Found this recording on Archive.org listed as "The Microphones Live at Belmont on 2001-02-26" and felt compelled to upload it since there are very few live recordings of Phil singing both songs back to back. The person who archived it claims this is from the Golden Shoulders tour, featuring Karl Blau and Kyle Field. I have tried to find more information about this tour and confirm this date but haven't had much luck. If anyone else has information on this or is more in the know, let me know!
Image is from the Wikipedia page of The Glow Pt. 2
Archive.org features a ton of other Microphones and Mt. Eerie recordings that I can't find anywhere else, so I might upload some of those too since way more people use KZread.