Few people who don't travel with the Doctor ever see them again. Imagine what Tim must have meant to the Doctor for them to come to a memorial service to see him in his old age. The Doctor doesn't like to look back, so it must be something special to make them do just that.

@jamieolberding7731

3 жыл бұрын

Giovanni Magnus 2 months ago (edited) Tim was glad to see the Doctor one last time as the Doctor to me sort of saw and treated Tim as an adopted son.

@SchultzDorinda

3 жыл бұрын

The Doctor also probably came back to retrieve his watch

@fadikhoory5350

2 жыл бұрын

But we don't know what year they came to the memorial. Tim is about 15, so he was born in 1898 and it doesn't look like he's above 80.

@sourishbanjo5037

Жыл бұрын

@@fadikhoory5350 I mean who says that’s 2007? Could be like the early 90s.

@markdurl8341

Жыл бұрын

my guess is the doctor saw something pretty special in him, so he kept tabs on him

One of the best episode endings of Tennant’s time imo. It’s as if The Doctor and Martha were there for Tim his whole life, protecting him like silent guardians :).

@phantomfire7205

3 жыл бұрын

Did the doc travel in time when Tim was old? I'm confused

@mantabond

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed.

@quillerpen

3 жыл бұрын

I have this theory that the Doctor knows that this will be Tim's last Remembrance, so he comes back to say goodbye. And when Tim sees him, he knows this too

@darrensmith8730

3 жыл бұрын

@@quillerpen Makes sense

@gerathys

3 жыл бұрын

Tim was the last of his generation at the ceremony and he was so happy to see The Doctor and Martha again. The poem being read described both the fallen, and from Tim's perspective, The Doctor and Martha as well.

I like it how the Doctor sees himself in Tim. A dedicated sacred young boy who is afraid of the war but fights for what's right

Tim basically is John Smith’s adopted son at this point

@jamieolberding7731

3 жыл бұрын

Robotic Spiderguy 11 months ago I strongly agree. Tim is also one of my favorite Doctor Who characters as well.

I remember when this first came out and the number of British WW1 veterans still alive could be counted on one hand. This hits harder now some 15 years later when even the end of that war was over 100 years ago.

@oasis4life014

2 жыл бұрын

None left anymore 😢

@samalvey8168

Жыл бұрын

That's why it is our burden to bear now, to remember the cost of war and never let another one like the one they fought happen.

@crazyjameswaikle2695

6 ай бұрын

This is, The going down of the son. I have seen in my lifetime the last of the veterans from The War To End All Wars die, and I will likely see the last of the veterans from the war after that die as well

I've seen this clip dozens of times...and it makes me well up every time....

@amybebop

4 жыл бұрын

Nunya Business me too. When it’s about the war I always get emotional.

@Alexandrashepiro

4 жыл бұрын

Yup..me too!

@phantomfire7205

3 жыл бұрын

Did the doctor travel to the future when the kid was old. U was very confused

@TheShattenjager

3 жыл бұрын

@@phantomfire7205 yes, the guy in the wheelchair is holding the fob watch because that’s the kid as an old man at a memorial for the fallen soldiers. Doctor and Martha attended and he saw them, just as they looked when he was a kid - because for them it has only been minutes.

@mahlicarmichael1046

23 күн бұрын

Well up, I literally ball tears

Fun Fact, the ending scene was filmed in the same village in which The Eleventh Hour (Matt Smith first episode) was filmed. (There is no Pond)

@Squicx

4 жыл бұрын

WHAT! NO WAY!!!!!!

@jamieolberding7731

3 жыл бұрын

@@Squicx Oh... YES WAY!

@causti9744

3 жыл бұрын

This happens quite often in the show, like Clara and Rose living in the exact same house.

@jamieolberding7731

3 жыл бұрын

@@causti9744 I strongly agree.

@josephchambers2000

Жыл бұрын

I like to think therefore that canonically Tim and Amy met at some point not knowing their connection.

For anyone asking the music is called "The Doctor Forever" This is 10's actual theme and is unreleased officially

@Sharpteeth32

Жыл бұрын

It's my favorite piece of Doctor Who music.

@TheRuddster95

7 ай бұрын

​@@Sharpteeth32same 🙏🏼

Back in the good old days when Doctor Who could make me cry... sigh

@jamieolberding7731

3 жыл бұрын

MATILDA 16 hours ago Same here. Everyone cries.

@TheShattenjager

3 жыл бұрын

Makes us all cry now, too, just for a different reason.

@jamieolberding7731

3 жыл бұрын

@@TheShattenjager Dalek Supreme: "Daleks do NOT cry!" [sniffles] "Okay, I think it's just raining in here that's all...." [quickly turns and leaves, while his assembled soldiers look on in confusement] Dalek 1: "I wonder what that was all about?!" Dalek 2: "I do not know?!" Dalek 3: [appears out of nowhere] "I'm BACK!!! With the popcorn. SOoooooo.......................... What did I miss you guys? I'm not late again, am I?"

@z-rex6068

2 жыл бұрын

Ikr, Russel T Davies era provided many moments that gave me goosebumps (and still do to this day), something that you no longer get with Doctor Who today..

@chrisdiokno5600

2 жыл бұрын

@@z-rex6068 12 had numerous great moments and 13 had a few

Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn. At the going down of the sun and in the morning, we will remember them.

@ilanakidiadia3181

3 жыл бұрын

You're crying... i'm not

@michaelhyde-parker6344

2 жыл бұрын

Lest we forget. It's ANZAC day here as I am writing this, in honor of all of those who have gone before us, those who made the ultimate sacrifice so we can be free.

@TheRuddster95

7 ай бұрын

We will remember them ❤

Seeing Tim order that guy around made me smile to see how his confidence has been built up. And to see a bit of the Doctor in him as well

Martha, 'You don't have to fight.' Tim, 'I think we do.' My grandfather agreed with Martha, he served at the front as a medical orderly and stretcher bearer during WW1. His son, my father, saw things as Tim did; flew Spitfires with the RAF during WW2. Respect to them both and their comrades, for their service.

@polkka7797

Жыл бұрын

Good on your family, reminds me of that Peter Jackson documentary “we had a job and we got on and did it”, I’m a bit younger but had great grandads who fought in ww2 all over the place and a few great great uncles who died in ww1. And uncle in the army and an uncle in the RAF. We were lucky not all are

@samalvey8168

7 ай бұрын

There's more than one way to fight. Medics, quartermasters, cooks, technicians, mechanics, all have their roles.

@Ogloserlol

3 ай бұрын

🫡🫡🫡

I make a point of watching this every Remembrance Day and shed a tear each time that I do, today included. Beautifully crafted and so poignant.

Best series of the entire revival, there isn't one weak episode.

@thewerewolff7248

2 жыл бұрын

42 is pretty weak in my opinion

@Multiversal_Productions

Жыл бұрын

@@thewerewolff7248 So weak, poor AzaPro911 probably forgot all about it

@RealRezzo

Жыл бұрын

@@thewerewolff7248 well it was written by chibnall after all

@Sharpteeth32

Жыл бұрын

​@AK Nah, 42 was still good. Probably the weakest of Series 3, mind you, but not bad.

@camillechauve1352

Жыл бұрын

I'd say S4 is better but I fully respect your opinion - S3 is definitely my 2nd favourite!

I watched this scene all those years ago when it aired, and I was too young to understand it. Now I'm an adult, watching it again, it just brings me to tears. What a beautiful ending.

@youknow227

7 ай бұрын

Such a pointless war

I watch these two episodes every year on Remembrance Day and they remain my favourites to this day. I wear the red poppy proudly for one of my family fell in the war, but I also wear the white poppy alongside it as a reminder of what he fought for: peace.

Doctor who was just so bloody good. The humble little kids TV show managed to produce television of this quality. It had no right to be this good, but amazing writers, actors and producers made it so. Sadly everyone that made it so good back in the day have all left now, and at present it's really struggling. I personally think they need to go on a hiatus for 10 years or so and bring it back for another generation. They've got everything they can out of this instalment of the show, it's time to go down a completely different path, or leave it for so long that we all miss it and want it back, I can't see another way to get fans back on board

@slickwine

2 жыл бұрын

Reading this after Davies has been announced to come back. Honestly, can't wait!

@zachzacuro3510

6 ай бұрын

​@@slickwinewell...

Probably one of the bestest soundtrack this episode had in all the doctor who years

Came back for VE Day 75th anniversary, so much respect for all the heroes 💜

@alri1054

3 жыл бұрын

Wenn, „heroes“ in quotations After being neglected by their govt

@reichtangle7734

3 жыл бұрын

I mean this is 106 years ago but ok.

@arianebolt1575

3 жыл бұрын

Wrong war

@Kuingar

3 жыл бұрын

Have you spoken to VE Day veterans? WWI was a tragedy, WWII is more controversial since they see themselves as closer to Hitler than to Mohammad next door with his 12 year old wife.

@Cybermat47

10 ай бұрын

@@Kuingarwhat?

This whole sequence always got me...i'm not crying...you are

Imagine the long and sortied history of that watch, from the hands of young Timothy to the pocket of Dr Yana at the end of the universe. Bloody hell.

@DD99654

3 жыл бұрын

I thought the one at the end of time was a similar watch but not the same one

@oracle8192

2 жыл бұрын

No it's actually just a basic unit many timelords carry, the one Dr Yana had was his own unrelated to the doctors.

Here on 11/11/2022, this always reminds me of those who died for our country.

@ht-ve9fe

7 ай бұрын

11/11/2023

Watching this again after 13's regeneration, after when he says during the Christmas Truce that it never hurts to have a few less dead on the battlefield, you realise why The Doctor gave him that watch. So that it was time to get out of the way, and save both his life and his comrade's.

It’s the theme that does it for me mostly, it coveys it’s message well, hope, hope that the doctor will save people, and he does

"To the right."... Gets me everytime.

The fact that Tim kept the watch all that time is heartwarming

After jodie regenerates would like to see tim go round with the doctor for a while and for continuity’s sake it could easily be way after the war

@thehorrorcounselors4747

4 жыл бұрын

WardyJ the fans need a white male doctor and to erase everything in the timeless child

@wardy6224

4 жыл бұрын

Josh Mcgrath i agree with the timeless child stuff but the doctor doesn’t HAVE to be white or male.. its just the writing that ‘crapifies’ everything.. jodie could’ve been good but nah brownie points are more important

@jensennguyen02

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah exactly, the problem does not lie with the character. If the newest doctor was white and male, it would still not change the writing at all and how weak it has been. Atleast not in any signifigant way, characters and especially the doctor can be done by whoever. The people writing the show need a better understanding of the material they are working with and have more concrete ideas on what they want to do with the characters.

@meeper46

2 жыл бұрын

@@wardy6224 although this is a reply to an older comment, gender swapping and race swapping are completely stupid

@loganmorrison3731

Жыл бұрын

@@meeper46 except that in this case the doctor could literally be anyone. It’s not race or gender swapping it’s literally just part of being a time lord, when regenerating they can turn into anyone, regardless of race, gender or age.

2022 Thank you Vets. from Canada on Remembrance day

@tinacorbet4705

7 ай бұрын

2023 thank you

Damn you Cornell. It was a masterpiece. It was YOUR masterpiece. Should have just left it alone.

@filbencs5098

3 жыл бұрын

What happened??

@TheBOB235

3 жыл бұрын

Did I miss something??

@ummwho8279

3 жыл бұрын

​@@TheBOB235 ​ @Fil Bencs What I'm about to say, take with a massive grain of salt as it is, admittedly, very biased. TL;DR He wrote something amazing, ruined and retconned it, and since then has been pumping out garbage and looks like he's been taken hostage or severely bullied by the nutjobs who have hijacked the show behind the scenes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- This episode, written by Paul Cornell, is considered one of the best of the modern show. Now, while in lockdown during COVID-19 this year, Doctor Who launched a "lock-down" event and released additional franchise content during the lockdown. Paul Cornell wrote a story for that event (it is considered "cannon") that essentially retcons the ending of this episode and effectively seals the Timeless Child as cannon. You can read more about it here: tardis.fandom.com/wiki/The_Shadow_in_the_Mirror_(webcast) (Personal opinion) It lessens the impact of the story and its characters, which were the strong point of the story in the first place. It also speaks to a deeper and more disturbing part, as this once-amazing writer is pumping out trash for DW. If you watch him in interviews these days he comes off as very nervous, I think they're bullying him behind the scenes. That or I guess he's been hanging around the franchise so long and received nothing in return he's just going along with whatever they do now, even if it's complete garbage, hoping that they'll give him some sort of greater compensation. I think he's been denied the opportunities owed to him for devoting 30 years of his life to the franchise (they made Chris C*nt-nall the showrunner over him for one thing) that he's in an awkward situation where he can't speak out against their (ironically for a bunch of people claiming to be "all inclusive and tolerant of everyone") intolerant and quite frankly disgusting actions (given how they did Gareth Roberts SO dirty). I just feel sorry for him more than anything. Also he would have been a WAY better show-runner than Steven Moffat, Moffat stole the idea of River from him, the ***king c*nt. Bernice Summerfield > River Song ANY day.

The music in this part is so amazing so is the bit when thay dream of growing old and having kids

This makes me sad every time.

This was back when Doctor Who was unmissable TV 🙌🏻

This episode, before this and the weeping angels is brilliant!!

Endings like this are one of the many things that make the RTD Era my favourite, and i'm so excited to see what else RTD has In store for us in the next week or so.

I miss when Doctor Who made me feel deep feelings

@benwasserman8223

Жыл бұрын

Ohhh it still does :)

@tailsprowerfan2729

5 ай бұрын

@@benwasserman8223 nope it doesn’t

Today we shall remember them it’s the 11th November 2022

In my opinion this is the saddest scene in Doctor Who

@ht-ve9fe

Жыл бұрын

or second saddest. First could be when we lost David Tennant and the original team and Doctor who went on a Downward spiral

A sci-fi show that can evoke emotions like this is unheard of. Doctor who, at this time, is the greatest tv show of all time.

Ferb is that you

@stuartmiller4363

3 жыл бұрын

Yes

Old Tim smiling when he sees the doctor… man…

Simply.....superb!

beautifully done

Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.

From this to the return of the "Master" in 2 weeks? Series 3 is drastically underrated!!!

@youknow227

7 ай бұрын

I love Series 3

@julianadlyngton6806

22 күн бұрын

@@youknow227series 3 & 4 were peak

The Tardis just standing there in a rainy field is such a majestic sight

Best two episodes ever

'The Queens Gambit' brought me here..

I would of loved to see an episode of doctor who when he helps drafts the UN charter

David Tennant filled the role so well they even debated whether or not to shut the show down after him because no one will ever be so good. They were right.

Old Tim looks like George W Bush

I always thought it was weird that they went with that for the fobwatch pay off instead of it simply being in his pocket and stopping a bullet from killing him.

“Verity was standing there. 'Doctor. Dr Smith.' Smith spun round and gazed at her. 'Verity. My dear.' The woman smiled. 'I'm flattered, John, that you regard me as an old flame. That was your interpretation of what I was doing in your memories. But I think you're on rather dangerous ground. I'm one of the Doctor's dreams, an icon, a female custodian of something that's deep inside him. I was the only piece of himself that he left behind in his head. I'm important to him. He hardly listens to me, mind you. And he never returns my telephone calls.' 'Do you want to tell me what you told John in the glade this morning?' the Doctor asked. 'What you were trying to whisper in his ear for so long?' 'You still don't know? I don't see why I should tell you now. You employed me, after all, to defend and take care of your deepest memories, and then you failed to take heed of any of my warnings.' 'I didn't, you mean,' Smith interjected. 'There are things down there in my unconscious that even I don't know about, memories from before I was born,' the Doctor explained. 'I couldn't get rid of all of them and Smith was certain to start accessing some of it. I just thought that there ought to be somebody in there who knew who I was.' 'Couldn't she have appeared earlier and saved me all that bother?' Smith asked. Verity patted him on the shoulder. 'I wasn't allowed to. That was the frustrating thing. I couldn't intrude into your consciousness. I could only appear when you'd got it sorted out for yourself.' 'So what did you say to him?' the Doctor asked. 'That he believes in Good and fights Evil. That, with Violence all around him, he's a Man of Peace. That he's never Cruel, or Cowardly. That he is A Hero.' Smith closed his eyes for a moment. 'It felt good to hear it confirmed. Of course, that's not a definition of me. That's you, Doctor.' The Doctor reached out and touched him on the shoulder. 'As I believe you said, Being Me is A State of Mind. Six other people apart from you and I have had a go. You were rather good at it.' Smith looked at him again and managed a smile. 'Perhaps I taught a few more would-be Doctors how to do it.' 'Perhaps. But I wonder how many will remember when they grow up?' Verity waved a hand between them. 'Sorry to interrupt. Look who's here.' Death looked at them all, sniffily. 'You deal with me again, raven Time Lord, possibly for the last time.' She put a hand on Smith's shoulder. 'This one belongs to me, now. I told you long ago, Doctor, that I would take a life from you in return for that of your companion. Our business is now concluded.' Smith shivered at her touch. 'What's going to happen to me?' he asked. 'Another owl for Lord Rassilon?' the Doctor asked. 'That is not for you to ask,' Death replied. Verity kissed Smith's forehead. 'It'll be fine. Bloody Eternals think they own the universe. They don't know everything.' Death began to fade, and Smith with her, the man looking around himself in wonder. 'Give my love to Time and Pain,' said the Doctor. 'If it wasn't for Time, I would never entertain you.' Death glared at him. 'But you cannot let Family down.' She clicked her fingers. The Doctor opened his eyes.” - Human Nature

Where is the scene where he visits the grand daughter in the book shop?

Oh look it's newt sorry tried to say actors name didn't work

Anyone know the song name at the memorial?

@kumasenlac5504

10 ай бұрын

For the Fallen - a poem by Laurence Binyon written in Autumn 1914. The poem is often recited at Remembrance Services with a communal response at the end of either "We shall remember them" or "Lest We Forget". The line "They Shall Not Grow Old..." is an unnecessary modification of the original "They Shall Grow Not Old..."

@tbicks2822

7 ай бұрын

It's called The Doctor Triumphant.

Very sad

I miss how good doctor who used to be

@tailsprowerfan2729

5 ай бұрын

We can’t have good story’s anymore sadly because we live in a woke hell Westland

🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹

Before Doctor Who fell down the wokehole never to surface again.

@davidmason7765

Жыл бұрын

if you use woke as a sledge it says more about you ... did you know Abraham Lincoln had a volunteer bodyguard called the wide awakes?

@jinkino

10 ай бұрын

They don’t make them like they used to anymore