www.patreon.com/metaltrenches

@TheRockSocietyReviews

5 ай бұрын

I see

Can't wait for Weird Al to drop "The Canadian Dream Is Killing Me"

@TheRockSocietyReviews

5 ай бұрын

Or Look Grandpa, No Cane!

@ROOKTABULA

5 ай бұрын

Exactly what is the Canadian Dream and how is it making you upset?

Dookie is the album that defined the 90s. Also, it had one of the most memorable hidden tracks ever.

@F4RB3YONDM3T4L

6 ай бұрын

I mean, it’s AN album that defined the 99’s. Nevermind was THE album that defined rhe 90’s.

@guilhermeribeiromichelino3852

6 ай бұрын

One of the albums. Can't forget things like Nevermind

@caidenh04

6 ай бұрын

Nirvana defined the 90s.

@Cwin-ny6bp

5 ай бұрын

There were several major genres that dominated the 90s mainstream (grunge/pop punk/post-grunge/alternative metal/nu metal). I don’t think any one album can really define the decade as a whole.

“Never really stuck with me” lmao reference to a song in insomniac

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

You caught it...

Insomniac feels a lot like In Utero to me. It followed a hugely successful and popular album with many singles, that made the band a sensation yet the band chose to take a darker, more twisted turn. They didn’t repeat their breakthrough album. This is why both Insomniac and In Utero are my favorites from each discography.

@NbleSavage

5 ай бұрын

Great take, I agree. Insomniac was the band deliberately trying a more edgy, sinister tone compared to Dookie. Dookie made them famous, Insomniac was their response to the artistic freedom that comes with fame. They're both amazing albums in their own way.

@Jayagebee

5 ай бұрын

Interesting take. I love the album for those reasons, too, but aside from some stellar bass work, I find the music side of the album more “one-note” than its predecessor and successor. Its biggest strength lie primarily in the introspective nature of the lyrics.

@Cwin-ny6bp

5 ай бұрын

Angel Dust by Faith No More kinda fits that same mold.

@gabix7488

2 ай бұрын

Insomniac its Green Day's Raining Blood

Macy's Day Parade was also a single off Warning. Their best ballad IMO.

Trilogy is hugely underrated and Tre especially. Its quite shocking how people think this album is bad.

@bambampewpew32

5 ай бұрын

No no it makes sense why people think those are bad (even though I like them), but IT'S INSANE how people think 21st and American idiot are bad

@arinthia827

5 ай бұрын

Bro fr

@bungus49

4 ай бұрын

I grew up listening from American Idiot to the Trio Albums era of Green Day, thought it was peak music as a teenager haha. But as I get older I prefer their earlier stuff more and more. Besides F of all MF, there isn't a "bad" album on this list, but several "mehs" in my humble opinion.

@bambampewpew32

4 ай бұрын

@@bungus49 lmao true yeah

I love that you did a Green Day album ranking in a BTBAM shirt, because I just bought tickets to both BTBAM's Colors + Colors II tour and Green Day's Dookie + American Idiot tour. :D I really don't care for anything after 21st Century Breakdown, but all their albums from Dookie to American Idiot are classics in my book. Insomniac is my personal favorite.

@takodabostwick8507

6 ай бұрын

I just wish it was the Colors shirt. Because that is their best album easily! One of the best progressive albums ever made! Genius!

@gabrielparadis5895

5 ай бұрын

Nice mask you have

"Slapped training wheels on it for simpletons" lmao! I'm stealing this for describing so many other things! Absolute gold

I love Green Day, but I had no idea they had a new album coming out. I'm excited to listen to it.

One Eyed Bastard taking the riff of Pink is now on par with Disturbed taking Living La Vida Loca's beat

I love Insomniac. It suffered the same fate as Offsprings Ixnay on the Hombre, both are great albums that followed up quickly after their best albums and almost got overlooked. Also both albums almost feel like their most, experimental is the wrong word, deliberately different maybe, but you get my drift...and funnily enough both Insomniac and Ixnay have aged the best for me.

@saneiac

5 ай бұрын

I was confused at first when you said Ixnay followed their best album, as I wondered how Ixnay could follow itself.

@themetalpig7613

5 ай бұрын

@@saneiac lol! I prob should've said successful...I think Offsprings Smash still has the record for the highest grossing independent album.

I'm a diehard Metalhead but before I got into Metal - Green Day along with The Offspring were my gateway bands to appreciating Rock. Basket Case was on a Rock compilation I bought, and from there I had to own everything they ever put out. Amazing Pop-Punk band. Distorted electric guitar is actually something I DIDN'T hear much of growing up in the mid to late 90s - the mainstream was dominated by Electro-Pop here in the UK, and the only "Rock" that was big was the likes of Oasis and Blur. So hearing something with a hint more aggression was a real ear opener.

@bloweedrawings5177

6 ай бұрын

Terrorvision, skunk Anansie, ash, the cranberries....

@Cwin-ny6bp

5 ай бұрын

I think nu metal and post-grunge (along with boy/girl bands) dominated the late 90s in the US.

Death metal kid here, but was just hitting 16 when Dookie dropped (hahahah) and it was a fantastic time to be a music fan. That album was what got me into punk (outside of things like Misfits/Ramones/70's Euro punk.) To think day Pulling Teeth is one of my absolute favorite songs.

@SuperStrik9

5 ай бұрын

I was 13 lol. Dookie is a pop punk classic imo. Insomniac is a good album too. Brain Stew is a fun tune. Saw the Ramones at Lollapalooza 96. So glad I got to see them before they broke up. Also lol @ Dookie dropped 💩

Dookie is perfection. My older sister had it on tape and my parents got so tired of hearing her complain about me stealing it, they bought me my own. The tape was brown. Wish I still had it. Nimrod is excellent. Glad someone said it.

Dude! Really cool of you to create a tier list for Green Day. They were definitely my introduction to rock music as well, and I was a huge fan of theirs before getting into metal.

Construct is for me is what Damage Done was for you. Construct was one of the first melodeath albuns I've ever listened to and I adore it to this day, for me every song is incredible. Sending some love for this album because it's often one of the least liked by people. Great video!!

Now that is something, I didn't expect from you. A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one. 🙂

@MetalTrenches

6 ай бұрын

🤘🏻

Damn, didn't expect a Green Day tier list on this channel. Ngl they are still one of my favorite bands of all time, i unironically love American Idiot. Great video man.

If Kerplunk isn't at least a "Good" due to "2000 Light Years Away", we riot.

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

Riot prevented

@NbleSavage

5 ай бұрын

@@MetalTrenches that bass riff! "…"

Maaan this band is my childhood and early teen years their music is the quintessence of nostalgia for me. I remember when I was in elementary and middle school this band was absolutely MASSIVE. Love it or hate it, American Idiot is the most popular rock album of the last 25 years and still unmatched. Now tho I do think that as a entire album experience is kinda a mixed bag because it has these super huge and anthemic songs that defined a whole generation (American Idiot, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, When me up when September Ends) but it even has a lot of filler tracks and super mid songs (Extraordinary Girl, Give Me Novacaine, Homecoming ecc), tho I would like to suggest the last track Whatsername which is one of my favorite Green Day songs ever and I think it's criminally underrated.

NEW VID HYPE

@MetalTrenches

6 ай бұрын

Happy Ice Apocalypse

I gave the new Green Day album a listen this morning and I was pleasantly surprised. It’s not their best album but I do think it’s their best since American Idiot. Though to me nothing beats Dookie and Insomniac as Green Day’s best. Here would be my ranking of their albums: S - Dookie, Insomniac A - Kerplunk, Nimrod, American Idiot B - 39/Smooth, Warning, Saviors C - 21st Century Breakdown, Revolution Radio D - Uno!, Dos!, Tre! F - Father of All Motherfuckers

I wasn't expecting this tier list. Green Day are my favorite band, are from my hometown (also hometown of Possessed), and I went to high school with Billie Joe's nephew. I really enjoyed the new album and it's one of my favorite things I've heard this month. My favorite album by them fluctuates back and forth between Nimrod and Insomniac. Here's how I would tier out their discography (no ranking within tiers). Perfection: Nimrod, Insomniac, Dookie, American Idiot Great: Warning, Kerplunk, 21st Century Breakdown, 39/Smooth Good: Saviors, Revolution Radio, Uno, Dos, Tre Meh: Bad: Father of All...

I love how you deliver your criticism, it always has depth to it. i don't always agree, but I always enjoy hearing your reasons. Great channel

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

🤘🏻

@chili_phil

5 ай бұрын

Thanks bro ;-) @@MetalTrenches

Haven't seen the whole video yet but Teenage teenager is the worst thing green day has ever done and nobody can tell me otherwise.

@stefandelhaize557

6 ай бұрын

Nightlife

@_amp1262

6 ай бұрын

​​@@stefandelhaize557 oh yeah nightlife's definitely worse. then there's also that bonus track on Dookie. not a necessary addition at all

@solarwinds5114

5 ай бұрын

​@@stefandelhaize557nah Nightlife is catchy and fun

@daa343

5 ай бұрын

Agreed the lyrics make me cringe

@Jayagebee

5 ай бұрын

“Oh Yeah” is definitely up there, too! Most of the “Father…” album is pretty goddamn awful!

I really love it when you talk about non-metal bands. It's really refreshing to see from time to time.

Here is my ranking of Green Day's albums: 14. 39/Smooth 13. Father of All... 12. Warning 11. Dos 10. Tre 9. Uno 8. Insomniac 7. Saviors 6. 21st Century Breakdown 5. Kerplunk 4. Nimrod 3. Revolution Radio 2. American Idiot 1. Dookie

Hot take nimrod is my favorite with American idot being in 2nd and warning being my third favorite

@tbolt720

6 ай бұрын

Dunno what's hot about this. That Dookie - American Idiot 5 album run is legendary.

@The3Virus

6 ай бұрын

​@@tbolt720 Warning was absolutely hated at release

@tbolt720

5 ай бұрын

@@The3Virus oh I'm aware. Seems many people have come around on it over the years

@Agostoic

5 ай бұрын

Same 🎉

Mine would be: BAD: Uno, Tre, Father of All. MEH: Dos. GOOD: Warning, Revolution Radio, Saviors. GREAT: Kerplunk, 39/Smooth, 21stCB PERFECTION: Dookie, Insomniac, Nimrod and American Idiot.

Green day list: 1-21st Century Breakdown 2-American idiot 3-Warning 4-Dookie 5-Nimrod 6-Father of all Motherfuckers 7-Revolution radio 8-Insomniac 9-¡Uno! 10-¡Tré! 11-¡Dos! 12-Saviors 13-Kerplunk! 14-1039/smoothed out slappy hours I love their discography! Every album is a banger, except for their first one witch is really boring, it killed me for puting kerplunk, saviors and the triollogy so low, i love those albums, but, it is what it is, insomniac is awesome, i love how raw and angry it is, rev rad was an album that i didnt really cared about for a long time, but now i know what a great record it is, Yes i LOVE FOAM, i dont care what people say, its fun, Nimrod its one of their most experimental records, i love that, Dookie its an instant classic when you listen to those lyrics and riffs, warning its their most underrated work, american idiot and the beast that it is, 21st century breakdown the most relatable one in my opinon, BANGER!

We may have some different tastes (your "good" tier being my two favorite albums) but I respect the review!!

Dookie is a pop punk classic. Longview has a killer bassline. Heard dude was tripping acid when he came up with it lol.

I put their new album with Dookie. I love it

Growing up in the Bay Area when dookie dropped 😉 you could feel the effect immediately, the nirvana of Gilman street. I was a staunch metalhead from the get go, but dookie was such a great uniter between the communities. Even more so for me with me and insomniac. Geek stink breath is a criminally underrated single, and it was always a treat to hear the brain stew/jaded hybrid on the radio (often jaded wasn’t included so I’d wait in anticipation.) My generations heartbreaker/ living living maid 😂

First GD teir list ive seen done intelligently and intricately . Well done , love your channel n your lists the past couple of months. Cheers!!! 🤘🤘and good luck with the ice storm, as a canadian during winter season, I feel your pain 🙂

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

Thanks

This tier list is a hell of a lot better than Anthony Fantanos

Good night Adeline is my personal favorite. It’s more of a pop sounding song but the solo and vocals are catchy

Insomniac has always been my favorite.

You should do a debut, sophomore, album etc tier list for grunge.

10:53 we need an Elton John album teir list next 😂

@Duality_of_Man

6 ай бұрын

I second this, what a GOAT

@MetalTrenches

6 ай бұрын

I dod listen to them all several years back lol. Goodbye Yellow Brick Road goated

@mat2093

5 ай бұрын

​@@MetalTrenchesjust a warning his new album was pretty bad.

Dookie was literally the first CD i ever bought along with my first CD /cassette tape player combo.

3:50 Babe I’m gonna leave you by led zeppelin also has a riff that is almost identical to 25 or 6 to 4. So I guess this is just a very popular chord progression lol

I'm happy for Greenday. This album is great for them. Father of All was terrible so I'm glad they got back at it with enthusiasm.

I like it when you venture out of metal

Perfection: Dookie, Nimrod, American Idiot Great: Kerplunk, Insomniac, 21st Century Breakdown, Warning, Rev Rad, Saviors Good: 1039/Smooth, !Uno!, Trè! Meh: ¡Dos! Father of All (even though there is a lot of songs on ¡Dos! that I really like) If the trilogy was one album with all the good songs on one album, I definitely think it could’ve been a great album

Green Day have the same politics as my HR dept.

Insomniacs my favorite album

I’ve had good times with dookie, I agree it’s a 10/10 That’s where my love for them ends though 😅

Yknow, 90's Green Day would totally release a cough into a microphone as a single and it wouldve made it onto International Superhits and would be remembered as a classic and it would be in the soundtrack to a 90s throwback movie

I've been hearing a single look ma no brains in a taco bell commercial lol.

I loved Dookie and Nimrod, and after that I liked the odd song here and there like"Brainstew," "Blood, Sex and Booze" "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" and "Holiday." I do have many fond memories of Nimrod and Dookie though. Nimrod was the first CD I purchased with my own money at the age of 10, and Dookie is an album I would throw on a lot in my adult years while playing with my son becaue it was fun, and didn't have "scary cookie monster vocals."

i actually completely agree with this list except i slighly prefer 1039 to kerplunk

I got into them just before Warning came out (Warning tour they played for 3.5 hours which was impressive). When American Idiot came out, I had moved on a bit but I liked it a lot at first until everything was quickly overplayed. It was also too produced. 21st Century I didn't like at first, but it grew on me a lot (still too produced). I liked a few songs off RevRa but other than that I haven't liked anything since 2009. Nimrod was my first record and still a top 10 album for me and wish they would do an album like that again. 1) Nimrod 2) Dookie 3) 21st Century 4) Insomniac 5) American Idiot 6) Warning 7) Kerplunk 8) Revolution 9) 39/Smooth 10) Tre 11) Uno 12) Father of All 13) Dos Guess I'll go give Saviors a listen

Insomniac is my favorite album. Some nice cuts on there.

Love Green day.

Strongly disagree with your ranking of Warning. I love waiting, but the best tracks on that album aren’t the singles. Blood, sex, and booze, deadbeat holiday, church on Sunday, Macy’s day parade, it’s my favourite green day album by far. A lot of range and creativity, less same old same old. To each their own I guess

I’ll take first 7 inch “1000 hours”.

I didnt appreciate all of Dookie until much, much later in fife. I had a friend in 2006 who gave me American Idiot, Insomniac, and Nimrod and so i grew to love those first. Nimrod is still my favorite

I liked Saviors a lot

I’m that weirdo that ranks 1039 Smoothed out slappy hours as Green Days best album followed by Kerplunk and then Dookie. They kind of lost me after Insomniac. I think 1039 is my favourite as it came out when I was a young teenager (yeah I’m old as fuck) so has massive sentimental value and memories attached.

American Idiot is a 2000s masterpiece like Tommy or The Wall every songs is imediate yet fits the rock opera

I love insomniac with every fiber of my being. It's an underrated and under appreciated gem. Id say it, 20th century breakdown, and Revolution radio sit at my S tier for ranking. I do have to go back and listen to the other albums again to remember where id put them. But id say saviors is at a solid high b, low a. I'll give American Idiot a decent low a. Only because I find it truly overrated and over played. Insomniac has some of, if not a decent amount of my overall favorite songs from the album. No pride is a banger, I enjoy brain stew despite being a bit over played. Love geek stink breath, walking Contradiction is one of my all time favorite songs from Greenday. Stuart and the avenue is a good deviation from the typical breakup song. West bound sign is solid. Tight wad hill is growing on me immensely. Armatage shanks is a great opener for the album.

Isn’t it “Bab’s Uvula Who?” ? Also good ranking!

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

Oops

The brain stew chord progression is not only the same as that Chicago song, but also Led Zeppelin’s “Babe I’m Guna Leave you”, the Beatles “While My Guitar Gently Weeps”, and some Styx song… Madam Blue?

"I would be surprised if there is people out there who love this one" Well, I do. Except from DOS! e FOAMF, I love all of them

I agree with pretty much everything, except I would put Insomniac on perfection. The thing is GD were kinda of pissed off from the allegations that they "betrayed" the punk movement with the success of Dookie. Insomniac is born in response to that, so I feel like the songs not being that catchy is not a problem, for they were not trying to make catchy songs, but instead angry and powerful ones.

How about a classic punk band tier list ? ;)

@MetalTrenches

6 ай бұрын

Dead Kennedys S

@_amp1262

6 ай бұрын

​@@MetalTrenches my man

Good tier list, i personally love uno & 21cb, but you put kerplunk, insomniac, dookie, and saviors pretty high so i will have to give you this 👑

X-Kid feels a bit like a summer commercial song. For me trilogy was ok, not bad not the best

3:37 I saw what you did there

my top 3 are prob 1.21st century breakdown 2.dookie 3.insomniac i just love these albums the most lol

1) Dookie 2) American Idiot 3) Insomniac 4) Nimrod 5) Revolution Radio 6) Kerplunk 7) 21st Century Breakdown 8) Warning 9) Smooth 10) The Trilogy 11) Father of All Haven't listened to Saviors yet but the only one I dislike is Father of All

Christie Road 🤘

I kinda enjoyed myself some GD back in the days growing up during the '90s. My personal favorites would be Dookie, followed by Insomniac and Nimrod. They kinda lost me with Warning. And they lost me completely once American Idiot dropped. Haven't listened to anything since then. Except for a couple of songs here and there.

Do one for Bad Religion (that is, if you listen to them, their discography is kinda huge)

Hot take: as much as I love Dookie, I gotta say, the album is VERY top 2/3 to 3/4 heavy. I just can't get into Sassafras Roots, no matter how many times I try to listen to it, and it sucks that it's in between two absolute bangers (She and When I Come Around) and I'm too lazy to skip the song. There's some great deep cuts like Burnout, Having a Blast, Chump, and especially Pulling Teeth. I'd give the album a 9/10 personally, but I don't think it's their best album or a perfect album either. Edit: Also She is a great deep cut.

Baby Uvula 2?

WTF, a lot of albums 😂 the last album I listened was American idiot. Good times 😢 Saludos 👋 🇲🇽

Busted out the stop watch here, haha. Everytime there's a tier ranking , once the last album goes up, that chart is GONE. If ya want to look the whole thing over you got 0.82 sec. after the last album is placed. LOL (Please don't take this seriously, I'm only having fun.)

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

lol there IS a pause button you know

Is it just me or I think the Kurplunk version of Welcome to Paradise is better than the Dookie version. 14: Father of All 13: Dos 12: Uno 11: Tre 10: 39/Smooth 9: Saviors 8: Revolution Radio 7: Warning 6: Kerplunk! 5: Insomniac 4: 21st Century Breakdown 3: Dookie 2: American Idiot 1: Nimrod

Can we get a Marilyn Manson tier list? Would love to see that.

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

At some point

@wadehill116

5 ай бұрын

@@MetalTrenches 🤘

I don't like green day but I like you so I'll watch

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

Mark of a true fan. I do still recommend Dookie at the very least though.

I feel like you went easy on Saviors because your expectations were so dang low lol. If you don't like the preachyness of American Idiot, well "The American Dream is killing me" is way more on those nose. Jesus of Suburbia is an excellent roller coaster of a song that has more cool variety than most whole albums do (not to mention the harmonies and song writing is great). Give me Novicaine is a straight BANGER, and wake me up when september ends always hits me hard because he sings about his father dying, so I remember listening to this song as a kid and being grateful that my father is still around.American Idiot and She's a Rebel are just bangers too.

"oh no!.......My pre-metal youth". I've never understood why rock/heavy shit fans become tribal and limit themselves to their chosen genre or sub-genre. My fave bands back in the day, VH, Metallica, U2, Ramones, QOTSA, Nirvana, Ministry etc etc: ALL had a very wide range of tastes. People always were amazed by music collection because of how I looked and how hard and/or heavy tracks were on our albums. When I see metalheads who ignore everything not what they consider 'real music', I always ask them what their fave food is and ask them if that's _the only_ food they eat.

I liked Dookie as a kid but I hate greenday now. Just wanted to skim through this episode.

Insomniac is my favourite GD album.

Tried and tried, but never could get into much more than the radio songs. Even then, not my favorite. I certainly get why their popular and have been around so long, just not for me.

bro your review of Green day's album, im putting to bad😆

I believe in Nimrod supremacy, solid as fuck!

Never was a fan of this band but this was entertaining as always

Hope you can get the tree removed and your house safe. S: Dookie, Insomniac A: Kerplunk, American Idiot B: Warning, Nimrod C: Revolution Radio, 39 Smooth,Uno D: 21st Century Breakdown, Tre Father of all: Dos, Father of all

Green day seriously? I thought it was about DIR EN GREY, I had already gotten excited..

American Idiot was a cultural turning point in punk music... can't believe it didn't even make B tier

I’m the opposite, I preferred the second half of Saviors over the first.

Green Day is to music what Olestra is to chips. They tried it in the '90s, found out it caused people to shit like crazy and now it's just a bad memory.

Haven’t enjoyed anything they’ve put out for years now. Impressive how much they’ve written though when you see it all laid out like that seriously impressive body of work. I will admit though their headline grabbing political moments have given me so many eye roll moments that it’s tainted them for me

@MetalTrenches

5 ай бұрын

Agreed

Yeah, sugar youth is definitely the best from father of all

Ha ha glad to see Green day getting progressively worse with each album. ha ha I still enjoy this punk style of music but there doesn't seem to be many bands releasing quality music in the genre. The closest I come now is Origami Angel - Somewhere City.

Personally even tho I agree it does have its standout tracks and some songs that weren’t singles American idiot is my least faveroute green day album next to 21st century I thought that had to many ballads and songs that just didn’t interest me