Everybody Loves Raymond - Vinyl vs CDs
Ойын-сауық
This clip should end the arguments of which is better - Vinyl or Digital?
For more on this subject - check out Kory French's article "Liner Notes: The Vinyl Ritual" on BreakThruRadio. www.breakthruradio.com/index.p...
Пікірлер: 105
The reason Frank likes listening the jazz songs on the records instead of on the cds because the way they sound on the records is the way he remembers them.
@Destroysall
8 жыл бұрын
+Alexander Edward Pytko I think this is the overall truth.
@tynitty516
6 жыл бұрын
No . It's because the record labels that were distributing JAZZ like Blue Note and Prestige used different techniques than you find on CDs. The CDs for Jazz are typically remastered and compressed so you're going to hear the Dynamic range of Brass seem higher than they naturally are. Sometimes the drum dynamics are washed out. THis is common sense in the world of Jazz collecting.
@doctordickheadPhD
5 жыл бұрын
Nuri Abdi I’m sure that’s exactly what Frank Barone was thinking.
@Lookimataco13
5 жыл бұрын
Nuri Abdi تاي طه In time you might understand but for older folks every little sound, not just the music sends them back to their younger days. I've experienced this When I hear old VHS & Cassette tapes being played cause that's what I grew up with. now days you can download stuff from a cloud & stream stuff & add things to your SD Card/computer, it's just not entirely the same
@alexanderpytko5394
3 жыл бұрын
@@tynitty516 Well, hearing them unremastered and uncompressed is the way he remembers them.
What makes this episode great is how it touches on several things. Throughout the whole episode, Frank won’t stop giving Ray crap about how he ruined his jazz record collection so Ray try’s to replace them with CDs which Frank hates. Even though everyone keeps telling Ray to let it go because Frank is clearly the one who cares more about his jazz records then his family, but no Ray has to prove he’s right. Then we get this moment where Frank is totally at peace as he listens to the record playing, showing it’s not just the music, but the nostalgia of when he was younger and listened to them after a hard day. This episode demonstrates how we reminisce about our happy memories and it’s better to let things go then wasting time and energy trying to prove a point, especially when your pain is their pleasure.
The joy on Frank's face from 47 seconds onward makes the scene
It's more of a generational thing than which is better. vinyl records were his day. just like there are people who miss cassette tape players & eventually people will miss compact discs. all the imperfections such as scratches & bumps & sound quality were part of the experience for him not just the music. I know when my dad played his old rock records & cassette tapes it definitely felt like I went back in time.
@Lookimataco13
3 жыл бұрын
@Pete Melon nope
@Lookimataco13
3 жыл бұрын
@Pete Melon I also know from experience, my dad has cassettes & when I hear the sound quality of them it brings me back to when I was 8 or 10. I grew up on cassette, vhs & compact discs as they're called.
They're actually bringing records back. They're even putting present day songs on records as well.
@mattyshredz1071
8 жыл бұрын
even artists nowadays are putting their songs on vinyl.
@alexanderpytko5394
8 жыл бұрын
Mehdi Saad Yeah, my favorite band, Arcade Fire is putting their songs on vinyl.
@mattyshredz1071
8 жыл бұрын
+Alexander Edward Pytko Iron Maiden just released a new album in September on vinyl and CD.
@gpuppy1234
8 жыл бұрын
They havent stopped making records just made limited amounts. now that its popular again there are more records getting pressed so it seems like its a new thing
@gpuppy1234
8 жыл бұрын
+gpuppy1234 i meant to say that they never stopped making records.
The previous scene needs to be included where Raymond blasts the CD player the minute his folks walked through the door. 🔊😳
@elevatorproductionsbymaxpassa
11 ай бұрын
It caused a big mess on the floor.
If a CD was as scratched as that record it would not play at all.
@waynemyatt8262
3 жыл бұрын
If you made a copy of the CD in WAV format - you would be able to have it forever and make as many exact copies as you want onto CD. You can’t say that about vinyl.
Just hearing the needle drop sets my mind at ease.
The ending is somewhat bittersweet. This whole scenario makes you wonder whether Frank would have been less miserable if he hadn't lost the comfort of his records all those years ago. Especially since it comes so near the end of the series.
@jonathanpapadax6064
7 ай бұрын
That's a valid point
I suppose if Ray got Frank a stereo with a record player on it, Frank would stash it in the basement and say he wants to use his old record player.
I always felt it was the connection to the records themselves. Like it was Frank’s connection to life before the Korean War. Though it’s a running gag, it’s implied that frank has some form of ptsd and his jazz records reminded him Of a time before all of that.
Rebuilt 3 different RCA 1950's tube powered phonographs and they are heaven!
Last but not least,,thank you for uploading this video. I thought I was the only one that remembered this!
"Once upon a time, I had great jazz records. Then you were born. The end." LMAO.
they got to clean the needle and the record
My mom and I watched this episode a few days ago. What a riot!
As a musician I play four different instruments I grew up on vinyl when everybody was swapping from the CDs to MP3? I'll take my Hi-Fi stereo vinyl, there isn't really no sound like a HiFi stereo that's about 300 watts and you got a nice needle in a good set of speakers, I like that that was nice., no doubt vinyl has its own sound.
It's like me playing old games when they have remasters. I just enjoy the games on the original platform
I once saw Peter Boyle at the Village Vanguard listening to Dexter Gordon.
@QuietlyCurious
3 жыл бұрын
I once shared an elevator with Doris Roberts in an L.A. Borders bookstore.
@deepanjannag
3 жыл бұрын
Dexter is amazing.
No doubt, that's Webster! His sound is unmistakable.
@deepanjannag
3 жыл бұрын
I'm listening to Webster and Hawkins as I type this comment. Jazz was America's greatest musical contribution to the world.
0:35 Sounds like the last two notes of the music during the end credits of Blue's Clues.
Frank: You should try to keep an open mind about things!" Says the man that has a basement full of stuff that Ray bought him and Marie that they never bothered to use in the first place.
@12Blueace
8 ай бұрын
That’s Frank for you. He will go to any length to piss people off just to feel good about himself.
Sometimes cartridges can go bad not just the stylus vinyl can sound good on right equipment
You moved his records. Unbelievable. You had me suffer for 30 years.
@prideaviles5867
15 күн бұрын
Yes
Those jazz records sound better if they were cleaned with distilled water and a record vacuum stop some of the noise.Looks like old hifi record player guessing. Also when last time stylus was replaced that makes a difference.
@briansmith9698
3 жыл бұрын
@Pete Melon Vinyl is far better better sound better art work
I always wanted to listen to the old records
what kind of radio is that? I used to have one and I'm looking to own it again.
@AceTechHD
5 жыл бұрын
Michael Lane Looks like a basic console unit. Check your local thrift stores, chances are you’ll find one there.
Life long record spinner and I will be till the day I die! It is just to much fun!
the reason why vinyl is better than CD is because it comes directly from the source not digitally downloaded
@dvamateur
8 жыл бұрын
It used to come directly from reel-to-reel master tape, now it comes from Hi-Res digital master on a PC.
@mattyshredz1071
8 жыл бұрын
+Çerastes well no because CD is digitally moved
@mattyshredz1071
8 жыл бұрын
+Çerastes I know what source is
@mattyshredz1071
8 жыл бұрын
Çerastes you have your beliefs I have my beliefs
@Destroysall
8 жыл бұрын
+Mehdi Saad There is no difference. The masters on the two may be different, but one format is not "better" than the other.
Vinyl Records are like Future than CD's.
what`s the name of this song please
@mikeyterry28
4 жыл бұрын
Lucian Marius Bye Bye Blackbird
@elevatorproductionsbymaxpassa
10 ай бұрын
@@mikeyterry28Ben Webster meets Oscar Peterson.
Deffo Ben Webster 🎷
@elevatorproductionsbymaxpassa
6 ай бұрын
Ben Webster meets Oscar Peterson.
i like cds better
Goodbye Willy
Mp3's do not have a chance! You are missing out!
hate hate ray
Посмотрите русскую адаптацию
vinyl sounds way better than digital. 3 things make vinyl sound bad. Scratches,dust,warping
Yeah, the surface noise, pops and clicks, crackle crackle. That's totally unacceptable to me. I can take tape hiss, but no pops and clicks and crackle crackle. I truly don't understand the resurgence of Vinyl. It's unlistenable to me.
@MrChris-zb2bs
9 жыл бұрын
Andrew Piatek Yeah I don't like pops and crackle either. That is a sure sign that the record was not cared for. I have many records in my collection that were pressed in the 60's and 70's and they still are pop and crackle free.
@dvamateur
9 жыл бұрын
Chris Cordova Well, I like the fact that there's been resurgence of vinyl, analog synthesizers, DSD audio, etc. I wouldn't want to be confined to Apple imprisonment where there is no option but their option. So I like all the Hi-Res music push be Neal Young, Sony, and I like the fact that kids buy vinyl. That's a good thing to have more freedom of choice of format I want, not the one that Apple or commercials impose.
@MrChris-zb2bs
9 жыл бұрын
I agree. My system can play most formats except reel-to-reel tape. That just isn't worth it.
@dvamateur
9 жыл бұрын
Chris Cordova Oh, I'd love to have Sony digital multitrack reel-to-reel tape machine, the PCM 3348 from year 1988. Arguably the best audio machine ever produced on this planet
@MrChris-zb2bs
9 жыл бұрын
I actually have a Sony reel-to-reel, but I don't have it connected to anything. It needs new belts as it does not play at the proper speed. I just don't feel like investing in it because my favorite songs are not available in the format. My turntable sounds well more than good enough.
Nice try, EGGASS!