Avail our press freedom offer: pages.razorpay.com/press-freedom-offer Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscription?ref=AA Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61PEo0QeacOqU9vr2k

Another reason why you may end up watching Heeramandi is when you are totally jetlagged and don't know if it's day or night and you keep falling asleep and waking up to all the so called boring symmetrical nonsense and falling asleep again... I mean that's exactly how it happened with me and my wife...

@SurojitOBondhura

24 күн бұрын

And by the way we immediately watched some KZread clips of Utpal Dutta Golmaal to relish our asymmetrical, intelligent, heart-felt, masterpiece...

@RashminderKaurindia

23 күн бұрын

@@SurojitOBondhura I do that also...I watch Hrishikesh Mukherjee or Basu Da movies or similar ones frequently to just refresh my heart :)

Bombay has no red light area. Oh sweet summer child.

@preetipadmini

23 күн бұрын

Kamathipura!

@mansoorahmad1489

15 күн бұрын

Bhansali's last movie was about mumbai's red light area.

Thanks for covering the disaster that this Heeramandi Fiasco is. Literally I was irked by the actors trying their hands on Urdu, their diction was killing me and probably Mirza’s ghalib too in his grave.😢 You must have felt the difference how Farida Jalal was speaking. That was effortless and not heavy on the ears. Also the story telling with some worst kind of twists and turns were too much for me. Being well versed with Urdu I could not take this assault on my soul and quit the series after watching two episodes 🤝 Dosti bani rahe 😢

@nehaverma4889

24 күн бұрын

I stopped watching it after first 2 or 3 scenes. Don't know why this hype. Undeserved!

@RashminderKaurindia

24 күн бұрын

Its one thing to create an ambience and another to infuse spirit in it. Same was the case with Umrao Jaan starting Aishwarya and Abhishek. It was so cringe in terms of writing, shallow shayari and no layered veiled emotion...it was as if seeing a WhatsApp version of a Classic piece of literature. People who want to create a time period need to shed their own skin first. These actors and directors don't have time to even immerse their feet in the ocean they are attempting to represent...appearances never mean anything but the spirit does. Bhansali ruined Mastani and now this!! Nuances mein koi Degree hoti in se kehte ke jao padhai kar lo...I watched Satyajit Ray's Home and the World and he kept it so simple and true to its core and that actually brought the entire feel of 1900s effortlessly and its not rubbed in your face so that you can truly feel the story instead. The resources spent on mediocre works of art breaks my heart...

@SilentBoy10

23 күн бұрын

Urdu Talafus Nazi 😂

@indianfan1029

21 күн бұрын

Exactly. We dont give an F about Urdu.

@ibrahimuzair08

16 күн бұрын

@@indianfan1029 and Urdu is an Indian language for your F***ing ignorance

I couldn't watch 20-30 minutes of Heeramandi. I think I should've known it wasn't my cup of tea, I absolutely hate seeing women treated like things and I just had to stop at 'nath utarna' or something.

Kamathi Pura is the red light area in Mumbai. I live in friking Lahore and even I bloody know it. How could you people not know the red light area of Mumbai. Forget about knowing the history, have you not even watched the last movie Bhansali made? It was about a prostitute living in Mumbai's red light area. why are you even discussing his movie then.

20:29 Correction- Rasoolan Bai belonged to the Banaras Gharana. It has nothing to do with twaif. Gharana is the style of singing.

I can’t see the link for The Other Song, that Abhinandan has recommended

SLB is one of the most over rated film maker. He makes fairytales that only child like brains appreciate.

@Subhash_1987

24 күн бұрын

Agreed 💯💯

@adityaraj2213

23 күн бұрын

Its an escape from reality for some He is preserving what OG Indian cinema used to be(dialogues, dances, sets) It resembles a play rather than a documentary

@RandomThot

13 күн бұрын

Gosh he is so repetitive, I can’t distinguish between his last 3 movies - and for Heeramandi the Urdu diction and so called “kathak” absolutely no grace while delivering either of the ‘art forms’ !! The Alam lady was such a pain in neck absolutely expressionless

The description doesn't have the documentary link on Rasulan bai

Finally the facts are being reviewed here. As he said the whole show was pointless. 😂😂😂😂

Kudos for getting the accessibility features! Chitranshu thanks for leading that

Love you both & your super banter❤

Pop tarts are for breakfast what US is for democracy....damn it was difficult coming up with that.

@gitasingh1437

24 күн бұрын

It was smart and apt 👍😹

Thank you for this! Heeramandi is actually an insult to actual tawaifs and their achievements that paved the way for the Indian film and music industries. 🥲

Watched "The Other Song" as recommended by Abhinandan. Heart wrenching. Exceptional talent lost to the high morality guardians.

Thanks

Rajshree was about to compliment Taaha Shah who looked dreamy af and went full SRK with lovelorn eyes - the only silly fun that carried me through till his death episode. Loved this Fawad-lite performance of a stupid storyline. Also preposterous that a nawab’s son with bare minimum involvement in some fictitious revolutionary group that has no ideology somehow, would just be killed by Brits in prison unceremoniously

@indianfan1029

21 күн бұрын

Also, I felt that Fareedan may act as a witness in some sort of judicial inquiry. I mean kuch to hota hoga na us waqt bhi. But aisa kuch hua hi nahi. So it made no sense to show her going there. Choti bachi to nahi thi wo. Agar waha na jaati to kya brutality ka andaza nahi lagta usko.

After a long time I agree with you guys, Heeramandi is $hitty show, Bansali's movies are low on content. I am not watching Heeramandi.

@ibrahimuzair08

16 күн бұрын

low content but visually appealing..however i liked Devdas and Black

@ratulda1

15 күн бұрын

@@ibrahimuzair08 Didn't like those as well. He screwed up Devdas.

And 👏👏👏👏 for accessibility features for our friends with disabilities. Kudos.

So true Heeramandi was such a snooze, why didnt they start with the freedom struggle, i was not at all invested in the whole enimity blah blah...

thank you for the review. May December is on Netflix

Kamathipura is Mumbai's red light area. His movie Gangubai Kathiayawadi was based in that area

Loved this. New sub!😍

this is comedy gold please make review/roasting videos

Their are few areas at Mumbai which are known as Red Light area such as Kamatipura, Faras Road.

Loved this podcast ❤😂😁

Love Jerry Seinfeld and loved unfrosted. Just started watching the show. Awesome. Good fun😊

Awesome show guys ❤

I also do not know how it is different to any Saas Bahu series hahaha

Songs are actually good... Aditi Manisha, Richa and Sonakshi are so good

Thank you for the bit on Mandakini! 😂

She shud be appreciated fr nt watching the whole 8 episodes

Mumabi has Kamathipura. SLB has made a film on that too as Gangubai

Funy episode great show

Thanks Abhinandan for suggesting The Other Song!!

Art director now directing😂😂😂😂😂😂

Devdas was murder and Heeramandi was so shallow. Could have been magnificent but alas typical SLB. Visuals over substance. Manisha K was slouched all the time 🤣 And So true I was so confused I kept thinking it was in Lucknow.🤦🏽‍♀️

mumbai's red light area is kamathipura.......the movie gangubai kathiawadi was set in that area

@birajification

24 күн бұрын

For a decade or so, for us kids in Nepal, during the 90s, Bombai/Bombay/ Mumbai was synonymous to human trafficking and AIDS. That's where our lost village belles were sold. Awareness teleserials, songs, campaigns documentaries broadcasted by Nepal television depicted Bombay as a smelly place with skyscrapers and perverts with taste for Nepali kids. Then slowly we began hearing that's where Nepali film makers go for song recording and mixing. But the red light image of बम्बै stuck in our minds.

@sanjaygadhalay1523

24 күн бұрын

GB road. Too

@brascoperryjoe6425

23 күн бұрын

​@@birajificationGood that you saved yourselves. Now I guess, there's no Nepalis in Bombay\Mumbai earning their bread?

Not sure what the hype is about. At the same time as Heeramandi we are witnessing the greatest TV drama of all time on Netflix. Give Queen of Tears a try

Kamathipura is in Bombay, where the story of Gangubai is based.

24 मिनट के आसपास इंटीग्रेशन शब्द पंच क्यों किया गया है? Someone please enlighten

I am ok with reviewers giving bad review but it’s quite unprofessional to review something and not knowing or forgetting the names of the actors (Adhyayan Suman). Also someone who claims to have watched 30 minutes is of reviewing 7 hours of content.

Bombay's red light area is Kamathipura and its near Grant Road.

@riaagarwal6840

24 күн бұрын

Looks like you have good info 😂

How have you not heard of Kamathipura? Bombay?

I came across your podcast by chance. I'm from Pakistan and I can confirm no one talks like this in Lahore - not even in 1920s or 19040s -- if you want to see a Lahori Tawaif, I suggest you watch Iman Ali in Bol movie. The accents of all the actors except Farida Jalal were totally off. I agree the it was a cringe-fest through and through

Idk why, but i still liked heeramandi🤷🏻‍♀️, i could say i loved it even

We should have first and foremost ascertained whether this was a review of Heeramandi or merely a casual conversation during a break; in the latter case, the review felt more hurriedly done, since one should ideally complete the series prima facie before reviewing anything.

I guess it's high time we understand that only realism is not the perspective in art. It is a very Oriental way of looking at things

@adityaraj2213

23 күн бұрын

Bruh you spoke me mind 🫶

Guys, Pakeezah was another level! The dance was not the highlight. The painful story of the tawaif and the splendour of the kotha was. The beautiful romance and the dialogue delivery are just two of the countless magical displays. Come on...won't have you writing it off.

Mr. Sekhri you are very old, if you still remember the song 😂

Unfrosted in enjoyable movie. Its done well. Abhinandan Shekri, watch the damn movie. Its not as bad the lady is describing it.

32:32 looking at abhinandan and looking at her.... Yea stick to the Oats

If nawabs had to be shown! Mr. Bhansali should have also described the region of India they belonged to, I still think this story had to take place in banaras or Lucknow. And Please! anyone let me know the history of Heeramandi of Lahore

@bhadwamodi8294

24 күн бұрын

simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heera_Mandi

Also there is so much taam jhaam and decoration in scenes than nothing stands out!

The Urdu. Except Farida Jalal who nailed it, good grief, the cast couldn't even. Sonakshi was marginally better. Also. Lahore. You would have performative Urdu nakhra and nazaakat but in their personal lives it would've been solid Punjabi and how.

What's with the knocking sound?

Kamathipura nahi malum 😂😂😂 level of journalism

@6:27..... Thanks for the information 😁 I really don't know about sona ghachi area & GB Road of Delhi (it's grant road kamathi pura area area in bombay known as a red light area) By the way I wonder why modi ji did not change Name of GB Road, अगर अकबर रोड का नाम बदली हो सकता हैं तो GB Road का क्यों नहीं !!! 😁😁😁

@atinusabraham

24 күн бұрын

He is pure. Doesn’t know it exists.

Thanks... Some one is saying about the obscene Heeramandi ...

@gitasingh1437

24 күн бұрын

Sonagaachi is worse there is no concept of tehzeeb , manners or anything .

You forgot Kamathipura - Gangu bai?

She is a critic pr excellence she just put the whole hard work of bhansali to gp road and Sona gachi Love you Bengali Der naam paani te dhele dao

Nice show. Did not like how the man kept on correcting her so confidently. Even if you are right, try to say it with an intention to cross-check it, not to prove that you are correct. You dont always needs to have "facts are facts" moments.

Grant Road?

May December!

Songs are good

Guys, i think Abhinandan doesn’t like Heeramandi.

Everything is great about NL. But sometimes the CEO is intolerable and cringe. How is he so off the mark while rest of the team is in same place.

Its amazing how you guys manage to prattle away endlessly. ...

Come on Abhinandan Mumbai has Kamatipura almost as big as Sonagachi !

53 minutes of Abhinandan bullying the host :')

@AllThingsAudio420

22 күн бұрын

hahaha

Subscribed to your channel

mumbai has kamathipura

Mr. Sekhri and his counterpart, Rajshree Sen, both come across as boring and apathetic. They lack sensitivity and seem to associate Mandakini with Dawood. Regardless of her past, Mandakini is trying to integrate into society, much like Rajshree, who as a transgender person, deserves acceptance. However, both Mr. Sekhri and Rajshree mistreat women and prefer to ridicule them.

Dude keeps interrupting the woman. Very fun if amateurish reviews

Why are reviewers so uninformed about the show they are reviewing, please write notes

Well, I have no issues as long as the director is satisfied with the film.

There is no reason to pin high hopes on Bansali. But I couldn't understand the logic of criticisms of this review. Why courtesans are wearing heavy dresses, Lahore is hot, they must be stinking - in which film or portrayal you have seen courtesans are wearing airy loose t-shirt and barmuda? My mom even now wear sarees all the time - which i can't wear - doesn't mean she is stinking and i am not when it is humid. In TamilNadu women are out to work with heavy silk sarees. Dialogues and all must have been time appropriate(i didn't watch it, perhaps I won't watch it because i don't like this director's movies), those days women used to talk that way. My childhood neighbour was a zamindar, who used to return home drunk, peeing as soon as out of the taxi, calling the driver darling and feeding him sandesh all over the driver's moustache and beard.

@milymathew

6 күн бұрын

Wow, seriously,who told you all Tamil Nadu wears silk saree and works...you guys have such problems and behave like intellectuals but don't hesitate a bit to generalise the south

they have such good chemistry. I hope they are dating!

Hi. Couldn't watch your show... the moment you said that you couldn't watch beyond 4 episodes. Do you think you did justice to your review? Your review is based only on 4 episodes !!!

@AllThingsAudio420

22 күн бұрын

I think 4 hours of anything is enough to warrant an opinion no?

There are no different v and w sounds in Hindi. Not everyone goes to an English medium school 🙄

My point is! Were there any Nawabs in British Controlled Punjab? Coz the British won that territory from Sikh Empire.

@drjagritisingh6569

24 күн бұрын

Heeramandi is reality and the story is based on some urdu novel but plot adaptation sucked.

@bhadwamodi8294

24 күн бұрын

There were Punjabi chaudhry landlords in North Punjab. They are called Nawab in South Punjab. Lahore is in North Punjab.

Where is Meenakshi?

Bombay has Kamathipura

Funny enjoyable review except for Abhinandan’s awful but not awesome use of expletives. You need to use temperate language or begin with a Cautionary Advice or put him through a laundry to wash off the filthy words.

I Bhansali Cow Beltted Heeramandi . The Urdu was bad the Punjabi worse . He has not been able the capture either the sophistication / essence or nuances of Lahore . Otherwise a good Fairy tale.

Pakeeza ke baare me to mai ye sab nahi shn paungi

I always love and trust the news and review by newslaundry. But today I am quite disappointed. Your about one hour long review seemed more awful than the web series. No not because I loved heeramandi or anything. It was indeed very monotonous. But how can you review something and give opinions without watching the full thing. Even whatever you have watched is also just for the purpose of trolling. You could have skipped reviewing the series as it's not so important. But why to give a review just based on opinion and without actually watching the whole thing? It just decreases the trust about your coverages

@sunaina6328

13 күн бұрын

i second that👍

Sorry, Farida Jalal was miscast as the begum. She was too much of a pados wali aunty in it , the clothes aside.

The sorry sorry n doodhwali ..... too funny!!!! I don't like most of SLB films but I did like Gangubai in parts cos he did show reality apart from part opulence visavis costumes. I can say that cos I was with an ngo where we interacted with sex workers. Our ngo sponsored education of girl children under the Nanhi Kali project and they were daughters of these sex workers. Which brings me to something u both may want to know since you struggled with that... Bombay's biggest red light area is Kamathipura and the other is Falkland road. I dunno if anything has changed now but this is how it was about 20 yrs ago. And Mahatma Gandhi's remark about tawaifs stealing virtues ( hope I heard that correctly) , a bit much , though not surprising , cos once again it's not about the men who go there and enjoy, but the onus of protecting men's virtues is yet agn on women, not to mention it also insinuating how men can't hold on to their own virtues n go astray !! Also v holier than thou! I don't intend watching Heeramandi and i think Manisha Koirala often overacts/ overemotes. A Rekha, Shabana or even a less popular Ila Arun wudve done a better job. And sonakshi I liked only in Lootera. Brilliant performance ..... Ms Sen's guffaws were quite endearing , not to mention her being least least apologetic about them, lol, esp the May December....😅😂 And I'd love to know out of sheer curiosity why Mr Sekhri is always in a white Pathani suit! ( if that's what it indeed is!) 😈

, 10:25, 12:35, 18:56, 19:58, 33:29,

Mr. Sekhri did not like some of the songs in this web series, but three of them are good. "Azadi" song is particularly good, while "The Sakal Ban" and "Saiya Hatoo Jao" are also impressive. Mr. Bansali is a fine director, and his sets and costumes are amazing. However, I feel sorry for Mr. Sekhri's upbringing, which seems to have instilled in him a tendency to undermine women in every sense.

😮 unwatchable 😅

Its may december not may june

Also Ranveer has clarified his photo deletion, funny that you are not updated yourself.

I tried to watch, I want Covid back.

I watch all your shows regularly. But what are you doing here. अगर आपको किसी भी actor का नाम भी ठीक से नहीं पता, history नहीं पता। For the fact, हीरा मंडी का मतलब diamond bazar नहीं है। तो रिव्यू करने क्यों बैठे। TV news वालों की तरह हर काम में ख़ुद को कम से कम आप लोग तो एक्सपर्ट मत समझिए यार। Good luck.

guys did u watch goatlife

@serendipity0775

23 күн бұрын

What's that?

@danCK1990

23 күн бұрын

@@serendipity0775 new movie from the South that released in March

@serendipity0775

23 күн бұрын

On OTT? Subtitles ?

So late

Are you confusing mandakini with Mamta kulkarni??