The writer of this song personaly thanked Mrs' Hill for doing this song the way he intended for it to be sung.

@39thala

2 жыл бұрын

This is true,. A lot of people commenting negatively about Faith don't know, but she had never heard Janis' version before. And her producers would not allow her to hear it, so that she could record it fresh without being influenced by Janis version. They wanted her to do her own interpretation. It was good move imo. It turned out to be her first big hit!

I always prefer this version. 🧡🥰 I guess because I'm used to it, I grew up with this version. 🧡🥰

Faith Hill is a huge country artist. Check out "Breathe", from 1999. She won a Grammy Award for Best Country Album that year. The video has 30 million views!

HA! - figured this may be coming after BJ's convo the other day during Janis' original. I like her version and it's more melodic and more upbeat but it's definitely its' own thing that doesn't capture the pain that Janis does. Faith is singing after going to therapy and working through her issues responsibly, while Janis is walking down the street holding Jack Daniel's hand in public.

@Rosedach

2 жыл бұрын

I think that was Southern Comfort, not Jack Daniel.

@JadeK297

Жыл бұрын

Janis version not original. She wasn't the first to do this song..

Please do Faith’s song “Breathe” next?!

Faith had never heard Janis Joplin's version before and her producers decided not to let her hear it. Instead, they gave her a demo of the song to learn it from fresh without ever being influenced by Janis' previous version. It became her first hit. She didn't hear Janis' version until later.

There are a couple of songs that stand out to me that Faith sang, that you would never know a man wrote them. They are "It Matters To Me", I believe Alan Jackson wrote this one and the other one is called "I Can't Do That Anymore". Two of my favorite Faith songs. Two songs showing how strong a women is and how emotionally invested in her relationship with her man. Nothing wrong with that, all good. May bring a tear to your eye. ❤️🙏✌️

Faith hill is very talented. She doesn't get enough mention when talking about talented female country artist.

Thanks for reacting to this guys! Much Love ❤

@AsiaandBJ

Жыл бұрын

No problem!!

Y’all would really appreciate her work with husband, Tim McGraw. So much love and passion. How You Talk to a Girl - video a must & a Very Important Message for today’s culture.

Janis she just song the shit out of this song and left no stoned unturned still Faith did a good job

Faith Hill'd Wild one is great.

Beautiful voice!

The original "Piece of My Heart" was recorded by Aretha Franklin's older sister Erma 2 years earlier in 1967. Joplin copied her style and evrrything. Franklin had the same song on both sides of the single.

@natlisan

2 жыл бұрын

I mentioned Erma's original version too! It's not right that she doesn't get the credit she deserves!

This was a nice cover, but listening to it made me realize how much Janis brought to her version of this song…while listening to it I kept thinking Faith’s missing some ab libs here and there… Janis’s version I first heard when I was a little kid and because of how raw and unique it was I remember it all these years later…if the roles were reversed and I heard Faith’s first, I probably would have forgotten she had sung this song…there’s nothing memorable about it…

Faith Hill has some pretty good music… Cry, breathe, this kiss… You guys should check them out sometime.

Story goes Faith had never heard the Joplin version, she said if she had heard it she never would have recorded it.

You guys should checkout the original by Erma Franklin, She's Aretha's Eldest sister. She also had a set of pipes on her!!!

Faith said she had never heard the Janis version so she didn't have any idea how it was suppose to sound and had no pressure to sound like that version

I saw faith hill and Tim McGraw on tour before they were married. As they were falling in love. It was so cute.

Did you know when she recorded this song she didn't know it was Janis song

Janis for the win!

Damn hard to cover a Janis Joplin song. But I do give her credit for trying.

I know how much you guys love Janice Joplin, I’m begging you to give a listen to Susan Tudesci , the song. It hurts so bad. This chick is hardcore like Janice. I know you guys will love her. Mix of rock , soul, blues.

She has another version of this song i think.

This cover was easy to digest... commercial... Joplin's you FEEL her pain. Anyone who puts the two versions even near an equal footing just doesn't "get" art. I know how that sounds...but I don't care. It's true .

I go here!

You like covers? Do White Lion - Radar Love. Love that version of the song. The guitar is so much better

Did not know this was a remake. I still like Faith's version better

I hope you get the chance to check out Vanessa Amarosi's cover of this epic song 🎵 👍

Faith Hill is a huge Aretha Franklin fan, so it makes sense she would cover the original by Aretha Franklin‘s big sister, Erma Franklin. A slow, soulful song. Much prefer it to Janis‘ cover.

I like Janis and Faith... two very different women and sounds.

I don't know yet I like Janis 😊

janis joplins version was more emotional raw , both are good

They told faith to NOT listen to the original Janis Joplin version

You guys are my favorite reaction team, but something has gone seriously wrong with your music audio. It’s gotta be something you can fix, because your music audio used to be great! Meanwhile, I’m continuing to watch you guys daily. 🤞🏼

Wife here...This is really great..But, I still prefer Janis Joplin...I agree BJ and Ms.Asia, the words are are quite a bit more clear and concise in this version..Love the reaction as always!!

This was good Janis's version was great.

I'd rather have

Come on..sorry

Even though Faith does a good job making this country, I'd still prefer Janis Joplin's version.

Not my favourite. Janis Joplin does it so much better. This is a bit too fairy floss for me. Sacrilege really.

Way to be politically correct in picking your favorite

Soulless

Sorry, This F.....G sucks! Total disrespect for Janis!!!!!

Nope. Janice did it the best.

Faith Hill is really good. However this version lacks the heart that Janis puts into the song. It's still good however.