the girl is complaining to God. and the guy is singing what God would respond to such complaints... Its a famous poetry ( MY fav tbh)... Shikwa (human Complaint) and Jawab e Shikwa (reply to the complaint by God) are combined and shortened in this song.... This poetry is written by world's famous Allama Muhammad Iqbal aka Poet of the East.

@musmanminhas9702

2 жыл бұрын

And Allama Iqbal studied in germany and there is post doctoral chair in university of Heidelberg, and where Iqbal stayed is preserved there and Iqbal Ufer in Iqbal’s name. Germans love him.

@study_hub658

2 жыл бұрын

Rightly said 👍

@study_hub658

2 жыл бұрын

@Cojak_Rap you should listen to it again now to get proper understanding of the shikwa/jawab-e-shikwa

@syedtahaiqbal51

Жыл бұрын

Well elaborated

The first part of the song is actually a complaint (shikwa) by human/muslim to Allah (GOD) which is sung by the Natasha Baig, Female singer. The second part is the answer of that complaint by GOD (Jawab-e-shikwa) sung by Fareed Ayaz & Abu Muhammad Qawwal. These are two separate poem which were written back in 1924. You can find the english explanation of these poem on Internet very easily

@mirzah1162

Жыл бұрын

I guess 1913/1914

It is a "complaint" that is written in the voice of human-beings. And then, response to "complaint" written in the voice of God. Its poetry of Muhammad Iqbal.

The female part of song is the complain of poor Muslims towards Allah And the Male part is considered as the Answer from Allah

Honestly this is a tough song to digest for those who don’t understand the background, poetry, and language. The qawwali singers have plenty of wonderful coke studio tracks that are more easily digested, if you will. I’d check out aadam or kangna, much less to interpret and the music is more enjoyable to sit back and take in

@das2222

2 жыл бұрын

Seconded

@legendofnothing1

2 жыл бұрын

"piya ghar aaya" from the same season as well

These sentences are from the poetry of. Poet of The East.. The "Sir" Dr. Allama Muhammad Iqbal... From book "بانگ درا"

It's a masterpiece and i really love you reacted on it ❤

Beautiful reaction as always.

Hey bro, this is like conversation between Muslim and Allah. Female part is a complaint to Allah (God) and the male part is answer of complaint from Allah(God). And this actually about the era of "Ottoman empire".

I admire your patience in reaction

Muslims (humans) are very much allowed to question, and Allah answers all the question through the holy book Quran. And through the life of Prophet Muhammad PBUH.

I loved that u tried your best to understand this masterpiece. I remember the first time listening to this, I was also completely blank. Reason being that I was not familiar with Iqbal's work. Also bcz this poem was simply written in Farsi(Persian). Farsi is a language that has been used by the Muslims of the SUB-CONTINENT for centuries but as time passed, muslims picked on Urdu rather than Farsi. I being a Millennium Pakistani am not very much familiar with Farsi but my Dad is. He gave me some insights of this masterpiece and the rest I researched on my own. I've gotta say brother, Farsi is a beautiful language and this song by Coke Studio is a true masterpiece. Every time I listen to it, I get Goosebumps. I hope to see more of your work, reviewing SUFI music. Next plz do 'BOL HU'.

@cojakrap

2 жыл бұрын

Bol Hu I already did. Next coming up is 99 names asma ul husna.

Thanks bro for Reacting♥️♥️

I am from Bangladesh and I love this song very much.

Man I was going to comment u to react to this song and I just saw this

mashallah beautiful reaction 💚💖

Shikwa = complaint Jawab= answer Jawab e shikwa = answer to complaint. These are two poems written by Philosipher poet Muhammad Iqbal around 1920s. He is our Goethe equivalent, who did his phd in germany (munich and heidelberg) theres even a street named after him in heidelberg. Iqbal uffer. The first part is shikwa, complaint of disheartened state of muslims in world. The second part jawab e shikwa, is the answer from God, on why the believers are in sorrow state.

Writer of Shikwa and Jawab e Shikwa, Mr. Iqbal lived most part of his life in germany and did hi PhD from Munich University.

So Beautiful Song

This song is out of this world.🔥 Unfortunately you will never understand the depth of this song :(

@edwardspencer9397

2 жыл бұрын

Only for muslims. For all other religions this is shallow.

@sharpshootercs

Жыл бұрын

@@edwardspencer9397 lmfao “shallow” I speak the language and even for me there’s too much for me to analyze and explain each line due to its poetry nature. I get it you read English, which is shadow version of it…but this is anything but “shallow”

@Aquacrystal78

Жыл бұрын

@@edwardspencer9397 You haven't studied it in it's Original Language.Eastern Language have words with depth of meaning.

the original poetry is 20+ pages long, (In qawali form it is 1 hour long) in which a man is complaining to god about the sorry state of the "east" and "muslim world" and then the second half is basically a reply to those complains from the god's perspective. It was written when most the muslim world was under colonial rule

Hey nice reaction but there are few problems with understanding this 1 These are two very long poems Shikwa ( Complaint) and the other one is Jawab e Shikwa (The Answer) both by Dr. Iqbal. They have sung hardly 2% of the full poems so naturally its hard to make any sense with that. 2 There is whole islamic history and beliefs and situation of Muslims in early 20th century in the background which you are not familiar with. 3 Translation is not the best sometimes one word have a full history lesson or a story behind it so it becomes very hard to translate. 4 Even those people who have Urdu as there native language and have some background knowledge find it hard to understand because it's in classical Urdu. BTW Even if you consider the craftsmanship only poems are no less then master pieces, well they are narrated by Zia Mohiuddin sahab with explanation in English if you wish to hear the full versions.

Bro believe me there is great real stories behind every sentence.

I really loved your reaction cuz you not only enjoy the music but also go deep to understand the lyrics. Infidels are non believers of Allah.

Poet is Dr. Iqbal (poet of the east), studied in Munich, Germany in 1907 German Scholar Ms. Annmarie Schimmel a German professor worked on Sufisim and Dr. Iqbal

First part is compliant to God... And second part God's reply to that complaint. That's written by Pakistan's famous poet Allama Muhammad Iqbal. This is called shikwa (complain) jawab e shikwa(reply to the complaint). This not the full poetry but few verse... And His poetry is so difficult and even for urdu speaking.. Don't worry if you don't get some words because his some words contains a history, without knowing the back ground it hard to understand Bro I recommend you, to check history of songs like this. What it actually about Unfortunately you took many things wrong

@daimgamingchannel6054

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly bro love you ❤

@BATMAN-ys3re

2 жыл бұрын

@@daimgamingchannel6054 ❤️

LOL BRO, I LOVED THIS REACTION. I WANT YOU TO REACT ON THESE RANG , CHAAP TILAK, AAFREEN AAFREEN, BOL HU - COKE STUDIO

Re singing this song is the biggest sin of coke studio. It's original ,sing at ptv is one and only masterpiece one could ever hope for.

Please I am requesting again, react to these 2 Coke studio performances from these qawali Brothers. Aadam and Kangna

My favourite ❤️

Shikwa and jawab e shikwa were from two books written by the Greatest poet of the East. Allama Iqbal before the partition of India when it was a british colony, muslims were weak so he wrote shikwa(complaint) to God in which he complaint about all the things which os a big poem and only a very small part is in the song, so clerics and scholars of islam ruled him as an outsider and in return Allama Iqbal wrote Jawab e Shikwa(God's Answer) that why muslims are weak now and God reminded them their glorious past. These two books are a masterpiece they have such big impact on society that made revolution. IQBAL died in 1938. In 1940 Pakistan resolution was passed and in 1947 we got out independence from British Rule. So these shikwa and jawab e shikwa has a very big importance in the awakening of Pakistani muslims.

You are an intelligent and curious person.Why don't you study Islam. Our sufi poetry is rich in everything language, thoughts and emotions and it drives its expression mostly from our religion Islam. I have seen many reactions but you are very keen and I admire it.

this was written by dr iqbal poet philosopher,who is very deep in Heidegger and Nietzsche the german philosphers!! its a bit political poetry where iqbal was trying to motivate muslims to not loose heart following the decline and loss of muslim power!! trust allah be strong and muslim still has the potential to change the world and write destinies of nations!!

Master Master Master Poetry...Bravo

When it talks about slavery at 13:27 it doesn't only mean Slavery in literal sense. Although Islam did eliminated Slavery through reforms. It makes more sense to regard that slavery in this masterpiece poetry (Kalaam) as to the slavery that Humans were in at that time and still are; the slavery of Self. Becoming a slave to the desires of your heart and things that makes no sense (idols) and are temporary like Money, Health, Power, Popularity etc. Islam means surrendering your wills to the wills of Allah, rightly so, that is slavery, but Islam also means Peace. In a whole sense Islam means Peace through Surrender. That's why you see so many reference regarding slavery in lyrics of Coke Studio's songs. It's not in bad way as it seems. When you look at all the things that a Human becomes a slave of, it is because he think it will give him Peace but it doesn't always happen that way and often it becomes an headache. In the Answer to the Complaint, Allah counter question his devotee (Muslim) that "who freed mankind from slavery of Idols and Self?" So to remind his devotee that it was his generous gift in form of Islam that liberated/freed Human Race from becoming a Slave of something that can't give them peace. Also, Allah indirectly answers that it wasn't your strength that did my job of freeing Human Race from slavery, it was my generosity and the revolutionary idea of Islam that did so. The Devotee (Muslim) itself is part of Human Race, He (Arrogant) thinks he has done Allah some favor by believing in him and doing his part? The Muslim himself would've been in darkness like others if it weren't for the mercy and generosity of Allah. And Allah continues to Answers the point raised by Muslim Devotee through many perspectives and examples....It's just amazing.

Annemarie Schimmel, find out her work in german about the writer of this poetry. Allama Iqbal had a very intimate connection with Germany. You'll have better understanding of what the poet was trying to say.

I feel they didn't exactly put what Iqbal wrote in jawab e shikwa (answer of complaint)

Shikwa(complaint) is the female part And jawab e shikwa(answer to complaint) is the male part

This may of interest for you, the poet Dr. Iqbal got his doctorate from Germany in 1920s...

Ive memorised this whole poem (Shikwa) means (question /complain) (which was written as Muslim complaining God (Allah) (the female part of this song) and its 2nd part is "(Jawab e Shikwa) means answer to complaints from God (Allah) (the male part of this song) in my primary and it is actually written. By famous poet "Allama Iqbal" in Pakistan. Coke studio have amended and combined both of the poems abit. There is a whole history about this poem. And let me tell you every relegious song is not a prayer. Muslims dont pray while beating drums and playing guitar or anyother musical instrument. This poem was written in times when Pakistan was fighting for its freedom from India and british people. I cant tell you the whole story here. This poem "Shikwa"was actually about a debate between a Muslim complaining to God (Allah) And then in "Jawab e Shikwa" God (Allah) give response to that Muslim.

first part is about shikwa(complaint) that is sung by the lady and the next part is jawab e shikwa (response to a complaint) sung by the men...both poetries were written by Allama Iqbal but they are originally very long. The concept of shikwa is that the poet is complaining to Allah that why muslims today are in bad condition despite being the believer in one true God that is Allah and the poet is giving all sort of references that we did this and we did that for Your sake but now You are not helping us and we are in a devastated state.... then in jawab e shikwa the poet replies to his own complaint on behalf of God ..and God is saying that yes your ancestors were successful because they obeyed me and did hardwork and used their brains...but you are sitting with your hands closed and waiting for a miracle..there is no useful skill you have acquired etc

You should read shikwa and jawab e shikwa and their explanation

Good luck to you understanding the intricacies of the poetry of the song. Its a dialogue between man and God. This has history and religion and philosophy all in one.

This is u can say a conversation between Helpless, oppressed, Poor Muslims and Allah... Muslims are complaining to Allah why we are in this condition even though , they were us who kept Ur Quran in hearts and also they were us who fought wars for your sake..etc? And they get response from Allah that...O yes! Ur right, they were your "forefathers"(they got reward of what they did) but who are you? What you want and what you are doing? Why are you hopeless even though I've promised to give..you should do what you are supposed to and you'll definitely get the reward... *Shikwa* means complaint and *jawab e shikwa* means answer to that complaint

@Cojak Rap there was a person named Mirza Galib who wrote this poetry named shikwa jawab e shikwa in this poetry we have 2 parts in first one is the girl is singing in which she is complaining to God (ALLAH) and the Second part where mans are singing (ALLAH) is replying on this complain

First part was "shikwa" means complaint(it's a human complaint to Allah) Second part was "jawab e shikwa" means answer to that complaint (Allah's response/answer to that complaint)

Hey please react to sab Maya ha and Jind mahiya both are by coke studio and are underrated . You will love em

Some facts. These qawwals are so talented that they can sing in this energy for hours and they dont even need rehearsals... React to "Rang" the last kawwali of Amjad Sabri...he was murdered before its release...

@cojakrap

2 жыл бұрын

Rang is on my channel my friend, I liked it a lot.

I hope I can give you the answers of all of your questions..May Allah enlighyen your heart with the light of Eman..

💖🔥🔥🔥

If you have questions let us know and we will be happy to answer. Also you can listen to Dr. Zakir naik lectures to understand more about Islam.

Please react on paar chanaa de coke studio Pakistan. You will love music and lyrics in this song.

the point where the kalam shifted from female to males from there The Allah started speaking to answer the complaint,

the song is actually a property by legendary Alama Iqbal (Shikwa/Jawab-e-Shikwa) -Shikwa means "Complaint" Jawab-e-Shikwa means "Answer to the complaint" The First Half the female singer singing is Shikwa, so actually, she is compelling to Allah, And send half singed by the male vocolists is Asnwer by Allah to the complaint.

The female singer is complaining to god for the poor condition of Muslim in the today's world. She is reminding the god,the favours of Muslims. The male singer is replying the complaint from the God. He told that Muslims did believe in just God. The Muslims had unity in old daysbut nowadays the Muslims has not unity. Your ancestors were rulers because they have unity and believe in just one god. Your present condition is because of your activities of disgracing your oiwnself and disbelief. God always return better than expectations. These are two poems" complaint" and "answer of complaint"written by the "poet of east",Allama Muhammad Iqbal. It was written in about 1924. It was that time when Pakistan did not comf into existence and Muslims in that areas were in very poor conditions. Just respect to poet as well as singers. ❤

Shikwa (complaint by human being to God) jawab e Shikwa (answer to the human complaint by God)

please send me the link to your song at the beginning of the reaction

@cojakrap

Жыл бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/h5uE06d9ndrKm8o.html

The part of song that was sung by females was complain of believer to God. While the other part of song sung by Male singers is Reply of God to the complain of believer.

Sikhwa means complaint. Jawab e sikhwa means answering the complaint. The first part is believers or humans complaining about small things, even though they should be grateful for all they have. The part where the man comes in is the answer given to the people complaining. It’s says more like you complain but you don’t see the things Allah has given you. You only complain about little things. Don’t see the big picture. They answer in place of Allah saying. As long as you believe in Prophet Muhammad (saw) I will always be with you. It doesn’t matter if you have sinned a 1000 times. As long as you come back Allah will forgive you. It doesn’t matter if you’re a non believer. When you become a believer Allah will be there for you. This was not really a sad song. More a conversation of devotees. This however was a hard song to understand if you don’t have a lot of knowledge about religions or Islam. If you have any more questions. Just ask. We are happy to help you understand. Like always love from Amsterdam 🌺

They question with Allah. ALLAH IS GIVING ANSWERS

The main message is to believe in the Last messenger Prophet Muhammad PBUH, and when you do that the entire universe will be yours.

This is only a small part of Iqbal's complaint and its reply. It would be difficult to grasp the whole idea without some context. Basically this is written to answer rationally the complaints of a common devoted muslim.

React to Piya Ghar aaya coke studio version

REACT TO KANGANA COKE STUDIO YOU'LL BE AMAZED BY THEIR PERFORMANCE AND IT'S BEAUTIFUL LYRICS

👑❤💌

Brother again i m requesting you to react on Ali Azmat Song in Karachi Concert

react to Bang e Dara 105 please you will love it...

React to Ae dil kisi ki yaad mein by Ali Zafar Coke studio season 8

THE SECOND PART WHERE MALE SINGERS COMES IN IS THE REPLY FROM ALLAH's SIDE ASKING QUESTIONS AND TELLING US OUR WAYS

The lady singer makes the complain to Allah on behalf of today's Muslims and the male singers are responding on behalf of God . In this poem there are two parts in first part the complain and then reply to complain from God . As since last century Muslims are facing lots of persecution for being Muslims so as a Muslim in the first part there is complain to Allah and in the second part according to the poet the God addresses the Muslims today and God tells Muslims that they are themselves to be blamed for their bad situation as they are not as devoted to walk on the right path as their ancestors were and if they still sincerely follow the true guidance of Allah and His Prophet Muhammad (saw) then they will be so powerful that they will write their own destiny

In 2nd part of song Allah is addressing to Muslims and answering Muslims on his complaints

This particular piece is too deep even for many Muslims to properly understand. It's a master class par excellence kinda poetry by the legendary Allama Muhammad Iqbal. Infidel means non-believers, and somebody has rightly said earlier that one needs to have some prior knowledge of the background and history behind these lyrics. About the qawwals, can you believe that Farid Ayaz (with cap) sings live with "Paan" (beetle leaves) in his mouth!!.

to understand this poetry you need to study a lot because this poetry was written by great philosopher and the poet of east dr M allama Iqbal. germans used to follow his philosophy to motivate youth. for further information about this poetry you can contact me brother any time. the song is based on two parts 1st is questions to Allah and 2nd is answers from Allah. either you are jew christian or muslim have to believe in ALLAH the only GOD.

The girl is complaining Allah, that we Muslims spread your oneness and spread Islam, while the male ones is answering her, that those were your ancestors not you( recent Muslims) that spread Islam . its the part of bang e Dara book from Allam Iqbal. he mentioned in it, complain and answer from God from his knowledge to make recent Muslims to understand and practice Islam the way their ancestors did.

Plz check out "Aatish" by coke studio.

please react on Mahi overload in coke studio season 6

The first bit of the song is a complaint and the other bit is a reply to the complaint

Allah does not need us we need him

NESCAFE BASEMENT season 6 [SAWAL/ KANDEY UTTE]

This poem is written by The Great poet of East. Dr Muhammad Illama Iqbal 1877 _ 1938. He is Pakistan’s national poet. Most of his poetry is related to Sufism and Patriotism. Because during his time. Muslims were struggling for independence from Britain. His poetry provoked the courage of Muslims to fight for their freedom. We Asians especially people of subcontinent respect him a lot. And I don’t like the way these singers turned this sophisticated piece of poetry into such a savage performance. If they really knew the message given by Illama Iqbal through this poem. They wouldn’t have dared to ruin it. But your reaction is honest. Al though you don’t know the background of this poem. Still you try to comprehend the message. I appreciate that. 👍🏼

in this first half they were complaining in the second half( males part )allah answered that complain

It's all about. Muslims not for non-believers..

Please react to ‘Aadam’ by Fareed Ayaz.

Its the Most Famous Poetry of Great Eastren Poet Allah Muhammad Iqbal.

Dude first part is a complaint by the people, and the second part is Allah answering them.

You need to understand the history behind this poem, as explained in the comments its shorter version. But when u read the translation of the original poem and also understand the history then it will be easy to understand. U gotta put some effort for the answers . Peace . From pakistanis

Please react on pardadari by abida Parveen and Atif Aslam

Please react to "ao ehd karain Pakistan day special" ❤❤❤

Hi dear, this is written by a poet called iqbal. I will summarise it in one of his couplet. O Lord your free men are not so free. In this world its a compulsion to die And in hereafter its a compulsion to live.

Dear u listen same vocals in the voice of Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan with english translate first u listen Complaint (Shikwa) Then Answer of Complaint from God (Jwab E Shikwa) then u understand .

Hello kojac, nice reaction, but i can see the lyrics was confusing for you but you tried your best, though i like this one but if i were to recommed you something i wouldn't this one to you because its too lyrical for you to understand specially when you listen to it for very first time and have no idea that who they are addressing and how two poems are mixed here and the background of the poems, i see people in every comment told you about the poems so you must know by now but in this song the male singers part was a little long and a little boring and was not the best lines from the poem however the end was the soul of it, if you could read a few lines online you would know as you looked like having some questions unanswered,

Please don't take it negative it was just complaint and feelings of broken heart to God.

React to garaj baras Rahat Fateh Ali Khan coke studio

I get your confusion tbh. I am a Muslim but the response from God was posed as extremist in my opinion. It felt more like a condemnation of any person who decides to not follow God and he will be in hell forever (kind of like a threat). But this is the first time i am listening to the song, maybe the hidden message is clearly delivered in the language that it was actually written in (persian). I am a devoted Muslim, but every time Allah is presented as threatening, i sense that something can be wrong. The response from God seemed more like a threat than a response

plz reaction this 🥺❤️ Sina Sae - Toolani (Live performance )🇮🇷

Tepki - "HA ŞUNU BİLEYDİN" (prod. by Faruk Çeliker) [Official Music Video] react please

It is more of a complaint by the Muslim community to Allah. The Muslims, who are religious and follow the commandments of god are asking why all the troubles and disasters are happening mostly with the Muslims. Why those who truly worship Allah are poor and being oppressed. They are remembering about their great past in agony, when God was merciful to them and showered them with his blessings and power.

The first part of the Song is Complaint . The Second Part is Gods Answer to the complaint

Second half God is answering to people who complain

Read Iqbal