Every anthropology class shows this movie I swear.

@SUBSCRIBEtoSHAHRIYAR

Жыл бұрын

Yessirski

@ariful421

Жыл бұрын

nope...not in my uni😂

@CommieApe

Жыл бұрын

here for anthro lol

@themdamniguanas4368

Жыл бұрын

ong

@tlbaca120

10 ай бұрын

me watching this rn for my class at TTU in 2023

anyone else watching this for a college online class??

@willis12491

9 жыл бұрын

what colleges?

@PowderDeLaAngel

9 жыл бұрын

***** I AM

@heyzeusart1640

8 жыл бұрын

+Willy Mills-Fantin The Art Institute of Las Vegas

@stowys

7 жыл бұрын

Seattle Central Community. lol

@DerrickJamesMcKain

7 жыл бұрын

Palo Alto University, but it isn't an online course.

If I had a dollar for every pixel in this video I would be in crippling debt

We all here for class lmao

@kathcan7366

3 жыл бұрын

Not all I'm just like Franz

@CosmosArchipelago

3 жыл бұрын

And race isn’t a social construct.

@sevenft3

2 жыл бұрын

😂😂you mean here for the misinformation that Amerikkka use as guidelines to a destructive society

The fuzzy background noise in this vid is driving me CRAZY

Anthropology rocks. That was great. Thanks.

@adambrooks2528

Жыл бұрын

This guy was a fraud!!! He doesn't rock!!!

A person's worth should be judged by the warmth of his heart.

omfg i didnt think this video was going to be this long.. where is the spoiler/summation video??

I really enjoyed the video and thank you for taking the time to upload all this fantastic material.

Great documentary!

Very insightful, thanks

All the anthropologists in the comments saying Boas was an "intellectual giant" and "you need to take an anthropology course to understand" are like middle IQ.

does anyone know where can i watch this ethnography with english subs?

Just another prerequisite I am never going to reflect on again in my career as an engineer xD

@da5159

5 жыл бұрын

D Kot yeah it'll be great when you're on a site and have no clue about artifacts so your company can get fined.

@glorifing

5 жыл бұрын

What an ass

@doom8274

4 жыл бұрын

5 years later and engineering students still taking bullshit waste of time classes so the school can take more of our money. nothing changes

@lydiaaemily

9 ай бұрын

MOOD

Thank you very much. An excelent documentary about a great antropologist and humanist altogether. It is obvious that men are essentially cultural products. And I think that his german origins have helped to create his sense of comparative cultural relativeness.

@daniel3231995

2 жыл бұрын

Also biological,environmental, pathological. Human condition will never be completely understood till we're extinct.

I don't think Boas completely disregarded race, simply recognized that the biological differences between humans are very small. He saw many cultural differences, and spent his life studying cultures, but when it comes down to how 'human' we are, biologically we're all the same...

David Fazzino explains the different strands of Anthropology in coherent manner.

Is there a way to enhance the sound quality?

Dr Kevin McDonald and culture of critique sent me here

@audreydempsey247

6 жыл бұрын

Spencer Austin-Martin #me too

@skittleharbor

2 жыл бұрын

@@ruslanurss More like a chicken.

this is amazing

who did the music?

"Unlike specific biological traits morality is not dictated by biology" Morality is behavior labeled "moral" or "immoral", it's a purely social construct. Since different organisms have different behavioral tendencies, then they will have different "moral" tendencies. I don't know what you mean by "education" or what groups you're even talking about.

@mariussielcken

3 жыл бұрын

'Good' is what serves the survival and thriving of humanity or a genotype. It's relative, but above individual consideration.

I hope to know more about Boas but I have to say I still don't quite know him even after watching this document...

Panteio where are you?

UPSC anthropology optional 💓✨

@itsmelahi

3 жыл бұрын

same here :-)

wonderful

College student here 🙋‍♂️

A tip for my Anthropology class takers; watch at 1.5x speed. Thank me later ;)

@MarielaWilthew

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you lol

@CosmosArchipelago

3 жыл бұрын

When you find out this is pseudoscience. Colleges are nothing but brainwashing

@rolland890

2 жыл бұрын

@@CosmosArchipelago Oh no, cringe

@r3bs

2 жыл бұрын

@@CosmosArchipelago So you're salty you couldn't get into college? Makes sense.

@anapurchiaroni2059

Жыл бұрын

Thank you this cut the watch time in half

Magnificent

best episode of this show is the one about the Kula ring

What do you think were the most important ideas, concepts, and practices Boas contributed to not only the field of Anthropology, but our overall perceptions of other people?

ATTENTION ! There is a nasty screamer on 31:20 !!! I nearly pissed myself - watch out ! and You're welcome :)

@jy768 how so?

How can we recognize the shakles that tradition has laid upon us... for when we recognize them, we are also able to break them !!

So many comments, so many anthropologists. I doubt anyone else is interested in Franz Boas :D

whats with the creepy music tho

Alguien que hable español, me podría ayudar con el resumen del video por favor! :) Se le agradecería muchísimo .

@mariarabago8712

Жыл бұрын

lo encontraste?

Wow amazing intro song.

@quatroseven Since it's not a peer reviewed article that statement is a red herring.

I read a few articles by Boas, but where can I find information about his understanding of language as a means to transmit culture? Thanks!

@adambrooks2528

Жыл бұрын

Screw Boas!!! He sucks!!

im here bcz of sosin mam

Is there a version that is clearer without subheadings in a different language? The version with the Spanish subheadings is so much clearer. Compare 2:12 here to two thirty-two on the following. kzread.info/dash/bejne/rH9pzruJlaTIdLA.html I cannot believe the difference in visual quality.

文化はrelative 文化の教育や伝統を伝えることは、互いを認めて

"Who says they can’t assimilate?" Who says they can? "How well people assimilate to different countries depends on... measures..." Yes, just like your height depends on nutrition. Is that why women are shorter than men, because they eat less?

look at minute 37 and after, the traditional artist is wearing nikes lol, that´s globalization, and thet we are talking about these things using this media tool is even more globalizated. so we have to begin thinking how we insert on this new paradigm, not blaming boas or defending him, the damage was done when boas got there, the damage is done even on this moment, there is nothing else to do, that look the way we insert on this keeping ourselves and make it righ also on others

Hi all... who took Anthropology as optional (civil services exam, INDIA) ;-) Boaz Rockzzz...

@spencer5028

6 жыл бұрын

Prashanth Purastu Dr Kevin McDonald and culture of critique sent me here

Is it because of culture that all black Haiti looks like Detroit, which looks like Africa? Is it because of culture that white America looked like Australia and Europe? People can eat McDonalds and speak the language that doesnt mean someone from Zimbabwe is as American as George Washington. People only point to superficial things like the food, the clothes, the language people adopt but ignore the underlying aspects that make up human character.

@jameseldridge3445

Жыл бұрын

Exactly. But its too controversial to accept the truth in a multiracial democracy

@TruthDissident

9 ай бұрын

This is true. Culture doesn't spring from nowhere.

14:10 ?

MA Anthropology class sent me here :)

I can relate to where you're coming from on this - however, a coin always has two sides to it. For the celebration of anthropological successes and breakthroughs, my country Canada, is a living testament - for without people like Franz Boas and Samuel Hearne, it wouldn't have been possible to establish a country this vast. On the other hand, the decimation of native cultures that followed early pioneers is a truly shameful chapter in Canadian history. Two sides to a coin - always. Good luck!

@daniel3231995

2 жыл бұрын

Tragic revelations of assimilation schools rn

A stunning 240p

A fascinating video about a towering intellectual figure of our time.

@spencer5028

6 жыл бұрын

pfwms proto Marxist revisionist. Dr Kevin McDonald and culture of critique sent me here

❤️

@caviper 1 How does relativism separate us? I would conclude the opposite. Functionalism harkens more to an evolutionary model, which implies winners and losers in a cultural struggle for survival. Relativism gives us a basis for understanding the inherent value of all cultures--after all culture is the result of a specific society's adaptations and adjustment to their environmental and social environments --unlike functionalism, this does not imply that some cultures are better than others

@kupofdirt6509

2 жыл бұрын

Ive always thought that as well

"Man is not intended to see through the eyes of another, hear through another’s ears nor comprehend with another’s brain. Each human creature has individual endowment, power and responsibility in the creative p lan of God. Therefore, depend upon your own reason and judgment and adhere to the outcome of your own investigation; otherwise, you will be utterly submerged in the sea of ignorance and deprived of all the bounties of God." ~ Baha'i Faith

@dtasialatique751

5 жыл бұрын

Francis Mausley discuss two ways that the work of Franz Boas has contributed to the debate on race relations.

@francismausley7239

5 жыл бұрын

@@dtasialatique751 Sounds like a homework assignment.

@dtasialatique751

5 жыл бұрын

It was I completed it though.

@francismausley7239

5 жыл бұрын

@@dtasialatique751 Good deal!

i rest my case

Poor seals.:(

@shelzoth Is this Neil Rush, PHD basing his argument on experimentation or speculation? Is his finding going to contradict the conclusions of dozens of scientists, geneticists, physical anthropologists, over a period of 100 years? Remember science is based on conscensus, and there will always be outlyers. Based on the proponderance of evidence, I'm with Boas.

Boas said all Cultures, race, biology are EQUAL, Malinowski said all Cultures, races, biology are NOT equal, rather evolutionary and therefore different.You make up your own mind ????????

We all here for class smh

SSA101 WYA BOIS?

"Biology as such does not in fact dictate culture in any way." This is magical thinking. What does then? "It is only logical that people living in close quarters of one and other tend to adopt similar customs" Right, because people who evolved in similar regions have similar genetics. This is why europeans going to the US assimilated into one "white" people easily, while african immigrants to Canada, Britain, Sweden, etc. do not assimilate.

@johndoe4907

4 жыл бұрын

You need to take an actual anthropological class. It is not "magical" it is empirical. North America was colonized by Europeans, so yes of course European migrants integrated more in NA than Asians. Biological adaptation gave us the capacity for culture, but it was culture that gave us the capacity to adapt to nearly every ecosystem on the planet. It was the collective experience (culturally) adapting to different ecosystems that led to the formation of distinct cultures. From the resulting cultures and they're representative technologies people could stay in an ecosystems long enough for phenotype variation (usually referred to as race) to occur. The reality that most fail to see is that it is our very differences that prove just how similar we are!

@NS-pj8dr

Жыл бұрын

Yes of course all human behavior is rooted in biology to the extant that all human activities require a body to function. This does not mean that a particular biological trait x causes y cultural outcome. No such link has been made by biologists or anthropologists.

@fringeelements

Жыл бұрын

@@NS-pj8dr - You're so draining. It'll never end will it?

@NS-pj8dr

Жыл бұрын

@@fringeelements ...

this is psychotic. it's hilarious all the comments are from SCHOOL.

The kinds of people Boas warned society about are the kinds of people commenting calling him a 'zionist jew', very telling.

@Esoteric.Autochthon

8 жыл бұрын

+Brenda Quagmire It's funny how when you disprove these racists (or race realists), they'll resort to calling you a "Liberal", "Negroid", and other disgusting terms.

@lukasmccain3529

7 жыл бұрын

Brenda Quagmire was he not a Zionist Jew?

@MEyck97

6 жыл бұрын

Read the culture of critique!

Texas Tech anyone?

Oh, are we playing the "use exceptions to ignore the trend" game? Okay. I know a girl who is taller than most boys. Therefore boys and girls aren't genetically different in terms of height, because some girls are taller than the boy average. In fact, at young ages, girls are about the same height as boys, which is evidence that it's not until the cultural norm that "girls are to be small and cute" is internalized that the height gap develops, and girls start behaving more "girly" toward boys.

31:21

44:19 this is for an assignment that I have.

34:50 Not too sure I'd be as comfortable as they were when walking under that old decrepit house. That thing looked like it could have fallen at any moment haha

どうして言葉がわかるの？ Disappearしちゃう文化を残す

So this guy is basically another Freud huh?

"Education is largely effected by economic and social circumstances" - Kay. Are the currently extant differences in schools within the United States the cause of racial differences in years of schooling? Not "X is influenced by circumstance". Sure, height is influenced by "economic and social circumstance" too. That's why people in China were 4 inches shorter in 1950 than they are today. And that's why Bill Gates is 10,000 feet tall. (Hint: only one of those statements is true)

@ridingwild760

3 жыл бұрын

Some one really doesn't want to take this class. It's a short video from forever ago its inaccuracy is implied.

@knightschwartz Boas never discarded the idea of race on a social level. He says that "race" is just not a reality when it comes to biology; saying that a south african man is more inclined to rape women because his genes is complete nonsense. It all goes back to the entanglement with his own specific "system of meanings" and what sociologist like to call "socialization".

or of receiving the same level of education? Unlike specific biological traits morality is not dictated by biology - humans and other organisms with hierarchies are biologically capable to recognize moral units …but it is the moral unit that is passed down from the higher ups (i.e. social norms). Education is largely effected by economic and social circumstances. Just because someone is uneducated that does not imply that they are genetically incapable of learning.

Musial display が奇妙 音も奇妙かつ

Old age curiosity

The viewership of the video seems to break down between students here for an anthropology course, and those here because of the critique of cultural relativism as it was enshrined by Boas in anthropology.

10:40

@HannibalBarca13 Referring to "peer" reviewing and "graduate students" is simply an appeal to authority instead of truth. That doesnt mean that non authoritative knowledge is true but your rating agency mentality offers zero enhancement in quality. Also labeling people as "cowards" and "idiots" is non honorable discourse and if there were any sanity in your cultural life style you would subscribe to higher standards of interaction and not ego radiate yourself at the cost of others.

March

Sent by Sosin mam

Languageは文化の一つ　子供たちにでん

identifying with someone. When speaking with black people I tend to find that that even though they’d like to befriend whites some whites won’t respond to them the way they’d like to. It’s not necessarily a racial thing either but rather it has to do with feeling out of place; you feel you can’t relate to the other person. 4. Let’s say you adopted a child from Africa; are you seriously suggesting that that child is less capable of learning the moral values that you try to instill upon it

Soooo it's a bad idea to eat while watching this video lol

@knightschwartz Can’t help but be amused at your continued insistence that all these superficial aspects of culture are somehow biologically dictated; for instance I myself speak five languages…does that mean that I am genetically more capable than others? Is the prosperity the japanese in the field of technology due to their genes? No, it’s because they come from a society that enforces a hard work ethic; or in my case a household that emphasized the value of diversity.

I have a new idea on race

1900年あめりかのんのつびんひゅ

Changed education that is America thought race

I mean, did he **really** have to travel somewhere so remote to learn these things? Nah

@r3bs

2 жыл бұрын

Yes they did. Do you actually think they had Google in the late 1800s? Congrats on being the most brain dead loser on the internet.

I go for functionalism. Cultural relativism separate us.

"and subtle genetic variations are becoming even more subtle." Um... no? Without the mask of "culture", the genetic differences are put on full display. In the US for example, nobody speaks of italians or poles or irish. They speak of the genetically distinct races. The ephemeral and transient "culture" breaks down, leaving behind the underlying genetic base.

@spencer5028

6 жыл бұрын

The Alternative Hypothesis love your work on IQ man

Wow I hope you people criticizing him do not live anywhere near me (BTW I am of white Euro-Amer descent in case you thought otherwise or some crazy s***) You SCARE me to be so hateful to a man who opened so many minds and doors!

@zoopyjoobles

8 жыл бұрын

+Alexia Mellups I'm sorry, but you are mistaken. See Kevin MacDonald's 'Culture of Critique'.

@toomanyredpills649

7 жыл бұрын

Zoopy Joobles excellent work their analyzing the affect that Jewish intellectual groups have had on WASP culture. No hate mongering or antisemitism like you PC police claim.

@spencer5028

6 жыл бұрын

Dr Kevin McDonald and culture of critique sent me here

2023

so most comments focus on Jews and not the topic... hmmm. Funny how Jews interest so many people. As a zionist Jewess in Israel, I find this culture of focusing on Jews so very much, very fascinating. Thank goodness we are still here to interest so many people. ;)

Culture is created by people. People are the biology. Culture is created by the biology. To what extent this culture then turns in on the biology and influences the biology is more speculative and requires proof. We know objectively that culture is created by the biology. Biology is the base, culture is merely the superstructure.

Di❤打卡

a whopping 240p

anthropology is only subject to explore man.... humanity

Online NAS

Read culture of critique to learn more about Boas and the proto Marxists who became cultural Marxists

@zindaix396

5 жыл бұрын

cultural marxism doesn't fucking exist. What you think of as cultural marxism is cultural capitalism.