एक विस्तृत विश्लेषण देने के लिये आपको धन्यवाद। अंशुमान तिवारी सर तो हमेशा की तरह हर शीर्षक को विस्तार से समझाते हैं साथ ही शुभम शंखधर सर का भी आभार जो बिल्कुल अनभिज्ञ व्यक्ति की तरह सवाल पूछते हैं तभी सभी पहलुओं का ज्ञान हो जाता है।

साहब कह हो चुके है हमारा।काम नही है व्यापार फैक्ट्री चलाना हम महा मानव है हमारा काम है दुनिया में होने वाले युद्ध रुकवाना बाकि देश की जनता अमीर गरीब यह सब अडानी अंबानी के जिम्मे है

देश का बजट जनता को समर्पित किया जाता है। वास्तविक रूप में बजट कार्पोरेट को दिया जाता है।।।।

नोटबंदी और कोविड एक बार का दर्द था पर जी एस टी लगातार समस्या बनी हुई है और इस पर कायदे क़ानून लगातार बढ़ाय जा रहे हैँ। असंगठित व्यापार लगातार ख़त्म होता जा रहा है।

@brijsaxena7781

Ай бұрын

Dont worry Rahul Gandhi is going to become aur next PM, then he will certainly pull you out of this sad truth.

मोदी जी की फैंकम फांक ही सब से बड़ी उपलब्धि है।

लोगोंके पास पैसा बचता ही नही है. घर, शिक्षा और आरोग्य बहुत मेहंगा हो गयी है. इनकम उतनी जादा बढी नही है. एक नॉर्मल income 18,000 per month पे लोक फॅमिली का खर्च भी नही चला सकते

@gunwantks7460

2 ай бұрын

Ye duniadari Maya hai.sadhu ban jao.bjp middle class ke hi vote se aayi hai.roti ki jagah mandir chuna hai.ab ghanta bajao ayodhya jakar

By chance I watched this programme in August 2023 and since then I have become a regular viewer and a big fan of Anshuman Tiwari ji.

Income tax rates, GST rates should be cut. Then only consumption will. Increase and show in sales figure.

लेकिन गोल्ड और प्रॉपर्टी की लिमिट राजनेता कभी फिक्स नहीं करेंगे क्योंकि 99% तो यह दोनों चीजों का स्टोर वही करते हैं

राज्य सरकारों के कर्ज का लंबे समय तक अर्थव्यवस्था पर नकारात्मक असर रहेगा। क्या केंद्र और राज्य सरकारों को भारत की राजकोषीय नीति में नए बदलाव करने चाहिए?

What an analysis what an analysis logo ko ese samjhaya jaaye toh sarkaaro ko ek minute bina kaam ke rehne naa de . Vaah anshumanji.

Very educative programme

Sir bilkul shi kaha aapne . Humare yahan berojgari pahle se jyada hai. Or pure desh me hi .logo ke pass paise nhi kharch karne ko Toh phir GDP growth tej kyu hai... .. sarkar 2 hi chiz kar rhi hai mahangai or tax tax tax in dono ka bhot bada hath hai GDP growth main

@rajanchauhan6412

Ай бұрын

Inflation world wide badhi hai kisi ek ke jimme nahi badhi. 2008 me bhi toofani mehangai this 10% se upar.

Ye show Bharat ke sabhi educated logon ko dekhna aur samajhna chahiye.

Best program sir aap ki puri team ko salute. Love you all❤❤❤.

भारत में अधिकांश लोगों के पास तो खर्च करने के लिए पैसा है ही नहीं और जिनके पास है उनका एक बड़ा हिस्सा रियल एस्टेट प्रॉपर्टी खरीदने गोल खरीद कर रखा गया है मांग कहां से आएगी कभी नहीं आएगी

बहुत अलग तरीकेसे विश्लेषण होना चाहिए। This way of analysis is suitable for lowly populated and comparatively converse economies.

India is standing with countries like Bangladesh, Kenya, Angola, Haiti, Cote d'Ivoire, Nicaragua, Pakistan, Ghana, Sudan in terms of Households and NPISHs Final consumption expenditure per capita (constant 2015 US$) of Word Bank.

GDP बनाने में GST को भी जोड दिया था सरकार ने, जबकि GDP बनाने में gst को नहीं जोडा जाता ,इसके कारण 1-2% ज्यादा आ गया❤

Sir consumption mahangai badhne karan badha hai mahangai 100 se 200% tak badhi hai gat 10 saal mein government sirf corporate aur Dhani logon ke liye kaam karti hai

@radhakrishnamishra2124

2 ай бұрын

True vo hi election bond dete hai

Rural area 7000 13000 rupees. Monthly salary.

Results are as expected. Income of people, spending pattern also increased. Inflation has also increased.

बिते 10 साल में जीतने भी लोग खेती छोडकर चले गये उन्हे रोजगार नहीं मिला और बेरोजगारी ज्यादा बढी..

Very Important discussion. Thank you.

Brilliant observations.Good analysis Anshuman ji and Shubhamji 🫡🙏

मोदी देश को 10 साल पीछे छोड़ दिया लेकिन अंध भक्त को नही दिखेगा 😂

@Fekuchand_

2 ай бұрын

70 साल पीछे ले गया

@Prithvichouhan406

2 ай бұрын

..ha desh main ghutala sarkare 70 saal se vikas he to kar rhe thi...ek se bada ghutala karke😂😂

@rajeshkumarchaudhary3729

2 ай бұрын

@@Prithvichouhan406 aa gaya bhakt 😍

@Rainbow..7

2 ай бұрын

100 saal pichhe le Gaya hai unpadh...desh ka Paisa loot kar apne mitron mein bant diya...

@Prithvichouhan406

2 ай бұрын

@@rajeshkumarchaudhary3729 ...chamche ko milne😃😃😃

Awesome explanation, too much clarity got from this video about Indian expenditure.

गाँव में भी इलेक्टिशियन,राज मिस्त्री, सेनेट्री, व्हाइट वाश,खेत में गेहूं काटने ,खेती से संबंधित किसी भी काम के लिए बुलाते हैं तो बड़ी मुश्किल से मुंह मांगे दिहाड़ी पर काम करने को तैयार होते हैं। आप कागजी आंकड़े का गाना गा रहे हो !

This channel should be viewed by each an every citizen

Hats of sir,very good information, thank you

अच्छा होगा यदि आप निवेशकों के लिये भी एक एपिसोड बनाये. लम्बी अवधि मध्यम अवधि के लिये. धन्यवाद.

Anshumanji and shubham , You are great

Excellent Analysis.

Sir Tex बहुत लगाता है। खाने के लिऐ पैसा नही है। जॉब भी नही लग रही है। 10 हजार की जॉब में हजार रूपए भी नही बच रहा है। गाड़ी के लिए शादी करना पड़ेगा। दहेज़ में शायद मिल जाए।

Sirji , बहुत practical बात बताई है,आप जो बोल रहे वो बिल्कुल भी सच से परे नही है। मेरे पास भी आप लोगो से शेयर करने के लिए कई बात व DATA है । बताये DIRECT कैसे शेयर करू

Knowledgeable video

Great information

In the comparison of villages and cities Food and other We must have daily transport or travel expenses parameter too Because this is a major factor of urban living Only then, we will understand the true picture Also This will help people decide in shift from rural to urban living 🎉🎉

Surya Narayan ji lagta hai iss program ko seriously nahi dekh rahe the.unka jawab isi program mein ansuman sir bata diyA tha mahngai(inflAtion) badhne se GST badh gaya. Jaise chijon ke daam agar dogune hogaye aur GST 18 percentage agar 100 krore aata tha to ab 200 korore ayega..

Very interesting And informative

Valuable content, thank you sir

There is need of separate price index to measure Service Inflation other than CPI?

Eye opener 🙏

This is very good topic and your explanation touch my heart ❤️❤️

This feels necessary to feel the CHANGE in time coming. Yea

हमारे देश में एक संगठन है ,आपके आंकड़े उस संगठन के सोच बिहार के बिलकुल ठीक अनुरूप है ऐसा ही तरक्की चाहिए

Sir, Thank you for the fantastic explanation of the consumption of our country. This is Gold.

Anshuman ji well done 👍

Good information sir thank you

Always pleasure to hear❤❤

Dear Money9, A question for Economicom. Central Govt debt has increased by approx 110 lakh crore in last 10 years. At broad level it seems bulk of it has gone into building infrastructure. Which means it has gone into construction industry and to large number of people as compensation for land acquisition. Then how come all this money is not fuelling demand and consumption. Is it possible that this money got directed into stock markets and most of it lost to big sharks in F&O and crypto trades.

Msme aur mnrega ko बढ़ावा देने से डिमांड को बढ़ाया जा सकता है, हर ग्रेजुएट को अप्रेंटिस देने से भी हालात में सुधार आएगा,be possitive, धन्यवाद

Well done 👍

income bhi badhani chahiye... employment bhi deni chahiye... ajib baat hai real estate ke prices abhibhi badh rahe hai.... slow down toh hona chahiye tha...

Good analysis sir ji😊

दुःखद स्थिति, चिंता का विषय

Anshuman ❌ Superman✅

@agrotechhindi

2 ай бұрын

❤

Very nice analysis.

Bhi MAINE TO AAJTAK YEHI SUNA JUB DEMAND JAYADA HO TO PRICE UPPER JATA HAI...YEH APP KON SI ECONOMIC BATA RHE HAI KE DEMAND KUM HAI ISLEYE PRICE JAYADA HO GYE MEDICATIONS KI...JARA BATANA

Also please In all your financial presentation include consumption per unit in quantity terms too Because Rupees analysis alone, becomes illusionary due to inflation and currency devaluation Thanks 🎉🎉

अब समय आ गया है कि देश के आम लोग समझें कि उनके साथ चल क्या रहा है. कहां जा रहा है उनका पैसा? मंदिर-मस्जिद जात पात के झगड़े से बाहर निकलें और अपने भविष्य के बार में सवाल करें. मैं देश का युवा हूं और जब ये स्थिति देखता हूं तो सोचता हूं भविष्य कैसा होगा. आपके द्वारा उठाए गए सभी सवाल जायज हैं. लोगों को सवाल जरूर पूछना चाहिए.

@Prithvichouhan406

2 ай бұрын

Ha phir vahi ghutala sarkare aa ke desh ka odhar kege😂😂

Question to Anushman Sir, Why IT companies are not coming out of silent layoffs (micro layoffs). Job markets seems frozen. It can't be the only AI who is responsible. Please explain the reasons and when we can see openings as usual in future. Indian IT market is mostly service export oriented sector. Does it has linkage with low spending power of Indian masses. Please Include the question.

@bollywoddance1194

2 ай бұрын

The problem is not AI.... Koi toh desh ki sampatti loot raha hai.....hmm. kaun ho sakta hai........

भारत में गोल्ड और प्रॉपर्टी की लिमिट फिक्स कर दी जाए सभी समस्याओं का एकमात्र समाधान हो जाएगा

Also 🎉 The real situation is much much worse Because We have this data in dollar terms and rupees terms These are Fiat currency If We do the same analysis in value of gold terms It will be an eye opener far all, We will feel like crying and curse even the best government of all times, This is the real sad truth of our country and people 🎉🎉 Thanks

Facts of our economy

Demand is more than previous years

There are some numbers for per person and few are per family... comparison can be done with same base

Sir India me 850 ton lag bhag gold h . And haderabad ke nava. Hi lag bhag 150 ton gold leke bhag Gaya tha 13 trucks me. Is ke upar bhi 1 News video kijiye. And gold ki asliyat bhi bataiye ki logo ko gold bata ki petal becha. Ja rha h. 🙏🙏🙏

Manmohan Singh Jo kar gaye, narender ne sab barwa dita.

So consumption is constant to economy What is wrong in it. It will always be constant why will it outgrowth economy In last few year population is not growing fastly and growth is driven by exports that should be good

The clear thing is that it has only increased the income of the government.

Dhaga khul gaya😊

The expense on government advertising on any particular scheme is much more than that of the scheme itself. This tells where the money is going to.

In Bangalore lakhs of people are spending 1.5 to 2 lakh per month

वाह तिवारी जी ने सरकारों के झुठ का कच्चा चिट्ठा खोल कर रख दिया अब संभावना है की ईडी ओफिस में आपकी फ़ाइल तैयार हो गई है

Sir you are giving information is right but see the change in dollar rupees equation . Sir people are spending there income in gambling and liquor and in stock markets assuming that stock market will make them crore Pati. Which is a big gambling.

If remove 2% of top rich in India we are equivalents to countries like Somalia chad south sudan central african republic

It foolishness to do COMPARISON WITH OTHER COUNTRIES. BEST OF YOUR STUDIES IS YOUR KNOWLEDGE FOR DOING CHANGES IN POLICY IN OUR COUNTRY.

Consumption will only increase if taxes are cut & income tax is reduced. Plus govt has to make housing, education and healthcare affordable for a person earning Rs 20,000 a month. 40:32 41:06

How do one co relate the consumption with continuous increase in real estate prices ? While capital spending by the govt is leading to increase in GST collection may also be contributing to increased corruption which is leading to real estate price increase. So high country debt and increased taxation burden has not done any good to common man

जनसंख्या नियंत्रण बहुत जरूरी है |

if prices of commodities are rising nationwide then lower-income states are suffering more than people living in the city

Introduction is too long. Let there be important info, trends and implications. Thanks to both of you.

Sir, shouldn't the comparison between world consumption figure and Indian consumption figure be on PPP basis? Thanks !

Khapat ki savings humari share market mai jaa rhi h sir😊

Dikta ye hai Abadi jadaa vahaa prsaa jadaa

Petrol ke daam adhe kar do , khapat ka pahiya chal parega. To start the consumption cycle, cut petrol prices by half.

@lokeshchoubey2634

2 ай бұрын

तू अपने अरबी अब्बाजानों से कह आधी कीमत पर पेट्रोलियम दें

The program has to be watched 2-3 times before we get the feel of reality.

Next PM must be economist because भारत is cunsumer country

🎉🎉

Anshiman ji The consumption of house hold is directly proportional to the income and inversly proportional to the inflation, considering that the employment opportuinities in INDIA have declined The present Govt have failed to geberate more employment opportuinities and the focus of govt. is more of distributing free ration that is putting an excess burden on the govt. the govt should rather focus on generating more job opportuinities with decent earnings and shold focus on decreasing the inflation. Cewrtain policies of the present Govt. has also boost in creating monopoly in the market hence creating more challanges in unorganised sector.

koi baat nahi... log wait kar rahe hai 15 lakh account mein aane ka. ;)

This comparison is totally wrong. Today in canada packet of potato wafer 235 gms is 6.25 canadian dollars means 387 rupees. So their consumption is high in dollars and they are all dependent on readymade food. In Canada normal man is hungry as compared to India on today. This scenario is also in US and Europe. In one month price of petrol hikes 30 % in Toronto Canada. So India is too much better condition as compared to US, Canada,Europe etc. This is my experience from Canada. People have no money to eat enough and proper food in Canada.

India needs 8 to 10 percent of GDP growth to reduce unemployment. GDP per capita is more important than the total value of GDP.

@profarmer9087

2 ай бұрын

अब ग्रोथ बड़ने से रोज़गार नही बड़ने वाला, ai आ गई है, दोस्त, एक सीधा सा उधारण सड़क मार्ग का बाडिया विस्तार हुआ लेकीन टोल प्लाजा से व्यक्ति गायब हो रहे हैं वहा टेक्नॉल्जी आ रही हैं

@ashishjoshi4061

2 ай бұрын

@@profarmer9087 Still RBI report itself is saying that India GDP needs to grow at 8 to 10 percent to fight unemployment. To achieve this growth, Government needs to invest money on infrastructure and research and development and manufacturing.

Kindly tell us the saving data vis a vis consumption

Aaj kal ye tranding hai Modi ji ecomomy ko paar laga dege😂 Very informative videos 🎉

@Prithvichouhan406

2 ай бұрын

Bhi yeh log America ke sab se bade bank ke ceo JP MORGAN JAIME DIMON..SE JAYADA JANTE HO JO MODI KO CREDIT DE RAAHA INDIA KI PROGRESS KI

13:45

Sir over all government Kitana expense kar Rahi he as per including all scheme avarage per parson

Actually we r in stagflation,if v c real inflation fig,and gdp,per cap.income..u will feel it

Where did the money go Answer is The money in hands of people is directly proportional to the number of times the money circulated in one year in the economy This circulation has gone down to 30% or even less ( perception) 🎉