Hope you liked the video!! For car buying doubts, connect with our Auto-Experts over a phone call for unbiased car recommendations that suit your requirements. For faster communication drop a “Hi” on this WhatsApp link wa.me/918779952811 You can also book your call by clicking on this link and submitting your queries: motoroctane.com/car-consultancy

@kumarsunny7636

8 ай бұрын

i guess hundai exter gives 15inch tires not 16inch.

@saurabhahuja5102

8 ай бұрын

you missed citroen c3..BTW, fantastic review.

@motoroctane

8 ай бұрын

Talk had an error - we fixed it in the text.

@puneetpathak8490

8 ай бұрын

Waiting for new seltos comparo

@hp8319

8 ай бұрын

True

Kiger and magnite r the best out of all them when it comes to design price and comfort

@umairarifshaikh5095

2 ай бұрын

And safety.

@netke6177

2 ай бұрын

4 star ⭐⭐⭐⭐

@Newbieee69

Ай бұрын

Fronx design>

Nissan magnite- stylish, comfortable and safe. 🔥🔥🔥

@kirankvk6666

2 ай бұрын

What about engine performance?

@kethavathkishore2892

2 ай бұрын

​@@kirankvk6666what about safety 😅 broh

@sakshiarora3475

2 ай бұрын

Reliability?

@HAMMAAD247

2 ай бұрын

@@kethavathkishore2892 bro it has 4 star safety rating 😄

@kethavathkishore2892

2 ай бұрын

@@HAMMAAD247 I know broh iam ask this who say about performance

Nissan magnite got an update in end 2022 which got a shark fin antenna and a trumpet horn. Renault Kiger was given a dual horn set up in 2022.

This is the Ultimate comparison, most of the doubts are cleared, only motor octane can do this. Thankyou

Excellent Video 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 Thankyou MotorOctane for this type of best comparison

This may help if you have priorites : Tata Punch - Safety Hyundai Exter - Features Nissan magnite - Value for Money Suzuki Fronx - Mileage Renault Kiger - Design Language

@rudraakshchauhan1172

8 ай бұрын

And maintainance too

@rohittanwar6255

8 ай бұрын

Right mintinace bhi bta do kiski kaam hai

@1234kenekiii

8 ай бұрын

​@@rohittanwar6255suzuki

@pritom21

8 ай бұрын

Maruti Suzuki Fronx - engine performance, mileage, features, design etc

@jaishreeram9746

8 ай бұрын

​@@pritom21 Maruti matlab Mautkasaman

beautifully presented and awesome intro nice work motoroctane

Finally a decent comparison.. also a correction, Magnite has Shark finn antena..

Only motor octane have real fellings for middle class family's 😊❤❤❤

If you look at average ratings across all areas kiger and magnite scores well. Also gncap is done for base variants of these cars . So there will be definitely better safety now because in kiger (since 2023)there is Hill start assist, ESP, tpms, traction control across all variants and side airbags from rxt variant. Also isofix is present in top variants which will improve child safety rating as well. But unfortunately kiger sales are low in numbers because people doesn’t understand the value for money it offers

@tejasgosai8949

8 ай бұрын

Kiger is best option from all above. But with turbo. NA is not enough for car this big.

@Suvik6198

8 ай бұрын

@@tejasgosai8949 I did test drive of NA as well . If its city commute mostly and rarely highways/hill stations, even NA is good. Quick overtakes are not possible. But serves the purpose at a really good price point. Turbo ticks all the boxes.

@GarryThakur07

8 ай бұрын

It's not the people, it's the brand which is responsible. At the time of duster, renault was crazy hit but they didn't upgrade their flagship vehicle PLUS rest of the cars they introduced were full of crap. Their after sales was trash and the parts were mostly out of stock. Instead of building on a promising thing they treated indian market like shit while hyundai and maruti always retained their customer. That's why these 2 lead the market share in india.

@sona4575

8 ай бұрын

Kiger need 1200 cc engine & then increase sell this car

@lals8438

8 ай бұрын

Kiger ❤

magnite and kiger are subcompact SUV segment while punch and exter are micro SUVs. It is like comparing venue to seltos and creta !!

@bugbuggy3866

8 ай бұрын

Dude, they are in same price range, why on earth will you buy a micro SUV when you can buy a compact SUV at same price ? Only fronx is very overpriced.

@prvkm7

8 ай бұрын

price bracket

@prvkm7

8 ай бұрын

price bracket

Nissan magnite is an underrated car. It's CVT Turbo variant is better than punch, and even nexon AMT when it comes to the smoothness.

@pistonhead05

8 ай бұрын

Yes bro but people are afraid that they are not updating it so they might be leaving soon

@bugbuggy3866

8 ай бұрын

@@pistonhead05 these Japanese brands don't advertise much. They let the quality speak for itself. But if people not aware, they won't buy. Same is the case with Honda. They have just 2 vehicles in portfolio. E.g. I have driven WRV of my mamaji. Its a bit underpowered but man the space management and comfort it gives is amazing. Not to forget the engine refinement, no one comes even close to that. It seems as if I am driving an EV. Doesn't even make a slight sound, inside or outside.

@nomanland5752

8 ай бұрын

Turbo with small engine

@bugbuggy3866

8 ай бұрын

Have you driven one ? @@nomanland5752 That small turbo engine is more than enough to kick the ass of Venue or Nexon. Watch the drag race on auto car channel between magnite turbo and venue turbo

@abisabis7011

8 ай бұрын

Nissan automatic is best . But their non-turbo engine is 999 cc with 72bhp.

In my Magnite XV Premium CVT Sharkfin antenna is given.

Most awaited comparison 🙌🏻

Excellent Video, thank you Rachith for clearing confusions

Superb non-biased video. Clearly showing the highlights and lowlights of each of these cars. Thank you @motoroctane Rachit for making this fantastic comparo

@AnishRaii27

8 ай бұрын

Non biased? Paid promotions krta hai wo

@atulkalkhuria4405

3 ай бұрын

@rohit Kya mst joke Mara re baba 😂😂😂

This video will break all your channel's records. Fastest growing. 👍👍

Nice video as usual. Should've added Citroen c3 as well

As always, great video Rachit and team.

very good detailed long video review; i am sure it took a lot of efforts to come up with this video, good work ☺

Punch is now available with sunroof, front armrest, shark finn antenna, iTPMS, express cooling, additional charging ports, etc

@deepmalde9448

8 ай бұрын

Is Hill Hold Control and Electronic Stability Program available in Punch?

@aryamannreddy4848

8 ай бұрын

@@deepmalde9448no

@trainsbyanvesh

8 ай бұрын

​@@deepmalde9448features are just made to attract people isko segment mai hai koi jo 5star safety laaa pai

@abhijeetgalphat9502

8 ай бұрын

@@deepmalde9448 electronic stability program available but Hill start assist is missing, they should have added HSA.

@indom2964

8 ай бұрын

​@@abhijeetgalphat9502i love tata punch

Anyhow content of Motoroctane was unbeatable💯and of course rachit bhiya you nailed it 😎

Nice with detailed explanation.

woww!!❤❤ I was waiting for this video ❤❤ Thank you ❤😊

My most favorite & recommend cars in this list:- 1. Tata Punch 2. Nissan Magnite

Holy crap, what a thorough video man. Really props to you!

Presentation of motoroctane is very good nd different from other...try to cover all aspects...❤

Which is the best car for a short person? (5ft)

Hi Rachit, as usual your analysis was bang on unlike others who I feel are biased, you on other hand gave a clear visibility on pros and cons. Just one point where I diagree was Hyundai Exter scoring 4 to 5 stars on global NCAP test as platform remains same as that of i10.

@GauravKumar-xf2iy

8 ай бұрын

It's not what he feels, it's what Hyundai has said while launching the Exter. He is just echoing that. Both may have the same platform but overall design language can change the scores drastically. Like, for example, both Renault Kiger & Nissan Magnite share the same platform and scored 4 stars, but the Kiger's bodyshell integrity was rated UNSTABLE, and STABLE for Magnite. PS: Even I don't have high hopes for Exter.

@cyzefx

8 ай бұрын

Exter has got compulsory 6 airbags this might help to get some points as an appreciation from the gncap

@nikhilvijay6022

7 ай бұрын

But the platform is a key decision maker & its definitely not a stable one.

@haraharamahadev6976

5 ай бұрын

Exter koi mat lo bhai. Mene kharidi thi. Abhi Diwali me uska accident hua. Bhai sahab, sirf 15-16 ki 1st gear wale speed se hi hua, bas samne wale ek gadi ko corner ki oor se thuk gayi. Bas itna sa accident hua par iss gadi ka engine tak khatam ho chuka hai. Ab total loss me ja rahi wo. Puri chapak gayi thi samne se. Bhai sirf 15-16 ki speed pe itna jyada impact ho raha hai to jyada speed pe kya hoga?

@merajeev007

5 ай бұрын

I think it wall score a 4 or 5 cos Hyundai is now giving 6 airbags as standard across all models

Hi can you provide the comparison videos of Tata punch accomplished S manual and Hyundai exter SX manual?

great review, very well done ,great comparison ,please keep it up

Kiger looks the best of all.... wish it came with a bigger engine

@sudarshangs4235

8 ай бұрын

of course not. Magnite is the real looker.

@Suvik6198

6 ай бұрын

I have 1.0l turbo. It never feels underpowered in any manner

@dr.nikhilkurian

5 ай бұрын

We have kiger turbo CVT.. engine is no way underpowered

Very good comparison, different aspects covered very well. Personally, i did find the video little biased towards Exter, but thats my personal take and i may be wrong. Overall i love your maha comparisons...they clear many doubts. Keep up the good work! Cheers!

@stevencharles8421

8 ай бұрын

You are right it is heavily biased

@sharayupatki617

8 ай бұрын

Totally biased

@ayushpathak8671

7 ай бұрын

Fr exter is getting biased its small af

@Ko-gp2qi

5 ай бұрын

Yes

Hey Rachit your intro is always 🔥🔥

Sir ek request aap boht achi info provide krate h But Cars ki style or looking se jyada target 🎯uski toughness or engine performance p details btaye plzzzz

Reliability, enginee refinement, after sales service, resale value, quality of fit and finish should also be included in the comparasion.

@Marshall_Law

5 ай бұрын

After sales depends on area to area so it's not worth to add this for comparison

Very Nice and authenticate review. Most remarkable car is NISSAN MIGNITE. BBB. safety with features and Budgeted. Specially Turbo MT.

Which one is the best of all in after-sales services?

U r too Good Bhaiya 👌👌 Awesome video 😍😍

I have a Renault Kiger. Highly underrated car. Its one of the best cars out there but unfortunately not so popular

@games1565

8 ай бұрын

most if the parts are plastic and fragile.

@Zer0-0

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, let's see 2 years later, I'm sure you won't be so happy

@Suvik6198

6 ай бұрын

@@Zer0-0 do you have a kiger. Is that why you are sure ??

I relief stress by watching your videos

Fantastic explanation 🎉

It is a treat to watch your video ❤

Kiger and Fronx for looks! 👍

Didn't know Magnite's head lamps are best!

Great job team. Was really helpful 🎉

This is the shortest maha compairison i have ever watched 😊

@Motoroctane team please compare 2nd base model of these cars so that normal middle class person can get a proper comparison, these top models are costly and confuses people like me who only see minimal features

The EX, EX(O), S and S (O) variants come with 165/70 R14 tyres, while the SX, SX (O) and SX (O) Connect variants come with larger 175/65 R15 tyres

@haraharamahadev6976

5 ай бұрын

Exter koi mat lo bhai. Mene kharidi thi. Abhi Diwali me uska accident hua. Bhai sahab, sirf 15-16 ki 1st gear wale speed se hi hua, bas samne wale ek gadi ko corner ki oor se thuk gayi. Bas itna sa accident hua par iss gadi ka engine tak khatam ho chuka hai. Ab total loss me ja rahi wo. Puri chapak gayi thi samne se. Bhai sirf 15-16 ki speed pe itna jyada impact ho raha hai to jyada speed pe kya hoga?

@vineetverma8664

5 ай бұрын

@@haraharamahadev6976 air bags khule the???

@haraharamahadev6976

5 ай бұрын

@@vineetverma8664 nahi

@asifmujawar3442

3 ай бұрын

​@@haraharamahadev6976fronx ka ek truck ke saath aur tractor ke saath bhi accident ho chuka hai KZread pur video bhi hai fronx se zada truck aur tractor ki halat kharab lagrahi hai tractor me Jo Banda tha use major injury aayi hai jab ki fronx ke charo passangers safe hai

Motoroctane.... Do you think kiger and magnite would upgrade themselves with sunroof in future due to competition?

@motoroctane pls do once again for these cars with AMT version, non turbo. Also mention spare wheel tyre sizes.

Magnite is best ❤️

Non Turbo me Delta Plus is the best choice cause it's also most Value for Money varient

comparision among Nexon CNG , Brezza CNG , Hundai Venue and KIA Seltos. Please Help

Ab tak ki sabse achi collection video hai ye love ❤❤❤ 🎉

Ranking based on this review 1. Nissan Magnite (no doubt all rounder with turbo) 2. Renault Kiger (Trying to catch Nissan) 3. Punch (proper micro SUV, Safety , twin cylinder CNG) 4. Fronx (Everything is good except Safety yet to be tested) 5. Exter (Jack of all trades, Safety yet to be tested)

@a_RedClaw

8 ай бұрын

Should have added Kia Sonet too

@hindustanmerijaan7761

8 ай бұрын

@@a_RedClawthis all r hatchback and sonet is compact mini suv

@PrinceKaria

8 ай бұрын

Magnite is best ♥️

@princedabhi7865

7 ай бұрын

​@@hindustanmerijaan7761 can you suggest best car under 10 Lakh , I've selected fronx delta variant but I'm still not sure about it

@hindustanmerijaan7761

7 ай бұрын

@@princedabhi7865 suzuki worst quality bro, i will suggest u nissan magnite japanies car will never disappoint u, or either go for tata altroz best indian car company (ASLI LOOHA)🙌

❤ Only motoroctane can do this ... ❤ for us❤

Punch heading for newer heights. Top seller in 6 months

Great video ❤

Kya feature mai Mahindra TUV300 ya kahe Bolero Neo mai Diesel Engine ko hata k Petrol Engine la sakte hai

2:25 Exter comes with 15 inch if I am not wrong !?

@motoroctane

8 ай бұрын

Yes you are correct - it was a human error. We have mentioned it in the text there.

Tata Punch and Hyundai Exter fulfill all the necessary demand. So both are Segments best two cars.❤️

@SharkFishSF

8 ай бұрын

Punch is lunch in front of exter

@lakhankatare7630

8 ай бұрын

@@SharkFishSF Jaha dekho waha Tata Fans vs Hyundai Fans bhara pada hai. Koi reality bhi bole to gyaan dene aa jate hai.

@sudarshangs4235

8 ай бұрын

I test rode Exter and it feels like a slighty more beefy Wagon R

Excellent bro❤

Bhai tumare hisab se apollo cross ke new tyre creta mai lagya hai kuch gadbad toh nahi hoga nA Mai Bridgestone laga ne wala tha

Me bought Kiger 2 months back since it provides the best VFM with the features it comes with. Amazing pickup and excellent space for 5 (ironically it looks very small from outside). All necessary features with decent 4 start GNCAP. I got last year's dual tone Turbo (MT) top model for just 10.25L on road (along with full tank petrol+body cover+floor mat+mud flaps). None of the others can give so much except Magnite. Biggest dissappointment was fronx. The showroom guy gave a quote of 12L (that too with a BH series number) which is soo inflated.

@nikhilbhati339

8 ай бұрын

I too bought 2 months ago last year's model in 9.4 on road non turbo dual tone rxz it's value for money no doubt about it

@bugbuggy3866

8 ай бұрын

awesome bro. Even my friend has non turbo and he is happy with the power, he has driven about 30k KMs in 1 year. Not everyone is interested in drag racing. Non turbo is more than enough for city and highways. @@nikhilbhati339

@jomyjohn8175

8 ай бұрын

I bought mine RXZ CVT two months ago for 12.6

@sreejithr.g.8151

8 ай бұрын

its really a VFM car

@rdcal

8 ай бұрын

@@jomyjohn8175 how much mileage you are getting in city

Fronx is in a segment of its own These other cars are all micro SUVs while fronx is a coupe suv or even a premium raised hatchback So comparing fronx with these cars is really useless

@1234kenekiii

8 ай бұрын

Your comment doesn't make sense. These all hackbacks belong to same segment. The point you are trying to make is invalid.

@hutashankaushik6782

8 ай бұрын

Magnite doesn't belong to this segment...it's length boot are even in line with brezza

@justlikethat8213

8 ай бұрын

Just check the dimensions of Magnite. It is more than any other car in this video.

@armaangirdhar5549

8 ай бұрын

Fronx tatti

@abisabis7011

8 ай бұрын

Fronx comes in crossover . Whereas others micro suv. They should have included ignis and citroen c3.

Long waiting completed🙏👍❤️

This is the video is wanted I wanted to see. We at home already own one of the cars shown in this video. Generally like watching car comparisons and reviews 😁😁

@mohankumarbalakrishnan8048

3 ай бұрын

Which car?

only those who knows about the smoothness of cvt will go Magnite. not really bad in sales number. it having 2500+ sale per month now. About get my CVT Turbo on this Friday

@abhiramdeshmukh1

7 ай бұрын

Totally agree,love my magnite CVT

@aldrinpabraham6932

7 ай бұрын

It's good as a combo but the turbo engine is better in fronx but it's quite pricey

@NA-so5by

7 ай бұрын

​@@aldrinpabraham6932 Indeed, that's the key and the undisclosed strategy behind Nissan's sustenance in the Indian market with just one vehicle. When you focus solely on the engine, you'll find other brands with superior engines, but none can offer the holistic package that the Magnite provides.

Being a Kiger owner with non-turbo engine, I have never felt any issues while driving in hills. I have driven the car across western ghats of south India. Trust me the car is superb. In the Maha comparison, I would love to move towards Exter but the NCAP rating is yet to be produced and top of that it has some suspension issue too once the car is fully loaded.

@prasanthracerz

8 ай бұрын

Me to bro ❤ kiger non turbo owner its ture

@saraswatrahul73

7 ай бұрын

Exactly brother kiger is best in segment ❤

@viralfever2665

5 ай бұрын

I have heard kiger is best in segment price wise but after some years inbuilt quality specially hard plastic makes noise n losses ?

Rachit Bhai one video on venue vs fronx pls not available on whole KZread

Superb video bro.. I am little bit confused between punch and exter..

Basically Video made to make baised review for Exter against much better rivals. Kiger & Fronx are much better than Exter. Too bad by motor octane.

Thank you for information about my fav car Nissan magnite ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ value for money car Nissan magnite

The latest punch does not have sharkfin? Thats a bummer. Aftermarket ones are available so have to switch for looks.

Thanks sir I am buying exter on 15th October. Very excited

Bhai har mahacomperision me ek winner 🏆 bata Diya kariye please 🙏. Mere hisab se punch and magnite winner hai ❤❤❤

Exter is budget friendly hope it gets 3 to 5 star safety rating and arm rest and upgraded engine

@abisabis7011

7 ай бұрын

wont get more than 2. Based on Nios platform

@aldrinpabraham6932

7 ай бұрын

It can get almost 5 stars as its almost as heavy as punch

@aldrinpabraham6932

7 ай бұрын

​@abisabis7011 nios platform yes but it's actually not the platform that made the nios unsafe. Lots of corners were cut on the nios while they are now making amends with the nios

@Amit-mt8eo

2 ай бұрын

4 star safety rating❤

bohot mehnat se video bnayi hai bro....hatts of to you and team...lots of love

very nice, thank you

Nissan should offer turbo in xe variant, xe offers most feature in the segment it only lacks in engine department, i mean they can charge extra 10 to 20k for it on top of 1 lakh premiun they ask for turbo but i think it would be worth it

Great video … but don’t trust on Hyundai about NCAP rating … anybody can expect 4-5 rating about their new car but in reality may be its way less than that …. They need to prove it first in NCAP test

Thanks for video।।ek video se sara confusion dur

C3 ka bhi comparison karlo! With headlamp comparison as well!

Wonderfully crafted comparison. Just one change - Exter has 15 inches wheels not 16. Hope you'll consider this in your next video. Thank you.

@motoroctane

8 ай бұрын

🙏🏻

Punch and magnite 😊

Sir please which cng car extreme kushning comfort in bed road fronx, exter or brezza ?

Excellent comparison

Wrong information.. Exter mai small tyres aate hai.. Inn sabke comparison mai 💀

@krushnadhanne472

8 ай бұрын

sahi bola

@smarty_ujjwal2881

8 ай бұрын

Bhai motoroctane Wale paid promotion krte h

@pritamkanire585

8 ай бұрын

​@@smarty_ujjwal2881Roji roti ka swal hai😂

@myfilmyshow4463

8 ай бұрын

Naam badal ke bika hua octane rakh do😂😂

@pritamkanire585

8 ай бұрын

@@myfilmyshow4463 Dalal bolo

Punch needed a much punchy engine than new features

I20 vs Baleno vs Fronx vs Altroz kaa detailed comparison video bhi banaiye sir.😊

What a comparison. Superb

Wow very informative video and thanks for combining vived information in one video. I was looking for only this kind of video So thanks Motor Octane team!!. Although i almost compared all these cars since last few months and finalized Kiger atlast. In the end i had to decide between Exter and Kiger and felt few points - that exter has tyre size R14-15. And top varient is bit overpriced but Kiger has R16 and top varient under 10lac with all features. - Although if u compare interior of i20 or venue then thr interior feels more premium then Exter whose interior i found is similar to Kiger in quality. - suspension wise Exter is smooth and better than Kiger.

@vivshij1349

8 ай бұрын

Good study! Go for Exter if you prefer: The slightly smaller and boxier design. More premium interiors. Sunroof option. (Cons: safety is still a ? although having more airbags. The design is not so pleasing to many. Need to go for the highest variant if u wanna enjoy all the features) Go for Kiger if you prefer: Assured safety/built quality. Bigger and more stylish. Handling and driving quality very well suited to Indian roads. Wide range of variants to suit budget buyers. (Cons: not-so-premium interiors. No sunroof option. Engine noise. Poor AC.)

@aldrinpabraham6932

7 ай бұрын

​@@vivshij1349highest variant is pretty cheap

I dont understand why Indian consumers demand for sunroof and not for dashcams.

@sripadhulakshman4804

2 ай бұрын

Because we look to the skies and dream❤

Very good vedio. Lot of hardworking done really appreciable

Bhai ne Voiceover sote hue kia hai Ek dum relaxed e

Im a big fan of Kiger nd Magnite, im afraid of the service cost nd mileage issues😬

@nazneensaeedsaeed165

8 ай бұрын

Service cost is minimal too the issue is they take time to provide u service

@sssdctn4009

5 ай бұрын

Service cost is comparable to Hyundai

I have magnite cvt turbo, best automatic i have driven , fun to drive car, can do everything highway or city no problem at all. milage upto 18-20 is fairly attainable on highway,12 in city. but best part is transmission.

@sanem2555

5 ай бұрын

Absolutely. I too own Magnite Turbo CVT XV premium. So far so good.

sir sabhi cars ki base model ki video bhi banaiye.