of the war, after the armistice had been signed but not gone in to effect, and after writing a letter to his mother that he thought he was going to make it after all.

@hmvollbanane1259

Жыл бұрын

Yes in reality the Germans didn't launch any offensives on the last day but the entente did resulting in another 3k dead on that day. I guess they reversed it for the storytelling while still showing the senselessness of it all. Would have been a weird watch to suddenly switch perspective to a French general giving the speach

@neoxyte

Жыл бұрын

Even the Americans attacked on that day. There was a congressional investigations done into the commanding officer for ordering the attack even though he knew the war was technically over soon. The last man to die on the western front died at 10:59 am. The last of the fighting officially ended 3 days later when the German guerillas in Africa surrendered (the only Germans to win pretty much all their battles).

@lordhoot1

11 ай бұрын

The attack on Mons was basically over by the time the armistice was confirmed to be going ahead. In reality the scenario as shown in the film wouldn't have happened - the only person there whose life was in danger was the general, and that's from his own men. Best case scenario they'd have laughed in his face and told him to "verpiss dich".

I'm so sorry, I watched this movie all the way through, but the way that you cried so many times, I kind of laughed😂😂

I’ve never cried harder when Kropp was burned. That whole battle scene made me bawl with my jaw dropped wide open. The tanks, the pyro-people with the flame throwers. I legit felt like Paul did, dead, after that movie.

One of the best films ever watched. It does sound better and realistic in German.

Should've watched it in German with subtitles. I learnt that lesson after going through Squid Game with the English dub.

@Lm-hm3kj

Жыл бұрын

But then you gotta read for three hours

@ghostface3140

Жыл бұрын

​@@Lm-hm3kj is it too hard for you to read?

@Yegallut

Жыл бұрын

@@ghostface3140 As VKunia mentioned, even today there are people who struggle to write and read.

@kessu1863

Жыл бұрын

@@Lm-hm3kj not a problem at all people who are from countries where they only do subtitles for movies have to read subtitles all the time.

@crunchylemon3811

Жыл бұрын

​@@Lm-hm3kj sounds like an excuse for being bad at reading

"He fell in October, 1918, on a day that was so quiet and still on the whole front, that the army report confined itself to the single sentence: All quiet on the Western Front"...

Bringing in morr recruits like that 15 minutes before the war ended is so horrible. Im atleast glad that young boy survived and had something to remember paul by as he wouldnt be alive without his help

That part where the French leader was all pooped up about the croissants not being fresh made me almost as mad as Kats senseless death. Fantastic movie and reaction.

@liamcurran6955

Жыл бұрын

Oh I thought it had something to do with the croissants possibly being poisoned, but you're probably right

@sniperniko

5 ай бұрын

Wut what crossaints

The score, and sound design for this was incredible. And the cinematography was superb, from the gritty war scenes to the calm, beautiful landscapes which provided a break from the war and some purely abstract studies with light that added dreamy quality. We saw this at home but I really wished we saw it in a theater.

I read the novel in 10th class (germany "gymnasium") and the scene when he stabbed the french and tried to save him afterwards was much more cruel there. They fought for life and death at first, then he stabbed the enemy, but in constrast to the movie where the scene was rather short, it took hours. Paul (the main character) was even sleeping in this artillery-crater this night before he got back. Furthermore the french man didnt die as quickly, he layed there for hours, gasping for air as he slowly bled out. And Paul heard that the entire time.

We need more strong men like this❤

When Paul first got the uniform, it originally belonged to a friend named "Heinrich", who was sent to fight and whose friend died. The name of the first user, namely "Heinrich Gubert", is written on the tag that the officer threw.

As well made as this version is, the 1930 version that won the Oscar for Best Picture and Best Director resonated with me because it almost looked like real combat footage made at the time. Plus that version has the character of Himmelstose, a kindly mailman who becomes a sadistic drill instructor, illustrating how war brings out the worst in people.

@AngryAlbertan

9 ай бұрын

I have seen all three the one from 1930 is also my favorite. one of the reasons for looking like real combat was because the director hired german combat troops as extras and had the main cast trained in the German style and tactics. The scene of the two arms on the wire was put into the film when one of the extras told the director how he saw it happen.

@AverageEnjoyer265

7 ай бұрын

Werent the actors in 1930 version real WW1 veterans? They got to act oit the things they saw and experienced for real.

@stevonwhite8933

3 ай бұрын

@@AverageEnjoyer265 Yep, many were.

What I really like about this story is it shows the times of lull as well, not just non stop fighting. Most of war is really just sitting around bored out of your mind. I forgot the exact quote but someone once said war is 90% sheer boredom filled with 10% terror.

The fact they didn’t grow older it just sad rest in peace for the people who fought in the war

Fun fact: even after 11 AM skirmishes still happened between armies, for example, a German sniper attacked a truck with french soldiers returning home, another is when fifty American soldiers charged at a German trench at 11:25. And yes, the general would in fact get in trouble, since he recieved orders not to attack and leave the men to enjoy their last minutes on the front,.plus he knew exactly well that his troops wouldn't be able to capture the territory in just 15 minutes

Thats why there is a saying, "War is young people dying, and old people talking".

@AuroraBea

3 ай бұрын

More like “taking” instead of “talking”

Goddammit I love “Remains”. Like I absolutely felt like it was a masterpiece of a composition, now I will only see it like that 😂😂😂😂

I'd never seen the 2022 version of this movie, didn't even know it existed until now. When I was a senior in High School, 1983, my history teacher made us all watch the 1979 version of this movie. It was very moving, I still remember watching it to this day, about 40 years later. You should watch the 1979 version.

@tbd-1

10 ай бұрын

Nothing beats the 1930 original. One of the great war/anti war movies of all time.

One of the best movies from 2022! It’s best in its original language, but the english dub isn’t the end of the world.

@onniel8318

Жыл бұрын

One of the worst tbh, it's a REMAKE of the old one + originally the story is from a book named "all quite on the western front" and as i studied the book, i hate the film for literally not making any sense, i mean it might look good, but it shouldn't be called by the same name as the book

@acdragonrider

Жыл бұрын

@@onniel8318 Disagree

@Sonof_DRN2004

8 ай бұрын

1979 version is superior imo. The only thing the 2022 one had better was the visuals.

And you have to remember this is what the war in Ukraine has become, trench warfare in some places.

@Real_NicoPlayer

Жыл бұрын

no warfare has changed a lot but it's similar but more mechanised.. and less messy

@Mercury_cougar_lover223

Жыл бұрын

@@Real_NicoPlayer we have men in mud filled trenches fighting over small amounts of land. It’s just WW1 with more modern uniforms and equipment, that’s it

@Marzelmusik

11 ай бұрын

@@Mercury_cougar_lover223 No! The scale of the fighting is very different. You have small platoons and groups fighting. There are not hundreds of men running across no mans land and getting mowed down by machine guns.

@Musabre

11 ай бұрын

@@Mercury_cougar_lover223 Tell me you know nothing about modern warfare without telling me, etc. No, modern 'trench' warfare is NOTHING like ww1. It's all much smaller scale tactical engagements with far more emphasis on mobility and technology. No-one is charging across fields into machineguns because it doesn't work in today's wars.

An easter egg is that the uniform that Paul Bäumer or the main character is using is the same uniform that the guy (Heinrich) used, i have a theory that he served frkm 1916 - 1917 and died late in the war, one year later like Paul Bäumer, basically like a curse.

I love how passionate you are

The” fire burning “ sound is what I love about The movie , it feels is so raw and it plays after every bad thing that shows what war is about happens , it’s like a “ see ,this is war “ kind of sound

Other "anti-war" WW movies I can recommend are *"Letters From Iwo Jima (2006)"* and *"The Eternal Zero (2013)".* Both from Japanese perspective. And please reupload your reaction to *"Grave of The Fireflies".* Thanks. 🙂🙏

@derrickowen8162

Жыл бұрын

Letters From Iwo Jima is such a great film! Haven't seen the other one though.

@petersvillage7447

Жыл бұрын

Does Come & See count as anti-war? I suppose not, despite depicting war as relentlessly atrocious. But that's not a film I recommend to anybody lightly...

@CloneByDesign

Жыл бұрын

@@petersvillage7447 Come and See left me feeling like the main character.

@driezzy

Жыл бұрын

Grave of the Fireflies is such a beautiful movie but so so sad.

I was 17 years old when I joined the army I went to basic right after high school to join the army infantry and I was happy and smiling. But when my first deployment came my first battle was in Fallujah and I was scared to death when I had bullets flying past me about 10in from my head. Than my adrenaline kicked in.

he first tanks were used in battle during World War I. The British were the first to deploy tanks in battle, at the Battle of the Somme in September 191612. The tank was originally designed as a special weapon to solve an unusual tactical situation: the stalemate of the trenches on the Western Front1. The great weakness of the tank predecessor, the armoured car, was that it required smooth terrain to move upon, and new developments were needed for cross-country capability1. The tank was intended to be able to protect against bullets and shell splinters, and pass through barbed wire in a way infantry units could not hope to, thus allowing the stalemate to be broken

Hi I just wanted to say i really love seeing your view and emotional connection to these films. As a British Veteran and now military historian it is really amazing to see that such films bring forward so many questions of war. Most are to either enthral or show horrors through violence but what all Quiet on the Western Front showed more arguably than any other is the emotional toll such activity plays on the average person

"I'm very excited to jump into it" Really setting yourself up for tears with that one

In movie's, I never cry, but I actually shed a small tear..

I love her explanation on the german hire ups as well, they really put to much pride in their country when the war was already a lost cause

VKunia I loved you reactions for years. I wish there were more people around as thoughtful as you. My great great uncle died in October 1918 in the Western Front and it had a massive impact on his family. He was in his 20s. Millions died like him for nothing. My grandfather died at the end of world War 2 because of tuberculosis caught in Italy, and never saw his son, my dad. This film teaches people they should not do this. Sadly humanity never learns. I love your heartfelt reactions and wish for better things for people.

I also had to cry a lot with this film , all these many young men who had lost their lives there. It hurt my heart. The film is played so realistically and you had a picture of how things had turned out on the war front in WWI. My grandfather fell as a young man in WWII at the Battle of Stalingrad/ Russia. Unfortunately we don`t know where he is buried there . It`s very sad.💞🙏 RIP

Good catch on wondering if they knew what tanks were - There's a good possibility not many of the new recruits did, which is why their first instinct was to start shooting at it. Tanks were invented by the British in 1915, but they were a closely guarded secret at the time, basically like the Manhattan project was during WWII. The British first utilized them in 1916. The French produced the most during the war, and first used them in mid 1917. Germany, in contrast, only ever deployed a grand total of 18 and didn't first use them until a few months before the war ended.

The most brutal thing that the german soldier Got crushed over by the first tanks is brutal

Glad you reacted to this. Kind of prefer seeing these foreign films with the original live dialogue in the particular language with English subtitles, but whatever floats your boat.

@Alex-kd5xc

Жыл бұрын

That’s especially true for me when it comes to war films. Can’t stand watching German or any other foreign soldiers speaking English.

@honkhonk8009

Жыл бұрын

Its kinda wierd saying "foreign films" yk? Like it aint really foreign. The voice acting is insanely good

The movie is actually very popular in germany

That thing they brake off the uniform was metal with their names on, to inform the leader from the group

Its been said multiple times but i feel films should be watched in their original language, dubbed versions are never as good. Loved this film, really shows the horror that is the meatgrinder of war.

@crapshot

Жыл бұрын

Then it's distracting. You can either concentrate on the images or the subtitles, never both.

@triviajjunie9896

Жыл бұрын

​@@crapshotmaybe you're the one who can't concentrate,,, I've been watching films in their original language all my life 💀

Watched it the first time in a theatre and it was the first time nobody was moving or saying anything during the credits. I had goosebumps all over my body.

when I watched this movie with my mom she was crying because they were all only a few years older than me. 34:30 it's not that Paul isn't afraid, he is they all are, in the book Remarque wrote "We have become wild beasts. We do not fight, we defend ourselves against annihilation." they are so full of fear that they fight in order to stay alive for it is the only option in combat. this fear turns to hate anger and rage. It is what allows a man to kill another. when the fear of death leaves them, they return to themselves, and it is why Paul can go from stabbing a man in the lung and to desperately trying to save him and begging his corpse to forgive him.

@scarfedman8144

5 ай бұрын

True, i also read it

I wish you watched it in the original German version with subtitles! But still a great reaction! I love how you understood the grim reality of Old Men tricking the younger generations to die for a war they know nothing about.

why the English dub tho

@kylemajerczyk8160

Жыл бұрын

I was thinking the same thing! 😂

@drewpaupanekis4710

Жыл бұрын

She can’t read, that’s why she watching foreign movies in English. She is dyslexic and can’t read properly, please be more respectful.

@the98themperoroftheholybri33

Жыл бұрын

Some people just don't enjoy subtitles

@acdragonrider

Жыл бұрын

@@the98themperoroftheholybri33 I never understand. I am an English speaker. Grew up with it as my first language but I watch all movies including English speaking ones I with subtitles

@Edninety

Жыл бұрын

I do agree and nowadays I definately prefer originals, but I'm also happy it enables people to watch movies they maybe wouldn't have touched otherwise. So yes to original, no to hatin' people because they like dub(s), not that I suggest you were hating though^^ In germany we mostly grew up with subs and If done right I'm totally fine with that existing. I might be a bit spoiled in that regard though, I'd argue we've got some really great voice actors here

Nice reaction! "Generation War" is a 3-episode series showing the German side of World War 2. I enjoyed it a lot!

Heyy Vicky New to the channel... this is great content 👏

Im watching this reaction months later, so don't know who im writing this for. Tanks were the most terrifying addition to the weaponry in world war I. They were designed and developed mid WW1 in the 1915s to 16s. They were designed pass trenches and kill anyone inside them. For the boys in this movie, tanks weren't even something they had imagined, and to see these unstoppable metal machines was for certain the most nightmarish situation.

what i learned long ago is that it seems all the best novels of war are the ones that show not only how absolutely horrible it is, but no matter how it changes and the circumstances, it's always the same. The feelings and utter destruction of the inner human that was and can never be again. Red Badge of Courage, All Quiet on the Western Front, For Whom the Bell Tolls, Homage to Catalonia and others. Great works, devastating works.

This one and the original 1930’s one both show really how bad war is without having a really good hero story. Instead of making Paul a cool badass war hero, it makes him a scared young boy. 10/10 remake in my opinion.

They didn’t know what it’s like it because that’s why they were so excited to do it but once you start doing the war you realize how scary and hard it is and that’s why are you figured out that you do not want to get into the warn you want to go back, but there’s no stopping it until the whole thing is over

Das hast du sehr gut gemacht. Ich hatte Tränen in den Augen...😢

I saw this film yesterday and I thought it was very good as well. The hardest part for me to watch was the scene in the shell crater. You are right that the movie is told in such a way that it is very personal compared to other movies. I remember reading the book a long time ago. Even though this film diverges from the book a lot, I thought they did a great job at recreating the sense of regular people being trapped in a horrible, neverending nightmare. Another good anti-war war film is The Thin Red Line about the Battle of Guadalcanal during WW2.

2 scenes stick with me. the recycling of uniforms. showing a little of the mundane logistics of waging war, but knowing each name patch is a son, father, brother, cousin... and kat's letter from his wife.

This movie does not make me cry it just makes me cold and depressed

The first one that was made had me in tears in the end because the one that survived at the end he was reaching out for a butterfly and one of the French saw him and he died:(

This version of the film is really good! If you are interested, you should check out the 1930 version, the extras are veterans of WW1 and did the battle and bootcamp scenes. For a 1930 film it's pretty graphic, very well done from start to finish.

Downfall (Der Untergang) is a good WW2 movie from the German perspective

„Fun“fact: General Asshole here, Hindenburg, was viewed as a hero in the broader German population and became later President of the first German republic, also called the Weimar Republic. He was the one, who appointed Hitler Chancellor and brought him to (legal) power. Just in case you need more reason to simply hate him. But only this year my hometown stopped calling a street after him („Hindenburgstraße“) and finally renamed it, because Hindenburg is viewed much more critically in Germany today than before. 😒

@paulb6154

11 күн бұрын

General Arschloch xD der war gut. :D

Those music notes are a death knell

If you want another one from the German perspective, you should watch "Das Boot" Director's cut (The Boat) in German with english subtitles. The best submarine movie ever imo.

In classical Western history, Hannibal was the last commander to do so. A big problem is that doing that risks losing your commander, which then tends to end the battle (if not the entire war) in defeat. See the Norman Conquest - when Harold was killed at Hastings, their success was all but guaranteed. Even at the tactical level, I was trained (by US Marines who taught “military” disciplines to sailors) that a LEADER should NOT be fighting: a leader should be observing, thinking and giving orders. In a large battle, often things are very confusing. Against a well organized peer enemy with enough forces to put up a good fight, often the best a general can do is either decide when (and perhaps where) to commit his reserves, or when to give up the fight and retreat to preserve his forces from being routed. Contrary to a lot of assumptions about modern warfare, skilled Western troops ARE taught to retreat, it is not entirely about dishing it out in a one sided contest. We have had an easy time for a long time in high tech warfare - but it is unclear we can dominate it against a peer. [A DoD review finds we may well lose against a peer opponent] I remember suspending air operations because we lost every tactical action we engaged in. I participated in a naval battle you never heard of directly which was a strategic defeat: you DID hear about the Army “incursion into Cambodia” to block enemy supply lines - but no one told you it was because the Navy FAILED to cut those lines by sea. We suffered another STRATEGIC naval defeat at the hands of Iraq in the “first” Gulf War - to its mine warfare campaign. [Saddam executed every service chief except the Navy one - since he had done his job successfully, preventing the Marines from coming in along the coast] A famous consultant and simulations expert thinks 1945 vintage Japanese propeller plans could deliver ordnance against our ships today. I - a Navy air defense specialist - think he might be right. Things can go very wrong - and the boss of a fight needs to be somewhere he can get good information and figure out what it means as soon as possible. The idea of the boss going in with the troops is close to idiotic - too counterproductive to contemplate seriously.

Watched this with my family yesterday

Adrian Carton De Wiart: "Frankly, I enjoyed the war."

Winner of 4 Oscars: Best International Film Best Original Score Beat Production Design Best Cinematography

@PlumbPitiful

Жыл бұрын

The 1930 version won two Oscars; Best Picture & Best Director

@acdragonrider

Жыл бұрын

@@PlumbPitiful EEAAO was hogging the others

I already seen this review earlier and I have to say All Quiet on The Western Front was one of my highest recommended films. I have been trying to get my family to understand what my experiences were like while I was in service. I may have been a different field but it catches all the emotions and depravity. If you enjoyed this movie, I recommend watching Das Boot. It’s another anti war film that is closer to my experience as a Submariner. It’s funny that over 100 years nothing has changed. It literally has changed my world belief and made me into an Anarchist. People like General Friedrich should never have power like that nor anyone else. Unfortunately also Matthias Erzberger was assassinated because of the Armistice. It was horrible that WW1 was what paved the way for WW2.

22:37 - And for good reason. Tanks weren't widely deployed and after so long of nothing but grindingly slow warfare, seeing an armored behemoth just waltz through no man's land like was nothing while cutting down anyone in its way is fucking terrifying.

The recruit at the end of the movie collecting tags wasn’t one of Paul’s friends. When Paul storms the trenches and shoots the Frenchman in the head before jumping on the next one, the German on the ground about to be shot is saved by Paul killing the French soldier. So when he sees Paul dead he just kinda stops from shock