If you'd asked me a year ago, I would've been very surprised to learn that this video would eventually have 200,000+ views, so thanks to all who have liked it, commented on it or subscribed. Just because this video is bringing in the most views, I thought I'd sticky a comment - yes, I'm fully aware the sound quality and general production value on this video is quite low. I was a noob at movie-making at the time, and I'm still kind of shit, but it's definitely improved to a much more watchable level and most importantly, most of the videos I've published this year have been done with a good quality microphone, so don't let the toaster mic scare you away. Thanks everyone.

@wanneerde8854

4 жыл бұрын

Darth Gandalf wow hello this was a really good video my compiments

@daluven

4 жыл бұрын

How many men were lost at the battle of pelennor fields?

@CMAzeriah

4 жыл бұрын

What about Arnor?

@npierce14

4 жыл бұрын

E excellent video bro and Haters relax he didn't expect to blow up this quarantine is making myself and other late twenties and early 30s year olds time think about all the stuff that we used to love. So a lot of people are starting to blow up who made fun videos about SW, GOT, and.LOTR vids. They were just do it for fun, dont.be a hater its not.cool

@diamondsandgold1993

3 жыл бұрын

Can we see a video about how many troops at Gondors height of power?

Aren't Men supposed to be mightier than orcs? (Mordor orcs at least) and Men of Gondor mightier still? It really was frustrating seeing Gondor soldiers outnumbered AND outclassed.

@grimgrauman7650

4 жыл бұрын

Sauron breed stronger Orks called Morannon Orks who are stronger than normal Orks

@Reubixvk1

4 жыл бұрын

Factor in Nazgul and the Madness of Denethor to lower moral. Then each soldier is worth 2-3 orcs, but trolls account for 5-10 men (easily) depending if they are armored or not. And again, Nazgul. If there are wargs, the are probably equal to 1-5 men (depends on the type of soldier). I think one of the failures of the movies was its difficulty to portray time passing. Rohan shows up about 6-7 days after they're summoned and the battle is started about 5-6 days after. The Gondor army would have been on high alert for much of that time and had little to no rest during the battle. TL;DR if it was just orcs and Gondor was rested, they'd be fine. It wasn't just orcs...

@floppsieflopps3450

4 жыл бұрын

@Joseph Stalin Unlike yours

@feazy5479

4 жыл бұрын

Orcs are quantity gondorians supposed to be quality

@CamoflaugeDinosaue

4 жыл бұрын

The gondorians has been fighting for 3 days nonstop and were exhausted

If that's the size of Gondor's army at their low point, imagine how large Numenor's was during Ar Pharazon's reign!

@Frank-il3kt

4 жыл бұрын

Paragonath Probably around 150k, considering Morgoth had hundreds of thousands.

@oscaka0073

4 жыл бұрын

@@Frank-il3kt I thought Morgoth had around a Mil orcs ?

@Frank-il3kt

4 жыл бұрын

Oscaka 007 in any given battle Morgoth put 150-300k Orcs on field with other things such as Balrogs, dragons etc. He did have a million Orcs but spread out in different armies. Morgoth waged war on massive fronts. Remember Morgoth was the highest Angle, much stronger than say Sauron, so in a sense he was a God. Morgoth dwarfs anything Sauron could do. It took the literal world to beat him. This was a time where men, elves and dwarfs were at their strongest.

@oscaka0073

4 жыл бұрын

@@Frank-il3kt The Silmarillion right ? Getting one of them Tolkien books is rather hard in my country . Wish PJ could've make a trilogy out of that one . With proper funding and preparation time this time around and less , less that horrendous CGI . Can't wait for Morgoth to appear on the big screen and watch Sauron trembles before him .

@Frank-il3kt

4 жыл бұрын

Oscaka 007 Yes the Silmarillian. Where are you from? And I agree the Hobbit Movies were laziness and crappy CGI, nothing compares to the Lord of Rings. It’s sad PJ can’t do the Silmarillian because of copy rights I believe or something to do with that. If done right it could be the greatest movie of the next 20 years, kinda when Lord of Rings came out in 2001. Sauron would have been Morgoths chief Lieutenant. He was huge, but there were things much bigger even than him. By the time the events of Lord of the Rings happened the giant dragons, and spiders had died. I think Gandolf killed the last remaining Belrog, who would have fought with Morgoth in massive massive battles.

If I recall those knights in Gondor actually aren't bad. We do see them holding their own in the background. It's just the up close shots that are usually them getting killed by orcs. In the book I think they were actually beating the orcs pretty bad to the point that even when the gate went down they kept the fight there.

@christianhaegler4817

4 жыл бұрын

In the book they do nothing of the sort. In the book they're driven off the Rammas fairly quickly and chased across the Pelennor in a mostly disorganised manner. When the siege starts and goes, the Gondorians abandon the walls in fear and desperation and seek shelter in the second ring. When the orcs finally attack, the wall is empty. Except for one spot. The gate. Held by the Knights of Dol Amroth. These are the proper badasses and the heroes of the entire siege. They held yhe gate, they drove back the orcs on the Pelennor and saved Faramir's life, they joined the relief effort and figured out Eowyn wasn't actually dead.

@AdeptKing

4 жыл бұрын

@@christianhaegler4817 Really? I guess it's been a long time since I've read it then. I could of sworn that they actually held the orcs back at the gate even when it was knocked down.

@christianhaegler4817

4 жыл бұрын

@@AdeptKing Nah. While you are right, they defended the gate well, as I had mentioned before, it was not due to their defense that no orc passed through. In the book, right aftee the gate falls, the Witch King rides in for his faceoff with Gandalf...conversation ensues and then the horns of Rohan were blown and the Witch King fled. Gandalf stood alone, having none but Pippin on his side. Everyone else fled before the sight of the Witch King.

@christianhaegler4817

4 жыл бұрын

@Joakim von Anka The Rammas Echor is a very defensible position. If you have the troops to man it which Gondor had not. Technically EVERY fortification is just a delay. A delay till back-up arrives to lift the siege. That's why they exist. Regardless of it, the soldiers lf Gondor still performed fairly poorly in the books untill the Hordes lf Sauron were suddenly experienced withdrawal symptoms after having lost their Sauron mind drug.

@christianhaegler4817

4 жыл бұрын

@Joakim von Anka uhm...you do notice that I agreed? As said, every defensible position is just a delay. And the Rammas was primarily defended only at Osgiliath's side, where the attack was most likely. The battles for Osgiliath, Cair Andros and the Rammas Echor were all delays with the best possible defensive positions to hold the enemy for a time and hopefully cost him dearly. I do not agree on your view of Rohan on the other hand. Denethor was very mucy aware that Rohan would not come in time to man his walls, as Theoden said. Even with the aid of the Palantir he would have known that Rohan, which was already prepared, could not come before a week was over...more even considering that he sent Ingold before their preparations had progressed that far. Nay, he very much counted on a relief effort. And even that could've still come too late, hence why he probably urged them so much to hasten their approach.

As far as I know, a vanguard was very rarely more than a tenth of the army size and usually even smaller than that, it was not unusual that an army of 30k would have a vanguard of 500 knights. A vanguard is just some guys that ride ahead to check out the terrain and possibly seize good positions and try to hold them against nearby militia until the main host can catch up and reinforce the position. The vanguard was often not even a fighting force at all but just experts that rode ahead to look for good camp sites and possibly to demand the surrender of nearby towns or castles before the main host even arrived. I like to imagine Gondor at its height to be somewhat like Rome was around the time of the first and second punic wars 250-200BC where Rome when it was nesscesary could field armies of 50k+ men.

@razagoulbruce3044

4 жыл бұрын

Rome at peak could have between 450k to 500k

@JeyC_

4 жыл бұрын

@@razagoulbruce3044 an army that huge would be a waste anyway. I mean, many soldiers in most wars in history died more of diseases than the actual battles.

@van-sx1332

4 жыл бұрын

@@razagoulbruce3044 Yes but good luck trying to raise such an army on an Empire that had already integrated people who were angry for being part of them anyways. Plus the logistics to field such an army, the resources. And there are no known enemies that would require such a force. Like Jehiah said, they would probably die on marches, on camps, on sieges, before even getting a taste of battle.

@freedomfighter22222

4 жыл бұрын

@@JeyC_ In a single formation yes, Rome did in fact have around 450k millitary men around year 200AD but they were ofcourse split up in many different field armies and combat areas aswell as guard duties around the entire empire. I believe @Razagoul Bruce meant that they had total army not single field army of 450-500k men. You should also provide a link to the information and assumptions you are suggesting. What is "many" soldiers? I would argue about the"most wars in history" but that is impossible unless I know if by "many" you mean 1% or 50% of an army.

@XxBNFootball21xX

4 жыл бұрын

Gondor + Arnor combined are like Rome, Gondor were like the Byzantines

This appeared in my reccomdations, you're about to get a lot more views soon😁

@christophmatenaer2842

4 жыл бұрын

Same here :) Keep going

That is still a very respectful size for the Gondor army when they have been pretty much at war with mordor for the entire trilogy

@user-bs5wi2of6m

4 жыл бұрын

You mean 36 years

@realworldforum

4 жыл бұрын

For the entire 3000 years you mean

@user-bs5wi2of6m

4 жыл бұрын

@@realworldforum "trilogy" or Lord of the Rings

@realworldforum

4 жыл бұрын

@@user-bs5wi2of6m gondor has been at war since the begining of the third age

@armybear2

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah the entire Trilogy of LotR was only 1 year... so that doesn't sound very impressive. They haven't fought against Mordor for the entire Third Age, but they have been fighting essentially endless wars for the entire like 3000ish years against various factions. Essentially Easterlings, Haradrim, Corsairs, Dunlendings, Agmar, the kingdoms that use to belong to the other Ring Wraiths, themselves in various civil wars, possibly the elves and dwarves at some point in border skirmishes.

That last bit was interesting, with Prince Imrahil's quote about how the current army was only a fraction of what a Gondorian field army used to be. It reminds me a lot of late Roman history, where the Byzantine Empire's army was considerably smaller than the old Empire's armies at their height, but they kept shrinking in size as the Empire's size (and revenues) shrank in the aftermath of the Plague of Justinian and the Islamic conquests. In many ways there are similarities between Byzantine history and the lore surrounding Gondor; a weakened but resilient and determined empire that holds invaders at bay for many centuries even though it's only a shadow of its former self.

This really makes me want to play "The Last Days of the Third Age" mod for Mount & Blade: Warband.

@mdhall04

4 жыл бұрын

I see you are waiting for bannerlord.

@bloodlessbeast2661

4 жыл бұрын

@@mdhall04 it's been a hundred years

@mdhall04

4 жыл бұрын

@@bloodlessbeast2661 ive been told my future grandchildren will inherit my pre order.

@bloodlessbeast2661

4 жыл бұрын

@@mdhall04 one day it will be harvesting season

@pluvio154

4 жыл бұрын

I am rn

So detailed. I love it - great job. Also in the books, it said Gondor kept 10,000 men to guard the entire coast at all times. Even though there were attackers in the north. If that is true, then Gondor’s armies would maybe be closer or little more then 30,000 soldiers. But that’s speculation.

Gondor the crown jewel of the men of the west,the everlasting realm,surrounded by enemies but always prevails in the end

Citadeal guard had alone 3000 men

@BVargas78

4 жыл бұрын

Maybe at peak strength. But i'm pretty sure it was a lot less than that at the time of Return of the King.

@emwjmannen2

4 жыл бұрын

I think thats wrong, I think its supposed to be 300.

@BVargas78

4 жыл бұрын

@@emwjmannen2 That actually sounds right. But at Gondors peak i can imagine it being 3000 mighty warriors!

@emwjmannen2

4 жыл бұрын

@@BVargas78 Yes I think that too!

@angrycrusader3926

4 жыл бұрын

@@emwjmannen2 I think your thinking of the Elite Guards of the Fountain Court.

Forgets that I raised the volume. Plays another video. Ears explode

@kaireddy5700

4 жыл бұрын

lol

I’m glad this was in my reccomended

The answer is how ever many people applied to be an extra in the movie 😂

@darijoa1832

4 жыл бұрын

CGI armies are endless tnx to Isildur

@jiadizhang4107

4 жыл бұрын

Well, no. Because one extra can act as multiple soldiers in multiple shots.

Thank you for this information. The work you did was literally doing gods work in a sense

Think like medieval armies. 10k to 12k is the norm. Anything over 15k is a large army. So Gondor would have 25k max.

@luc1fer373

4 жыл бұрын

Sexywrm yeah unless your Pompeii in Greece Ahahah

@umbertalonsorovira9260

4 жыл бұрын

10000 was the norm for the biggest nations. The norm could be about 6000 - 8000

@martan1414

4 жыл бұрын

uhm... even Bohemia had more than 10k

@umbertalonsorovira9260

4 жыл бұрын

@@martan1414 we also have to clarify the period, because the medieval period is quite extense. If were talking about the last period 1200 - 1500, those numbers are quite possible

@martan1414

4 жыл бұрын

@Umbert alonso rovira Yeah, sure. I was talking about Bohemia in early 13th century

I love Gondor and everything to do with it. Thank you for the amazing video

I made an estimate of 30000 as a teenager back in the 1970's. Years later I came up with a smaller figure like this: As for troops that came with Aragorn, the text refers to ships as dromunds, which is a variant of dromon, the Byzantine galley. The text refers to 50 great ships which would be full size dromons, which carried 150 rowers and 50 marines. So that would be 2500 fighting men. The text also says there were innumerable smaller ships. Dromons came in two smaller sizes, one with about 100 men and the other with about 150 men. I'll assume 25 and 35 fighting men per ship and 50 of each. So Aragorn brought 5500 to the relief of the city. We have more information We know they the composition of the force sent to Morder had 3500 troops drawn from X, 2000 drawn from the 5500 that came north with Aragorn, 500 out of Imrahils 700 and 1000 out of the Rohirrim. Another 3000 Rohirrim were sent to waylay enemy forces in Anorien. So this suggests that X is roughly 3500/2000 times bigger than the 5500 Aragorn brought or about 10000. This gives total Gondorian strength as 10000 + 5500 with Aragon + 4000 with Angbor + 3000 outlanders to give 22500. Then if you add the 3000 assumed left in the other fiefs I get 25500. So a tad higher than your figure.

The video was perfectly fine and the content well appreciated. Thank you!

Only 17 subs? You deserve thousands man!

@bubbamike4743

Жыл бұрын

Amazing to see how far you’ve come, I’m entering another lotr obsession and have been binging all your videos like crazy

Lots of potential... Loved the video, song choices, atmosphere creation. Stick to that and your exhortations will fly far.

Great job, both entertaining and informative - keep up the good work, I'm sure you'll explode very soon.

Amazingly interesting subject and video overall. Love it, nice job! Instant sub

I don't know why you would say you are not making amazing stuff. The videos you make are an absolute delight for any Tolkien nerd or to pull another guy into the rabbit hole of middle earth. Thank you so much for your awesome work, I hope you never stop making videos.

@DarthGandalfYT

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much, but I do love my self-deprecating humour.

I really enjoyed the video. Keep them coming :)

I think you the way that you thought through this to be very clear and while open to interpretation presents us with a reasonable assessment for the purposes of comparison.

Enjoyed this video a lot and keep up the good work :)

Liked the video! It's hard with guesswork can be frustrating as all hell but I think you made some really good choices. Keep it up! I like seeing discussions about those little topics you didn't realize you needed lol helps to get a better picture of events and enriches the experience of reading the books. I really didn't like how weak they made the Gondorian soldiers seem. Overwhelm them if you have to but it seems like every two seconds you were seeing men run up to an orc, he gets his sword parried and then the orc runs him through. They weren't farmers, farriers, and stable boys and yet Rohan did way better! (Don't get me wrong, I personally find Rohan more interesting) but still!

that video was awesome. I'm glad I found your channel on reddit

As I prepare to binge your content and add you to my rotation of Tolkien discussions

Very good video, hope this channel picks up, subbed, only criticism I have is the mic quality, if you want to pick up a better one down the line you can get some great usb dynamic mics for very little, combined with a pop shield and you’re sorted :)

Outstanding video

Subbed! Good video mate keep the vids coming

just came up in my feed, liked and subbed. good content! Maybe look at getting a better mic and processing since you sound pretty distant, but you have the right voice for this sort of material. I'll watch more. And your 20k-25k estimate is right around where I would have put them as well if they could muster their complete army. If they armed all able citizenry, what could they swell to? How many people lived in Gondor at this time? 250k is likely on the high end. A complete last ditch levy militia could swell the ranks to almost 100k, but most would be easy prey for Orcs and Sauron's allied Men.

This video is very informative and good. Educational is a good thing.

Literally subbed because of your name. Love it

Ey very nice video! :D

Nice analysis

Gondor soldiers are so underrated in the LOTR movies. Rohirrim are so far more competitive than Gondor’s

@Ba5edAF

Жыл бұрын

Cavalry vs Infantry....

@sosna1443

10 ай бұрын

Look how much screen time we got of gondor vs rohan actually fighting. Rohan may be seen as better just because they are involved in tide turning events and provide groundbreaking shock value. But in the end its gondor that Has tougher stationary units and can actually hold off heavy attacks. Rohan probably wouldnt do that as well which was kinda proved by them fleeing to helms deep.

Wow I’ve always wanted to know this. And I like the logic that you bring with it about the different fiefdoms and how they would also have to defend them selves. I agree with the numbers as well that seems to be right. I’ve seen speculations that Gondors total population is 2 million. So 20-25 thousand would be a very small portion of their male population. But yeah man what an awesome video.

Very interesting video. Gondor reminds me so very much of the Eastern Roman Empire, in our own time. I hope to see more, carry on the excellent work!

@DarthGandalfYT

4 жыл бұрын

I'm actually planning on doing a video on that at some point. I don't know if Tolkien had it in mind, but there are lots of similarities.

@nikolalesov8359

4 жыл бұрын

@@DarthGandalfYT I suspect so. Gondor also seems like 17th century Austria. There are some similarities between the siege of Minas Tirith and the siege of Constantinople 717 - 718 AD, when the Bulgarians helped the Bysantines hold off 2 Arabian armies. It is even more similar to the siege of Vienna 1683 AD, when the hussars helped the Austrians to drive back the army of the Ottoman empire. This event marks the beginning of the end of the said empire.

@henrikg1388

4 жыл бұрын

@@nikolalesov8359 Yup kzread.info/dash/bejne/lal-zZiGdLjAdrA.html

It is honestly a shame that Jackson wasn't able to showcase the various feifdoms that are loyal to Gondor and are duty bound to raise banners in times of war. Prince Imrahil and his Knights of Dol Amroth, Dol Amroth Men at Arms, and also the Axemen of Lossarnach, fiefdoms of Anfalas, Belfalas, Lebenin etc etc. In the 3rd movie I felt as though there was a feeling of emptiness or lack of character with the Gondorian Army; one that was permeated by fear (not that they shouldn't have feared), but there didn't seem to be a major rallying defiance in defense of the city....no ANGER and battle lust to slay the orcs or aggression. Just my thoughts.

@Sanguinary797

6 ай бұрын

Yeah, the movies somewhat portray Gondor as a buffed up city state, although I realize that hiring that many extras, and making that many sets in an already expensive and long enough movie would be difficult at best.

@road3557

Ай бұрын

That’s why there should have been a series on this war so they can show it in detail. Rings Of Power has ruined Tolkiens work.

Well thought out and done. The portrayal of Gondor in the Return of the King movie always bothered me. Like you said, it was still the most powerful free kingdom in Middle Earth and had been holding back the tide of Mordor for centuries by that point. I would have much rather the whole mini "side quest" of Pippen lighting the beacon been left out and replaced with a scene showing the beacons already lit and Gandalf explaining to Pippen (and thus, the audience) who the lords were and what was happening. That, and a proper Battle of Pelennor Fields.

@alphalegionary7646

2 жыл бұрын

At least we got that one chad Gondorian soldier who impales two orcs on his spear and slams them on the ground.

@bosertheropode5443

10 ай бұрын

​@@alphalegionary7646If you pay attention to the background there are lots of Gondorian soldiers who absolutely body the orcs (some literally beat them to death lmao). It's just in the foreground that they get destroyed :/

@zippyparakeet1074

10 ай бұрын

​@@bosertheropode5443 yeah I saw a gondorian soldier literally pick an orc by his hands and slam him against the wall, punching the shit out of him. That's lote accurate in my opinion.

@bosertheropode5443

10 ай бұрын

@@zippyparakeet1074 I find it highly amusing how they just screw their swords and decide to beat the living crap out of them instead.

This was great!

i subbed on this video, cool stuff man

Cool vid! Try sorcing higher res image's or adapting your render settings

I have to say I share your frustration at the soldiers portrayal in the movies. They just bumble about like idiots and totally takes me out of the battle scenes for Minas Tirith every time. Sauron might as well have only sent 20 orcs to beat that mob of stumbling spazoids

Nice Video! I absolutely agree with all your points here. What do you think about the Numenorian Armada during Ar-Pharazon's Invasion against Sauron?

Good video! And I found your numbers sound.

Great analisis

I do think Gondor's full army is larger than you estimate as Lossarnach which you referenced only sent a tenth of what was expected. I say that Gondor's full muster was probably much larger, because not all fiefs are equal and some would have larger contingents that had not been sent. If we estimate that based on the reactions in the books that only a tenth of the total strength of each region was sent to the Battle of Pelennor Fields, and even with Aragorn taking a sizeable number on the boats he took from the Corsairs, I'd say at most we saw maybe 20-30% of the total army size at the Battle of the Black Gate. Based on that I'd say the total strength of Gondor at full muster would be around 42K. But this would be a total muster, not the small musters we saw in the books.

A reasonable guess. Nice vid!

Let's create a patreon to gets this guy a new mic! Awesome vid 👍

Gondors lands and armies were huge and vast from when the the faithful arrived and settled from Numenour. Before the Stewards 32 kings ruled`, there land stretched from north field of Celebrant to southern Mirkwood, west to the Greyflood, inland to Rhun and and the ruled Umbar. - but there realm grew smaller as it due to a mixture of reasons after the death of King Hyarmedacil around 1050. Firstly the kings didn’t have many children or heirs and numenorean blood was weakened, then they lost Umbar in the kinstrife civil war were many soldiers died and Osgiliarth was pretty much ruined. Then the great plague swept through killing huge numbers in Gondor including the king and his children - there wearn’t enough soldiers left to guard the fortesses watching and defending against Mordor. Then attacks by the Wainriders for about 100 years shrunk Gondors armies further - and their lands shrunk even more. The last king, Earnur went to fight the Witch king and never returned - in 2050 the first ruling steward replaced the kings rule`. 3019 was the year of the attack on Minas Tirith - so thousands of years had past since Gondor was a truly huge and vast kingdom with enormous armies `- this is probably what Denethor is referring to IMO - the slow decline of this one mighty kingdom.

@CailinZwarts

10 ай бұрын

From the Gwathló to the sea of Rhûn, from the fields of Celebrant to Umbar, everything in between used to belong to Gondor, and after Aragorn reunited the kingdom it became even bigger, adding almost all the lands of Eriador to it.

ive always wondered about these things glad im not alone

Lord of the Rings does mention the numbers, Aragorn, Prince Imrahil, Eomer, and Gandalf talk of the armies they have...

Was good mate. Cheers

Very well done

Good job!

Very underrated channel

Good video keep it up.

Good video thanks

I broadly agree with your number crunching. Karen Wynn Fonstad's "Atlas of Middle-Earth" arrives at similar numbers. She argues that Gondor's troops that participated in the Battle of the Pelennor fields numbered about 5,250 (11,250 total, minus 6,000 from Rohan). That doesn't count Angbor's troops and the other coastal folk coming up the river to reinforce Minas Tirith after the battle; nor does it count the troops that stayed behind in Gondor's fiefs. If we also consider the host marching on the Morannon being about 6,000 Gondor troops, and Minas Tirith being left "better defended" than before the Battle of the Pelennor Fields, and the troops still in the outlying fiefs, you are looking at a minimum of 6,000 on the Black Gate, 6,000 left behind in Minas Tirith, and probably 6,000 to 12,000 still in the outlying fiefs (especially if we consider Lossarnach alone would have 2,000 troops, considering Forlong's 200 men arriving at Minas Tirith were only "a tenth" of what was hoped for), for somewhere between 18,000 and 24,000 total. Perhaps a few thousand more levies could be scrounged up if things became even more dire and Gondor's hinterlands were being overrun, but I'd guess that the fiefdom troops had already raised what levies as they could, as some of the troops arriving from the outlying fiefs to Minas Tirith are described as being not incredibly well-equipped, and if there's any time that levies would be raised, it would be during the War of the Ring when Minas Tirith is about to fall. Gondor's population probably totaled less than a million in all, so 24,000 would be a very reasonable 2.4% of the population engaged in arms. (Hard for medieval-level societies to go far beyond that without running into problems supplying their armies with food and weapons, unless you are like the Rohirrim where almost all of the fit male population is expected to be answerable to muster on short notice, and where shield-maidens are expected to bear almost the entire responsibility of protecting and supplying the home front. Rohan likely had only 100,000 or so in population total, so their 12,000 cavalry would have represented about 12% of their total population, or almost every fit adult male that could be spared who had access to a horse).

@adrianciobanu5856

4 жыл бұрын

ROHAN ARMY BIFORE 2 ISEN BATTLES MAST ARIVE TO MINIMUM 20000 ARTER FULL MOBILIZATION NOW THAT GONDOR HAVE MORE TERITORY BETER DIET LIVING AROUND 50% LONGER THAT ROHANS GIVE TO GONDOR A TOTAL ARMY 0F 30000 O SOLDAIRES TUGETHER WITH DRU CONTINGENT , OLSO IS LOGIC THAT AROUND OF 1000 OF NORTH RANGERS CAME MEIBI IN UMBAR SHIPS OLSO SAME MEN FROM DORVINION SO FOR THE ENTIRE SOUTH WAR CAMPAIN WITH MINIMUM 3 BATTLES OF ROHAN 2 OR 3 BATTLES FOR OSGHILIATH PELENOR BATTLE PELAGIR BATLE AND IN FRONT OF BLACK GATE BATTLE MAST HAVE FROM 51000 TO 52000 SOLDAIRES FOR 8 OR 9 BATTLES.

dope video, new sub :D

Great video!

Men in service?About 30k Including militia and levies?60k

@jackedwards4264

4 жыл бұрын

so basically elite, trained soldiers akin to early roman legionnaires and then a further peasant levy including fighting-age men from around gondor?

@MJFAN666

4 жыл бұрын

No way that high

@jackedwards4264

4 жыл бұрын

Mr. Myxzptlyk probably 20k servicemen and at the very very most 30k levies

@realworldforum

4 жыл бұрын

@@jackedwards4264 yep but the type of the soldiers of gondor changes.You have axemen of Lossarnac,soldiers of Dol Amroth,archers of Lamedon ect

@realworldforum

4 жыл бұрын

@@MJFAN666 look at the numbers.They had 5000 men stationed at Minas Tirith.They excpected ten times the number of men to come and defend the city.That means that they excpected 30k men.Let's say most of them were levies.Also Aragorn brings a lot of men from western and southern Gondor.

Tower Guards have such a cool armour design. so majestic, royal and high class.

This is the first LOTR lore KZreadr I've seen without a lisp.

@jaimebuan262

4 жыл бұрын

Agreed

@drip9210

4 жыл бұрын

Licshp

I can not understand that everyone complaining about gondor soldiers in the movies. My opinion is that PJ did a pretty good job with them. Many forget that the battle of Gondor was more psychological, despair was Mordor's best weapon. PJ shows us the chaos and horror just as it was in the book. They fight for days against odds 10 against 1. Remember that in the book when Grond approached the gate, the defense was already broken, the men had already begun to retreat to the second level, before the enemy took the gate, except Dol Amroth's soldiers. The soldiers in the movie even do a better job when they meet the enemy at the gate, and fight every street all the way up to the third level.

@mmcaog

4 жыл бұрын

There is a disconnect in the films between what is implied to be happening and what you actually see. At Osgiliath the Orcs attack at night and in the morning Faramir's very small force is still fighting, suggesting they have held the orcs off all night. Again at Minas Tirith they are implied to be holding the enemy off from the afternoon all the way to the next morning. But in the close-ups you almost always see them getting killed. I don't think there was ever a deliberate decision to make Gondor's soldiers look weak, just that extras are given directions like 'you guys are on the back foot' so if you had nothing else to go on you would allow yourself to lose.

@C00kiesAplenty

4 жыл бұрын

@@mmcaog Yea they are implied to be valiantly holding the enemy back at all costs; but whenever they are shown they are just getting slaughtered.

@tylerellis9097

4 жыл бұрын

Torbjorn Sjoblom Because literally every scene they’re getting stomped

@cameronbergen4848

4 жыл бұрын

They're supposed to be hardened veterans of war wearing high qualify plate armour with quality steel weapons, and you'd assume some training. They use very little in the way of organized tactics and show almost no skill against the orcs. They get ploughed over. The only time men of Gondor fight well in the movies is the ranger ambush on the Haradrim. The Rohirrim save the day are always super awesome despite Gondor's better equipped and likely more experienced soldiers.

Good one

Imagine the last alliance with how big that battle was. Gondor is pretty large they have a lot more numbers then we think just at the time Gondor was being pushed back ever so slowly

@hazzmati

4 жыл бұрын

Imagine the battles that were fought back in the first age, third age battles pale in comparison.

@chasebuckner4479

4 жыл бұрын

Hazzmati 10000%% correct

@SantomPh

4 жыл бұрын

the Gondor of that age held back Mordor for 3 years on its own before Elendil and Isildur returned with the Elves.

@Will.Flavell

3 жыл бұрын

Gondor has over one hundred thousand soldiers back at the end of the second age

nice. some dwarf vids would be awsome

Great video! Now the only question is whether I want to collect Minas Tirith or Fiefdoms for my Middle Earth SBG good army.

@DarthGandalfYT

5 жыл бұрын

I'm not sure what the pieces look like, but I reckon the Minas Tirith soldiers would look cooler. And also the Swan Knights of Dol Amroth would probably look pretty sweet too. A lot of fiefdom troops are described as being feudel, ie. dressed more like hunters or peasants than soldiers.

@friedmanfamily9194

4 жыл бұрын

@@DarthGandalfYT not Dol amroth, they are described as being the most close to what numenor was originally. also the fiefdoms models are way cooler

@mitch1748

4 жыл бұрын

Minas tirith have more options and better hero’s!

The warriors of Gondor looked like they’d never been trained except to outrun women and children

Gondor was so strong that when Sauron first fought them he surrendered without a fight. makes the one ring and still fails in battle against them, manages to be in superior numbers against them for decades as an immortal maia and still fails lol

@randomelite4562

Жыл бұрын

Gondor didn’t exist when Sauron surrendered, that was Numenor

I always felt like they had like 50men in the movie :P

@tonyabohannan891

4 жыл бұрын

Ikr

@Badnercalabrese

4 жыл бұрын

Yepp and just getting rekt from all angles ....

@nathanmerritt1581

Жыл бұрын

​@@Badnercalabresebut they prevailed at the end.

Can you do like a vs. Military middle-earth style like who would win if dwarfs vs. Gondor type of deal

Could you do a video about how big was Mordor's army was? I mean after all they attacked the most powerful kingdom with a massive army, I know the movies are different from the book but I think I remember hearing something along the lines of 200,000 orcs attacking the city. I think I heard that on the special features for return of the king. But Sauron still had a massive army waiting at the black gate later on.

I myself played around with these numbers. My personal guesses put a theoretical max for Gondor’s armies at around 40,000 though that was assuming similar situation with Lossarnach for the other fiefs who were worried about the Corsairs an sent only about 1/10th of their army to Minas Tirith. Of course population can vary wildly in some regions and some groups may have sent proportionally more of their force so i choose to treat my estimate from way back when as the high end. I felt this number made sense as the Army Gondor sent to fight Angmar was supposed to be almost 50,000 which still gets across how far Gondor has fallen from its heyday. I’ve seen some estimates here in chat for as much as Thirty thousand or figures similar to what you proposed which I think are probably more realistic. I personally now go with about 30,000as it leaves a bit more wiggle room just in case some parts of Gondor are withholding similar amounts of their forces to Lossarnach.

Can you do an elves one with 1st age era and a 2and age era?

Very informative Quasimodo! So how many orcs and such were at the Battle of pelennor fields?

@DarthGandalfYT

4 жыл бұрын

Tolkien never gives a number. The only number we receive is the Haradrim, who "thrice outnumbered" the Rohirrim, so 18,000 for them. If I had to guess, I'd say the total number of evil forces at Pelennor was around 100,000.

@markdiperna1523

4 жыл бұрын

@@DarthGandalfYT oooooooweeeeeeee! That's a whooole lotaa whipin! ooooooweee! Thanks for the response. How many were sent to erebor and mirkwood?

aye, kinda bugged me how there were no exact mentions of army size(s) in the books. great video btw!

@SantomPh

4 жыл бұрын

Tolkien never wanted his story to be a Homeric epic of numbers, which is why most of the narrations are by the Hobbits being present.

Please can you do a army size of mordor as by size at the peak of there power during third age.

When England was invaded in 1066 the Saxons mustered 7,000 men for the battle of Hastings, just a few weeks after defeating the Northmen at Stamford Bridge. While some of the core units would have been the same, most were local levees. Prior to the agricultural revolution it took a lot more men working the fields to feed the country and they could not all go off to fight without starvation happening. 25,000 would be a sizable army to put in the field considering the long decline of the population and the ever more harsh conditions for farming.

@nodinitiative

4 жыл бұрын

Yup, if you notice, a lot of ancient and medieval armies have their average sizes. During ancient times a full scale military operation would be around 40,000. During Medieval times the average amount was just 20,000-30,000. This was not just because of population sizes, but mainly due to the ability of army to be fed. So Gondor's could have been larger, but the army could only feed fewer than 25,000 at a time.

@itshenry8977

2 жыл бұрын

I disagree The Pellenor fields were a great bread basket in The books it almost looked like Verdun since they brought food, weapons, people into The City with such haste that stuck wagons would be thrown off The road

@zippyparakeet1074

10 ай бұрын

In the year 960 the Byzantine Empire- aka the Eastern Roman Empire- fielded 40,000 men transported via hundreds of assaults ships for the reconquest of Crete. And this was at a time when the Empire was nowhere near the height of its power. Army sizes varied from state to state. The Eastern Roman Empire was far more centralised with a well-oiled bureaucracy compared to the Western European kingdoms of the time.

Every nation needs an army. It was pitiful that Gondor has so few soldiers available.

What I really would like is a video on how big could Isengard's army be without the haste to attack and how big could it become had Saruman suceeded on his campaign on Rohan.

As your sixtieth subscriber I demand a video on the number of the Dale defense force and their allies in Erabor *GOOD LUCK GIVE EM HELL* 👍👍

meanwhile in GoT they always talk about hundreds of thousands while you only see 100 soldiers at max in the show. :D

Please raise the volume

I gotta get that Gondorian armor that's probably the coolest armor in the history of fantasy unless you count the clone wars as fantasy.

@randomelite4562

2 жыл бұрын

A bit unfortunate that the Gondorians in the books don’t actually have plate armor lol

Nice vid. Talk a little slower though, especially when going over numbers. It’s tough to follow when you’re going so fast. It was something I had to learn too as an attorney when doing trial work. Interesting topic for us nerds to ponder and something I always wondered. I always felt like the movies made the armies at Pelennor Fields seem too large; I’m pretty sure of it now. Although I’ll go back and watch to see. And stormtroopers of middle earth- 😂

Gondor armour is visually impressive

A movie on the Witch-King would be amazing.

A very nice video... I agree it's sad to see how Gondor was portrayed, likely so Jackson could put up Aragorn as the one hero. Showing Denethor as a neglectful dictator was a waste. Book Denethor was indeed a master tactician, who did what he could, with what he had, only falling to despair when he saw in the palantir that actually Mordor had three or even four times as many forces in waiting East of Anduin, or assaulting the North. My only comment is about Vanguard sizes.My impression was that the vanguard; the Forward Guard, was functionally an army ready to fight, and always on patrol, clearing enemies, removing obstacles, and holding the line, should an enemy army be encountered. Armies are huge. And move at roughly 2mph when heavily laden with supply wagons. Having a mobile force to enter and hold terrain is key. The rear guard does the same at the rear. So Gondor having a vanguard of 7,000 in the olden days, would imply to me a standing army of 50,000... And that's just one army... Rarely can a nation attack in one place. They may have been able to field twice that.

your mic made me check the videos release date

What I didn't like was that Peter Jackson made the elephants the size of tenement buildings. That was kinda ridiculous, IMHO.

@timmycrw91

4 жыл бұрын

PS- I also am thinking of the time of Alexander the Great. When he went about conquering "the world", he "only" took 30,000 soldiers when doing so. So maybe that might need to be applied to the reasoning here. Otherwise you're left using numbers more akin to Dark Ages European kingdoms as opposed to barbarian hordes, IMHO.

I think it is sad how your video blew up this much and your new videos get few thousand views at most.. keep it up though

@DarthGandalfYT

3 жыл бұрын

I'm hoping my persistence will pay off.

Nice

That was interesting :-)