Did This Great Muslim Music Director Hate Hindus? | Drama series Indian |
Ойын-сауық
Strange story of a famous music director...
Did This Famous Muslim Music Director Hate Hindus? | Drama series Indian |
#Naushad #NaushadMusicDirector #DramaSeriesIndian
The famous composer of Indian Cinema was a phenomenon of popular Indian cinema from the early 1940s into the early 1970s, who introduced a unique fusion of devotional, classical and north Indian folk music. Without Naushad's vision and thematically composed songs, it is difficult to imagine the impact of films like Mother India (1957), which features classical ragas and folk music.
A product of the composite culture of Lucknow, Naushad understood Hindu and Muslim culture and the languages, dialects and poetry associated with them. Against the wishes of his father he learned classical and folk music and, aged 18, moved to Mumbai (formerly Bombay), India's film capital, in 1937, to pursue a career in music in what is today known as Bollywood.
Without any contacts, by 1940 Naushad was music director on M Bhavnani's film Prem Nagar. But the "Naushad era" really began with Jamini Dewan's Rattan (1944), after which he became established as one of the highest-paid music directors. For the next 30 years he enjoyed unsurpassed celebrity.
Naushad's creative team chiefly comprised lyricist Shakeel Badayuni, singers Mohammed Rafi and Lata Mangeshkar and film-makers AR Kardar and Mehboob. There were films like Mughal-e-Azam (1960), which showcases the best of Urdu lyrical poetry set to music and rendered, under Naushad's direction, with sensitivity, romance and overpowering emotion. In the 1970s Naushad's high water mark was Kamal Amrohi's Pakeezah (The Pure, 1972).
His magic lay in his appreciation of the nuances of Urdu and Hindustani lyrics and his genius in expressing and enhancing film lyrics. By drawing that inspiration from classical ragas and folk, introducing a range of Indian instruments into film music and grooming some of the most talented singers, Naushad gave his music wide appeal. He also had a keen eye for talent. It was he who, after coming across a girl of 13 singing on All India Radio, gave her a break in AR Kardar's Sharda (1942). The teenager was Suraiyya, who became one of the most glamorous singing stars of the 1950s.
Naushad could produce masterpieces be it a ghazal or romantic song, a bhajan or Hindu devotional number, a qawwali sung by Sufis at a Muslim shrine or a dance number for a nautch girl. His songs were truly Indian in essence.
Akbar Khan's Taj Mahal (2006) bombed in spite of Naushad's music and he seemed to have fallen silent for many years. This was not because his musical genius had dried up - rather because, after the 1980s, Bollywood directors looked upon cinema less as a creative art and more as a moneyspinning device. This left little space for aesthetic music, poetry and romance.
Naushad was one of the last of a group who had urbanity, polish and old-world charm. In true Lucknawi style, he also had the gift of kissagoi (storytelling) characterized by effective use of words, poetry, body language and anecdotes. He also published Athwan Sur (The Eighth Note), a collection of his Urdu shairi or poetry.
Courtesy - The Guardian
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education, and research.
Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
-----
Did This Famous Muslim Music Director Hate Hindus? | Drama series Indian |, Naushad songs, naushad khan, Naushad music director, Naushad music director biography, Naushad music director songs, Naushad mughal-e-azam, Naushad mukesh songs, Naushad music director interview, drama series indian, bollywood history,
Пікірлер: 3 100
Eye Opening. Our great music director whom we celebrated so much are shallow. Sometime I think we are such ignorant society
@munimansari6956
Жыл бұрын
U r absolutely wrong
@lakshmyiyer4517
Жыл бұрын
You obviously swallow anything you are fed on WhatsApp University... Learn about the creation of " Mann tarpat hari darshan ko aaj..." phir aana debate karne
@direc8762
Жыл бұрын
It is not ignorant but stupid society
@lalitatellusaboutcountry861
11 ай бұрын
E to hinduonka badappana haiki sabhiko apanaaliya aur e abhibhee jari hai. 👍👍🙄
@UttamSingh-di5fv
10 ай бұрын
@hs8757, You are absolutely correct✅
नौशाद अली ने देवानंद सुरैया की शादी नही होने दी यह उनका सबसे कट्टरपंथी सोच का सबूत है ।।
On the other hand my favourite the legend "MAJRUH SULTANPURI" Sahab sticked to Sachin Deb Burman -Rahul Dev Burman -Kishore Kumar.......some people of all religions guides us towards the feeling of heart above religion...MAJRUH SULTANPURI Sahab was one of them..❤️❤️ MAJRUH SULTANPURI Sahab was Relative of Naushad sahab
ये कोई हो किसी ऊँचाई पर पहुंच जाए मानसिकता वही जेहादियों वाली ही रहेगी ।मुस्लिम मुस्लिम भाई भाई बाकी सब दुश्मन।
Aaj kal ye trends chal raha hai ki har muslim ko gali do ...purane sab Bure the ab inse koi puche tum itane achhe the to kaise mahabharat hua kaise ramayan hui kaise kaling yudh hua ..us time to koi muslim nahi tha 🤔
@shashinigam2434
Ай бұрын
Mahabharat aur ramayan padhiye tab janiyega ki dono mein kis vajah se ladaiyan huyi.aapko jis baare mein pata nahi to us cheez ke baare mein comment bhi mat kariye
@arifkhan-pw8zz
Ай бұрын
@@shashinigam2434 ladai kisi bhi karan hui ho par hui na manav ka sawabhav hi isa hai
@ishubhangi
23 күн бұрын
@@arifkhan-pw8zz Ramayan and Mahabharat dont teach us to fight but 'Q' does... says to kill nonbelievers
@enayatdabir6476
19 күн бұрын
@@shashinigam2434 yehi baat video banane wale ko bi bolu kuch pata nai tu Hindu Muslim na kare. Disgusting such people.
@ramnarayanswami1566
12 күн бұрын
रामायण और महाभारत का युद्ध किन्हीं शांति प्रिय लोगों को दुर्भावना बस लूटने के इरादे से नहीं लड़ा गया था बात के लिए धर्म के लिए लड़ा गया था
दु:ख की बात है और यह सच है कि देवानंद और सुरैया के अगाध,असीम और निष्कपट और निष्कलंक प्रेम को शादी की दहलीज से खींच कर जीवन भर के लिए सुरैया को दर्द और अकेलापन देने के लिए नौशाद मुख्य रूप से जिम्मेदार थे। देवानंद भी जीवन भर इस टीस से उबर न सके।
@faizanhashmi389
Жыл бұрын
To devanand ne dusri shadi kyu ki
@kingempire9393
Жыл бұрын
Wusne. Sahi Kya koi aadmi यही चाहेगा किऊ की सुरैया को नौसाद साहब के दोस्त A R चहते थे सादी ब्रेक करना ही था अब क्या पता सरैया आजीवन सादी ही नई करेगी
@miteshkumar7966
Жыл бұрын
@@faizanhashmi389 ek hi shaddi ki hai surya se sirf pyar tha us se shaddi nahi ho saki ...
@manojverma-rk2gt
Жыл бұрын
Namakul insan 😂😂😂
@snehaldeokar6628
Жыл бұрын
सच बहोत बुरा हुआ. क्या मीला किसी को. सुरैया जी उम्र भर अ के लि रही . देव साहेब की शादी भी कामयाब नाही रही .
Nausad sahab sangeet samrat the, unki soch chhoti nhi thi
@nasumalik337
10 күн бұрын
insan ke chale jane baad ye zoothi baate karna Ek Bakwaas hai. Too earn some money on someone name.
He was a heart patient of cardiologist in usa,the doctor is my brother in law, and he had a great respect and love for LM,he told that she is so simple, nice,clean character woman like a Devi.buhuat Acchi hai LM.he used to praise her all the time.-MMK-usa
@m_ggamer8631
Жыл бұрын
देखीये जवाब देणे केलिए शब्द बहोत है. मगर क्या कहू.मेरा तो कहना यह है कि. जय जवान. जय किसान. जय मानवता.
@sunitaratnaparkhi3262
8 ай бұрын
बहोत सही कहा आपने
एक मुस्लिम न नेता होता है,न अभिनेता न कोई अन्य ।वो सिर्फ एक मुस्लिम है जिसकी नींव ही हिन्दुओ के खिलाफ पड़ी है। ये बात पता नही भारत के बहुसंख्यक को कब समझ मे आएगी
Film "Andaz" was a hit film. Naushad sahab chose Mukesh ji to sing all the songs for Dilipkumar. He didn't chose Rafisaab or Talat sahab. Even much later he again chose Mukesh ji in film Sathi to sing for Rajendra Kumar although Rafisaab's voice suited most for him. Shankar & Jaikishan sahab always allowed Rafisaab to sing for Rajendra kumar sahab .
@pakakaka4227
Жыл бұрын
Yes, but notice the time gap between earlier films and SAATHI and it will all be clear what happened! For that matter check all his lyricists after 1947.
@dewdrops5969
Жыл бұрын
@@pakakaka4227 Music directors may have fascination for particular lyricist. For example Shankar Jaikishshan for Shailendra ji , Madanmonanji for Raja Mehdi Ali Khan etc..Pruducer's and Director's discretion shouldn't be ignored also.
@ShikhaBhargaw
Жыл бұрын
@@pakakaka4227 Very true.
@neelamsharma1191
Жыл бұрын
@@pakakaka4227 yes bro l totally agree with you. Dilip kumar alias Yusuf khan also had the same anti Hindu ideology as naushad
@dewdrops5969
Жыл бұрын
@@neelamsharma1191 No sweeping comments , please. Concrete proof should be placed before defaming the greatly respected actor.Otherwise you can be termed as a communal person. Dharmendraji treated him as elder brother and said that although they were from different mother's womb it mattered little. Manoj ji and Amit ji always spoke high about Dilip sahab and spoke high about his great qualities. Satyajit sahab , Bimal Roy sahab were full of praise for the senior actor. Raj sahab and Dev sahab were his close friend. Amitabhji went a little far to say that Bollywood industry can be divided in two parts "before Dilip kumar " and "after Dilip kumar". Spreading of Communal feeling will not bring any benefit neither for the industry nor for the country.
We need to listen to the songs from baiju Bawra to know how the music was composed. Absolutely marvellous.
@panditaeenji6977
Жыл бұрын
kzread.infoUYpAY9BeFqA?feature=share
@grc178
Жыл бұрын
कोई भक्ती से नहीं बनाया ये बिजनेस है कथा और निर्माता के लिए किया
@ashishdeb6986
Жыл бұрын
Exactly
@MN1961M
Жыл бұрын
He didn't use Manna Dey in Baiju Bawra despite Manna Dey being the greatest playback singer of classical songs in films.
@udaykumara.j.3034
Жыл бұрын
I think the best person and the final authority to choose a singer for a particular song is the music director. On many occasions a song was sung by a singer but for some reason the song was later given to another singer. We cannot decide who is right or wrong.
आपने यह जानकारी देकर एक महान कार्य किया है ।शायद भारत देश के हित चिंतकों को कुछ सुधि आएगी और अपने महान संस्कृति और आध्यात्मिक परंपरा को बचाने का प्राण प्राण से कोशिश करेंगे।
Even when she was not popular, he had Shamshad Begum sing in his films...!
बहुत महत्वपूर्ण जानकारी देने के लिए आपको धन्यवाद।यह जान कर बहुत अफसोस हुआ कि हिंदी फिल्म जगत यानी बालीवुड अपने जन्म से ही इस्लामिक कट्टरपंथियों द्वारा हाईजैक कर लिया गया था।
Thanks for deep routed information.Naushad sahib is the greatest.But Kishore Ji is also loved by music lovers.kishore da is my idol.
@MohammedAli-dk5gc
Жыл бұрын
Animal Raag
@karanraj9237
Жыл бұрын
Yeah we can see his greatness u fool
@sridharmahadevan7694
Жыл бұрын
Agree
Sir, His last film was Shahrukh khan-Manisha Koirala acted-"Guddu" ,It's release in 1995 n its director was lalwani. Also u said Mugal e azam was 1950 film. Actually it's 1960 film.
Hence proved that talent has nothing to do with character.
Noushad ji ne bahut accha music diya tha
Kuchh to shrm kro..ek achhe musician ko bhi apne gnde agende me my lapeto..
@israengineerfouru5219
Жыл бұрын
U will come to see more agniveers in coming days god save the country from jansanghi agenda
@israengineerfouru5219
Жыл бұрын
U will come to see more agniveers in coming days god save the country from jansanghi agenda
Despite all odds of communal bandwagon Devanand and Suraiya attained their supreme glories. Although, Suraiya unable to marry him sensing life threat of Devanand but she kept her determination intact -"not to marry lifelong". Devanand's passion for films guided him to a super iconic actor/producer/director.
A classic example of looking through coloured glasses - Please remove the coloured glass and look with your God given eyes without any bais - God save my country - Height of prejudice - please do not bring dishonour to this great music director - disunity
You are absolutely right...he hated Kishore Kumar so much that when he was chosen for Lata Mangeshkar Award by the jury he angrily rushed out of the room...beacause Rafi Sab was eclipsed by Kishoreda by that time...also because Kishoreda ' wife Badhubala was a co religionist of Naushad. It reminds us about the film Sarfarosh. A man may be great in his profession but he may also be a bigot at the same time. Not at all surprising. Hindus have a large heart. The credit goes to them and not to Naushad.
@pakakaka4227
Жыл бұрын
Very well put.
@bhadwamodi8294
Жыл бұрын
Kishore Kumar converted to Islam to marry Madhubala.
@runcoweezrun8143
Жыл бұрын
He also fought for the rights of Dalits. Ask your ancestors 😎
@sauravrajsingh2
Жыл бұрын
@@bhadwamodi8294 Fake news No , His son denied that report and Kishore Kumar never Practiced any Islamic tradition .... That's a fake news . He didn't convert to the Middle east religion , He was still a Indian origin Hindu and was Cremated according to Hindu Traditions when he died ...Same goes for Dharmendra and Hema Malini , They are Practicing Hindu .
@biswaruppaul8841
Жыл бұрын
@@runcoweezrun8143 Then what Baba Saheb did...?
Naushaad ....ekhindu hater.....but a tragic end in kolkata....
नौशाद जी मेरी नजर में कोई महान संगीतकार नहीं हैं, ये तो किस्मत के फूटे un अभागों में हैं जो किशोर दा जैसे बॉलीवुड गायकों के भगवान से नफरत करते थे और मिमिया कर औरतों की आवाज में गाने वाले रफी साहब को ही पसंद करते थे और अपनी तकरीबन 90% फिल्मों में उन्ही से गवाया। किशोर दा अपने वक्त के अकेले वो महानतम गायक थे जो वास्तविक मर्दों वाले आवाज में गाते थे और मर्दों की आवाज ना पसंद करने वाले मर्द तो ताली बजा कर पैसा कमाने वाले श्रेणी के होते हैं, वैसे भी "बंदर क्या जाने अदरक का स्वाद"। मेरा बस चले तो इस घटिया और बेरौनक धुन बनाने वाले संगीतकार के बॉलीवुड में जो इतिहास इनके नाम है उसपर कालिख पोत दूं।
@mk79139
5 күн бұрын
👍
Jihadi hamesha jihadi hi rahega chahe koi bhi ho
Gaane sabit karte hain ke naushad sahab ek genius sangeetkaar the aur gaana kis se gwana hai wo khoob jaante the .film industry mein wo akele hit Muslim composer hue hain. Heere kya cheez hai ye johri se behtar koi nahi jaanta. I salute to great Naushad sahab.
@meripasandrk4497
Жыл бұрын
Waah।
@somendraduttchandola9726
Жыл бұрын
. (
@eponymous386
Жыл бұрын
Laakh rupay ki baat kahi hai apne ! Lekin yeh kaminay log bas ek toxic culture pehlarahen hain jis mein sirf evil mongers, witch hunters aur mob lynchers paida ho rahein hain.
@rajivsavant8109
Жыл бұрын
Khayyam was another great muslim composer.
It seems that hindi cinema was introduced in India thru Muslims.
यही इनकी असलीयत है।हर करने मे हमे एकहोकर आगे बढ़ने की जरूरत है ।वह धर्मांध है भरोसा करणे लायक कतयी नही,
Where is the evidence?? Who are your sources and where are the references??? Don't spread lies. Naushad sahib was one of the best classical music composer of Indian cinema. He has created so many beautiful songs. From Baju Bawara - Maan Tadapt HARI darshan. From Amar - Insaaf Ka Mandir Hai and many other like Daya kar Girdhar Gopal. How can you say that Naushad hates Hindus. Use your common sense.. He was the master. Burman Dada was his very close friend. Lata ji had high regards for him . Seriously do something good and don't spread hate...
@kharbandasatish8755
Жыл бұрын
Right
@mumtazdamani8830
Жыл бұрын
Very negative video. Creating rift between Hindus and Muslims.
@lovetoeveryone5151
Жыл бұрын
Welcome Gagan Deep ji . Sangeet aur Kalakar ka kyoi Mazhab nahi hota hai. * Aap ke Sangeet ki Pahchan ki Qadar karta hun.
@ShikhaBhargaw
Жыл бұрын
Gagan Deep Sir, why don't you watch the video carefully? The evidence is clearly given in every aspect. Even the mother of Suraiya called Naushad a communal person in Naushadnama. Pleas watch again.
@afrozjahan3610
Жыл бұрын
True, these negative kind of videos are being made just to earn money I don’t agree with it
मैं आज यह जानकर बहुत ही आश्चर्यचकित हूं की जिस संगीतकार के हम इतने बड़े फैन है, उसके अंदर इतनी सांप्रदायिकता भरी थी।
@dineshkadam5191
Жыл бұрын
ये तो ईनके खुन मेही होता है ईसका नतिजा आज भी देश भुगत रहा हैं
@HARD20
Жыл бұрын
@@dineshkadam5191 100% सत्य 👍🏻👍🏻
Great video ; very educative. You have not mentioned pakeeza.If I properly recall the background gazal "yeh dhuan Kahan se uthta hai sing legendry actress (dalip Kumar,s mother -in- law . Very haunting singing. Hindi films Industry over century old need to be remembered. A video like yours is very much appreciated 👍 👍 👍. Keep it up show more. Thank you.
Music & art have no religion, plz don't make the public confused. NUshad was a great composer and Kishore was a great singer.
स्थान नही दिया स्थान खुद को बनाया था।
@adityatrading4236
Жыл бұрын
by coot nausad
Undoubtedly Rafi sahab was a great singer.Rafi sahab and kishor da liked each other.kishor kro himself was fan of Rafi sahab like other singers.
@sridharmahadevan7694
Жыл бұрын
Exactly.They were the best of friends
@dewdrops5969
4 ай бұрын
@@sridharmahadevan7694 Even more than that. Kishoreda cried like a child sitting beside deadbody of Rafisaab.
@LokeshKumar-nv6nc
2 ай бұрын
Kishore was fan of KL saighal not Rafi. donot spread the rumour
Naushad jee Gem with heavenly music ! साष्टांग प्रणाम !
Not only Kishore, he neglected Manna De like singer who showed how to use classical music to modern singing.
1) *The great personality of Mohammad Rafi is above Bollywood and also above Dada Saheb Palke Award* 2) *The voice of Mohammad Rafi is "A School of Acting"*
@bharatbhumi101
Жыл бұрын
Yes 👍👍👍
@ArifulIslam-bq7kh
Жыл бұрын
Yes, right.👍
@sridharmahadevan7694
Жыл бұрын
Agree
Whether he hates or like doesn't make any difference to the lives of ordinory people...But Inflation, Unemployment makes a huge difference to every indians irrespective of his/ her religion
@bhaskarwatve5236
Жыл бұрын
These बॉलीवूड बाते is absolutely worthless & discussing about a Decent Brothel House. It is also true that no secularism exists worldwide. It is a big myth. Mr. Naushad, looking to his staff was definately nonsecular. &truely, nothing is wrong with it.Religion is a fake matter & is worst addicting than Drugs.He couldn't help avoiding Lata Mangeshkar.
Kaash us samay bhi #boycottbollwood hota.
Not to respect such person who hate others religion.
Wish u read the comments...majority of comments will answer your question mark.
@bhadwamodi8294
Жыл бұрын
This communal youtube channel owner has pinned a communal comment.
@HARD20
Жыл бұрын
@@bhadwamodi8294 Communalism can also seen in you Name..!💣💥
Most of your observations are correct. You say that Naushad did fantastic music for many actors like Raaj Kapoor,Dev Ananand,Rajendra Kumar etc. The bhajans he made for Baiju Bavra were immortal. How can he be a Hindu Hater. Please,please do not spread such poison. The era of forties and fifties was so different. Quality was important and not religion. So please do not lower your status.
@muhammadafzal2653
Жыл бұрын
Agree
@panditaeenji6977
Жыл бұрын
kzread.infoUYpAY9BeFqA?feature=share
@abhaysardesai7551
Жыл бұрын
Toxic understanding of identity. Stop this please.
@gulamahmad2011
Жыл бұрын
👎
@pakakaka4227
Жыл бұрын
There is very fine proverb in English : PROOF IS IN THE PUDDING. Well, keeping Suraiya unmarried for the life (her own mother's statement shows that), Mukesh not called for until very very late like in SAATHI, Kishor Kumar totally banned, even only song he sang was not allowed to be included in the film. Bhajan/Ghazals/Songs/Poetries - well that is all his professional requirements - you know very well the difference between professional (for the money) vs vocational (for pleasure).
It was Naushad who composed devotional songs like, ''Man Tadpat Hari Darshan ko aaj''....Please give proofs for your story
According to Khalil Gibran, “Even a donkey can kick a DEAD lion!” It’s very simple: How come this gentleman remained silent during the life time of Naushad Saheb?? Nor was there anybody else who did ever spit such venom when the legendary Naushad was still alive so he could respond to such unfounded allegation!!
नौशाद हिंदुओं से नफरत करता था ये बात 100% सही है । किशोर कुमार जैसे लोकप्रिय गायक से इन्होंने एक भी बार नही गवाया था ।
@Homes654
Жыл бұрын
Lies. Go research and see if Mukesh and Kishore ever sung any songs for Naushad before following a hate bigot’s channel.
I want to add one film probably in his last phase "Awaaz De Kahan Hai" 1990 most of the songs by Munna Aziz & Anuradha Paudwal 🙏🙏
@panditaeenji6977
Жыл бұрын
kzread.infoUYpAY9BeFqA?feature=share
@rafikshah6167
Жыл бұрын
जाकी रही भावना जैसी प्रभु मूरत दिखी वैसी।
Hamaare ek uprashtrapati bhi kattar rahe hay. Ye ISLAM ki asaliyat hay or hamesha rahegi, ha kuchh hi hote hay Abdul Kalam saab jaise sachche INSAN.
इसमे कोई शक नही की हरेक मुसलमान हिन्दुओ से सख्त नफरत करता है और मौके बे मौके इस नफरत का प्रदर्शन भी करते हैं। यह सच्चाई हिन्दुओ को समझ मे आ जाना चाहिए।
But Naushad saahib encouraged Latha mangeskar right from the start of her music career!
Reply@pc mittal...very shameful and narrow minded statement मोहे पनघट पे नंद लाल और मन तड़पत हरी दर्शन को सुनकर प्रायश्चित करिए
I had met Naushadji couple of times and found him soft spoken and humble without any conceitedness despite his great success in scoring innumerable hit songs with pleasing orchestration under his baton. He had great rapport with most playback singers to deliver quality rendition and lilt. He had thorough knowledge of Hindustani classical and folk music that listeners know from his creations.
@tipsandtricks5289
Жыл бұрын
May be in his last days he realised being hindhuphobic is not good.
@jsm3692
Жыл бұрын
He was a bigoted u p musalman: Shaitaan ki awlaad. Deeply envious of Hindus. Highly complexed and complicated person with a deceptive soft presence. What is the purpose of your comment? Are you trying to be nice ? Call a spade a spade. Takes some courage, though, goes against the fudamental upbringing of a brahmin.
Naushad was 100% fanatic about his religion.
Naushad saheb Kishore da ko gayak hi nahin samajhte they. 1970 ke baad Naushad saheb ki naiya hi doob gayi.
@nonconverted
Жыл бұрын
Sahi😂
Of course Naushad was a genius music director of Hindi film but unfortunately he was responsible for separation between Devanand & Suraiya on religious ground...... Genius person if wicked is most dangerous.. Naushad was like such a genius person..
@kamrannoorani5514
Жыл бұрын
what a stupid statement. How many Hindus would like a Hindu girl marry a Muslim. Lets be fair.
@tipsandtricks5289
Жыл бұрын
Not genius its hinduphobia.
@CME1970
Жыл бұрын
@@tipsandtricks5289 Undoubtedly Naushad was a genius person. But he was communal by his thinking.
@tipsandtricks5289
Жыл бұрын
@@CME1970 even bin laden was a genius, but ruined many families and killed many people. We praise such genius people because we are not one of the families affected by their communal hatred and we dont know their pain and agony.
@tipsandtricks5289
Жыл бұрын
Cancer is a very intelligent bacteria which can withstand bodys powerfull immunity, but it will kill the body in which it lives and finally it dies. Lesson is cut the cancer before it kills u.
Such nonsensical videos and their provocative titles should be stopped being published on KZread. There was no greater gentleman in the Hindi film industry than Naushadji. Every Music director had his favourite song writer and singers, nothing to do with their religion. Naushad for Dilip Kumar, SJ for Raj kapoor and SD Burman for Dev Anand was common. Sahir, Majrooh, Raja Mehdi Ali Khan and Kaifi Azmi all accompanied likes of Madan Mohan, SD Burman, Roshan, Laxmikant Pyarelal, religion did not come into it.
@Unifor23
Жыл бұрын
good knowlege man
@harpar1028
Жыл бұрын
SHAILENDRA ????
@ranjitballal712
Жыл бұрын
@@harpar1028 what is your question?
@kavithamegharaj713
Жыл бұрын
Truth is difficult to digest
@Uuuuuuuuuu502
Жыл бұрын
Tumari sacchai sabko pata chal ni chahiye, bahan khoddo
Great information ji. ❤
Naushad ko Jannat Naseeb nahin hona chahie
Ye video ek sampradayik aadmi ka zahrila nazariya hai jisne filmi duniya jahan log jaati dharm, bhasha aur kshetra se uper uth kar kaam karte hain per aise nazariye ka aarop lagaya hai.. Kaun bhul sakta hai ki Naushad ne 1949 me movie Andaz jiske director Mehboob khan aur Hero Dilip Kumar they, ke liye Mukesh se 2 amar geet gawaye they.. 1. Hum aaj kahin dil kho baithe.. 2. Jhoom jhoom ke nacho aaj...
@sufisahab454
Жыл бұрын
Aap ne bilkul correct kaha hai
@bhaiyavivekpriyadarshi1376
Жыл бұрын
@@sufisahab454 Shukriya
@ShikhaBhargaw
Жыл бұрын
वीडियो पूरा देख कर ही कमेंट लिखें भइया जी। सबूत के साथ बना है ये वीडियो।
आप कहते हो वो सच है । सभी मुसलमान प्रोड्युसरो , दिग्दर्शको और संगीतकारोने उनकी फिल्मों में सभी रोलमे मुसलमानी कलाकारोही प्राधान्य दिया ।खास रोलके लिये जब सुयोग्य मुसलमानी कलाकार नहीं मिले तबही हिंदु कलाकारों को अनुबंधित किया ,ये सत्त्य है ।
@dynadyna3014
Жыл бұрын
Yahi haal to BJP government ka bhi hai Ginti k do eak musalmnan miljayenge mantrimandal mein Aur nara loktantra ka lagayeinge Sabka saath sabka vikas....
@RajeshKumar-uo3yu
Жыл бұрын
@@dynadyna3014 ये बड़ी जेहादी पार्टी तो तृप्ती करण के लिए पूरी तरह दीन को समर्पित है।
It's obvious that the converted will hate brave hindus because they did not convert under swords of islamic invaders or to escape Jijiah.
Wrong he made good Bhajan songs better then anyone else
This absolute bullshit. Dev Anand Suraiya break up has nothing to do with Naushad, it was her mother who opposed there marriage. This was stated by Suraiya herself. Talat Mehmood was Naushad's lead singer prior to emergence of Rafi. After Rafi's success he ditched Talat for ever. Naushad was a hardcore perfectionist, as a result only the best singers could sing his tune.
@Devyani2727
Жыл бұрын
Well said🙏🏻
@ShikhaBhargaw
Жыл бұрын
Then how the mother of the actress blamed Naushad?
It is impossible to sing for any other singers to film like “Baiju Bawra”accept instruction of singing the great RAFI SAHAB.
Why only Naushad, many lyricist like Majrooh Sultanpuri, Sahir even to this day Javed Akhtar are the same. Brilliant Hindi lyricists like Pradeep, Indeevar, Rajinder Krishna were systematically sidelined although they could not do so to Anand Bakshi. Then the ultimate of all was Dilip Kumar, who even acted as a Pakistani spy!
@telepost2250
Жыл бұрын
ऐसा सिर्फ बामणा कहता है , आप भी बामण हो क्या ?
@nash6414
Жыл бұрын
@@telepost2250Oye hoye hoye … Brahman Kya hota hai , Hindu bas Hindu .
@telepost2250
Жыл бұрын
@@nash6414 गांडु होता है
बहुत ही दुख की बात है वो इतने कटरपंती थे,, और दूसरे समुदाय से नफरत करना, ये उनकी बहुत छोटे इंसान मे शामिल करते हैं,,
@shubhamtiwari8881
Жыл бұрын
Muslims aise hi hote h ku ki bachpan se hi unke dimag me ye dala jata h ..... Hindu the yaha isliye use fir bhi pyar mila itna krne k bad .... Pakistan me agr ak hindu aisa kre to use kaat k fek denge
@bhaskarwatve5236
Жыл бұрын
ये सभी ऐसेही है |चुते हिंदू इनको सरपर चढाते है |हिंदू सर्वधर्मसमभाव जैसे षंढ विचारोमे लिप्त हो जाते है |जय मोहन 💀💀
@ghanshyamregmi1398
Жыл бұрын
ये मजहवी कट्टर पन्थी मुसलमान था ,बहुतो हिन्दु से नफरत करता था ।।
@moonibemamdee3845
Жыл бұрын
go and listen to few but best songs of K.L. Saigal sahab under naushad
मन तरपत हरि दर्शन को आज जैसा बेजोड़ भजन रिकार्ड करने से एक दिन पहले नौशाद साहब ने सभी सांजिदों से विनती की थी कि कल भजन रिकार्ड किया जायेगा लिहाजा सभी नहा धोकर पाक साफ आयें ।ऐसे उच्च विचारों से ओत प्रोत व्यक्ति को साम्प्रदायिक का तगमा देने के लिए आपका बहुत बहुत शुक्रिया ।साथ में यह भी बता देते कि भारत भूषण के लिए अन्य स॔गीतकारों ने मुकेश भैया से कौन कौन से गाने गवाये ? दिलीपकुमार के लिए तलत और रफी साहब तय थे फिर भी मुकेश भैया से मैला , अनोखी अदा और अंदाज के गाने गवाये थे ।गाये जा गीत मिलन के गाने से ही मुकेश साहब संगीत की दुनिया में पैर जमा सके थे । रतन में ओ जाने वाले बालमवा पर डांस करने वाले मुमताज अली महमुद के पिता हैं ।दर्द का नगमा अफसाना लिख रही हूँ भी उमा देवी अर्थात टून टून से इन्होंने ही गवाया और हास्य भूमिकाएं करने की सलाह भी नौशाद ने ही दी थी और टून टून नाम भी दिया ।बैजू बावरा में तानसेन का किरदार निभाने वाले कलाकार भी अपने जमाने के हीरो और गायक सुरेन्द्र है ।
@sufisahab454
Жыл бұрын
Kya answer diya aap ne maza aa gaya
@ShikhaBhargaw
Жыл бұрын
टुनटुन के पति का नाम भी क्यों नहीं लिखा? ऐसा क्या हो गया कि बीस साल तक मुकेश साहब की याद ही नहीं आयी नौशाद अली को? वीडियो एक बार फिर से देखें। साफ कहा है कि फिल्म बरसात के बाद नौशाद हारा हुआ महसूस करने लगे, तब ही लॉबी वाला खेल खेलने लगे।
@abdulshakoor4642
Жыл бұрын
बरसात फिल्म की सफलता से लता दीदी और शंकर जयकिशन जी के बीच मन मुटावभी हुआ था ।शंकर जयकिशन जी का कहना था कि हमारे संगीत ने लता को बुलन्दियों पर पहुँचाया ।इससे चिढकर लता दीदी ने भी कहा कि वो मूरी ही आवाज थी जिसने बरसात को हिट किया ।इसी बात पर श॔कर साहब ने लता दीदी से किनारा कर लिया और एक नई गायिका शारदा को ले आये और कुछ गीत गवाये भी थे जिसमें एक गीत था तितली उड़ी उड़ के चली आकाश ।जबकि जयकिशन जी लता दीदी के पक्ष में थे।इसके बाद दोनों की दोस्ती में दरार आ गई ।कुछ समय बाद जयकिशन जी का स्वर्ग वासहो गया ।लता दीदी ने खुद एक इन्टरव्यु में माना था कि उनका सबसे पंसदीदा संगीतकार सज्जाद साहब थे ।दूसरे नम्बर पर खेम चन्द प्रकाश जी थे जिन्होंने फिल्म महल का संगीत दिया था ।टून टूनकी बाॅयग्राफी यू ट्यूब पर उपलब्ध है ।देख लो ।
@rashpindergill4088
Жыл бұрын
@@ShikhaBhargaw मुकेश जी की याद नहीं आई क्योंकि नौशाद जी के पास स्वर सम्राट रफ़ी साहब थे और साथ में मन्ना डे जी और महेंद्र कपूर भी थे
@lokivillain6669
Жыл бұрын
@@rashpindergill4088 manna de se kitne song gwaye bhai btana to, aur mahendra kapoor ji se kitne gwaye , aur tumhari baat maan le ki rafi sahab the to suru me mukesh ji ne hi nausad ko pahchaan dilayi, saal me ek ya do song gwa hi sakte the
Very informative. Although I doubt that the eco effect for 'Mughal-e-Azam' was produced and recorded in bathroom. I remember Naushad sahab disclosed it in one of his interviews on TV long ago. He had told that the eco was produced by the same voice recording played on many players with fractional difference in all and this created the eco the first time.
Gruesome tales of the Hindi Film Industry,communalism then and now
Any thing can be said to put down a person he/she is no more. He/she can not come back to defend. So it is not decent to to talk ill of a person whom we did not know personally. But we still do all the same because of our conditioning. Personally I think the Late Naushad Ali was one of the greatest music composer of the sub continent. He created lilting melodies which are time less.
@gauravdadhich9529
Жыл бұрын
Truth must come out even though it's uncomfortable.
@rajeshkumarsingh813
Жыл бұрын
See the whole team of naushad you will understand the fact.
@krishnadassingha5461
Жыл бұрын
Dhoot
@S.Ghosh_221
Жыл бұрын
His work is not being discussed here, rather an aspect of his life, apart from the work. Knowing such aspects are also necessary to tap into the thought process of artists. It helps revealing what line of thought and message they wanted to convey through their art.
@sandeepsuri9168
Жыл бұрын
@@krishnadassingha5461 Arre Dhoot !!!
Dont give too much importance to such things without any strong proof.
@iqbalahmad769
Жыл бұрын
Yeh sab naushad Sahab per galat iljaam ha
@ShikhaBhargaw
Жыл бұрын
What else proof do you want? Even the mother of Suraiya, who was Muslim, called Naushad a communal. Watch the video first.
@rajeshmoza6504
Жыл бұрын
@@ShikhaBhargaw What is new in this. Isn't every individual like that. He/She might be from from any religion or community but has has such characteristics. You can as well make a video, interpret the story in a different way altogether.
Very nice among Indian musicians.
Great musician who gave jobs to multiple artists regardless of who they were because of their talent. Very unfortunate this series is clumsily trying to put a communal angle to his work. Rise above, people.
@sayfiroz
9 ай бұрын
Actually now they are done or falling short of Muslim rulers like Aurangzeb,tipu sultan etc so now they have shifted to next Lott in history for their Hindu Muslim hatred for politics
Naushad gave opportunity to Hemant Mukherjee , Mukesh, Manna Dey and Subir Sen to sing in the films. Also he in most of his songs used Lata Mughrskar. He was against Kishore Kumar as Kishore Kunar practically ruined Rafi in the Bombay film Industry. Rafi was very close to Naushad. Someone who composed the songs of Baiju Bawra cannot be a bigoted person.
@panditaeenji6977
Жыл бұрын
kzread.infoUYpAY9BeFqA?feature=share
@khalidgulzar1052
Жыл бұрын
He disliked Kishore because Kishore was an untrained singer and required a lot of hard work. Naushad wanted perfection in his songs which was only forthcoming from legends the like of Mukesh, Manna Dey, Lata and Rafi.
@pakakaka4227
Жыл бұрын
@@khalidgulzar1052 Read what Pandit Bhimsen Joshi-ji said about Kishore Kumar - may help you understand the genius of KK & failure of Naushad's recognizing KK talent.
@pakakaka4227
Жыл бұрын
KK did not ruin anybody, he simply outshined others after a long delayed time during his tragedy about Madhubala's death. Yes he was untrained but great music directors did obtain wonderful results from him - read the story about MERE NAINA SAWAN BHADO sung by him after practicing Lata version for several days - that's real master!
@rajarshighosh4821
Жыл бұрын
@@khalidgulzar1052 that’s why Kishore da eclipsed the ordinary Rafi and everyone else.
अगर ऐसी ही बात होती तो नौशाद साहब इतने शानदार भजनों को संगीत न देते जो आज तक पूरे विश्व में मशहूर हैं ।
@vandanashrivastava799
Жыл бұрын
बात पूरी तरह सच है, ये लोग मौका परस्त होते है जो आज भी मानने को तैयार नही हैं वो लोग और क्या होते हुए देखना चाहते है भगवान जाने
@sushmasingh8008
9 ай бұрын
Ji sahi kaha! Ye video makers bahut gairzimmedar hain.
Very informative. Thanks.
Great information 👍👌7.10.2022
Sangitkar ka dharm màzhab Sab sangit hi hota hai naushad sahab ne kitne achhe bhajan banaye o dunia ke rakhwale madhuban men radhika mohe panghat pe nandlal ,,,,,,,naushad sahab nemukesh ji Mahendr mannaa dey hemant Kumar lata ki asha ki sabhi se gane gawaye aap aur ek Rahul ji aap log sampardayikta ka angle talashte Hain jab ki filmi dunia ke log Sab se Kam sampardayik hote hain
@panditaeenji6977
Жыл бұрын
kzread.infoUYpAY9BeFqA?feature=share
No doubt Naushad Saheb was a most popular distinguished trained music director. I liked his music. very much. He is my favourite M.D. History of Naushad Saheb depicted here is pleasing to me.
@shreelaxmitradingcompany3110
Жыл бұрын
Really Naushad was a great music director but Shankar Jaikishan was the best.
As a musician he is really good but as a human he is toxic, envious enviousness.
Naushad ne dev suraiya ki shadi nahonepar bahot. Mahatvapurna bhumika nibhayi
As given in their religious texts - Muslims will differentiate between Muslims and non- Muslims. It is normal and only few exceptions exist. Even AR Rahman and his elder sister differentiates. As non Muslim try getting into their music school. The elder sister divorced her husband to convert to Islam. Her husband and son remain Hindus to this day. U can see the joy in AR Rahman or SR Khan eyes and words of appreciation when a young Muslim boy sings well in a music contest. AR Rahman father died a Hindu. But the family consider a him a KAFIR. This is the reality.
@absalom359
Жыл бұрын
Absolutely ,even rafi was A zealot he sang bhajans for money .
@akhandbha
Жыл бұрын
It's an existential defect. So cannot blame anyone except the man who created that faith. Followers are just followers
@HinduWarriorForever
Жыл бұрын
@@akhandbha Nope. Followers also kiII' and do Sar tan se juda'. That rotten souI who founded the cuIt is not kiIIing but his fana'tics do.
@HinduWarriorForever
Жыл бұрын
@@akhandbha If you will not bIame kiIIer then whom to blame? Victims!!
@swathikriyengar1913
Жыл бұрын
Since ARR is mentioned I am writing this , ARR was a Hindu Brahmin, his Father was great Musicians and worked along with greats like SBP, this convert is more original than Original, like the saying goes Copies over takes Originals. ARR father had drinking issues and he died young. Rest is history. ARR was introduced by K Balachander, Hindu Brahmin again to revolt against Ilayaraja, as Ilayaraja was too busy to oblige KB those days. KB was a demanding director and quite famous too. ARR is anti Hindu in every sense, and he has very subtle way of creating separatism and in the pre text of Sufi Music he introduces Islamic music copied from Afro Arabic composers and musicians of today. ARR is out there only to spoil Indian Values of Indian Music, meaning Carnatic, etc. But his approach is very subtle and he has a good strings to pull in Dubai and Bollywood due to his present religion. ARR is not to trusted, He is totally anti Hindu.
It is extremely in poor taste to talk about the deceased. Naushad sahib's Hindu Bhajan in Baiju bawra stands as one of the best.
@panditaeenji6977
Жыл бұрын
kzread.infoUYpAY9BeFqA?feature=share
@prasenjitbanerjee3523
Жыл бұрын
That dosen't hide the fact that he prevented Suraiya from marrying Dev Anand simply because Dev saab was a Hindu...it is a proven and well documented fact
@starman923
Жыл бұрын
O jungli Jaanwar Raaksas Muslim...u r also doing ur share of Taqiyya jehaad
@username36garhia
Жыл бұрын
पापी पेट का सवाल है लौंडे, लेकिन प्रयास तो भरपूर किया भड़वा नौशाद ने😂😂😂
@Homes654
Жыл бұрын
@@prasenjitbanerjee3523 How many Hindu girls were stopped from marrying Muslim boys in India and vice versa?? Do you have any knowledge ?? Why didn’t you speak about it. The hatred in India is beyond the understanding of a normal human. So much hatred!!! Hate and hate and soon your hatred will destroy you.
😢टीपू सुलतान सिरीयल को भी संगीत दीया ....
Rafi sahab jaisa koi gaa nahi sakta....
@swifttuttle5662
10 ай бұрын
खुदा था क्या रफ़ी 😂
VERY VERY STRANGE!!!!! SUCH A MISDEMEANOUR FROM SUCH A CELEBRITY!!!! BUT HE WILL ALWAYS BE REMEMBERED FOR HIS LOVE FOR MUSIC WHICH IS A GIFT OF MAA SARASWATI.
It is absolutely unfair to brand Naushad Ali pro muslim. If he preferred to choose Mohammad Rafi, so did OP Nayyar choose him for long. He was perhaps the greatest singer. Naushad chose Lata not because he had no option but because Lata was so great. An anti Hindu music director could never have produced such masterly Hindu songs.
@syedhaieder9023
Жыл бұрын
U r an honest person May ALLAH always be with you your family and friends as well I also like legendary 💘KISHORE 💘and 💘MUKESH ,💘💘TALAT 💘💘💘💘💘MAHMOUD ,💘LATA💘 and 💘💘💘all 💘others also performed their 💘best thanks u r a clean hearted 💘🙏💘person💘🙏💘
@ShikhaBhargaw
Жыл бұрын
Mother of Suraiya ji was herself a Muslim, but she called Naushad a communal person.
Maybe it was an ego issue with Mukesh. Naushad used Lata throughout his career. He had to go back to Mukesh for Saathi as Rajinder Kumar insisted. Naushad was surely the villain in the Dev- Suraiyya love story. I hugely admire Suraiya for her resolve to remain unmarried.
Thanks a lot for your video.
He refused to score for RK because he was Hindu. If you see the list of producers whom he scored for, you will see.
@ImtiazKhan-qo3ct
Жыл бұрын
How will it be recieved if I say that as RK is Hindu so he has not accommodated muslims like Naushad saheb and very sparingly engaged Rafi saheb for his films.This is all rubbish. Both RK and Naushad have their own priorities.
@vivalingua9377
Жыл бұрын
@@ImtiazKhan-qo3ct I have nothing against Naushad. I love his songs and his methodical work. I met him personally and he did not drive me away. I only reported the facts and that I had heard about RK asking him, since this video had raised that point. RK always had at least one song by Rafi in his movies. OP even had RK singing in Rafi’s voice in Do Ustaad and SJ did that in Ek Dil Sau Afsaane. Naushad even used to call SJ not musicians, but magicians.
@ImtiazKhan-qo3ct
Жыл бұрын
@@vivalingua9377 sir Music has no mazhab. However let there be no hard feelings. We are all music lovers.
@HinduWarriorForever
Жыл бұрын
@@ImtiazKhan-qo3ct Yes. Music has no mazhab but Dharm. Because Samved and naad gave music and sound to the world. Mazhab divided humanity into 'kaafeers" and cuIt creatures."
@HinduWarriorForever
Жыл бұрын
@@ImtiazKhan-qo3ct Your cuIt book that says earth is fIat and in 6th century moon was broken hate music' as deviI's work. Stop your kaum' deception.
GREAT SALUTE TO GREAT NAUSHAD SAHEB .
I have seen many KZread Song channels where Muslims praise Mohammad Rafi sahib but never talk about any other Hindu singers or composers. Only in India these people cherished their passion because of Hindu Hearts. Have you ever heard any Muslim singer composer or artist flourished abroad.
@kafilqureshi9088
Жыл бұрын
LOL. Mohan I quote and unquote Lata " Mehdi Sahab (Mehdi Hussain Of Pakistan) kay galay may Bhagwan bolta hay".
@dr.asad5552
Жыл бұрын
Hemant kumar was a great singer. Lata g asha g were grat singers. I m a Muslim but I appreciate them
@arifujjamansahake5371
11 ай бұрын
@@dr.asad5552I am muslim.I also appreciate but the thing if you Check comment section of Lata ji and rafi ji duet song.though both of them sang equally but they always bash Lata ji and praise rafi ji .and most of are Muslims
Lata ji was not sung any song related to Dr B R Ambedkar even then after two Ditectors request.
We are fortunate that Naushadji chose Md.Rafi for Baiju Bawra.Actually Md.Rafi was the singer who suited best for Dilip Kumar.BharatBhushan and Naushad- gharana. Kishore kumar's singing style was totally different.Music directors can not choose the producer,director or actors of a movie rather THEY choose the music directors.
@yba666_
Жыл бұрын
If Rafi Saheb wasn't there, no noushad or gaushad will be this great. Even half of this even. Imagine when a bigot like naushad was doing what he wanted, here you have a RAFI who was gold not just in his job, but in his heart also pure gold. He was a close friend of kishore da as well. God creates all types...he creates zealots, bigots, perverts....and he also creates RAFI saheb...a pure gold human being! My humble respects to Rafi saheb
@VijaySharma-it8hg
Жыл бұрын
@@yba666_ my man Naushad was one of the most well known composers of the 40s even when he used b grade singers such as Shyam. I dont think he would have faired to badly in the 50s.
@sayedakbar6411
11 ай бұрын
KIA KISHORE * O dunia ke rakhwakey* ga sakta tha ???? Agar reply yes me janta de dey to mai Kishore ko Rafa se bada man loonga, jab khud Kishore ke liey doosrey M.D Rafi ki awaz me gana gawatey they to Kioon ????
@sayedakbar6411
11 ай бұрын
Mohammed Rafi jab Nahi aaey they to K.L.Sahgal se kitney mashoor ganey gawa kar Noushad fame hi chukey they, G.M.Durrani, Talat Mahmood jo Rafi se bhi zyada senior they un se Noushad gawatey they. Lata ke alawa Noor Jahan, Uma Devi (Tun Tun) Raj Kumari, Zohra Bai Ambale wali, Mukesh se bhi kai gane gawaey, Jab group bandion ka chalan hua to Poets, Singers, Music Directors doosron ka kaam zyda nahi kartey they.
@nemainag7967
9 ай бұрын
It is concluded that Naushad had no capability to use Kishor or Manna De.Naushad should learn it from Sachindeb.
पहली वार यह सब जान कर दुख हुआ कि जिन लोगौ को हम सिर पर रखते रहे वे कितने, गंदे, रहे
@Indian26Aug
Жыл бұрын
@@ashfaqibrahim7026 जैसे अशफ़ाक की अम्मी रखती हैं 🧕👙 के नीचे?
@ramkalap2259
Жыл бұрын
Aap unke chehre pe comment toh nahi kar Rahi Hain
@HARD20
Жыл бұрын
@@ashfaqibrahim7026 Waah ek sache Muslim ne apni tehzeeb dikh di..!👏🏻👏🏻💣💥💣💥
@pratiksagar6239
Жыл бұрын
@@ashfaqibrahim7026 tu to rkhwa hi rha hga burqe k andr
@profdrrajanniyermddacdscff8398
Жыл бұрын
@Uma Sharma🙏 maa... Aj 60+ ke hue aj Im a Dr. with 42 yrs Experience..Aj shadyantra ka pata chala.. Us waqt ham innocent they bachhe the radio pe gana suna acha laga parents ke sath chale gaye.. Hamko no pocket money..school. Ane janeka 2/-milta... Fir bhi khush they...
It has been more than 15 yrs of the death of Naushad saab ,so I don't know whether it is fair to attack him when he is not there to defend himself. This accusation is most likely based on the premise that Mohd Rafi sang the bulk of his songs ,while Kishor almost never sang any. Rafi sang the maximum no of Naushad Saab's songs BECAUSE HE WAS THE BEST AT THAT TIME & EVEN NOW Rafi Saab is the greatest we have EVER had & it is very unlikely that we will EVER have someone better than him.Kishor da was a fine singer but of a limited range,he sang only songs of a particular genre.Has anyone ever heard a quality bhajan,ghazal,qawwali Or classical sung by Kishor.His supporters will say that he didn't learn classical music,BUT,WHO PREVENTED HIM,his father was a top lawyer,so money obviously was not the problem.Rafi Saab landed in Mumbai in utter penury,but started learning various types of music as he went along & thereby sharpened & polishing his already God gifted skills,to the extent that the next best singer the great Manna Dey was always two steps behind Rafi.Naushad gave a lot of songs to Mukesh,Manna,Mahendra Kapoor.His most favorite female singer was Lata ji & not Suraiyya Noor Jahan or Shamshad Begum,so the accusations of Naushad Saab hating Hindus seems motivated.Let's leave Naushad,why did the other greats like Ravi,O P Nayyar ,Madan Mohan,Shankar Jaikishan etc not touch Kishor with a barge pole,ONLY S D Barman( another Bengali) took him, were the others also Anti Hindu.By the end of the 60s & beginning of 70s Rafi's main music directors had either aged or died.The genre of music led by RD Burman also had changed leading to Kishor da's rise & as luck would have it Rafi Saab died in 80 leaving the field empty for Kishore da
@rajatnakamoni5959
8 ай бұрын
if it is untrue so why did not sang by kishore except 1 song?
Excellent vlog. Aapse bahut kuchh seekne ko mila❤❤❤❤❤❤
जैसा की हमने भी कोई प्रोग्राम में सुना था कि उर्दू के उच्चारणों के बहाने से नौशाद ने लता मंगेशकर जी से अप्रिय व्यवहार किया था और बाद में लता जी ने नौशाद के संगीत में गाना बंध किया था...मुगले आज़म के डायरेक्टर भी कट्टर मुस्लिम ही थे...कुछ मुस्लिम संगठनों से उनके जुड़ाव के बारे में पत्रकारों को ही सबूत जुटाने होंगे
Aisa kuchh nahin hai
He could have migrated to Pakistan instead of spoiling peoples’ lives. Shame on such people however great may they be!!
Very interesting and knowledgeable. History is so well placed. Thank you.