Finally a good video about this mess of a war

@hosephanerothe1440

11 ай бұрын

As a wise man once said, what a clusterf**k !

@user-wh7kt5oz3r

7 ай бұрын

no, Albert Pikes 1871 letter on display in London until 1977, says flat out with 100% accuracy the British central banks (Bank/City of London, yes they have a DC like city/Country as does the Vatican and all 3 have the same monuments as DC). The war of 1812 was a seize fire not a win for the USA, it decided to join forces with England, being the world military might (until the one world order comes around 2050 or before they decided) Anyways this letter is only a page and the most famous freemason letter in HOSTORY It is right about all 3 world wars, meaning it was right about the Zionists and the Muslims destroying each other and it spreading around a globe where forced migration has caused culture instability on purpose. So he nailed WW3, WW1 was to "get the Czars that have rules Russia for centuries out of power, creating communism in this largest of territories, which will destroy religion and the family structure. Making sure that the State is the only god and that the people are promised equality when it will actually serve to be used as a master and serf system. WW2 was to destroy Nazism the English crown/USA scholars taught Eugenics/Genocide based on Darwinist ideology to Munich University in 1912 The Nuremburg trials never mention this in history but was discussed A LOT! It also says WW2 is to make sure an Israeli state is made in Palestine from the Zionist leaders of western countries and that a STRONG unelected world parliament, and the main goal of WW2 was to create a globe where communism and the western governments were equally strong and equal in territories. Read the letter. I just wrote almost all of it out of order lol

@caboosej8749

3 ай бұрын

@@user-wh7kt5oz3r sounds like a 4chan conspiracy bruh...

@xFlared

Ай бұрын

@@user-wh7kt5oz3r If you want to make a plausible conspiracy case then you have to at least work on your grammar and spelling.

I’m sorry to say but Cossacks were not “semi-nomadic”, they were a class of peasants who had additional obligations (military service) in exchange for larger freedoms and privileges compared to other peasants. There were no Cossacks in Ukraine by that time, but they lived on the Don, Kuban, Ural, Orenburg and other historical borderland regions of Russia. They did not want “independence from Russia”, they also participated in the civil war on all sides, but favoured the Whites (the monarchists) more. I can refer you to a great Russian novel of 20th century, a Nobel prize winner “And quietly flows the Don” by Mikhail Sholokhov, it is exactly about the civil war and the Don cossacks

@peterpetrow9822

Ай бұрын

Nevertheless this is a very good video. Concise explanation of the events and the moves of the major players during those chaotic and explosive times.

how the HELL does this only have 600 views??? This is AMAZING

@caboosej8749

3 ай бұрын

I know right, i had know of this civil war but videos about it are far and between

Incredible documentary, the clearest video I've seen on the subject that is complex and includes so many intersecting and interrelated characters and that it doesnt lasts 5 hours. Fabulous job =)

How did the Bolshevik faction become the majority in the Petrograd Soviet? It's very simple! The Soviets were elected from labor collectives and soldiers' units. As soon as people felt that the deputy did not express their will, they immediately held a meeting and re-elected the deputy. The Bolsheviks proposed: peace with Germany without annexations and indemnities, to lease land to peasants fairly, to introduce an eight-hour working day, vacations and a collective labor agreement for workers. Abolish estates and privileges, hold a Congress of People's Deputies and make Councils the main form of government. And voila! The people followed them. By the way, the first two laws passed by the Bolsheviks were: the Law on Peace (a proposal to put up with Germany and Austria-Hungary on the zero option) and the law on land - where it was prescribed to divide the landowner's land by consumers.

I'm so glad I came across your channel. One of the few I actually look forward too

Such a great video, clear, concise and amazing visuals. This is a channel to watch!

@HenryStewart

11 ай бұрын

Thanks so much Cy!! So kind :)

Way more context and details than any video I’ve seen on it, and only 20 mins your great

Amazing video ... Absolutely brilliant Covered so much in such a short time. I was looking for a informative video on this topic for so long. Cant thank you enough👏👏

rly incredible video, each event/character is given enough context to understand, but so much that gets overwhelming. perfectly balanced. this is helping me out a lot in my history course rn, thank you ☆

Fantastic video! Ive been reading about this war for a while but this really nailed the explanation, with all the big characters and the map to comprehend the territorial status. Congratulations! I also want to watch your South American wars of independence videos. I have waited for so long for someone to make good videos about them, they're so interesting! (And I'm south American myself 😅)

Hyped and ready!

An excellent job describing events on the many fronts involved in this war.

Great video as always. Would love to see more videos on Russian revolution, which is relatively less covered.

That was actually so amazing I always thought a video over this period of history would be inpossible to make but I was clearly wrong!

I love the way this video was made, thank you for this video, I’ve learned more about the civil war then I had known before.

Dude thats super high quality you are terribly underrated,just subscribed i hope your channel gets a boom soon

Good work as always ❤. Thanks

it's a pity that there is so little good content on KZread on such an important and interesting Russian Civil war1

@mnemonija

6 ай бұрын

Check out the great war channel. They go deep in the Russian civil war as well as many other developments resulting after the great war.

great video, deserves more views. im surprised at how little knowledge about this war ive absorbed in my life, despite it being very consequential and interesting.

Just discovered this channel,great stuff 🎉

What an amazing video! SO UNDERRATED! LIked and subbed!

HistoryMarche sent me here, what a recommendation this is , outstanding content !

amazing video man

Great video you deserve more praise

My man I just signed up to your channel at 6900 followers. You will reach big numbers in the future. Best regards

Excellent outline, thanks!

Wow this is a new yt history guy that is dropping bangers Great content dude

Excited

Incredible documentary.

Amazing detailed video. Congrats! Make one about the anarchist!

I discovered your channel today. Subscribed immediately. Top quality content and no lengthy intros, sponsors and begging for subscribers. Cheers.

Excellent work friend 👍👌😉.

How to give praise to a great KZread channel without sounding like a bot or paid shill? I fkin love your channel bro!!!!

Amazing content. You deseve much more view.

Great video

dude how do u make these maps

Amazing video

There is actually a game just announced about the Czech Legion, made by a Czech developer. Called Last Train Home.

@user-sonosada

5 ай бұрын

Who cares about those idiots?

@justachannel8600

4 ай бұрын

Just played it. Very nice game.

@vadimanreev4585

3 ай бұрын

It was necessary to name the last train with the loot.

Syrian Civil War entered the chat

awesome!

There were literally British and French troops still in Murmansk when they sent the Czech Legion east. Wtf were they thinking?

Since WW2 a huge number of Russians had been fighting with Germans against Bolsheviks.Some of them were just cowerdly,but a lot of Russians had been fighting for Freedom of Russia. Other than that,the name of their army was "RLA"(Russian Liberation Army) that was operated by Andrei Vlasov who was a great commander in Soviet Army before 1942. To my mind,that was a completely dreadful moment in history when people from one nation were fighting against each other

1. I had to pause and rewind so much to fully understand the depth of the conflict. 2. How did the Red Army even win with so many fronts and different enemies, wild. 3. White Army would have won so easily if they just worked together from the start. 4. Just when I thought all the nonsense was finally over, here comes Stalin... Unreal explanation, thank you.

You have a mistake in your document. It was not the Czech legion it was the Czechoslovakian legion.

Good video. Peace for 🇵🇱🕊️🇷🇺

"Most complicated war in hiatory" So we just ignoring the warlord era in China?

@jamesgarner327

3 ай бұрын

Well a lot of the chaos of the chinese warlord area was the direct result of the russian civil war with many former white russian soldiers fighting in the chinese warlord armies...

God dame this is good!

Hello, this is an interesting video about history, I hope you continue to make more battles about the Spanish American Wars of Independence and make a video also the Brazilian War of Independence it is very interesting learn more about the history of Central and South America. Love you videos greetings from The Philippines❤❤❤.

I just watched "Dr. Zhivago" so now I understand the Russian Civil War. hahaha

I don’t know if it’s the most complicated war in history. The Punic wars got really funky there for a bit.

Bro love from Bangladesh, best illustration of histroy I've ever seen

Let's gooooo

This is a jewel

So sad to see, but great video

Most complicated American Civil War: YoU WoNt tAkE mUh SlAvEs! Least complicated Russian Civil War:

The fact that this only has 4k views shows you how much of a joke youtube is.

Well done! A video on the events that led to the rise of power of the Bolsheviks would be fascinating. Especially as it pertains to the similarities of what is happening in the USA at this time.

Did my disitation at Uni on this one and still would say it was one the most complicated civil wars you can study. Add foreign powers and it is has to be studied area by area. Ukraine is by far the hardest to follow with Germans, Austrians, French, British in the mix of independence groups, anarchists, monarchist, left social revolutionaries, bolshevik and bandit warlords. Cities changing hands a number of times weird alliences with betrayals. Bloody and pitiless with more to come whoever took over.

What an excellent channel! You deserve million subs 😊😊😊

I'm not sure I agree with your assessment that the majority was against the revolution.

@CommieSense

4 ай бұрын

If majority was against Bolsheviks - how could they possibly take control of such territory? This video is generally very informative, but quite biased if we look closer.

Yayyy

The respected author of this video reread the fantasy, otherwise how can you understand that twenty-five thousand Bolsheviks captured the one hundred and fifty million former Russian Empire. How the Bolsheviks started with the Red Guard (detachments of workers) and sailors, and ended the war with a five-million-strong united army.

Didn't manage to watch till the end, but I definitely will. Suggestion - drop background music to some 5 or 6 dB more in your next videos... Especially if it is epic music...

Both sides apparently tried to ‘out-psyche’ the other by inventing even worse torture methods than their opponent. This is how we got the Red and White Terrors. The people of Russia were absolutely brutalised in this war, with the leaders (Lenin, Trotsky, Denikin, Kolchak) having very little regard for human life. And so suffering was immense. Bearing in mind at the same time as the frontline war between the Whites and the Reds was taking place, the Bolsheviks had launched their war on the peasantry, a horrific campaign which basically terrorised the civilian rural population of Russia due to the fact Lenin saw them as combatants.

@issigonis975

5 ай бұрын

That was it. The tragedy would go on for Russians whoever won as it was the survival of the most brutal. Trotsky introduced decimation into the army something from the Roman empire. Any group who could have brought a real end to it was crushed and if lucky gone into exile. Civil wars are the worst of wars but this was the worst of the worst.

@CommieSense

4 ай бұрын

It is obviously incorrect to put Lenin in line with war criminals Krasnov and Kolchak. Kolchak and Krasnov are regarded as war criminals even in today's anti-red Russia. Lenin is not a war criminal and no court in the world gave him such credit. I urge everyone to stay calm and beware of mass-media propaganda. Use common sense and do not fall for lies!

I make video like you, but using indonesian leanguange

The Soviet civil war is still ongoing. Russia-Ukraine, Russia-Georgia, Azerbaijan-Armenia, Russia-Baltics, Transdnistria, etc.

Those ultraleftists were mader than the natzies!!! :/

@CommieSense

4 ай бұрын

This video is about history, and not about emotions. Using common sense can help us understand our civilization better.

Why no mention of the critically important Jewish role in establishing the Bolshevik regime? The following lists of persons in the Bolshevik Party and Soviet administration during this period, which Wilton compiled on the basis of official reports and original documents, underscore the crucial Jewish role in these bodies. These lists first appeared in the rare French edition of Wilton's book, published in Paris in 1921 under the title Les Derniers Jours des Romanoffs. They did not appear in either the American or British editions of The Last Days of the Romanovs published in 1920. "I have done all in my power to act as an impartial chronicler," Wilton wrote in his foreword to Les Derniers Jours des Romanoffs. "In order not to leave myself open to any accusation of prejudice, I am giving the list of the members of the [Bolshevik Party's] Central Committee, of the Extraordinary Commission [Cheka or secret police], and of the Council of Commissars functioning at the time of the assassination of the Imperial family. "The 62 members of the [Central] Committee were composed of five Russians, one Ukrainian, six Letts [Latvians], two Germans, one Czech, two Armenians, three Georgians, one Karaim [Karaite] (a Jewish sect), and 41 Jews. "The Extraordinary Commission [Cheka or Vecheka] of Moscow was composed of 36 members, including one German, one Pole, one Armenian, two Russians, eight Latvians, and 23 Jews. "The Council of the People's Commissars [the Soviet .government] numbered two Armenians, three Russians, and 17 Jews. "According to data furnished by the Soviet press, out of 556 important functionaries of the Bolshevik state, including the above-mentioned, in 1918-1919 there were: 17 Russians, two Ukrainians, eleven Armenians, 35 Letts [Latvians], 15 Germans, one Hungarian, ten Georgians, three Poles, three Finns, one Czech, one Karaim, and 457 Jews."

@user-mk3lo8ir9r

4 ай бұрын

Ты удивишься но потому что евреев в большевиках меньше чем в пресловутом Бунде, который и был самой еврейской партией

@CommieSense

4 ай бұрын

So called "Bund" was in opposition to Bolsheviks. Overall, you seem to be misled bu the "Bolshevik-Jew-Zionist" myth that was invented in early 80's to assist in dismantling the USSR. Falling for such lies in not a common sense! Beware!

@rhfr7929

3 ай бұрын

No one on youtube with any followers is going to ever tell anyone about the roll they played in WW1, WW2, Weimar or current day America.

@DmoneyS44

2 ай бұрын

Jews weren’t a monolith and there is no mention of the “Jewish” role in the bolshevik regime because it is a misconception spread by nazis. The conflict was a first and foremost political. Jewish people played roles just as non jewish ones did.

@DmoneyS44

2 ай бұрын

There is no mention of the “jewish role” in establishing the bolshevik regime because it is at best a mischaracterization and at worst a right wing conspiracy used to try to delegitimize the Russian revolution. The problem with your source wilton was that he was a conspiracy theorist who blamed the death of the Romanovs on a jewish plot. One major problem is that the Romanovs were hated by more than just jews by this point so the idea that the romanovs were killed just because of the jews doesnt make any sense. Jews werent a monolith and many were loyal to their countries over judaism.

We should acknowledge that all the nice people in the recent history were juice, except for Mao and Pol Pot.

#bring back the Russian Empire

It was a good video until you ruined it with your illiterate liberal takes about "dictator stalin" and "utopia".

@CommieSense

4 ай бұрын

This is typical for western "historians" that were taught by "correct books"... Good thing is - history is not about the past. It is about the future. And the future is almost here...