Malhun sultan ❣❣

Bala khatun ❤️

Malhun sultan💖

I don't know why some Bala fans always try to prove Malhun as fictional. Sultan Abdülhamid grandson Shehzade Orhan believed that they descended from Malhun binte Omer , almost all modern day historians believe that Osman had two wives. The signatured document of Orhan says that Malhun was not Şeyh Edebali daughter's name, she was Ömer Bey daughter. But still they don't want to accept reality

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

You snd me the link of Orhan document?

@AdnanAli-cl8wi

Жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 Unfortunately, due to some issue in my account, I can't post links on KZread. I can send you on Instagram

@Zeynep_mihri

11 ай бұрын

Again, that is incorrect. Why do you keep copy and pasting this comment on every video? The Mekece Foundation did NOT mention Mal Bint Omer as the “wife” of Osman Bey. She is mentioned as one of the women present at the shelter at the time of Orhan Bey. And also, why are people ignoring the sources of Asikpasade, Nesri, Rustem Pasa? They all lived at the time of the Sultan, do you really think that the Sultan would tolerate a writer who misuses the Sultan’s background?

@NJ-rw1rd

11 ай бұрын

Hmm can you plzz tell me where did orhan osmanoğlu said that he is descended from malhun binte omer kindly tell mev???

@AdnanAli-cl8wi

11 ай бұрын

@@NJ-rw1rd I said that he believes that he decended from Mal binte Ömer. As I already told you about Osman Biography competition. He follows two wife Theory as I told you earlier that on the day 16 July 2022 , he organized a competition about biography of Osman Gazi , actually it was a series about all Ottoman Sultans , but we specifically talk about Osman in this case. He asked his followers to comment correct biography of Osman Gazi and the announced that the person who would write the correct information will be winner. Many people commented that day , but he selected two winners "Hussain Öztürk and a girl Asiye" and Orhan mentioned the winners names in a comment and announced that they are winners. Hussain Öztürk commented that Osman married to Mal binte Ömer in 1280 and in 1281 Orhan born from them and he married to Rabia Bala binte Edebali in 1289 and she gave birth to Allaedin Pasha. Orhan replied Hussain with a congratulatory msg on that comment. Asiye was also a winner and she commented about policital and battle life of Osman. So it's clearly show that Orhan believes on two wives theory. If he is one wife theory believer then how can he declare the guy as winner who made a fictional character their ancestor and wife of Osman in the presence of some other comments who said that Mal was daughter of Edebali. Plz go and check that post on Orhan account and scroll comments under the post . Read the Orhan comment mentioning winners and scroll more until you find the comment of Hussain Öztürk , read his comment and read what Orhan replied to him on that comment. I will take 3 or 4 minutes. Hope I answered your query 🙂

I love bala

Alauddin bey , orhan ghazi , savci bey and Fatima hatun is the brave children's in Osman ghazi

Bala and Malhun same person. Osman had 1 wife and her father was Shiekh Edibali - so Bala character. Historically twisting the story in KO as Bala Mulhan one woman...

@NanoNanoozge

Жыл бұрын

Yes

@DIRILISXKURULUSLEGENDS

9 ай бұрын

no it's wrong

orhan ghazi and alauddin is the brave

Greeting From Holy Makkah Maa Sha Allah

Wow!

Love frm punjab, india

Best video of the

Malhun was a busy woman.

@shaiksiddiq7425

2 жыл бұрын

indeed she had 6 sons

@kamranshaikh4483

2 жыл бұрын

Really she is very busy

@DS-ve1eo

2 жыл бұрын

On the TV show didn’t he marry her to be a baby machine. She serve her purpose

@fatimamaryamvlogs8112

2 жыл бұрын

Any problem

@welyaahmed5771

Жыл бұрын

Yes she is

Aladin Bey and Pazarli Bey is Osman and Bala Hatun Son not Malhun 😊

@HACKER-qi1gn

7 ай бұрын

pazarli bey is malhuns

No, no daughter Bala rabial malhun is the daugh of shekh Edebal pls

You forget halime hatun child of Bala and osman

The first Ottoman Historian Asikpasazade, was asked to write history by Sultan Mehmed Fatih. And what Asikpasazade mentioned in his first book is that Malhun Hatun is the daughter of the famous Sheikh Edebali and indeed the names Mal, Malhun, Bala, Rabia, Mal belong to the same woman. The daughter of Sheikh Edebali. The statue of Malhun Hatun in Turkey in the city, Eskisehir mentions "Sheikh Edebali kizi" Which means the daughter of Sheikh Edebali. And not just 1 book mentions the Sheikh Edebali Malhun Hatun, but 5 books more. And there's no book that mentions the Daughter of Omer Bey Malhun Hatun. She is fictional. Sultan Orhan Gazi himself mentioned in his documents that he learned spirituality from his grandfather Sheikh Edebali. Orhan never mentioned Omer Bey, he only mentioned Sheikh Edebali and his daughter Malhun (Bala) but as Kameriye in one document. All of these names belong to the same woman. Neither Omer Bey has a grave nor his fictional Daughter Malhun Hatun. The mother of Orhan Gazi was the daughter Of Sheikh Edebali, Bala Rabia Mal Sultan.

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

Yes but in historical documents the Name of Malhun Bint e Umer is written. If Osman bey had one wife so she was Malhun bala hatun. Orhan gazi mother was Malhun hatun

@Anabiaaaaaa

2 жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 Dear no document mentions Malhun bint e Omer. Even the Ottomans never mentioned Omer Bey and his daughter, they always mentioned Sheikh Edebali kiz Mal Hatun. Even of you visit the tomb Of Sheikh Edebali, there's a document framed which says "Sheikh Edebali kizi Mal Hatun."

@anaya2452

2 жыл бұрын

asikpasazade wrote bala as the mother of orhan bc they wanted the ottoman to have a religious background , they lied , in the mece charter signed by osman or orhan it states mal hatun as the daughter of omer bey mal hatun names are mal/malhun/kameriye

@anaya2452

2 жыл бұрын

@@Anabiaaaaaa and for your information asikpasazade was born 100 years after osman , so are u gonna believe him or a document signed by osman or orhan himslef

@Anabiaaaaaa

2 жыл бұрын

@@anaya2452 Mekece is a piece of fake information. And i can confidently say that. Mostly people rely on that. After Turkey became secular, secularists started writing false information that catched people's mind very fast. And there's also a book written by a secularist "Yavuz bahadiroglu." That books mentions that Sultan Orhan was the Son of Malhun bint e Omer. But what we know secularists hated the Arabs and Prophet Muhammad (Astagfirullah). And their purpose was to seperate the Arabs and Turks. Also, Sheikh Edebali and his Daughter Bala Rabia Mal Hatun were Arab origins. Now you know why Yavuz wrote Malhun bint e Omer. And Mekece document doesn't mention Orhan And Osman. There's just written Omer Bey Kizi Malhun. And that Mekece document was present in the palace from a really long time as Yildiz Cagri's fans say. And as I mentioned in comment earlier, Asikpasazade was the first Ottoman Historian, he was asked to write history by Sultan Mehmed Fatih. Of Course, he was born 100 years after Osman's death. There are hundreds of documents that mention that Orhan is the son Sheikh Edebali's daughter. And it has never been like this that a Sultan's mother will be recorded as some one else just because of the Religious Background. Malhun bint e Omer doesn't have a grave, her father doesn't have grave not even her family members. It's okay if you won't believe Turkish historians then read a book ny a European Author "Sheikh Edebali Kizi Mal Hatun" By Johannes Tralow. Also, the confirmation of Osman's all children isn't there. Because the history mostly talks about Orhan And Alaeddin, because if there are 7 sons of a Bey, only two can't have the right to ascend to the throne.

Drama ma to in kay two sons hai or two daughters hai

please make on video how many children sultan orhan had

@amnahashmi3629

2 жыл бұрын

please banade

OSMAN FIRST WIFE BALA SULTAN AND ORHAN MOTHER BALA SULTAN OTTOMAN EMPIRE FIRST DEVLIT ANA VALIDA MUZIMA MALIKA BALA SULTAN

please allahudiin vs orhan bey per aik video banaye

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

Hmm banao giii

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

Wase mee topic hii search kr rahii thii. Good idea

@amnahashmi3629

2 жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 kab banaye gi my sister

@amnahashmi3629

2 жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 mei bhut kush hui

@amnahashmi3629

2 жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 ap mujh se mashwara kar liya kerein

malhun born brave son of islam and its best mother and wife but bala feel jealous👩‍👩‍👧‍👧🤴👸🕋♥⚔🏳

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

Right

@itx_ari__9005

2 жыл бұрын

Shut up bala doesn't feel jealous u r jealous

@mariumirfan6546

Жыл бұрын

No

@user-jv9ih3my9k

Жыл бұрын

It is not true But yes Malhun jealous bala because bala is first wife of osman

@ashiqali5770

Жыл бұрын

​@@user-jv9ih3my9kbro , who cares if she is the second wife . She is the mother of the ottoman empire.

Allah-Allah, pls do not share the false history. Malhun & Bala were same person. Pls prepare a video showing truths & facts. I’ll suggest you books as well. Aşıkpaşazade, Oruç bey, Neşri, Rüstem Paşa, Lütfi Paşa. And so the grandsons of sultan abdulhamid says. I cannot believe how people call Malhun a warrior and ignore bala’s sacrifices just because in the series she didn’t gave birth to the sultan 😡. ORHAN GAZI WAS BALA HATUN’S SON IN HISTORY.

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

According to Asikpasazade Orhan Gazi mother was Malhun Bala hatun the daughter of sheik. The name was Malhun (Mal) not only bala

@zahrassm

Жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 yes, that means that Malhun was Edebali’s daughter. Doesn’t matters whether Bala was Malhun or Malhun was bala🙃

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

@@zahrassm But according to Ottoman historical documents Orhan gazi mother was Malhun Binte Omer.

@zahrassm

Жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 she wasn’t mentioned as Orhan’s mother or osman’s wife. That can be some other woman too close to their family!? In Orhan’s wife’s document she is mentioned as Orhan’s wife. And if Malhun was really Orhan’s mother then why the whole dynasty ignored their real grandmother? Like the statue of Mal Hatun says she was the daughter of Seyh Edebali. The turkey gov websites too says that Malhun Hatun (Rabia Bala Hatun) was the Daughter of edebali. And also malhun’s name was mentioned after osman’s children why?? Is this Orhan’s respect to his real mother? Edebali’s daughter name was mentioned at the first only

Bala hatun ka two kids ha ap bala ki beti ka zikar ni kar ri agar ya farzi ha to hamid bey ya pazarli bey in dono masa eik bala ka son ha

Çagan efe ak ❤️😘

Pazarli ka bary ma kush bato

Aladdin bey and savci bey son of osman bey and bala hatun and pazarli bey is first son of osman bey not orhan bey

Malhun khatoon is winner .... Yehhhhh

Bala sultan😊😍🙂

Offfff what is the real history about Osman gazi

mashallah apko tareekh ke baray me sab pata hai

BALA HATUN USMON BEY ALAVIDIN ALI♥️

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

💞💞

Poor bala

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

Why?

@sameenamuneer8340

Жыл бұрын

Shut up

@ashiqali5770

Жыл бұрын

​@@historicalworld9141ikr

Why drama is different things

Where is Bala hatun's second child.

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

Bala had only one child

@BalaMalhun

Жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 no bala will have a child in 102 episode she was pregnant in 95 she will have 2 children

@sadimfarzan8237

Жыл бұрын

Yes you are right pushpashastri because Bala had a baby girl too called Halima

@sadimfarzan8237

Жыл бұрын

@@BalaMalhun I agree

@fatemehradmanesh-ge3ms

Жыл бұрын

halime is a fake child of osman and bala

Use Smayee Jung me bete Shauk se Islam ke liyee jaan dete the

Any series like kurulus osman in hindi

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

The great Seljuks (Uyanış: Büyük Selçuklu)

Bala hatun ka or bachy nahi hae?

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

Haleema is fictional baby

OSMAN second son was ALLAUDIN

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

According to Kurulus Osman Alaeddin is second son but According to history Alaeddin born in 1290

@welyaahmed5771

Жыл бұрын

It’s interesting

sultan orhan sons name kasim suleaman pasha sultan murad ; neluifer hatun sons halil ; theodora maria son shazade ibrahim ; asporca hatun son fatima hatun ; asporca hatun duaghter 5 sons 1 duaghter please is pey aik video banaye

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you 💞 jaldi hi banao gii

@amnahashmi3629

2 жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 ap bhut achi hain 💗💗

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

@@amnahashmi3629 time lage ga thora Phale me Malhun Sultan or Halime vs Malhun ki video banao gii

@amnahashmi3629

2 жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 behan gi orhan k aur bete hain shezade eyup yeh ; eftandise k son hain 💙💙 orhan ghazi 6 sons 1 duaghter mujhe koi jaldi nahi hai lekin ashlihan hatun ka banadein

@amnahashmi3629

2 жыл бұрын

mujhe jaldi nahi hai lekin ashlihan hatun pey banadein wo video aisea banye name ashlihan the duaghter of jandar bey the sister of aliyar bey and ural bey 2nd wife of turgut alp 💜💜

But in Osman gazi serials they show bala khaton another pregnancy

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

Kurulus is fictional series

My conversation with some fans who says Malhun is fictional She : None of ancient historian had mentioned Osman's two wives. Me : Ok ! Osman Gazi had how many children? She : 8 Me : Ancient coz historians only mentioned two children, they never mentioned that Osman had 8 children, so how you came to know about other children She : No answer Me : Do you know that people came to know about other children of Osman through mekece document of Orhan Bey. She : So what ? Me : The same document mentions about Mal binte Omer. She : That document is fake no one believes on it. Me : So you mean siblings of Orhan and Alaeddin mentioned in the document are also fake ? Me ending this conversation on last note that , ancient Historians ne to Osman ke dosre 6 children ke baare main bhi nhi likha to kya un ko bhi fictional maan lein . She : No answer

@Zeynep_mihri

11 ай бұрын

My conversation with you: Me: the Mekece chart doesn’t prove that Mal bint Omer is the wife of Osman You: the Mekece mentions the children, so not believing the Mekece means you don’t believe in Osman’s children. And btw, Asikpasade is a LIAR, he just wanted to glorify the sec! Me: did you know that there are three women mentioned in the Mekece, one being Mal bint Omer? And that these women were present at the shelter at the time? So are all three women are wives of Osman according to your logic? You: Stop distorting history! You like actresses and your being biased! I read the Persian script! Mal bint Omer is mentioned as the wife of Osman! Me: nope! Not true. The children’s names are mentioned with “bin Osman”. But how come they didn’t write “Mal Hatun bint Omer eşi Osman? You: *silence* Me: How come you are ignoring other sources by different historians (other than Asikpasade who you dearly hate?). How come you just read books on Mal bint Omer aka the two wife theory? I smell bs! You: the Mekece chart, the OLDEST chart proves it! Orhan has written it him self! Malhun is the mother of Orhan and the daughter of Omer! The Mekece chart proves it! Me: can you explain why the Mekece was taken down by the Topkapi Palace? Can you explain why Turkish schools teach otherwise? Can you explain the interactions between Osman and Omer? Can you explain how the marriage of Mal bint Omer and Osman took place? Can you explain where the grave of Mal bint Omer and Omer bey is? Can you explain why Murad I (son of Orhan) mentioned the importance of Ahis and none regarding Omer? Can you explain why the Turkish community built Mal Hatun Meydani, Mal Hatun Camii, Mal/Bala Hatun Turbesi, Orhan Gazi Camii, and Valide MalHatun School in the name of Edebali’s daughter? You: The Mekece chart says Mal bint Omer! She’s the mother of Orhan! Me: also, how do you know about the Siege of Bursa, and the importance of Orhan Bey? You: *silence* Me: through Asikpasade, and early authors of the Ottomans. So will you call that a lie? Will you call these historians, who lived during the time of the Sultans, who knew the consequences of lying about the Sultan’s family, liars? Where’s your proof, sources? You: stop distorting history! You are just like one of these KO fans! Me: you didn’t prove crap. Edit: based on a true story. trust me, there’s more crap that this user has displayed, and he is nothing but a lame KO fan. Seek out to a professional researcher instead of KZread 🤌

@AdnanAli-cl8wi

11 ай бұрын

@@Zeynep_mihri Lie , A complete lie ! And My conversation with you , Me : If Mekece is baseless according to you, then why you believe on Osman other children? You : Silence 😂 Me : Why Shehzade Orhan declared Hussain Ozturk winner who commented Osman had two wives? You : Silence According to your logic , if Mal was wife of Osman in that document then other three women too , I already told you that Efendi was wife of Orhan and Melek was granddaughter of Osman. You : Silence Even Fatma was not mentioned by her husband name , she was also mentioned by her father name , same with Malhun. And you arrogant girl ! Don't you know that Osman had already died that time , after the death of husband , women are not mentioned with her husband names in official documents. Me : Why the dream story is referred to two different personalities by ancient historians? You : Malhun is fictional Me : Where is the proof that Mekece was removed from toptapi coz it was baseless? You : Silence😂 Me : you believe on history books narrations which don't even match each other and written after a century but you don't believe on Orhan words that all witnessed are his heirs? You : Silence Me : why Nesri has written that Osman kidnapped Şeyh daughter ? You : Nesri is credible Me : Can you explain why all Turkish government official websites mentioned Mal binte Ömer ? You : Keep crying 😭😂 Me :You don't have proof that mekece is removed from Topkapı lol? Me : Graves of Malhun and other children are in Osman's tomb but destroyed due to Earthquakes and it is mentioned in books of historians M.Cagatay Uluçay and Leslie. P. Pierce and also on official website of Turkish Ministry of culture and Tourism? You : Silence 🤐 You : Malhun is fictional bcoz ancient historians didn't mentioned her? Me : They didn't mentioned Osman's children and they too don't have graves ( Fatma , Hamid , Savcı , Melik ) You : No she is fictional 😭 bcoz he are jealous of her According to you Orhan Gazi is a liar too , you called the document signatured by him a false document . According to you , Erdoğan government is Liar too , which has mentioned Mal binte Ömer in official websites. According to you , Shehzade Orhan is a liar , who made Hussain Öztürk winner of Osman's biography competition? Can you explain how Osman married to Şeyh daughter actually bcoz all the history books telling us different stories about their marriage? Can you explain why ancient historians didn't know about other children of Osman? Can you explain who actually saw that dream , two books referring to two different persons.Can you explain why 99 percent of modern historians believe on two wives? You : Bcoz they are kemalist Me : Malhun has nothing to do with Mustafa Kemal. Me : Can you explain if İsmail Hakkı was kemalist then why he told world that what Sultan Murad has said about Ahi efforts for empire and why he presented the land documents of Eskişehirto the world which was gifted by Osman to Bala on wedding? Can you explain why most of the Turkish people believe on Mal binte Ömer as she is mentioned by 99 percent government official websites and 99 percent modern day historians Keep crying , Orhan Gazi had written her as his heir and ottoman decendents believe that, now cry more ? Lol And don't lie , I have provided you all the answers, read again , where I have said that Aşıkpasazade was glorifying his sect , read again I said he had incomplete info. Plz read again previous comments , I had already explained everything

Bu videodakilerin hepsi yanlış. Osman Bey'in tarihte tek eşi var oda Şeyh Edebali'nin kızı Bala (Mala/Malhun/Mal/Rabia) Hatundur. Ve tüm evlatlar ondandır. Tarihte Ömer Bey kızı Malhun yoktur. Malhun hatun dedikleri kadın Şeyh Edebali'nin kızının adıdır. Tarihte sadece o var ve tüm evlatlar ondandır. Aşıkpaşazade, Oruç Bey, Rüstem Paşa, Ahmet Şimşirgil, Halil İnalcık dahil tüm tarihçiler böyle söyler. Ve Osman Bey'in eşine ait tek mezar/kabir vardır oda Bilecikte'dir.

@renatabrutel-tuczko1461

2 жыл бұрын

You are wrong, Malhun is mother of Orhan Sultanand 6 more choldren. Bala is mother only Aladdin. Bala fans do not to accept this historical fact. Malhun Sultan is mother of state.

@zahrassm

Жыл бұрын

@@renatabrutel-tuczko1461 nope you are wrong, Malhun fans disagree facts.

@fatemehradmanesh-ge3ms

Жыл бұрын

aşko mekece vakfiyesinde malhun hatun binti omer bey geçiyor bala ve malhun bir kişi değildir ve orhan gaziye ayit bir vakfiyedir.

Bala stan do not want to exsept reality so they say that they was same , and daughter of sheikhadabali , no Osman Ghazi married Malhun Sultan in 1280 and Orhan Ghazi was born in 1281 , and Osman married Bala in 1288 only on advice of Sheikh adabali, Malhun Sultan was the first and beloved wife of osman ghazi, kameria sultan, zumurd Anka, and Develet ana ❤️👑⚔️🗡️👑❤️

फेंक है

This video is fake.Bala had 4 to 5 children.Not only one child.

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

Ok, tell me the name of the book

@Anabiaaaaaa

2 жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 Asikpasazade Tarihi, Oruc Beg Tarihi, Nesri Tarihi, Tevarih i Al I Osman By Kemalpasazade, Tevarih I Al I Osman by Lutfi Pasha, Tarihi i Al I Osman By Rustem Pasha. All these 6 books were written during the reign of Ottomans. And they mention the daughter of Sheikh Edebali was the mother of Orhan Gazi.

@historicalworld9141

2 жыл бұрын

@@Anabiaaaaaa yes, but they all mention the name " Malhun Bala hatun" the daughter of sheikh and the mother of Orhan.

@Anabiaaaaaa

2 жыл бұрын

@@historicalworld9141 Exactly. The exactly what I said, Malhun was the Daughter Of Edebali. But the Malhun that we've been showed in the series is the daughter of omer, who is fictional.

@shahwaranigar6272

2 жыл бұрын

@@Anabiaaaaaa nope

Bala hatun ki ak or beti bhi thi Halima

@historicalworld9141

Жыл бұрын

History me osman gazi ki haleema.name ki koi beti nai thiii

@smallyoutuber4012

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for the Information

Ja ja Malhun no tuvo tantos hijos gue Bala pero bueno el huionidta es un lovo imaginario no sabe lo que le gusta a la audiencia Es el smor rntre Bals y Osman.

ne pas vrais 100 pour 100

fake news

@hannantv2862

2 жыл бұрын

Yes

@azwahahsan7390

2 жыл бұрын

Yes

@shahwaranigar6272

2 жыл бұрын

bozdag crate own history

@ashiqali5770

Жыл бұрын

How do you know it's fake . Do some research to prove your point 😂

@mredz88

Жыл бұрын

@@ashiqali5770 I knew because you're FAKE too!🤣🤣🤣

Dejen de debatir ests mas claro que el agua solo existio la hijsa del jeque Edebali por lo menos tiene tumba y representa mejor la historia otomana que un personaje ficticio como Malhun que aparece mas que uns esposa sino como una amante saca maridos

@amvharem3357

Жыл бұрын

Oh shut up