A reply vid: kzread.info/dash/bejne/e6OWpNideNG0qrA.html

Richard stating indirectly to Neville that “mainline celebrities going there for big cheques”. The look on Neville’s face. 😂

@SirReginaldBumquistIII

6 ай бұрын

It didn't show Neville's face when Richard said that.

To your point at the end of the video, Ian Hislop isn't a BBC employee so he can't 'quit the BBC'. There is also a very big difference between the BBC showing the game and him being on a completely different TV with nothing to do with football that happens to be on the same channel and Gary Neville being directly paid by the Qatari government to commentate on the match.

@NewsWagg

Жыл бұрын

He can quit the show, that is being shown on the BBC. If the game is shown on the BBC then those on the BBC are making money from it. In the same way if a country hung people and a TV station showed the films, they are still profiting off the hangings This is the point, it is a case of I am old right jack, but your in the wrong. I am correct in what I do, but others are not. Everyone is a hypocrite. I am not as I hate football.

@PlatformNo14

Жыл бұрын

@NewsWagg the BBC doesn't make directly via broadcasting and nor do they make a profit. They are a public service broadcaster funded by a TV licence. Ian Hislop is paid by this licence fee, and HIGNFY is also funded by this licence. Being paid by the BBC to host a completely unrelated programme to the WC is not in any way comparable to being paid vast sums of money directly by the Qatari government. It's bad faith arguing to attempt to draw an equivalence between the two when none exists.

@bletheringfool

Жыл бұрын

@@NewsWagg the point of HIGNFY being made by and independent production company is to have editorial independence from the broadcaster. Yeah it is a grey area for sure but Hislop didn't take cash directly from them (Qatar) so that, I guess is what his argument would be.

@davidbowie50yearsofbowiean23

Жыл бұрын

@@PlatformNo14 during the apartheid, when the US came out in condemnation towards the South African government, many African American employees of various federal agencies quit in a move praised by various civil right organisations. The mini exodus of African American employees of the federal government was down to the fact that the US had condemned South Africa but had yet to take any economic action against them and continued doing business with them as if it was still the 50s. Now if these African American employees could see the principle in not working for an organisation that still did business with supposed evil, even if they did not receive any actual profit from south Africa as individual employees, then so could Ian Hislop. And therefore, no, It isn't a bad faith argument to expect such principled behaviour from Ian Hislop, especially when he expects principled behaviour from everyone around him. So get off your high horse.

@thesampsoninstitute

Жыл бұрын

shut it

I disagree with you there. It's hypocritical for Neville to complain about a country while still making money from them. It's not hypocrtical for Hislop to complain about Qatar while making no money from them. The BBC makes its money from license fees, not viewing figures, and they won't make any money from Qater. Who will be paying a license fee just for the world cup coverage?

@HeyZeus667

Жыл бұрын

Hislop doesn't do anything for LGBTQ outside of complaining about someone else getting paid by a government that has anti LGBTQ laws and culture.

@vis7139

Жыл бұрын

@@HeyZeus667 I'm guessing you don't read Private Eye...

@mallan3024

6 ай бұрын

@@dingopisscreekno because that’s how a holocaust happens mate. By keeping quiet and not speaking up either as a coward or as someone who doesn’t care because it’s not happening to them. Punishing people for their sexuality between two consenting adults is a human rights violation and needs to be called out by the whole world in order to put pressure on the oppressors that it’s not ok what they’re doing. If you just stay quiet then nothing changes.

I think the important point here that nobody seems to have pointed out is that Gary Neville is a bell end

@tb5226

7 ай бұрын

A massive one at that.

Ian is bringing up relevant points as are many of the other panel members. you on the other hand are not for the reasons listed elsewhere in the comments section. Also thank you for posting this snippet from the show.

"The surprising thing is not that every man has his price but how low it is" Napoleon Bonaparte

Hislop isn’t employed by the BBC, he’s an independent contractor. Also, Hislop isn’t taking the Qatari blood money whilst at the same time complaining about the source of said money. Neville on the other hand was being paid by the Qatari government (indirectly) to commentate there. Hislop’s job as a journalist and political satirist is to call out hypocrites like Neville for what they are, which is exactly what he’s doing here

About bloody time someone said something!

Just say "I want the money"

@_Shadbolt_

Жыл бұрын

Or "My entire life has been about football and I want to go to the World Cup". It's probably just as accurate.

BS. Madeley would be over there in a second if they wanted an Alan Partridge rip-off.

Think your point is throwing the baby out with the bath water. You could take it one step further, England are playing in it so you would leave the country. Gary is having a direct financial benefit from the World Cup and presents himself as a voice of the working class. For me his issue is being deluded enough to go on a satirical news programme with no comeback to this

Back when I was an IT contractor. I was offered a contract with a religious organization. It was well paid, and it was a 2 yearlong contract it would have been good for my career. I turned it down for ethical reasons, the head-hunting agency explained but you're not doing anything religious, you are just looking after their infrastructure and rolling out new software. Me, the more I learned just how filthy rich they are when they are meant to be a religion makes me angrier and I will not assist them, I am sorry. Now the thing is, I'm no one special, they got someone else to take the roll. But I don't care, I would have been helping them, I would have been investing my time and I would have been financially rewarded. Perhaps I am an idiot, perhaps I was a virtue signalling fool. Doesn't really matter, you either have values or you don't!

@easterneye2773

Жыл бұрын

Stop lying just to get likes your cringe mate now do one IT boy 🤣🤣

@soulunknown1

Жыл бұрын

What ethical reasons? What makes you think your ethics are correct and another’s is wrong? Who set the measure to rule by? What exactly did you learn about “they” being filthy rich? And “they” being a religion? Who the hell is they? How are they a religion? A religion is a faith not a person or peoples? Are only atheists allowed to be rich? Someone who’s not attached to any religion? Do religious people need to be poor to meet your satisfaction? Perhaps your an idiot is the understatement of the century…. There’s no substance to what you’ve written to justify any stance let alone one of a boycott 😂 Your values are so superior to the rest of the world… more like your unjustified hate and bias. Just a reminder… us/uk have killed a over a million in the last two decades. Please tell me more about your morals and ethics 👍 Peace out old man

@julielevinge266

Жыл бұрын

If you work for the BBC think it’s more than obvious you have 0 values!!😳

@jochendejager8046

Жыл бұрын

Or more to the point, you either “live by”’your values or you don’t.

@void0350

9 ай бұрын

Which religious org? Great morals on your side

The difference with Gary is he is working for a Qatari run business in beIN Sports so its unlikely they will actually give him a chance to speak out against it

@salmafrero4595

Жыл бұрын

Same goes for these anchors they ll never speak against their boss

Man didn’t even google Ian Hislop’s name before ranting on YT about him 😂

Ok, that commentary is completely off.

Noone here has any morals or backbone. It's just all virtue signalling. Don't let them fool you.

Money money, no equality

Everyone knows why Neville went to the world cup not because he wanted to address the injustices from within or any of those lies he is trying to pass off for truth it's because he is skint and was about to lose his hotel

@jsmith4230

Жыл бұрын

Fill it with Albanians. Job sorted.

Who’s this guy chatting at the end

You make a good point at the end. In fact, you showing this clip means you are also indirectly benefiting from the BBC and their broadcasts which include World Cup broadcasts form Qatar. I'm appalled at myself for watching it and at you for having anything to do with it. I am boycotting this channel :D

You could argue that Ian is utilising his BBC appearance to highlight specific issues and ensure his voice is heard

@terryboland3816

Ай бұрын

You mean, get free publicity for his magazine?

Many nations with awful human rights records have hosted the world cup - Russia 2018? The colonising nations of the West really don't have much authority to boycott other nations for not enjoying the bourgeois liberalism our ill-gotten wealth has afforded us. The Qatari Kafala (worker sponsorship) system has its roots in the movement of workers between colonies by the British Empire. Islamic nations were some of the world's most tolerant of LGBTQ rights prior to european colonization. Islamic homophobia has its roots in anti-colonial struggles which pushed Islam to become more fundamentalist and reject liberal values which were imposed upon them externally. The same thing has happened in Christian African nations. The unique response to Qatar's hosting of the World Cup stinks of racism as this the most peripheral nation to ever host it.

They all need the money 😂😂😂

Beckham and Neville have sold out. Pair of hypocrites.

@discodave8412

Жыл бұрын

The hypocrites are the ones who could've done something when the draw was made 12 years ago....and did nothing! No point crying over spilt milk this late in the game

@jakewellard1368

Жыл бұрын

@@discodave8412 You act like it wont make a difference to boycott. If we just all pay to watch it and participate in it then thats gonna let other countries that have terrible issues such as Qatar know as long as they push through the a bit of backlash they will be able to pull off a successful world cup and get what they want.

@discodave8412

Жыл бұрын

@@jakewellard1368 The point I'm making is that action shouldve been taken years ago....we've known about Qatar's human rights record for years, more than enough time to boycott and force FIFA to change the venue, but no one did anything.

@jakewellard1368

Жыл бұрын

@@discodave8412 Yeah you are right Im just saying we should keep talking about it even after the World Cup thats the only way any change will happen try to boycott as much as we can events that are this outright corrupt and inhumane

@discodave8412

Жыл бұрын

@@jakewellard1368 I agree, the only thing we can do now is make sure things like this don't happen again

Why did the BBC put it on In the first place. What about all the to rest? Upper middle class hypocracy at its best

The USA has an appalling human rights and anti gay record, but football clubs, bands, actors and entertainers go there all the time without a peep from anyone Target 'right on' flavour of the month Ian?

The BBC buy the show off a company that makes it. Ian isn't a BBC employee

That’s like saying anyone objecting should leave the country because their licence fee is going partially towards Qatar. How deep do you want to go?

THE MAIN OPTION WOULD BE DONT BUY THEIR FUEL FOR YOUR CARS AS WELL. ENOUGH SAID.

Its all virtue signalling nonsense.

Neville is a hypocrite but he’s going over there to commentate. The singers are going over there to sing. They ain’t going over there beating up gays

Jesus. Wasn't expect Craig Cash to pipe up at the end of the video.

Let's be honest, moaning about the Qatar world cup now is like shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted....the draw was 12 years ago, plenty of time to put pressure on FIFA to change the venue

@SvobodovaEva

Жыл бұрын

there has always been pressure but it didn’t do anything

@discodave8412

Жыл бұрын

@@SvobodovaEva Nowhere near the amount of backlash that’s appeared over the last few days….Qatar’s record on human rights has been appalling for years, yet all these people who have appeared out of nowhere to criticise Qatar recently stayed silent when it happened! The only thing they can do now is to make sure things like this don’t happen for future tournaments

@SvobodovaEva

Жыл бұрын

@@discodave8412 …by talking about it

@PlatformNo14

Жыл бұрын

@discodave84 Who'd have thought there would be more backslash when the WC is actually happening, its on TV, adverts, in the papers, everyone is talking about it. There was always backlash but it stands to reason that backlash would increase the closer to the actual event we got. Your argument is pretty poor.

@baoboumusic

Жыл бұрын

That doesn't mean we should suddenly stop talking about it, does it?

No one said anything about the world cup being in the US when theyve killed over a million people in the middle east in the last 20 years. Qatar having repressive laws is a pretty minor foible compared to that

Hypocrite taking the money and criticising the country

@Dickiemiller179

Жыл бұрын

Gary Neville: "I don't like what you're doing, it's wrong, we shouldn't support it, it doesn't align with my principles, and I won't be attending." Agent from FIFA/Qatar: drops a cheque in front of Gary. Gary Neville: "you son of a bitch I'm in."

When in Rome etc.

Telling a country how to run is obsured and these English lot are lucky to be honest to be called out for racism.

Yea I'm sure he'd love to come back and host it again 😅 Good job BBC

Football Boring. Your voice is being saved. If I have trouble sleeping I'll play it,and I'd be straight off.

Quick poll: people who don't touch any dirty money at all, put your hands up.

Your comment at the end was revealing, we all know that some people dont have a moral spine, however you did not need to make it quite so obvious that you don't.

"football is the most boring thing on he planet" he drolled

You’d take the cash? Yeah, checks out…no scruples detected in any of your content 👍

Now let's have the other prominent ex-footballer Gary back on to face Hislop.

Qatar was the worst world cup ever!

What's with the random voice over at the end which cuts off half the clip? I wanted to hear Ian roast Gary, couldn't give a flying elephant turnip about that mongs self important dribble.

Everyone in the comment section would take the money

@ImNotReallyHereMCFC

Жыл бұрын

Yeah didference is most in comment section aren't rich and need it, he doesn't.

I mean regardless of gay rights, i think if a country has its laws and beliefs, than you have to respect them. They have a modesty policy regardless of whether youre gay or straight. Straight people have to abide by them also. Its not about you being gay, its about you flaunting your rights around, their own citizens dont have them rights. If you dont agree with their policies and laws thats fine. Protest it all you want in your country where you have them rights. But dont moan about 'not being able to go there' because they wont accept you for who they are. They have a zero tolerance to sexual behaviour regardless. And protesting your sexual identity is going against that. Thats it unfortunatly. Personally im straight and im ok woth gay people when they act like normal citizens. But people being openly sexual in public makes me uncomfortable, and being straight im not comfortable watching gay activity, kissing is one thing, but the media have taken it wayyy to far and are making everything more and more explicit and i think explicit straight scenes in films are awkward. But they can turn me on at times, gay scenes are in everything i watch now and there was never that much straight sex, or to them extremes in movies. Now its in every movoe and is irritating me. I dont have a problem with gay people at all, i have a problem with those who push it on me as their identity and make it as known as possible. I dont always make my sexuality apparent in my actions. I live my life and theres much more to it then my identity, and its uncomfortable when people whatever their sexuality push it on me constantly. Thats it, its not really about sexuality, its abkut respecting other peoples beliefs and personal lives, and forcing your way of life on others is not respectful, the same we us pushing ours on yours isnt. Live your life and dont worry about what others do and think. If you was straight youd hate qatar because youd want to be able to hold your wifes hand, we dont protest it though.

@BradleyWindsor1

6 ай бұрын

“I think is a country has its laws and beliefs you have to respect them”. If they are actively discriminating against you and murdering you because of what you are, why would you? You also go on a lot about it being do with with doing stuff in public when that doesn’t really have any correlation. The law about public affection and being homosexual are two separate things. Even if you’re engaging in homosexual activity in private it’s illegal and punishable by death. Which again, why would you be okay with or respect that? “I’m okay with gay people as long as they act like normal citizens” Them being gay has nothing to do with how they act as a person, being gay isn’t a personality type. Unless you’re saying them engaging in gay activity isn’t “normal” in which case that’s just flat out homophobic. No one needs to know you get turned on by sex scenes in movies. Don’t know why you’ve mentioned that, that’s just a weird thing to publicly say and has literally zero correlation to the topic which is about Qatar. “Gay scenes are in everything I watch now”. If that’s the case then that’s solely your own fault as you’re specifically choosing to watch things with them in. Gay scenes aren’t in every tv show/movie/series and if you think they are then you’re just simply wrong. “There was never this much straight sex in movies”. Again just not true, there is absolutely no way there’s more gay sex scenes in media than straight sex scenes, there just isn’t. “That’s it, it’s about respecting other people’s beliefs and personal lives”. Unless your personal life involves being gay in which case we’ll imprison you and sentence you to death. How respectful ay? “Forcing your way of life on others is not respectful”. Just like how they’re forcing their way of life on gay people? “If you was straight you’d hate Qatar because you’d want to hold your wife’s hand, we don’t protest it though”. Don’t know what rock you’re living under because there were protests about it during the build up to the World Cup, so much so that the police were told to be more relaxed about public displays of affection during the duration of the tournament.

The lgbt thing is not the worst of it though. Thousands of migrants died in the construction of the stadiums. They were scammed and treated like slaves before dying in the heat. Thats a dorect result of Qatar geting the world cup. The lgbt stuff would have happened either way.

"I'd take the cash". How sad. I guess many, perhaps most, would. That's even more sad.

Who the fuck is the disembodied voice at the end??

Was Richard cleared of Shoplifting? I can’t remember🧐

Either way it's all virtual signalling and boring. I would be "braver" and more refreshing to hear someone say, "I don't really care about gay rights, not my problem not my fight; respect their traditions like you constantly preach or don't you understand diversity?"

That's the problem, not caring.

Your point at the end of the video is incredibly silly of course. The point of having an independent broadcasting organisation like the BBC is of course that dissent is possible. You CAN criticise your own organization trying to make it better, and you can and MUST be critical on the guests you invite on your show.

The BBC narrative is totally hypocritically obscene. We all know Neville went for the money and who gives a f*ck about his opinion anyway. The BBC could of said we do not agree and not gone. Simple.

What did you highlight or take on neville when you were in Qatar...nothing ....typical labour supporter

Too easy for Hislop.

Isn't he semi retired?

Take the cash,or don't take the cash.But don't take the cash an then try to take them moral high ground as well

Who's the clown at the end who doesn't know what the BBC is?

Don't comment if you have nothing intelligent to add

Ian Hislop is a sad old man

Started watching the World Cup final on ITV but as soon as Neville opened his mouth I switched to BBC, hypocrite.

Very dumb point at the end there. The point is gary was taking money from the qataris. Is Ian taking qatari money? Brainless.

Neville, a classic champagne socialist.

Neville ia an hypocrite.

I think gary neville is the greatest right back of all time

Partridge trying to show the higher ground

I believe a sovereign state has the right to make up their own rules without western ideals being forced on everyone. Their religious country that have warned people to take into consideration their rules

It’s a football World Cup ! Enjoy football

If you cared about anything, had a moral compass of any sort you’d quit the BBC!!!😳

It seems that Ian and the rest are very concerned about gay rights when there is a host on the show who is getting paid by a government that has anti gay laws and culture, but I don't hear about any of them doing anything outside of this to support that agenda, did I miss something.

@eamonreidy9534

Жыл бұрын

For some reason, I don't think Ian is a homophobe the rest of the time

Let's be honest here folks. Gary Neville is one of the top pundits/commentators in the game right now. Millions of people (myself included) have been tuning into the Qatar World Cup and we want the best commentators/pundits available. Fairly simple. If Gary doesn't go, then it's someone worse and he's also been quite vocal about how corrupt Qatar has been.

@bencleary1124

Жыл бұрын

Isn’t that the point?! If it’s someone worse than you’ll tune out? And Qataris might think ooo maybe we should do something about the human rights…

@GG-qx5uc

Жыл бұрын

Sending someone worse is exactly the point.

Best world cup ever, in my opinion. Should have it out there all the time. Haven't enjoyed a world cup asuch since 2002

@Tzukaikari

Жыл бұрын

Sandal shagger

@f0ns0r

Жыл бұрын

What a bullshit, he was a great wc becouse games were lit, not thanks to Qatar. Actually the atmosphère was lame and Qatar slavist country still shouldn't have never hosted that.

@Station9.75

Жыл бұрын

Nice bait mate.

@deckyBWFC91

Жыл бұрын

@@Station9.75 what do u mean??? Ireland was in it 2002, england got far, Brazil played great, Korea did well... Can't remember the 06 WC, and anything better than that shite vuvuzuela racket

@lewanbroski504

Жыл бұрын

@@Station9.75 it was a great world cup tbf

I dont care I just like football who are we to tell other countries how to behave in there own land?

@raynegoaway69

Жыл бұрын

Human

@jimmyhun91

Жыл бұрын

The fact that you can't spell "their", and started a sentence with "I just like football", informs everyone that you are to be ignored. Yeah we should ignore genocide, rape and pedophilia as well...because you know football ⚽️

@django3422

Жыл бұрын

Take that logic further. Who are we to tell other people how to behave in their own land? With that in mind, is it right for a theocratic dictatorship to criminalise and demonise people for being gay? If you think the answer to that is no, should we then not stand in support of gay people in Qatar and speak out for the Qatar government to end their discrimination?

@discodave8412

Жыл бұрын

@@django3422 As much as I agree with a lot of your points, the draw that handed Qatar the World Cup was made in 2010....why wasn't action taken much sooner?

@jdawg3444

Жыл бұрын

@@django3422 its western propaganda. They dont criminalise people for being gay. They criminalise sexual acts in public including homosexual ones. When will the west realise that not everyone wants to live by our intolerant values?

Love Gary Neville! He’s honest, went there AND spoke out which takes balls. Hislop is a snide weakling who’s done plenty for money just like all the other celebs but would never admit it.

This is all a storm in a teacup. I don't see the issue with Neville taking money from Qatar, which I am completely confident he will donate to charity anyway. That way it benefits struggling families here in the UK.

Outstanding Gary Neville! Unlike the rest of the virtue signalling buffoons! Let's make football about football, not politics. 👏

@soulunknown1

Жыл бұрын

What the hell are you talking about? Neville’s been chatting shit for weeks about Qatar and politics. You must be a united fan.

@scerpalman

Жыл бұрын

Sport and politics are massively intertwined, you have to be a moron not to recognise that

@PlatformNo14

Жыл бұрын

News just in, disagreeing with human rights abuses is now virtue signalling and bad.

@saakib26

Жыл бұрын

@@PlatformNo14 It is virtue signalling if it's selective.

@smash461986

Жыл бұрын

@@saakib26 unless it happens to be something you believe in. If abuse was something I was against and I advocated for longer prison sentences but didn't focus on the other 99.9% of world issues, then I would not be virtue signalling.

Well done Gary. In your position, I'd be doing the exact same thing. Nothing wrong with earning money. I think a lot of people criticising are envious of you.

@BigKnobJack69

Жыл бұрын

No, a lot of people have morals, nice to see the people who don’t

@iffy0085

Жыл бұрын

@BigKnobJack69 I'm assuming you used a phone or laptop to write this comment you posted. Where do you think that was made? Do you think that country has the best standards for human rights? We all pick and chose where our morals start, then get pissed off at others when their standards are different to ours. We're all hypocrites to some extent.

@kofisam4106

Жыл бұрын

@@BigKnobJack69 morals? I guess Throwing of bananas at black players is the epitome of high morals in Europe.

@merlinmediagroup

Жыл бұрын

This is always the obtuse retort to such criticism - that it comes from a place of envy, which is just completely missing and failing to actually address the issues in point.

@iffy0085

Жыл бұрын

@@merlinmediagroup what are these issues you're referring to?