How old is each Thomas & Friends character's basis? T&F Age Comparison
This video is comparing the ages of when a character's basis was first built, evolved, naturally created ect.
Here are some rules that I went by:
1. I based a characters year date/country of origin on the year that the first of their basis was built (Main exceptions to this are the SKR, CFR and the human characters, there are other characters that are excepted to this rule which I will point out in the timeline)
2. Canonical year dates from the series are not counted for, more info at 0:19
3. If a character was originally a freelance design, I will use a similar looking basis to get a year date and country of origin
4. If a character does not have a country of origin, then they will still be in the list. This list is about year dates mostly, not country origins.
5. Precise dates are not included. Only year dates.
6. Only characters from the RWS and TVS are in this list with a few exceptions explained in 0:43
Idea by RedoStone35
Music Credits:
0:00 - Elektronomia & RUD - Memory - NoCopyrightSounds
0:48 - Lost Sky Fearless pt.II - NoCopyrightSounds
1:58 - Ascending the Vale - Kevin MacLeod
3:07 - A Day At The Court - Victoria 2
4:07 - Rome Theme - Medieval - Civilization 6
4:50 - Krakow - Hearts of Iron IV
6:14 - Luftwaffe Strikers Again - Hearts of Iron IV
9:00 - Winter - Victoria 2
11:23 - Russia 1917 - Victoria 2
13:03 - Inventions - Victoria 2
15:00 - The Horde - Warcraft: The Beginning
17:53 - Fire Festival (Alliance) - World of Warcraft
19:04 - Electro-Light - Symbolism pt. III - NoCopyrightSounds
The FULL Story of Eppleton Hall’s Transatlantic Voyage - The Unlucky Tug
• Video
The COMPLETE History of Henry the Green Engine - The Unlucky Tug
• Video
Google spreadsheets I used (Note: It's outdated af)
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
Let me know if you would like a version of this video but without the "How old their basis is" rule. For example, Stepney's year date would be 1875 instead of 1872 if I made that video.
Пікірлер: 180
Since people don’t like reading the description or the beginning of the video I’ll say it here. The dates are based on when the FIRST of the characters basis was built. Yes Toby was canonically built in 1914 but the FIRST of his basis was built in 1903, hence why he’s placed there. Let’s put this into perspective with the information in the video. Gremlin the dog’s origin date is 3,700 BC in the VIDEO, and considering the life span of dalmations is 10-14 years, he would’ve died at 3686 BC or sooner. WAYY BEFORE charters like Stephen was even built. Gremlin appeared in an episode with Thomas and Gordon and if he was born in 3,700 BC then he shouldn’t’ve been in the episode with that logic. The origin date for Gremlin is a reference to when dalmations were FIRST bred. Another example. I ranked the elephant in Henry and the Elephant to 34 million BC because it was around the time the first elephants started to appear (I think, I’m not fully sure but it was 100% a very long time ago). ANYWAYS, IF the elephant that appears in the episode was born 34 million years ago then that would mean that the elephant is a time traveler because the episode includes HENRY who wasn’t built until 1919, canonically. I hope that cleared things up. I’m surprised nobody caught onto the fact that I CLEARLY didn’t incorporate canonical build dates when the TOAD(the animal, not the breakvan) is older than Thomas, Edward, Gordon and James by 310 MILLION years. Did it not seem strange that the animals were all older than the train characters? Yes there were exceptions to the “first-basis-built” rule but they’re only a small minority in the video. And of COURSE I will make mistakes, it’s a LARGE set of characters I’m researching and I’m human just like you are. If you notice a mistake, great, tell me where I went wrong and give me some evidence, I’ll really appreciate it. Sorry for this little rant but I really had to adress it!!!
@jeletin
Жыл бұрын
He’s the same model as Thomas tho
@incompetentdiplomat3716
10 ай бұрын
harold is a sikorsky s-55/s-19 so hes from 49-50 instead of 51, doesnt matter much but i just like harold. hes also american.
@Ukrainyi1917
10 ай бұрын
You did a mistake. Henry and Gordon's basis were built in Late 1918 And yes Henry and Gordon were built by the same company Henry was Probably built in 1919. Gordon although was built in 1921. 3 years after Henry If that can make an explanation to some things Wrong And if you Put Henry based as the LMS black 5s im Sorry for my mistake
Thomas being older then Gordon is so cursed
@user-si2zg5nu3h
11 күн бұрын
Ben being older than bill is cursed
@noname-iw3tj
10 күн бұрын
I have a theory that they age the more work they do since they are machines for example if thomas was built and hasnt been used in 5 years while edward was working himself to shreds in those 5 years Thomas would physically be in a better working condition that could be an excuse to make gordon older than thomas
Emily's designer was of Scottish descent, so it makes sense that she has a Scottish accent. It also does for Connor and Caitlin, as their basis were built by Irish immigrants. Also, Connor is a New York Central locomotive while Caitlin is a Baltimore & Ohio locomotive.
I like that ben is older than bill and i like to see a mature and grown up ben
@kaldesyzdi595
11 ай бұрын
twins are same old. if one were older that the other then they wouldn't be twins then.
The standard gauge treat the narrow gauge engines like little engines in the show. But in real life the narrow gauge engines are very, very old.
@legoisthebest001SCR
Жыл бұрын
That's just hit era stuff
@ThomasAndRandomRobloxGames
Жыл бұрын
@@legoisthebest001SCRlol
@AlexsStopMotionAdventures
Жыл бұрын
Hit era skarloey and rheneas be like: goo goo gaa gaa I’m a baby, waa, waa, I want milky milk.
@toadbreakvan1107
11 ай бұрын
@@AlexsStopMotionAdventureslmao
@toadbreakvan1107
11 ай бұрын
bro have u not seen season 4?
Lady is that young??? It doesnt make sense how she appear during 1930s-1950s Thomas and the magic railroad. Oh i forgot, She is a claimed to be Godess
@Toby-wu4ve
Жыл бұрын
Actually her Country of Origin is England
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
@@Toby-wu4ve if you consider her two potential basis shown on the wiki, then yeah her COO would be England. But in this list I went for the life-sized model of Lady because that is her basis technically. I could only assume that it was built in the USA because the wikia says that the life sized model was transported from NY to LA after the movie released. Yeah, it didn’t say it was built there but I could only assume it was built in NY and stayed there until the movie’s premiere. It still remains in Florida.
I'm starting to think maybe Bradford was used during WW2; his mannerisms do sound like they come from the military and he's built during that timeframe.
@MineraftxD
Жыл бұрын
Could have sam got shellshock by artillery in WW1? (I mean, I know Bradford was made during the 2nd and not ww1, but probably the earl or who ever is incharge of Sam signed him the breakvan in order to atleast try and keep calm the locomotive or idk wut i'm saying :/)
@numberjacksoctonauts7138
Жыл бұрын
@@MineraftxD Perhaps...
Timothy’s basis could have been built anytime between 1908 and 1934.
10:42 Connor was a J3a, introduced in 1937-38 J1 hudsons were introduced in 1927.
started laughing uncontrollably at Boulder being the oldest character. Of course he is! It's a rock! But it still caught me off guard XD Update: still laughing as we go through the animal characters. This video isn't missing ANYONE I see :] thank you
@flickcentergaming680
2 ай бұрын
I did not expect Boulder to even be on the list, but I'm glad he was!
The tumbleweed is counted as an character? What other character will we have? the floor boards from Percy's Promise?
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Omg yes!! Thanks for the idea!!
@TimTheWellTank
Жыл бұрын
Ok...
@rheneastheorangetankengine8727
8 ай бұрын
@@cactusparty258here's my headcannon: Before season 1: 1853-1920 Season 1-7: 1921-1967 Season 8-12: 1968-1972 Season 13-16: 1973-1976 Season 17-21: 1977-1981 Season 22-24: 1982-1984 After season 24: 1985-2023
can you do one of where every characters basis/class are now, like if they are scrapped preserved still in serves or not etc?
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
A quantity comparison, if that’s what you mean, is an idea I’ve had for a bit actually…
@florjanbrudar692
Жыл бұрын
Boco's number was of a real class 28 which was scrapped, D5702
No wonder I like Salty so much, he and my father are the same age! Happy 62nd, Salty!
Hey peeps, I would like to adress some oopsie poopsies I've noticed by myself. 1. Captain's description says he's the only boat in the list with a known basis which is incorrect. I added skiff in the list last minute and I forgot to change the description. 2. The slip coaches weren't treated like the Horrid Lorries, I counted the slip coaches as 1 entry but the rankings below them only go up by two so not much changes really. 3. Emily and the Tumbleweed's part of the timeline are misused. They were created/introduced in 1870 which is still part of the same decade as Duke, Rheneas, Whiff ect and yet they have the background and timeline music of 1871-1880. I have no "good" excuse. I just thought the music would fit better if Emily was the first character introduced. The same also applies to Molly. 4. The background for 1991-2000 has the Class 390 as its background when the EMU itself was built in 2001 and introduced in 2002. Again no good excuse, I just wanted to add it. 5. samson's entry mentions that Glynn is older than him which is incorrect. I did mention that I originally placed Glynn between stephen and Iron Duke in his description so this was just me forgetting to update samson's entry. 6. In Lady’s entry I was talking about her life-sized model. Not the gauge 1 model.
@thiagolimawestwood1686
Жыл бұрын
The timelines u got wrong are Duke/Bertram Sir Handel Emily Toby Flying Scotsman was built in 1923 as this year in Feb was his 100th birthday Bill and ben Donald and Douglas
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
@thiagolimawestwood1686 NOTE: sorry if I come across as agressive in this reply but I have to adress it. I’m assuming you didn’t read what I wrote at the beginning of the video, and in the description so I’ll tell you here. I’m basing the built dates on when the FIRST of their basis was built. So let’s go over the characters you listed. Duke/Bertram: Canonically Duke was built in 1879 and Bertram has no built date confirmed so he’s already crossed off. The FIRST of Duke's basis was built in 1863 (From what I’ve researched) so he’s ranked as 1863 with Bertram. Sir Handel: Same with Duke (Except Sir Handel was built in 1904). Also odd you didn’t mention Proteus. Emily: Like with Bertram, she has no confirmed build date. First basis was built in 1870 and it checks out with the video. Toby: Same with Duke and Sir Handel Flying Scotsman: Read the description at 9:16 in the video Bill/Ben: Read the description at 12:30 and 15:57 in the video Donald/Douglas: Okay, yes I know they’re 652’s and the first was built in 1908, but they’re almost identical to 812’s so who cares? Right?? I even adressed this and explain in more detail in their descriptions at 6:04 and 6:09. So I will give you the win here. With that all being said, word of advice. If you’re gonna tell someone they’re factually wrong, could you explain and give evidence as to WHY they are wrong? Because just saying that I got Donald and Douglas’ build dates “wrong” without explaining why I’m wrong doesn’t exactly help me fix my mistakes
@ThomasAndRandomRobloxGames
Жыл бұрын
@@cactusparty258was it just easier to do first build dates?
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
@@ThomasAndRandomRobloxGamesYeah, because some characters (especially the non-RWS ones) don’t have canonical build dates
Congrats Madlad, You Put Lady’s Basis Being Her Life Size Model Instead Of The Engine Unlucky Tug Mentioned. I Respect That. EDIT: Also Why Do People Only Ask That Glowing Eyes Question About Caroline, When The Same Question Also Applies To Brum And Belinda, Who Both Also Have The Headlight Eyes Going On
3:57 TRXN A bad day for Sir Handel? Nice reference, have a subscriber Also was the image for 9:12 intentional?
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Yes and yes!! :O Also ty for subscribing
I was a little afraid you weren’t gonna add Lady she is my favorite
I can’t believe it toad is older than Toby and Edward 😮
@daviszdirector
4 ай бұрын
He isn't. The years in this video are when their basis began to manifacted, not the actual years they were built. Toad for example, wasn't even built the 1940's
1:45 Are you sure Stephenson is not a replica? After the trails, the locomotive was modified to be similar to his later Northumbrian design.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
I’d say there is a high chance he is the actual Rocket
I know that I'm late to the correction game, but Bear the diesel's number is 7101, 7101 isn't a separate diesel
The amount of people who didn't watch the beginning or read the pinned comment is astounding.
Thx
All the thomas characters were built before me at the zoo
Idk if you are willing to update the list but in a new Japan exclusive Thomas books they added a MAGLEV character. That would bring the series up to like …2017ish
Hank being a challenger would have been pretty interesting but it would far too big for the British loading gauge
Wilbert (engine) is the funniest character in the franchise
15:47 fuck Fernando That got me laughing soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much
Emily is older than Edward 😂
@florjanbrudar692
Жыл бұрын
Yes, what's funny about that?
@mosquitoxicuguinhiaxicugui1893
6 ай бұрын
@@florjanbrudar692 I think it's because of Emily's personality that makes people think that she is younger than Edward. Like at first glance, many would not believe that she is almost 30 years older than him.😅
Rauls parent company: YOU ARE GOING TO BRAZIL
12:21 Green Arrow
The background is a derailed tank engine?
I do miss mighty mac to bad it isn't in the present series
Judy and Jerome are in the adventure begins which takes place in 1925 but weren’t built until 1960?
@cactusparty258
11 ай бұрын
Listen, they were one of the few character build dates I was unsure of.
tumbleweed killed me xD
What about other characters from Ivan’s chilly way home and my oc
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
I only incldue characters in the Railway Series, the TV series and TUGS. Anything outside of that will not appear in my comparison videos.
This reminds me of the e2 class steam locmove😢
correction: Thomas was built in 1915, not 1913. if he was built in 1913, he wouldn't have his famous extended side tanks
@cactusparty258
12 күн бұрын
Please read the pinned message
there are 1 maby 2 other trucks that are named if you count fred pelham from the rws the other is hector
I seriously gotta personally just suddenly point out that Victor: the locomotive who works @ the Sodor Steamworks @ Crovan's Gate certainly happens to be very shockingly surprisingly just 1 of the exact over 7O,OOO different types of American-origin locomotives built by Baldwin Locomotive Works in the officially well-known state of Pennsylvania in the city of Philadelphia! Plus, you'll be very shockingly surprisingly pleased to happily know that I seriously just suddenly realized that his own official real-life locomotive basis counterpart was basically built to run on standard gauge tracks! He'd been sent to work in Cuba for their own official sugar industry, but nonetheless some years later, he'd been officially sent to the Island of Sodor where he ran into a misunderstandable mishap when nobody understood what he tried to tell 'em that the chains holding down his own official 4 drive wheels to the ship's deck were un-ship-shape SINCE he only spoke Espanol back then when he was basically painted yellow with green lines! Plus, according directly to the info right here, he's a saddle-tank/pannier tank engine design! I seriously guess that you certainly COULD say that he's a hybrid of Percy the Small green saddle-tank engine alongside Duck the Great Western Railway 57OO class pannier tank engine! Also, apparently for another awesome well-known fact is basically that come to really carefully think 'bout it much further, Victor certainly happens to be exactly 14 years older than Duck the Great Western Railway 57OO class pannier tank engine! Plus, you'll be very shockingly surprisingly pleased to happily know that despite bein' a narrow-gauge steam-driven railway tank engine, Victor's steam-driven engine makes the exact same chuffing sound as many of the other standard gauge steam-driven railway locomotives on the Island of Sodor's North Western Railway as I seriously listened carefully to the sound of his own official steam-driven engine system very shockingly surprisingly carefully multiple times recently! For example: the show's own official complete full CGI animation era's complete 13-24th seasons including the officially well-known movies that officially include Wobbly Wheels & Whistles in the officially well-known episode titled Victor Says Yes when he certainly did actually have lots of different tasks that he certainly COULDN'T do all @ the same exact time!
@DavidScholz-bu1ix
10 ай бұрын
I seriously do specifically wonderfully officially hope you certainly do actually know what I personally meant to say through extra-specific details!
@DavidScholz-bu1ix
10 ай бұрын
Plus, you'll be very shockingly surprisingly pleased to happily know that I seriously found out through scientific observation, Victor certainly appears to be older than Flying Scotsman himself by 8 years to come to carefully think 'bout it further in detail meaning that Victor who works @ the Sodor Steamworks @ Crovan's Gate certainly happens to be very shockingly surprisingly exactly 1O8 years old despite the official observation that we actually DON'T even know what date of what month that he'd been officially well-knowingly obviously built by Baldwin Locomotive Works!
@DavidScholz-bu1ix
10 ай бұрын
However, it's basically quite good enough for me to happily know that he's exactly 1 out of 7O,OOO different types of American-origin locomotives manufactured by Baldwin Locomotive Works in Philadelphia in Pennsylvania; which certainly would basically explain his own official American accent with a Cuban influence!
@cactusparty258
10 ай бұрын
Oh. Me. Oh. My. That was a lot to digest. If I had to pinpoint a Victor fan, it’d be you.
@DavidScholz-bu1ix
10 ай бұрын
@@cactusparty258 OH, SHUCKS!
bro what about Ivo Hugh, built in 1996?? Also, Lady must have existed around the time of Burnett Stone's childhood in the 1950s.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Again, the basis dates. Also as for Lady I did forget to mention in the video that she is specifically based on her life-sized model in the movie since Lady doesn’t have a pre-existing basis. I just took an estimate as to when her life-sized model was built.
5:53 hey man you got Culdees desc in Shane Dooineys part
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Oh, zwoops… thanks for telling meeeee!! 👍
@SlantTrimreal
Жыл бұрын
@@cactusparty258 you welcome
Wasn't flying scotsman build in 1923 correct me if im wrong 😅
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Yeah he was (or she if ya wanna get fancy) But I’m basing these dates on when the first of their class was built. Read the pinned comment for a more detailed explanation.
i found out that lady was based on a 1950's coal shunting locomotive. sadly, non survived the dieselization and were all scrapped country of origin unclear.
Bradford is a drill sergeant
1:30 - That fish has a Very Wierd Name
I had no idea Oliver was almost as old as Skarloey.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
He isn’t lol. I was just saying if he WAS a GWR class 157 then he would ne almost as old as Skarloey. But he isn’t.
@LegoMiester14
Жыл бұрын
@@cactusparty258He is a 1400 autotank.
so sir handel is about a decade older then skarloey rheneas and duke?
@cactusparty258
11 ай бұрын
The other way round.
I think Boulder is an Angel meant to look after the Island of Sodor
Not to be rude but you missed 2 characters (Carly and a background diesel from BWBA) both of their basis where actually built in the 21st century
BEN IS OLDER THEN BILL BEN IS 1937 BILL IS 1953
Should've put Shane upside down
Wait, so thomas and Tug are tagger top hat was built in 1887 4:41 and oj was built in 1914 8:16
Edward was from Scotland maybay that Albert is from Scotland to
@mr.marvgokul1.7
Жыл бұрын
welp looks like I'm not the only person knows that Edward was built in Scotland
So, the Boulder was made during the stone age? What
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
No, the stone age didn't happen until 2,500,000 BC. Boulder was likely created when the Earth was only 500,000 years old or even younger. Yes, rocks are very old.
@thethomasthetankenginechan4055
Жыл бұрын
@@cactusparty258 oh
@thethomasthetankenginechan4055
Жыл бұрын
@@cactusparty258 I never expected Boulder to be That Old
06:15 HOI4 MUSIC 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
whait i didn't know the tugs are in the show they have there own show called "tugs"
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
I just added them in cuz it felt nice. Also Big Mickey appears in both shows.
1:50 thats inacurate; iron duke's basis is specifically the NRM replica, not the original.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Yikes… true… I’m not sure if the replica is a member of the class’ basis but if it is then I think I might still be correct, I’m not sure. Cuz I’m basing the dates on when the first of the basis was built. If not a member then that would mean Iron Duke would be in 3rd instead of 212th… wow
In Proteus' info you say that Proteus is the Greek equivalent of Neptune, but that's Poseidon.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Okay in my defence… I have none, I’m an idiot. I mean Proteus and Poseidon both begin with P so… no?
@RinneP
Жыл бұрын
@@cactusparty258 seems like a valid defence whaha. Nice video nonetheless!
You forgot to add ivo hugh.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
14:50
After this video , I wish the Thomas x Lady shippers sweet dreams because they’re shipping an E2 that’s over 100 and a one off that’s 23
@ThomasSirHandel
10 ай бұрын
To be fair it's just the basis, not in universe. TVS Thomas barely resembles an E2.
I was kind of hoping for a Boxhill mention, as they were mentioned, but not illustrated, in the book where Thomas goes to NRM. Might not have been really needed since you weren't working off of canonical build dates, and Boxhill being the youngest surviving terrier.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
You have no idea how much joy I’m experiencing right now knowing that someone FINALLY knows I’m not using canonical build dates. And yeah, with the exception of City of Truro and Märklin, I didn’t want to include any faceless locomotive characters so rest in pepperoni Boxhill
Thomas class is 108 years old
Where's Noor Jehan, the Indian diesel locomotive?!
@cactusparty258
10 ай бұрын
I didn’t include most season 22+ characters as stated in the beginning of the video
Phillip was built in 1930
12:27 is green arrow Gordon’s brother?
@cactusparty258
8 ай бұрын
Cousins* They’re both designed by the same person but are different classes.
@Splodge-productions_2010.
8 ай бұрын
@@cactusparty258 like Gordon and Spencer are different engines but same man that built them
I hate to say this but.. Corrections. Thomas:1915. Henry:1919. James:1913. Percy:1900. Toby:1914. Donald and douglas:1909. Oliver:1934. Bill and Ben:1948. Daisy:1960. Stepney:1875. Class 40/D261:1960. Arry and Bert:1955. Murdoch:1960. Bear:1964. Wilbert:1953. Pip and Emma:1978. Bertie:1946. Terrance:1934. Harold:1949. Bulgy:1958. Rheneas:1865. Sir Handel:1904. Peter Sam:1920. Rusty:1957. Duncan:1928. Duke:1879. Ivo Hugh:1996. Little giant:1867. Hiro:1937. Ryan:1925. Patrick:1943. Jeremy:1963.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Okay, see this is what you’re not understanding. The rankings are based on when the FIRST member of its class were first built. Yes, Toby was built canonically in 1914 but the first of his basis was built in 1903 and THAT is what I’m ranking. (Except Percy because the first member of his supposed basis was built in 1872 which is utter pandemonium.) The only ones you got correct were Harold and Terence. I did say that I would rank the characters based on when the first of their basis was built: in the description, multiple replies and even at the beginning of the video. Yes, there were exceptions to this rule (but from the ones you listed the only exceptions to this rule were Bill, Ben and Percy) Didn’t you notice how strange it is that I ranked characters like Gremlin, the toad and Champion WAY before any of the locomotive characters were even built? Sorry for this little rant but I just wanted to clear up any misinformation.
@charlesgerloski7607
Жыл бұрын
I forgive you. Also, You could of put the years 1983 and 1984 because the Christopher Awdry books were published in 1983-2011, and in 9 1984, show came out in 1984 because the show was released. And here are some characters that you did not put in the video. Toby's brothers:1903-1921. Puffing Billy:1813/14. Novelty:1829. Stanley(SG):1920/29. Kevin:1923/30. American Diesel:1958. Thomas' new shape:1960. Gordon's new shape:1939. James' new shape:1924/25. Percy's new shape:Somewhere in the 40's. Dukes new shape:1969. Hiros new shape:1959/79. Victoria's new shape:2007. Dexter's new shape:2018. Henry's newer shape:1992. Gordon's newer shape:1983. Sorry if I kinda blew your mind a little.
Thomas was built in 1915
eurorunner diesel new engine
PERCY IS 126 FUCKING YEARS OLD??? WHAT????
I genuinely hate the fact that Billy and Charlie are older than Edward
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Their class were built between 1881-1926, so there’s a possibility that Edward could be older than them.
Am I really thit old?…
Wait, so henry rebuilt count. Then that means thomas rebuilt should count since his front-running board was rebuilt in the 1960s
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
The thing is with Thomas is that he’s still the same basis after his rebuild, so that’s not counted for. Cool observation tho
@kingkoopa64
Жыл бұрын
@cactusparty258 Well, the thing is, after the rebuilt, he's more of a jinty than an e2, so kinda a new basis
0:58 - WTF?
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
I based the dates on the characters basis when they FIRST appeared, were built, evolved ect. This is why most of the animal characters are at the beginning of the video.
@thethomasthetankenginechan4055
Жыл бұрын
@@cactusparty258 oh ok
How is Bill way younger than Ben if they are twins, that defeats the whole purpose of them being twins
@BHGaming159
11 ай бұрын
Also Stanley has a class and has a build date which is 1934
@cactusparty258
11 ай бұрын
See, I never considered Stanley to be based on the engine that’s on the wiki cuz they look to different (But then again that could be said about most of the characters in the video too). So in that case I suppose I’ll include Stanley in future comparisons. As for Bill & Ben… well they were one of the “exceptions” that I stated at the beginning of the video just because.
@BHGaming159
11 ай бұрын
Oh alright
12:19 Green arrow is a human😂
Where is Ivan
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
He appears at 18:29
6:36 toby was built in 1914
@cactusparty258
11 ай бұрын
Read the pinned comment
11:53 why did you put 2 Henry’s it’s not because of the 2 Henry’s theory
@cactusparty258
8 ай бұрын
Henry’s resembled an A1 before his rebuild. And he IS a Black 5 after his rebuild. Since he had two basis’ he appears twice. I do not believe in the two HeneH theory
@Splodge-productions_2010.
8 ай бұрын
@@cactusparty258 me too. I do not believe the two Henry theory is bullshit
Rheneas was built in 1865 not 1866 btw
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
I based the dates on the characters basis as stated in the beginning of the video. Dolgoch was built in 1886.
@theotherrailway
Жыл бұрын
@@cactusparty258oh oke
Sorry but if this where engines were from then visitor would be incorrect he speaks Spanish in blue mountain mystery and is not from the us he is from Cuba look at unlucky tug’s cgi timeline video it has correct locations on where characters came from also flying Scotsman should have when he was originally built irl.
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
I based these rankings on when the first of their basis was built, evolved, ect (with the exception of thr CFR, SKR and the humans). Hence why the animal characters are at the beginning. This is also why Flying Scotsman shares a spot with Gordon.
i thought edward was the oldest on the steam team
@ThomasSirHandel
10 ай бұрын
it's just the basis, not in-universe. Emily could be a replica for what we know.
stanley has a basis
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
And that is...?
I have 2 problems with this. (No offense) 1. Thomas was built in 1915 2. No way top hat is the oldest tug
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
None taken, also 1. Read the pinned comment 2. It’s possible he was built a lot later, who knows 🤷♀️
Culdee is number 4...
87546 and 98462 where
@betterthanunknownfnaf
Жыл бұрын
I made this comment before I saw the whole video
The music over the first 2 minutes put me off this video.
Where is ben
@cactusparty258
11 ай бұрын
12:29
I DEC TRA
Thomas actually was made in 1915 my facts idk
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
Read the pinned message
Toby?
@cactusparty258
Жыл бұрын
The first of his basis was built in 1903, even though the real Toby was built in 1914. I ranked him on the former.