Chair is so chilled bruh😂

@ndikxxndimande5542

4 жыл бұрын

Chilled A. F

Im dead 😂😂😂when the Chair says to Sonti uHonorable member asingo Baba lo and the way Sonti says ohh ngu honourable yeah sorry uxolo... kills me😂😂

@musasamelasoncasenduli1086

4 жыл бұрын

I laughed such a way that I've listened to that a thousand times, still can't get enough.

It's not an issue of language. It's a matter of wasting time and shifting attention from the matters of corruption. However; it must be acknowledged that the translation devices should consist of more than just English and Afrikaans. This gross lack of langauge assistance will just lead to communication difficulties. And it's clear everyone here needs all the help they can get.

Madame speaker manages to keep calm though bless her. Not an easy job.

@FreddyTams

5 жыл бұрын

She is so matured with experience

@angelachristie26

4 жыл бұрын

Steenhuuzen has a point

@Ivanus59

4 ай бұрын

She's too old for this stuff.

Our country is full of hate

@siphomogale779

5 жыл бұрын

@Becky Britin I don't know but it never end

@maryduplessis2510

5 жыл бұрын

It is manufactured by these people.

@maryduplessis2510

5 жыл бұрын

@@leratotanya1123 still trying to push generational guilt? Yawn....

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

Mary Du Plessis You continue to benefit from the 500 years of cruelty and we continue to carry its scars. No generational guilt here in my opinion.

@maryduplessis2510

5 жыл бұрын

@@peachfm9377 so what yawn. I could point out all the flaws in your self entitled little speech but it is really getting boring.

EFF don't respect anyone... it's a great circus!!!

@nitromania5827

10 ай бұрын

The only growing major political party in the whole of South Africa. That's the circus you're referring to

@AscendingGoogle123

2 күн бұрын

@@nitromania5827 This did not age well...

she is right .no white man who learn black languages

@emilenauta9825

5 жыл бұрын

Learning doesn't equal respecting though :/

@VeronicaCrawford-er2td

2 күн бұрын

Many white people can speak a black language a lot a black people can speak Afrikaans so stop your false nonsense

but other 9oficial languages are undermined if on two translations are on the device

@RastaAfricanGentleman

3 жыл бұрын

Coddesa agreements are long lasting

If you disrespect my language you also disrespect me. Dont expect anything from me either .....

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

If you have the opportunity to choose which language you want to learn then you are racially privileged.🙂

@ibrahimgassama8362

5 жыл бұрын

It's barbarism your language .

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

@@ibrahimgassama8362 English was and still is regarded as a superior language and is therefore forced upon us. non native speakers have the choice to either learn our native languages or not

@joaquinfonseca4858

3 жыл бұрын

@@peachfm9377 wtf whats the connectuon between racial privilege and choosing a language?!?

if Mama Mokwele wants respect, she should show respect... Also, the ANC has been in power for ages... had no time to get interpretation services for all official languages? Is this the first time someone brought it up? :D

@kingabstract2695

3 жыл бұрын

Considering South Africa's histrory I'm not surprised

EFF with unnecessary animosity...

@RastaAfricanGentleman

3 жыл бұрын

A good question is why do we have two translations in a 9 official languaged country? This undermines the Africans and I truly understand why you don't see it because the system has made us desensitized to this issue. It makes no sense that you go to a police station to make an affidavit and they want to write it in English in a township.

I love afrikaans from cape town

Well... if, after 25 years, the black majority did not vote for a larger translation budget and keep having only 2 languages at their parliament, the afrikaners are no longer to blame.

@aweleo.1220

2 жыл бұрын

The white people monopolise the economy. 25 years v 350 years my dear

I am French, some of my ancestors were brought by the Dutch in SA, then chose to return to France when their religion was no longer a threat to them, more than a century ago, so I may not be South African, I keep following what happens there. I also work for an airline. Everytime I leave SA my aircraft has Afrikaners emigrating to Europe, I help them fill their paperwork, we get to chat a little. They keep paying for something they did not do, as, for the most part, they weren’t even born when Apartheid was a thing. Rainbow Nation my a..

@aweleo.1220

2 жыл бұрын

Poor them, it must have been so hard for them... Right?

@thato596

Жыл бұрын

There were not even born? Do you think apartheid happend 1000 years ago? Millions of South Africans who lived during apartheid are still alive today including the people you see in that parliament

She called Afrikaans an "understepping language". The English dude said that as 11 languages are official and with equal status, that was inappropriate. She then goes to say she doesn't respect, on the basis that neither speak each others languages. In the end, it became a lost in translation kinda thing, with a kick of historical animosity. Not gratuitous, but could have been addressed in a different way. The issue was lack of translators, not historical oppression (at that moment).

Oh my.. she can’t even speak her own language 😂😂😂😂😂 I am not shocked but shoket 😂

@tfmkhonza5084

4 жыл бұрын

She was angry so no words easy to come out

@tfmkhonza5084

4 жыл бұрын

One language for Africans Swahili

Isn't she the same lady was shouting "don't call me a straw man"? In any case, if you don't respect a constitutionally recognized language, an d in the parliament out of all places, anywhere else in the world you would've lost your seat

I'm shocked that after rejecting to withdraw their statement the speaker didn't ask the member of parliament to leave.

What about us who want to hear what he is saying freedom front plus, thanda ukuzenza ngcono

@mhlengimathews211

5 жыл бұрын

Why vele ama black engakhulum eyabo i language

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

Bayanya laba. 😑 if we were to speak ours they would complain.

@christoffdebeer1233

4 жыл бұрын

I kind off agree to this. You want to get a msg across but you know no one there already isn't listening so now it just sounds like noises. Making it just worse. This house is already full of hate and race hatred. I believe everyone should love their language. But atleast if you want those who hate you to like you atleast try and find common ground.

5:13 Amen. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. ~Jesus Christ

Why isn't she expelled from the House?

Mmm this language is disturbing indeed 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

@netherlands7534

3 жыл бұрын

What is wrong with you all?

@sephulanomsa1789

3 жыл бұрын

This history of that language thats what disturbing

@netherlands7534

3 жыл бұрын

@@sephulanomsa1789 its only a language lol

@cdcarelse796

3 жыл бұрын

@@sephulanomsa1789 Yet you are typing in your colonial Master's language ok sisi you see the irony here? All languages have history attached to them

It is very wroooooooong not to have our African languages in Parliament.

@xhalanga

5 жыл бұрын

True

@hyakintos

4 жыл бұрын

Afrikaans is african language! It's language of people who built your country. You can condemn apartheid but South Africa is now one of the most modern countries in the world. It would not be possible without people who speak Afrikaans.

@ludwembam303

3 жыл бұрын

@Bastian 96 You speak rubbish this time. Boers killed our people and you are still saying that nonsense?

@naomimothekge1135

3 жыл бұрын

You are out of order. This country initially belonged to the black africans. It is WELL WITHIN THEIR RIGHTS to speak their AFRICAN languages...

Come on Black people. Let's allow Afrikaners to speak their language and use it whenever or however they feel like. We have our own languages to do the same to. It is important to stick, use and promote your language. We don't seem to understand that. When people are using theirs we complain because we don't have an understanding of how important one's language is. Still now, after 25 years of freedom from apartheid and the colonialisation, we don't have an answer to the language question. We will only understand why Afrikaners are so proud and defensive of Afrikaans when we have come up with an answer to the language question that we keep sweeping under the carpet despite it constantly haunting us.

@andrevanas85

5 жыл бұрын

Everyone should be free to speak in their mother tongue in parliament. The issue here is that they dont have all the relevant translators, an issue that has been raised before but still has not been resolved.

@lordbane729

5 жыл бұрын

"We will only understand why Afrikaners are so proud and defensive of Afrikaans when we have come up with an answer to the language question that we keep sweeping under the carpet despite it constantly haunting us.".......I can PROMISE you that the same situation exists in other countries.

@xhalanga

5 жыл бұрын

@@lordbane729 really? 🤔

@lordbane729

5 жыл бұрын

@@xhalanga Yes. Canada, USA, Belgium, France, Finland, Ukraine, China, India, the list goes on and on.

@xhalanga

5 жыл бұрын

@@lordbane729 What same situation exists in other countries?

I am from the United States and I see something interesting here. There’s a lot of hate. There and here. Troubling

@NellyMfeka

5 жыл бұрын

...and there’s love between different races in the US🤨🤨

@juliusmaehlich3138

5 жыл бұрын

@@MrSweetaz Yes, you are right. Koeberg, the nuclear power station is on the verge of blowing up, Eskom is down the drain, hospitals are non functioning, roads are in a terrible state, murder and theft is sky high and everything in S A is in shambles and all the EFF members can discuss is about one of the official languages they hate. EFF consists of a bunch of non constructive hooligans and illiterate idiots whose main aim is to disrupt Parliament meetings with their stupid, idiotic, mental behaviour.

@carlmiller369

5 жыл бұрын

MrSweetaz go back to your cave

@grahamt5924

5 жыл бұрын

@@gameZA40 What people do with that hatred is a problem. She is showing that she is never going to respect a people that happen to speak Africaans. This is a leader in the house who's views are obviously shared by other respected leaders in the house. This is how a genocide happens. It's very telling how widespread her views are and once these views become so widespread that she can spout them in such a public forum without someone who she respects chastising her and making her realise how dangerous this can be, things are going to get worse. Her leader is calling for the throats of whiteness to be slit on stage and she is calling for anyone who is Africaans to be disrespected.

@thekgi1349

5 жыл бұрын

If you don't like this country you must leave.

What is the name of the chairperson in this video ?

This parliament is never short of drama

ask myself these questions in the last 25 years, who more racist blacks or whites?who encourages race violence the most black or white?who spreads the most hate speech openly and confidently black or white? what is more, black on white murder? or white on black murder? who has benefited from government policies the most black or white? if you live in south Africa you will know this answer

Respect Afrikaans for who for what

@strongertogether3890

5 жыл бұрын

Haha you dont have to respect the language you idiot..you respect the person regardless of language

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

More than 500 years in Africa and most fail to even utter a single word in any native language. Even a phonic sound is difficult yet We are forced to know the languages of races considered as superior while ours are undermined by not being learned.

@dominiquebeaulieu

4 жыл бұрын

@David Miles Why English? It is imperialism language.

@nandadulaldas3221

3 жыл бұрын

@David Miles Africans are also colonisers of South Africa they aren't indigenous either

@nandadulaldas3221

3 жыл бұрын

@David Miles agreed mate I've heard some indigenous people say that they aren't black and shouldn't be called black

Why don't they just speak English, how are speakers elected, because she does not have a good command of English?.....was English not used to conquer the world? This is pure comedy

@MrSweetaz

5 жыл бұрын

Its tragic that these are the people elected to run a country

Even though I am an Afrikaans-speaking person, I strongly disagree with the use of Afrikaans in parliament. From a practical standpoint, it just doesn't make any sense - not everyone in parliament understands Afrikaans, just like everyone doesn't understand Zulu, Xhosa, or Sotho. So therefore, insisting on speaking Afrikaans despite it not being universally understood is extremely inconsiderate and rude to other members of parliament.

@nitromania5827

10 ай бұрын

So what about members who don't understand English?

@JJ-ZUMA

8 ай бұрын

@@nitromania5827 Everybody understands English.

@Bibirallie

7 ай бұрын

@@nitromania5827well learn it or use translators. But foolish to think you are the center of the world, especially when you are only a minority.

And please do not get me wrong, of course the fact that isiXhosa, isiZulu, seSotho, etc. not being an option in Parliament is a major problem. That is undebatabl. It cannot be that today the native people of the country are excluded from discussions and debates in Parliament. That is a major no no.They should have fixed that on the spot, because majority of our people speak native languages and it is not fair nor is it acceptable that they can't understand someone else that is speaking their native tongue. And abelungu need to start learning African languages, that's my belief.

@lefetawasemzantsi6102

5 жыл бұрын

@Simon Jr. Prince I don't know what you read. So was where was I wrong in my comment? I didn't touch on anything that you mentioned, but you're accusing me of saying that Africa is not for Africans? And that is based on me saying that Native Languages in Parliament is a must and is non-negotiable and that abelungu learning native languages is what should happen? That equates me to being "a Mandela"? Wow, I am so confused. Please balance me, and quote me where I have defended Afrikaans or amaBhulu in any way. haha hayi, I am so lost.... please send location.

@lefetawasemzantsi6102

5 жыл бұрын

@David Miles Yes, Afrikaans was birthed in Africa. But I do believe that just as we are forced to learn English, just so that we can attend university, they should also learn a Black African language. How is it that white and Indian South Africans can be satisfied with only knowing English? Before schools offer French, Spanish, Greek, or whatever, they must start at home. Native Black languages should be encouraged upon all students. That is just my belief. I hope you respond without attacking me.

@richern2717

5 жыл бұрын

What is interesting and very few people know is that the abelungu learned different African Languages according to the region in which they went to school during the Apartheid era. I had Setswana till Matric/Grade 12. This apparently changed after 1994...

@lefetawasemzantsi6102

5 жыл бұрын

Simon Jr. Prince I agree with you completely. South Africa and Africa as a whole will thrive no matter what. White people leaving South Africa or the continent will not be the end of us. That threat does not make us shake in our boots. We will survive and we will succeed

@lordbane729

5 жыл бұрын

@David Miles I was always under the impression that "Afrikaans" is a derivative of Dutch mainly and is NOT an AFRICAN language.

Can we get a legal expert to help on this matter!! Seems everyone is confused, must MPs add sugar to the peach mix or just bottle it?

@hectord2032

5 жыл бұрын

@Sabal Guema Awono ... I hear you, but !!

Ons sal nooit saam staan

Syabonga Cc angeke sihloniphe isibhunu nismele njalo kondlebe zikhanya ilanga

If you had respect for everyone language then the only two languages can't be English and Afrikan especially in an African parliament 🔥

EFF is a very fun party, always to laugh heartily. Of course, you can't take the EFF seriously, but it's funny.

What about black people who speak Afrikaans as their 1st language they're not welcomed in EFF? We talking Rowen Williams, Benni McCarthy, Steven Pinner etc .

@chrisnaicker55

5 жыл бұрын

@The Plague Firmino that's because we are not my fiend we have our own culture. A lot of black Africans don't like it which is fine however they can fuck right off.

@theconfusedoromo5361

5 жыл бұрын

@@chrisnaicker55 what culture? yeah you are mixed, but hate your blackness, gtfoh

@theconfusedoromo5361

5 жыл бұрын

@Sabal Guema Awono good answer.

@moreovermore17

5 жыл бұрын

Yes

@thembisibanyoni4435

5 жыл бұрын

@SA MUSIC so Muhammad Gaddafi was not an Africa because he wasn't dark skin like you?

The chair woman has the patience of a saint.

What's the social situation on South Africa so as to the parlamientary acts like that?

This "fosting" business wont survive these sittings😂😂

@BigMeech1

5 жыл бұрын

Kikiki I also heard that one

05:59 What is that language? I'm from Latin America and I have no idea, sorry🤷🏿‍♀️

I can't see Hon Julius Malema, Where is he, I guess he should have came up with better solution,

@gideonmosia

5 жыл бұрын

It's good he was not there we can't afford being suspended all the time and leave the decisions to be taken in our absence as we got the most effective and intellectual representatives

Most native speakers of Afrikaans are not white.

@alastairaspara4554

5 жыл бұрын

It was a mandatory form of oppression.

@reeds5160

5 жыл бұрын

@@alastairaspara4554 so was english in many countries around the world but no one calls it disturbing

@stoneomountain2390

5 жыл бұрын

@@alastairaspara4554 then why did the "freedom fighters" use Afrikaans as their preferred language in their training camps, when they all could speak another common language.

@tiagodasilvabelo7391

5 жыл бұрын

@@gustavozar5365 why do we have to be racist me bleed the same we are just another skin why you have to be like that

@maryduplessis2510

5 жыл бұрын

@@alastairaspara4554 no.... It was made out to be a mandatory form of oppression by communists. That is how communism works.... Make a scapegoat, cause disruption and violence then shout poor me we are the victim when there is a reaction so that it gives others false ideas of what the situation is. .... If it wasn't race it would be... Short people, fat people, rich people, beautiful people, gay people, ugly people..... And the list can be infinite. Get real.

I don't think Hon Chair she will make it, this 2019. She'll see flames

@msantos321

5 жыл бұрын

lol

Yesssie what's the speaker saying 💀😂😂😂😂

We do not have to like a certain language, but you do not have to disrespect that language. If a white honourable member stood up and said "I do not respect isiXhosa/isiZulu/seSotho..." that member would be howled at by the black honourable members. We cannot have double standards. Afrikaans is part of the 11 Official Languages. I do not speak Afrikaans, nor am I interested in it, but I have no reason or right to disrespect it. As umntu that is not Zulu, do I have the right to say "Andis'funi isiZulu." Also, what message is she sending to millions of viewers and listeners? Soon, black people will have a negative outlook towards ALL Afrikaners, which will solidify the negative stance soooome Afrikaans people have against abantu abamnyama, and where will lead to after that? Unnecessary racial wars (the most extreme outcome). We don't have to llike each other, kodwa ke noko masihloniphane.

@hamza-Timi

5 жыл бұрын

You are so right...

@lefetawasemzantsi6102

5 жыл бұрын

@@gustavozar5365 enkosi for your matured and open-minded attack.. yho, I mean response, partly in another colonisers language. Speaking respect and truth does not mean standing up for abelungu or Afrikaans and does not translate to traitor. Clearly you do not see the manoeuver that is being played here. But ke, maybe being educated got the better of me, or "fukked" up as you put it so nicely. I'm just thinking about how it was our first Democratic Black President that was smart enough to know that you have to speak the colonisers language to be able to think like him. I remember Julius Malema, Commander-in-Chief of the EFF, saying that he can think like the enemy, because he can speak the enemy's language.

@lefetawasemzantsi6102

5 жыл бұрын

@@hamza-Timi me or the first person that responded?

@hamza-Timi

5 жыл бұрын

@@lefetawasemzantsi6102 You

@lefetawasemzantsi6102

5 жыл бұрын

Gustavo ZAR ekse ndigqibile apha mna ngoku. Ndiphumile kuwe nalencoko. Yonke into oyithethayo oyicingayo yinyani , 100%. Andizuphikisana nawe on KZread, ndibhadlile mna. Futhi you’re not here to have a constructive discussion or give a constructive opinion, which would have been nice. Wena uze apha to type out your anger, it seems like. Soooo, enkosi for your input. Shap broer.

I pray for this beautiful land... I speak the blood of Jesus upon its inhabitants. May your Mercy flow lord and may your salvation find it self in the heart of every individual in this country , lord. I speak against darkness hovering upon this nation, I speak against confusion, rape, hate speech , racial discrimination, corruption, & crime in this beautiful land, South Africa shall see the Goodness of the Lord. Heavenly Father Remember this land. In Jesus's Name I prayer 🙏

You know that language.

This old Chair wa Magogo is Going to see flames

@rennieshady8559

5 жыл бұрын

😂😂

@edwillfourie4280

5 жыл бұрын

😂 Yes, she will indeed.

@gideonmosia

5 жыл бұрын

Is this the best the anc got ?

@sphiwegoodwill4396

5 жыл бұрын

Yes she will

@sphiwegoodwill4396

5 жыл бұрын

@@gideonmosia lol lol

How could you respect a language that you don't understand hysuka Afrikaans yokunuka la

@shashikanaidoo5553

5 жыл бұрын

I do not speak the 11 official languages ... but respect them all because languages are a beautiful thing...

@1EaglehunterGaming1

5 жыл бұрын

Tbh english should only be spoken, no other languages should be spoken because it will be too complicated and people will get pissed off. On the point of ‘respecting’ the language, its understandable why people wouldn’t respect afrikans, yes it is the language spoken of previous oppressors so of course there will be hard feelings, but then again the english oppressed us too and here we are speaking majority english. So its fine to get angry at someone speaking in a language you don’t understand but don’t simply disrespect a language because of its past, otherwise we wouldn’t respect 90% of language in the world.

@thekgi1349

5 жыл бұрын

There are many people who do not understand english or Afrikaans.Just because you and me understand this language we should not deny our grandmothers and other people to understand parliament or to work in parliament.

This is why people should be nice to each other at all times. You never know when the oppressed will gain power and seek revenge. This is a nightmare situation. Feelings are still raw and white South Africans have only themselves to blame.

@maryduplessis2510

5 жыл бұрын

Who is oppressing you? The only thing oppressing is the government who after 25 years has dropped the standard of living of all people in South Africa. Bring facts and statistics. The stats say different.

there should be no translators then everyone must be forced to use their language and see who is going to suffer most

@sowhat1273

5 жыл бұрын

Siyabonga

@zakhemgenge4568

5 жыл бұрын

nath but to be honest Afrikaans is not African language it more of Dutch even English is not African language the thing is ANC has been sympathizing with whites for too long to the point they think they are Africans

@zakhemgenge4568

5 жыл бұрын

Gustavo ZAR 😂😂😂 nyi!!

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

Porter Maxwell doesn’t make it more important.

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

zakhe Mgenge too much 😑 and this thing must end with us. We are tired of choosing between English or Afrikaans as our first additional language in school. We want more options.

A disgrace to humanity.

@dominiquebeaulieu

4 жыл бұрын

@Mthuthuzeli Musa You prefer dictatorship of traditional chiefs?

@eoghan-uk9yi

4 жыл бұрын

@Mthuthuzeli Musa watch european parliaments, this kind of time wasting nonsense never happens

@wandiledlamini4860

3 жыл бұрын

@Mthuthuzeli Musa 😂😂😂🤣🤣 so true

Mokwele will certainly be missed.. She realy packed a punch 👊.. Although sometimes she flew of the handle but my my Eff has lost a pillar of strength.. Apartheid is long gone but the damage its done,will ego for centuries..

2:25 😂😂🤣😅

mama Mokwele o bua nnete tota

@matsosomsetho9720

4 жыл бұрын

This white guy is full of masepa

@drewbranch7700

4 жыл бұрын

It’s funny I am Learning Setswana and i can understand that 🤣

Looool 😂😂😂auc oo yess mojwetse

A very wise chairperson and no respect from those shouters who call themselves MP's.

When the serious national matters on desk no time for playing!!! South Africa home of all lead by samples not by color!!!

@mandingpeace3240

5 жыл бұрын

Carmen Fox you don't understand, am not telling you about language!!!

As a Dutch person I think it's shocking to see the hate towards Afrikaans in the comments... It feels really awkward, cause it's a daughter language of Dutch 😅 I even saw a comment calling it a 'barbaric' language, the disrespect 🥺 However, I do agree that it's weird the only two languages available for translation are English and Afrikaans 🤔

@netherlands7534

3 жыл бұрын

Dude ze willen 5 miljoen blanke afmaken we moeten er wat tegen doen als nederland

@jerrakhalifa

3 жыл бұрын

Wit*

@lelobikitsha8144

2 жыл бұрын

Die mense huil omdat die hek oop gemaak by die bal

@aninternetuser2074

2 жыл бұрын

It is ugly and barbaric

@TSGC16

2 жыл бұрын

@@aninternetuser2074How is it barbaric

Dis sooo lekker om Afrikaans te wees

@misstee7403

5 жыл бұрын

Ek stem nie saam nie, maar hoe weet ek, huh?

@misstee7403

5 жыл бұрын

@@leeuvegter5810 ek weet, dit was net 'n grapie domkop

@MrSweetaz

5 жыл бұрын

Stem saam, as ons nou net one eie land ook kon kry sodat ons nie moet hierdie houtkop kak tyd te mors nie. Hulle spandeer 80% van die tyd in parlement met hierdie stront, verbeel jou net hoeveel werk kan gedoen word sonder die kak?

@KingofgraceSARA

6 ай бұрын

Dutch.

Mama Jane though..😶

The "Fosting " lady will not survive..she's so slow

Ek is Filipina en ek verstaan Afrikaans.

@KingofgraceSARA

6 ай бұрын

🍪

exactly all respected

honorable mokwele we miss you already

Haai Wena ek is Coloured en dai is onse taal...

@pieterprinsloo7616

5 жыл бұрын

LordBane you're sick

@lordbane729

5 жыл бұрын

@@pieterprinsloo7616 The TRUTH always sounds that way, especially to the ignorant and unwashed, like you !

@pieterprinsloo7616

5 жыл бұрын

LordBane look at you being a racist

@tshiamishogopane633

3 жыл бұрын

I thought you also fall under the falsified claims that you khoi.

What is south africa national language???

@MrSweetaz

5 жыл бұрын

South Africa has 11 official languages,----now do you see why we had apartheid and bantustans?

@khanyisa7373

5 жыл бұрын

Afrikaans. Isn't that obvious?

@maryduplessis2510

5 жыл бұрын

@Becky Britin yawn..... Try something new.... We are bored with those types of comments.....

But madam speaker also is a EFF check the she is wearing 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Shes speaking in English a more colonial language than Afrikaans who committed far more ateocities than Boers.

Eish thie Afrikaans guys,sound brutal indeed.

@lizettezyl4675

5 жыл бұрын

No we are not we are God fearing people we like to work and live in peace our language is under attack all are scools and university has been taken away our children old people fathers mothers are getting slaughtered..what do you expect we must just sit and wait we are boere Zulus tried to wipe us out English tried to wipe us out our food sources are under attack..but what the world don't know we are already building new schools trading school and soon we will have our own afrikaans university..we have given everything to them they cannot build and maintain. SA is burning. Parlement is a joke whole world is laughing at us our young men died on the border war protecting everybody in SA. If this happen in America here would have been a full on war so don't judge us..

@dissdad8744

5 жыл бұрын

@@lizettezyl4675 Stop being arrogant. You were not very god-fearing when you broke the Lords Commandments and stole our land, abused and killed our people while you were full of hatred, selfishness and greed. Do you understand that our Lord doesn't like hypocrites who use his name in vain? On the Afrikaans issue: Afrikaans is a Western Germanic language that is neither indigenous to South African, nor a useful language in regards to the international context. Do people in Flanders / Netherlands speak Zulu as an official language in parliament? I don't think so! Why must we speak Afrikaans in our parliament?

@lizettezyl4675

5 жыл бұрын

@@dissdad8744 voetsek asshole cannot deal with stupid people pls go and get yourself educate before you try and make a point..🖕

@lizettezyl4675

5 жыл бұрын

@@dissdad8744 obviously somebody very stupid thought you history sad part is you carry our stupidity over to you children go and do someting for society feed a widow knit blankets for the poor keep your hands busy and your mouth shut.

@dissdad8744

5 жыл бұрын

@Porter Maxwell We don't differentiate our African family into categories like Khoi, San or Bantu when we talk to foreigners like you, since we are all indigenous Southern African people, unlike the Dutch-French-German descendant foreigners and wannabe "Afrikaners", who are clearly of Western Germanic and Gallic ancestry, not African. So please do us all a favour and stop appropriating our African identity and culture! You are obviously uneducated and delusional if you never heard of Mapungubwe, which was built by Bantus by the way and is situated in South Africa. Also, most people that you refer to as Bantu in South Africa have in fact also Khoisan ancestry. Especially the Tswanas who heavily intermarried with Kalahari San people and the Xhosas and Sothos who intermarried with Khoe Khoe fleeing the Trek Boers and finding refuge within those communities, where they assimilated into. That's why you find many Black South Africans with Khoisan features (slim and muscular built, pepper corn hair, smaller eye folds, lighter yellowish skin hue etcetera). Even the most famous Black South African, Mr Nelson Mandela, was a Griqua descendant and therefore partially Khoisan. That's not unusual at all. I recommend you the article that was released in the renown Nature journal by the title "Complete Khoisan and Bantu genomes from southern Africa". They've done genetic testing on various South African individuals and studied their entire genome. One of the participants was Desmond Tutu. He was surprised to learn that he also had Khoisan ancestors, that he wasn't aware of. That's true for many Black South Africans. Most are not even aware that they have ancient Khoisan ancestry. Yet it's so obvious, otherwise we would look the same like Congolese or other other Bantu people, who have no Khoisan admixture, but we have distinct South Africa features due to the mix with Khoisan. We are a mixed population, like the British who are mixed between Germanic Anglo-Saxons, Celtic and Roman Latins. Then there is also ancient admixture betweem the groups, since

Maybe it's time there are 10 official languages 😎

@reeceheuvel5338

5 жыл бұрын

What a horrible person you are

@juliusmaehlich3138

5 жыл бұрын

Tk Hannibal. Why do you want to harm the coloureds in S A?

why english and afrikaans only, wow we still slaves in 2019. They need to add all the SA languages

@maryduplessis2510

5 жыл бұрын

They have the facilities, not sure where the translators are. Ps... No one is slaves.... Hell of a leap from language to slavery.... Totally out of context.

@shafiyaalgiquadra1105

5 жыл бұрын

I think he meant mental slavery, a country where the majority comprises people who speak several dialects of the Nguni languages still pandering to an Afrikaans minority 25 years after "independence" or atleast that is what I assumed Mr Dube was referencing. The problem extends to other forms of media such as jurisprudrence or texts designated for schools or workplaces, where the default is English and Afrikaans; indeed, there are some documents where African languages are espoused with the same fidelity as Afrikaans but this is the exception.

@maryduplessis2510

5 жыл бұрын

@@shafiyaalgiquadra1105 can we be realistic here for a minute. There are 11 official languages. No person speaks all 11 languages. It is therefore better to have a language that is understood by most people. The languages happen to be english and afrikaans. Most government documents do have at least three translations - english, afrikaans and the language that is prevalent in the area where the document is used ie. Kwazulu natal would be zulu. For the most part thus works. It would be an impossible task and extremely expensive to do so otherwise.

@shafiyaalgiquadra1105

5 жыл бұрын

@@maryduplessis2510 is it your belief that people who speak Afrikaans outnumber people who speak Sesotho, for example, in a region where Sesotho is most prevalent? How do you come to the conclusion that Afrikaans is more widely spoken than any Nguni language in any region save perhaps the Western Cape?

I shocked about the attitude towards other languages in south africa. If this happened in anywhere in the world that woman will be asked to leave. So called rainbow nation is a failed state.

What right they doing to use

Everyone must ask himself or herself why we comment in English

@magerixhealthyliving1589

5 жыл бұрын

Because most people understand English you dumbass. Not all black Africans understand each other.

@samuelchabalala639

5 жыл бұрын

@@magerixhealthyliving1589 you are 100% correct

Same on her then the eff want us Afrikaans speaking people to vote for them.

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

Hermen Philander you don’t have to. You can always go back home and rightfully vote and make decisions there however you want to without dictating or making decisions on how we choose to present ourselves in our country. After all we are not visitors who overstayed their welcome here. 🙂 May the God of all white people be with you.

It is my democratic right not to respect other people, their religion or their property or their privacy or their bodies or anything.🤷‍♂️ In fact to hell with all respect. Democratic rights ankere? ✊🏻

@nich2468

3 жыл бұрын

Did you hear about constitutional rights ? You would see that your democratic rights are limited by the one of others.

@mechailreydon3784

3 жыл бұрын

If you couldn’t tell this is a sarcastic comment

was she in the Stylistics ?? her English is very poor for an adult

These people

Why are only two languages provided for? What about the other seven official languages?

@casualp8562

5 жыл бұрын

I think it would be better if there was a fully functional interpretation system that translates all nine official languages. It is South Africa's parliament. Let the languages used in parliament show diversity that this country has.

The should be discussing important thing bt the Eff is known for making arguments abt minor things ,since well they hv nothing to say.Its nt our fault that she cnt understand Afrikaans and nobody is forcing her nt to use her own.All 11 official languages r here to stay

@weredifferent2353

5 жыл бұрын

it's the little things that you do that matters.this language issue may seem small because we know she understands then,but she wants them to be valued the same way. they can't interpret only two languages out of 11 and to make things worse English and Afrikaans if only it was Afrikaans and Zulu then I'd understand but Afrikaans and English only this doesn't need you to have common sense

its our democratic right to as well

@mpendulomahlangu4391

4 жыл бұрын

I saw ur comments on most of the EFF videos....u comment more like twice.....see u all the time

Mokwele has the most beautiful voice

@misstee7403

5 жыл бұрын

Do you have a hearing impairment?

@chinyelu225

5 жыл бұрын

Miss TEE why’d you say that? You don’t love her voice? Interesting

@misstee7403

5 жыл бұрын

It's probably the most annoying voice in that Parliament. Nothing beautiful about it. Maybe you have a crush on her

@chinyelu225

5 жыл бұрын

Miss TEE well actually I also love her skin and natural hair as well. But I like her quiet conference. I find it refreshing.

@misstee7403

5 жыл бұрын

@@chinyelu225 I wouldn't call her quiet, she's rude for one. The hair may look natural but it's a wig

she is crazy. what people like her are doing in parliament?

@kennethvolwana7799

3 жыл бұрын

That's racist to say.

Democracy every body is allowed a opion uneducated people will become abusive.

"democratic right to disrespect" a language. What bullshit. No matter how some boeres may disrespect your language, not all Afrikaners disrespect it, and it is entitled to think it's your right to discriminate. If it being the language of your abusers is the reason you will disrespect it, half of the world can disrespect the English language.

A black African language should be official language any where in Africa. It will happen sooner than you think...

@hyakintos

4 жыл бұрын

Afrikaans is african language. It's unique and should be official language of RSA.

How many cigars has Ramaphosa given MP Steenhuisen, he sounds like he's getting a clogged throat

That's why 11 official languages don't work. The intention might be a good one, but it's never going to work in practice. So, I'd say just make English the official language with the rest having a sort of secondary position. Because English is an easy to learn language and all

Madam not respecting Afrikaans, when I happen to meet you somewhere, I'll greet you with 'Goeiemôre, hoe gaan dit met jou? With love.

The problem is there too many people who dont respect themselves. So this behaviour is to be expected. 🙁

@lizettezyl4675

5 жыл бұрын

You don't have to speak Afrikaans then shut up understanding and speaking Afrikaans is not for everybody only for the intellectual like who has a history and build and made the country a first world for those who cooses to take it back to dark ages will never understand the complexity.. just whant to say i can speak zulu and and i am proud of it it is a good thing to educate youself.. and so i will teach my children also to speak Zulu and any other language i can . Whiles you teach to hate steal rape murder and kill old people innocent unspected victims babys see who will get the furthest in life. Asshole uniformed hope you don't have children must be terrible to be brought up stupid people..

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

Lizette Zyl saying hello and just the basic good morning and how are you is not speaking it.. just saying 😂 and you speaking it is not amazing and it isn’t a favor. It is a must do because it’s a language your ancestors found here and in order for you to have conversations with Zulu speaking people you’d have to adjust to the language.

@lizettezyl4675

5 жыл бұрын

@@peachfm9377 how would you it is 3rd language what is it to jou anyway..

@peachfm9377

5 жыл бұрын

Lizette Zyl 😂 please rewrite your comment. I do not understand it

@lizettezyl4675

5 жыл бұрын

@@peachfm9377 go back to school then🤭

What a shame to have only English and Afrikaans not our indigenous languages.

Mxm look in africa parlimanet is address with oppressors language mmmmm none of the victim is ther wat type of freedom is this Mmmmm u r fighting the system my sister which favor certain charactr

Waze wanesdina losisi we EFF, koba nini s'lalela lamasimba eparliament

@khulethandazani5955

4 жыл бұрын

Onesdina wunyoko

Nice question

What abt us who are watching parliament,who do not understand Afrikaans,why not put English subtitles.Members of parliament are immature.

madam chair is old don't do this, 😔 u gonna give her a heartattack

Saku lesalukwazi lesingu chair manje