India's population is 1.48 billion, while the total population of Europe, with more than 45 countries, is about 740 million. China is a highly homogeneous country with 90% Han Chinese population and 80% of the population speaks the same language, Mandarin. The most spoken language in India is Hindi, spoken by only 48% of the population, and this includes dialects like Bhojpuri. Standard Hindi is spoken by only 27% of the population. India is subcontinent functioning as a country.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

Amazing when you think about it that way

@main_stream_media_is_a_joke

4 күн бұрын

All 4 corners of India as well as central India are wildly different in almost all aspects of their lives. We have forcefully brought these wildly different people and made them stay together as 1. Every state is the size of a European country. One reason why India hasn't progressed as much is because of totally different people forced to work together as 1 when that is far from the case.

@rjpadbatan669

4 күн бұрын

China is almost homogenous now but it was due to the forced assimilation policies of the long lines of emperors in China's history. China was made of many warring states with their own language, culture and traditions. First emperor Shi Huangdi went on a bloody forced assimilation process. He forced one language one system with brute force and conquered almost all of present day China. Which is why China is the world's oldest and longest lasting empire. The current communist leaders are not unlike the emperors of the past. They are continuing the policies of the past.

@saurabhrawat3878

4 күн бұрын

No bro you are wrong china is Also diverse but China goverment delibrately start the hanisation of whole china. Infact now they are hanising the Muslim population of china they have order that Mosque would be in certain chinese artitechure.

@YourFuhrer1933

4 күн бұрын

​@@main_stream_media_is_a_jokethat's why India matters because we are one otherwise we are nothing better than sub Saharan Africa

Finally someone said it. Too much diversity and happy politics to Celebrate it will ultimately hamper any major reforms.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

Needs a balance 🧘🏽‍♂️

@alonewithmythoughts5035

3 күн бұрын

Well the latter option is homogeneity but India cannot embrace homogeneous because we're diverse our survival as a country depends on gujaratis and tamils working together, and it takes respect to do so

@thomascromwell6840

2 күн бұрын

That sounds as ridiculous as it is.

@AjayKumar-hh6hx

Күн бұрын

Well, let's build a time machine and prevent homosapiens and neanderthals from ever merging in India

We are diverse, not divided. "All Indians are my brothers and sisters" are not just words for me. They are my true feelings.

Your video explains the Indian political dilemma better than some Indian political scientists. Great work.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

❤️

@vorrdegard2176

3 күн бұрын

His video explains typical western view

@NoThing-ec9km

22 сағат бұрын

Yes

Bhārat is diverse and united because our concept is not ‘Unity in Diversity’ but ‘Diversity in Unity’

@sreedharreddyabbidi5374

Күн бұрын

Yes. These westerners coming from homogeneous societies will never understand this.

@Zzmaster_-mj2xv

Күн бұрын

Muh unity. Indian cope

@buddha9715

18 сағат бұрын

Pissy enough?​@@Zzmaster_-mj2xv

I am not Indian but i have Indian ancestors and i have been to India only once.. during 10 days i travelled hundreds of miles througout the land by car and by plane..it was really an unbelievable experience..it was like travelling through different countries altogether..from Delhi to Punjab via Agra then to Jaipur and finally to Mumbai before going to back to Delhi...one thing that helps very much is knowledge of Hindi language which i learnt at school..and by watching Hindi movies...because in all different places people also speak Hindi even if they their own regional mothertongue.. i could understand why India is without any discission the most complex country and most difficult to administer in the world..

@wazukyan7696

2 күн бұрын

Is Hindi spoken by everyone ?

@RojaJaneman

Күн бұрын

People like this r trying to use academics to tear it apart with these baseless theories from within and without. Diversity has always been their strength. Until u mix a group that believes u r not acceptable as u r but they can help change it; all u gotta do is surrender to their ideas/book. Then there’s no chance. Up until that point, u can live together. Doesn’t mean there’ll always b pewce. Even families never live in complete peace. But they love and value each other

too much diversity its like a clash of cultures who dont like each other

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

needs a healing balm

@crazy_for_kpop562

Күн бұрын

We Hindus don't hate each other's culture. Neither Jain's, Sikhs and baudhs.

Christains and Muslim societies can advance rapidly because its easy for them to organise an entire population under a Pope, Caliph, or Imam, and have a consensus over what they want to do. But the same cant happen in Hinduism because Hinduism is not a single organised religion with a strict code of law, its a set of many religions and beliefs co existing, One community will say its bad to do animal sacrifice, another won't see any issue with it, the only factor binding them is that they all come from the same vedic roots and are under the Dharmic fold under which they organise when needed.

@karumotoart5040

4 күн бұрын

Umm Pakistan

@HDB41

4 күн бұрын

​@@karumotoart5040Yes, any Islamic country can develop and advance including Pakistan. The only thing holding them back are their own political leaders, maulvis, and imams, who preach that education and science are creations of satan to distract Muslims. They do this because its easy to hold power over a weak and dumb society, and so they spread hate, and focus more on converting others to gain more power. The real enemies of Islam are Muslim leaders, preachers, and influencers themselves.

@HDB41

4 күн бұрын

​@@karumotoart5040As a matter of fact, compared to the standards of middle ages Muslim societies before the fall of the Abbasid Empire were very tolerant, scientifically driven, and advanced in all fields, that's why it's called the "Golden age of Islam". After the fall of Baghdad due to the Mongols Islam and Muslims became so highly regressive that we are seeing its effects till today.

@karumotoart5040

4 күн бұрын

@HDB41 I do remember reading something on those lines. When I think about it, you have countries like pak and Iran and then you also have uae, qatar. What explains this diversity in outcomes in all these countries?

@HDB41

4 күн бұрын

​​@@karumotoart5040The diversity in outcome is solely due to leadership, and government structure, all these successful Islamic countries like Saudi, Qatar, or UAE, has monarchy, whose kings are prudent, while Iran and Pakistan tried democracy, and whenever Muslims are given democracy they always elect some regressive religious leader and these leaders ban education and science because they think it's a creation of Satan, and so keeping the population weak and dumb helps them in keeping their power at the cost of the general public.

Kaliyuga and its effects Either way I cannot disagree if someone says god himself saved India ( divine intervention) because India is so diverse,it should've been broken into multiple small kingdomes some 64 years ago,but somehow it didn't and it's growing VERY rapidly

@gtmashok

4 күн бұрын

Technically, it did break apart in 1947 thanks to the sweeping demographic changes on the western and eastern flanks of the Indian Subcontinent 1,200 years ago.

@NobleDorito8698

4 күн бұрын

@@gtmashok Yeah,but I mean,we still exist don't we? All those centuries of brutal foreign invasions and we,our culture,our religion, still manages to exist

@theislander-sj1kq

4 күн бұрын

​@NobleDorito8698 apart from Muslims most of the Indians practice Hinduism ( many sects of Hinduism) is what keeps the country united. I don't think the country would eventually be divided due to foreign influences and overseas Indians returning with their corrupted valurs.

@shimankumaheshwari6904

3 күн бұрын

God saved India. That God was Mahatma Gandhi to be precise.

@NobleDorito8698

3 күн бұрын

@@shimankumaheshwari6904 Mahatama Gandhi? My foot🤣👌 Go and get yourself educated about the Ideological subversion of India. And don't forget that if it wasn't for Patel,then the whole of Punjab and Kashmir would've been Pakistan today. Not to mention those princely states who would've never accepted Gandhian diplomacy

India is not a single country - its a continent pretending to be a country. Bharata varsha literally means the continent of Bharata. India always had 100s of countries within itself.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

Jai Bharat

@pradeeptumatius4538

4 күн бұрын

Don't fall for this "India is not a single country" logic... United we stand, divided we fall just like how we have fallen twice.. once to Muslims and second to east india company.

@Aadi_Varaah

4 күн бұрын

BharatVarsha means Country of India...Bharat khand means continent of India.

@D.S.handle

3 күн бұрын

I mean, it is a continent and a country.

@aritrabhattacharyya8797

3 күн бұрын

@@Aadi_Varaah Not really as per Puranas Varsha is a geographical land mass that has certain number of mountain ranges and ocean on 2 or more sides. And there are 7-9 such Varshas in the world. So that clearly shows they were thinking of it as a continent.

Such an accurate and on point description about India from probably someone who isn't Indian is super rare but you literally nailed it not just discussed the ground reality in full depth but also covered the on going political scenario perfectly. You earned my respect hope more such quality informative videos further.

@TheEmissaryCo

2 күн бұрын

Haha I am Indian-American but yes not born or raised in India

Not only is our strong society too diverse but at a mean level, the quality of our human capital is very low. This means that being democracy and freedom hasn't lead to enough of us leveraging it for entrepreneurship and innovation but hold the state hostage and demand freebies and appeasement.

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Luckily I think human capital of india is only rising now!

@kimseokjin2803

Күн бұрын

Yesss. Indians have become too comfortable with entitlement.

This the most accurate description of India in the shortest possible video.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

thanks a lot!

For a country like india, We need strict leaders who proudly support the indic values and cultures, which are followed by almost 88% of the people.

Indian society is back not coz of it's diversity coz at the end we all are same in a way but it is back coz of corrupt politicians. It's just democracy is not made for such a huge country it needs a patriotic permanent leader. Bharat ( India) was at it's peak as akhand bharat at the time of king maurya, ashoka and gupta.

@chirag4648

3 күн бұрын

The people choose their representatives. Therefore, it is impossible to hold politicians repeatedly responsible for lack of development or backwardness if the people electing them are the ones who do so repeatedly.

@lly_09

3 күн бұрын

Bharat was whatever before centuries ago, and during those ancient times, the whole of northeast wasn't present, stop including us in the history that we never were in there.

@shobhitdagur1086

3 күн бұрын

​@@lly_09if you get converted for some money that's not our problem bcoz North East was always Bharat

@Awesome-21

2 күн бұрын

​@@lly_09 North East was ruled by many dynasties and tribals. The most prominent of them was the Ahom dynasty which ruled from 1228 to 1826. Almost 6 centuries. And most of the rulers and general population converted to Hinduism ( Sanatani ) and the North East also had many trade with the other parts of India too and some major parts of North East was under the Gupta Empire and Nanda Empire for centuries. Hence, your claim is invalid and thus I also believe that you ain't even an Indian to begin with. So, first get some knowledge and then speak!

Imho, India will always need a more federal govt structure, where states can have more say about their governance, India is too large & diverse to be controlled from delhi and not every state is the same, some are industralized and others are not. Cause while I don't like to admit it, India has never been united as a whole, and when it will we would have long passed the time to benefit from our population dividend. We've always been more like europe as a continent and the only times we've been united is when under a dictatorship.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

More power should be given to municipal rather than state gov’s imo

@YandereEnthusiast

4 күн бұрын

@@TheEmissaryCo True, actually if I'm not wrong congress actually wrote in its manifesto to convert cities into mayoralties whether it would actually do it or not is up for debate, bjp or others should add it to their manifesto as most of the mlas or mps are from rural areas and don't really give a F about cities and are there just to earn money.

@lly_09

3 күн бұрын

Agreed, India never was united truly, because we've to much differences within. I'm from the northeast so I'll only speak for it. The northeast is the most economically, industrially, educational, developmentally backward region, since it's merging with India. It's also the most conflict prone region given its geography and it's history of how it truly came to join India. The Indian union have ignored, neglected NE for the longest time, hampering our development in many ways, we aren't visible until it's some resources, geographical interest, as we have international borders too. I could write more but I'm tired. Anyways, I don't like the current India, as a citizen from a minor community, religion, a small state

@madhusudhanraovengamsetty407

3 күн бұрын

​@@lly_09 whether you kiek Or not india is 1 country and those who ignored North East are congress even now congress bring politics into serious issues north east bengal tamil nadu whenever BJP try to do any good congress intervene create instability to a already senstive areas make it political play the blame game basically time waste congress tring since day 1 to break aprat india literally and they have western and chinese support north east is part of india forever be with India so all those bad things you see happening in north east because of congress and western Chinese attempt to destroy India that's it never go hating on india as a whole for the faults of congress western Chinese

@YandereEnthusiast

3 күн бұрын

@@lly_09 I understand man, union govts ignore ne cause it doesn't have much seats and the terrain is very difficult to reach and develop. India would be much better off being like Europe but foreign policy and defence policy stays with centre. I hope things change for you guys, there have been recent developments but ne is still largely ignored.

It's a trade off, Between letting everyone be the way they are and advance slowly, or imposing one thing over everyone and advance rapidly. India is diverse, in terms of race, religion, caste, creed, language and many more. It isn't like France or China where the majority of people look the same, speak the same, follow the same set of beliefs which makes it easier for them to advance and get a consensus since there isn't much friction between thousands of communities.

@TheEmissaryCo

5 күн бұрын

yes definitely a double edged sword. Honestly it just doesn't feel right to think India's diversity will reduce! Makes one sad.

@ddeviddyoung

4 күн бұрын

Truly double edged sword.. Its makes it difficult to progress as well regress. If a single authority can't control and dictate us to betterment easily it also means that due to these diversity, a single authority can't control and dictate everyone to mischievous and malicious intent.

@noneoftheabove666

4 күн бұрын

Advancing slowly is fine n all, but we don't have too much time in our hands. The demographic dividend we have now will end in two decades. If we don't take drastic steps, the train will be gone, forever.

@DevRajIES1999

4 күн бұрын

​@@TheEmissaryCo brother why did you used "foolish bravery" for Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji's reforms 🤔❓❓

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

@@DevRajIES1999 brave to do reforms. Foolish because it lost him elections

Hundred percent agreed. There are so many diverse groups here. People generally talk about the positives of diversity in terms of architecture, cuisine, religious events and languages. But they forget that almost always these groups have different versions of development and interests. Often these interests are opposite to each other. Even if your decision is rational and suited for the growth of the nation as a whole, some group will find it abhorrent. When protests happen, they will be portrayed as failure of the government. Not every leader is willing to take that risk. And that lack of risk taking appetite is holding us back severely.

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Yes there’s def a dark side!

@RojaJaneman

Күн бұрын

Diversity is great until u mix in a group that doesn’t accept u but wants to live amongst u anyways. UP UNTIL THAT POINT it’s a great strength. But then d removal of that group is d solution, not dismantling everything for that lack in that one group.

That's like saying, the World's diversity holds the world back. India is doing well for its diversity. All we need is uniform development away from a few mega cities, by encouraging more regional cities. Historically, regional cities were quite prosperous. Only after British era, regional cities lost their importance to the British created metros and socialism screwed us in multiple ways.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

Indian diversity is good. But too much emphasis on it at the expense of unity is issue imo

@aqualord6285

4 күн бұрын

But the world doesn't act as a single unit like india, my friend.

@jyotiradityachoudhury7987

4 күн бұрын

We need to develop SEZ and new cities

@kaamdev810

3 күн бұрын

If only each state govt in India could function properly and bring prosperity along with economic growth that would lift the country as a whole..unfortunately there is no uniformity..

@lly_09

3 күн бұрын

It's a failed experiment of building a nation from too diverse backgrounds. Now it's becoming a dictatorship, perhaps totalitarian

Constructive criticism...how rare, almost extinct. Appreciated brother✌️🇮🇳 Subscribed

@sauron2000000

4 күн бұрын

😂😂😂😂😂

Truly it is something else to rule India it's not like a normal society. It's truly amazing how things evolve here. Soo many pieces influencing each other you never know how things will turn out

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

India is a miracle!

I was going to work and never intended to watch the full video but the sheer amount of clarity and detailed analysis about the actual problems in India in commendable. The only thing holding India back is Indians themselves.

Never lose your indianess brother. Our Great Motherland needs people like you. Great video 👍

I was such shocked with the result of 4 June,that i was watching videos of Jayant bhandari 😂😂and now urs.... Diversity is the biggest curse on India, Tribalism of caste groups, socialism,anti corporate mindset but need jobs.Even Ayodhya was also after so much development and 1 crore+tourist...no vote for railway station/airport/highway/expressway....I am an Indian and telling u that my country has zero morality, zero love for development, zero vision....Thank u for the video. Subscribing u

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Thanks for watching. Sorry you watched Jayant 😜

@sourabhjain55

2 күн бұрын

@@TheEmissaryCo he is bit harsh ,i dont agree with 50% what he said...he taked about morality integrity tribalism of indians caste,reservation etc which i agreed.

Thanks for the video. You understand India better than most foreign media, and even better than most of Indian "Secular-Liberal" population 👏🙏👍

Diversity when propagated too much leads to a chaos like india. In india people take it as an offence if told to let go off their regionalism a little. This has been cultivated by regional parties especially in South of India since ages. People harass other people from different states for their language supremacy and whatever. This is further amplified by the media run by the various parties to act as their mouthpieces. After all this people are told to celebrate this "diversity" 😅😅😅. WTF. India will not grow to become a powerful nation. A nation being systematically weakened from inside is bound to be broken. It will happen, not now,but later.

@Hiromi_SUgata

3 күн бұрын

It will never happen even if they have difference they still care ,love and depends on each other. Just like bio diversity ìs dependent on its each components. 😊

@RD-ol5ry

3 күн бұрын

@@Hiromi_SUgata Good theory. Lol

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Yes it’s used in malicious ways

Sure we are diversed but it is not like outsiders united, but insiders followed different path inspired by the same ideal called "Dharma"~ eternal balance in the universe. Together we are called "Bharat" ~ The followers of the light. 😊

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Nice 😊

@The_Indo_Aryan

22 сағат бұрын

The Hindu Dharma in itself is extremely divided. Not by caste, All Hindus don't worship the same God. Hindus don't belong to the same race, they don't have the same origin. The dharma in itself is so divided, it's impossible to unite the entire nation on its basis.

Enshrining caste, reservation directly into constitution of India was the second largest disaster the law maker did while making the constitution, first was not making Bharat a Hindu Rashta.

@shravan7623

3 күн бұрын

Inventing and eventually abusing the caste system was the biggest tragedy & travesty of the South Asian sub-continent, past & present. Let's not forget that Brahmins still treasure their "sacred" thread.

@Altman.sam1

3 күн бұрын

No one invented caste system,it precedes hinduism, Hinduism is new caste is old.

@lly_09

3 күн бұрын

Hindu Rashtra means for the Hindus only, but the country has too much diversity for it, why should the smaller communities and other religions give up their own to fulfill your hindu superiority complex? If you think it should've been a Hindu Rashtra, then free the states who have different religions, culture, tradition aka northeast and some more other states

Man you have just encapsulated and captured my emotions and assessments after 4th June. I have been slightly disillusioned as well even though Mr Modi has come back for a third term. But I can easily see that this jubilation is transient because we are just one Election result away from blowing up our economy as the opposition in India can quite effortlessly lead us down a spiral into a dark future. The examples cited of Argentina, Brazil and South Africa in your video are quite apt but you missed out on the example of Venezuela. Its downfall can easily be mimicked by India as the ingredients that were present in Venezuela are also present in our country. The Maduro regime and Hugo Chavez in Venezuela explicitly stated that they will not enact socialism, but once in power did the exact opposite that led to V's current situation where there is mass starvation, poverty and inflation even after it being a high oil rich country. Just a glance through the opposition's(particularly the INC) manifesto is enough to scare the living daylights out of any sensible being interested in economic affairs. Their only USP is to divide the Hindu vote to carry out their massive social engineering and bring about their communist utopia. What pains me is that the Janta clearly hasn't learnt any of the 40 years of Nehruvian Socialist Sh*thole phase of this country where everyone of our peers like Korea, China, Singapore etc raced ahead to become rich while we were stuck redistributing poverty.

@milindu8919

3 күн бұрын

But if this is what the Janta(which is called a 'God' in the democracy of India) wants then this what we will get. Ultimately a people get the leaders it deserves. "Yatha Praja, Tatha Raja"

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Opp is crazy. No other choice but development!

Sir you should make a video on the horrible Cast system in Buddheism that sadly 99%of Hindus still don't know!,that video is needed specially for all the Neo Buddheists in Bharat who only wants to blame and disrespect Hinduism,just because our modern day Hindus have a dangerous virus on them named Sickulerism that's why they mostly talk about Islam only but I strongly belive that Buddheism should also be exposed!🙏🕉️

@sahilsingh6048

4 күн бұрын

Hinduism along with all religions are dumb

Positively surprised at how good this analysis was

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

thanks a lot!

Fully agreed with you. India's diversity is the core reason why India is still not developed.

This channel will shine if the people of our country look with open eyes and free mind!

@TheEmissaryCo

2 күн бұрын

Thx 🙏🏽

Reforms, reforms, reforms are the solution of India's woes. However for that to happen in a democracy, consensus and patience has to be built up (unlike the Farm Laws).

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Yessir!

honestly I wish agriculture reforms passed. so angry with these insane mobs protesting about it and the govt being soft on them.

@parvadhami980

3 күн бұрын

Consensus is the key to reform especially when you have a demography that is 50% of the country. Unfortunately the Arrogance of the BJP Government raised many questions regarding the laws.

@ashnaagarwal4825

2 күн бұрын

Dude in india most of the farmers are illeltrate it's not America so it's very likely that big corporates is gonna misuse them and will not give them their due if bjp wants to implement farm laws they first start to educate farmers on farming and make them aware about buisness so they can negotiate

@pario850

Күн бұрын

@@ashnaagarwal4825 dont agree, the farm laws were partly to create a more free market and only one of them had to do with corporations. they shouldn't have repealed completely

@pario850

Күн бұрын

@@ashnaagarwal4825 I think it should be done in a more cautious manner but honestly its going to be painful either way, reforms are never easy to implement

Whatever you say about India, end of the day India is NATURAL / ORGANIC in all ways from times immemmorial.

I see India's independence in 1947 unique in the manner that India not just freed itself of British Raj but also pulled itself out from the Persianate cultural sphere that it got sucked in under the Islamicate rule (Pakistan and Bangladesh carry that culture instead). But, it is a harsh reality when we see the exact same problems today that we saw in Pre-Islamic Indian society - behaving like crabs, where we hate ourselves, we feel jealous and disgust at one-another and cannot see each other succeed unless we have a share in it. We don't truly associate with our past and yet we also don't want to let go of something from that past, perhaps it's the seemingly noble values. It is a frustrating mental scenario Indian Hindus are going through, as they realize that Hinduism has now effectively become a folk or tribal religion with perhaps some potential, but no immediate practicality in bringing people together. Perhaps we are in need of another Adi Shankaracharya-like figure who can truly map the whole of this country and bring a collective cultural consciousness again. Or perhaps another foreign invasion. But this Hindu nationalism rhetoric isn't working in my opinion, at all.

I've had this exact theory at the back of my mind for years, just didn't find anyone who shares the same sentiment. Indians are quick to say things like "unity in diversity", or that we are the biggest democracy in the world.

India is not Gay enough😂😂😂

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

🌈

@prajullas

4 күн бұрын

This is problem with Indians : Just don't bother to focus on the actual topic.

@The_Indian_Politician

3 күн бұрын

Well that's not true...

@shahanshahpolonium

3 күн бұрын

@@The_Indian_Politician how

@JusticeAboveAll-ro3sm

3 күн бұрын

😂 bruh!

Thank you . This is the thing which is actually the strength of India.

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

🙏🏽

Kindly create a short documentary on "secularism and its loving relationship with Muslims"

India is most Diverse country in the World, Every region, state, city has its own culture. that why we say “Unity in Diversity” 1) Geographical 2) languages 3) Facial Features & skin complexion of the people are different 4) Food varies according to region (north, south, east, west, north-east) 5) traditional Clothes & Jewellery of each state is different 6) traditional Temples & Home architecture 7) traditional Dance forms 8) traditional Music 9) traditional Art forms 10) Festivals 11) Greetings 12) wedding

Another phenomenal video. Your work is truly nuanced and exemplary.

Self proclaimed KZread social gurus

*Seeing this broke my heart and I'm in tears yet I agree with your 100%, this is the bitter truth we should know so we can find real solutions. Hindutva needs real implementation to unite Hindus over their caste. I hope and wish one day we will be really united for betterment of our nation.*

Finally, a rational angle to the looming discourse on the maladies of Indian society which are many. This wasn't a ranty episode but a message those concerned with India's development need to hear. Before one has a chance to solve a problem, one needs to first accept it exists and ask the right questions. The Hydra analogy fits the Indian societal malaise well. One can't change a nation with massive population pools operating on a religiously retarded mindset, drowning in ignorance and superstition. To even broach this conversation with a fellow Indian, one has to pierce through layers of denial, delusion, and cope. Modern world has been engineered by rational minds and countries like India are functioning at the bottom-rung of that global order. India is in a dire need for cultural reinvention. Every generation has to have conversations and confront issues that their predecessors have ignored and neglected. Culture goes beyond costumed role-play. How you dress, what folk songs you dance to, and what deities you grovel at has no impact on what feeds you. But what you produce and offer to the economy does. As was perfectly posited at the end of the video, the cult of the village must be supplanted by the creed of the polis!

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Thanks 🙏🏽

I aggree on almost all points Except the point about Defence Reforms. The main Problem with defence forces is not a Qualitative issue, rather an issue of Modernisation which is very Sluggish due to all the red tape involved in procurement processes. Take for example the MRFA Tender, where they couldnt even decide on a Fighter playform in 21 years. This leads to Governments sanctioning emergency procurements which is just a simple way of legalising acts of Corruption, Like the General staff decides to procure a Foreign gun platform when comparable Platforms are available at home. Secondly, I dont think that Indian Military per se is having a bad time, we have seen far worse times in 90s and 80s. And Recent Examples such as Ukraine Teaches us that No matter how Advanced Technology you have, warfare always takes toll on manpower. So you need well trained forces in big no. ESPECIALLY If you aim to defend against China. And Agnipath messes that up entirely. You have a slashed manpower with way less training and exposure and are NOT REGGIMENTED(The scheme puts an end to Regimentation). Regiment system has worked very well in the past, no indication that it wont any further. If something isnt broken, dont fix it. But slashing down manpower can prove to be an enormous blunder. TOS may work for smaller countries with low population like Israel but not India. In Recent Jammu attacks , the Security lapse happened because the Units were streched too thin to provide any any necessary coverage and are still struggling with low troop strength. The need of the hour is a well trained Bureaucracy that understands Defence and a strong Defence Minister who can stare the Generals into taking indegenous options.

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Good points!

Very informative video! Left me with a lot to think about

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

Thank you!!

Great analysis, this video needs to be viewed by more people❤

That's what makes India unique.

Honestly speaking I don,t see it as a big issue or even the main issue of Indian society at all. If you look at Darwin,s theory of natural selection and evolution and also add the concept of genes then Indian society has the largest database of cultural genes in the world. And therefore it is very likely to survive through multiple changes in human history. Whjcg is why the Hindu civilisation considered on of the oldest and outlived the Greeks, Egyptians , romans and even the Chinese and sumerians

This is a most honest unbiased assessment. Great job you got a subscription

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Much appreciated!

It's crazy to think what India would've achieved if Caste did not exist, or wasn't such a core part of Indian Identity that politics form around it, of course past discrimination cannot be justified, but Even Ambedkar wanted the caste system to End, Same as Savarkar who was against caste.

@anshupandit4490

4 күн бұрын

The problem is that we have a 70% population who are good for nothing no caste just imagine if we had only the 20 crore "good people" we would have been leaps ahead usa

@huboffunn

4 күн бұрын

Both were idiot

@enhaa784

4 күн бұрын

🤡 cast is Portuguese word not indian.

@YourFuhrer1933

4 күн бұрын

Just imagine if so called lower castes never existed, they are a burden

@MARKCRASTO

3 күн бұрын

​@enhaa784 it's a Portuguese word to describe an Indian system that was already existent. Dowry is an English word, will u clowns claim that Dowry was introduced by the British? 🤡

I think you're very hopeful about young urban Indians.. they feel it's cool to be on the "Left".. they don't remember the UPA era. And they don't see/realise how bad UPA was for India. All of them think BJP is bad for India becuse that's what the West and the "cool", "unbiased", "neutral" "intellectuals" of India tell them! Here's hoping they'll see through the bs but after seeing this time's result I don't really have much hope from young, urban Indians.. PS: I'm a young urban Indian

@jyotiradityachoudhury7987

4 күн бұрын

Congress hasn't repeated a single state govt for years . The young generation should get a taste of what great Congress govts feel like obnoxious commie social control bills , no lgbt rights as to appease mullahs and fathers , repeated power cuts , water Mafia, land mafia, IAS Babu corruption, local MLA corruption, mp corruption, drowning foreign investment . They should see it once what congis do

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

let's see how it goes!

@srishtichaudhary3580

4 күн бұрын

​@@jyotiradityachoudhury7987 You're absolutely right they should get a taste of the medicine! They'll be reminded why they voted UPA out of power 😅

@MrAgolikeri

3 күн бұрын

​@@srishtichaudhary3580technically they didn't.... Many of them were uninformed first time voters back then ,with very less knowledge about politics and current affairs as media back then was skeletal, not as developed and thriving as today .

@srishtichaudhary3580

2 күн бұрын

@@MrAgolikeri that's true

Bold video, Akshar. You just said some things that not a lot of other Indian political commentators would even think about. Good stuff. You can probably expand on parts of this video and make a series of videos.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

Thanks! Yes definitely a lot of places to branch out

Read your whole article about this and what a piece. You provide such indept analysis. After a long time found a platform and creator who talks so indepth about indias political cultural and societal dynamics with covering so many subtleties that too after living outside. Excited for more of ur stuff on ur platform and yt channel. Even added ur platform on home page.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

omg thank you so much!!

I agree 100% with your assessment. But with industrialization and urbanization will come a lot of issues too…values will be reassessed and there will be a lot of conflict surrounding what “modernity” means in the Indian context and anxiety over what will be lost as a result. I think there will be a violent identity crisis in the coming years…we are already seeing the preludes to this. Let alone the underemployment and unemployment crises that need to be ironed out in the coming years. Not to be pessimistic…but I foresee a tense transition to say the least.

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Yes modernity is another beast entirely. Community must be preserved in some way

That was a really good video. Wish you good luck for the channel.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

Thanks!!

Very well put video, any Indian person who has gone through years of understanding it’s country will reach these conclusions and rarely so a westerner. Thanks for the analysis and including Sanskrit scriptures to give context. Keep it up.

Hmmmm , im here to see your comment section , not because i love commenting , but because i m here to see wether IT cell has found this video or not. Im sure your channel is underrated but after this video , forget that , you have chosen a right content.....

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

I am the IT Cell 😎

@sahilsingh6048

4 күн бұрын

​@@TheEmissaryCo😱😱😱

Subscribed, brother. Well done. I hope your channel grows exponentially. Much love from india❤

In my view, India’s biggest problems are its diversity, political system, and over population. India needs following revolutionary reforms to achieve China like growth: 1. The state must be created based on population rather than based on language, culture, religion, ethnicity, cast, etc. If any state’s population surpasses more than 3 cr, the state must be bifurcated immediately. The smaller state would make the administration much easier and transparent (less corruption). 2. The state level parties are not allowed to participate in national election (loksabha) and the national level parties are not allowed to participate in state election. In short, any political party has to make a decision whether they want to be national level party or state level party. 3. To be eligible to vote in national election (Loksabha), one must have at least 12th pass qualification. However, everyone can vote in state level election without any education requirement. 4. The selection of ministers in parliament must be based on meritocracy. For example, the person who has served in foreign service as an ambassador is only allowed to be a foreign minister. 5. One county One election 6. Population Control Bill (Only 2 child policy).

Something i feel we will disintegrate anyway coming 75 years from independent is itself a miracle 😅

I will strongly degree with what was said in the video. The greatest problem lies in hindu society not having any strong connection with thier sastras and orginal knowledge system which is casing too much confusion and fake historical narrative with drive so called caste system narrative plus hindu society itself only remaining in name but inside they are nastik. Remember the time bharat was prosperous was always under rulers who followed and ruled by dharm.

@gustavkirchoff4633

2 күн бұрын

How is this disagreeing with the video?

@breakingdrawn7008

23 сағат бұрын

@@gustavkirchoff4633 Directly he is not willing to acknowledge the root cause of Indian society decline lying in ignorance of sastras and inability to distinguish between dharm and adharm plus not having clear values and standards creating confusion in society. By default Bharat should be Rajtantra plus Loktantra instead of democracy. Many of the words of Sanskrit are not used in there correct meaning instead used as meaning of English words. Democracy is not equal to Loktantra.

India is not just a country it’s a sub continent

We really need Akhand Bharat or else the opposition party will turn India into various small countries😢

@parvadhami980

3 күн бұрын

You already have an "Akhand Bharat" which has absorbed 550+ Princely states. What more could you get? Maybe PoK and Aksai Chin

Who is the brilliant person behind those immaculate illustrations?

@TheEmissaryCo

2 күн бұрын

I made them via midjourney!

@revenantwolzart

21 сағат бұрын

Wild stuff AI can do now, we are truly in the future. I myself am learning it as a CSE student.

That African guy video is awesome just that along deserves a like and subscribe for this guy

@Shourya899

Күн бұрын

Name Sammy? Which KZreadr?

I want to know about that statue on the left..and where can i get one.

India needs stable government till it becomes developed Nation. Reforms are so much important for any government to prosper any nation to future Atleast for a Decade or till 2035 policies should not change & same policies should be continued. Congress wins on Freebees as Policies and BJP wins on Development as policies. islamists who love hamas are with congress and who put nation first are with BJP. countless regional and small parties get elected on diverse issues, thats another Toast.

Dude, that cut to that African reel got me rolling in laughter.

The main issue of Indian society is casteism, there is deep hatred among different caste groups.

I have a criticism for you sir that you make long form video because your videos gets extremely less views and subscribers!,just look at the amount of views and subscribers our beloved German Shephard gets in literally every single of his videos(You already know who)I know at first it's going to be hard for you but once you make long form video essays then more and more people are going to watch your videos!🚩🕉️

@sahilsingh6048

4 күн бұрын

Whats that Golf flag doing in the comment?

@Anubhavsengupta1902

4 күн бұрын

​@@sahilsingh6048 Kuch samajh mai nahi aya!😑

@enhaa784

4 күн бұрын

​@Anubhavsengupta1902 ek to in vesdhi chujo ko bhav Dena band kro ...y Christian colonizer kbhi Bharat ko khda nhi dekh skte

internet will bring india homogeneous

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Hmmmm!

Good analysis. Should be part of an academic programme and debate. Very reasonable for the current situation.

The most unbiased video

Are the Chinese happy people? Given a choice, where would you live - India or China?

Great video man

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

Glad you enjoyed!!

India's diversity is a boon and problem together... In case of crisis the diversity actually helps us but in peace time this diversity creates fault lines...

@RahulkumarMak

4 күн бұрын

Which crisis?

@runajain5773

4 күн бұрын

​@@RahulkumarMaklike lebanon is also diverse and develop country at time very much like europe until they bring religious based on government like sunni will pm or shia will be governor or cholitcs will be president or orthodox christain will be speaker also thousand of migrant palestine come in lebonan and there is civil war between christain and muslim after civil war lebonan have some iran backed islamic militia and now today lebanon consider backward poor country .

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

it is indeed very beautiful

@lly_09

3 күн бұрын

It is indeed a curse and a boon, it's almost like a failed experiment, still a useful one to study but a disaster

You put our thoughts into an eloquent video

“….And i smell like garlic” 😂😂😂.. great and informative video bruh..

@TheEmissaryCo

2 күн бұрын

😅

India is not a country but a continent masquerading as a country.Great content. But when you carefully look at developed countries, there's an authoritarian leader or a system to stop the bickering and bring everyone to the nation's growth.❤

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Thanks!!

Spot on video. Our chatterati class usually waxes eloquent about the beauty of our diversity, it's like a salad, like a thali, a tapestry of colours and fabrics...yada yada, but it also comes with a whole load of detriments. We have 10s of millions of different races, hundreds of millions of religions, ethnicities and languages. Everyone in India is a majority in at least one minority category.

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Some things are difficult to say! Diversity is the flavor of the era

That last part is what i have recently come to believe. To overcome the village. It may have some dire consequences but it must happen.

It's just like a quote from my one of the favourite novels LORD OF THE MYSTERIES. We strive to save ourselves; only better to destroy ourselves.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

I still believe!

I'd be cautious to interpret 2024 results just thru the lens of caste and diversity. BJP themselves made tactical error in campaigning particularly in candidates selection and GOTV.

@kaamdev810

3 күн бұрын

What went wrong really with BJP according ...every in international forum was heaping praise on India's economic progress and reforms..

@chirag4648

3 күн бұрын

The "unscrupulous amount of freebies" promised by opposition parties, for which the BJP offered nothing substantial in return, costed Modi a few seats (a possible majority on their own). A few other issues include rural distress and the Agnipath scheme..

India is not a normal country. It is true that India has made some progress but there are so many underlying issues which are getting severe as time goes on. Suicides are increasing.

@anirudhhhh

4 күн бұрын

Each and every country has severe underlying problems. Even developed countries. India's task is just harder because of the diversity and population. For a very long time we haven't had bold leaders and reforms in laws. Also our close relationship with Russia has steered us more towards socialism. After liberalization and a competent government we are just starting to see positive effects. It takes time for change.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

a lot to fix yes!

Love this man.......he is a real wellwisher of India....

India is an empire. That will upset a lot of Indians, but the fact remains, all the semi independent countries under The Raj were forced into one entity at independence, some like Kashmir and Khalistan, against their will. India should put it to the vote whether it remains an empire or become a federation of sovereign states.

Which homogenised nation is ideal and heavenly ?! Thank you very much, we have been doing just fine since thousands of years even before the world knew about the word democracy, autocracy, monarchy, dictatorship, etc... "Reform" is not necessary in agriculture and wherever that's done, is not a nice experience. The only thing that comes out of reform is packaged food !

Nehru's socio-economic policies are responsible for many problems India is facing today. China rejected the socialist economic policies in the early 60s itself and focused on industrialisation while India stuck to it until 1990s.

@ashnaagarwal4825

2 күн бұрын

You are able to live and write this comment only because nehru made some great desicion yes of course not liberalising India earlier was congress biggest demerit but still calling nehru India's biggest mistake is wrong at so many levels he made many great desicion because of which our country is together and evolving modi has lead India to massive economic depression because of which it is difficult to recover from it now

@satishmaurya3404

2 күн бұрын

@@ashnaagarwal4825 Nehru did everything to Islamise India...

@ashnaagarwal4825

2 күн бұрын

@@satishmaurya3404 seriously man go and read about him instead of believing 2 watsapp forwards

I got to know about you from Kushal’s podcast and bro you’re fire 🔥

Bravo! Loved your comprehensive and incisive commentary on Indian politics and economy. The writing was brilliant and kept me glued while the high production values made it more interesting. You just earned a subscriber. Will look forward to your future videos. Btw dude, my man. Don't get me wrong but that necklace thingy that you have on you is very distracting. It reminds me of slow-crawling leeches 😅

Can you Dub this video in Italian? I desperately want westerners to understand the problems of India's diversity .

Re: 12:09, Congress encouraging redistribution and economic progress being the preserve of the privileged lot sounds very much influenced by the likes of Jean Dreze and Thomas Piketty and their BS theories. They expect India to conform to European welfare standards without tackling corruption, creating avenues for wealth creation, and enhancing state capacity on law & order. They want first world benefits and handouts without first world state capacity.

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

big mismatch in economic development def

We are one cause there is conformity and unanimity over few things, which are subsconciencly there, which proves that india is a civilizational nation. But ofcourse when someone goes against the subconscious setup then things turns out differently. And the credit goes to hindu way of thinking.

Appreciate your effort❤

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Thank you so much 😀

Insightful and needs to be talked more in mainstream. I thought of sharing this in my friends' group , but thought, I might be leveled as pseudo progressive or preacher. So now I wouldn't share it.

@bv3144

4 күн бұрын

@rahulbrahma8311 share it! Maybe they’ll learn something new 🤷🏼‍♂️

@TheEmissaryCo

4 күн бұрын

haha take the risk :)

thanks somebody said it

@TheEmissaryCo

3 күн бұрын

Thanks

Very well balanced analysis