2024又回到这里，好多人攻击家强，哥哥在家强的心里有多重要，就只有家强自己明白。那委屈我能理解和感受，家强，还是有很多歌迷会相信，继续支持你的

@CalvinCK

2 ай бұрын

是的, 每個人的背景都不同, 不應該以自己的角度去批評別人, 尊重別人的決定, 每人也有各自的自由喔

2023仍在聽，仍在流淚😢 永遠懷念家駒，願他在天國那邊快樂🙏🏼

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

永遠懷念家駒🙏

看見他們悲傷地唱著這歌，眼淚也掉下來了。

每次聽這首歌都會流眼淚 家強加油 二哥不曾離開過你 二哥會在你的身邊保護你看顧你的，家強你不要害怕😭😭😭

我和朋友們都在台下, 也一起哭著擺上招牌手勢, 為家強加油! 這是沒有家駒後的第一個演唱會, 我們看了三場, 就是要鼓勵和支持他們三人 - 繼續搖滾, 創作音樂. 明年是家駒離去30年, 其實我和朋友們從未忘記過他!

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

能在現場直接支持他們, 實在是很難得的一個經驗, 謝謝你的參與, Beyond的光輝唯有靠我們一直傳承下去

@wlien-cy7tb

Жыл бұрын

@@CalvinCK 欣賞你的公平和正面, 也會禮貌地回覆每位留言的朋友. 有些版主會以帶風向的標題, 使其中的成員受到責怪, 但你沒有這樣做, 很好啊! 我是高山時期未上地面的粉絲, 那時剛升上大學. 我很榮幸見證這隊偉大的華人樂隊 - Beyond IV的光輝歲月, 更榮幸見證偉大的華人音樂家 - 黃家駒的十年音樂歷程. 至今, 我仍然讚嘆家駒的決心與毅力, 還有目光之敏銳和看待人.物.事的前瞻.

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

謝謝支持 :) 我其實感恩大家用心的留言, 所以我也會盡力回復, 而且我也只是一個凡人, 跟大家沒有什麼不同, 很慶幸你有機會一直陪伴著Beyond成長, 那時候我還是小學生, 演唱會是遙不可及的大人的玩意, 只有長大後才能看到3子時期的演唱會, 但也覺得很感恩, 香港音樂聽了那麼多, 由小到大, 再又大聽回舊曲, 就只有家駒的歌曲, 到現在仍然不老, 說的東西都仍然對的, 俾面派對, Amani, 光輝歲月等等, 世界至今仍有歌詞內所說的問題, 而曲風方面更是不會有老的感覺, 很多舊歌一聽就覺得是某些時期的作品, 現在重聽Beyond的歌感覺比現在的流行曲會更流行, 真的讚嘆家駒實力之強, 音樂天份真的是香港第一, 其他能達到他這種名氣的香港歌手們也望塵望及喔

@ABCDEWXYZabc

Жыл бұрын

❤🫡

@mht718

Жыл бұрын

Same here. I came back to watch this again. Gone but never forgotten! Keep rocking! 🫶❤️

一個痛到唔想唱。一個痛到只能跟住本能打鼓同補飛。一個痛到唔痛，將所有情緒發洩落段solo度 。所有版本同其他人cover既海闊天空solo都係賣技巧 。Paul只有這一次海闊天空的solo是注入了靈魂 。這一天的beyond三子應該是他們這一世最齊心的一次 。希望他們某天能重新看一次這條影片，重新記起當年的自己 。

@CalvinCK

Ай бұрын

是的, 這次是他們最有靈魂的一次表演, 但事情總過有變數, 日後他們重看此片時, 能不忘初心, 就可以了

@kooa98765432

28 күн бұрын

Paul段solo真係好emotional....我覺得係佢彈過最正嘅solo😢佢好似將所有嘅嘢都放曬入個solo入邊...

@CalvinCK

27 күн бұрын

@@kooa98765432 是情感及技術到頂峰才能做到

Paul這首solo彈得我淚眼滿面，真的佩服

@whuan1024

3 жыл бұрын

这个solo是独一无二的，之后的所有solo都没有这次的感觉了，这个solo的感觉就是吉他都哭了

@dyjacks5732

Ай бұрын

Paul這個solo是所有海闊天空版本中最有感情

2022-6-10還在聽，真的每次聽也忍不住哭了，永遠懷念家駒

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

💐💐

@patrickwoo6067

2 жыл бұрын

16/7/2022...!!!!

@dplus8338

2 жыл бұрын

@@patrickwoo6067 5-8-2022

@user-up7fb1hj6j

Жыл бұрын

同感

@Ka-gz5nm

Жыл бұрын

@@user-up7fb1hj6j 如果Beyond和家駒現在還在就好了😞

真的！真的！很想念你！黄家驹! 如果有来生，我希望你仍然热爱音乐！ 你说过，音乐是你的命！就算投胎了，也不要忘记音乐！

从初中开始听Beyond，到今天37岁。感谢在这个肮脏的世界还有摇滚乐，愿荣光归香港。家强别沉沦、阿paul继续加油不要再妥协，世荣好自为之，红领巾不是随便戴的。我来自大陆

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

說得好, 謝謝你的分享 😉

@pengliu7966

2 жыл бұрын

和你同龄，同你一样的感受

@puikihung5882

2 жыл бұрын

十萬個讚！

@chenjinda4811

2 жыл бұрын

收皮拉，傻嗨

@zongyouye2489

7 ай бұрын

傻橪仔

108年6月10日我還在聽，懷念家駒和Beyond，永遠的亞洲殿堂級天團，永遠的歌神，家駒-生日快樂！

家強以前在我印象中一直像是一個長不大的小孩子，可能是因為哥哥的突然過逝，讓一個男孩一夜之間長大變成一個成熟的男人，真是令人心疼。

@ROY-yv9cj

4 жыл бұрын

哥祝願你當時告知我，想已什麼職業……。去做未來終生職業。無論怎樣，我亦一样可為你兩需要……。將我可給予你們的支持。令守護神伴在你伴……。不需擔心我。哥要用活在我心、身的星光。踏上孤獨嘅路守護我其他家人……！还有星蔣隨我行。蔣帥後來居上……。與其他五粒星相遇……

每次看這段總忍不住心酸，卻又一段時間想看一遍。明年家駒就走了三十年了，對他們來說，真是‘‘君埋泉下泥銷骨，我寄人間雪滿頭’’……

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

太感人的經典片段, 每次再看都忍不住傷感

家駒你的離開是我所有人心中永遠的痛😭😭😭

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

香港樂壇痛失英才 :(

祝福家強跟beyond所有人…

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

祝他們都愉快

老藝人傳承，下一代青年人當藝人，訓練青年人當藝人，培養下一代藝人，表現青年人活力，舞台上青年人創造輝煌歷史，懷念你黄家駒唱歌，百聽不厭的好歌

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

希望香港樂壇日後也能出現一個像家駒般出色的音樂人

黄贯中的solo 真的把情绪全寄托在里面了 那一段是我最感触的

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

是的, 他的悲傷透過結他轉化為音樂訴說出來了

小学三年级10岁开始听Beyond的歌，直到现在从未听过，一直很想看一场Beyond演唱会，家驹还在的时候，我还小，三子开演唱会的时候，我在读书，没有经济能力，Beyond2005年后解散后再也看不到三子同台了，如今有经济能力时台上只剩下两个人了，所以2018年特意从美国飞去新加坡看了【冲动效应】演唱会，千载难逢的机会当晚在酒店大堂还和Paul哥握手合照了，也算是给自己童年完了一个梦，有遗憾也有不舍，也许这就是人生吧！

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

我也未能趕上4子的年代, 有點可惜, 不過那個年代很少人能看到演唱會, 但能看到Beyond其他成員的演出, 也算是安慰

海闊天空是家強一輩子永遠不敢唱的一首歌，每次唱到會跌倒這句家強都會想到哥哥真的跌倒了在也沒有爬起來了 家強想哥哥了😭😭😭

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

這句歌詞太沉重了...

@godsbelovedchild1810

2 жыл бұрын

当时在写歌的时候，那有人会知道家驹哥早已预料他会出事... 😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

有時候世事就是那麼巧, 那麼的不幸

@NiceYo

2 жыл бұрын

可怜他😭😭

@tanwaygiap2795

9 ай бұрын

歌是黄家驹写的

唱自己哥哥的作品時，還必須控制自己的情緒，真是太難為他了

@user-vb5fk1ll5t

3 жыл бұрын

家強，加油你別怕二哥会在遙遠的星空看顧你的~

听着听着，我以泪流满面，当年的年轻，现在的老年，谢谢你们。😭

@CalvinCK

10 ай бұрын

時代在變, 但家駒的歌永不變

不知道也不可比較這是不是最好的Solo, 但這是獨一無二的，充滿情感的，永恆的存在，現場觀眾成就這經典的表演，充滿悲傷憤怒同時也充滿愛

@CalvinCK

9 ай бұрын

同意, 是獨一無二的, 只是屬於家駒及愛他的人的, 最特別的Solo

I've watched this music video many times. But every time, I don't know why, tears still come to my eyes. Ka Kui, we miss you so much!

呢個live, 好耐之後聽後, 依然咁感動

那年代有好多巨星… 而且寫出的歌都非常的有意義，讓人久久無法忘懷… Beyond是香港樂壇的經典樂隊！

@CalvinCK

3 жыл бұрын

同意, beyond是香港最有理想及才華的樂隊

我愛Beyond團體，更愛黃家駒，創作歌曲好聽，永遠活在我們這些歌迷的心中

@CalvinCK

3 ай бұрын

家駒的才華是香港樂壇全盛時期的天花板, 我目前仍沒有感受到有比家駒更有才華的香港歌手了

好幾年 好幾十年，每次聽到個solo都會覺得支結他在說話

@CalvinCK

4 ай бұрын

是的, 他們把感情都貫輸在樂器裏並放大地表演出來, 很讓人感動

2024 依然聽

@CalvinCK

4 ай бұрын

謝謝支持

到今天2021年底了，再看这个视频仍感到心碎。

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

Beyond是永恆的經典, 失去家駒是香港樂壇的最大遺憾

When you can't sing due to overwhelming emotion and a band member got your back, and then because of that, you come back with a flourish. Awesome! Long live Beyond!

我信想這是最感動的演唱會.

1993年，我還是小學生，剛喜歡Beyond他們，家駒就遇上不幸，他的曲子永遠是那麼好聽~

@CalvinCK

11 ай бұрын

多可惜呢, 不過能在Beyond的時代, 欣賞到他們的音樂, 也是一種幸運

@oldhongkongmusic888

11 ай бұрын

@@CalvinCK 我們是如此幸運 👍👍

@CalvinCK

11 ай бұрын

@@oldhongkongmusic888 是的, 我看著他越來越受同學歡迎, 但忽然家駒的離世, 對很多同學當時來說是很大的打擊, 後來再重聽Beyond的歌, 越聽越有理想, 長大了才知道家駒的才華真的是廣東話樂壇來說是前無古人

Until now i can't accept ka kui gone,i feel he is just sleeping and in time he will wake up in different time and state,every time i see him and listen to his song my heart trembles,i crying in my heart,i love ka kui,🥺🥺🥺😭ka keung lost half of his soul,his brother who always took care of him,gave him encouragement,taugh him to learn music has gone forever,his musical soul has also decreased because ka kui left,but i always hope beyond and ka keung can get together again,i love you ka kui and beyond forever😭😭😭😭💔💔🤟🤟🤟🤟

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, I hope he will wake up again sometimes...

泪湿了眼眶，曾幻想着有一天，能在台下，和beyond一起高唱海阔天空，一起泪流满面

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

真的希望能有如此的經歷, 一起再次高唱海闊天空, 不停地唱

Ka Keung, Paul and wing, please be comforted in knowing that millions and millions of your fans share your pain and lost and still cry rivers of tears. you guys have created albums of xtremely beautiful, powerful, heart wrenching music. We love all 4 of you with all our hearts and souls. We cherish the fond memories of our sweetest darling Ka Kui. Salute Beyond, you are excellent beyond words.

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

Yes, the memory of 4 peoples was phenomenon. We will not forget Ka Kui with Ka Keung, Paul and Wing together becoming the strongest band.

每聽一次就掉一次淚

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

真的讓人傷感

家駒 我想念你 !

108-4-1我還在聽，少了家駒，Beyond三子一定孤單，三子加油，家駒永遠在大家心中，從沒離開過！永遠的亞洲殿堂級天團，永遠的Beyond！永遠的歌神，來自臺北竹子湖歌迷！

@samlam4650

5 жыл бұрын

雖然家駒離開了，但三子並不孤單，有家駒在天堂守護，還有一直不離不棄追隨你們的歌迷Beyond記着你們並不孤單。

26年前，年輕的我，聽著黃家駒的歌，喜歡著。 26後，成熟的我，聽著同樣的歌，感動流淚。 非常非常想念黃家駒。

@kamkeilo6673

2 жыл бұрын

我也是～

@ET-lk5ns

2 жыл бұрын

😭😭😭😭永生難忘

真的這段影片啥時候看都會很傷心😢永遠怀念家駒😢

He had flipped his sleeve and didn't bring a piece of rainbow cloud, then left us unexpectedly. The fact is he did bring a lot of hope and love to this turmoil world in human history even after 29 years he has gone.

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

Totally agree. The message he brought regarding love and freedom is still valid today. You can still find the truth in his lyrics and the love he is offering in his melody.

一直都在聽不會停每天聽住Beyond音樂，感覺4子從未分開過👍👍👍🤟🤟🤟🙂

好感動亦是最傷感的音樂會 。

真希望有生之年看到他們和好 再開一次真正嘅Beyond演唱會 ！

@CalvinCK

3 жыл бұрын

應該會的 :)

@StoneCold3.16

2 жыл бұрын

家強崩潰嘅時候，有阿Paul出來頂上，呢段兄弟情，我相信家駒在天之靈一定會感受到。希望家強同阿Paul嘅種種誤會與不和，總有一日會消失。「過去的一切會平息⋯」《灰色軌跡》

這是家駒離開後 beyond三子的第一個演唱會 那時候家駒離去不久 所以家強仍然十分悲痛 可以說是海濶天空最感人的一個版本

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

同意, 這個是最感動的一個版本, 之後他們再演出都沒有那麼感人了

@pangkangsiew3097

Жыл бұрын

黃家強是想念哥哥家駒

突然觉得，少了家驹，他们三个显得多么的孤独。 我们也很孤独。 无论如何，我们终有再见的一天。

ฟังทุกครั้งขนลุกตลอด และน้ำตาไหลออกมาเอง

家駒，我很思念您

PAUL最後的 電吉他在哭泣 ...2021+1

2022-6-10祝家駒60歲生日快樂…

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

家駒生日快樂, 大家不會忘記你的光輝歲月 kzread.info/dash/bejne/i6J5za2xhsq0fps.html

2022年我还在听呢！太好听了

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

百聽不厭的經典歌曲👍

@pongwong9711

2 жыл бұрын

同感!😭😭😭

2021還在聽...

@CalvinCK

3 жыл бұрын

百聽不厭

I know the feeling when you lost a family member and can imagine if he still alive Beyond will be super band from Hong Kong until the end.. R.I.P Ka Kui...

@CalvinCK

3 жыл бұрын

Yes I agree, Beyond is so far the best band from HK up to now, what a pity HK has lost this genius...

@user-vb5fk1ll5t

2 жыл бұрын

家強你要堅強加油二哥會在遙望的星空看顧你保護你的👍👍👍

我的ktv,第一首歌 就獻給這個版本的 海闊天空 影響我很深很深

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

這真是一首很有意義及感人的歌曲

缘分就是这么巧妙家驹去世那年我爸就在日本。我也莫名其妙喜欢上了

最有情感的演唱

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

同意

看得都哭了 真的。。。💔 永远怀念家驹 ❤

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

家駒的離去真的令人傷感

im from malaysia..watching on disember 2..1:26 still makeme cry😭😭😭..5:12 so painful😭😭😭..miss u ka kui😥

@CalvinCK

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, it is a sad song for all Beyond fans :(

现在听回还是很好听，感觉海阔天空全部人一起唱最好听，再加上六月接近家驹的生日，也接近家驹的忌日😢😢

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

是的, 想起來很快就到6月, 又要記念家駒的日子了...

我寧原早十年出細 去佢地既演唱會!!

I love how the fans and the other member helped the vocalist when he struggled to find his range. This band is a legend, Im a fan from the Philippines, proving that there is no language or nationality barrier in music. One of the best band and song of all time! 🤙🙏

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

Yes, it is touching that the fans were supporting Ka Keung. Thank you for listening to Beyond's songs. Good music does not have boundary and it is the international language for our human race. 🙂

@whatsup342

Жыл бұрын

@@CalvinCK And I will continue listening to their songs and I will definitely influence my friends here in the Philippines to listen to Beyond's songs.

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

Thank you. I think your friends will like Beyond's songs and will be inspired by their meaningful lyrics and music

@whatsup342

Жыл бұрын

@@CalvinCK Yes cause we have the same genre in music. Here in the Ph, we also have a legend band like Beyond and we are all listening to their songs so Im quite sure theyll like Beyond's too.

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

That's good, I think your friends will like Beyond music. Thank you for your sharing 😃

阿Paul的solo令我感動！

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

最動人的solo

真好聽❤️❤️❤️

I am a Japanese. I haven't been able to stop crying since I first saw it on KZread in 2023. I was surprised that there are such wonderful songs in the world. Of course I don't understand the words, but it makes me feel hot. This is a masterpiece. thank you.

@CalvinCK

10 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening to the Beyond song even though you are not familiar with the lyrics. Ka Kui will be glad that you have listened to his songs even though there is language barrier. I hope you enjoy his song and will remember him

@opm6056

10 ай бұрын

thank you for your reply. I just learned that Ka Kui passed away in a Japanese TV accident. I loved that TV show when I was in elementary school, but it suddenly ended, and I was a kid so I didn't understand why. As a Japanese person, I would like to express my sincere apologies. . Even in Japan, there was a KZread video of many people singing this song. This song lives on forever. I would like to cherish it too.

@CalvinCK

10 ай бұрын

No need to apologise. Thank you for your kindness. It was an accident and a tragedy that no body wanted to see. Thank you for your support and happy to see your sharing.

@Yeezy47

5 ай бұрын

@@CalvinCKIt’s also possible that they set him up because think about it he was getting up there in fame. I wouldn’t be surprised if they were coming after him due to whatever unknown reason.

@CalvinCK

5 ай бұрын

Yes, that would be possible

最經典最好聽的海闊天空solo，paul的吉他在哭泣

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

是的, 這個版本是最好最感人的海闊天空

2019年12月还有谁在听的？

不喜歡這片的那人,若不是鐵石心腸,就是不喜歡太令人傷心的場靣.

最後這段SOLO…阿PAUL,用結他🎸說出他們心裡面…當時仍然對家駒突然離去嘅傷痛同思念😢

今天我 寒夜裡看雪飄過 懷著冷卻的心窩飄遠方… 風雨裡追趕、 霧裡分不清影蹤， 天空海闊你與我，可會變？（誰沒再變？） 多少次… 迎著冷眼與嘲笑， 從沒有放棄過心中的理想。 一剎那 彷彿若有所思的感覺 不知不覺已變淡 心裡愛（誰明白我？） 原諒我這一生不羈放縱愛自由， 也會怕有一天會跌倒...（Oh, no） 背棄了理想， 誰人都可以， 哪會怕有一天只你共我…

damn that solo still gets me after all these years

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

Sorrow from the guitar

家強真係好掛住家駒😢

@CalvinCK

11 ай бұрын

他都是跟著家駒而生活的, 沒有了家駒, 家強也忽然間變得十分迷茫

好多年前在書城買了beyond歌書，奇蹟就發生，好聽的歌通常不易彈，但我竞然可彈琴弹到海濶天空的主旋律，要讚嘆家駒真是神駒，R0CK與親民的结合，雖然段solo還是彈了2年

@CalvinCK

9 ай бұрын

謝謝你繼續讓Beyond的歌曲延綿下去🙂

4:10和4:13 是家驹的声音 不知道有没有歌迷注意 永远怀念你 二哥

真係好好聽

我想专门来谢谢 Calvin for uploading this video。 更难得的是12年了，你还在这里回复大家，谢谢你！ 我之前听过Beyond的歌但是不认识他们，是看了这个video之后好奇发生了什么才去了解背后的故事，然后被家驹的嗓音，才华和人格深深打动。家驹要是在，一定还会和他们一起夹Band。希望他们的音乐一直传唱，也祝福三子生活美满。

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

謝謝你的分享😉 感謝大家不吝留言才對, 讓大家繼續可以交流對家駒的感覺, 的確他的才華及人格於香港樂壇來說幾乎前無古人後無來者, 他用精湛的音樂告訴大家什麼是自由, 民主及理想, 希望大家繼續把家駒的自由思想傳頌下去☺

😭 마음 너무 아파요. 형 노래 대신 하니 얼마나 슬퍼요. 보다가 나도 울엇어요 아름다운 노래. 넘 아까워요. 왜 ?? 이리도 발리 우리 곁에 떠나 야 했나요 ? 😭😭최고 에 너래 최고 에요 👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍

好喜歡見到世榮打鼓，真的好有型❤

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

專業, 有型有實力

其實paul都想哭..

我90後.. 聽到尼首歌好感動..

我相信歌迷既聲音一定可以傳送到比天堂既家駒

@kwokfaichan7527

7 жыл бұрын

wilson chau ii

2023/6/10 家駒生日快樂🤟🏻

多谢Calvin Ck上传. 1997年中国大陆，我 十一岁 第一次听到这个 演唱会 卡带。 从那时 开始 听beyond 的广东歌。 beyond 让我第一次 接触到 华人音乐 的 精华。 感谢 香港 ！ 感谢家驹 ！

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

很高興你接觸到家駒的音樂, 感受到香港歌手的才華, 雖然他已經不在, 他聽到你的故事也會感到欣慰的

@Skyhawk2077

Жыл бұрын

@@CalvinCK 我也希望 某天 大陆和香港 能 同在 自由制度下共存。 感谢香港 人民对 大陆 几十年来的支持和帮助，没有你们 就没有大陆的 成就。

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

@@Skyhawk2077 謝謝你的支持及理解 😌 曾經何時香港人也寄望著內地可以改變, 家駒也一樣對內地的民主自由充滿著憧憬, 可是卻發現原來自己的力量實在是微不足道, 最後都改變不了什麼, 不過也感謝你的分享, 自由及民主的理念就藏在家駒的音樂中, 就算結果不盡如人意, 但只要問心無愧地做自己認為對的事就好了, 然後把正確的思想盡可能地延續下去, 用音樂用故事去感染更多的人

@Skyhawk2077

Жыл бұрын

@@CalvinCK ”若有理想， 哪怕崎岖实现那自由。”

I miss you so much wong ka kui and beyond,,you always in my heart forever,,wong ka keung you must strong your brother ptotect you from other side😭😭😭😭😭😭💔💔🤟

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, Ka Kui is missed so deep and hope everything is smooth and fine for his brother, every member in Beyond, every one who loves Beyond and every one in the world

2020.1.20 永遠懐念家駒

beyond加油

眼淚流淌

You right Ka Kui never die

ending solo very nice

30年喇，家駒哥你喺天堂仲過得好好嗎？知唔知全世界都仲掛住你呀？！😢😭

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

轉眼就30年了, 希望家駒能在天堂繼續創作他獨特的音樂

天妒英才，每次听这个版本，都想哭😭。我第一次接触这首歌，比较晚，我记得已经是1998年，当时也是看的这个版本，那时候流行万利达VCD😂

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

是的, 這個版本最賺人熱淚, 那時候還是VCD的年代喔

家強唱這首歌時，我看他快哭了

@samlam4650

5 жыл бұрын

眼淚心裡流。

@user-vb5fk1ll5t

3 жыл бұрын

最疼愛他的二哥突然離世對家強打擊非常大😭😭😭

～～搖滾不死～～ ～～懷念家駒～～

2020年聽到+1

@yusinleung5897

3 жыл бұрын

＋1

@user-vb5fk1ll5t

3 жыл бұрын

2021還在聽的🙋‍♀️

for those who dont know whats going on here. the elder brother of the guy in green passed away in 1993 from an accident in Japan who was the vocal and the writer of the song. so he will get emotional every time he sings the song. he apparently had a hard time to sing it and needed the audience and his fellow member helped out

@jonathanabishegam9982

3 жыл бұрын

Oh I see. Wow, that's sad. This is such a good song!!

@user-vb5fk1ll5t

2 жыл бұрын

無法接受哥哥永遠的離開了 哥哥無法陪伴在身邊是家強永遠一輩子的痛😭😭😭 家強至今還是無法接受哥哥離開的事實😭😭😭

@robertng4286

2 жыл бұрын

May I ask u here, the guy wearing yellow green, is he Paul or Steve because I got confused by both of their looks? Another thing, is this band the original Beyond band? Thank u

@LedZeppelinHK

2 жыл бұрын

@@robertng4286 Steve and the band name has always been Beyond they never changed the name.and no, a few first members from the original line up have left the band , Paul was the only member that joined later to replace the guitarist. but it doest matter since the original line up werent even poplar . the members in this video and deceased guy shaped the sound of beyond basically.

@robertng4286

2 жыл бұрын

@@LedZeppelinHK thank u so much Sir for your sharing..

好難想像當時台上的他們 一樣的歌 少了一個人 內心空蕩蕩的失落感

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

這個感覺真的很空洞, 尤其是第一次演唱會時更傷心

香港人努力爭取 民主及自由 最感動人心的天籟～ 加油!

@saulengwong6988

4 жыл бұрын

永远有人在听！百听不厌！而且，带着泪水。

@user-fk8et5lk4n

Жыл бұрын

家驹爱国Ok

感受自由之歌❗

@CalvinCK

2 жыл бұрын

是的, 家駒一生就是一直在追求自由, 也希望全世界的人都能得到自由 🕊

2020/01/16好想家駒😭😭

家強加油

我破防了。。。。眼泪流了。。。。没有beyond...今天的我，也不会弹吉他。。。beyond让我认识音乐。。。经典。。。烈火莫烯😭😭😭😭

@CalvinCK

Жыл бұрын

謝謝分享, Beyond的影響力太大了, 雖然已經離去, 但仍感染著我們

@leeannie7780

9 ай бұрын

沒有家驹，我也不會彈琴❤