It’s pretty interesting that each of the ancient hero’s have a following tribe that represents them Shadow Milk: Magic Library Eternal Sugar: Sugar Swan Mystic Flower: Saint Pastries Burning Spice: Mala tribe Silent Salt: Tea knights

@samanthacookierun

5 ай бұрын

That’s a great catch :0

@PGold3

5 ай бұрын

I think silent salt could also be related in some way to dark cacao. Looking at this literally, chocolate often has salt used as an ingredient

@noone1556

5 ай бұрын

I believe that the three warriors that competed in the triple cone cup were meant to be silent salt , red spice and shadow milk Shadow milk creating the ancient yogurt academy or old parfedia which white lily will destroy later and it being rebuilt as the current parfedia Red spice created Scovicllia And silent salt surprisingly the paladins If it was based on theme I could've said mystic flour but the fighting style is different while the paladins use swordsmanship and pure physical strength mystic flour uses what is some sort of magic and mental abilities So it's probably was meant to teach silent salt's swordsmanship to the people of the old town that where the republic is currently located (and them being sea related) I forgot it's name but when the vanillians came and started the republic they started mixing it with the light magic from the vanilla kingdom and created the current paladins (Sry for bad English)

@noone1556

5 ай бұрын

And I believe that mystic flour might know the truth of the witches since she has the light of knowledge and also the fact that saint pastry order knows about the witches and also the reason they were trying to steal the souljam was to free the fallen heroes by returning their powers to face the witches And I also believe that she has something to do with the avatar of destiny Having the same pose when it uses some of the attacks The same face with eyes closed similar clothes and colours and similar attack the one we see in the trailer looks a lot like one of the avatar's attacks and the star on the forehead where her souljam used to be

@stawpppOvO

5 ай бұрын

Their name reminds me of the ingredients to cookies

Since dark enchantress cookie was the first cookie to depict the witches, she depicted the witches as evil since she learned that cookie were meant to be eaten. The narrator depicting the witches here depicts them as good since the witches created the cookies and other such beings. There is a difference between the banquet cookies and the crispia cookies. The banquet cookies were meant to be eaten. The cookies in crispia were never ever meant to be eaten. The crispia cookies had their own wills and beliefs. The banquet cookies don't really show or do anything that says they might have a will and beliefs. The banquet cookies were most likely never meant to have a will or beliefs since they were made to be eaten. No use in having beliefs and a will if your gonna be eaten. Gingerbrave and the cookies that escaped the oven are an exception since they escaped being killed by the heat of the oven. or the cookies that escaped the oven woke up, or maybe they came to life in that instance. Well this comment became longer than I thought it would. :P

@TikiWikiWaaah

5 ай бұрын

This makes so much sense

@LAHDL

5 ай бұрын

Yeah also the narrator who depicted them that the witches are good I heard that voice before in the kitchen probably

@tsunertoo9149

5 ай бұрын

The Important piece that makes this whole thing work actually isthat a on of cookies are stuff that is blatantly inedible. For example white Cotton Cookie. Who would want to eat that? Sapphire Cookie, simply can't eat at all. Jellyfish cookie, Most Jellyfish are poisonous!! Abalone cookie, who wants to eat a cookie made out of SNAILS?? Infact it kind of reminds me of a documentary I watched once where a guy was talking about how one of the ways they make the food in foodcommercials look so good is by pouring car oil on it to make it shiny. Yes its food but no ones going to eat it, its there for purely decorative reasons which is what I think Crispea is about. THey aren't meant to be eaten, they are meant for the witches to watch and enjoy.

@michaelcheng9987

5 ай бұрын

@@tsunertoo9149 Okay, cotton and sapphires I can understand. But people _do_ eat poisonous marine life like jellyfish, pufferfish, lionfish. You just have to process them carefully. And people eat abalone too! I see it everywhere in my country as a fancier ingredient, especially during celebrations(I think they represent prosperity and good fortune).

@tsunertoo9149

5 ай бұрын

AS A COOKIE?? Pardon me but I don't think we're going to get a Salsa cookie, or A chicken Soup cookie that anyone thinks you're supposed to EAT. That's not inedible but unappetizing doesn't even begin to touch the very concept of a HAGGIS COOKIE. And yet we have cookies made of pearls, of SNAILS, of ACTUAL OYSTERS, deep sea fish, BIRDS. WHat even is a Silver knight cookie? We just got a cookie MADE OF MERCURY. Do these sound like things anyone would even THINK of eating? White Lily Cookie (who by the way, is a cookie made out of a flower, an edible flower, but I don't normally conceive of the idea of a cookie made out of a normally decorative flower as being good) I don't think is really putting the puzzle pieces together here. @@michaelcheng9987

In most scenarios like this. Just like how there are good & evil cookies. There are good & evil witches. White Lily Cookie must've encountered the evil witches during the night of the witches. They prefer to create cookies to either torture or eat them. While the good witches have no intentions on eating the cookies they bake to life. Giving them a purpose to help the world all the cookies reside in

I think the reason why there's evil and good witches is because of perspective. The evil witches was depicted by evil enchantress cookie who have seen the secrets while the other cookies sees the witches as their god or creator.

@aweirdlookingcat3707

5 ай бұрын

That or different covens which I think is an easier answer but feels less creative than the theory you said

@Mrpudgy-pudge

5 ай бұрын

Yeah, I agree with the theory. Since the prologue is narrated by dark enchantress cookie, it would make sense If it was through her point of view.

@Renkencen

5 ай бұрын

While I agreed that it's a matter of perspective but isn't there an upcoming game with Brave Giner inside the Witches tower and trying to escape? Can't remember much of the trailer but wasn't the witches still portrayed as evil?

@noone1556

5 ай бұрын

​@@Renkencen the witches are actually evil but most of the cookies portray them as gods

So we are not going to talk that angel is probably the oldest cookie…

@kingdragon3122

5 ай бұрын

Why? If this is about the columns or statues depicting an angel, this doesn’t directly have to be angel cookie herself. Those figures aren’t necessarily the exact same cookie. It’s very common for religious or sacrilegious buildings to depict heavenly beings, and Angel Cookie is a very basic form of one. In the bond story where Angel Cookie and Madeleine appear, Madeleine speaks of a god-like or angel being and Angel cookie asks him who that person is. This implies that there are more angels. Besides, Angel Cookie isn’t exactly some grand design. She’s very simple. She’s not God Cookie, just an angel. When angels are apart of some legend or religion, they often are a race of sorts, having a bunch of them. Also, Angels don’t die so.. I suppose?

@nookietp

5 ай бұрын

@@ency-gachatutorials9303no because we already know how sugar swan cookie looks like thanks to oven break

@planetbluegas-giant998

5 ай бұрын

​@@ency-gachatutorials9303She was already sealed away on beast yeast. If that was the case, Sugar Swan wouldn't even appear on ep7

@thetitanpuiz2436

5 ай бұрын

The diffrence is..eternal sugar is a cookie, and the sugar swan is a pure embodiment of pink sugar crystals

@MariaReyes-sw1dg

5 ай бұрын

@@ency-gachatutorials9303her name is eternal sugar btw

2:21 the witch is shown as good because thats when gingerbrave wasn’t baked (along with dozer) as them both (in lore) destroyed a youth gem that made the witch look young and that’s why the witch is now shown as evil instead of good as shown in the beast yeast trailer

@enaisberrios7482

5 ай бұрын

That's what I'm saying. I believer her name was Gruntilda er something 😊

@XXXzoomz

5 ай бұрын

It was Matilda, that’s the witches name

@enaisberrios7482

5 ай бұрын

@@XXXzoomz Ah thanks. Must've mistakes it for another 😅😂

No because mystic flour and eternal sugar looks absolutely divine and powerful

Wait… so does that mean the saint pastry order was right about the witches being good??? Dang- but now the witches are bad sooooooo- they’re partially correct

@tagalogako991

5 ай бұрын

Maybe some cookies have survived by the old ancients power.

@BlissfulHues13

5 ай бұрын

I think only a slim amount are good and the rest aren't. It would explain why we see a regular and red eyed one in the gacha and only few have the hearts. The heart eyed ones are probably the good ones who just love to bake cookies for fun rather than eat them.

I’m not sure anyone else have noticed, but with the old soul jams were different and only the crystal from it was for the new ancients. Also, I’m guessing the witch was said to be evil because the fallen heroes were corrupted BECAUSE of the witches problems making the soul jams.

We really need the good witch. I really feel bad for her, all she wanted was peace 😭

Im not sure if Im the only one who noticed it, but I noticed that the fallen heroes were like opposites of our current ancients. Like Shadow Milk being manipulative also depicting them having eyes open, while Pure Vanilla is seen as peacefull/trustworthy and usually has his eyes closed. Also in Eternal Sugar, I noticed that there was a part in the animation where she was like laidback, which was the opposite of Hollyberry who was usually very outgoing and loud. Also in Mystic flower, they were Dark Cacao, also described there being peaceful like PV, unlike our DC

2:14 i guess its becaise the witches are seperate to two different camp, the first camp is the white witches wich is shown in the trailer and known as a good witches and Black Witches wich is shown in the game opening and known as evil witches just like Hacker (White Hacker is good and Black hacker is bad) and if it inspired by the hacker color maybe there will be Gray Wotches wich is follow their own will

Anyone wanna bet the during the story event that focus on one of the ancient cookie stories, when the souljam speak to him or her, the voice is probably the fallen cookie? Also while I read the whole good and bad witches is a matter of perspective, what about when they imprision the fallen cookie, the witches somehow get corrupted and become the evil witches and we know til this day?

MORE LORE!!! ALSO THEY LOOK SO GOOD OMG

maybe the soul jam corrupted the witches or start to become evil and the ones not corrupted left so they wouldn't become corrupted.

In the video the guy said "the witches" in 1:00 and "they punished the five" in 2:26 That mean there is not just one witch that create the cookie, the good witch made the past ancient and the evil witch made the current cookie (only theory, don't take it personal)

@Monokuma._.

5 ай бұрын

The "evil" witches is only the depiction from dark enchantress cookie, former white lily cookie. Witches even tasked Elder Faerie cookie to watch over the seal AND baked the former heroes. Crispia and other continent cookies are different from regular ones eaten at the Banquet and thats the part White Lily was missing, she thought they were cookies of her kind.

So we'll be meeting DE And the others soon and DE will surely get ahold of the tree and destroy the seal and even empower them with some parts of the soul jam (the outlines probably)

Why does Eternal Sugar Cookie moving silohouete looks líder lychee dragón cookie but with E.S (Eternal Sugar) standing silohouete (like one in thumbnail) it looks different

@samanthacookierun

5 ай бұрын

hii i made the thumbnail, I used the picture of eternal sugar & used snapdragon’s eyes as a base and added more details, it’s not official artwork but it’s *made up* of official artwork :) if that helps clear up the confusion

The devsisitets has blessed us And also im stopping kids saying first.

Not the "tapu lele" from pokemon sun&moon In the front clips 😂

Guys did ya remember in the special episode of the legend of the red dragon?, something about pitaya dragon cookie say in the pitaya dragon throne?

@twitnobxd4142

5 ай бұрын

If ya don’t know then… Pitaya dragon cookie: An story about five heros, one of them was TILTHEND, the power of the oath…

@possiblyanerd

5 ай бұрын

@@twitnobxd4142I could be wrong but I thought TILTHAENT was actually pitaya’s soul words, and that was what they traded for white lilys story?

@twitnobxd4142

5 ай бұрын

Well idk I haven’t completed the legend of the red dragon yet (quill cooldown 2 long :( )

@possiblyanerd

5 ай бұрын

@@twitnobxd4142 I FEEL YOU BRO

@twitnobxd4142

5 ай бұрын

Oh wait, I realize now… Welp, I think I’m gonna say my favorite word in these type of scene FU-

It's White Lilly's fault she was so clumsy that she slipped and fell in that cauldron

@tagalogako991

5 ай бұрын

It isnt actually her fault. Some cookies are already born before the new five ancients exist.

@samanthacookierun

5 ай бұрын

bro she was shocked 😭

@starrified

5 ай бұрын

@@tagalogako991 still if she wasn't a curious btc then this would never happen

@Ipan_Shiroi

5 ай бұрын

BRO SHE WAS TRAUMATIZED😭 Imagine finding out your creators only made you to eat you? Hell nah I'd be running too without watching my feet from how shivering me timbers I'd been. Plus all she wanted to do after that was inform other cookies about it so she had good intentions 😭

@starrified

5 ай бұрын

@@Ipan_Shiroi ofc if she only stayed calm instead of panicking she'll never slip and fall in the cauldron

WHITE LILLY COOKIE 🫶🫶🫶

IM SO EXCITED FOR BEAST YEAST 🤩🤩🤩🤩🥳🥳🥳🥳

They fr just “lol get tree’d”

THIS IS SO EXCITING

Dang, poor good witches, just cleaned up a mess and then created another

THE LORE THICKENS mat pat or prob the next one should make a video about this funny cookie lore because its soo deep

2:15 It has been said somewhere that there are good and evil witches. And the good witches baked Earthbread and the evil ones ate cookies. The witches in Cookie run are too mysterious and weren't really revealed to us, and they were always on our radar, but they weren't shown to us live (gacha animations and these mini videos don't count)

Ah ok i see how this goes. DEC tries to break their seals and unleash a worse fate upon the world, and she turns back to WLC after her friends save her, so we get the new big bad, the ancient 5

you don’t need to watch it on KZread. You can watch it in the game on the title screen press the film button and then watch it!

isn't sherbet going too? because in one of the stories (Towards the light at cookie stories) frost queen said "There is something foul out there... Something twisted, disrupting the entire course on nature. It's powers are now disturbing the balance on my domain." #2 Millennial Tree Cooke said "It is heading towards the land of beast-yeast" #7 sherbet said "stealing life energy to create a forbidden being..." "why would anyone do that? And who would do that?" #8 so are they planning something and if so... will sherbet be required?(this took forever to type)😭

i have a feeling the cookies will set them free. i just feel like this is the only way u could add spice into the expo.

@rain6539

5 ай бұрын

I’m p sure white lily is stuck in the silver tree, so when they free her the five cookies will be released

@sttarflower

5 ай бұрын

@@rain6539 well im pretty sure they will go for white lilly whike they figure that out

WHITE LILY COOKIE

WAIT, I remember back in hollyberry kingdom, the soul jam spoke to her...I saw someone on tiktok saying the soul jams are actually the old ancient heroes trying to communicate with the new ancients! But I 40% think that's not true because if the old ancients are corrupted and got evil, then why else would they talk so kind to the new ancients?

@Monokuma._.

5 ай бұрын

Its not automatically wrong actually. A potential theory could be that the current soul jam does contains the soul of the Beast cookies but from the past, similar to how Dark Enchantress cookie still had a fragment of White Lily past which was then protected by the Light of Freedom.

@joel784

5 ай бұрын

It does.. The Problem is it caused Pure Vanilla to go insane It still has the old ancients but they cannot speak to them unless their soul is free from the tree And also the Soul Jam of the new ancients are only HALF of the power of the old ones Even though PV full power is insane I cannot imagine Shadow Milk FULL POWER

Looks like they don't want the lore to end

Amazing

What I think is interesting is the narrator he has a guys voice and out of the 5 past ancients the one with white Lilly’s soul jam seem to fit the most so maybe there’s something special there also the heart soul jam always belonged to a girl or at least a feminine character

I don’t know where I got this from but for some reason I always thought they’re was multiple witches like they’re were wizards and one of the witches was good I might just be crazy

u made me desperate to see the nee fallen heros sprites with that thumbnail

i wonder why tye witches got evil tho??

@Potato_wads_the_latina

5 ай бұрын

Same

@metamayhem6503

5 ай бұрын

Maybe there are so many witches, who are bad and good, of many covens.

how to make cookie run: Kingdom: make five cookies and create the soul jams give it to the five cookies let them live in peace and then they’ll start to rage and start the war after the war seal them make another five cookies and give them the soul jams start another war and then the start of the war and the heroes will just disappear. Find the remaining cookies. lol p.s. The creator of the war also disappear and you’re not the creator of the war

Is it me or that animation was giving me the genshin impact story cutscene of 5 yakshas vibes?

why does the fallen hero in the thumbnail kinda look like jewelry bonney from one piece or pink diamond from steven universe

Honestly this is like fnaf when it just keep repeating history it self

The narrarator said witches so there coukd be other witches?

@tagalogako991

5 ай бұрын

Yeah.

This is interesting...

Why Mystic flour cookie looks like Osmanthus cookie at the start off the animation🧐

Wait, how did white Lily get corrupted? We literally saw her fighting with the other ancients against dark by the way, I don’t really play those side ones, so yeah I don’t do the lore

@joel784

5 ай бұрын

No One really knoww but I'm confident to say that It was an Illusion of Dark Enchantress

Silent salt is so dadd- /j

The witches clearly added too much of one ingredient to each of the cookies!

Lollipop drop. This is random. :)

Is paystary cookie will scarifice herself to save White lily?

Is it ‘em or do they kinda look like the five legendary dragon? Especially the pink on at 1:53 looking like lychee dragon cookie

@joel784

5 ай бұрын

Actually more similar to angels

Maybe there’s good witches and bad witches

Yooo 900th like

Cheese

Will they show us thr fallen heroes

@possiblyanerd

5 ай бұрын

We’ll probably see their faces during the story, because they’re obviously gonna be Important so I assume they’ll be in the story

@tagalogako991

5 ай бұрын

​@@possiblyanerdIts probably gonna be a special episodes or exploring the backstory.

They might be a mystic rarity

@joel784

5 ай бұрын

They are evil and overpowered so nah

@joel784

5 ай бұрын

Also you kinda predicted the new costume rarity

meow :33

In the past i actually had a theory that the witch is good.... sooo what can i say😏

Hello

Huh 🤔 I like this video

LORE DROPE

dont we love it how these mfs use clickbait! yeah me too.

O

They made a better mess... thats all im gonna say