Grateful for Kathleen Stock and Helen Joyce writing books and being outspoken about these issues. There's still more work to do for women's rights.

Still don't see how Trans isn't seen as the highest form of (what most Woke are against) _appropriation_ . Contending that transition-to is equal to biologically born-as runs up against the need to distinguish what one is changing INTO which means a from-to state. Appropriation, as a negative connotation, seemed to imply that the issue was gaining all the positive social returns on using aspects of another culture, without incurring the costs that ACTUALLY LIVING AS that culture incurs. It seems to me Trans does this in that the idealized view of what being a woman IS seems sufficient for that person to identify as to suit their inner self, and/or gain social acceptance as the gender of their personal choice.

@user-us5cf3qc7b

2 жыл бұрын

They don't think women are oppressed. The reason wokies don't accuse us ethnic people of cultural appropriating white culture by dressing in jeans or t-shirts is because they see us being less privileged. However, they think women are privileged and evil or even nazis for not being okay with men identifying as women.

@kamaliancirranoush1916

Жыл бұрын

Well stated.

@TJ-kk5zf

11 ай бұрын

Honey, ninety-nine percent of everybody agrees with you. We just need to make our voices heard

@user-yc5lb8fw5r

11 ай бұрын

I think the reason they hate and avoid the “trans racial” argument is because it’s too obviously devastating.

@charlesbrown1365

14 күн бұрын

We Woke anti-white supremacists aren’t pro-trans .

17:16 "what is a woman?" is mainstream not because of misogyny but because a transman being in a male space (men's sports, toilets, changing rooms etc) is zero threat. I, a man, do not care one bit if a female shares a changing room with me. I do, however, care about males sharing a changing room with my female family and friends, and children in general.

@Gingerblaze

Жыл бұрын

Young boys are not comfortable having trans identifying girls in their change rooms either. The danger aspect is less a threat but the invasion of privacy is still a problem.

@janedoe3648

Жыл бұрын

​@@Gingerblaze yes it is soo inappropriate, we have to protect children both boys and girls this is violating and leads to bad thing. I mean it's not right to have women in men's spaces either. Just because this man claims not to care, I'm sure many do

@mattbradbury

2 ай бұрын

And how would you tell whether a man in a woman’s space was trans or cis man, then?

Genevieve thank you. Your site is most underrated. Thank you

@GenevieveGluck

2 жыл бұрын

to be fair I am terrible at self-promotion, can't stand it lol thanks

Thank you so much for your work, Ladies.

If it's just '' all about identity'' why don't we talk about the right of black, arabish or asian personnes to say they're white because they feel it so that they don't suffer from racism anymore ? Why don't we give the right to any human personne on earth espacialy from the south to feel from any rich country and get the nationality so that they can have a better life ? Since it is '' all about imoroving society'' ???

Don’t worry about exceptions; go ahead and make generalizations.

What makes you you is your body . Of course you have memory of your body’s past . Most thinking is memory ; except immediate sense experience.

Glad I discovered you, bril, subscribed

@GenevieveGluck

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you!

Why don't you ask yourself '' who could have pay so that these ideas have been spread all over the society ?" And one of the answer is Martine Rothblat (trans who wrote '' from transgender to transhuman '', very rich and who work since 20 years to push this phenomenon in laws, médecine and culture) but also other personnes like Jennifer Pritzker (also trans) and Jon Styker. But there are other rich people who got interests in medecine, technologies and culture. Just search! The world is not just '' fool of ideas''! It's all about money !

@Tina06019

Жыл бұрын

Cherchez les $$$$.

Gender is partially innate , because being a female is a necessary condition of being a girl -woman ( necessary condition in the modus ponens sense).

There is old fashion voyeurism and indecent exposure, as well as autogynphilia .

Abolish male supremacy, not binary “gender .”

Bahahaha. Poor Simone de Beauvoire. She's rolling in her grave. However maybe I'm wrong. I think existentialism is bollocks. So who knows what side she'd be on!

As a cis gay man with many trans friends, I laugh in the face of Ms Stocks’ ignorance around AGP and the idea that it’s anything to do with being trans

I think its terrible Kathleen has turned out this way - 600 philosophy academics signed a petition she is being discriminatory, alongside student protests; and she still can't see she is wrong....she has cut her nose off to spite her face so to speak; she handled this all wrong...and sadly still thirsts for more...please stop giving her a platform to do this to herself; she has diminished her beauty and herself with all this... It even seems like her partner may have left her as a result too; for all that to happen and see no fault, screams a lot about Kathleen...

@Bibirallie

7 ай бұрын

Kathleen is actually on he right side of history. I bet most of the professor who signed the petition probably agree with her behind closed doors. who are you to say we shouldn’t give a woman fighting for women and girls a platform. If you don’t like what she’s saying then don’t click on the video. We stand with Kathleen and all that she is doing for women’s rights. We need her voice now more than ever.

@ambientsoda106

7 ай бұрын

@@Bibirallie Kathleen's operating in the public arena, as such she is open to my criticism and anyone's criticism. Consequently, I argued against her discriminatory comments, this isn't about her fighting for women's rights, it about her explicit discriminations and ignorance...consequently, her peers were not forced to sign that petition and you should not make unproven assumptions about their actions when her peers made a clear statement and openly criticized Kathleen...if anything you should be taking note of their brave actions...not finding some imaginary coercion behind it.

What makes you you is your body . Of course you have memory of your body’s past . Most thinking is memory ; except immediate sense experience.