Support anonymity on the internet by trying out Atlas VPN. Get Atlas VPN 3-year offer with a 82% discount: get.atlasvpn.com/Eastory

@junescott7290

Жыл бұрын

i did

@wow-roblox8370

Жыл бұрын

Are you going to pin this comment?

@junescott7290

Жыл бұрын

@@wow-roblox8370 he shud

@Kristof1

Жыл бұрын

oi pin this comment mate

@takasmaka820

Жыл бұрын

RuSSia is like Nazi Germany in 1945

It feels strange to transition from watching your WW2 stuff to something ongoing. Thanks for this comprehensive account for the events up to now.

@DaveSCameron

Жыл бұрын

Except I've not seen him lie regarding WW2 like he does about this!

@kommy-

Жыл бұрын

@@DaveSCameron What is he lying about?

@Christian-rj2yc

Жыл бұрын

@@DaveSCameron Example?

@DaveSCameron

Жыл бұрын

@@kommy- The intended operation by Russia, thats all!

@johnsmith1474

Жыл бұрын

It's the opposite of comprehensive, it's pure bullshit.

I look forward to you taking a look at this war in the future with divisional symbols like you did in your other map based analysis.

@MultiWhatever007

Жыл бұрын

Gonna be a long while since so much is classified, and also because of Ukraine using some militia formations mixed in with regular army brigades, while Russia uses god knows what between the actual army units, donbass militias, PMCs, Rosgvardiya units, Kadyrov's personal retinue, etc.

@blenderslawblender689

Жыл бұрын

@@MultiWhatever007 Almost same thing happened in II WW

@gavindodd133

Жыл бұрын

Ooh I can’t wait for that, it’ll take a while though.

@just1it1moko

Жыл бұрын

same. a lot of it is gonna be speculation until the war is over and both sides can give their give their perspective. despite it being a horrible conflict and my thoughts go out to everyone that got affected it is interesting to see warfare on this scale. makes you wonder what people back home heard during WW2 especially since information was way harder to share and verify.

@abdiabdi3225

Жыл бұрын

@@blenderslawblender689 yes but it has been 7 decades and so much is public knowledge at this point making it a lot easier to say this and this happened while this war will not be so easy.

9:20 I disagree with your comment about the Russians "not realizing they could cross the river". It really understates what happened. They tried, several times, and were bloodily repulsed on each occasion. It wasn't until at least 2 BTGs were pretty much gutted that they stopped trying.

@G.A.C_Preserve

Жыл бұрын

Which is essentially what he said They realized that they couldn't cross the river

@noobmansuperstarboy

Жыл бұрын

So eastory was right? Are you smoking crack?

@user-db5zc1nf4b

Жыл бұрын

Not 3 btg but yes like 55-70 cars

@Dragonite43

Жыл бұрын

I think he should've rephrased it to say, "Russians attempted to cross the river, but meant heavy resistances from the Ukrainians." With the way he currently phase it, it sounds like they couldn't cross because of lack of bridges or logistical reasons.

@nicholasconder4703

Жыл бұрын

@@Dragonite43 To me it sounded more like they took one look at the river and decided to not even try crossing it.

Important parts of the struggle that you did not include are terrain and weather. Northern Ukraine is full of forests and hills, making it hard to maneuver with heavy equipment there and easier to defend. While southeast is basically one huge steppe, offensive there was so successful in big part due to place being just a half empty fields with few key points and no natural borders, Donetsk frontline could catch up on some defensible positions, so it stands, in Luhansk there was nowhere to stand the ground for the most part, so russians were able to quickly push for huge chunk of land until they were stalled at the first defence line. War is also turned from the ambush slaughterfest to the classic frontlines struggle because seasons changed. In the early spring all ground was essentially just a mud, you couldn't traverse whenever you want, you'll get bogged, so russians were forced to move almost exclusively by the roads. So combined with foresty terrain in the north this resulted in the astonishing casualties for russian forces there due to guerilla warfare.

@nvelsen1975

Жыл бұрын

Plus judging by what happened, Russia never did proper recon. It used to be one of my jobs, satrecon. Not a specialist mind you. Still, stunned at how dumb Russia was, I did the work. It took me about two hours to scout by satelite one of the routes from Belarus to Kiyv, identify boggy or difficult terrain for scouts to mark and maps to show, to identify some points of ambush and whip up a rough road capacity estimate with the locations of chokepoints. Implying that somehow, Russia that prepared this war for years, didn't do that.... It's really hard to explain how we know from them building bases that they prepared for years, but yet something you STILL can do even if you tell your analysts only 1 day in advance, Russia did not do.

@romualdcaffeserre6230

Жыл бұрын

@@nvelsen1975 Hmmmm, I think the explanation is actually pretty simple. Recon was made, the higher ups just didnt gave a shit about the result of that recon. Think about it, the higher ups (a.k.a putin and his crew) had already decided to invade ukraine, and were sniffing their own propaganda about how strong and powerfull the russian army is and how swift victory would be. In those circumstances, any reports that claimed the task ahead would be difficult for the russian army was ignored or ridiculed. After all, we know at this point Putin seriously thought the ukrainian resistance would be symbolical at best, and launched an attack on Kyiv in hope of capturing the capital immediatly. Why bother read some reports about the danger of a strat when you think the ennemy is going to instantly surrender?

@trevorsomers8344

Жыл бұрын

I just think the Russian military is shit

@nvelsen1975

Жыл бұрын

@@romualdcaffeserre6230 That's true, but on a level of stupid where common sense would say "Naah, nobody's that dumb, dig deeper". That's why it puzzled me: All possible explanations are so stupid they shouldn't be true.

@VCE4

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, pretty important parts that was missed in the video

Hello everyone, I'm from Kharkiv. I remember well the morning when the war started. The roar of multiple launch rocket systems, civil defense sirens, people in huge lines, someone just grabs children and puts them in cars, forgetting things right next to them. I sealed the windows with tape and turned on the TV. By evening, the city seemed to have died out, garbage that was not taken out was rolling around in the wind, only ambulances and military equipment on the avenues, Russian planes bomb factories multiple time, miss. My high-rise building was cowardly like cardboard. The whole next week there were heavy street battles, machine guns, grenade launchers, mortars, a couple of "Urals" drove into the very center of the city (as if then a computer game where you need to capture the point)

@Krusesensei

Жыл бұрын

U are still in the city? Good luck to you!

@DaveSCameron

Жыл бұрын

And surprise surprise you're still a part of the Ukraine, c'mon people invading and overtaking Ukraine was NEVER the intention if only you shared the truth?

@johnsmith1474

Жыл бұрын

Gee your memory works all the way back to February, you are quite the guy!

@odeboy6659

Жыл бұрын

@@DaveSCameron You do know the Russians are planning to hold referendums on joining Russia in the occupied southern regions? They are already making the ballots for it and they got propaganda posters up proclaiming that Ukrainians and Russians are one people.

@AlreadyTakenTag

Жыл бұрын

Just asking. Do you still live there or have you evacuated? If you have decided to stay I hope you are doing your part in defending your nation (if not on the frontlines then on the homefront which is important as well)

As Ukrainian, I can find a lot of small nitpicks, but then video would be longer to explain everything, much much longer. As a simplified version of events this video is good. Broadly explains events of the war from strategic point of view, good enough for its length.

@alabin3471

Жыл бұрын

Would really want to see you make a video where you point them out.

@Cortesevasive

Жыл бұрын

How does being Ukrainian makes you an expert ? , I would rather trust russian.

@alexanderflemming6788

Жыл бұрын

@@Cortesevasive ah yes. COMRAD I AM GLAD YOU ASKED LET ME TELL YOU. THAT 1. WE HAVE DESRTROYED THE HIMARS THE AMERICAN IMPERIALISTS GAVE TO UKRAINE. As you can tell by very bad footage that you can't even tell if it was a HIMAR and then an explosion which missed what they were aiming for. Or the other time where you can't make out what it was again but this time there was an explosion that was only record behind a hill so we can't see what it was. Or the reason POW incident where Russia said it was done by HIMARs except from there was to little damage for any type of missile that was fired from a HIMAR but instead rounds from a motor or other artillery. As well as the fact that the day light proves it was done from Russia as the daylight that can be seen is pointing towards Russia through a destroyed wall. Or the fact that "MIGHTY RUSSIA HAS DESTROYED ENTIRE UKRAINIAN AIR FORCE" multiple times other when in reality they haven't and Ukraine still has planes and helicopters in the sky. As well as many many more so Russia shouldn't be believed mostly when they are only allowed to consume Pro-Russian forces obviously Ukraine is still biased but they can at least read Pro-russian and pro-ukrainian sources without persecution and make up their mind about things. As well as Russians do believe these things as they aren't allowed to read non-Russian sources and that it was pro-russian sources say.

@somerandomboibackup6086

Жыл бұрын

@@Cortesevasive Because Ukrainians witness more of the war than Russians genius

@Cortesevasive

Жыл бұрын

@@alexanderflemming6788 Thats speculative and subjective mate. It could be either way. What makes you an expert on Himar damage on buildings or the angle they hit or the damage they do? . What ? some conveniently intercepted call xD between russians once again admiting to war crimes.. ? Cmon Ukrainians have no real aircraft left there, its the country size of two Poland sure they gonna have something left in a garage or some spares or some soviet stockpile but mostly Polish old stock which comes through border, but its still irrelevant amounts Also arent russian channels and prorussian parties banned in Ukraine? what sort of liberty are you talking about mate? If they had any liberty in them they would let Donbas have referendum these regions are like 80percent russian, who do you think they would side with?.

it’s kind of hard for me to realize that I was in cities that are now occupied, I remember eating pizza in Melitopol, my sister was in Mariupol a year ago, I remember how I went to Chernivtsi by train and Lisichansk, I remember how I went to rest on the sea in a town near Melitopol. we have friends who are now under occupation. I remember how I was sitting in the bunker and found friends there and made board games with them and played, I remember how I sat at the computers in the evening and I see how outside the window and I see how the sky turns white and after about 2 seconds the sound comes because I know all sorts of cool things I knew the speed of sound and shielded and it turned out + - 1350 meters from me and I was terribly horrified when I saw when the next day my friend and he writes to me that a house was blown up 200 meters from him, I was especially touched by the moment when we were driving along a green corridor from the environment and the girl told her mother "I want to go home" and my mother could not say anything else like "we are going, daughter, we are going" (i'm from Sumy)

@user-jq1kc1xm2o

Жыл бұрын

А помните, как в 2014 г. детей Донбасса убивали? kzread.info/dash/bejne/mqV4ldORf8a9c6w.html

@Andrew-oh6kg

Жыл бұрын

@@user-jq1kc1xm2o да, убивали русские солдаты. Привести ссылку на пропагандаТВ - как цинично! Смени методичку ибо "дамбили бамбасс" уже обсосано 1000 раз

@user-jq1kc1xm2o

Жыл бұрын

Если мы их детей убивали, то почему тогда ДНР и ЛНР вместе с нами сейчас воюют?

@user-jq1kc1xm2o

Жыл бұрын

А можете ещё назвать точную дату ввода российских войск на Украину в 2014 г.?

@limoncello3438

Жыл бұрын

@@user-jq1kc1xm2o 20 февраля 2014 года - начало оккупации Крыма И правильно: в Украину)

It was interesting to watch this video as Ukrainian that lived through this events. Your pronounciation of cities is perfect, thank you for high-quality content

So I think it can be summed up in the following points - 1. Ukraine choose better tactics of defending from cities rather than dispersing their forces to hold at the border. 2. Russia opened war on 4 fronts with insufficient number of troops. 3. No element of surprise from the Russians. They just tried Rushing for the Ukrainian capital with insufficient number of troops which was rather predictable. 4. Russians didn't mobilize. It can clearly be seen from the video that they are so short on troops that they can't launch offensives from both the directions to secure and encircle salients, which leads to over extension of the spearheads and simplification of problems for the Ukrainians.

@thiccchungo1041

Жыл бұрын

Also a lack of air superiority and minimal damage to Ukrainian communications, Russia charged in and never carried out any extensive SEAD operations like the US did in Desert Storm, so they had to contend with little to no air support, even worse Ukraine was able to use Turkish Bayraktar drones to devastating effect on Russian convoys near Kyiv, making the urban combat even more painful for Russia. Russia also failed to do any damage to Ukrainian communications, months in and Ukraine was still able to communicate and organize across a massive front almost better than Russia in some sectors

@dachicagoan8185

Жыл бұрын

The Russians had the same false idea as the Germans did in Operation Barbarossa. They thought just showing up would cause the whole government to collapse.

@littlefinger4509

Жыл бұрын

They can't really mobilize, with the amount of deaths they are taking using civilians would most likely lead to a collapse of the country.

@VRichardsn

Жыл бұрын

_Ukraine choose better tactics of defending from cities rather than dispersing their forces to hold at the border_ They clearly took great in avoiding what happened to Poland in 1939, when it overstretched itself trying to defend everything.

@user-wc5mg5uu9n

Жыл бұрын

1. Yep. It's called using human shields. They are staging guns and personnel in civilian areas and prevent civilians from leaving which leads to excess number of civilian deaths. Even Amnesty International had to admit this. 2. True. Russians have much fewer troops on the ground than Ukraine that had like 7 waves of mobilization. The breakaway republics of Donbass have mobilized though. But they number less than 50 000 troops in total 3. Looks like the Russians tried for a repeat of Crimea 2014. It was a political decision vs a military one. This tactic worked in the south though and let them take Kherson and Melitipol without fighting. 4. Yes. Because it's not a war but a Special Military Operation. They won't even let you join if you lack combat experience. Lots of people who wanted to enlist and go fight in Ukraine were turned down by the Russian Army because of this. 5. Ukrainians are suffering extreme casualties due to the Russian artillery. Mobs lack weapons, ammunition and get wiped out by long-range guns before they can do anything. It's a slaughter for the defending side. Low morale and frequent desertions. Ukraine keeps plugging gaps with cannon fodder. It really is a proxy war till the last Ukrainian. 6. Russians also don't have the initiative to rush. Time works for them. Europeans experience more and more economic hardships, and the Ukrainian economy is on the verge of collapsing. International support for Ukraine is decreasing. They are suffering horrible casualties. They have lost their industrial and energy-production base in the South-East. Military-related production and repair facilities and most of the pre-war hardware was destroyed by the Russian missiles. No way Ukraine can win the war if NATO doesn't get involved directly, but then it's WW3 and nuclear winter.

Excellent video. Very comprehensive and well animated. Probably the best that i have watched so far about the Ukraine War. Thanks 👍

Thank you Eastory for this video. Your map based visual with event lines and symbols gives a clear view with clear explanation.

This was very helpful in understanding what has happened these past few months, thank you!

@johnsmith1474

Жыл бұрын

It's pretty much garbage so have fun being misled.

@Finkaisar

Жыл бұрын

@@johnsmith1474 Ok genius, how did it really go?

@markom4794

Жыл бұрын

@@johnsmith1474 Lol I've seen you posting russian propaganda everywhere. Cope harder, Russia is losing the war.

@juantamayo5295

Жыл бұрын

@@Finkaisar "Russia is crushing Ukraine, the war is lasting this long because who knows"

@Mikhail_Zaitsev

Жыл бұрын

@@juantamayo5295 Россия выдыхается, не достигая поставленных целей, которые уже несколько раз менялись, Украина набирает силы для успешного наступления и деоккупации своих территорий. Подробно тему освещает советник офиса президента Украины Алексей Арестович, а вот канал с переводом на английский: kzread.info

Just a thanks for tackling this story and making some physical sense of it in more or less real time. This would not have been possible 80 years ago. But still you had to do some very heavy lifting to produce this. So again, I probably speak for everyone. Thank you!

@dyslexicbatnam1350

Жыл бұрын

Newspapers and radios in the west were reporting the invasion of Normandy in pretty much real time.

@bjorntorlarsson

Жыл бұрын

There is a YT channel called "military summary" where a Belarusian makes daily updates. He has a good understanding of the terrain and Russian speaking sources.

@HamiltonStandard

Жыл бұрын

tack så mycket, Björn. Jag ska kolla upp det.

@sitting_nut

Жыл бұрын

this video is an example of willful ignorance and total disregarding of verifiable facts. given this channels is a nn fanboi that is no surprise. russians were not intending to capture kiev. they were tying down kiev regime military so that they can destroy the air force, navy, and air defenses, and shape the battlefield. and since then they are using minimal forces with minimal own casualties to achieve their stated goals (and some unstated ones) . and they are achieving them all successfully, and a heading for a comprehensive victory. western weapons have failed to stop that, and kiev regime is suffering by their own admission 500+ casualties a day ( confirmed by media with 100s of dead ukraine soldiers daily) .

@f.s.1429

Жыл бұрын

You don't speak for everyone!

Very nice substantive video. A separate thanks for getting the city names pronounced so well, music to my ears.

Hey man, love these videos very much! I love the style and how well you explain everything. Please make a video about the Cuban Revolution. Thanks

Another major reason why Ukraine survived the initial assault was because their C&C (command and Control) was largely intact. They lost some command posts, but it wasn’t enough to cripple them!

@CERBEREX63

Жыл бұрын

To destroy the significant command posts of the Ukrainian army, Russia would have to bomb the Pentagon. All adults are well aware that Ukraine is an absolute proxy for the United States.

@DaveSCameron

Жыл бұрын

Of course it's in tact because it hasn't been attacked at all, where do you read this bollox and has anyone on this channel tried viewing alternative sources? #smh

@ranndino

Жыл бұрын

@@DaveSCameron Alternative sources? You mean like Putin's propaganda on RT, etc.? Talk about bullocks.

@VajrahahaShunyata

Жыл бұрын

David Scameron making vague accusations with zero substance. And ya'all can't tell its a troll?

@Ionizap

Жыл бұрын

@@DaveSCameron Let us know what those alternate sources are please.

Safe to say that we've all been waiting for this video. Thanks Eastory!

@johnsmith1474

Жыл бұрын

It's empty, it's piffle.

I'm so glad to see you covering this!

Thanks for this video , I watch 93 time your WW2 serial videos . Nice work . Thanks again .

“Peace is not so much a political mandate as it is a shared state of consciousness that remains elevated and intact only to the degree that those who value it volunteer their existence as living examples of the same... Peace ends with the unraveling of individual hope and the emergence of the will to worship violence as a healer of private and social dis-ease.” ― Aberjhani,

@mabussubam512

Жыл бұрын

Man seeks peace, yet at the same time yearning for war… Those are the two realms belonging solely to man. Thinking of peace whilst spilling blood is something that only humans could do. They’re two sides of the same coin… to protect something… another must be sacrificed.

@explicavit9470

Жыл бұрын

Everywhere I go, I see your face. Which isn't a bad thing.

@aaryanbhatia4939

Жыл бұрын

@@explicavit9470 Omg same! It's like this guy is omnipresent

Ah nice another in depth analysis looking forward to the next one whenever it will be

And then in early September, the Ukrainians conducted a successful counteroffensive in the Kharkiv region and showed that the second army of the world is not so second.

@Amal_Russia

Жыл бұрын

Russia used at least 8% of the army before mobilization. 150,000 were able to resist 700,000 APU (Zelensky announced this number on May 21). That's what the 2nd Army of the World means🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺

@user-ju2tn4pj5y

Жыл бұрын

The second army finished Ukraine in April. Ukraine was able to survive only because of NATO and the enormous casualties they took by throwing troops into the Russian artillery fire, just in order to slow the Russians down. 😉

@liviu09hjoe

Жыл бұрын

Stop using ukraine this is all NATO and ukrainians are only cannon fodder

@Amal_Russia

Жыл бұрын

@@user-ju2tn4pj5y Ну да, только благодаря НАТО. Они её растили уже с 2014 года, Украина была готова.

@user-ru6tx9xv7o

Жыл бұрын

kherson bro

Cool video, you do a good job of explaining things, hence I subscribed.

Really great summary. Great video!

@anthonym9977

Жыл бұрын

Patreon?

@tiborhelienek

Жыл бұрын

yes, patreon so early acces to new video

@sitting_nut

Жыл бұрын

this video is an example of willful ignorance and total disregarding of verifiable facts. given this channels is a nn fanboi that is no surprise. russians were not intending to capture kiev. they were tying down kiev regime military so that they can destroy the air force, navy, and air defenses, and shape the battlefield. and since then they are using minimal forces with minimal own casualties to achieve their stated goals (and some unstated ones) . and they are achieving them all successfully, and a heading for a comprehensive victory. western weapons have failed to stop that, and kiev regime is suffering by their own admission 500+ casualties a day ( confirmed by media with 100s of dead ukraine soldiers daily) .

@louisbeerreviews8964

Жыл бұрын

@@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 wrong

Hey Eastory, I was wondering how you animate your videos and make your maps. Do you use a software to make maps and units? Do you use map pictures or do you look at google maps and copy it on your own made map? I would love to know how long a 10-20 min video takes to make? Thanks for making connten and keeping us entertaint

@turbochad69

Жыл бұрын

Good question lol

@vixinitydbz

Жыл бұрын

he uses blender

@turbochad69

Жыл бұрын

@@vixinitydbz Epic

Excellent recap. I realize the purpose was to cover the overall “what happened” and not get into details, but it might be mentioned that the initial Russian advance was slowed by self-inflicted logistical issues as well as Ukrainian threats to their supply lines. It might be mentioned that the original plan for the special operation was for a 15-day timetable. There are two places where the video implies something about this, but it’s not entirely clear in the video. Lastly, Russians failure to gain air superiority should have been mentioned. Setting those criticisms aside, this is an excellent and informative video, recapping the conflict up until recent events. You had to pick and choose which details to bring forward, what parts of the conflict to emphasize, and I think you nailed it wrt to the overall strategic picture.

Damnn your ad was intense.. 2 point for effort. Liked and subscribed 😇

This is the earliest I've ever been on one of Eastorys videos.

you know its a good day when Eastory uploads

Thank your for making this video, i always love watching your videos. Would be great to make more vids about Ukraine. Keep going!

A lot of things happened since august, will be there new video :)?

It's incredible that we are live tracking a modern battle. What a time to be alive

@johnsmith1474

Жыл бұрын

Are you ten?

@Jummeli

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, Ukrainians must feel so good right now too. What a time indeed...

@hamzamahmood9565

Жыл бұрын

@@Jummeli Who says they are?

@seneca983

Жыл бұрын

The Yemeni and Ethiopian civil wars were already ongoing when this war started.

@Konstantin3208

Жыл бұрын

@@seneca983 who cares about those who are not white))

"The Ukranians did not apply their special tactics there". I swear if this is a reference to WhiteRa, an Ukranian SC1 Brood War and SC2 professional gamer from Odessa, then you are amazing! And a big thumbs up from me my friend. P.S: Been following you since your first video (and will continue to do so!)

@klakier19901

Жыл бұрын

This guy is getting it!

@bjorntorlarsson

Жыл бұрын

@Seaworth It's KZread that deletes comments, not the channel host.

@ElkaPME

Жыл бұрын

@Seaworth yt moment, it's not the guy's fault, hell my comments sometimes get deleted and some other content creators' videos as well for no reason.

@BleaK1211

Жыл бұрын

We make expand then defense it. - WhiteRa

@KrecikBobasek

Жыл бұрын

@Seaworth oh no. smone fill offended. who cares ;D For most of the world ukrainian war is nothing more than sad tv news for morning coffe.

This video was incredible, thankyou!

Great videos! Thank you.

Well done. The best description of what has happened so far that I've seen.

Thank you for this. Was looking all around for a summarized (yet as detailed as possible) war in Ukraine for a long time.

@Mikhail_Zaitsev

Жыл бұрын

kzread.info - ещё более детально почти каждый день!

@Ivan19271

Жыл бұрын

@@Mikhail_Zaitsev 🐷🇷🇺 bot moment

Was expecting a deeper analysis but this was still satisfactory. Good work bro.

3:43 here is an error. I am from Ukraine, or rather from the city of Konotop. My city was not taken under control, but was only surrounded but not taken.

@user-rw7ov1yh7d

Жыл бұрын

-"Это Конотоп, здесь каждая вторая женщина это ведьма. У тебя завтра хуй стоять уже не будет" :)

@loran4169

Жыл бұрын

So you didn't evacuate from your city instead you stay there?

@KravchenkoIgor

Жыл бұрын

@@loran4169 it was dangerous to go from surrounded city because russians shoot civil vehicles.

@user-me4tw9pr8w

Жыл бұрын

@@loran4169 I will say more. Most stayed in the city.

@user-me4tw9pr8w

Жыл бұрын

@@loran4169 I have nowhere to evacuate, I defended the city from the freaks who came to my native Ukrainian land

When an Eastory video comes out it makes me really happy. Keep up the great work!

I think you making a video about the Bosnian or Yugoslav wars would be interesting

Great analysis. Thank you for your job!

Thank you for the great insights!

Great content, happy to see you didn't "took" any sides in your analysis and stayed true to your channel legacy. Love from France. :)

@qwerty70231

Жыл бұрын

where are our leclercs?))) russians want to go home

@user-rw7ov1yh7d

Жыл бұрын

@@qwerty70231 they surely won't give MBTs it's just useless, they won't even give a couple more Caesars (Ah maan but we reeeeally need artillery)

1.1991-1995 Yogoslavian civil war 2.1994-2000 Chechen wars 3.1997 Albania civil war 4.1998-1999 Kosovo war 5.2001 North part of Macedonia incident 6.2008 Georgian war 7.Ukrainian war 2014-still going So you see how many conflicts happened in east Europe these decades.

@maerto

Жыл бұрын

Yugoslavian were wars of independence

@kallekulmala1876

Жыл бұрын

This is the first major war in Europe since ww2. Civil wars are very much different. And the rest are either agaisn't very small nations or weak nations.

@davidiashvili1800

Жыл бұрын

You forgot 1991-1992 abkhazia war

@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714

Жыл бұрын

And this is the biggest one since WW2.

@user-gu3xj3pl4i

Жыл бұрын

You forgot the war in Transnistria

Really solid review here Eastory. What we expect from the channel that covered WWII so well. If you're looking for actual regiment locations for future updates, check out 'Military Summary'

thank you for continuing to draw people's attention to the war in my country 🇺🇦🤝🇪🇪

@Favoki

Жыл бұрын

Z

@user-fy8in8kx7y

Жыл бұрын

@@Favoki Zalupa

Very insightful. Especially making it clear how the northern invasion suffered from extremely long flanks thus massively diluting its strength. Also the info about the (mis)deployment of the forces facing Crimea was actually new to me. Of course it was tempting to try and use the chokepoint/bottleneck there to shorten the line so perhaps there was no better choice. Defense in depth and fall back lines at the Dnieper/Melitopol would be possible but that's a much longer line to hold.

@user-vf3wr7ij8z

Жыл бұрын

I'll explain why it happened. Head of regional department of СБУ,ukrainian intelligence was a russian agent,so,he demined this chokepoint and that led to troops disorganization.

@DaveSCameron

Жыл бұрын

Oh the Northern flanks have suffered sure but not because they were planning on taking Kiev, I must have been watching a different conflict so far as I swear I see Russian forces making steady and safe progress through the Eastern Russian areas and down to Crimea but hey I'm just another person with eyes and ears and WiFi...

@bjorntorlarsson

Жыл бұрын

​@@DaveSCameron Oh, I'm sure they tried to reach the government buildings with their spetsnaz troops, or try to scare the government to negotiations. But a secondary goal was to tie down forces.

@bjorntorlarsson

Жыл бұрын

Some General had a bad day there. It is a scandal that the Russians could cross the Dniepr so easily. I wonder how much the advance was airborne and amphibious?

@DaveSCameron

Жыл бұрын

@@bjorntorlarsson Maybe..

Thank you for the informative videos

HOW DO YOU MAKE YOUR MAPPING PLEASE TEACH?

Hope you'll do another update, many things happened since then.

Please, make a video about the Kharkiv counteroffensive!

@YuraL88

Жыл бұрын

@@user-xi4yu3sr1m потому что альтернатива - полное окружение. Ситуация зеркальная с Лисичанском, оставили чтобы избежать окружения. А вот оставление приграничных сел уже действительно было "жестом доброй воли" так как удерживать их после падения Изюма и Купянска смысла никакого не оставалось.

@zhanboyko8310

Жыл бұрын

@@user-xi4yu3sr1m не из-за одного города, а из-за Балаклеи, Шевченково, Волохов Яра, Купянска, выходу к мостам и переправам через оскол и подходу к городу Изюм с тыла в течении 3 дней. Действительно, зачем из-за угрозы быть полностью уничтоженными в котле полностью оставлять всю область, бросая почти всю тяжелую технику и военные склады?

@cryaboutit6670

Жыл бұрын

@@user-xi4yu3sr1m Cope

@dembenter572

Жыл бұрын

@@user-xi4yu3sr1m ихихихих и оставили 300 ед техники и тысячи снарядов? спасибо за ленд-лиз :)

We will need an updated version soon now that Ukraine is doing counteroffensive

What editor or application do you use for your videos?

I seriously can't with the russian bots

@bearcatben4762

Жыл бұрын

yeah, they're incredibly annoying. I don't see why they would even come here of all places where people are a bit more educated about the situation than your average NATO resident

It's an awful situation, but I have to say that I love these videos so much. Eastory is the best.

It would be cool if you did an explanation of the battle of berlin

I love the ruzzia you make on your map! it's so tiny :D at 0:01

Im from Mariupol. Peace to you guys🙏🙏

@user-kx8fu8sr5p

Жыл бұрын

🇺🇦

Excellent analysis. Based on what you have explained it shows to great effect how ukarains forces employed the elastic defence. however they do have the strategic initiative and remain on the defence due to lack of equipment to go on the offensive.

@user-jq1kc1xm2o

Жыл бұрын

😆

Our Eastory is back. BTW Can you make videos about ww1?

@ferem55

Жыл бұрын

Yeah! We want it!

@seneca983

Жыл бұрын

He does have a video titled "Germany's plans to win WWI".

@J.Mahbub

Жыл бұрын

@@seneca983 But we need an animated video of the fronts.

will there be a sequel?

Good. Thank you!

I'm from the DPR Russia really has problems with planning this war and apparently the calculation was that the Ukrainians would surrender from the fact of the attack + in the DPR itself, no one was preparing for this battle

@command_unit7792

Жыл бұрын

We dont know the Russian MOD plans so we dont know what they planned for.

@johnsmith1474

Жыл бұрын

So you think. But you are just a kid so ....

@raichiovasily2156

Жыл бұрын

don't say that , Russia is not in Ukraine to make them surrender , it is to free them from Jewish Zelensky, and a western proxy gouvernement, Russia want ukrainians to join them, many Joined Russia, this why Russia easily entered Kherson , but the media don't tell people the truth, Russia has a huge reserve of ammo , they can easily bomb cities with no mercy, but actually Ukraine is sacred to Russia, you will understand when you read history

@MrIluvbutts

Жыл бұрын

@@johnsmith1474 okay Igor

@Mikhail_Zaitsev

Жыл бұрын

@@command_unit7792 Не нужно быть академиком, чтобы понять, что планировали они совсем не то, что получилось, и что планы менялись несколько раз. путина спасает только рабская покорность и тупость россиян. Но интересно будет посмотреть на процессы в российском обществе после деоккупации украинских территорий этой осенью!

Love to see when russian veterans of this war who got injury like leg loss, get as a gift from government a new pair of SHOES. They really mean that.

@AlejandroNievas1

Жыл бұрын

well if u are lucky russian father, and ur boy get killed , u get enough to buy a rusty lada.

I'm looking forward to the next video.

7:32 honourable mention that one squad which somehow managed to get to Zhytomyr and was supposed to go on Vinnytsa.

Damm that’s crazy I haven’t been keeping up with the war so

@martinsmolik2449

Жыл бұрын

I have been checking news obsessively since the war started, and I have to say this is incredibly precise. It glosses over many details, but those aren't necessary for this sort of overview. Overall, incredible video as always.

Good video. One thing that you could have mentioned is the help Ukraine got in the defense of Kyiv from the Belarusian opposition. Although Ukrainians themselves successfully ambushed and destroyed many Russian supply columns, I remember reading a statement by the Belarusian opposition leader in exile. The Belarusian opposition reported halting, damaging or stealing something like 82 train carriages of supplies (food, fuel ammunition etc.) that was being sent from Russia through Belarus for the attack on Kyiv. It is hard to say how much this contributed to the Ukrainian overall victory in the defense of Kyiv, but I think that the Belarusian partizans deserve at least an honorable mention, especially now that some of the brave men and women that stopped those trains may be executed if caught.

@NebulousOdious

Жыл бұрын

Sounds like a bunch of BS, honestly. I mean, stealing or sabotaging a train?

@G.A.C_Preserve

Жыл бұрын

@@NebulousOdious that pretty easy, the Czechoslovakia foreign legion did it just fine with the tran-siberian railway

@NebulousOdious

Жыл бұрын

@@G.A.C_Preserve But in your case that would be, aside from time difference, a combat unit. While Belorussian opposition(i'd speculate) is mostly students and such, not an armed force capable of such maneuvers.

@norwegianboyee

Жыл бұрын

@@NebulousOdious It was the Belarusian railroad workers themselves that were suspected to play a part in it.

@cyberwarrior8382

Жыл бұрын

@@NebulousOdious man, read about protests in Belarus... most people of Belarus wants freedom for their country. And its not only students.

Such a nice pronunciation of the name of our capiatal city) big admiration for your efforts!

One of the most concise descriptions with the help of maps to clearly show main events and battle lines in the 6-month Russia invasion. Good job!

@evgeniam685

Жыл бұрын

Its actually not close to reality. Do you think this channels actually know what is happening in other country while all these happening. They just tell you what you need to know, just like mainstream media.

@cf3714

Жыл бұрын

@@evgeniam685 This might surprise you, but there is this thing called "the Internet". It allows someone to look at maps and photos from places all the way around the world. There is also this thing called a "satellite", which sits really high in the sky and can see things like armies, forest fires and buildings. These 2 things allow anyone with half a brain to be able to get a decent picture of what is happening.

@evgeniam685

Жыл бұрын

@@cf3714 wow, genius. Russia attacking Ukraine and West trying to save it and care about Ukraine like it's own mother?

@cf3714

Жыл бұрын

@@evgeniam685 You being dense on purpose? "One of the most concise descriptions with the help of *maps* to clearly show *main events* and *battle lines* in the 6-month Russia invasion." Hey genius, can you follow a conversation or is that to much to ask for?

@user-sf5zv4jc5v

Жыл бұрын

@@cf3714 Половины мозга не хватает для жизни, когда у вас только половина мозга вы инвалид. Боюсь в таком случае вы даже не поймете кто ваши родители. Интернет давно превратился в свалку, так-что зерно от плевел следует отличать. Спутник покажет фото передвижений и только на остальные вопросы не ответит. Остаётся логика. Контингент в 20 000 человек на 3 000 000 миллионный город, да логично справимся!!! Не кажется безумством? Почему до сих пор есть железнодорожное сообщение на Украине? Помню "Калибры" долетали до Львова. Почему труба по которому газ идёт в Украину и Европу до сих пор не взорвана и более того торговля не прекращается и газ поступает в Украину. Почему ТЭС ещё работают? Почему плохие, злые русские не хотят этого делать? И последний вопрос, когда именно вы перестали называть украинцев русскими? Наверное вы совсем не понимаете, что происходит. З. Ы. Если вам интересно, то переводите сами. У вас вообще встроена система автоперевода в браузере? Или youtube приложение предлагает вам перевести сообщение?

nice no bullshit vid. trust a history buff to understand current affairs

The weird Russian moves on the very start are solely reasoned by a very bad understanding of situation in Ukraine. The main Putin's adviser on the matters of Ukraine at that time (with is kinda just a half a year ago, but nevertheless) was Vladislav Yurievich Surkov (now he is fired and put under home arrest due to incompetence). Who was vastly exaggerating support of Russia inside of Ukraine. Those fast and deep launches of troops into Ukrainian territory were because Putin was sure the population of Ukraine would support Russians and Ukrainian army will just give up and surrender as it was in Crimea in 2014.

@armengraham6925

Жыл бұрын

Russia amassed 170+ thousand troops at the border with Ukraine, that is almost *the whole* regular Army of Ukraine (220 thousands). Russia had an overwhelming advantage in the quantity and quality of missiles, air planes and artillery systems (the later was almost 10 to 1). Not to mention Russian fleet in the Black Sea, while Ukraine has barely any fleet... It is insane that under these circumstances Ukraine was able to hold with what crappy equipment they had.

@vladrootgmailcom

Жыл бұрын

@@armengraham6925 well, as I said, the reason of such overwhelming success was that Russia completely missed the motivation of Ukrainian army.

@armengraham6925

Жыл бұрын

@@vladrootgmailcom So for Russia to defeat an already much weaker opponent, this opponent also had to be unmotivated? That's quite a slap in the face of Russian military capabilities.

@vladrootgmailcom

Жыл бұрын

@@armengraham6925 you misunderstand a bit the Russian side here. For Russia it was not the question of defeating the opponent, but acquiring control over the territory, infrastructure and integrating people into Russian citizenship. Basically Russian was going to do with the whole Ukraine what it did to Crimea - make it a part of Russia. Obviously in this situation there is a goal to keep as much infrastructure intact and as much people alive and healthy as possible. Russia's plan was to just come, remove the government and that's it. No war at all. To be honest the same mistake of not understanding of how low the support of pro-Russian course in Ukraine Russia kept making for at least 1-2 months of this operation - still hoping Ukrainian army would just surrender. In simple words - it's like a father trying to just slap on the butt his little son for being naughty and the kid gets the baseball bat and tries to kill his parent - obviously a grown man would easily overpower a little kid, it's just father's goal is not to kill his son.

@user-si7ep1lz7z

Жыл бұрын

@@armengraham6925 let me correct: to defeat quickly, as first planned

excellent summary of events up to this point

Learnt about this channel through TIK who is a legend already on YT

Im seeing this being played in school classes in year 2050 as archive material

@johnsmith1474

Жыл бұрын

As an example of garbage propaganda,

@putinpunhere

Жыл бұрын

@@johnsmith1474 Hasty garbage yes, given we'd definitely have better maps😉 by the end of the decade, let alone 2050.

@bongomeister9965

Жыл бұрын

@@johnsmith1474 10 ruble was added to your account

@vladislavsulimenko5276

Жыл бұрын

@@johnsmith1474 you think schools use quality material?

@aaroncabatingan5238

Жыл бұрын

@@johnsmith1474 I doubt schools would resort to using RT as material for teaching.

i remember first hours of this. I was literaly waked up because of gunshots on paratroopers on Kyiv north part and artilery fire

Eastory is knowledgeable amazing and blown me away with his up to date knowledge 😂

And now, Ukraine has managed to recapture vital regions through it's counteroffensive around Charkiv and also managed to retake Cherson.

@SilencedP2P

Жыл бұрын

Those are both spelled with K's instead of C's.

@darth_nihilus_

11 ай бұрын

@@SilencedP2P The Ukrainian versions is different.

I am a resident of the city of Lysichansk, I was lucky and we evacuated and our city is a brother of Severodonetsk, there was a real hell, the cities were erased by 80% ..

The map just keeps zooming in. It's gonna be like WW1 in the west with vast numbers dying for meters of territory.

Good analysis, thank you.

@antonkirov1923

Жыл бұрын

Analysis? 😖 About Blitzkrieg?!🤣

@user-rw7ov1yh7d

Жыл бұрын

@@antonkirov1923 Brainwashed dude

В какой программе ты сделал эту анимацию?

I wish in the future for the divisions to be included, but I know information on that is hidden. To be fair, I don’t even know how to find such information on division

@G.A.C_Preserve

Жыл бұрын

Find the military records

Remember to make an update when war end From 2014(the beginning)-202?(the end)

Does that VPN company still pay you even though people skip straight past your ad for them?

This video is amazingly informative

A series about the American Civil war year by year would be incredible

from watching ww2 tactics from all sorts of master generals (manstein, zhukov) ancient battles from caesar to hannibal and to Napoleonic era i just realized how hard it really is to win a sigle battle and tbh i kinda miss having some sort of legendary general on the field

Can you do a tutorial in how to make videos like you Please?

bro these politicians who know everything about this war during a big misinformation

I would like to add the challenge of artillery shell usage where for several moths Ukrainians were firing 10 times less of 152mm shell then Russia. Mostly because Ukraine does not have 155 howitzers. It will help to understand why Russia concentrate all forces where railroad can provide 20 000 shells daily. First months they were not able to use railroad from Crimea and after sinking in Berdyansk the only approach was from Donbass where they used human waves tactics with rolling artillery strikes.

@konstantinriumin2657

Жыл бұрын

Human wave tactics? Citation needed

@Usmodlover

Жыл бұрын

@@konstantinriumin2657 sounds like what the separatists have been doing. I think maybe it was Igor Girkin who mentioned that new conscripts weren’t even being trained properly, just sent to the front to die or figure it out

@konstantinriumin2657

Жыл бұрын

@@Usmodlover But it's not the same as human wave attacks.

@impaugjuldivmax

Жыл бұрын

today even with 777 shells, Ukraine has 4-5 less rounds per day than Russia

@simondesmond3574

Жыл бұрын

@@konstantinriumin2657 The citation is the Russian casualties

I am a Ukrainian, and you did your research, in general everything is mostly accurate and huge thanks for making videos which support us!

@user-il7yh6dc7w

Жыл бұрын

Ты это тот балабол который выехал со страны как и тысячи людей с западной Украины и здаешь жилье в три раза дороже ?

@streamjpeg

Жыл бұрын

@@user-il7yh6dc7w харош

Wow!,The best explanation, thank's!

Good short analysis

It seems Russia didn't mobilise enough troops to perform encirclements, maintain supply lines and destroy Ukrainian units. Sounds like Russia expected Ukraine to lose morale immediately. Maybe they thought Russian-speaking Ukrainian soldiers would surrender immediately (like in 2014) or even switch sides and that Zelensky would run away like the Afghan president. Kyiv in 3 days was based on these assumptions. They also didn't expect the West to support Ukraine this strongly. Russia basically underestimated Ukraine.

@andreksjour

Жыл бұрын

The 3 days narrative never came out of Rus. I argue it's the west that underestimated Ukr, but mostly, they over estimated how much force Rus would use. With all the options they have, it seems Rus went with the most economical. Enough forces to overpower defenses, with no time restrictions. And Zelensky did get out. After Rus retreaded from the north he returned, at the time that everyone from EU was visiting him, he pretty much came back with them. I have no evidence. But its logical.

@oleglozinskiy5216

Жыл бұрын

Hi, I am from russia. The opinion that our command assumed a loss of morale is quite popular with us. That's why we decided to retreat from Kiev. Because the original plan didn't work. And there was no mobilization at all. We have a contract army and a draft army. All men are conscripted. But they go to the contract voluntarily. And just those who serve under contract, they carry out the work of the conscription army. Which of course does not participate in any conflicts. This means that not even all contractors are involved in the war in Ukraine. I hope I'm writing clearly. Ask if something is interesting

@MDP1702

Жыл бұрын

@@andreksjour There is nothing indicating Zelensky fled. In fact he was offered sanctuary by several bordering nations, but he refused and stayed in Kiev for so far we know.

@exohome1

Жыл бұрын

Если бы Россия действовала как Америка - применяла ковровые бомбардировки, то завоевала бы эту страну за неделю. Но борьба идет не с мирым населением, а с вооруженными солдатами и нацистами. Поэтому зачистка идёт медленно, но уверенно. Вооруженные формирования Украины это понимают, и поэтому прячутся в городах, а точнее в административных зданиях - школах, детских садах, клубах, домах культуры, торговых центрах, кинотеатрах и прочих. Также вооруженные формирования Украины не выпускают мирное население из деревень и посёлков, где они базируются.

@romchik_ukr

Жыл бұрын

@@exohome1 Бред не неси, боже мой. И о каких нациках идёт речь когда сами стёрли Мариуполь в порох и устроили резню в Буче? Прежде чем нести бред, подумай, а не транслируй росс. пропаганду. И ой, как американцы. А то что ваши Грозный уничтожили бомбардировками и арт-обстрелами ничего не значит? Ах точно, у вас же это пытаются скрывать, не удивительно.

It it just so bizarre to watch this video after viewing ones about WW2 and WW1, I have never thought that something similar could even happen in my country in 21 century, nevertheless, nice video, appreciated)

@Eastory you should read "Strategy" from Svechin

That's spot on prononunciation on most of the city and town names