Father is the antagonist, not the protagonist.

@PatrickWilliams-ip5wz

5 жыл бұрын

Sage's Rain technically he is both if people consider Ed’s father a protagonist ig

@efrentorresjunior8954

5 жыл бұрын

Lol no

@winsonxie3179

5 жыл бұрын

Patrick Williams it doesn’t work like, that Father is main villain

@PatrickWilliams-ip5wz

5 жыл бұрын

winson xie I don’t think you understand I mean father took the form of Ed’s dad important character who is the is the reason for father even existing this long and has been sulking and drinking because he didn’t think he could defeat him but in reality there dead even so when I say both I’m saying Ed’s father who is a side protagonist and father are two half’s of the same coin they both have the same alchemy etc if father took the appearance of someone else my comment wouldn’t be here.

@winsonxie3179

5 жыл бұрын

Patrick Williams Ok, the antagonistic nature is defined by the actions he does in the story. But in cases where bad guys becomes good guy they aren’t suddenly the antagonist for the whole story. We follow the story of Ed and Al which directly oppose fathers actions therefore he is the antagonist. And they are not different sides of the same coin, father is just using his shell and appearance as a cover and merely imitates it, though he does exist because of Hohenheim, Hohenheim himself doesn’t support of like the actions of father.

I feel like their is one quote that really sums up Envy's character, one that I am sure many know by now: "Do not pity the dead, pity the living, and above all: those who live without love." Envy from Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is (imo at least) a prime example to add even more meaning to that already super meaningful quote. But that's just me. :)

@kennethsatria6607

5 жыл бұрын

Ayy HARRY POTTER

@justAguyDs

5 жыл бұрын

@@kennethsatria6607 oh cool, who said it?

@sorrowdusk5068

5 жыл бұрын

Dumbledore

@devontejefferson6520

5 жыл бұрын

That actually does sum up Envy RIP Dumbldore

@IrvingIV

5 жыл бұрын

Well, hello Albus.

5:10 People talk a lot about the few good English dubs out there, but Envy’s final performance really solidifies FMA:B as one of the best.

@Soundwave._

3 жыл бұрын

I'm rarely much good at noticing voice actors but Wendy Powell is just utterly phenomenal, hats off to her for crafting such an incredible voice so perfectly suited to the character.

Not gonna lie but when I saw Envy crying, I was about to- okay I actually cried. Idk why but I feel like I understood his view. How weak and pathetic it must have felt when he was on the ground and ppl looking down on him. I felt that pain because I also feel or have felt that pain and embarrassment. And also hearing his voice made it even so unbearable of how small he felt at that moment. So yeah FMA hit me right in the feels so many times.

@blackshogun272

4 жыл бұрын

Weird Tree the worst thing that can be done to a sapient mind is to be made outcast and vilified; subject to intangible temptation for love or care only to be ignored...

@Thoralmir

Жыл бұрын

Tell me, are your politics more right-wing or left-wing?

Envy is one of my favorite villains of fmab and how he portrayed the sun envy was phenomenal. He hated humans more then any of the humanculi combined. The others just saw them as lesser beings but he loathed then cause he was jealous and that jealousy led to his cruelty towards them. It was just amazing in my opinion and it’s the reason why he’s 2nd favorite villain in fmab just a little behind King Bradley.

@wealthforthecommoners3146

3 жыл бұрын

2 years late but envy is better than wrath because he's drowning in his own edginess

@AyAnMajumdar03

3 жыл бұрын

@@wealthforthecommoners3146 Bradley is badass.....no competition with him.

Minor correction, not even the Philosopher's Stones bypass the law of equivalent exchange, they just hold so much alchemical value that it seems that way, evident by the fact that they do get used up, and there is no stone shown that last forever.

@godknightomega

5 жыл бұрын

That and the price that is paid upfront when the stone is created. The old saying "nothing is free" comes to mind.

Envy in himself is interesting and could have gone in two routes with himself. He obviously felt insecure and empty, and lack the things that humans have which grew into resentment and hate. He’s psychologically the embodiment of malicious envy. It would have been interesting if he had turn into benign envy: aspiration and found the love that he was looking for.

@Alaryk111

5 жыл бұрын

I doubt if this would be better for the writing than his death.

@Thoralmir

Жыл бұрын

@Tony Tran No, Envy didn't want power, he just wanted to bring others down to make himself feel better.

Envy is probably my favorite fictional character of all time so this video (which was very good tbh), almost made me cry. It angers me how people only see his actions, not his motivations caused by emotional pain he constantly felt. What makes it even more sad, is the fact that everything what he did, could be easily prevented. If he could experience friendship and love, who knows if he’d stayed by fathers side. Maybe, he would turn to humanity and the Ishval incident would never happen? Truly a tragic character.

@lidyarahmah6307

3 жыл бұрын

Yea, u r right, like what greed did right?

@raintalon6138

2 ай бұрын

Envy killed Hughes. Yet we cannot forget Hughes is not an innocent. He took place in a genocide. Envy killed a child. This is no more then Mustang did or many other states alchemists did. Envy acknowledged not only his actions but their repercussions. Mustang, in contrast, offered rationalization and excuses. And never truly owned up or faced consequences. The only other one who actually ownes up is Scar. In this way, Envy is more worthy of redemption then someone like Mustang or Hawkeye.

I wouldn't say Envy is always looking for a fight. Whenever he gets into a real fight, he runs like hell, because he quickly finds himself outclassed. What Envy is, is an instigator, a sh*t stirrer and a sh*t talker, he loves to get people riled up so they will either play into his hands or get so angry they don't think straight.

@KarlAndArma4ever

5 жыл бұрын

Yes! Exactly! Thank you! If anything, he prefers to put up the least amount of physical effort, hence his extra focus on talking. Envy is not about taking action, but about twisting emotions.

@giadapxysister3179

5 жыл бұрын

HEY CALM. DOWN leave alone my little angel

Seems like Envy had a not so envious life. I feel that he was the one I always did feel the most simpathy towards, maybe gluttony because he didn't really seem to understand right and wrong well. However, Envy had such a tragic life.

@garnett2350

3 жыл бұрын

Envy is cute

I wouldn’t say Envy couldn’t feel love or emotions, I think it’s more that he was never given the chance to. The dynamic of Father’s “family” was clearly not a healthy one, and we can pretty easily reason that Father did not raise his children with love. He did, however, pass onto them his view of humans, that they are weak and below Homunculi. The majority of the Homunculi adopted their father’s opinions on humans, much like a child looking to their parent to learn about the world. The one thing Envy really wanted was love. He grew up watching the loving relationships that humans formed with one another and deeply coveted them. He never received love from his father, and because of the beliefs he’d adopted from Father, he would never seek any kind of relationship with a human. He considered them far too below him for that. This leaves his siblings, the other Homunculi, as the only people from whom Envy could have received any love or affection - but, it doesn’t look like that ever happened either. We know the Homunculi are capable of caring about others: Gluttony was close to Lust and mourned her loss, Wrath chose and (probably) cared for his wife, Greed was able to befriend others, etc. But it doesn’t seem like Envy was especially close to any of his siblings. He looks like he might’ve gotten along with Lust, but even then, we don’t know if their relationship was ever very intimate. With no one who loved him, not even his “family”, Envy was unable to get the one thing he truly wanted. This, in combination with his already low opinion of humans, drove him to hate them more than any of the other Homunculi. He took delight in harming and killing them, hoping he could fill the emptiness he felt with his sadism, and put up an egotistical front to hide his compounding insecurities.

It’s funny because I honestly love both Envys, even though people don’t really talk about the 2003 adaption of the character. While Brotherhood Envy isn’t just jealous of Elric brothers but of all humans in general, the FMA 2003 is special to me because it gives Envy an anchor to the main characters and the hatred he feels for Hohenheim is only a shade darker than Ed’s own resentment for the man. Dante gets all the attention for having the sins of her seven homunculi, but I believe it’s Envy who shows most those sins the best because the source of his negativity is more easily attainable. Brotherhood Envy kills themself because someone understood them; 2003 Envy kills himself because even though he would die too, fulfilling his desire to kill his father was the only way to release himself of his only wish. While that might seem a bit one-dimensional, I enjoy it.

The voice at the beginning scared the shit outta me.

I love this channel, seriously you surprise me in the best way possible every time. Envy I found to be one of the most believable villains in anime. In fact each of the seven deadly sins sprouts from certain negative human emotions. Envy-from feelings of discontent and inadequacy Lust- loneliness and mentality that you are not worthy of attention/affection/love Gluttony-having an emotional void in your heart, a lacking of positive emotional nourishment the root of your constant need to physically feed yourself Sloth- thinking a task is to hard for you to succeed, and that you'll suffer disappointment and humiliation just for trying. Pride-the question of your existence and your convinced that everyone and even you yourself looks down on you Wrath-emotions of fear, your terrified and feel like your fighting for your life thus you lash out even if irrationally Greed- believing that possessions are a crippling need so you push all you can to yourself believing there's nothing of value on the inside of your being.

@slothful2039

4 жыл бұрын

Human sins are in and of themselves not so much sins as they are hurts. Hurt people hurt people. Maybe through love and forgiveness of everyone's shortcomings we can heal these "sins".

1:33 I would argue that we have spent more time with greed than with envy...

@SylentVoidkeeper

5 жыл бұрын

cLoud unDerWeather ...It’s debatable. Greed is a big presence for a while, but kind of fucks off for most of the end of the middle of the series till he and Ling finally get along to some degree after Greed breaks down. Envy is the one we see in action the most, then Greed, Pride, and Wrath

Good god Fullmetal Alchemist is depressing.

@vampirzii

5 жыл бұрын

Nah

Man, envy was the one that actually made me cry. It completely caught me off guard because out of all of them. Envy's needs we're simple, but unattainable. I really didn't expect envy to commit suicide.

His suicide is one of my favorite moment of the whole serie. Really moving.

@LenOnTheDoor0000

2 жыл бұрын

Still left a sour taste in my mouth because Roy had the perfect chance to end it but was stopped for no reason.

@dhivaansalig6398

Жыл бұрын

@@LenOnTheDoor0000 There was a reason. If he had killed Envy then and there, he would've lost his mind completely to anger and vengeance, and that's the face the people of Amestris would see of their future fuhrer. Honestly I wonder why, when people watch anime where characters are about to commit acts of vengeance and are stopped, people encourage the vengeance and become disappointed when they're stopped. Why?

No matter what he does throughout the series you still gotta love envy lmao

I really like the voice actor of envy They played every emotion i could imagine from envy

Envy was my favorite FMAB character and one of my favorite villains. Though I was mostly satisfied with his ending I wish he found love and had a happy ending.

I never watched this show but this video really made me emotional, espescislly at the end 😢

Very happy you made this video talking about one of my favorite characters in fma. I always felt like envy was my favorite of the homunculi

You need to be more popular your such an intellectual individual and how you explain basic concepts is fantastic

I love your videos, they know how to drill emotion into me. Thank you

In FMA original anime, Envy was envious of the relationship Hoenheim had with Edward and Alphonse. In this rendition, Envy was the abandoned son of Hoenheim.

@kinnikuzero

5 жыл бұрын

The original was so confusing to me, but I like a few parts about it more than brotherhood

You know, now that I know that Envy's human form is genderless, it actually makes sense. Maybe Envy takes a genderless form because it even further separates them from the humans whom they claim to despise. In one of the episode, there's a flashback where Ed and Al are discussing the "^perfect being" as being genderless. This might suit Envy's taste, because they consider themselves to be so far above the "inferior" humans. It also stands to reason that Envy's massive bestial form is their way of widening the divide between themselves and humanity even more. I think their jealousy stems in part from the fact that he can take on the physical appearance of any other living creature, but can never really belong anywhere; even among their Homunculus counterparts, Envy and Pride are the only ones whose true forms aren't human or humanoid. In a way, they're kind of tragic. they've watched, possibly for centuries, as humans have fought wars, lied, cheated and stolen; and they've been ready, willing and able to escalate the strife...but they've also seen selflessness, devotion, courage and love; and Envy could never be a part of those things, really. And it didn't help that Father didn't really seem to care about his "children"; other than how they could be useful in furthering his own goals. Essentially, all of the Homunculi were just his cast-offs; he didn't even seem to notice or care when they were injured or killed.

@tvbuu

Жыл бұрын

i love this

That one dislike is mustang 🤭

Great video Sage, you should think about making a video about Madara Uchiha!

I want to see an in depth look on the character and evolution of sesshomaru from a selfish power hungry brat to a caring compassionate individual and how his views and thoughts on life changed through out his life.

This scene made the show for me

I think you accidentally called Father Protagonist and not Antagonist

@king3860

5 жыл бұрын

I'm glad I wasn't the only one that noticed that

@skippernolen5644

5 жыл бұрын

#Metoo

@skippernolen5644

5 жыл бұрын

But like, what if he legit was the protagonist? I don't know if I'd root for someone of his character.

@jeangentry6656

5 жыл бұрын

@@skippernolen5644 Well, Ed's father pretty much is the "good" version of Father.

This made me reevaluate Envy. Thank you for your words.

Great vid,Love you.

Loved it !

Litterally love your voice and your videos! Keep doing it man

Your voice is amazing and calming to listen to, and I love it!

Just finished the anime yesterday, good timing sage!

Your videos somehow always capture the beauty and sheer cold of despair and longing. Each video is touching, well made, excellently spoken and above all soul touching well done.

Yet again. Sage's voice drops by an octave.

Envy is that villain that we love to hate, then simply hate, and then cry when he dies even though we should be happy he's gone. No other villain death has affected me as much as Envy's, not even Greed's. And Greed wasn't even a villain anymore by the end.

Yay awesome vid sage.

Another great video.

I actually cried when envy died ...😂😂😂😂

@zushi7363

3 жыл бұрын

SAME i freakin loved envy and his death was absolutely heart-breaking if you ask me

I love your videos so much

I love your videos

I love this video so much

My eye twitched when the video ended. Nothing beyond that... *tears*

Ur vids are so good

Damn your video hit my emotions deep

Very eye opening

so nice to see a FMA video about the characters in my recommended! and this video is so recent! nice! the only thing i have to say about this video is that in the beginning you say that the Philosopher Stone bypasses equivalent exchange, its been a while since i've seen the anime but im pretty sure that the philosopher stones doesn't have infinite value, its just that souls are very versatile have a very high "value" despite being such a small thing, you're still giving something in exchange with the stone, you're just paying with the souls inside of it instead of the traditional "turning a stone slab into a stone statue with the same amount of mass"

Envy’s death made me wanna laugh but cry at the same time

Envy is amazing and I hope they atleast appreciated a small bit that they had the coolest power of all the homunculus: shapeshifting. They did so much w it already but the applications of it are just amazing.

Oh boy I can't wait to hear about the other homunculus or better yet father!

Man thjs is really great.....

You have a very good channel 👍😁👍👌

Continue with the other sins please! I love your creations!

This made me bawl, I fucking his character he embodies a basic human nature that's undeniably human out of all of the homunculus

I could feel my heart slowly breaking into pieces while watching the video T.T

Omg daddy plz talk about the other homuculi and characters from fmab pretty plz finally someone who talks about this yesss

Envy for me is like the opposite of greed

I just finished this show, cNt wait to see what u say.

Great Video ;) could you some kind of Video about greed? Because he is my Favourite character from this series :)

fun fact: did you know that detective conan and envy are voiced by the same person in the original?

Im still waiting for you to do Monster!

You should revisit more of full metal alchemist

Please do an episode on Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood's Father/ Dwarf in the flask, or Hohenheim of Light. Two of the most interesting characters in anime! The Dwarf in the Flask episode... with the music... Perfection. You're awesome man. Thanks.

What was lust's lust? She never really slept with anyone that we know of, yet she is a physically attractive woman who more well endowed than most, what did she lust after, what is it that she coveted? Edit: why is Greed's ability the ultimate shield? It has nothing to do with avarice, unless it harkens to dragons greed, and dragons being nearly invulnerable. Why is wrath's ability the ultimate eye? Wrath is supposed to be a blind rage, wouldn't super human strength make more sense? Sloth has speed and strength, quite ironic considering he's supposed to be lazy, and all he wants is rest, pride has the abilities of father when he was dwarf in the flask, and gluttony can eat everything since he was a failed gate of truth.

@ColossalRay

5 жыл бұрын

blood.

@operandwriter

5 жыл бұрын

In the 2003 anime, her lust was to become human.

@carna-9501

5 жыл бұрын

@@operandwriter the 2003 anime has a different plot, and different reasons for why the homunculi exist(failed human transmutations create them and then they feed on philosophers stones), brotherhood is the story that everyone prefers because it's better animated, and better written.

@jeangentry6656

5 жыл бұрын

She had bloodlust.

@jeangentry6656

5 жыл бұрын

Maybe the Sins special powers are supposed to contrast or reflect the sin they represent, or their personalities? Wrath is said to be blinding yet Wrath has an eye that allows him to see clearly. Greed's shield allows him to protect himself, but it doesn't allow him to protect his prized poessesions. Lust usually brings people intimately close, yet Lust fingers allow her to attack long distance. Sloth has great physical traits, but no will or desire to use them. Pride has his shadows, and shadows can represent darkness, or can used to hide or conceal, esp. The truth of a matter, just as Pride hid his true form behind the alias of "Selim Bradley". Envy can become anyone, but he can never be himself. Gluttony can eat anything, yet never feel full. Perhaps what he truly wants cannot be consumed?

3:44 Very nice, you totally left out Lust.

The end made me want to tear up a bit...😔

oohhh my god i forgot just how good the FMA soundtrack is jesus

You should do all Alchemy since tell their part of their story makes him more interesting and more human about what each one dying

i love envy so fucking much

You should do one on greed

Sad envy 😢

And I'm crying shit...

When I saw this true, green form, I kinda understood his envy...

man i fuckin love envy

You should do a video on “Koi to Uso” or “Your Lie In April”

Envy still my favorite character

Envy was such a pitiful character.

Damn.

You should the whole cast of homuculi

I consider Envy a better antagonist and character than Wrath, because Wrath’s fury just seemed so aimless. His ruthlessness was understandable, but his contempt and hatred wasn’t really motivated by much at all. Envy, however, had such a compelling and understandable insecurity at the core, making them a truly tragic and compelling villain.

Contrary to popular belief the philosopher stone doesn't actually bypass "equivalent exchange", it still obey this law. Equivalent exchange states that to be able to obtain something, something of equal value must be lost or sacrificed. Think of this as a simple business transaction, you pay $ 3.00 for a piece candy of the same price. What the stone does is pay the price without you paying by asking someone else to buy it for you. The souls within the stone is sacrifice for the exchange to happened.

Honestly Everyone is gonna hate me for this but Envy was my favourite character at the very beginning in broth Fullmetal alchemists and before people say that They (Im using they pronouns caouse I want to) I know They killed hughes and idk why but I absoulutly loved them BUT DONT GET MAD AT ME I CRIED WHEN HUGHES DIED I JUST FREAKIN LOVE ENVY

@AnimeRayanne

2 жыл бұрын

Envy is definitely my favorite villain and I liked him even before his death too. I think their death actually hit me harder than Hughes... I love Hughes too and I hate that Envy killed him but I could never hate Envy.

Fun fact in the original fma envy is the son of hohenheim

Why Envy is my fav homunculus... idk...?

He broke his leg God

Philosopher stones do not bypass equivalent exchange, they use the human souls inside as fuel, thats why they do eventually shatter, though it takes a long time to break them down, just as human alchemy is more than possible, bypassing equivalent exchange was just a simpler explanation offered early and then it was shown that it was there to hide the truth of philosophers stones

Envy walked so that Zeke Yeager could run. And they both died of suicide (Zeke's death was assisted suicide)

Waiting for Greed..

I'd say that the philsopher's stone does not bypass the law of equivilant exchange but acts more like a battery. During it's creation a horrific price was paid and all the people using it are simply collecting the debt. Philospher's stones stop working if they are used constantly. That is when the debt is paid.

Please do more fma

Envy is a boy, for those who are curious

👍👍

Can u pleaseee make more

Can you please do a video on Ciel Phantomhive? He is like no other character that I have ever seen, but I'm not good with words so I suggest checking out the manga as it is a lot better source!

Severus Snape pleasee!!!