Doctor Who David Tennat's Regeneration Is Either Really Smart Or Really Dumb

Ойын-сауық

Hello Guys. Today on Gate of Theories we are looking at the regeneration of the 14th doctor being a bigeneration for the Doctor Who 60th Anniversary Specials.
Doctor Who The Star Beast Is Too Woke • Doctor Who 60th Annive...
If you enjoy the video make sure you smash that like button and share it on social media. Tell us what you think in the field section below. Make sure you hit that subscribe button for more theories, top 10's, then and now's, reviews and much more every week as well as daily shorts.
Tik Tok:
Gate of theories / gateoftheoriestiktok
GOT Then and Now / gotthenandnow
GOT Facts / gotfactsofficial
GOT Sports: / @gotsportsofficial
GOT Reacts: / @gotreacts
Podcast and Music: www.mixcloud.com/lewis-gate/
Twitter: / gateoftheories
Facebook: / gateoftheories
Instagram: / gateoftheories
/ lrulesok
#davidtennat #ncutigatwa #doctorwho #drwho #disneyplus #bbc #regeneration #newdoctor #bigeneration

Пікірлер: 191

  • @joeskittlesman
    @joeskittlesman7 ай бұрын

    "Its just plain old gunfire you're dead, which hasnt happened to the Doctor before" The 7th Doctor would like a word, he was shot down like a dog in the street.

  • @stevenkun01

    @stevenkun01

    7 ай бұрын

    Came here to say exactly this!

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    Their not very good at recalling past events which is ridiculous when its about time travel. I always thought they missed a good story by not having Wilf as the copper he played in the Dr Who movie in the 60s, that would have made the older fans like me tingle. I watched the first ever episode late november l think aged 6 in 1963. An unearthly child. With the real Dr William Hartnell. By gum I'm bluddy old.

  • @stevenkun01

    @stevenkun01

    6 ай бұрын

    Bernard Cribbins was 93 when he died last year, and he shot those scenes just before his death. Having him up and about as the copper would have been near impossible given his health issues... plus, the films are not part of the official canon@@biggusdickus5986

  • @Justin-cw7rg
    @Justin-cw7rg7 ай бұрын

    I think it boiled down to RTD bringing back Donna and 10 and deciding he needed to give them a happy ending this time if he was going to do that. He also just has a history of playing with the rules of the show as opposed to Moffat who danced around them. I think primarily giving him another TARDIS was down to him thinking back to the metacrisis Doctor and deciding it was weird to have a Doctor without a TARDIS. I do believe it also was low key meant to serve as a back door to David Tennant though

  • @seanjones180
    @seanjones1807 ай бұрын

    I could retire and be a curator... Pretty genius

  • @moro2485

    @moro2485

    7 ай бұрын

    Bi regeneration might actually add more to that line than you think. The 11th met his 4th incarnation as a curator. He then said he might end up revisiting a few "old favorite" faces. Now we got the 14th doctor with the 10ths face spending even more time on earth with his tardis. The 14th could eventually regenerate into his 4th incarnation and travel back in time to retire as a curator while the 15th continues his story for future regenerations.

  • @seanjones180

    @seanjones180

    7 ай бұрын

    @@moro2485 sorry... That's what I I meant and why I quoted it

  • @moro2485

    @moro2485

    7 ай бұрын

    @@seanjones180 Ah...I think I've been watching too much doctor who. "Talk too much, that's my problem"

  • @zemoxian

    @zemoxian

    6 ай бұрын

    I thought about that too. I like that better than him becoming the Valyard.

  • @CToph23
    @CToph237 ай бұрын

    I absolutely HATED how they handled the regeneration. The whole magic and appeal of the Doctor regenerating is that although he is completely different he is the SAME person. This doesn’t feel like that anymore. It feels like 15 is a brand new entity and OUR doctor, the actual Doctor has just given up the tardis and who knows if and when we’ll ever see him again? Nah. Hate it.

  • @Luciry123

    @Luciry123

    7 ай бұрын

    Each Doctor is different though? Yes they are literally the same character, just each one has different personality. It's why multi Doctor stories like The Three Doctor, and Day of the Doctor work as we can see how different each Doctor is. Also it works for a decent way to have Tennants Doctor a break he so desperately needs while Ncutis off doing his Adventure

  • @underscore814

    @underscore814

    7 ай бұрын

    Bi generation is so woke its gay. Should've ended at Peter capaldi imo

  • @CToph23

    @CToph23

    7 ай бұрын

    @@Luciry123 yes each doctor is “different” but they are the same Doctor. Multi Doctor stories have worked in the past due to time travel not because the doctors have split apart!

  • @andrewterry6538

    @andrewterry6538

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@underscore814 "bi" just means two, ya moron. He regenerated into TWO people. Jesus Christ. Keep using the word "woke" when you're a little uncomfortable, though.

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    ​@@underscore814Should have ended after Patrick Troughton. Then after Chris Eccleson

  • @elliesteele2027
    @elliesteele20277 ай бұрын

    I feel like the bigeneration _might_ work IF: a. This is the only time this happens so we don't have a mass of Doctor's running about simultaneously. and b. Don't have 14 #2 have the ability to regenerate so the timeline doesn't get even more excessively conplicated than it already is.

  • @RandomUser7773

    @RandomUser7773

    7 ай бұрын

    3 woke culture genocide.

  • @AnotherGuyV

    @AnotherGuyV

    7 ай бұрын

    This episode was a better one than the 2 previous one so for me there is still a bit a hope for the x-mass special and the new season. However RTD is a mystery box and it can be good or bad depending on how much he wants to piss off the fans.@@RandomUser7773

  • @trashboat5388

    @trashboat5388

    7 ай бұрын

    Well the 14th is obviously going to be the Curator from the 50th so he will likely regenerate into old faces when the 15th regenerates into new faces

  • @taliaalvarez7235

    @taliaalvarez7235

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@@trashboat5388I approve of that plot line :D

  • @ryanread8617

    @ryanread8617

    7 ай бұрын

    I think this will be the only time it ever occurs, since David Tennant doctor was the only doctor who cried not to leave, his wish finally came true. IT also reminds when his hand was cut off and it started regenerating, so this bi-regeneration isn't complete nonsense.

  • @HarmonyShoal
    @HarmonyShoal7 ай бұрын

    The question no one is asking, Does14 eventually regenerate into the fugitive doctor somehow? It could explain why she had a second Tardis that we saw during thirteens run.

  • @PaulRichards-vz4pl
    @PaulRichards-vz4pl7 ай бұрын

    It’s really dumb because it spoils the impact of regeneration and turns it into a goofy joke. If the Doctor can live on then why have him regenerate at all?

  • @brucewayne7838

    @brucewayne7838

    7 ай бұрын

    this whole show has been a goofy joke since 2005 onwards. i want this show kept well away from the original classic series thankyou.

  • @PaulRichards-vz4pl

    @PaulRichards-vz4pl

    7 ай бұрын

    @@brucewayne7838 I have to agree with you.

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    ​@@brucewayne7838the timeless child should be deleted fom history and everyones misfortune who encountered it. RTD should be locked up for interfering and treason for attempted murder of a national treasure that is the Doctor. I wonder how great tennant would have been with a great writer shorn of " messages " things said that wouldnt have even been thought of and definitily not needed in the older shows.

  • @doctoratheist1573
    @doctoratheist15737 ай бұрын

    When it comes to doctor who there's always gonna be hits and misses but overall. I think this will be all right for now. You gotta remember when the fourth doctor regenerated into the fifth. He basically merged with another creature in order to regenerate into his fifth regeneration. So if anything should happen in the near future. I got a feeling something might like that might happen. But that's too early to say

  • @spacey_432
    @spacey_4327 ай бұрын

    All I can say is, I really want Ncuti Gatwa's doctor to succeed. Thats all I want, if that happens then nothing will be wrong in the world.

  • @animeswitch

    @animeswitch

    7 ай бұрын

    All it would take is to leave out politics and someone that cares about writing good stories

  • @randombsgo4367

    @randombsgo4367

    7 ай бұрын

    @@animeswitch well thats not happening

  • @crazychips123
    @crazychips1237 ай бұрын

    I like it. I’m thinking eventually they’ll merge together again in the future and become a full doctor again and be the next doctor at one point.

  • @LavosGaming

    @LavosGaming

    7 ай бұрын

    They're both "full" though, Fifteen has Fourteen's memories and experiences. There's no loss of anything. It's bi-generation, it's new, it's Doctor Who. I'm pleasantly surprised and hope it paves way for Tennant adventures as a spin-off.

  • @BuffNerd_

    @BuffNerd_

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@@LavosGamingi hope it doesnt pave the way for tennant spin offs. I like Tennant but he has had enough screen time for sure lol, every other doctor has had way less. He should go to extended media if he wants to carry on.

  • @enzyte9215

    @enzyte9215

    7 ай бұрын

    @@BuffNerd_ honestly, i enjoyed his time with the specials but my god anymore i will get tennant fatigue... i was gonna be happy with a happy ending and a regenration with him accepting his deathnthis time and seeing donna one last time

  • @Luciry123

    @Luciry123

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@@LavosGaming I think it would pave the way for him to maybe Pop up occasionally in future Specials. My main problem is that if they had a spin off following another Doctor it would split the fan base in half

  • @ShamrockParticle

    @ShamrockParticle

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@Luciry123 many doctor actors have come back before without this unnecessary contrivance.

  • @Olly_2024_
    @Olly_2024_7 ай бұрын

    A DT spinoff in the future?

  • @MLaak86
    @MLaak867 ай бұрын

    It's incredibly smart imo - the Toymaker wants to play the last round vs a new Doctor but cause the game is still technically in play from the second round he can't simply eliminate 14 from the playing field so instaed of forcing a regeneration he causes a bigeneration.

  • @phir3fo3nix39

    @phir3fo3nix39

    7 ай бұрын

    Yeahhhh that's a good idea

  • @Starsteam1

    @Starsteam1

    7 ай бұрын

    So he cheats against himself? what

  • @MichaelM28

    @MichaelM28

    6 ай бұрын

    No it's incredibly stupid shill

  • @AnotherGuyV
    @AnotherGuyV7 ай бұрын

    Personally i think RTD made the bi-regeneration only to have a 'plan b' with David Tennant Doctor if the new Doctor fails. For me it shows how little faith RTD has in the future with the new Doctor. It wasn't as 'outrageous' as RTD claimed this episode would be but not worthy to be considered a masterpiece. It's a solid episode i'd say but like the 2 previous specials it didn't feel like a 60th anniversary special. RTD still can write a good story if he concentrates on the characters and storytelling instead of adding stuff just to piss off the fans. However the Christmas special is better to be outstanding if he really wants the show to take off and give the new Doctor a good push and a chance to succeed.

  • @shippendales8543

    @shippendales8543

    7 ай бұрын

    I think it's a way of having David Tennant return again He is arguably the most popular doctor of our generation So people will always be happy to see David in the role

  • @MasterChiefSpartan117
    @MasterChiefSpartan1177 ай бұрын

    I'm just happy we keep Tennant this time and that version doesn't die and regenerate this time. We get to keep him and Donna, and they get a happy ending. He can still travel the universe whenever he wants and he gets to keep that face this time. I'm happy. I didn't want to say goodbye to my Doctor all over again. This was a good compromise by Russell. We get a new Doctor but fans at the same time we get to keep our Doctor (Tennant).

  • @masauchongwe
    @masauchongwe7 ай бұрын

    Gatwa said that he was fine because tennant fixed himself. Rehab out of order. Im pretty sure that means that they are still the same dr just at different points in time but happening at the same time. Meaning that eventually tennant will regenerate into gatwa and both tardises are actually the same tardis. Like the toymaker pulled his future self out through him rather than him actually regenerating

  • @piercemckenzie3403
    @piercemckenzie34037 ай бұрын

    The answer is simple for either how 14 and 15 will end up...The Valeyard

  • @Sam-zu5mr
    @Sam-zu5mr7 ай бұрын

    2 Doctor's and 2 TARDIS's....nope doesn't work for me. It just feels like the real Doctor got so wary, that a clone was made and said, hey you just put your feet up and i will now travel the universe instead and in your name. For me the real Doctor has just retired. Leaving a fake Doctor to do his job for him. Not a great way to honour what should have been Ncuti Gatwa's passing of the torch as the 15th incarnation. A new Doctor with no cares for the Doctors past- which still remains very much unresolved.

  • @Justin-cw7rg

    @Justin-cw7rg

    7 ай бұрын

    I think you put into words well what bothered a lot of us about this. The duplicated TARDIS is what really nailed the whole “clone” thing down. Really delegitimized Ncuti in a way

  • @blakemeade6982
    @blakemeade69827 ай бұрын

    So not a cheap out… 15 said that that he was doing rehab in the wrong order… so that means what happens to 14 on earth affects 15… they had to give 14 a ship because then when he regenerates 15 wouldn’t of had one… and they said 15 was older… so what if the whole Bi-regeneration is just somehow the future doctor coming into past through the means of his younger self do to a sticky situation that 15 had found himself in. So essentially 14 pulled a 10 and didn’t change is face after the beam… and has far as there being two doctors on the same time line that’s always been a thing… they can time travel and time is constantly moving so it’s sorta the same as the doctors being in the same place at the same time as other specials has had them do they’ve just found themselves at the same time and place as a past/future version as the one we’re currently following

  • @russmorgan315
    @russmorgan3157 ай бұрын

    Doctors in the olden days usually have some angst about being in the company of their regenerations. I preferred it that way.

  • @lukedaley17
    @lukedaley177 ай бұрын

    I agree with u. A lot of unanswered questions surrounding the bi-generation term. Other than that looking forward to seeing Ncuti Gatwa as number 15 in the future season’s of Dr Who.

  • @jameshurcombe2049

    @jameshurcombe2049

    7 ай бұрын

    It's not unanswered questions it's just plot armour

  • @joshinthesauce4636
    @joshinthesauce46367 ай бұрын

    I thought it was pretty clever and interesting. It keeps possibilities open for Tennant’s Doctor while having the new Doctor, Ncuti Gatwa, make his own debut.

  • @user-on5dl9hc2z

    @user-on5dl9hc2z

    6 ай бұрын

    it actually solves a plothole from the baker era.

  • @michaelmcdonald3275
    @michaelmcdonald32757 ай бұрын

    I thought in an earlier story that the doctor was never allowed to physically come into contact with earlier versions of himself lest it destroyed the integrity of the previous Dr timestream before the next regeneration...

  • @davidgraham8299
    @davidgraham82996 ай бұрын

    It certainly isn't dumb. It's so smart and maybe a bit too smart for it's own good. Cause now we're seeing so much conjecture and theories from people who are determined to over think it

  • @gm2407
    @gm24077 ай бұрын

    Wonder if the older Doctors are going to show up again. I keep hearing that Russel said that it has retroactively changed all the older regenerations to bigenerations. Havent seen it for myself though.

  • @justdidio
    @justdidio6 ай бұрын

    I just wonder if they will both be able to regenerate, did ncuati get a new set of 12 regenerations or did he take the rest of tennants.

  • @BrianRosenbergMusican
    @BrianRosenbergMusican7 ай бұрын

    if 14 is the fugitive doctor after a regeneration its a pretty good idea, Cleans up some of Chibs mess.

  • @brandoman79

    @brandoman79

    7 ай бұрын

    sadly that wouldn't make sense; as why doesn't The Fugitive Doctor know about the 13th Doctor her past self or know what a sonic screwdriver is? My Belief is after listening to what the 15th Doctor tells the 14th Doctor , is that he is from the point after the 14th Doctor has spent time with the Nobles, talking to them and getting things off his chest and mentally healing; hence the 15th Doctor's line to the 14th Doctor about having had therapy out of order, my theory is a Bi-Regeneration is when a Time Lord has a regeneration in two different points of time at the exact same moment. As for the "2nd" Tardis; there are clues that the 15th Doctor's tardis and the 14th Doctor's tardis are the same one, but the 15th Doctor's is from the future; it is an exact copy except it has the added juke box and also the wheel chair ramp. Why a wheel chair ramp? Well when we see the 14th Doctor with the Nobles we hear Wilfred shooting moles in the distance; Rose mentions wanting to go on adventures with the 14th Doctor; and I wouldn't be surprised old Wilfred wouldn't want to go on some more too and I can easily see the Doctor adding a wheel chair ramp to make it easier for Wilfred to get in and out of the tardis. Since the 15th Doctor was brought back to his past, again implied by his excitement to see Donna and Mel, and play the Toy Maker's game; to the point he gladly whips the ball at his past self. Why? Because he knows they defeat the Toy Maker he's already witnessed it when he was the 14th Doctor, but since he is from the future he is separed from the tardis so his prize is getting the tardis back to him in the Toy Realm; so him grabbing the mallet and hitting the tardis to "split it in two" is all an act so he doesn't spoil stuff for his previous incarnation , but he didn't actually split the tardis into two, it's really the same tardis brought from the future after the whole living with the Nobles and healing himself brought back to his past when he fought the Toymaker.

  • @BrianRosenbergMusican

    @BrianRosenbergMusican

    7 ай бұрын

    @@brandoman79 Doctor who has changed cannon so many times since 1963 its insane. every showrunner seems to decide if gallelfrey is gone or not. Mind wipes happen. Tardis interiors change. The master had a tardis until he didn't until chibs gave the master a tardis again. Fact is right now two police boxes exist. 13 dug up one of them. the interiors get reset. Its possible they can make something up to explain this. Two doctors Same DNA. Same brain.

  • @namle198818
    @namle1988187 ай бұрын

    If you follow the comic, the David tenant doctor with Rose also have a TARDIS. He regrown the Tardis from a small piece of the Tardis. I wish they would have shown that in the TV series. Now there are 3 doctors with three Tardis. In addition, the timeless child storyline shows that there were more regeneration before the first doctor and other bigeneration may have happened before.

  • @dainethompson6531

    @dainethompson6531

    7 ай бұрын

    It was shown in a deleted scene

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    Who takes any notice of the timeless child,? Nobody liked it nobody wants it as canon, it should be a deleted nightmare or something complete and utter borlocks

  • @namle198818

    @namle198818

    6 ай бұрын

    @biggusdickus5986 Without the timeless child storyline, the doctor would run out of Regenerations at the 11th doctor. He is limited to 12 Regeneration if we count the war doctor.

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    @@namle198818 they could have wwriten in a get out clause for the doctor to regenerate any half way decent writer could have come up with something, people would have accepted it to keep the doctor going. The timeless child was just self indukgent rubbish a travesty that should be eradicated along with its writer.

  • @CaesiusX
    @CaesiusX7 ай бұрын

    I wonder if this will cause some to see the new Doctor as an almost temporary or _unreal_ Doctor. 🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    Well he's always only temporary, but l get the feeling the new doctors going to be the worst yet, l think we will be shouting for the lady doctor to come back because he's going to be so awfully annoying he sounded gay in just a few minutes on screen, l mean camp type too, l wait in trepidation. But l know its going to be bad, asdoes RTD which is why he left open the door for tennant.

  • @1PiezeF0rEv3r
    @1PiezeF0rEv3r7 ай бұрын

    I'm Surprised not Many People aren't Suggesting David's Doctor just became John Smith again (It went Full Circle from Tenant's Era also)

  • @Rajesh-Koothrappali

    @Rajesh-Koothrappali

    7 ай бұрын

    At the end he’s still timelord

  • @user-on5dl9hc2z
    @user-on5dl9hc2z6 ай бұрын

    one of them will become the watcher from the tom baker series. That regen had a second doctor merge into him.

  • @debonaire_nerd
    @debonaire_nerd7 ай бұрын

    I feel sorry for Ncuti because, so far, he has been given second hand treatment - TWICE. First - including him in An Adventure in Space and Time. A lot of fans like this, but really think about it. Instead of giving Ncuti his own moment, he's just been digitally superimposed into a scene that belonged to another Doctor. It's a literal hand-me-down. Second - now. For reasons stated in this video, he is sharing a simultaneous existence with David Tennant's Doctor (who also has his own TARDIS). For now, Ncuti is not his own Doctor. And that's a shame. The bigeneration is a bad idea.

  • @junethanoschurchill6750

    @junethanoschurchill6750

    7 ай бұрын

    I agree with you, however I did hear that the scene from Adventure in Space and Time was shot with the intention of it being updated with each new Doctor. Apparently Matt Smith was originally superimposed into the scene as well.

  • @debonaire_nerd

    @debonaire_nerd

    7 ай бұрын

    @@junethanoschurchill6750 I heard that same thing too and, if true? A poor creative decision. Lazy even.

  • @BadluckTribe
    @BadluckTribe7 ай бұрын

    The 11th stepped into his timeline. Its going to cause some issues which havent played out yet

  • @teab0244
    @teab02446 ай бұрын

    I believe the 14th Doctor will eventually regenerate to become 15. Dies of old age (perhaps his life span is shorter now so he can spend it with Donna) and awakens in the bi-regen as 15. In the bi-regen, it is, after all, implied that 15 was pulled from 14’s future “I’m better because you fix yourself”. So they’re not separate entities anymore once 15 arrives, hence my theory.

  • @gingercouzins8513
    @gingercouzins85137 ай бұрын

    Time is never Linear. Time lines and lives can change because of it. Like some doctors can make appearances from their adventures like in the Day of the Doctor when we thought all of their lives were finished. Crossing ones own time stream may have tremendous effects so what if he never did that. Maybe Bi generation isnt a universal breaking thing like the Celestial Toymakers prize was to play with the next doctor never stating for this one to die. Its only a myth because breaking the rules weren't considered. Maybe in the future we see an event of all the doctors saying a thank you or seeing glimpse of different timelines where all was Victorious no lives were lost and no sorrows felt. This may be the era of the Doctor Infinite solidifying a mere title in the Fabric of the Universe.

  • @Rajesh-Koothrappali
    @Rajesh-Koothrappali7 ай бұрын

    I mean can’t it be both ? There’s 2 doctors, the David tennant doctor, might become the curator back in the time of the doctor, this could be a thing ? I mean the curator did say who knows implying it might NOT be the actual doctor

  • @redhilleagle9518
    @redhilleagle95186 ай бұрын

    We'll likely see another Tennant episode, I predict spin off specials with him. He loves Doctor Who and will always come back to it if asked. Giving him a TARDIS always gives them that option.

  • @brianotoole1642
    @brianotoole16427 ай бұрын

    There is already 2 David tennants ,one human and one time lord, also there is also never used plot for the human one with the piece of coral like structure that was to grow into another tartis.

  • @MichaelBaldwinb3l0kk
    @MichaelBaldwinb3l0kk7 ай бұрын

    did they every answer the question about his cloths regenerating during Jody to tennant?

  • @randombsgo4367

    @randombsgo4367

    7 ай бұрын

    apparently the TARDIS was providing them mid regeneration, it could always do that now

  • @al56890
    @al568907 ай бұрын

    I think it’s an okay idea. Retire the classic doctor and begin a new era. I do like that they did say it’s rare for Bi-regeneration to happen which means it’s not a guarantee that when Ncuti regenerates it will happen again. I really think this is the only time they will do it.

  • @ryanread8617
    @ryanread86177 ай бұрын

    I did think it was a bit crazy this bi-regeneration, but now I kind of like it. David Tennant doctor was the only doctor who cried not to leave, his wish finally came true. IT also reminds when his hand was cut off and it started regenerating, so this bi-regeneration does have the grounds to exist.

  • @jameshurcombe2049

    @jameshurcombe2049

    7 ай бұрын

    Nope he just shoots him to cause him to regenerate he doesn't know about bigeneraying. Its just plot armour that the 2 could exist

  • @ryanread8617

    @ryanread8617

    7 ай бұрын

    @@jameshurcombe2049 Nope I never said he knew it would happen, of course he shot him to just regenerate normally, but with plot armor, everything is plot armour. As long as it has a basis I'm fine with it, since the previous doctor said it felt different I believe the 4th or 5th on Tardis floor, I'm fine with this fresh change whilst as said doctor limbs tried to regenerate on there own, so regeneration can occur when the host splits whether it be a limb or himself it seems now.

  • @markburgess6801
    @markburgess68017 ай бұрын

    maybe a future adventure will see the 14th doctor be reabsorbed into the current doctor to save the life of that future doctor or maybe 14 can become the curator

  • @smabb
    @smabb6 ай бұрын

    1. they also broke the rule of the doctor haveing the same clothes & the meta doctor had no clothes bereminimum 15 should have tenants clothes double its makes sense 2. each of the doctotrs regenerations got more explosive so it should have been big this thime

  • @nuclearbumrecords
    @nuclearbumrecords6 ай бұрын

    It's like something written by a 5 year old. Particularly the whole idea that it happened simultaneously for all the past Doctors, utterly ridiculous. At least The Timeless Children was properly thought through and explained on screen, even if it was unpopular. RTD has jumped the shark AND the dolphin AND a whole bunch of penguins

  • @justaghostinthesea
    @justaghostinthesea6 ай бұрын

    I like it on a story level. The Doctor getting to both settle down _and_ continue adventuring is lovely. But on a meta level... I think it would have been wiser to just go with a straight forward regeneration. Because I've already seen videos spouting nonsense about 15 "not being The Doctor", which could have been avoided. Though I'm ultimately quite happy with the ending we got, it does feel like RTD trying to have his cake and eat it too (which I don't blame him for in the slightest btw).

  • @UltraPokeZ
    @UltraPokeZ7 ай бұрын

    To me that's a smart move you have two doctors both occupying the same space and time. Also that keeps the door open for a possible season finale cliff hanger at some point. The 15th doctor would be fighting a enemy too powerful for just one. Also during the day of the doctor yes there was three different doctors together. They was from separate timelines war doctor from the great war of galifrey, the 10th was after the time war and the 11th "centuries" later. That would of caused a catastrophic event that could destroy all of time if the doctors didn't go back to their own timeline.

  • @leviswift4489
    @leviswift44896 ай бұрын

    I think it’s clever as everyone hated the 13th run but Davies being a good writer was like it wasn’t false that line but instead it’s the end with Jody regenerating into David and David retiring at the end of this season. It also links to the 13th doctor episodes of the people who had regeneration powers and in my opinion if worked well can make the 13th run as well turn good. Yes as side the script and half the episodes were terrible but you cannot start fresh from a show that’s been running 60+ years you need to link. I hope and you guys need to hope and trust. 😊

  • @TomHaynes-cb5yh
    @TomHaynes-cb5yh7 ай бұрын

    I think it was a good idea it was a fantastic episode of the specials i did like the regeneration to the new doctor it was absolute so difficult than previous doctor's it was great to see the new doctor with David Tennant & he was so happy which i liked. I don't think it was the last time to see David Tennant but i would be surprised to see him again. I can't wait to see more of the new doctor

  • @CameronKiesser
    @CameronKiesser6 ай бұрын

    If Ncuti flops hard, they could just retcon him as a "non-doctor" and return to Tennant. But I still think this is all dumb.

  • @gm2407
    @gm24077 ай бұрын

    I like how all the focus has gone on the bigeneration and that RTD got away with the biting social commentary in the episode about everyone thinking they are right and never compromising. Personally that was one of the best bits of the whole story in my opinion.

  • @robr7815

    @robr7815

    7 ай бұрын

    But that's true. Everyone on the left (RTD included) all think they're in the right and never compromise. I have no issue with it because it is so true xD I find it ironic that he puts this social commentary when he is exactly like that. Everyone on the left think they're right due to "moral superiority " (which is really utter rubbish) and everyone opposing the left think they're right because they adhere to logic and common sense. Neither compromises. Both hate each other. Left hates right for being "sexist/racist", the right hates the left because they get called "sexist/racist" for not agreeing with the left. Like, can't both sides stop seeing each other as the villain? Compromise bruv. There are sexists and racists on both sides. But there are a lot of good people on both sides as well.

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    Yeah he was talking about himself. 😂

  • @yonkouaquaman4969
    @yonkouaquaman49697 ай бұрын

    It would be cool for the story to tell the origins of the valeyard (the evil version of the doctor) through this bi-generation with one of them becoming the valeyard

  • @rhysstuart7035
    @rhysstuart70357 ай бұрын

    God I hate the bi-generation. So many unexplained things. Can 14 regenerate? Or does 14 have to go merge back into 15 at some stage to bring the bodies back together? With the rumoured UNIT spin-off, will 14 join UNIT? That could give the spin-off some serious draw power, having Tennant signed on, even if it's just a minor role. The biggest issue I have now, is that whenever Ncuti's Doctor comes to save modern day Earth, we'll always just say "well couldn't 14 have dealt with this?" Something dramatic happens globally, and 14's just gonna stay seated in Donna's garden talking about eyebrows?

  • @MichaelM28
    @MichaelM286 ай бұрын

    It's Really Dumb R.I.P DOCTOR WHO 1963 - 2017

  • @ysthafellgynghori8423
    @ysthafellgynghori84237 ай бұрын

    Its really smart. I hope we get a spin-off featuring the Tennant Doctor and Donna in the near-future.

  • @KainReave

    @KainReave

    6 ай бұрын

    That's cute. You get a trans POC Rose running of with 14th Tardis spin-off.

  • @banvard
    @banvard6 ай бұрын

    Tennant is sort of on a sabbatical, I think eventually they will re-merge?

  • @ApolloStarfall
    @ApolloStarfall7 ай бұрын

    Maybe if you spelled his name right in the title, I'd be more likely to agree

  • @samburgerwithcheeze8145
    @samburgerwithcheeze81456 ай бұрын

    Heres my theories for bi-regeneration and why 13 reverted back into a previous face(not saying this is what 100% happens but my assumption. So if this is not the case dont bite my head off becayse russel's reasons differ from mines) *Reason why 14 uses 10s face:* Is due to the master messing up the doctors regeneration cycles by becoming a doctor. Then 13 returning back not stable(because she just regenerated back and the phase wasnt solidified, like how ten could regenerate a hand before the process was done) and her instantly being force to regenerate *again* makes her go back to a familar face due to the meddling of the master. *Why bi-generation happened:* The doctor was in the toymaker's domain and regenerating in this weird place causes him to bi-generate. You can also add on the master theory to this because he did mess up the doctors rotations and forced her to regenerate into 14.

  • @danforrest7765
    @danforrest77657 ай бұрын

    It served no purpose whatsoever and makes Ncuti into discount Doctor

  • @Badnewsblink
    @Badnewsblink7 ай бұрын

    They are grasping so badly to save Doctor Who but they are only digging the hole deeper. This is just meta crisis 2.0, we never heard from that doctor again. Instead of having self reflection and looking at what has worked and what hasn't, they just keep trying to fan the flames. It's all just so disappointing.

  • @michaeldemarco9950
    @michaeldemarco99507 ай бұрын

    “If I have to live my life with a past companion, the 14th Doctor asks, “can I go back to Clara?”

  • @justdidio

    @justdidio

    6 ай бұрын

    Where was this said? thanks.

  • @michaeldemarco9950

    @michaeldemarco9950

    6 ай бұрын

    @@justdidio , it wasn’t. I was just projecting what I would have said.

  • @kealiimaxilom2465
    @kealiimaxilom24657 ай бұрын

    It explains the former 3 Part doctor.

  • @denial987
    @denial9877 ай бұрын

    Is this how the character always gonna regenerate from now or is this a one off?

  • @KathleenHolland-nk8nk
    @KathleenHolland-nk8nk7 ай бұрын

    I was just about to say that he should be like the metacrisis Doctor! 😅😲

  • @mathieuleader8601
    @mathieuleader86017 ай бұрын

    what if the bi-regeneration happened with the Timeless Child creating the Doctor and the Master

  • @victorkreed4629
    @victorkreed46297 ай бұрын

    Dumb , Pandaverse bs especially Jason/Rose and splitting The Doctor and doubling his T.A.R.D.I.S.. This show has being going down since the companions were first called fam. The doctor should have stayed with the Ponds or better River. DO NOT LET RUSSEL EVER WRITE ANOTHER EPISODE!!! I partly blame Disney.

  • @Night-Cat123
    @Night-Cat1236 ай бұрын

    This sucks it better be the only time this happens I don’t know why they want to change the way regeneration happens and works

  • @kevincarbonneau
    @kevincarbonneau7 ай бұрын

    I loved every second of this.

  • @thatokperson
    @thatokperson7 ай бұрын

    Allons y means let's go in French so that was nice

  • @doritofan1002
    @doritofan10027 ай бұрын

    I don’t think it a a very smart decision bc I just wanna watch Donna and the doctor hosting dinners in Donna’s backyard and that’s not fair to the new doctor

  • @aname.5439
    @aname.54397 ай бұрын

    My biggest disappointment with the Bigeneration is it didn’t feel like ncuti was the real doctor. He was so quick to leave Donna behind which I don’t think the real doctor would do even if her favorite face was still back there with her Yk?

  • @animeswitch

    @animeswitch

    7 ай бұрын

    litterally! Its so weird, it doesn't make any sense if they are the same person, he just buggered off and was somehow completely free from all guilt like a completely different person.

  • @Enzo012
    @Enzo0127 ай бұрын

    So they're both the exact same person not an original and copy? That's what I'm not quite getting. You could kill one of them and he'd still be not dead?

  • @evangravell5140
    @evangravell51407 ай бұрын

    This is getting out of hand now there are two of them!

  • @user-qt8ys4nv9k
    @user-qt8ys4nv9k6 ай бұрын

    I thought it was mind boggling, and I really like that, how

  • @michaeldemarco9950
    @michaeldemarco99507 ай бұрын

    The 14th Doctor has already regenerated into the 15th Doctor. Next time he regenerates, it’ll be into his own 16th Doctor, while the 15th Doctor will regenerate into his own, parallel 16th Doctor.

  • @JoffreDon
    @JoffreDon6 ай бұрын

    It makes sense in an evolutionary sense

  • @Boomer_Schooner_24
    @Boomer_Schooner_246 ай бұрын

    This tbh destroy regeneration why couldn't the 10th and 11th bi generated

  • @ruralrebeltory7474
    @ruralrebeltory74747 ай бұрын

    I love the happy ending and am looking forward to many more 14th Doctor episodes and adventures!!!!

  • @robertkeller9828
    @robertkeller98286 ай бұрын

    It's going to take something VERY radical to SAVE DW after the past 3 Seasons under Chibnal.....

  • @michaeldemarco9950
    @michaeldemarco99507 ай бұрын

    The 7th Doctor was shot and killed . . . sort of.

  • @Artur-Itas
    @Artur-Itas7 ай бұрын

    KRAPPPPPPPP. UR A MUPPET. HE REPEATED THE SAME ENDING ON THE YEAR OF YOUR BIRTH SPENCER!!!!!!!!

  • @ARenamonOnTheInternet
    @ARenamonOnTheInternet7 ай бұрын

    I loved the new Generation

  • @highlander723
    @highlander7237 ай бұрын

    Sooooo who gets the TARDIS

  • @Ziran_Uru
    @Ziran_Uru7 ай бұрын

    is this guy in prison, because it looks like hes in a prison cell.

  • @DMann2006
    @DMann20067 ай бұрын

    Another Doctor Clone - AGAIN? One for Rose (in the alternative Universe) - and one for Donna? RTD is running out of ideas. Even the Global Threat that was linked to technology that all Human's were linked too was a rehash of ATMOS for Season 4. The Spice Girls song "Spice of your Life" was a rehash of "Voodoo Child" from Season 3. Another rehashed happy ending like Rose? Grabbing the Master via Tooth (via red fingernails) ala Season 3. Where are the original ideas? Ncuti Gatwa was great. I'm worried for Doctor Who with rehashed bad writing from RTD like this!

  • @danielr5552
    @danielr55527 ай бұрын

    I honestly appreciate it. This is the jumping off point for those of us that have no interest in watching the show anymore. The show ended for me today. 10 got a family and can retire. Beautiful. I do appreciate it from RTD. He can now go do whatever he wants with his doctor. Mines over.

  • @channyh.221B

    @channyh.221B

    7 ай бұрын

    Bye

  • @LavosGaming

    @LavosGaming

    7 ай бұрын

    Be honest, you're gonna end up curious to see how the new one's doing. Don't lie.

  • @danielr5552

    @danielr5552

    7 ай бұрын

    I haven’t watched since that “trump” Jodie episode. Decided it wasn’t for me but I did watch reviews to keep up with story line. Not even that now. I’m not the fan they want. I really do appreciate the episode. It’s a great ending for the original line of doctors.

  • @MoodyTheRellik
    @MoodyTheRellik7 ай бұрын

    I think there was no hole in him because the toymaker didnt want there to be. He just wanted to do enough damage to force a regeneration. And as he controls everything now he can decide what the laser does. Pretty sure the whole bigeneration thing was the toymakers doing aswell as he wanted to keep duplicating the doctor to keep killing and playing with him

  • @MLaak86

    @MLaak86

    7 ай бұрын

    I think he's bound by the rules of his own game - if you start/continue a best of 3 vs one incarnation of a Time Lord you can't remove it from play cause you want to play another.

  • @KathleenHolland-nk8nk
    @KathleenHolland-nk8nk7 ай бұрын

    Same here! I kinda like it, but I don't.

  • @F5ss
    @F5ss7 ай бұрын

    I think its a perfect way for the 60th to end, given that next series is going to be branded as season 1, this could be looked at as one Finale of doctor who. So they ended it. But in a way that it still goes on

  • @skullknight4579
    @skullknight45797 ай бұрын

    Honestly…not the weirdest regeneration I’ve seen amd it has an explanation unlike how 4th regenerated into the 5th

  • @Rajesh-Koothrappali

    @Rajesh-Koothrappali

    7 ай бұрын

    How is it not the weirdest one you’ve seen ? It’s literally the only one that’s weird, they even say it’s a myth in the show

  • @JazzFan76
    @JazzFan767 ай бұрын

    I hope the show tanks and they just get rid of it altogether.

  • @IamNOTyourSLAVE
    @IamNOTyourSLAVE6 ай бұрын

    Cannot watch anymore of this, the dude keeps repeating himself lol

  • @mechapineman
    @mechapineman7 ай бұрын

    Just fills the plot hole of the curator from the 50th. Bi generated Tennant retires and regenerate in to a few of the old favorites and heads back in the Tardis to meet 11, the long way round. It was brilliant.

  • @drishalballaney6590
    @drishalballaney65907 ай бұрын

    this also adds another theory, what if the master was actually a bi-regeneration way back, which is why they could be friends, and maybe due to some trauma they did not remember if they actually were the same being I have another slightly more messed up theory...(maybe possible), the 13th doctor might have had a one night stand at some point and resulted in bi regeneration here

  • @benjaminhopley3045
    @benjaminhopley30457 ай бұрын

    David turns into Tom baker lol 😂

  • @annied1827
    @annied18277 ай бұрын

    I think its genius, as it opens up a for a spin off series plus David is my 2nd fave dr so I'm happy he's back.plus I think there would be a uproar if he left again so soon after coming back. It made me laugh when you said the dr from our childhood, I forget that he is the dr of may people's childhood which makes me feel very, very old as my childhood drs are Tom Baker, Colin Baker and Sylvester McCoy 🙈 although Tom Baker will always be my no 1 Dr. That's because Tom was never acting as a character he was just been himself which made him all the more fun to watch, there is a reason so many people like the 4th dr and say hes one of the best we have had. David was a lot like Tom in many ways, which is why so many are happy to have him back again.because hes either the 1st or 2nd favourite of so many. I say 1st and 2nd as you will find most older fans like myself will always Tom 1st and David 2nd where as the genration of my kids will put David 1st and Tom 2nd unless your like my son who would put Tom 1st and David 2nd lol 😀

  • @bbernard1981
    @bbernard19817 ай бұрын

    No Timeless Child was dumb, Fugitive Doctor horrible. This could be cool, give it a chance.

  • @wolfvermilion
    @wolfvermilion6 ай бұрын

    Its terrrible

  • @YaBoiJoosh
    @YaBoiJoosh7 ай бұрын

    When I was watching the episode I was honestly hoping that both of them would merge back together somehow, because I honestly really don't like how there's two of them now. I would rather just have a regeneration that works in the traditional way that we've seen a million times before. I thought the laser going through 14 was honestly a good way to make him regenerate, but I'd rather 14 actually regenerate into 15.

  • @GateOfTheories

    @GateOfTheories

    7 ай бұрын

    I like the idea of splitting then having to merge back again

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    Open your minnnnd. To quote another traveller in time and space and dimensions, 2 Drs alive at the same time..? Fantastic OPEN YOUR MINNND.. But no pickleDoctors tho. 😂

  • @biggusdickus5986

    @biggusdickus5986

    6 ай бұрын

    Just from the few minutes we've seen of the new dr calling people well tennant love, I'm getting a baaaaaad feeling about his tenure l think the new Dr is going to be sooo annoying and crap.

  • @animysticamv4417
    @animysticamv44177 ай бұрын

    This is the end of doctor who as we've known him. Ncuti is rebooting it for the pc woke people who want to watch shows with diversity and sexuality issues, as a kid who grew up on Russell Davies work and then seen the previous doctors as years went by I want to watch ncuti gatwa but I can't stand how openly their forcing gay sexuality on people, that shouldn't be the point of the show when it's meant to just be an awesome scifi show. There's nothing wrong with lgbtq whatever it is people can do whatever they want but just don't force it on everyone too much

  • @markenetube
    @markenetube7 ай бұрын

    I loved that they left it so David could "guest" when required, or even do the odd "special" with Donna. Ncuti Gatwa's Dr. was full of fun and engergy, just like David was. That' what was missing with the last two Whos.

  • @gladiator652004
    @gladiator6520047 ай бұрын

    Dramatically it was a TOO happy ending. There needs to be a smidgen of despair in addition to a great deal of hope.

Келесі