Gulag, the Story - Part 1(1918-1936) | FULL DOCUMENTARY
A major political, historical, human and economic fact of the 20th century, the Gulag, the extremely punitive Soviet concentration camp system, remains largely unknown.
The history of the Gulag is long, complex and in many ways out of the ordinary. From the Revolution of 1917 to Gorbachev, touching on the civil war, the Great Terror, World War II, the Cold War and the death of Stalin, this series describes the workings of the Gulag.
How and why did the USSR create this system of forced-labour camps in which 20 million prisoners were exploited and worked to the bone?
Documentary: GULAG, THE STORY - Episode 1: From experimentation to setting up the forced labour system (1918-1936)
Directed by: Patrick Rotman
Production: KUIV Productions pour ARTE France
#fulldocumentary #documentary #film #history #gulag #soviet #urss #russia
Пікірлер: 634
This whole set of documentaries should be required watching for high school graduates as well as being tested on the subject!!!!!!
@kenbowser5622
27 күн бұрын
Should be required for college educators
@timkempuk
25 күн бұрын
And especially universities
@Gdub33
23 күн бұрын
This is Russian. I'm telling you, this channel is Russian. The way they say certain things are complete propaganda.
@user-ht4pp6ly1v
12 күн бұрын
Yeah it would have to be a video because most of today's high schoolers can't read or write.
@Gdub33
12 күн бұрын
@@user-ht4pp6ly1v not true. They are smart, however they are obsessed with horrible things like clout and fame instead of actually caring about the world and understanding history and how it repeats itself.
Back in the 1970s I worked with a German colleague who had been imprisoned in the Gulag system from 1945 through 1953, I lent him the book "One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisonovich" by Alexander Solzhenitsyn, when he returned the book his comment was " Every word in that book is true". R I P Herman Ziegler.
@ilikemitchhedberg
15 сағат бұрын
"Werner... Ziegler...."
This has happened enough throughout history that resisting government roundups should be a part of school curriculum.
@richardalexander1036
Ай бұрын
You think these folk had the option to resist roundups? Can you even resist an arrest today? That's exactly how it happens.
@stopgotdamndeletingmycomme8642
Ай бұрын
I want to give u unlimeted likes💯
@nickchung8961
Ай бұрын
School is a government institution. You really think they're gonna teach kids how to overthrow the government?
@robfromvan
21 күн бұрын
But schools are run by government.
@dancarter6044
20 күн бұрын
Yet when we see such regimes in fictional forms like movies, 99 out of a 100 of them involve right wing regimes.
I watched an interview with a camp area supervisor (not sure of his title) in the 1970s or 80s. Interviewer asked if he had visited all of the camps and the supervisor chuckled. When asked what was funny about the question the supervisor stated, 'It would have taken several lifetimes for someone to visit every camp.'
@olympicjbrag5913
Ай бұрын
You are referring to Danzig Baldaev, the camp supervisor and visual artist responsible for Drawings from the Gulag. He also documented prisoner tattoos.
@danlowe8684
Ай бұрын
@@olympicjbrag5913 Yes!! Thank you for that information. Now I can find it to watch again. It was fascinating.
@GhyuRtyu
Ай бұрын
My grandfather was supervisor in the Gulag in 1930s
@karlwalther
Ай бұрын
In 1940, there were: - 50 correctional labor camps in the USSR (people are kept and work in prison). - 400 correctional labor colonies (people are imprisoned, but work in ordinary construction sites and factories) - 50 colonies for minors.
@danlowe8684
Ай бұрын
@@karlwalther Not even close. Even the Germans had 1000's of camps and we only know the names of the big ones.
A very rare film material, never seen before. . An interesting document. Thank's a lot for this 👍
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
Thank you so much for watching!
Backwards then and Backwards now still no progress in these countries
@hunmari
10 күн бұрын
because they had to start from zero! 45 year communist regime, while the western countries flourished in peace, and couldn't care less for Hungary, or any iron curtain countries.
@SimonPhelps-qg1eg
10 күн бұрын
@@hunmari And should we of
@halasipipacs
Күн бұрын
You clearly have no clue as to the achievements of these countries, particularly the Soviet Union but other Soviet bloc countries as well, despite 2 World Wars and a Civil War and a brutal totalitarian regime. The space program, for one.
Ive seen this documentary before. The best documentary on the Gulags anywhere.
@jabom99
Ай бұрын
I believe it's from France. There are few docs from France on KZread and they very good.
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
Thank you so much!!
@starwarsfreak1111
Ай бұрын
@@jabom99 can you mention others you know please?
@deeem2628
Ай бұрын
Find watch and share a documentary called Europa the last battle.
@Daniel-ys3gh
Ай бұрын
Don't watch that europa shit, lies
I experienced extreme cold whilst working in Canada. The pain is beyond description. RIP all those souls that no longer have to suffer
Another hard one to watch, no matter how much your heart aches for these people, there is nothing that you can do to save them or offer help as they are all long dead now. People, unchecked, behave like brutes.
@MCMLXIable
Ай бұрын
Human beings are gonna human being.
@anhumblemessengerofthelawo3858
Ай бұрын
Past lives, anyone? Reincarnation, anyone?
@user-mq6fu6ou4f
Ай бұрын
blyat
@MrSomethingElse
Ай бұрын
@@user-mq6fu6ou4f Yep. Hear that.
@MrSomethingElse
Ай бұрын
@remington5978 There are currently more slaves today than during the entire east African slave trade, come to new Zealand Cuzzies, we wont treat you this way, if you can get here. We got love for everyone.
Thank you for this documentary!
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
Thank you for watching!!
Evil can only exist when good people do nothing.
@xx-hc4sx
Ай бұрын
Applicable to literally everything including the US
@nickfarr691
Ай бұрын
Thank you.
@beavs1516
Ай бұрын
Nick u sound like a wise old monk that has seen alot
@Gas_Station_Tampons
Ай бұрын
There's a whole lot of good people doing nothing at all today.
@Thusssle
Ай бұрын
@@beavs1516it’s in the Bible
Why isn't 1984 required reading anymore? Also the gulag archipelagos changed my life. I never bought the idea that marxism, socialism, and communism were anywhere near good. But it gave me perspective on how they got there along with how bad it can actually get.
@johnredman2065
3 күн бұрын
Yes me too read both same awakening for me , one thing though, 1984 could be communist or fascist.
@jamusloos2859
3 күн бұрын
@johnredman2065 facism is just a tactic of communists. Fascism is the government partnering with private organizations to implement things they couldn't do otherwise.
@vladeputinovic6128
3 күн бұрын
😂😂😂😂😂
@jamusloos2859
3 күн бұрын
@@johnredman2065 dude fascism is just a tactic of communists. Fascism is just a government partnering with a private entity to enforce something it otherwise wouldn't be able to.
If you want a full experience, read Gulag Archipelago by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn.
@bricedesmaures2005
Ай бұрын
Soljenitsyne
@junglesuperstar9270
Ай бұрын
@@bricedesmaures2005wrong .😅
@junglesuperstar9270
Ай бұрын
You butchered the last name
@janosnemeth9984
Ай бұрын
Thank you so much Dear ❤
@bricedesmaures2005
Ай бұрын
@@junglesuperstar9270 So tell us right name ...
Fantastic documentary, thank you.
@SLICE_Full_Doc
11 күн бұрын
Thanks so much!
So sad to see the atrocious things we humans do to each other.
@Cazgirl-hq4hi
Ай бұрын
Power drunk individuals ..power ,greed, vileness.all,the qualifications they need to enforce their regime.
@Mongieboy
Ай бұрын
And it doesn't stop. Still the same problems, the same lunatics in charge. What does it tell us? That it won't change. Ever. Something seriously radical needs 2 happen 2 change the way the human race acts. I for 1 can't wait 2 see that change. Even if it would cost me my life, I want the world 2 be so different. The way people act towards each other, the way governments act, it makes me sick. Greed and selfishness, power hungry madmen, psychopathic leaders. I mean what the living hell is going on? Who out there thinks the world is in harmony? With each other and with mother Earth? Yea exactly. Nobody.
@Vanilla-jd1ez
18 күн бұрын
Governments do to their people
. .or The First Circle by same author. It remains one of my favourite books of all time. Beautifully constructed, compelling and deeply moving.
You think your life's hard until you see how Brutal they poor souls were worked no wonder many prayed for death 💔
It’s hard to understand how stuff like this could ever happen
@mytmt1613
Ай бұрын
The events of 2020 and onwards showed how easily normal rational people can change very quickly. Fear has always been and will always be the most effective way to control people, and to get them to commit heinous crimes they would never commit under normal circumstances.
@jacobjorgenson9285
Ай бұрын
It will come to America one day too …. Tic toc tic toc
@annatannehill716
Ай бұрын
It still happens while the world sit back and does nothing
@tonesw6957
Ай бұрын
No, it isn't.
@user-zy3co8ei5u
Ай бұрын
You can experience it in real time now.
WHERE ARE THE SUBTITLES? we are missing a big part of the story.
Everyone needs to watch this when they think their lives are so bad.
@user-vz6vz4rt3u
Ай бұрын
And laugh at the "oppressed" in the USA and UK
@Jennifer-ql5qf
Ай бұрын
Suffering is subjective. While I agree with your statement 💯 My husband of 24 years passed 9 months ago, I would rather live in poverty and a camp than luxury without him.
@shable1436
Ай бұрын
@@Jennifer-ql5qf I'm so sorry for your loss, and you're correct, everything is subjective when it comes to suffering. I hope you understood my context, not comparing it to being tortured, but I meant in everyday living, where you think you have it bad. You could be not living
@kotkotlecik7310
26 күн бұрын
That's stupid. Not being enslaved doesn't mean one's life is easy. A social worker once yelled at me that I have nothing to complain about and that her life was difficult in socialist Poland. It was such a dumb comment I feel second-hand embarrassment. If the country doesn't oppress you, there are still lots of people who will.
What a coincidence, Exactly in 1938, France released the last German prisoner of war. After 20 years. The last of 6 million Germans who were unjustly forced to perform forced labor in France
@chickensteez2906
Ай бұрын
Almost like Germany invaded and pillaged France
@jason.larsenthedanishgreek1226
Ай бұрын
Yea. That actually happened though. Unlike the gorilian
@winifredherman4214
29 күн бұрын
They were released in 1948 & 1949!
Good documentary 👍
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
Thank you!
Not all people are equal. And the gulag is the logical consequence of trying to build an utopia that defies this fact. When you want to make everyone equal, sooner or later you will have to use force.
@vladeputinovic6128
3 күн бұрын
😂😂
@dpelpal
3 күн бұрын
I am Russian and was born in Samara in 1960. The only "utopia" in Russia was for cockroaches and thieves. We had little food. Our flat was in constant disrepair. We had no clean water and were forced to share bathroom with an almost 6 other families. Alcohol over use was very common and I knew three mens who died from pancreas problems from alcohol. All men in Russia seem to die from this. Not liver problem from Alcohol. Pancreatic problems from Alcohol. I've been in America since 1994 and I've never known a person to die from pancreatitis. In Russia, it was very common. And that was in 1970s and 1980s! Only 45 years ago!
@vladeputinovic6128
2 күн бұрын
@@dpelpal 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
"They moved from house to house and took everything, up to the last seed." - Russian Peasant Farmer, under Stalin
@annatannehill716
Ай бұрын
He starved millions to death on purpose
Dziękuję za ten dokoment .
@SLICE_Full_Doc
8 күн бұрын
Dziękuję, że to obejrzałeś.
So many mentioned that compared to Vladimir Lenin that Joseph Stalin was a teddy bear, but I don’t believe that at all, and I think that death of Stalin was much worse but it’s just that Vladimir Lenin was a revolutionary and less of a statesman. Joseph Stalin was a little bit more statesman, like even though he was a thug. All of those Bolsheviks were brutes
@salvadorvizcarra769
Ай бұрын
Stalin was a GIANT of his time. Joseph Stalin lived in a historical era, where the world required strong leadership. So, he had to be an energetic, severe leader. Imposing! Or, otherwise, “Mother Russia” would have disappeared from the map. Stalin was what he had to be: A Great Leader. A Great Statesman. Stalin inherited a barren, rural, forgotten country, illiterate, hungry, superstitious, lacking everything and, to make matters worse, helpless until eviction. Stalin turned it into an industrialized and powerful superpower, which made the world tremble. Russia was 100 years behind the West and, once the precariousness and devastation caused by the War had been overcome, he, Stalin, the “Founder of the USSR”, launched the world's first Aero-Space Program. Stalin received a Russia that was at war for almost 30 years. (Starting with the humiliating defeat against the Empire of Japan, 1904-1905. Russian Revolution, 1905. WWI, 1914-1918. Bolshevik Revolution 1917-1922. Civil War against the “White Russians”, 1922-1927. WWII 1940-1945… Plus the Pandemic of the so-called “Spanish Fever”, 1918-1920. And, plus the “Wall Street Financial Crash”, from 1929-1937). In other words, Stalin assumed power in a country hit by wars, sickened by the Pandemic and economically bankrupt by the world crisis. These calamities left Russia dispossessed and miserable. Stalin rescued her by imposing discipline and work. Stalin was great; magnificent, highly cultured and astute. He was a Titan with an iron fist. Loved by his people and feared by his enemies. It has been more than 70 years since Stalin died, and Western Propaganda doesn't stop vilifying him. For what purpose? What would be its use now? .
@shable1436
Ай бұрын
Yeah look how he treated his own son, that says it all
@user-px1uj1sj3q
Ай бұрын
@@salvadorvizcarra769👍🤝✌
@ninjawizard3865
Ай бұрын
And those Bolsheviks were mostly Jews.
@ellenanortje3707
Ай бұрын
@@ninjawizard3865No matter what you watch or read, there is always an anti-semite that crawls out if the woodwork.
Hope you have the other two also.i wait to watch them together❤
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
yes we do, they're coming up in the weeks to come!
Adding to my previous comments(see above), in the West, additionally to the items mentioned previously, in my experience in mining, tunnelling, oil rigs, heated, airconditioned free rooms are provided for jobs in far- off places. Also, free food, various, of good quality is provided, as much as one can eat. When these items, in addition to those mentioned in the other comments section are in place, then people can work without becoming sick, on a good wage, and survive normally whilst doing the construction, etc., for a few years.
It would help to have subtitles considering few of us speak Russian
Russia has and treats their citizen like crap, disgusting. My family is from Lithuania and they lived under Russia regime, disgusting, horrific but they luckily excaped to Germany in the early 1900..the stories are are heart wrenching
@cheems5643
6 күн бұрын
Wait till you hear about migrant accommodation in New York and where most veterans end up after serving
@vladeputinovic6128
3 күн бұрын
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Russia hasn't changed since the first czar Never will
@jacobjorgenson9285
Ай бұрын
You’ve never been to Russia and you never will ….. so what exactly do you know ?
@kristinashepherd3003
7 күн бұрын
You really sound ridiculous 😂
What a documentary 😮 when is part 2???
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
Right here: kzread.info/dash/bejne/iqCd1rhueritqZc.html and part 3 is to come ;)
@karentorkar8256
26 күн бұрын
@@SLICE_Full_Doc These gulag survivors who you feature, look incredible considering. Particularly that man who was there for 27 years? Are they actually the survivors of it? Wouldn't they be very old by now, or are these interviews a few years old now, perhaps? The music throughout is excellent. It has such a depth to it.
My mother here in Canada described to me once a true story her grandmother told her once about how a relative of hers living in Germany who at first soon after the second world war was declared over failed to recognize her own son who had almost starved to death in a Russian concentration camp during the second world war. The second world war he survived only because it had been declared over before he starved to death while continuing to do his best to remain a consctientious objector while so many governments around were always relying on conscription of peasants into the military most to save the day. He survived by eating garbage. His favorite garbage to eat was potato peelings gained by peeling potatoes for the Russina instead officers there.
The Future of America
@nooodles939
Ай бұрын
Considering that we have more people in prison per capita and sheer numbers than any other nation on earth, I'd say we're well on our way. Land of the free??
7:34 Correction: Che-Ka rather means “emergency committee”, not “extraordinary commission”
It was their own choice for the reign of terror but no one found any profit of it, honesty is more important. So much is still left in this documentary like the pogroms after the extinction of the traveling gypsy. Germany followed adopting the same methodical system. Still the people of this world are like that prepared to lie out of shame loosing their name, it was all a word game. This world has all the potential to a better future and still they make war while the history is not to visit.
The slaves of XX. century, the slaves of socialism. 😢
And yet even today they long for the Soviet
@PerJustert
Ай бұрын
As if 144 million Russians agree on the same thing.
@travhammer
Ай бұрын
@@PerJustert they certainly dip the propaganda their fed. Period.
This is an excellent video. Should be required viewing in schools Instead of rainbows
@Gas_Station_Tampons
Ай бұрын
Both are evil. One is communism the other is fascism.
@timcasady4750
Ай бұрын
Should be required viewing in Russia but we know that will never happen as they omitted this tragedy to their own people from the history books
@brianhoeben7974
Ай бұрын
Reality, facts, truths, and actual history aren't part of curriculum anymore unfortunately. Indoctrination to totalitarian liberalism and all of it's mental illnesses is the push these days.
Well made documentary. The map of the USSR is wrong however, seems to only include Russia. And the mention in passing that five million people were starved to death, as if by accident, mostly in Ukraine, and then to move on is kinda weird.
Kruschev and others feared to talk. They condemned Stalin the dead. When someone heckled him. He roared ' Who said that' total silence. Kruscheve then said . That is why we dared not oppose Stalin. 48 rules of power. The name and God of this system of things is called FEAR OF DEATH.
What's the music at the start
What's wrong with Russian gov't? Why is the gov't so crazy?
@RWM195
4 күн бұрын
They’re always drinking vodka. It rots their brains 🧠.
@russianbotstein1422
Күн бұрын
The Bolsheviks werent Russian. Look up the ethnicity of Yagoda and Felix Dierzynsky. Go down that dark rabbit hole
great doc, but audio mixing is a little off
The fate of Nalvany shows that nothing has changed 🫠
@joekulik999
Ай бұрын
Navalny was a CIA plant whose only backers in Russia were Paid Stooges of the CIA.
@russianbotstein1422
Күн бұрын
Don't be so nieve. Who funds coupede tas all over the world? Why then is Assange in prison?
We could do them the honour of not repeating this kind of behavior. Leaders in this world will have a special place in hell. I will be praying that they meet the right shepherd once life is done with us.
🐕💚🍕we all know that history repeats itself so get ready cause this is going to be a doozy 🎉🎉🎉
My grate grandfather spent 15 years in the gulag 😳
Great video! But the music was a little too loud on this one and hard to hear the narrator.
WHO CAN TELL ME THE MUSIC AT 1:53????.
Why have we grown up seeing movies about Holocaust in TV, and hardly anybody knows about Gulag or Holodomor ? Have we been manipulated, have we got a kind of indocrination, according to which there are second and third class victims ?
@Warcrimeenthusiast
Ай бұрын
Probably the large amount of marxist /leninist ideology in modern western schools.
@eddiedelisio
Ай бұрын
Good observation. USA and England enabled not only Stalin victory in WW2 but also the multiple millions of rapes at the end of the war. At least 2 million German women and children alone were brutally gang raped, some 60-70 times, ages 8-80. This can be found even on Google. Poland and Baltics as well, surviving men taken to Gulags.
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
A lot of archives about all these events stayed locked under secrecy status under the soviet regime. With its collapse, historians have been able to study those starting the turn of the century, and a few archives have only been declassified in 2018. It explains that.
@juozassakavicius4726
Ай бұрын
@@SLICE_Full_DocHolodomor was known for 90 years and nobody cared about it. katyn massacre was know for tens of years and nobody cared about it. gulags was know for hundred years and nobody cared about because rotten west was happy with ruSSofascist regime!
@user-xm4ep1rl1j
Ай бұрын
Yes.
Incredible footage! So much work must have gone in to collating it all. Putin is gleefully turning the clock back to those days.
@stephenbiggins9114
Ай бұрын
Your a bonehead
Would be nice to have a documentary about the concentration camps that Winston Churchill built in Kenya and the colonies.
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
That would be indeed, thanks for the idea!
Nice to find a doc that has evaded yt's ham-fisted censorship.
Is it available in french?
We Humans tend to do the worst to our own....May we never forget....
How much has the Russian people suffered. And it continues now with Putin.
@russianbotstein1422
Күн бұрын
Nonsense, Putin has dragged Russia out of the ashes of Perestroika. Russia is a thriving nation that the west seeks to destroy.
Well, it was a dictatorship of the proletariat, after all. This is exactly what they said they were, right from the very outset.
That narrator sounds like she's narrating a day in the life of a cake shop, not one of the biggest terrors in history.
@noname-pz9kb
10 күн бұрын
I think the narration is appropriate. It sounds neutral.
Winter has 12 months the rest is summer.
25:21 David Lynch. 😅 He took a time machine out of there asap.
LOWER THE MUSIC PLEASE!!!
Rusija izgrađena na leđima svoga naroda,a zapad na leđima kolonijalnih naroda Ne zna se što je gore
@annatannehill716
Ай бұрын
Both are horrible
24:00 there are long sections of Russian language with no subtitles. Why?
@user-xm4ep1rl1j
Ай бұрын
Too lazy to include the captions from the original. Pirates.
@Chainsaw-ASMR
Ай бұрын
@@user-xm4ep1rl1j Thanks. Do you know the original source?
@user-xm4ep1rl1j
Ай бұрын
@@Chainsaw-ASMR Just what it says: "Documentary: GULAG, THE STORY - Episode 1: From experimentation to setting up the forced labour system (1918-1936) Directed by: Patrick Rotman Production: KUIV Productions pour ARTE France"
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
We own the AVOD diffusion rights for this series, not putting subtitles was a production choice. It is always nice to see our work valued :)
@user-xm4ep1rl1j
Ай бұрын
@@SLICE_Full_Doc Just another sarcastic prick. Shame, boy.
I have a hard time hearing spoken words over music. I really wish they wouldn’t do that. Or at least adjust it so the speech is louder.
So very sad
25:27 It's like watching 1984.
After watching this I have no complaints!!! How on earth could the Russian people allow this inhumanity and continue for so long? Here in the west there's a riot if a prisoners don't get there mouthy phone cards,😅
@shable1436
Ай бұрын
It's called human rights, you know the ones we are born with under our constitution
@JeffMTX
13 күн бұрын
You didn’t witness the Covid social experiment?
At list six hundred years before the revolution, the monasteries in Russia served also as prisons. @2:08 The prison on the Sovetesky island wasn't the idea of the Bolsheviks, it was established in 15-th century, at the same time when the monastery was build. Ivan Terrible would set to that monastery prison, some of his lucky opponents.
Whos the guy with glasses on the end at 21:50
@shable1436
Ай бұрын
Mikhail kalinin
@joeygrim0654
Ай бұрын
@@shable1436 thank you, I keep seeing him pop up in soviet documentaries and didn't know who he was
@shable1436
Ай бұрын
@@joeygrim0654 same ppl in Stalin inner circle, wasn't hard to find
Still open today.
Not much different to Australia back then. In 1918 there were 10 concentration camps for people of German or Austrian background and those of other ethnicities who lived in the Austrian Hungarian Empire. The British were sending people from all over Asia (ex German colonies) to those camps. Even those who were born in Australia and had German parents. The conditions were awful. Norwegian and Swiss ambassadors tried to intervene on few occassions. The British-Australian soldiers treated these prisoners as bad as the Aboriginals. Bayonetting was common, stealing from them too, raping etc. One could write a letter - but only in the English language. Most were never sent though. You won't find any memorials in those places today commemorating the victims. No trace is left.
@88njtrigg88
20 күн бұрын
None of the facts you've pointed out are correct, just a word sandwich of twisted facts turned into non-fiction nonsense. Reported as such. Have a nice day. Cioa.
@lukei6255
20 күн бұрын
@@88njtrigg88 dig deeper and you will find it. Not with your spade 🤣
Cool & Normal!
Unbelievable
It was all about slavery.
@jefferyharris4066
Ай бұрын
🤡 ninjas?
Britain was the world's number one customer for the timber Also the labour gov said it was a utopian system, yes you read that right
I know a couple former u.s politicians who should be there. Thanks for sharing.
@geraldek4948
Ай бұрын
Former?
@change691
Ай бұрын
@@geraldek4948yes, trump.
@anatoliykazak9528
Ай бұрын
Then how are you different from what those communists who did those horrible things in my country that documentary show? No matter how much you don’t like your political opponents, if you wish them to be in that camp, you are as evil as those who created those camps.
Solovki was used by Rissia back in the 18th century and after for anyone not liked by the authorities, often anyone with thoughts of freedom, human rights and the like. And so to this day. Slave labour, atrocious, unsafe working and living conditions, malnutrition, bad stuff. Therefore the high casualty rate. Those sort of jobs can be done properly....8 hour or so working days, safety equipment, tools machines, humane living conditions, above normal wages. For maybe 2 to 5 years. Remote distance living allowance, bonuses, free meals, free accomodation, approved washing, showering, toilet, laundry facilities, recreational facilities and other necessary needs catered for, medical, for example. A reason why those essentials were inadequate was probably because the Russian leaders had never touched a shovel in their hands and knew nothing, and therefore didn't give a stuff. Similarly, Russia fought its wars, as it is doing now during the illegal invasion of Ukraine, using human meat waves. Again, from its leadership, whereby people come last. The video shows many zeks. I wonder how many of rhem were Ukrainians, since I have read that 60%+ of zeks were Ukrainians. That makes sense since Russia, since 350 years ago, has been trying to bury, denationalise Ukraine and Ukrainians. I have also read about that Frenkel mentioned in the video. According to him, if a zek could last 3 months before expiring, the gulag system could be maintained. He convinced Stalin with this theory. Whenever dad saw Stalin on TV, he would cal him a 'son of a bitch'! Also, as in the video, in some place in Siberia, the Komi or Kolyma regions, during a spring thaw, a whole hillside uncovered multiple corpses of zeks. An eyewitness account portrays a burial procedure of a deceased zeks whereby a nude corpse is carted to a bog and unceremoniously thrown in the mud and observed to sink out of sight. Such were the burials, apparently. Those people cheering the party hacks were(and probably are now, the present ones) either duped with propaganda or rotten types themselves. Those 'kulaks' and many others, most even, convicted and sent to the gulags were probably innocent mostly. Those Kremlin gremlins, past and present, their lackeys, and many Russians, are the ones that should have been in the gulags before anyone else. Although, some Russians suffered, mostly it was Ukrainians and other minorities. In the present illegal invasion of Ukraine, I would not trust Putin and his hacks, nor 80% of Russians. If Russia was having more success in the illegal invasion, those 80% would be praising their scoundrel leaders.
What makes you think that they are gone? There is no difference between the Russians and the Nazis.
Music too loud unfortunately
The evil that men do 😢😢
24:16 what are they saying? Why isn't this party translated?
@jason.larsenthedanishgreek1226
Ай бұрын
Because she literally explains what is happening you don't need to see subtitles of each one confessing to bogus charges as she states
part 2?
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
in a few days now!
FBI checka same thing got it
8:56 interesting 🤔
History repeating itself now!
When is part 2 coming out?
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
it is right here: kzread.info/dash/bejne/iqCd1rhueritqZc.html and part 3 to come in a few days!
@Nikoravesh
Ай бұрын
@@SLICE_Full_Doc you guys are the best!
Communism organized by certain Bourgeois minds as a (political, economy, and social ideology and way of life)for worker classes and peasants interesting (as they proclaimed)..when communist politicians organized( Communism regimes) those regimes committed width Peasants annihilation and ultra exploiting and prosecutions of workers
I recently have decided... Nothing whatsoever.. It took years of mass debating..and.. Millions of dollars..to reach this conclusion.
10s of Millions more have gone through the US prison system, here you will only see the early situation at the gulag, US prisons much the same, the Soviets did not have the death penalty except for very special cases.
Isn’t it about time the Gulag was given the publicity it deserves? Isn’t it about time the BBC, PBS America, and Channel 4, for instance, started informing the public of this monumental crime against humanity perpetrated by Communist Russia?
Yeah sorry waaaay too many ads
You should do one on the country with the worlds largest population of incarcerated people ie America
@tc556guy
Ай бұрын
There's a difference between political prisoners and criminals. We didn't have political prisoners until after January 6th. We have so many incarcerated criminals because we have a significant population that has no qualms about breaking the law.
@user-mb9zx9lg7p
Ай бұрын
you sir are completely brain dead Dead from the neck up
@shable1436
Ай бұрын
@@tc556guyor our laws are too strict for the population you're referring to.
@tc556guy
Ай бұрын
If that demographic has problems following the laws then that's on them.
Its gone full circle foor the farmers today
How on earth did these men or women, survive Kolymer. Incredibly sad.
To all those who advocate for Communism/Socialism take note
@RikkeNielsen-we5vz
25 күн бұрын
@JeepWrangler1957 Crimes against humanity is a horrible and nasty thing! 30 milions Russians in Gulag! 60 millions native american first nation peoples! The list goes on , and on...!🌿
@RikkeNielsen-we5vz
25 күн бұрын
Terminated and lost lives, culture...!
@phillipschouw2462
24 күн бұрын
Bruh socialism is a necessary opposite. Communism is a cruel system.
@sonofsophia
23 күн бұрын
Dont equate the soviet style of communism/socialism with all communist movements. In fact, other communists socialists and assorted "leftist" radicals were some if the first and most persecuted groupsby the bolsheviks and maoists. There have been many positive and effective examples of what coukd be defined as communism throughout history, not least of which was the early christian church. But yes you are still right. Communism without a healthy spiritual perspective is a recipe for injustice. "Vengeance is mine" says the Lord. Man trying to take justice into his own hands often leads to injustice
@CarlosGarcia-wh5bw
23 күн бұрын
Hiroshima, Moulin rouge, Pinochet, abuse of children in schools, depravity, to genocide in Gaza, Rwanda and the list goes on ,to all those advocating democracy, take note
Never change ?
All hell is from the monarchy. From the careless czar to the careless king in london
I've always taught that Russian woman we're very masculine. I think this was encouraged and possibly helped along by the communist by whatever means possible in Stalin's time.✌️
Could you make video about usa concentration camps of American native japanese locked up in ww2 as usa government considered them enemies?
@peter2023
Ай бұрын
The Japanese treated any westerner in pow camps far worse..war is hell for the innocent
@SLICE_Full_Doc
Ай бұрын
this would be a very interesting subject indeed!
@Arete37
20 күн бұрын
Found the Russian.