솔직히 아트비트가 뭐 대학 동아리 이런 것도 아니고 엄연히 영상을 만들어서 수익을 내는 단체라 어쩔 수 없다고 생각함.. 쿨하게 헤어지고 다시 친구사이처럼 지낸다고 해도 주변 사람들 입장에서는 헤어진 커플이랑 같이 있다는 것만으로도 눈치가 보일 수 밖에 없지 같이 연습을 하면서도 많은 대화를 하게 되고 같은 곡을 하지 않더라도 회사에서 언제든지 왔다갔다 하며 마주칠 수 있기 때문에 더 그렇고ㅜㅜ 선남선녀 커플을 못 보는 건 슬프지만 어쩔 수 없네요

@catabolic610

3 жыл бұрын

여긴 영리목적으로 만들어진단체인데 대표가 규칙을만들면 거기에따라야되는것도 사회생활...

@user-he1ii1ef8x

3 жыл бұрын

대표적인 예시가 작쏘랑 재민

@ojuteot

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-he1ii1ef8x 헉 조심스럽지만.. 두 분 사귀셨나요..?

@user-pd4hb6rh9x

3 жыл бұрын

@@ojuteot 3년전이었나 꽤 된 걸로 기억해요

@lo___o5648

3 жыл бұрын

Translate ?

금지가 솔직히 이런 컨텐츠 보여지는 거에선 좋을 듯...솔직히 사귈 땐 많이 축하도 받고 좋겠지만 헤어지고 ㄴ사ㅓ는....진짜 특히 외국...쪽은 엮는 거 진짜 ..........ㅎ그런 경우가 많아서 맘 고생엄청 하실 듯한데.........아니면 금지를 안하더라도 공개는 절대..안하는 게....

@user-et1xt2hy1o

3 жыл бұрын

ㄹㅇ 문규유빈 친해지길바라 컨텐츠 사라지긴 했지만 그거 나오고 외국인들 인스타에서 계정도 만들어서 엮는거 보고 연애금지는 하는게 맞는듯

@K-Director

3 жыл бұрын

하여간 외국애들이 더해

@catabolic610

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-et1xt2hy1o 와 그걸보고 엮는다고 억결충 역겹네 ㅋㅋㅋ

@user-et1xt2hy1o

3 жыл бұрын

@@catabolic610 근데 진짜 잘생기면 엮이는게 많다는 말이 팩트인듯 문규님 맨날 여자멤버랑 있을때마다 존나 엮던데 (하은님,시은님,유빈님,가은님)

@user-uv3bv7mo3z

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-et1xt2hy1o 맞아요 근데 그런 컨텐츠 나오기 전에도 많이 엮더라고요... 걍 해외팬등은 적당히를 모름 ㅠㅠ

서현님이 왜 연애금지를 해야하는지 잘 이야기 해주신거 같습니다!

사내연애해서 좋은 꼴 못봤다는 사람 많죠... 남들도 말리는 사내연애... ㅜ

Actually, as their fans, we should refrain ourselves from shipping any of the members unless they are the one who confirmed their relationship publicly such as Soyoung.P and Jihong. It's funny when people are arguing with each other about their ships and sometimes forcing their ships to other fans. Edit: Regarding the dating ban within the team, it is a human's instinct to like and date with one another no matter what you tell them. If it doesn't interfere with the teamwork within the team, it shouldn't be a big deal tbh.

@leilamariehernia7735

3 жыл бұрын

preach!!!!

@woonie9637

3 жыл бұрын

Shipping is a fun thing tbh.. its just not to the extremes.. even some member are okay with the shipping because its supposed to be a fun thing

@haru4440

3 жыл бұрын

@@woonie9637 yeah, I know that but arguing in the comment sections regarding their ships is just an immature act for me, personally. Edit: And it's getting annoying when some fans keep on commenting/mentioning certain members regarding their ships.

@yyuul6142

3 жыл бұрын

@@woonie9637 it suppose to be a fun thing but some people take it too seriously. Shipping them is okay but dont be too serious about it. They probably date someone outside of AB without publicing it. Imagine how it felt to be a couple but your gf/bf got shipped with other person.

@woonie9637

3 жыл бұрын

@@yyuul6142 thats why it depends on people.. as a fan, we really should know our limit.. those who crossed it are the wrong ones.. but there are still shippers who still keep their limit.. so to ask these shippers who always keep their limit to refrain themselves from shipping as well.. for me its unfair

ㅋㅋㅋ실제로 사내든 뭐든 해봤거나 봤으면 대부분은 이게 풀어주고 규율을 만든다 해서 지켜지지 못한다는거 알지..주변사람들이 눈치보는 것도 진짜 많고..하지만 또 사람들은 하지말란다고 안하지도 않으니 참 항상 어려운 문제네요 아트비트 내에서 이런 토론의 장을 만든거 너무 신선하고 좋아요!!

와 뭐야 이 신박한 컨텐츠는.. 개인적으로 너무 궁금했었고 아직까지 연애금지가 유효한지 알고 싶었는데 그걸 컨텐츠로 올려주시다니ㅜㅜㅜ 사실 멤버분들이 예쁘게 사귀시는게 좋지만..아무래도 많은 사람들이 함께 하는 팀이다보니 말도 많을 거고 안 그런척해도 분위기도 살피게 될 것 같아요..ㅜ 영상 보는 내내 쭉 생각해봤는데 아무리 생각해도 부정적인 생각밖에 안 드네요ㅜㅜ +) 서현님 말 너무 잘하셔서 깜짝 놀람..

연애금지있는게 맘이 편하고 팀에도 좋은것같습니다 서현님 귀여운 인상이신데 똑부러지게 말을 잘하셔서 반전이시네요 재밌게 봤습니다ㅎㅎ

nah even if there's a dating ban, couples would still find a way to date. banning someone's emotions and feelings shouldn't be normalized. it's mentally torturing and very unbearable.

@camille6423

3 жыл бұрын

^^ i agree

@_itslilac

3 жыл бұрын

true

@gab-tm1un

3 жыл бұрын

yassss

@RM-ri1ze

3 жыл бұрын

So true

@samiekim6091

3 жыл бұрын

True

팀활동하면 애초에 안좋은 꼬투리가 생길 일은 애초에 싹을 잘라버리는게 낫죠 금지조항 있는데도 분명히 연애하는 멤버들 있을텐데 조항 아예 없애면 진짜분위기 흐려지는건 진짜 무조건...

원래 토론이 웃긴 컨텐츠였던가🤔

@user-xd6up1mf9w

3 жыл бұрын

그러게요ㅋㅋㅋ

연애금지조항 있는 게 좋은 것 같아요 춤에 포커스를 두고 활동하는 채널을 좋아하는건데 연애금지가 풀리면 다들 연애할 것 같고 헤어지면 영상에서도 불편함이 전해져요 ㅠㅠ다들 지홍소영처럼 4년 넘게 만날 수 있는게 아니니까..연애금지 풀면 파국일듯..

@user-he1ii1ef8x

3 жыл бұрын

몰래 연애하던 커플들 다 깨졌죠

@llllllgollllll

3 жыл бұрын

헐 지홍님이랑 소영님 커플이세요?? 큰 소영님?

@blessyou4872

3 жыл бұрын

@@llllllgollllll ㅇㅇ

@blessyou4872

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-he1ii1ef8x 몇팀정도됨? 제가알고있는건 ㅈㅁ ㅉㅅ인데

@user-ee5ro5sj6r

3 жыл бұрын

@@blessyou4872 그 커플은 진작 깨짐;;

the only confirmed couple in artbeat are Soyoung.P and Jihong only. So stop shipping the boys and girls in artbeat until they confirmed it that they are dating.

@suivreme

3 жыл бұрын

agree

@woonie9637

3 жыл бұрын

Shipping is a fun thing.. why should we stop shipping? Its not related at all tho

@ableze

3 жыл бұрын

agree

@ajunicee

3 жыл бұрын

@@woonie9637 because they’re real people and it can be annoying and hurtful to be shipped. i don’t think you would like it if hundreds of people started shipping you with someone. it’s ok to ship tbh but do it quietly, don’t comment all about how you think about it because it can make them uncomfortable

@sh1twithsh4

3 жыл бұрын

@@ajunicee agree!

댄스팀 내 활동에 지장을 주지 않을 정도라면 가능할거같긴 해요 하지만 지장을 인준다는게 어려우니까... ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 서로 쿨하게 헤어지겠다는 문서 작성하면 가능하게 하는게 어떤가 하는... ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

@user-et1xt2hy1o

3 жыл бұрын

ㄹㅇ 내가 감독님이였어도 연애 금지령 내림 싸우거나 헤어지면 연습할때 분위기 개판에 멤버들만 피곤해짐

@user-lb1sk9lk7k

3 жыл бұрын

말이 쿨이지 헤어짐에 쿨이 어디있음ㅋㅋㅋ

@joho3166

3 жыл бұрын

인정요. 대학이건 회사건 어느 집단에 연애하다 헤어진다? 한 명은 반드시 떠나고 와해되더라고요.

@catabolic610

3 жыл бұрын

저긴 말그대로 영리목적을위해 모인곳임 하다못해 커뮤니티에서도 좆목질하면 거기 ㅈ망하는거 시간문젠데 연애하다가 헤어지면 분위기땜에 불편해할사람들이 얼마나 많을까

@user-pd4hb6rh9x

3 жыл бұрын

근데 피해 주지 않으려고 쿨하게 헤어지고 조용히 지낸다고 해도 주변 사람들 입장에서는 헤어진 커플이랑 같이 있는 거 자체가 눈치가 보이기 때문에,,

초반부터 봐 온사람은 아는 사람있을거임. 사귀던 사람이 있었는데 헤어진 적이 있었음. 그래서 그런걸 거임. 연애금지를 이해 못하는건 아니지만 어짜피 할 사람들을 할거니까 맘편하게 금지 풀고 몇가지 조항만 만들어서 지켰으면 좋겠음. 뭐 예를 들면 헤어진 후에 과도하게 티 내지 않는다 뭐 이런 것처럼 근데 뭐 이 사람 저 사람 다 사귀는 건 그 사람이 문제 있는거 아닌가 생각함

@user-et1xt2hy1o

3 жыл бұрын

@@sweetrain3158 그건 그분들한테도 실례니 물어보지 마세요

@aaa-bt8yt

3 жыл бұрын

@@sweetrain3158 알아도 대답할 생각 없습니다. 물어보지 말아주세요.

@user-et1xt2hy1o

3 жыл бұрын

@@sweetrain3158 죄 지은거 아니여도 이런 답글 하나하나 다 읽는 분이시면 불편하실수도 있죠

@user-et1xt2hy1o

3 жыл бұрын

@@sweetrain3158 예예 이렇게 띠껍게 구시는거보니 그냥 개념 자체가 없으신 분이시군요^^ 네네 님 죄인 맞아용~~^^

@user-et1xt2hy1o

3 жыл бұрын

@UCxCEPQmeli4GqbHllhbhoHQ 아 넹 그럼 님도 친구들 연애하다 헤어졌을때 계속 민폐처럼 물어보고 다 까발리고 다니세용~ㅋㅋ 그러면서 뭐라할때 왤케 예민하냐고 말하세용^^ 그리고 글쓰신분도 얘기 하기 싫다니까 싸물으시고ㅋㅋ

조직에선 규율 규칙이 중요하지 연애금지를 해놓더라도 감독님께 날아온 카톡처럼 어떻게든 사귀게 되어있음 하지만 그 연애끝난후 팀에게 끼치는 피해는 누가 책임져야하는건데.. 자기들로 인해 발생되는 피해는 그 누구도 책임져줄 사람이없음 무대하나를 완성하려고 몇날 몇일동안 연습하는데 헤어져서 힘들어서 못하겠다 불편해서 못하겠다 분명히 그런사람들도 생길껀데

춤도 좋지만 이런 멤버들끼리 예능같은것도 재미있는듯ㅋㅋㅋ 수익도 나오고

jihong saying dating has never been a priority to him🤣🤣 soyoung p. who’s filming: ......

@yabanu7927

3 жыл бұрын

Are they dating 😂

@czariyah

3 жыл бұрын

@@yabanu7927 lol yes

@shintawitaanggoroima3928

3 жыл бұрын

9:24 😂

@jaicaraenaval6548

2 жыл бұрын

@@yabanu7927 yesss they've been together even before entering ARTbeat..they've been together for almost 5 years

Now artbeat is like an entertainment company lol🙀

@ZiyandoingVids

3 жыл бұрын

Are they idols?

@weiberry1332

3 жыл бұрын

@@ZiyandoingVids No, they make covers

@ZiyandoingVids

3 жыл бұрын

@@weiberry1332 oo

@ZiyandoingVids

3 жыл бұрын

@@weiberry1332 thx

호준님 중간에 말이 없으셨어도 마지막에 경험담 얘기해 주신 게 깔끔하게 안되는 걸로 마무리 되는 거 같아서 좋았어요!

이렇게 멤버가 다양하고 많아진 모습을 보니까 약간 연예기획사같네요..

근데 진짜 약간 같은과cc같은 개념? 사귀는건 상관없는데 사귀다가 서로친한사람들끼리 친해졌는데 헤어져버리면 그 친한 친구들한테도 서로 피해가고 눈치보게되고 어색해지고 팀 내 분위기가 흐려지니까 .. 그리고 다들 보여지는 직업이니까 연애하더라도 티안내는게 최고일듯 ...

일반 동아리도 아니고 어찌됐던 수입을 창출하는 하나의 회사로써 연애 금지가 맞습니다. 요즘 기업도 사내연애 금지란게 있습니다. 일의 효율이 떨어지고 헤어지면 그 분위기. 주위사람 눈치등 팀의 분위기를 망쳐버릴수 있기 때문이죠. 대학교 같은 과 cc만 생각해도 벌써 답이 나옵니다. 연애 금지는 있어야 생각합니다. 라는건 사업하는 입장에서 그렇고 시은 웅겸 존버합니다^^

무조건 금지조항 있거나 최소한 사겨도 티는 내지 말아야 할 듯. 팀 내 분위기때문에서도 그렇고 특히 외퀴들 영상에서 남자멤버가 여자멤버 쳐다보기만해도 (반대인 경우도ㅇㅇ) 엮어대고 짧막한 영상만들어서 둘 사이에 뭐 있는거처럼 존나 많이 함; 그래놓고 그 영상에 다른 외퀴가 둘이 사귀냐고 댓글달면 영상 만든 놈은 그건 모르지만~사겼으면 좋겠다~ㅇㅈㄹ하는게 외퀴들 특

사실 팀에 선남선녀 많고 남녀 함께 있는데 마음이 안생기는게 이상하죠 ㅠㅠ 근데 에이블로써... 팀 오래보고 싶은 마음으로썬 감독님 의견에 한표 🥺

I think director should just advise them to be careful with their personal decisions but at the end of the day they are adults that should be able to decide for themselves. They are not idols and can’t help how they feel. It’s unfair to create “shipping” content like yubin and Moonkyu that could hypothetically speaking “create feelings” and then ban them from dating. What they do is private and they can keep it private if they wish to. They can also be responsible and if issues arise then hopefully they can deal with it themselves as mature adults. Also most of them are at the studio almost all day everyday so what chances do they have to meet others outside of Artbeat? Or even go on dates when they prioritise dance? See they need that balance between Artbeat and social life too.

@chickajefe5696

3 жыл бұрын

I agree with you, these are not idols but regular common people who like dancing and joined a company to fulfill that passion. It's unfair to impose the same restrictions and bans on them when many of them are in their 20's and in the studio 24/7 and like any other person would want to experience love and relationships, especially when they are with each other and create content together all the time. It's impossible to not catch feelings. I specially couldn't help but scream YES when you mentioned them creating "shipping" content like Yubin and Moonkyu but not allowing them to engage in those feelings if ever created. The director constantly mentioned that fights/breakups/etc. might get in the way of their dancing/practice/chemistry, etc but stated that he thinks it'd be unfair to ask Jihong and Soyoung to break up because they've been dating since before joining. But the same thing applies to them too? It's unfair that they're allowed to date and "show" their relationship while others don't have the opportunity to act on their feelings and are probably envious seeing them be promoted as the IT couple of Artbeat but themselves have to hide whatever feelings they have or "secret" relationships. At the end of the day Artbeat is just a dance channel and restricting them from dating makes no sense when they're not even idols whose fanbase will leave them due to a dating scandal.

@lastdusk2848

3 жыл бұрын

Yubin and Moonkyu content was not made for people to ship them, it is not a shipping content like you stated. It was made to create a better atmosphere within the team as we all know from AB enquette those two are awkward with each other. You know who were going to be the second couple? Hojun and Seyoung, before it got cancelled bcs of copyright issue. If it was a content to make people ship them, they'd put Hojun and Hyerim or Seyoung and Jaemin but as I said earlier it wasn't for that purpose. It is the fans' fault who started to ship them out of nowhere and their delulu mind. The reason the rule was made because there was a problem. It was quite obvious even from the fans' eyes when two of those members have tension let alone the members who meet them irl...it was uncomfortable

@bw2462

3 жыл бұрын

@@lastdusk2848 yubin is awkward with all boys lol and it just happens that she gets paired with moonkyu when a lot of comment sections have requests to see them together cos they get shipped a lot. It was obviously a move for views which is fine but im hypothetically speaking about the “catching feelings” part. I’m calling it with how I personally see it, I never said there was no problem but I do think there are better ways to handle things than just to BAN adults from dating. There’s a whole comment section for you to post your opinion too tho lol

@andieethechibii

3 жыл бұрын

Is thay why that content was taken down, or something about copyright? I was confused when i went back to watch it later, it was taken down..

@chickajefe5696

3 жыл бұрын

@@andieethechibii It was NCTzens being pissed and accusing Artbeat of "plagiarizing" NCT's idea of the show, but Artbeat members themselves mentioned that the segment was inspired by NCT but they decided to take it down to not raise issues with fans

연애 금지가 베스트인 게ㅠㅠ 금지인 상황에서도 일부 무례한 사람들이 멤버들한테 누구랑 사귀냐 누구 좋아하냐 궁예 판치고 스트레스 주는데 이거 풀렸다고 하면 멤버들 정신적 스트레스가 너무 클듯

4:46 there are no dating ban at first because some members are already dating even before joining Artbeat and i think the ban started because it is awkward when the couple broke up (what happened with two members in real life). It is suffocating to be with your ex in the same room. Well those two former lovers, as i see it they have their closure now and it seems like they are comfortable already whenever they're near each other.

@hanibee4374

3 жыл бұрын

I think I know what you are talking about and it's bothering me a lot

@sireneleiyh7861

3 жыл бұрын

Why do I feel that only one couple is comfortable being near to each other they are also seen sitting, talking and cheering to each other while the other are still adjusting(?)just my observation I've been watching them every time they're doing gym here.

@hanibee4374

3 жыл бұрын

@@sireneleiyh7861 I also barely saw one confirmed couple sitting beside each other. maybe they are just being responsible and professional when the camera is on

@esmilloalexis

3 жыл бұрын

@@hanibee4374 yes I think, they are being responsible given that they are one of the oldest members.

@sireneleiyh7861

3 жыл бұрын

@@hanibee4374 maybe and it's also hard for them to not be attracted to other members I've been experiencing this to my circle of friends and tf they are not in good terms now after my friend's ex date our friend(long story but that's their situation rn)idk why I'm saying this😂 but I wish that they'll be able to love they want to love.

I really like what Jihong said "The laws must always be developed and improved" This doesn't only apply in the dating ban that they discussed but it should be also applied in everything. Laws are made to keep everything organize, systematic and peaceful however everyone and everything changes & adapts along with the passage of time, this means that the law can't be always fair in given situations.

이 미친 새로운 컨텐츠잖아 개좋아 사랑해요 앝빝 400만 가즈아ㅏ아아아ㅏ아아앙

Some fans should really stop shipping the members because they can also read the comments it just make them uncomfortable

i understand why the whole dating thing might worry the members however people can't control their feelings so banning someone's freedom to have feeljngs and date someone isn't right to me and shouldn't be normalized. as much as a fight or a break up can make someone uncomfortable or cause problems in one practice the same can happen with two people who like each other but can't express their feelings because of the ban. wouldn't it feel uncomfortable to be in the same team with someone you like? will that person be able to focus? no matter what if dance is what they really like to do, as professional dancers they will know how to keep their personal life and problems outside of work.

I'm loving this new content! I can't wait to see what other debate topics they come up with : O Jihong was hilarious and Seohyeon is super good at refuting~ it was so interesting to watch hahaha I don't know if they really meant it for viewers to say why or why not lift the ban but: I personally think the dating ban is okay. Along with all the situations and scenarios they brought up, I also think that dating within such a popular dance team actually hurts the members individually... just because fans these days are kind of... intense. If they don't like one half of the couple or if they "ship" them with another member, it becomes mentally draining for those members. Most aren't harmful comments but its the build up of such comments that become an issue as well. Due to how big Artbeat is, the members are more or less treated like idols/famous content creators and they have to watch what they post, say, and do. Anyways I think I digressed hahaha but I support the dating ban just because they're are so many outside factors that just seem to outweigh the pros of lifting it and I definitely don't want the members to suffer from comments left by fans or by what would happen if they did lift the ban. Of course suppressing emotions and feelings for another person can be mentally draining...Idk.. I'd rather they not get attacked online? People on the Internet find ways to hurt others just because they are behind the screen and it's honestly terrifying how many actually do that to people ;-; Although logically thinking... how can there really be a full ban on dating since outside of dance practice and content/dance recording... no one but the people involved would know if they are dating secretly :") In any case and whether the dating ban is a good or bad idea... I just really want everyone to be happy ;-; please stay happy and healthy Artbeat members and staff and director TT Maybe this is a good time to say: they aren’t obligated to share everything about themselves and what is happening in their lives to us. :) they have their privacy and their own lives and we, as fans, should not meddle in their personal lives because we wouldn’t want others to do the same to us as well!

As an artbeat subscriber for a preettyy long time, I notice that i feel more excited to watch video that has a real couple in it Just like chungha-PLAY cover. I found it amazing how they really could show their profesionalism while they're dancing but also i could feel the "lovey-dovey" vibe at the same time (if you guys know what i mean😂). It just give a stronger vibe into the dance cover and i really do like it as a subscriber. I also feel that fallin in love is not a right thing to be ban. As long as they keep their profesionalism on camera, everything would be fine❤. #NoBanDatingTeam p.s. this new content IS SUPPERRR FUN! can't wait for the next AvsB vid❤

I'm amazed with Seohyeon. She knows how to organize her words very eloquent and politely. The way director-nim amazed everytime Seohyeon speaks hahahahha

((아직 보기 전이지만 벌써 재밌다...)) 서현님 되게 토론에 잘 어울리는 분 같아요 되게 말도 잘 하셔서 새로운 매력을 느끼게 된..?? 그리고 계속 옆에서 고통받는 호준님 너무 귀엽구요... 보는 내내 시은님 지홍님 너무 웃겨서 생각나는 거라곤 커다란 논리와 시은효과뿐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

Thought it's a good timing to say thank you for always putting on eng subs on all the videos!! I think people don't appreciate it enough and take it for granted (including myself), so thank you to whoever is doing it ❤️

I think this idea of 'dating ban' must've come from or caused by a serious situation, seeing their reactions and hearing their opinions. But I believe rules would be better than the actual 'ban'.

서현 이분 말 진짜 논리적으로 잘한다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ아이돌들한테도 보여주고 싶다

서현님 똑똑하고 야무지게 말 잘한다 ㅜㅜ 귀여워.. 시은님은 왤케 고장났는짘ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

@blessyou4872

2 жыл бұрын

알수없는 컨셉에 먹혀버린.. ㅋㅋㅋ

진짜 감독님 돌아오시고 분위기가 많이 바뀐거 같네여...행복 ㅎㅁㅎ

그래서 1년동안 연애하는 커플은 누구인가...

@user-py6kl5hn9m

3 жыл бұрын

그러게요..그것이 궁금하도다..

@user-qe5tz2kx8q

3 жыл бұрын

각색된 내용이래요~

@user-hh1yr6oy2c

3 жыл бұрын

지홍 소영 아님?

@user-bg3jh8vz1v

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-hh1yr6oy2c 지홍님 소영님은 4년 넘으셨어요

@user-bg3jh8vz1v

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-qe5tz2kx8q 아 그렇구나!

주변사람이 힘들지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 서현님 말처럼 처음부터 딱 싹을 자르면 됨 헤어져서 탈퇴하는 멤버도 있을꺼고

this got out in the most rightful timing. I like this kind of content, Director-nim!

연애하면 좋지만 끝은 절대 좋을수없습니다 결국 누군가 떠나겠죠...그러면서 팀에 금이가기시작하는거겠죠 ㅜ

@catabolic610

3 жыл бұрын

이게맞지 채널이만큼 키워놓고 개박살나는거 실시간으로 보고있으면 참...

진짴ㅋㅋ 시은님이랑 지홍님은 ㅋㅋㅋ주위에 사람들이 모일수밖에없을듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 말을 너무 재치있고 재밌게 하는데 누가싫어함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅎㅎㅎ

사내연애 절대 하지마세요....큰일납니다 진짜... 사내연애 잘못 했다가 이런 소문 저런 소문 돌고 여자 입장 남자 입장 할것 없이 안좋은 소문만 돌기 마련입니다... 감독님 절대 ㅁ말리세요 절대요 진짜 너무 좋아서 저여자 저남자 아니다 싶은 순간이 오면 차라리 비밀연애로 하되, 다른 사람들에게 절대 들키지 말고 러브러브 하세요// 사랑이 사랑의 크기가 들키는 순간 둘중 한명은...안녕 하게 될것입니다..ㅜ

Ok but like Seohyeon is really smart 😳

@jellylvy7507

3 жыл бұрын

Right!

@cherrysoms7651

3 жыл бұрын

💜💜💜💜

ㅋㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ멤버조합 너무좋다 호준님 서현님이라니 진짜 이마탁,,🤦‍♀️❤

연애금지가 나을듯......멤버들 한명이라도 잃고 싶지 않아ㅠㅠ 과동아리에서 커플하나 나왔다가 동아리 반으로 쪼개졌다......ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

맨처음에 열애중인데 공개못하고 비밀로 1년째 연애중이라고 하신 분들 누구실까 ㅠㅠㅠ 모르겠는데 ㅜㅠ 큰쏘님이랑 지홍님은 원래 공식 공개 커플이셨으니까 알고있는데 ㅠㅠ

@user-zs1zr6fv4r

3 жыл бұрын

음 이미 헤어지신 분들인건가

@user-ht6jw3rf2u

2 жыл бұрын

지금도 사귀고계신가요 ? 인스타 사진 내려가있길래욥..

@valentine2658

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-ht6jw3rf2u 누구 말씀하시는 거예용...??

이 컨텐츠 너무 나이스 한데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 승현님이 진행을 너무 잘하시네요 이 컨텐츠는 오래오래 했으면 좋겠습니다 다음 주제가 굉장히 기대가 되네요

지홍님 개웃기다 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 중간에 큰소영님 일어나는것도 개웃기네

i love how artbeat keep adding the ideas to their videos year by year. i can see how they improve. become more better day by day. we have dance cover, dance practice with mirror, dance speed, dance in gym, sing cover, acting video, AB debate, AB introduction, AB TMI, AB ideal type world cup, AB highlight, AB dance challenge, AB reaction, AB vlog, AB recruited. for me artbeat is the best team cover. they produce, they dance, they sing, they acting, they make reaction, they're funny, they edit their video, they recruit new members and be the judge. the are amazing. they are ARTBEAT. UNBEATABLE.

@TrafalgarDRuth

3 жыл бұрын

literal you read my thoughts :')

사회자 : 내 사업에 피해를 주지 않는 한에서...

SeoHyeon really did a great job in this debate. She's smart and I literally understand her point in dating ban. But for me I think it depends on the situation. Let's just say "Dating Ban" has a good and bad effects. Example you have someone who's literally close with you or let's just say she/he is your friend or co-worker and the two of you always chit-chatting each other and suddenly you accidentally cross the line and she/he feel the same way and the two of you decides to date is okay. I mean my main point here is it's ok if you date someone in your team or co-workers as long as the two of them know their limits and it won't affect their performance. And of course if the two couples suddenly break up, I think they need to have a quick break or closure? because if the ex-couples didn't have a closure and suddenly the two of them are in a one cover, the dance practice will be chaotic or uncomfortable and the other members will feel uncomfortable too. Anyways that was just my opinion and sorry for the grammar. Jihong's face is literally funny when he ask SoYoung P. To calm down #relationshipgoals HAHAHA

@husnakipli609

2 жыл бұрын

is jihong dating soyoung.p ??? i'm new to the chanel so i dont really know

@gachacookiegalaxiaanditssa7439

2 жыл бұрын

@@husnakipli609 yess, he is. As far as I know they're already dating before they joined Artbeat.

@husnakipli609

2 жыл бұрын

@@gachacookiegalaxiaanditssa7439 owhh thank you.

한두번 모여서 커버 영상찍고 헤어지고, 계속 멤버가 바뀌는 방식이면 모를까... 몇 달, 길면 몇 년동안 계속 만나고 지내야 되는 관계인데 팀 내 연애하면 자기들끼리는 긍정적인 영향이 클지언정 그건 정말 자기들끼리만 긍정적인 영향인거고. 그렇게 잘 사귀고 헤어져도 잘 지내면 다행인데 커플이 헤어지는 데에는 아름다운 이별같은건 드물죠. 나는 괜찮아 해도 상대는 힘들테고, 상대가 괜찮아한다면 내가 힘들고. 그게 그렇게 자기들끼리만 힘들면 다행이지만 주위에서도 눈치보랴... 주위도 힘들고... 결혼까지 할 생각 아니라면 연애금지가 맞는 것 같아요ㅋㅋ

I don’t like the idea of “ dating ban” because: - they are not idols, dating will not effect their popularity in bad way. (Even tho. idols have the right to date) - they are doing dance as hobby and they are in their most beautiful age to love and be loved. - is so wrong to ban two persons from dating because of it could be awkward in future or awkward for the ex. I hate when Idols can’t date each other and hate it even more when a normal young people can’t date from the same crew, company ....

@jellybeans.mp4

3 жыл бұрын

I agree with you! the members in this team are not "idols" they are dancers who happened to become youtubers as well that has a lot of supporters but they are different from idols, at the end of the day the people in this crew are regular human who also has jobs or are students at school/university. Having rules is okay but completely banning them from dating each other is kind of harsh most especially majority of the members are at the age of meeting other people.

@benjridimalek9051

3 жыл бұрын

If you watched the entire video you'd know that they don't ban dating becoz it will effect their popularity no one talked about that and no one thinks it's the reason, as you said they're not idols who maintain an image .. the reason for the ban is the problems that come with dating within the members and i repeat dating 'within' ab members not just dating in general with people from outside the team or whatever..

@BashYou

3 жыл бұрын

@@benjridimalek9051 I know that but when I said “ popularity “ is the main reason for idols ban. Problems coming after dating can happen anytime. They could date people outside from AB and still can be late , effect their dance and other things. Awkward?? Is not like they do many mix cover to star with so their aren’t many chance to they meet each other after breakup. If they date from AB or out AB it’s the same what comes after dating. So yes I watched the whole video and know what I’m talking about. So if not for popularity there aren’t really important reason to ban since problems can happen in AB or out AB and still effect AB’s activities

@benjridimalek9051

3 жыл бұрын

@@BashYou okay so i didn't even say my own opinion in this i only corrected the reason there is a ban isn't popularity, it wasn't the problem in the first place... another thing is that they do actually do a lot of mixed covers becoz they don't only do it when they do a mixed version of a cover like they did with cherry bomb but also when they need backup dancers for it and they've done a lot of songs with mixed backup dancers so there's a higher chance for them to feel awkward and they can't just not include those two members in the same cover every time coz they choose who to include depending on the dancing style, the role and sometimes even depending on the similarity between the original artist and the ab member , there are also members incredibly talented who are included in a lot of covers like seyoung , damhee , jaemin, hayeon, jihong... and they can't just not include them becoz of that, even fans want to see them in a lot of covers ... but more important than all of this is that they will definitely meet becoz they all practice in the same rooms for long hours as we've seen there are like two practice rooms in artbeat so they can't just avoid each other all the time and they can't adjust their schedules according to that certain member's schedule to avoid them it's impossible they all have their own lives some have jobs apart from dancing some are still studying and many other factors go into this so them not meeting is far fetched and is only gonna affect the team work..

@Nini_0618

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah they're definitely not an idol to have a dating ban . Let them be in a relationship if they want to .

I really like the way seohyeon talks!! she’s so good

The director is such a nice man wow never seen a man doing it like him he is the besttt

Artbeat is really unique!! Omg I'm loving all this new content omg I love you director nim!!

보기전에 댓글 답니다 뭔가 무조건 시은언니가 있는 편이 그냥 바로 이길거 같아 ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋ

u know why i love this channel, bc the interaction between the members.. I just want "Artbeat" to stay like "Artbeat" no matter how popular artbeat now and soon..if you do this kind of rules, this channel gonna be same as other entertainment company..

아트비트 이런 콘텐츠 너무 사랑해요💓💓 진짜 편집 실력 대박.... 멤버들 감독님 너무 좋아요💝💝💝💝💝

헐 새로운 컨텐츠다!!! 엄청난 토론을 하시는 군요😁 진짜 다들 너무 귀여우시당ㅋㅎㅋㅎ

As long as the members are happy and they will do their duties well, i dont think dating should be prohibited.

몰래 연애를 하더라도 겉으로 연애금지라는 룰을 정해놓는게 확실히 좋은 것같아요. 겉으로 드러내서 좋을 게 전혀 없으니까요ㅜ 연애금지 룰 정해놓는다고 절대 사귀지않는다! 이거는 아니겠죠. 하지만 그걸 풀어준다면 진짜 난장판 될껍니다ㅎㅎ 더 미래를 보면 진짜 연애금지룰 있어야되요ㅋㅋ큐ㅠㅠㅠ

사내연애....참 어려운 문제이긴하죠ㅋㅋㅋ근데 춤추는채널인데 너무 토크가 재미있는거 아닌가요ㅋㅋ

Ahh jihong thinking about Soyoung.P and trying to save face 😂 at 5.19mins. I love this idea, because its really useful to hear the members opinions. Also my brain is alive with ships. 💖🤗🥺

seohyeon is so good at debate tho

Sehyeon is such an amazing debater, she's calm and extremely good explaining something 👍

서현님 말씀 조리있게 너무 잘 하심,,,

I really love this kind of concept on Artbeat!!!

PLEASE LET THIS BE A REGULAR SEGMENT IT’S SO CHAOTIC & FUNNY, I NEED SIEUN VS. CEO-NIM EVERY VIDEO

@iEssense

3 жыл бұрын

This is a "serious" video, yet im just on a roller coaster of being serious about the topic and bouncing in my chair laughing, i love it lol

Seohyeon is so good with her arguments.

can you all not name drop here pls respect the privacy of the members it's really not our business if they're dating or not they make dance covers for us to enjoy so pls just focus on that and don't always bring up unnecessary things coz they read the comments and i bet it's uncomfortable for them as well.

@seafog

3 жыл бұрын

EXACTLY! Please ABles, we don't want this series to end up like it did with that awkward members series... I'm sure the director and members don't want their hard work to go to waste either.

서현님 아직 미성년자이신데 말씀 진짜 조리있게 잘하시네요

사귀었다가 헤어지면 무조건 한명은 나가게되는 식으로 될텐데 그 전에 그런 일이 있었다는거 보면 전혀 좋지 않아보여요.. 왜 괜히 사내연애 하지말라고 하겠어요..ㅠㅠ 아직 어리고 서로 같이 오래 붙어있으니 마음이 생길 수도 있겠지만.. 댄스팀에서의 연애금지 조항은 좋은 것 같아요

jihong sitting there be like : what am I doin here👁️👄👁️????

@ebsatkbs

3 жыл бұрын

man is only there to talk about child birth 😭

The debate really goes well!!! Hoping for part 2 ☺️🇵🇭

서현님 토론에 소질있으신듯 하네요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 👍🏻

It doesn't matter if there are any members who dated each other because it's their life anyway. Let's say if they broken up, then it's up to them on how to handle the post-breakup's situation. Of course it would be awkward to work in a team with their ex but they need to manage their own emotions and feelings wisely since they are not a child anymore. In short, be responsible for your actions. Plus, it just dating though. It's normal.

Can y’all not mention Seyoung, nothing has been confirmed or anything so it’s not fair to say this is about her or others involved.

@hyj7190

3 жыл бұрын

fr it’s so annoying

@myfearless4595

3 жыл бұрын

its so annoying :(

@lastdusk2848

3 жыл бұрын

for real. the way those people be making scenarios in their head and making Seyoung as the one who disturbed someone else's relationship. I'm so angered. They call themselves fans? bs.

@woonie9637

3 жыл бұрын

@@lastdusk2848 so its actually not refrain from shipping.. but refrain from obessive shipping.. this actually similar to their debate About lifting the ban but with some controls or juat continue with the ban

@adampilget6158

3 жыл бұрын

Wht happened to seyoung

Artbeat producing new contents for us , hehe so thankful but Jihong's comments though🤣🤣🤣🤣

@abfans4421

3 жыл бұрын

🤣🤣

같은 공간에서 연애를 하다 헤어지고 같은 공간에서 또 다른 사람과 사귀면 전 여친과 현 여친은 친구사이가 엉망이 될텐요..

@sdjeud1517

3 жыл бұрын

에이 설마 같은팀에서 계속 연애를 하겠어요? 양심이 있지 같은팀에 전 여친하고 현 여친만들면 주변사람들만 불편할텐데

@user-cf5vy5ld5q

3 жыл бұрын

@@sdjeud1517 ㅋㅋㅋ그러겠죠?

@user-fd4nd9qu4k

3 жыл бұрын

그런 경우도 있을걸요..? 아마..?

이런 컨텐츠 좋아요. 일단 좋아요 누르고 시청 들어갑니다. 다 봤는데 팀을 잘 이끌어가려는 건전한 토론이네요. 사람의 감정은 마음대로 할 수가 없죠. 감독님이 그래도 인생을 좀 더 사신 분으로 경험치도 있고, 이 팀에 왜 연애금지가 필요한지 잘 설명하셨네요. 중간 어디쯤 시은님이 '여기 와서 천생연분을 만나면 어떡하죠?' 라고 하셨는데 그 둘이 팀을 탈퇴하면 됩니다. 절이 싫으면 중이 떠나는거지 절은 떠나지 않습니다. 어떤 조직에 들어갔으면 그 조직이 요구하는 규율을 따르는게 옳은 자세죠. 희생이라는 단어가 여기 어울리는지는 잘 모르겠지만 춤을 위해 누군가를 좋아하게 된 감정은 숨기고 나의 원래 여기 들어온 목적대로 해야된다 생각합니다. 하지만 좋아하는 감정이 너무 커져서 못 견딜것 같으면 나오시면 됩니다.

@catabolic610

3 жыл бұрын

이게맞지 AB팀은 그냥 개인동아리가 아닌 수익창출을하는 사업체임 거기서 대표가 만들어놓은 방침을 따라야할 의무도있는거고

Pls respect this content instead of asking members , dance covers they trying to cope other things dance covers have many copyrights this was theyre very own concept and contents hope ables know that.

I can't wait to see the next episode of this series! 😍😍😍

예쁘게 사귀시면 좋겠능데ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋ 근데 컨텐츠 너무 신박해요💖💖💖💖💛🐥

Please invite our shy girl Oh Yubin next time😍 everyone here doing great job. Love Sieun so much

Ssi ㅂ ㅏ... 무슨 댓글이 다 English.... yo 한국인 분들 jo아요 좀 nul어봐... 아놔 한국 채널인데.... 유튭 je발 나라별로 comment 보게 해줘...

Seohyeon is like a girl in the class that everybody have a crush on her because of her smartness😂

와 진짜 아트비트구독자로써 제일 궁금했던걸 컨텐츠로 내주니 세상 신기하네욬ㅋㅋㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋ

Woonggyeom was not even in this but he got called a lot thanks to Sieun 🤣 also Jihong is so sweet when he tried to calm Soyoug P so that she won't misunderstand

@sreevedaonce3327

3 жыл бұрын

Is woonggyeom and sieun really dating Because I don't know I'm asking

@clnmhy

3 жыл бұрын

@@sreevedaonce3327 they're not dating.

@yoluizy

2 жыл бұрын

@@sreevedaonce3327 woongyeom and damhee used to date before. they broke up now ig or maybe back 2gether again

이 콘텐츠 너무 재밌어욬ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 다음에도 또 해주세여!!

이제서야 봤지만 이런 토론왕도 많이 올려주세요...재밌네요!

i love that they are doing contents like this haha

I bet there are many couple inside AB lol, and sieun knows it all😂🤣

idrc if they do have a dating ban or not but either way as long as it doesn't interfere with their role in the team and they're aware of the awkwardness it may bring if they end up breaking up it should be fine as long as they know the consequences

please don't ban dating... they are not even celebrities (i also think that idol dating ban is ridiculous so having normal regular citizens have it baffles me even more) and they're all still young, don't take that away from them... also to ables, PLEASE STOP SHIPPING MEMBERS YOU'RE SO WEIRD IF YOU DO THAT PLEASE STOP.

@ever-kj7zn

3 жыл бұрын

They don't mean it in that way it's just to amuse. Srry if my english is bad