I love the fact that Cassian and Jyn didn’t kiss at the end, because in that scene it seemed obvious that they would but just the hug was perfection

@djmace9029

Жыл бұрын

There was clearly some attraction between them, but it was the end, and they were so humble about it and I just loved it. I think their death scene was just absolutely perfect.

@PerovNigma

Жыл бұрын

A hug works better in that scenario, getting comfort from one another right before you die. A kiss would have felt forced to me, and taken me out of the moment.

@GeneralMadinesBarber

Жыл бұрын

@@PerovNigma kiss would of ruined it but the first time I saw Rogue one I thought they were definitely going to kiss but so glad when they just hugged it was perfect writing/directing

@ugoeze7360

Жыл бұрын

As the nuclear light wave roars closer during their hug: Jyn: “I’m scared” Cassian whispers: “so am I” They hold each other tighter with a content smile on their face as they are enveloped in light. The theater would’ve just riot with 😢 😭 😭

@JordanDecker

Жыл бұрын

Idk man they got pretty close in that elevator ride 👀

Every line delivered by Ben Mendelsohn is perfect. “We stand here amidst my achievement, NOT YOUUURS” “Are we blind? Deploy the garrisonnnn”

Jyn falling to her knees after watching the message from her father is a powerful moment. You can feel the years of pain and loss.

My mom never watched anything Star Wars. (Yes, she doesn't yet know about Luke's father...) This is the first thing that we watched together and it's a testament to the movie that she was totally hooked while having zero backstory.

The two things I love the most about Rogue One is the soundtrack: "your father would be very proud" and the shot of the two crashing star destroyers.

@EACru2002

Жыл бұрын

I remember some people complaining about the music during the Star Destroyer crashing part, saying it was too “happy.” But I think they were missing the point that it was a small moment of triumph in the battle. I sometimes think Star Wars fans want everything to be the most obvious rock opera type soundtrack, which don’t get me wrong, has its place, but interesting music cues like that are what become memorable over time, not the generic film score stuff

I love that Baze and Chirrut flip what you'd expect from "the heavy weapons guy" and "the wise monk" - you'd think Chirrut would be exasperated by his comrade throwing himself into battle, but it's the other way round.

Rogue One is a great SW movie. Orson Krennic's character was so personable for an imperial. You could feel his frustration every time he was given another political or mission hurdle to overcome from either Tarkin or Vader

I love when Baze tells Jyn "good luck little sister". Whenever my sister does something big i send her that clip. Its very wholesome

This is my favorite star wars movie I was so surprised when it ended how much I liked it

@quinetastic

Жыл бұрын

This is superior to *The Empire Strikes Back*?🤔

@drjones694

Жыл бұрын

@@quinetastic I'm going to say yes or maybe a tie... Naw rogue one is number 1 Empire number 2 here.s why. Why for those that grew up with the series that was a pivotal moment and impactful but fast forward 40 years to today But when you show your kids or someone walking in now Rogue 1 shows the whole universe in 1 movie how regular people see the force as a religion how when a Jedi / sith show up and it is absolutely terrifying for regular people The desperation of a death planet floating around destroying us regular people and we need to destroy it And to be honest it's let's kiddy I really would like to see a more teenager grown up Jedi story like rogue one for a Jedi movie

@1516Spinola6040

Жыл бұрын

@Alphonse Noel People can have their own favorite Star Wars movie. I know you don't mean it wrong.

After the prequels I really got the understanding that fans can be fixated on lightsaber fights way too much. Rogue One really knocked it out of the park by focusing on the rebels struggle with the underdogs taking the lead.

Even not knowing what led Cassian before or knowing much of the characters, I loved it because it reminded me of A new hope where there’s characters for the first time not known but is in danger and fighting for hope to destroy a greater evil

When Bodhi responded "ugh Rogue one" i remember thinking, oh so thats how they come up with Rogue Squadron in new canon. I thought it was cool that for once, something in the movies explained something from the books and comics instead of the other way around

@Compucles

Жыл бұрын

Well, not exactly, as Rogue Squadron originated in "The Empire Strikes Back," but yes it was expanded upon much more in the supplemental material in both the old canon and new. I also agree that it was an awesome to retcon the etymology of the unit name. I also like to think that the call sign "Rogue One" is unofficially retired like a retired uniform number for a sports team, as the first Rogue pilot always has the Rogue Leader call sign instead, despite being far from the only Rebel fighter squadron to do that.

I remember coming out of the cinema and couldn't stop crying, even if knew most of the character will die, but all that death and destruction was something I never thought of seeing in Star Wars. I love this dark style and hope we see that again, but still in a mix with the more light Star Wars-charme.

Two of my iconic moments from Rogue One were: 1) The trailer showing Jynn Erso in her black imperial disguise in front of the sequentially illuminating lights which wasn't utilized in the movie 2) the Vader hallway scene which was not originally planned or scheduled by the director but was more or less a last-minute addition to the film.... that hinted at what Darth Vader / Anakin had become.... a monster.

@ruban8135

Жыл бұрын

i also liked the "I re-bel" line that was only in the traiiler.

@Nautilus1972

Жыл бұрын

Nor was the tie fighter ...

I was in tears upon seeing Red and Gold Leaders be revealed when I watched the movie in theaters. That was my favorite surprise in the entire movie.

The little moment when a more grand version of Leia's theme is playing and Jyn and Cassian are on the elevator after sending the death star plans is my favorite scene in the film. Jyn has been doubted by almost everyone she ever met and Cassian always gave her the benefit of the doubt. Willing to die for her and her cause is admirable than people let on.

My favorite moments in rogue one: 1. Stormtroopers for once portrayed as highly trained military combatants (especially on battle of Scarif) 2. The crashing of 2 star destroyers 3. The rivalry between Krennic and Tarkin 4. The iconic Vader hallway scene 5. Baz shooting a rocket launcher on the head of the AT-AT 6. Literally every scene of K2SO 7. Chirrut’s “Are you kidding me, I’m blind” line

@DarthTecolote

Жыл бұрын

This film was full of little gems. Everything K said was brilliant. “Congratulations. You are being rescued.”

So many moments you mention here remind me of the feels I get every time I watch Rogue One. It's my favorite Star Wars movie, hands down.

24:40 the Blue Squadron 'Hero' shot as you call it...I've always said it looked like it would be appropriate for a modern day celebration of 'Battle of Britain Day' over London with the 'period era warbirds' doing a flyby.

Rogue One is amazing

@muddymannn

4 ай бұрын

It was really good

I think the Vader scene at the end works so well because she have Never seen him being the Unstoppable Juggernaut of Death for the Empire on the big screen. In the movies we are TOLD he is a threat but never see just how much until Rogue One. Great video as always.

R1 IMO is the best of the Disney theatrical films. So much to love from the characters to the cinematography to the characters and action. Has the best space battle since Endor and did a great job in reminding just how terrifying the Empire can be.

When I watch Rogué One, I felt like a kid again. I Saw myself in the movie theater rushing to find a seat with My brother and My dad hoping to see luke again in The Empire strikes back. What a ride! Rogué One is raw, knee deep in the mud, Platoon storytelling. A blast!

💯Loved the score throughout the entire film. My favorite moment is Admiral Raddick watching the Death Star’s destructive power for the first time. I think I was more blown away than he was.

I love hearing how excited you were pre-Andor knowing how freaking great it is now

Wow this really makes me wanna rewatch rogue one. I said I was gonna leave it until I'd read the novelisation since I read the other three tie in novels a while ago but then never got round to it.

God the Scariff battle, both space and ground, is my favorite battle in star wars. It feels like something from one of the novels. There's a flow to it with plans and tactics. It's not just random shooting or random ships flying around aimlessly

I’m gonna rewatch rogue one after andor

i don't know why , but my favourite fun fact about the movie is that the star destroyer floating over jehda city is the same one you protect in the battlefront 2 campaign. also, nice fakeout

Love these videos, the fandom needs more love. All of Star Wars isn't for everyone, but there is some Star Wars for everyone.

the one thing i love about rouge one is the space battle on scarif best ever space battle in star wars and vader hallway scene and tarkin scene

Gareth Edwards is the man. Watching this vid makes me want to rewatch Rogue One. Good times.

1 I love how Krennic had that "oh poodoo" moment when the Death Star appeared. He knew his Porg was well & truly cooked. 2 Andor not wanting know the chances of failure or Jyn using a blaster against him was a subtle call-forward to Han never wanting to be told the odds. 3 Chirrut was my favourite character. Using the Force of Others, he was able to eliminate a squad of Troopers with little more than a bowstaff and take down a TIE with a light bow. It's too bad that "Solo" wasn't 50% as good as R1. I wanted more Imperial backstory, more Darth Maul, and less Woody. But that's just my 2 Credits.

Thanks so much for this! Rogue One is one of my favorite Star Wars anything! Brilliantly done. I hope Gareth Edwards get to do more Star Wars!

I'm gonna be a contrarian here: I don't care about the Vader hallway scene. But the rest of the movie was very good to me. I always hoped we could see the new characters again, specially Baze and Chirrut, but I'm glad we got a prequel story of Cassian.

@Nautilus1972

Жыл бұрын

Pfft. You don't care about Vader ... but you care about minor nobodies?

When I saw how the Holy City was built into the rock, it immediately reminded me of Edinburgh Castle. If you’ve been there, you know what I’m talking about.

I love Draven, and I love the little hints of his connection and camaraderie with Mon Mothma, and I love even more that the novelization gave more depth into their relationship and Draven’s perspective of how he sees the world and the rebellion. I really hope he pops up in Andor.

I always took Chirrup blowing on his hand as him warming it up. I bet with it being wet it might have been cold too. I have been shooting while its cold and you want blood flowing to your fingers for that 🙂

Everything to do with Admiral Raddus and Blue Squadron. I'm sure that's a very hot take.

11:42 I always loved that little comparison between Tarkin and Krennic in terms of their leadership capabilities. Krennic simply, yet aggressively barks his orders. Another good example of that being the "Are we blind?!" line on Scarif. Meanwhile, Tarkin is more smooth and elegant in a way with his delivery. It's almost like a younger brother desperately striving for admiration and attention, while the elder brother knows exactly what to do in order to obtain it. It's a good comparison between two rivaling, high ranking Imperials

@quinetastic

Жыл бұрын

EXCELLENT analysis 👏

I went to the Cinema 4 times to see it, including an entended work lunchbreak! My favourite SW movie by far. The flashy Jedi are cool but getting to know the underbelly of the galaxy is also very cool.

Death Troopers are my all time favorite Trooper design! Rogue One is my least fav SW movie yet I’m still most excited for Andor than I have been for any Star Wars project since Visions!

IMHO, this movie and the Andor series, have been the more interesting things in a long time in the Star Wars Universe. I love (most of) the new movies, but the stakes are SO MUCH HIGHER when you are starting a revolution. The risks that everyone takes, the small acts of deffiance, the politics, everything is on a different scale, it's not about a wizard messiah with the power to save the universe by himself, it's real people with fears and hopes, risking their lifes and the ones of their families

When I first saw this movie I loved it, watching this video makes me love it more. This is Star Wars.

Will always be my favorite Star Wars movie. And Andor is turning out to be my favorite series.

WOAH WOAH WOAH WOAHH! What about Vader’s end hall scene? That was soo good!

I've been a star wars fan since I was a kid, but after rouge one came out someone asked me what my favourite quote was from the franchise and honestly I didn't have one, not until we got "I've been in this fight since I was 6 years old" from Cassian, it hit me on so many levels, I was first shown star wars when I was 6 and it's themes of light vs dark, fighting for the freedom of others and that there's always hope. Hope has given me the strength to keep going through not only some of the toughest times in my life with the acceptance of my sexuality whilst also in coping with depression and suicide, but also to keep hope alive in my partner in his battles with depression and anxiety. It's the only quote I've considered getting as a tattoo probably paired with a starbird.

I'll be honest, the only Death Trooper appearance I was really disappointed by was that one episode in Rebels with the massive kyber crystal. Even their other appearances in Rebels I can remember seemed menacing.

At the very beginning of the movie, we are in space and look up at an asteroid belt. Before I figured out it was an asteroid belt it always looked to me like the scrolling text at the opening of A New Hope, as if we are looking at the text from the underside. I still believe that was intentional- to subtly indicate that this story is the story behind the opening Star Wars text. It shows the rebels and their first victory against the Empire and how they stole the secret plans mentioned in the text. Very fun and clever and not something I have heard anyone else mention.

I love how they showed the power of the Death Star in the perspective of the people on the ground. The sheer force of destruction and fear is something we haven't seen during the OG and sequels. They just blew up the planets and that was it.

“THIS IS MY ACHIEVEMENT NOT YOURS!!!” Unfortunately for you, history will not see it that way

The BEST star wars movie since the Disney takeover and undoubtedly in my top 5 or maybe top 3

I like the inclusion of blue squadron makes a reference to the original novelization of a new hope. Luke and his squadron were the blue boys

I love how the director is the one to pull the handle to release the Tantive (Tan-ta-vee ;) 4 and put a New Hope in motion. Additionally...if you have good subwoofers...crank the first step of the AT-AT...Eargasm...

You are one of the few mature perspectives in the online star wars "discourse" and gosh do I appreciate that

Rogue One and Solo are a tied 2nd for best Star Wars movie since 2015 (1st is The Last Jedi obviously) there's so many great moments in Rogue One and while the film isn't perfect, mainly in the writing and story department (too many characters resulting in everyone getting shafted which is kinda impressive tbh) Which is why I'm super excited for Andor because it'll give us the chance to get to know Cassian even better and I assume expand the surroundings of Rogue One in general.

Brilliant commentary. Thanks for the video

Rouge one is by far my most favorite star wars movie..😊

The AT-ST walking in though the city gives me chills every time.

I did exactly same (as did many) I re watched Rogue One yesterday ready for Andor, this video was very well timed.

Love this movie…really excited for ANDOR.

Wonderful vid. I share your love for this masterpiece completely.

I don't think I could come up with this many nice things to say about this film, but you have helped me to appreciate it a bit more.

4:15 those glass panes are the base's sensor systems used in similar fashion to an airport's radar systems. They keep track of all starships and fighters coming in and out of the Yavin system. You can find a bigger explanation in the 1997 Essential Guide to Weapons and Technology by Bill Smith.

Great video! 🙏🏼

The fake out at the end had me. Well sold. I really thought you were ending the video.

Dude, maybe it was because it was a packed theater and it was the first showing of the day, which means the A/C didn't get turned on right away, but I was sweating by the end of this movie back in 2016. They did such a great job at amping the tension in this movie, and despite knowing that the retrieval of the plans was going to be a success, the journey of making it happen and not knowing what was going to happen next that almost didn't let A New Hope happen was so well done. It's one of the best movies to come from Star Wars since the Disney acquisition. There are a few things I don't love, I can do without Ponda Baba and Evezan, R2 and 3PO's cameo should have been saved for Leia's scene (Like, have a guy give the chip to 3PO and then have him ask Leia what it is if he really must be the focus of a shot.), and I don't need the names of places in the corner if you have literally just told me where the gang was going next, but since you did it for every other planet, why not Mustafar? I know, they wanted to keep it a mystery, but then you might as well not done it for any of the other locations. It's like saying @-@ when you can't do that with any of the other AT vehicles. I demand consistency. But you know, everything else is pretty great. It's what the Sequels should have strived for when it came to making them feel part of the same universe. Just little connections without being a big fuss. This had Prequels, Clone Wars, Rebels, and Original Trilogy stuff littered everywhere amongst all the new stuff, too. That's how it should be done, that's how fan service works. I've heard people say that Rogue One is the best Star Wars movie, and I don't know if I would go that far (It's obviously Return of the Jedi) only because what helps make it so enjoyable is that it has context from all the other stuff that came before so you can appreciate those fan service moments, but it is pretty spectacular and I'm sure that since most of that fan service is well done, it doesn't hinder the movie for people that don't know.

@danielbalfour8493

Жыл бұрын

Mustafar is so iconic that it would be a mockery to viewers to assume they needed a location slide

These instances of neato-ness are interesting in their own right, but I'm digging the unironic enthusiasm too. :)

Why does everyone see "fan service" as a bad thing? I want to see all these things in Star Wars! Bring it on!

That slap was awesome

My favorite moments, the entire movie! Am I crying, yeah I am and I’m not ashamed, it’s freaking beautiful! You had me at the fake ending haha I didn’t actually think you would leave out Vader but maybe doing a special video on just that idk but that was fun.

Re upload? I could have sworn you made a video of this before 😂

@1516Spinola6040

Жыл бұрын

A surprise to be sure. But a welcome one.

He blows into his hand because its cold and rainy and he needs to aim accurately so doesn't want his hand to lock up from the cold. At least that's how I always interpreted it.

I love Chirrut's line "I fear nothing, for all is as the force wills it." I love Jyn's line "May the force be with us." I love the scene from the trailer when Jyn found herself face to face with a tie fighter, but I hate that it wasn't in the movie.

Bor Gullet should be in this, it was a weird choice, but it's an actual interesting idea, that expands further on the long list of Star Wars-Creatures.

Great show!

Awesome list of moments.

Finally, content we can all agree was good

I love the fact that the rowdy, punk rock, rebellion-in-the-streets movie no one expected to be the best of all eleven films turned out to be exactly that. The fight against evil fascism has always, always, always been the core ethos of Star Wars. No movie brings it to life better than Rogue One.

Rouge one has one of my favorite space battle scene. Episode 3 opening was a close second for me but more for nostalgia purposes.

just rewatched it last week

Best Star Wars movie from Disney

I only realized a couple of weeks ago thanks to someone else, but I never noticed Vader’s helmet was in the poster in the Death Star

This film is the Dirty Dozen of Star Wars films and is without doubt my favourite, of the newer films. Can't wait for the TV show.

I like 👍 the video Alex nice job 😊!!!!!!!!

I still don't like that the Tantive IV was even at Scariff. To me Vader should have gotten to the control room just in time to see where the transmission was being sent as Leia was already on her way to get Obi Wan Kenobi... who she doesn't know. My favorite moment is Jyn's escape on Wobani. She doesn't know who wants her but she doesn't care, kicks some ass and makes a break for it only to be immediately grabbed by K2S0 and thrown to the ground, knocking the wind out of her and K2's response was gold.

I love the void 3 d movie with k 2 so hope it comes back was so cool

Hi Alex, I raised this question before but I don’t know if you’ve answered it. It’s great that the bad batch clarified what Project War Mantle is, but here’s the thing, according to K2SO War Mantle, as well as other project code names Jyn read out were in the “schematic bank, data tower 2, structural engineering” within the Scarif archive. I don’t know if anyone else noticed it but clearly phasing out clone troopers does not belong to any type of engineering projects.

Fine, I'll go read the Rogue One novelization Hopefully they do one for Andor after Season 2 airs

3:27 It;s always the little things in Star Wars. Empire wouldn't have fallen if some guy in shield generator hadn't gotten overeager and opened the door without verifying the situation. 16:39 I think he was yawning. That or he was warming his hand up.

This video would be great if the movie's soundtrack played in the b/g. Get those rights! lol

Rogue One was not perfect. However it was obvious Disney put some genuine effort into it. Good story, plus fan service, plus new content, plus a story that tells a story. PS...I loved Tarkins CGI. PPS...Forest Whitaker is a fantastic actor. Clearly he had a small role, yet he was memorable. . He is like Brando. He takes something small and makes it better.

I went to the midnight premiere and it was like 2 am when the movie ended and me and everyone else in the theater stand up and started clapping and the first thing I did after coming home from the theater was to put Netflix and watch A New Hope.

What did Chirrut mean by "I sense that you carry your prison wherever you go"?

@CouncilCape897

Жыл бұрын

He most likely meant that Cassian feels a lot of repressed guilt over many dark decisions he had to take throughout his life. Be it for his personal survival, or in the name of the Rebel Alliance.

Should have just put the whole film and call it a day

Rewatching this post “Plan 99”, and I don’t love seeing Saw anymore. Nope not one bit

OMG Alex! To end a half hour breakdown of the movie and just mention the Vader ship scene being cool and NOT the fact that this was the first time we saw live action full-fledge bad A&$ Vader mow down rebels…..just cruel….you have some dark side in you! ❤ 😈

The entire final act on Scarif was so emotional and epic. It made me truly love these characters who I only knew for an hour or so. It's great that we got to see that the smaller, seemingly unimportant soldiers, or even non-military folks like Chirrut and Baze truly did contribute to saving the galaxy. Also, the Star Destroyers crashing, Raddus mourning the Rogue One's crew, and Darth Vader's rampage are incredible.

Possibly the greatest Star Wars movie.

Rogue One is my favourite movie after Revenge of The Sith.

@quinetastic

Жыл бұрын

I agree! 👍

@MidwestDankAlumni

Жыл бұрын

I only liked 1 prequel, and that was episode 1. I'll watch them all, but don't like them as much.