"Shouldn't quality of life be a consideration?" House: The thing about life... it has quality.

@aldodarmara1163

4 жыл бұрын

Also house :"i become a doctor to treat illnesses, not the patients"

@nugorcalamo1436

4 жыл бұрын

House in this show for a weird impossible crossover would’ve been beautiful

@sophielessore8155

4 жыл бұрын

Who is house

@nugorcalamo1436

4 жыл бұрын

He is the main character in a show called house m.d that went from 2004-2012 and he was a very intelligent doctor that was very unorthodox and a bit of a dick, that’s to summarise it by a lot, it’s a very good show and has 8 seasons.

The moment Dr. Hallstead looked at Dr. Manning from his locker I could immediately tell he cried. Such a good actor.

There is no doctor in the world who would refuse to start CPR because of breaking someone's ribs....

@TheSummerof2012

5 жыл бұрын

Nicol Bolas ikr, my sister just became a nurse and they told her “if you’re not breaking ribs, you’re not trying hard enough to save them”

@jsparky249

5 жыл бұрын

Shes useless

@kabs8548

5 жыл бұрын

Ivana Gacha yeah forget dying right

@simply.stvrlightt

5 жыл бұрын

No it's because she's old, and if you're elderly and your ribs break it's harder to repair, so you'd be constantly in pain.

@simply.stvrlightt

5 жыл бұрын

By repair I mean heal

“Treat the patient, not the disease” dr house would disagree...

@nugorcalamo1436

4 жыл бұрын

You watched the show?

@dangertm9702

4 жыл бұрын

100th like ^-^

@bananawilson

4 жыл бұрын

Nugor Calamo yes

@bananawilson

4 жыл бұрын

Psoro Studios thanks :DD haha cool

@dangertm9702

4 жыл бұрын

Wilson whoa that was a quick reply. Something mystical about quarantine

Everyone complaining about Dr Manning saying "I'll break her ribs": come on guys. Her character is a doctor and a good one at that, it's not like she doesn't know that breaking ribs while doing CPR is fine. The whole point of showing her hesitation, and April's hesitation too (if you notice), is to present the argument that was the primary focus of this clip: does quality of life matter more than life itself? Especially for someone that old, is it really worth it? Tough question with no correct answer.

@audreysmith2421

5 жыл бұрын

WOW that is a lot to say, but your right, and that is true.

@writajachakravarty9443

5 жыл бұрын

Finally someone with common sense! Thank you Neha for this comment. People need to see this and understand the plot for god's sake!

@audreysmith2421

5 жыл бұрын

@@writajachakravarty9443 that is so fucking true.

@noonereally.

5 жыл бұрын

I know I'm late, but there are so many comments saying that she is useless and all that, which is of course untrue. You are so right! It feels great seeing a nice, thought out comment once in a while.

@jamesmccomb9525

5 жыл бұрын

A doctor doesn't have the right to decide who gets to live and die, no matter the situation. That becomes the responsibility of the patient and their family.

Omg... I watched 1 SINGLE episode on here... now I’m addicted... but I can’t find full episodes in England 😓

@megwall4461

5 жыл бұрын

1000 subscribers without any videos omggggg same I’m literally sooo annoyed 😂😭

@nicoleseidl4353

4 жыл бұрын

Sweden can’t seem them either

@tami_sings5337

4 жыл бұрын

Search them on dailymotion you can watch full episodes but its not good quality

@kadeyyxd8825

4 жыл бұрын

1000 subscribers without any videos u gotta pay for em £16.99

@phoenixbearman6756

4 жыл бұрын

Try lookmovie

This is painful, losing your greatest mentor is like losing your own parents :'( those mentor is the reason why those doctors are being better everyday.

' shouldn't quality of life be a consideration' pity not all real doctors and the law can't see that.

@rithvikmuthyalapati9754

Жыл бұрын

That consideration should be made by the PATIENT and not the DOCTOR

It's not the fact that the ribs were broken, it was the age and how she was coping. A few broken ribs might not be as bad as us, but for her, it's basically death. It was the right decision at this time.

2:24 for those who are complaining about Dr. Manning asking Halstead about breaking a rib, that's the reason why she asked for it first. There's so many reason why she had to ask for permission, she's just concern about the old lady's condition to get worse (or live in worst) also, she didn't totally reject. I understand her.

@Pumpkin_3890

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah, but it's unprofessional un uncalled for. She's a doctor, she could know that cpr can result in broken ribs and that the life of a patient matters more than whether or not they have a broken rib. Ribs can heal, you can't bring someone back from the dead.

@SneakyWF

4 жыл бұрын

She did reject.... she just stood there even after being told after she asked.

@yixinzhang9862

4 жыл бұрын

CutsiePie 389.0 FYI,a broken rib can cause a lung to be punctured and that will just make her condition worse with a deflated lung

@joelvr101

2 жыл бұрын

@@Pumpkin_3890 oh yeah, because this patient was clearly going to be fine within a week. What does CPR add to a person that is so terminal?

@marlarmodiva485

2 жыл бұрын

@@joelvr101 The question here is mire whether or not you should revive someone, breaking their ribs in the process, diminishing their quality of life if they do not have much chance of living longer than a few weeks or something like that. It's an ethics question and that was why she asked him

The thing is about breaking her ribs is that she’s extremely old. So she won’t be able to move for a while etc. the question here was if QoL is more important

Ik this is a serious video but oh my god what was that randome cough at 2:04 because I bursted out laughing

@eeiity8600

5 жыл бұрын

Had me rolling once I noticed it😂😂😭😭👏🏼

@rivabajwa578

4 жыл бұрын

CORONAVIRUS jk

@sanasibghatullah2612

4 жыл бұрын

Wasn't a random cough. She was drawing his attention towards him.

@samaeldeul572

3 жыл бұрын

Sameee😂😂😂

Sharon Goodwin is a great woman, intelligence and warmth entwined, rational with a great heart...Acting 👍👍👍👍💜 As far as Dr. Halstead, I understand his position. Wonderful acting ...It's always hard to let go...

3:11 "Treat the patient not the Disease" - Dr Bella Rowan "Treating illnesses is why we became doctors. Treating patients is what makes most doctors miserable." - Dr Gregory House

NO ONE refuses to do compressions because they'll break a rib. That's literally one of the FIRST things they tell you when you learn how to do CPR; Even if you break ribs, keep doing compressions. If you are resorting to CPR, they are already on deaths door, a few broken ribs doesn't matter.

@joshuadoll9000

5 жыл бұрын

@Spidey Girl She clearly said she was worried about breaking ribs. That was her reason for not doing CPR. It's just an error in the script and they didn't run it by whoever they consult on the medical side of things. I just find it particularly annoying because it's a really simple thing and there are so many people that know how to do CPR properly and breaking ribs is not a valid reason to not do CPR.

@joshuadoll9000

5 жыл бұрын

@Spidey Girl That would be something to discuss with the next of kin about whether she has/wants a DNR or if she doesn't want life support. In this case though, there appears to be no next of kin available to make that decision so the doctors have to treat her like she wants to be saved regardless of the means they have to go to to keep her alive.

@89courtenay

5 жыл бұрын

I think it was more the patient would rather die peacefully than have more pain and suffer the whole time. She would have died anyway and having a machine expanded your diaphragm when you have broken ribs would hurt like hell. The doctor was thinking about what the patient wanted not what the grieving friend was insisting on. This is why doctors aren’t allowed to treat family. Keeping someone alive becomes their first priority, even if it isn’t in the patients best interest.

@verap18

5 жыл бұрын

So true

@YellawayHD

5 жыл бұрын

Point is she was already gonna die or have dreadful quality of life, and now it’s gonna be even more painful.

Anyone else hear that cough at 2:04 but looking at dr halstead he didn’t cough 😂😂

Lol, it's not about breaking the ribs. Even the actors know that. It's about her age and condition and what breaking the ribs might do to her in that state. Yall watched the whole clip right? Lol.

chest compressions chest compressions chest compressions

@megamarylis514

5 жыл бұрын

That immediately reminds me of Dr. Mike lol

@emmaasmr6892

3 жыл бұрын

@@megamarylis514 that’s what they are referring to!

@miki5748

3 жыл бұрын

Mike

I’d like to see Dr Mike’s opinions on this episode

When I saw dr. Halstead cry I- almost cried

im actually really happy the curator of this channel actually adds in a season and episode stamp.. great thinking

Its so painful to lose a mentor , if you are and were the real student , follwing the goodness of the mentor , this episode for me was very painful

Goddamnit where's the onion ninja hiding to in my room

Dr manning didn’t refuse to giving cpr she just hesitated because she thinks of how her bones may not heal because of her age and broken ribs are extremely painful. She was concerned for her well being afterwards

Chest compressions, chest compressions, chest compressions! If you get it you get it

often when older already sick people break bones it can be game over for them. so i can see dr manning’s point as it may be counter productive to revive her and then have her never recover from the breakages.

Chest compressions , cheat compressions , chest compressions ❤️

I almost cryed at the end😢😢😢😢

im not a trained doctor, only trained in first aid; but yall who said no one would refuse to do cpr in fear of breaking ribs? she’s an old woman. her ribs will be harder to repair and she’ll just suffer more.

@gracecalis5421

4 жыл бұрын

QoL isn't something you discuss while your patient is literally flatlining in the same room. You resuscitate, unless given a DNR order. That is a decision only given to the patient or anyone they deem fit to decide in their stead.

So they literally just killed her in the most painless way

Will is so good hearted

Imagine if there was a show with dr halstead, dr mike and dr house

Aaaawwww will cried 😭😭

For a second there I thought I was in a Doc Mike comment section! 🤣🤣

“treat the patient, not the disease” me: gives her a stuffed bear patient: 🕊✌🏼😱

5:41 Aight but who was that lady???

@mischa-roseelliman6040

4 жыл бұрын

@@Daydreamer-fj7ru but at that time his gf...manstead forever!

@BlackGirlWasted

4 жыл бұрын

Finalllyyyyy someone asking the right questions 😩

@nomawethundlangisa3021

3 жыл бұрын

Searched through rib breaking comments for this question

@jeslichew

3 жыл бұрын

@@nomawethundlangisa3021 me too!! lol

@jessicapearce9041

3 жыл бұрын

That lady was Dr Halsteads mentor back when he was attending a medical school. I assume he was very close to her 😞😞😞

Im gonna cry

Broken rib OR dying

@camerontoy8154

4 жыл бұрын

Schlahtt dying

Most of the time you have to put enough to pressure to brake the ribs like it's just something that happens

I don’t know why but when she said bed sores my feet felt funny

Jesus Christ when will this be in Netflix?!?!

I thought Will was letting go of his mother

happy but sad ending :(

Why am I crying

Is it just me or i learn so much about this until the disagre with everythink then im like break the ribs or not?? like wth

Wait. Was that the actress who played Anna in frozen broadway?

@kylee7189

5 жыл бұрын

Queen B yes it is also Dr Rhodes wife in real life.

Awww will cannot let her go

idc i sobbed in this scene

But it’s better to break someone’s rib than lose someone’s life

Who is the woman at the end who saw Dr Halstead and Manning hugging?

@eeiity8600

5 жыл бұрын

I honestly have no idea, but she might’ve been a doctor/nurse who thought that Halstead and Manning were dating or something. Which I don’t think is _okay_ in the medical world. Honestly I’m probably so wrong but whatever I guess lmao

@shimetta152

5 жыл бұрын

@@eeiity8600 wait ur saying you cant date if ur doctor? (idk if i red that right)

@brokenknee14

5 жыл бұрын

It was wills girlfriend in season 2

@frieddegg

5 жыл бұрын

Nina, a doctor from the pathology department, who was Will's girlfriend during season 2.

@jordanabeaulieu2530

4 жыл бұрын

@@brokenknee14 Looks like she's still not over him!🙂

Maggie put the pads in a very unusual position... There is no way that would work.

The reason why nat had issues with cpr is because if she does it right, it'll break her patient's ribs. Who knows how many they would have broken since the patient is so fragile. Patient: Intubated (meaning the machine was doing the breathing for her) Kidney Failure (Leads to many different complications including heart conditions, medication complications, blood pH fluctuations) broken Ribs ( in loads of pain most likely cannot do surgery since the patient is so weak, she wont be able to handle it, most of the time you dont do surgery you just have to let it heal, with the patient's age and physical state it will take a very very long time to become healthy, by that time she will pass away from other health conditions) Shes bed ridden (pressure injury leading to skin necrosis, muscle atrophy (muscle degeneration which can happen as fast as 1 week bed bound)) Of course quality of life will be a concern. Especially in palliative care, quality of life is a big concern. Thus all the pain medications and the rest. People say they want to live but other people just want rest after so much fighting. Sometimes its just ignorance, naivety and the lack of knowledge about how the body works.

If you break a persons rib do they repair like a broken arm ?

That sounds like one of those fire alarms beep beep beep

I’m sure that woman’s heart was still beating at he end. The thing was still beeping

Who else wants a job at this hospital? What a top show

"Treat the patient not the disease" so if you got cancer and your about to die you prefer being comfortable than alive?? Like the hell i rather live

@tsippora9267

5 жыл бұрын

That's not what that sentence means. Some doctors treat a disease, but without really considering the well being of the patient. I've personally seen this in operation rooms, where the surgeon does an amazing job, but the rest of the body comes out a wreck because of it. And then there are doctors that put the patients mental state and well being before anything else, and that's what the sentence means.

@XSHADOWTHELEGENDARYHEDGEHOGxX

3 жыл бұрын

I'd rather die

What happened when the hanger drip stops dripping?

Wow

To anyone who ever has to do CPR on somebody one day (I hope you won’t have to), breaking a rib(s) is completely normal. It’s recommended push down 5cm (2 inches) when doing compressions, plus most times it will be elderly people with more fragile bones. So don’t hold back because of possibly breaking ribs; after hopefully surviving a heart attack, a broken rib should be the least of their concerns.

I know this is a tv show I just can’t help but point out The compressions he did we’re way to fast 😂

I think the point of Dr. Manning's comment was to the futility of CPR in the patient's situation. Although I agree, in this case, advanced directives or the subsequent decision maker would have to clarify what would occur in such a situation, however, I think Dr. Manning's comment is to contract against Dr. Halsted's actions. It's a hard choice between but sometimes ensuring a peaceful death is more kind to the patient than life while subject to various treatments that do not cure and only prolong the suffering- for instance, CPR and the subsequent pain from broken bones. I think that's why Dr. Manning made that comment.

1:16 her hand moves

You can find full episodes at dailymotion

Where’s dr house when you need him

What is strange about the umbrella? They're everywhere...

How are they related

April didn't yell "clear!" before shocking her

Episode no and season?

That’s all I’m going to say

This days they never treat any.

I can't find full episodes

What was doctor halstead watching?

Guys if you all want to watch full episodes of chicago med and many more you can watch in Soap2day. I hope it will help you❤❤. Stay safe

4:05 both gloves on - 4:15 putting second glove on (the time-stream is fucked)

Ribs oh no 😱

omg I thought it says dr Halstead lets go of his *mother*

Oh wait nevermind

4:32 haha found a mistake

You all keep saying that it’s bad that she was afraid of breaking her ribs, but you have to ask yourself, would she be able to survive it when her ribs would be broken? She is old, and not really strong anymore so is it worth it to save a life like that if she wouldn’t be able to get better?

What if she DID want to live?

Just a thought

Are doctors allowed to do that? Just curious . . .

i kind of wonder why the patient is still in the ED. patient should've been brought to ICU right?

@tsippora9267

5 жыл бұрын

Because ICU would make a really boring TV show. Most of the time patients are just intubated for long periods of time, and have routine checkups until something in their condition changes.

People in England should watch on Amazon prime

@user-sc4vr7cx5c

Жыл бұрын

We do dumbass

I thought it said mother

Who was the girl in the red

Why is that one blonde woman in the end so shocked? Abt them hugging?

me to Grace

What’s a mentor?

@Caitzeee

5 жыл бұрын

Ping Quana They are like an advisor and someone who can teach you and help you! The other nurse said how in her first year of OR nursing, she wanted to quit because she struggled so much with it! That lady who they were treating helped her not to give up! She meant a lot of Dr Halstead and that nurse (I don’t know her name) They give guidance and that kind of thing!

What tf is happening?

hi how you

Who was the blond girl at the end

Wait, did the doctors let her go?

@Caitzeee

5 жыл бұрын

Tiny Butterfly Yes, she passed away after they extubated her! If they put her on dialysis, she still wouldn’t have survived on her own! She would be bed ridden and she would have had to have a tracheostomy as she wouldn’t be able to breathe on her own! They treated the patient and not the disease! They considered her quality of life and knew that if she survived, she wouldn’t have wanted to live like that!

@gandalfhan

5 жыл бұрын

@@Caitzeee Why do you put an exclamation mark after each sentence?

STOP WITH ALL THE YOU SHOULDN'T BREAK THE RIBS LISTEN IF HER RIBS HAD BROKE THEN THAT WOULD OF MADE HER WORSE SHE WOULD O NOT HAD A CHANCE OF SURVIVAL BUT IT WAS THE RIGHT DECISION USING THE COMPRESSIONS

Dr Halstead was right He had to as some people like christians always need to try their best to stay alive

@titoakin7489

3 жыл бұрын

Thats not true . Christians especially ones that old would be at peace with death

Who’s the lady at the end ?

@kfransissy8101

4 жыл бұрын

Dr Halsteads ex from season 2

V-Fib??? Are you kidding me! She is clearly in fucking flatline aka asystolie. You cant shock there

What’s the woman getting so upset about? He’s just lost his mentor and dr manning is just comforting him! Jesus stop being so sensitive!

Did she die?

@trevorbluesquirrel899

11 ай бұрын

Yeah, they took out the breathing tube!