Shubin is so enthusiastic, and it is contagious.

@derlinclaire1778

6 жыл бұрын

Yes,God bless him.

the enthusiasm is infectious.

I might have needed to watch this video for a class, but this was so interesting it held my attention the entire time This is the kind of educational content I could watch just for fun!

@andanssas

3 жыл бұрын

If you are going to present this subject, hear his recent #mindscape interview with Sean Carroll, lots of additional details there!

@pavel9652

Жыл бұрын

​@@andanssas I would be interested. Which video is it? Do you have it in the YT history? There are some AMAs or interviews, some are 3+ hours long. It is not really actionable information ;) If it takes you too long to find, don't bother ;)

@earlysda

Жыл бұрын

Where was the "educational content"? You do realize that "Evolution hasn't been observed while it's happening", don't you?

@evanwademan5602

2 ай бұрын

You did learn about natural selection in high school, right? I’m actually very interested in evolutionary biology, & this video is pretty nostalgic to me

Wow, I'm slowly understanding. Dr Shubin HiT the JACKPOT of Paleontology.

...and this is why I love science. Thank you. This is vital information for us all.

@clashacc7271

4 жыл бұрын

Jim Wills awww. so sad. i pity you. open your eyes. quit being brainwashed. god isn’t real.

@andanssas

3 жыл бұрын

Lighting up the mood (and the main subject), lots of additional details were added in his recent #mindscape88 interview with Sean Carroll. New information is not incompatible with one's beliefs, so you might keep your mind open ;)

Dr Shubin had made a monumental discovery...he's contributed a great deal toward a full understanding of the origins of tetrapods, among other forms. Thank you! Great video!

Who else is watching this for homework in quarantine??

@PRESTIGEOUSNESS

Ай бұрын

Watching for fun. You probably graduated by now. Congrats friend.

How fortunate that the find was led by such a personable and likeable guy! So full of joy of the world and all it's treasures.

This was a highly educational video! I've been looking for ages on how a dig site is actually found and excavated and I finally have the info that I've been looking for!

@earlysda

Жыл бұрын

"Evolution hasn't been observed while it's happening". That means it fails the scientific method.

he says we stand upright but the irony is we are all sitting down.

@ClaudiaMariaBritoPires

8 жыл бұрын

hahaha 😂😂😂 thank You for that. It woke my brain up after 6 hours of studying. #finalsweek

@PlainsPup

6 жыл бұрын

Yes, and barely even sitting up!

@antonishedsp2036

4 жыл бұрын

ahahah

@bhevrage

3 жыл бұрын

This is why you get bullied.

@phyzixs.8061

3 жыл бұрын

@Alejandro Carreon don't think that's a valid insult but ok..

Just the VERY BEST. Neil Shubin shows us all why Bio is so awesome!!

I love this guy Neil ..... I read his book when it first came out: He can certainly stand behind anything he says! Happy to see how much he enjoyed "the process" of finding Tik, albeit - it wasn’t always so easy.

Beautiful! The mutant legged fish coming onto land is a symbol of ventures into new (geographic and psychological) territories. And when the legged fish crossed the border from water to land, it didn't even get a visa first. ;-)

I'm only in middle school and I'm watching this for science class, but it's a type of video that I would just watch for fun because *the study of animals and adaption of creatures if friggin AMAZING.*

Love programs like this.

Tiktaalik sure looks like a happy go-lucky li'l water critter. Kind of like a mata mata with that big grin.

I can so much relate to Neil Shubin and Tiktaalik. Not the least because I'm living near a paleontological site that made history as well, the Neander valley (in German: Neandertal) where the first Neanderthals were found. What is still more amazing and barely anyone knows (apart from some local geologists): The limerocks in the Neander valley formed during the time when Tiktaalik lived, around 380 million years ago in the Middle Devonian. So the coral fossils that I have in my book shelf are exactly of that age. Everytime I have them in my hands I think of Neil Shubin and Tiktaalik.

Interesting and well presented with a pleasant and knowledgeable narrator

Dr. Shubin went out on a “limb” and it paid off!

@Shieldmaiden313

3 ай бұрын

Tetrapod humor 😅

The next man I marry must be as enthusiastic as this guy:))

@normalnate3447

3 жыл бұрын

funny

I am so glad to be living in a time when we have a handle on the development of species; we can make sense of present day diversity and trace back that development to its origins. It was 40 years ago when I first read Darwin's origin of species (on a Philosophy course, lol). It took time and the help of others to synthesize its contents and develop my understanding. I am enormously grateful for the work of scientists (Darwin himself and those that followed up his work). I am not sure I have the patience for such work, but I do love the results. I feel that that people such as these have rescued us from the magical 'explanations' with which were stuck with for so long.

@earlysda

Жыл бұрын

Everything on earth originated when Jesus spoke it into existence roughly 6,000 years ago.

@focke-wulffw-1902

Жыл бұрын

@@earlysda that’s a load of bs and you know it lol

Great video!

brilliant video keep it up!

great video, I learned alot by watching it, many things that I didnt even have an idea about! niiiiceee

@oskarcarlsson5025

4 жыл бұрын

🙂🙂🙃🙂

thank you

Professor Shubin, You are a great scientist 👌👌

@Kareem-Ahmed

2 жыл бұрын

of course he is, better than the Rahbar million times!

Great content on this channel!

@biointeractive

3 жыл бұрын

Glad you enjoy it!

Outstanding video. Thanks. Almost fell out of my chair when I saw the bear protection. Hahaha. Everybody is so PC anymore. Good job.

@biointeractive

5 жыл бұрын

You don't mess around when it comes to bears.

@whatabouttheearth

3 жыл бұрын

Hardly anyone is that PC. You may be infuenced by media that gives a false perception of most peoples mentalities (aka politically ideological)

@evanwademan5602

2 ай бұрын

This is why having a good science education is crucial in the modern world. I’m glad that evolution is taught where I live, & that I learned it through the internet growing up.

Neil Shubin! MA MAN NEIL!

imagine- there are spectacular fossils of all sorts all over the earth that we will never find..

awesome

I'm watching these for fun actually

Watched all of it

WOW to the knowledgde and video skills!!!!

@biointeractive

3 жыл бұрын

Glad you liked it!

👏 amazing

the sassy lil walk of the animated tetrapod

Very interesting stuff

@biointeractive

2 жыл бұрын

Glad you think so!

건국대 수의예과 1학년 동물학 수강자 여러분 모두 화이팅하세요~!

I am here from school lol

Grandkids will see this later today.

Kenn Borek Air, the "Mighty Worker" of high latitude flying services!

Those looking for updates, lots of additional details were added in his recent #mindscape88 interview with Sean Carroll. Cheers!

Yay!

so, we are all fish....my dog is a fish, myself is a fish, my chickens in the backyard are fish....dang lol

@jeanetteyork2582

6 жыл бұрын

No...all tetrapods are descendants of fish. DESCENDANTS are not exactly like their ancestors. What he's showing is where the one bone, two bones, many bones, digits pattern for limbs came from. 0

@1984potionlover

6 жыл бұрын

Pretty much...Tetrapod evolution's pretty much been the story of "Pimp My Fish". Technically you can go further back than just tetrapodal vertebrates..But "Pimp my Eukaryote Cell" doesn't roll so trippingly off the tongue,and gives too many possible options ;)

@williamchamberlain2263

6 жыл бұрын

Nancy Cousintine - I'm going to start calling it Darwin's Theory of Pimp My Fish

@williamchamberlain2263

6 жыл бұрын

Jeanette York the usage in day-to-day categories is different from in cladistics - day-to-day a rabbit isn't a fish, but evolutionarily a rabbits are a sub-sub-sub-....-sub-group of a particular type of fish and is therefore a fish.

@rondoclark45

5 жыл бұрын

@@1984potionlover "Pimp My Prokaryote" has a ring to it though.

3:51 that is called 'The Principal of Faunal Succession'.

Birds are dinosaurs

Re piola el video

The most insane thing is that when everyone called darwin crazy the proof was waiting to be discovered in the ground.

👍👍

How could an animal get more complex than tetrapodal vertebrates?

Anyone else have to watch this for class?

& we in to space..wow!

dr is strapped

it's 5 year already, but why is he holding that Tiktaalik like that?

@fredvenne9563

13 күн бұрын

Great Question. Dr. Shubin is holding a cast/reproduction in the video. This is very helpful for teaching purposes. The original type specimen would be much too fragile.

We find living things organized into groups that are themselves organized into groups. Every significant way that a lungfishes body is similar to a humans body, a frogs body is similar to ours in all those same ways but also in several more ways. And every significant way that a frogs body is similar to ours, a platypuses body is similar to ours in all those same ways, but then also in several more ways. And in every significant way a platypuses body is similar to ours, an opossums body is similar in all the same ways but also in several more ways. And I’m most significant ways an opossums body is similar to ours, a lions body is similar to ours in all those same ways but also in several more ways. And every significant way a lions body is similar to ours, a lemurs body is similar to ours in all those same ways but also in several more ways. And in every significant way a lemurs body is similar to ours, a baboons body is similar in all those same ways but also in a few other ways as well. And in every significant way that a baboons body is similar to ours, a gibbons body is similar to ours in all the same ways but several more ways as well. And in most significant ways a gibbons body is similar to ours, a bonobos body is similar in all those same ways but then also similar in a few other significant ways as well.

Jason who ?

So we come from a sort of salamander

If these people knew about metamorphosis or if they got to see a platypus... I think their heads would explode. ...

Isn't it Andrias davidianus?

It looks like a Gar Fish

were all related to a fish lmao

Snakes and whales are tetrapods :)

Sir this type fish my hous

The first colonisers.

IS THAT A SHOTGUN!!!!!!!!!! 7:45

@biointeractive

4 жыл бұрын

Bear country!

@mace6003

4 жыл бұрын

@@biointeractive oh

@whatabouttheearth

3 жыл бұрын

Mossberg 500 or Remington 870

All life land animals come from fish

@Rerbun

7 ай бұрын

No, 4 limbed vertebrates come from fish, all invertebrates come from their watery ancestors

If they want to know why or what motivated the Tiktaalik behaviors, cross compare that to a Snakehead fish or any number of such fish that can and do crawl out of the water, use their fins like feet, care for their young and what causes them to go on land in the first place. Mysteries over and its simple. Its also not the only"fish with those features. Take how everyone was making claims about coelacanth fish as the ancestor of all land animals. Everyone claimed they were extinct millions of years ago and now we see there are two species of them that still exist and they do not walk on land. Look at whales that are said not to have started in the water but on land and that is only claimed because whales still exist. The reality is things have been moving to and from the land and water since life began. worms were among the first species and they were and are found in all bodies of water, a rare species in ice called ice worms and in the soil. We have insects in water and on land as well that are said to have evolved from worms and another line evolved into fish, etc. They ignore the fact that kind of evolution in the water was occurring on the land as well and the have no clear evidence because worms don't fossilize well due to soft tissues Yet they dont acknowledge land insects could have evolved on the land from land based worms? And worms evolved from what, and those evolved from what? Germs. And germs are found everywhere as well even in deep rock, still alive and doing all their little microbial stuff. SO tracing all life to one source is trying to force a linear structure into a "tree" and ignoring its many roots, but also ignoring the fact life does not fork out and follow a tree pattern. Its chaotic, and is more like a tangled web with no single point and having many innumerable cross points back and forth at different times for all sorts of diverse and known as well as unknown reasons. Even if we look just at the related human ancestors and cousin species, there have been many changes, cross sectioning, extinctions, and so forth of so called evolution and devolution.

reminds me of a crocodile

I love his desire and enthusiasm. However, he just discovered another animal.

@spatrk6634

Жыл бұрын

i mean yea. its another animal. just happens to be that this animal is possible candidate for being ancestor of all four limbed animals

show

Hello world!

@natttemantv1977

4 жыл бұрын

Online classes?

So much effort when you just have to pick up an old book and find out whatever is necessary to know.. ;)

Who's here from science class

who is here for science class?

I like fish sticks.

0:57 MORE LIKE “HE BALDLY PREDICTED” AHAHAHA

@kennethsatria6607

6 жыл бұрын

Denise Thasder well done...

Ok, but where are the transitional fossils?

@ReubenCohn

5 жыл бұрын

You mean, like Tiktaalik?...

"The origin of four-legged animals" They were popped into existence by a genius.

H

sHouToUt tO miDdLe sChOol kIdS wAtcHiNg tHiS

😡 Each SPECIES of animal . . . ! Correct vocabulary is essential in scientific presentations, as elsewhere. Deduct ten marks for carelessness.

Can we please depict Darwin as a more attractive person!? I can't stand to look at the character you guys created. :P

who wants the answers for 8th grade science lol

Not funny. Also didn’t laugh

How do you explain the Cambrian period then when many groups of animals suddenly appeared full formed out of nowhere? There was no transitioning from anything that had gone before. So it is not true to say that evolution accounts for how animals evolved in small incremental changes and steps since there are no transitional fossils before various groups of animals appeared already fully formed.

@dancingnature

4 жыл бұрын

The Cambrian animals evolved from Precambrian animals . What you see during the Cambrian is the evolution of hard body parts

@corporateturtle6005

2 жыл бұрын

@@jimwills2094 Speaking of "propaganda" how's that book of fables you worship, the bible?

@willw5868

Жыл бұрын

really simple actually Ro. Precambrian fossils do exist, they are just MUCH rarer because mineralized tissue (the part of animals that fossilizes well) did not really exist in the animals of that period. The Cambrian explosion is not animals "appearing", it is just them evolving from animals which did not fossilize well and thus are very rare in the fossil record. Hence the lack of transitional forms.

Evolution is a lie created by Satan" is a lie created by creationists. Oops, I forgot to put the opening quotation mark.

@bpstve3130

7 жыл бұрын

answersingenesis.org/geology/carbon-14/doesnt-carbon-14-dating-disprove-the-bible/

@HaydenTheEeeeeeeeevilEukaryote

7 жыл бұрын

Frogger 81 Carbon dating is unreliable for things that are old. Radiometric dating is the big umbrella, and that disproves it if you use certain elements. Radiometric dating isn't the only thing you can use, though. I have a question: If all of the animals were created at the same time/day, then why do we find that the layers of the earth separate the fossils between time?

@robrosen7291

5 жыл бұрын

Satan is a lie created by uneducated, superstitious Pagans with an agenda. First, they scare you, and keep you in fear. Then they offer you a safety net and protection. If you follow their rules, and tithe faithfully, they'll keep that bad ol' Devil away. If you give them more, you're even holier and get better protection. It's all about money. Your money to them to keep the fear at a low level. If you stray and don't give them enough money, well then Lucifer starts nipping at your toes again.

@evanwademan5602

2 ай бұрын

Why would would god or satan put so much effort into creating this “lie” when most people will never notice? Also we can apply our knowledge of evolutionary biology to other fields, such as creating new medicine & determining how closely related particular species are. But you can’t do that with creationism, its always “evolution is just a theory” & about proving an entire field of science false

I still strongly believe the natures target animal was a bird not the four legged creature. The animal design of heart & lungs coordination with rib cage expansion and pulling in air with every stroke during all stages of flight does not match to any other movement so perfectly plus the the control of flight through end of wing digits and perching on branches n hunting animals and bringing to mouth to bite is not as perfect elsewhere as in bird life. We gets feet spasm by trying to grab something in fear or pleasure also resemble birds. I think we’re wrongly trying to prove the evolution backward or by matching the pictures we found instead of looking at the bigger picture of reading the mind of the creator. “It” might have wanted the bird and not the fish, frog or monkey! Think about it! Mhmd!

@walkergarya

11 ай бұрын

Your lies do not refute Evolution.

Basically, it comes down to a pattern. From the start, for those that believe the creation of the universe came about by natural means have set their pattern. Their pattern to believe in the impossible. They set their pattern for no matter how illogical and unscientific it is, they'll still accept it. We all do stupid things. Hopefully, we admit them and learn from them. It's not a matter of who's smarter; it's a matter of who loves truth more. For those that don't love truth, you can find reasons to believe anything; you'll find excuses for what you want to believe. For others though, like myself, I don't care what I want to believe. I care about what I should believe and why. It's easier said than done, but in the end well worth it. I just don't want to remain stupid.

@jonathanjones770

5 жыл бұрын

How is a natural explanation impossible?

@ReubenCohn

5 жыл бұрын

I would also like to know how a natural explanation is impossible? Everything else we have ever observed has turned out to have a natural explanation.

Good that we don´t have two mouths…and only one ear… WHYYYY do you not see the Designer behind the design??

@jonathanjones770

5 жыл бұрын

We have a practical form because natural selection necessitates one

@rockanderson1823

5 жыл бұрын

If I'm God's chosen, why create me after 4.5 Billion years? Why create me about 500 Million years after multicell life began? If we need God to create us, who created God? And what gave God the knowledge of physics? And if God doesn't need other thing to create him, then the same can be said of us. And if we had two mouths and only one ear...where's the problem there?

@FreedomAnderson

4 жыл бұрын

Lack of evidence supporting their existence.

Jesus Christ is the only way to heaven ✝️

@evanwademan5602

2 ай бұрын

Ok… I’m not sure why that would justify denying a cornerstone of modern biology & genetics tho… You can still believe in god & accept evolution tho

Ken Ham has different explanation

@biointeractive

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah they're different all right.