even the piano voice had a huge power of his music universe!

Quite a find and thanks for uploading. Some comments: 1. These movements were not intended to be solo piano pieces, so he is not playing them idiomatically for that instrument as if the recordings were capturing a live recital. 2. Rather, he sounds as if he is driving through them corresponding to how they would sound as orchestrated in his mind. 3. In other words, they are abstract audio templates that are realized only in full orchestral score. 4. The laser focus of Mahler's hands were in conducting and composing.

@RonaldKarle

5 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening!

If Mahler had lived to the age of 75, he could've recorded these and conducted his works in recording like Elgar and Strauss did.

@RonaldKarle

3 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening!

@maestroclassico5801

3 ай бұрын

@@RonaldKarle Thank You for posting! Mahler really was a true triple threat wasn't he? Concert Pianist, Composer, and Conductor. I can only think of a handful EVER that could match that....(some of it depends on the desire of the musician....doing justice to all 3 is next to impossible)

@jgesselberty

Ай бұрын

If Mahler had lived to 75, imagine how much more gloriouos music he wouold have composed.

@maestroclassico5801

Ай бұрын

@@jgesselberty so many theories, he'd have been 75 in 1935..... meaning he'd have had to leave Austria again pretty soon ANYWAY! Would he have come back to America? Walter and Schoenberg surely would have coaxed him to do so. Might he have maybe written a film score like Korngold? Would he, like many composers in the 19 teens and 20s, have started to write..... SMALLER? .. maybe even experimented with his protege Schoenberg 's style?

@PaulBrower-bw4jw

Ай бұрын

@@jgesselberty Opera. Symphony #6 itself suggests. Romeo and Juliet. Without question, he got the piano well, and I can imagine him writing some fine piano sonatas. It is easier to get a reputation with smaller works than with gigantic ones. They would be rich, but so is Liszt's sonata. Mahler was the definitive German composer when he died. Just think of how much harder it would have been to attack Jews if he were still that definitive German composer in 1925!

Thank you for posting these very interesting recordings. Many comments here about how much these performances might reflect how Mahler would have wanted his orchestral piece to be played. It seems incredible that he made no recordings of his conducting, given that recording technology had begun before his first symphony was written. As I understand it the first ever symphony to be recorded was Beethoven's Fifth, in 1913, two years after Mahler passed away

@RonaldKarle

4 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening 🎶!

@louise_rose

3 ай бұрын

Yes, very interesting indeed! It's too bad we don't have any recordings of Mahler as a conductor - his premature death meant that he missed out on the opportunity by just a decade or two. Of course, a couple of full recordings of Mahler conducting his own works, Beethoven or Bruckner would have been priceless - in his own lifetime he was known as the Great Conductor rather than an acclaimed symphonist. The recordings of his friend and pupil Bruno Walter are probably the closest we can get to an authentic idea of how Mahler would have fully realized his own works in concert.

Impressive 😊

@RonaldKarle

9 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening!

Thanks for sharing these Ron! Very interesting to hear! ❤️

@RonaldKarle

9 ай бұрын

I have enjoyed posting Piano roll recordings. I know there are more out there I will continue to search. Thank you, Donna!

From these recordings we can conclude that Mahler could be a virtuoso pianist if he only had more time... nevertheless he commited this time to composing his music

@ColinWren119

5 ай бұрын

Fortunately for us!

@tamed4171

4 ай бұрын

A ton of great composers from the past could have been amazing performing pianists, but they focused their efforts on composition and/or conducting. The bar for piano ability was much higher in the common composer back then. You don't see that as often today.

@colinwu4910

4 ай бұрын

Mahler being a virtuosic pianist would be too imaginary. Firstly, these excerpts are far from virtuosic. Piano was a widely expected skill for composers around that era to start with. There were also contemporaneous genuine virtuosic pianist-composers such as Prokofiev, Rachmaninoff. Secondly, he didn't spend all his time composing. He committed a significant part of his time to conducting, which was his job. Composing was already what he used his free time for.

É difícil acreditar que o som de um piano roll possa ser restaurado com esta fantástica qualidade. Ou que Mahler necessite de mais glória e reconhecimento de sua genialidade...

11:10 Symphony 5

@RonaldKarle

4 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening!

Some conductor needs to take these piano roll performances and turn them into orchestral ones that stick scrupulously to the tempi, rhythms, and dynamics ...

Obviously not some world class concert pianist, but there is so much to like about this.

@RonaldKarle

5 ай бұрын

I Agree! Most composers are not world-class Performers.

@floring67

3 ай бұрын

I think this is only a vague hint about how Mahler played the piano, not the real deal. Welte-Mignon mechanism had that problem of imprecise timing, especially in 1905. That is why in some moments no note is played, but they come in a bunch immediately after. The problem was partly solved by Ampico around 1919, but Wayne Stahnke still had a lot of errors to correct for releasing Rachmaninov's piano roll recordings; he mathematically reverse-modeled the punching-recording mechanism and used the master rolls for conversion (he explains that in the release). And well, Rachmaninov *was* a world-class performer, maybe the best of all times.

@RonaldKarle

3 ай бұрын

@@floring67 Thank you for your comment.

@ivanbotaro4697

2 ай бұрын

Rach: Hold my beer

🎵🎶💕

Isn't that first one from Wayfairer, not Wunderhorn? First movement Symphony 1 - not Symphony 4? Not Das Himmlische Leben. Or am I in the Twilight Zone?

@flawlessyt_7080

3 ай бұрын

it is from 1st symphony you are not crazy

@koolkdny

2 ай бұрын

Yes, but das himmlische leben is right after

Good day. Where did you get this enregistrement ? Is there other recordings of the Gustav Mahler whether on piano or conducting a symphony ? Thank you.

@RonaldKarle

9 ай бұрын

Thank you so much for listening. Besides my own works, I search the internet for public domain content such as this is. So far, I have only found 2 recordings of Mahler. I have a Playlist of piano roll recordings. I hope you enjoy my channel.

@lumieres369

8 ай бұрын

Formidable@@RonaldKarle

Isn‘z that firdt part from Mahler 1?

@RonaldKarle

2 ай бұрын

I don't know?

@jgesselberty

Ай бұрын

Yes, it is from the first movement of the first symphony.

11:11

Gotta love youtube comments

Si verdaderamente es él, ¿Por qué se escucha tan nítido? Mahler murió en 1910 ¿?

@RonaldKarle

2 ай бұрын

In 1890s they had Welte mingon "Player Piano Roll" Recorders. This was recorded on a piano roll and played back on a player Piano and recorded the piano playback on modern recoring equipment. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welte-Mignon

Mahler was a fully-mature composer by his twenties. He got the piano well enough that one can only wonder what uvenile works he wrote in his teens. Think of Mozart, Schubert, and Mendelssohn. I've faulted other compsers, most notably Telemann and Liszt for not taking out the trash -- Mahler may be the opposite.

@RonaldKarle

8 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening!

@pietervoogt

4 ай бұрын

I think the development of artists is very interesting. There is not really trash in life, everything tells a story.

@user-lj1sc9bs4t

2 ай бұрын

私の記憶が正しければマーラーは大学の試験でショパンのポロネーズ6番を弾いていたと言う記事を見た事があります。 最低限その程度の実力はありました。

@WetaMantis

8 күн бұрын

Mahler always tried to improve upon his work constantly improving it.

@paulbrower

8 күн бұрын

@@WetaMantis The edition that we know in concert is a perfect expression of a romantic symphony answering to classical norms. Mahler never wrote anything else quite like it. He went on to write "Beethoven's Tenth" (Mahler's Second is the perfect successor to Beethoven's Ninth).

Why is his jacket half brown and half gray?

@RonaldKarle

2 ай бұрын

Thanks for listening. I don't know. It is a colorized photo.

is this actually mahler playing?

@RonaldKarle

Ай бұрын

I have been informed this is a piano roll recording made by him.

@dimsum5987

Ай бұрын

@@RonaldKarle awesome

This is exactly how Mahler himself wanted and saw his own works ................. And you, hello, conductors, do you want to follow these patterns ? Or giving, here and there, some more "things" ? Some say : "a composer is a composer, nothing more. And a conductor, or an interpret, gives the sound". I say : the first is giving the bones, the second the flesh, and the third person (the listener) is giving the love to it. God the Father, Christ his Son, and the Holy Spirit .............

@RonaldKarle

5 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening!

@EASYTIGER10

4 ай бұрын

We can't and shouldn't assume this is how Mahler wanted his works played. Not based on a piano roll. Mahler was clearly an able, but far from virtuoso, pianist. He never claimed otherwise. Rhythms are inconsistent, things don't always flow smoothly, especially in technically complicated passages. And we have no way of knowing how much this is how Mahler "wanted" it and how much it was Mahler reaching his technical limits on the piano. Sadly we have no recordings of Mahler conducting as far as I know, so we have to rely on the manuscripts to be the ultimate guide.

@Fritz_Maisenbacher

4 ай бұрын

I do not share your position. I am a pianist myself and I can guarantee you that the way Mahler is playing is no coincidence and no virtuosity limit.@@EASYTIGER10

@ianwilliamson531

3 ай бұрын

@@EASYTIGER10

@ianwilliamson531

3 ай бұрын

There are piano rolls and there are reproducing rolls. If you knew the difference, and how the Welte Mignon reproducing rolls were made, and replayed, your comment might be a little different. Mahler recorded four rolls in a single session on November 9, 1905 at the Welte-Mignon studios in Leipzig. According to texts published by the Welte company, The artist was seated before a grand piano equipped with the Recording apparatus. It automatically captured, the tempo, phrasing, dynamics and pedaling of each particular performance, and not just the notes of the music, as was the case with other player pianos of the time. Mahler’s comments in Welte’s Visitors’ Book show that he was deeply impressed.. “ In astonishment and admiration, I joined those who have proceeded me [in this book] . Gustave Mahler.” These rolls would never have been released if he had not been thoroughly content with their playback veracity.. they were approved by him as authentic to his playing.

Is this original 😮How is possible 😮

@RonaldKarle

Күн бұрын

This again? This is a recording made from a player piano roll recording over 100 years ago. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welte-Mignon

@MrRbjunior83

17 сағат бұрын

@@RonaldKarle No! It's not the same question everyone asks you. If you have read carefully it is paper of the cardboard type! How exactly can this be authenticated and does the Mahler Society stand behind these proven authentic recordings? Because anyone in the recording industry will tell you that it's not possible. Yet young people will listen to this and believe it is really Mahler. If you have seen Welte- Mignon live you will understand why I ask. It's a totally primitive system that even today's technology can't make it sound like…

@RonaldKarle

14 сағат бұрын

@@MrRbjunior83 You asked, "how is possible?" I answered. Up to you to accept it or not. So you don't believe it is. OK. It was presented to me as authentic, and I shared it.

I'm guessing the roll is playing a fair amount faster than it was recorded

@ianwilliamson531

11 күн бұрын

Peter - not so - the manufacturers of this reproducing roll were were strict about playback speeds being precise and the restored player has been carefully regulated to specifications for this recording.

@PeterJensen7

10 күн бұрын

@@ianwilliamson531 it has the hallmarks in spots of a sped up recording. I do this for a living.

The arpeggiation is a bit too much for my taste. But otherwise fantastic!!

@RonaldKarle

9 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening

@alexanderreikreik

9 ай бұрын

stefan krauss: in so far as...it must have been to Mahler's taste, your comment lacks any veracity

@stefan.kraus-composer

9 ай бұрын

@@alexanderreikreik The one who can read is in advantage.

@HYP3RK1NECT

6 ай бұрын

Bueno. Citando el mismo Mahler, "Si. Después de mi muerte, si hay algo que no suena bien, cambielo. No solamente tienen derecho. Si no que también es un deber hacerlo"

@EASYTIGER10

4 ай бұрын

@@alexanderreikreik We can't assume - based on a piano roll - this is how Mahler wanted it played. Mahler never claimed to be a virtuoso pianist and he seems to be struggling technically at times. You should go by what he wrote on the score, not a piano roll.

I almost prefer this to his symphonies. I dislike his use of dramatic orchestral effects, especially the brass and percussion, so this reduction helps me.

@RonaldKarle

4 ай бұрын

Thank you for listening 🎶

This is stereo recording, can’t be Mahler who is playing here...

@RonaldKarle

2 ай бұрын

This was a stereo recording of a Player Piano roll recording made by Mahle played back on a player Piano. www.pianola.org/reproducing/reproducing_welte.cfm

@carlob95

2 ай бұрын

@@RonaldKarle ahh ok! I get it now! Impressif. Thank you!

@RonaldKarle

2 ай бұрын

@@carlob95 Your Welcome. I had similar responses from others.

@PaulBrower-bw4jw

Ай бұрын

The playback is on a player piano being played back in a stereo recording. Such has been done with Brahms, Grieg, Rachmaninov, and others.

Gustav Mahler Plays His Symphonic Movements LOOOOL 1904 - there were no records by this HD

@RonaldKarle

4 ай бұрын

Before you say it's impossible find out how it is possible.......at the turn of the 20th century, it was ideally placed to develop an experimental piano playing device, with the aim of reproducing the recorded performances of the finest pianists of the day. www.pianola.org/reproducing/reproducing_welte.cfm

@ianwilliamson531

3 ай бұрын

An easy mistake to make for people who know nothing about reproducing rolls. Best do some research, you will be surprised at what you find.

@niklassilen4313

2 ай бұрын

Ignorance is bliss, isn't it? You should do some research.. not everything was done back then the way it is now in terms of recording. There were numerous mechanical ways of recording things.

@PaulBrower-bw4jw

Ай бұрын

The piano rolls remain. Just think of it: a modern pianist like Ashkenazy gets recorded in stereo playing off scores that existed long before there were any recordings. Is that any more a contradiction?