Good journalism needs support from smart people like you. Subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/

Let's hope people having power to handle the situation are watching this

@patrickdsouza1780

4 жыл бұрын

They are only watching the forwards from their IT cell, Watch an article from a rabid Modi baiter on NDTV SG National Interest also merits a mention in the article. -- www.ndtv.com/opinion/3-traits-of-modi-that-have-cost-india-dearly-by-ramachandra-guha-2242669.

@niharikakhare8763

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks sir For appreciating Karnataka for its handling of the pandemic. It's heartening. Surprisingly all the channels refuse to acknowledge the fact.

@spikey1234567890

4 жыл бұрын

Hoping kcr watches this and saves himself and hyderabad

@rajeshjain5983

4 жыл бұрын

@@patrickdsouza1780 t

@humanculturesareautonomous3020

4 жыл бұрын

Modi moving superfast on Gates' evil agenda of mass surveillance, coercive vaccination and legal framework for medical martial laws in future kbforyou.blogspot.com/2020/04/modi-moving-superfast-on-bill-gates.html

If we had "less governance" since Independence, we would have been much better off; the bane of India has been the "Babudom" (a self-serving group) rooted in the Raj system of Governance, who ultimately take decisions on behalf of the Cabinet (remember the BBC series "Yes Minister"?). We have more and more Government and lesser of what is needed.

@omkarchauhan7675

4 жыл бұрын

If we had less government intervention in business and on social issues we would have been much better, socialism really did not help us. It was good only for the beaurocrats and the people in power and while the people suffered.

@techbasics6142

4 жыл бұрын

Really do you know Taj Mahal was sold to a businessman

@mikekazal

4 жыл бұрын

An ardent fan of *The Tribune*

@anishmohan3956

4 жыл бұрын

Wow! So you still went to 1940s to find someone to blame. The crisis is here today, there are people in power today who are doing (or not doing) things to control this. Atleast know where to place blame. Also, the need for babudom can't be seen without context, the times and conditions during 1940s. In retrospect almost everything can negated. Anyway. This is just my view. People find comfort I'm blaming past while ignoring present mishandling. Pls try to avoid that

@mirzahumayun5121

4 жыл бұрын

Ashok..you put it so nicely.. this all india sevice officers have become like a mafia... they joined the service to serve them self...

Metropolis handling ranking- Bengaluru-Best Chennai-Decent Mumbai,Delhi,Ahmedabad-Worst Hyderabad,Kolkata-No Data,No Worries..😂

@adityasheshadri8068

4 жыл бұрын

I’m from Hyderabad, and it’s close to impossible to get tested. Testing centres are only in a few areas, and are not accessible to people living anywhere else.

@aadityamurali18

4 жыл бұрын

In Bengaluru most people are wearing masks. That might be helping. But I'm not sure.

@himanshutrivedi9370

4 жыл бұрын

How is chennai descent

Pls do a CTC for telangana ...there is too much of ambiguity in terms of the numbers and testing and being in Hyderabad ,it's petrifyin as a parent.

@parmesh1982

4 жыл бұрын

Our Telangana is safe...no need of worring, Shaker Gupta became ARNAB,...and BJP supporter.

@glleeren7276

4 жыл бұрын

@@parmesh1982 What has BJP to do here...Plz explain

@prashantjha9824

4 жыл бұрын

@@parmesh1982 LoL here comes the dumbduck to defend the indefensible. KCR is putting Telangana on the line to make him look good. Abysmal testing rates and alarming TPR AND MORTALITY RATE

@1thaShivaji

4 жыл бұрын

@@parmesh1982 well done...... Blindfold and walk on the edge....and repeatvthe refrain All is well...

@ayanangshunayak6731

4 жыл бұрын

@Biswajit Patra Is that a sarcastic comment Biswajeet or are you being serious?

While other points he makes are ok, I don't quite agree with Rajiv Bajaj. Rajiv is a businessman and he foremost cares about his business. A govt. cannot and should not think like a businessman. One can argue any which way in terms of how India failed to control the spread but to argue that India should have given priority ro economy over lockdown is not ethically correct. If at a point where joblessness and poverty starts to cause more damage than the pandemic itself, then one can argue about removing lockdown. But saying lockdown was draconian is like saying "we could have let a few hundred people die and kept economy open". Rajiv Bajaj can think like that and thankfully he is not running the govt.

We have a collection of super-egoists of half-wits deeming themselves the ultimate superiors just because they have got into IAS; without requisite knowledge they boss over all professionals, including medical experts - "har shakh pe ullu baithe hai, anjamen-e-gulistan kya hoga?" In this age of super-specialization, why do we need "super" generalists who are Jack of all trades and Master of none

@binayakthakur5122

4 жыл бұрын

could not have written myself better

@acercbox4373

4 жыл бұрын

Agree with you, but the problem is with GoI. GoI answers for all problems is not how to manage but how to control.

@jaibirsingh6142

4 жыл бұрын

sorry , i disagree with this comment because their job is to co-ordinate the process of administration . They are the managers , it's the political will in which we are lacking . You have seen all the IAS officers are working on ground during the whole pandamic but have you seen any of those MLAs or MPs on the field

@ruchisingh1951

4 жыл бұрын

Super specialization comes later first we need some common sense !

@dibakarchakraborty8712

4 жыл бұрын

Walls have ears. The king's men will be angry.

What happened to the feluda test kit developed by CSIR and the trial of sepsis vac/drug against corona, we are daily hearing about new techs being developed for against corona but none of them seems to enter market/production. Are these being just developed to grab attention/news headlines, that is the question.

@pruthvibharateeya

4 жыл бұрын

Any vaccine testing takes time. After completion of dosage, patients will be kept under observation as side effects may crop up any time. And findings has to be peer reviewed before its published. Usually a vaccine takes couple of years to go for Market production.

@joyal876

4 жыл бұрын

Modi lost control. Entire show is run by babus

@dibakarchakraborty8712

4 жыл бұрын

To become Vishwaguru..

@parasujjainia9497

4 жыл бұрын

@sam bhai csir ne crisper-cas9 use karkr hi bnaya hai feluda test kit.

Sir I keep following your KZread videos. I am a doctor with (MS)degree. Keep practicing allopathy.but I had keen interest in alternative medicines.i would like to share some of my experiences 1.once i was attending yoga class.i was caught with cold and almost102 fever.i asked my guru weather to stop my yoga practice for some days .he said no ,instead you can just do simple pranayama in vajrasana and do some bastrika pranayamas.to my surprise cold and fever just lasted for 12 hours .I woke up next morning with full vigour. Science behind vajrasana -all the blood is pushed up in to upper body and flow increased twice to all organs where all the immunity mechanism occurs and with pranayama more oxygen indirectly we are boosting immunity by more exposure to virus.bastrika basically blows out virus hence the load is reduced in upper and lower respiratory tracts(which is the prime cause of fatality with covid) 2.plenty of sun light exposure at least 15 min where you sweat a little that increases vigour and boost immunity 3.food is very very important. No nonveg as it increases the work load on organs for digestion whose prime function at this time is for recovery .already lot of protein is there in body which body can utilise for immunological function 4.stay calm .the fear complex brings our immunity down more than the disease.in fact getting exposed with low dose of virus is beneficial like getting yourself vaccinated 5.some foods which I observed would increase respiratory difficulty by spasm and more mucous formation(which happens with asthma cases)are banana. brinjal . seafood .moongdal .cool foods etc.plenty of warm water and some tea to be drunk that would clear sputum and cleanse our blood and boost immunity 6.most important I was using silesia biochemistry medicine along with simple antibiotic for severe infections even with diabetes through out my practice with wonderful results.i once used it on my uncle whose foot was completely infected both ventral and dorsal part with uncontrolled diabetis who was prepared for below knee amputation. I have the pictures also .we could save his foot and now we can see a thin scar with wonderful healing with in a week.(so I think trial may be done on experimental mice or covid patients as silesia is simple silicon oxide which is equivalent to b -complex readily available in any homeo stores 7.Right now I was working with covid lab .where I had an interesting thing to share .for separation of virus silicon hydroxide is used which Sticks the viral RNA and then separated for RtPcr test.so does silesia work by holding the virus inside body?if it happen more blood cells get exposed hence quick and boosted immunity. I want to share this for research purpose but I work in a remote back ward district in andhrapradesh so I was sharing with you if its found useful we need not depend on vaccine each and every body can become a vaccine producing factory. Comments and suggestions in this regard are welcome Dr.narayanarao Watsapp 9440112957

A typical rtpcr kit cost 4500 . Mr Bajaj might have thousands of workers at his plant . So how will he afford it? An antibody test is not a diagnostic test it is a surveillance test and it also cost 400 rupees. And think of all the msme s. And think of media outlets . Does the print has its own testing kits available?

@ayanangshunayak6731

4 жыл бұрын

An excellent point made. Could not have put it better myself!

@prembuddy

4 жыл бұрын

Pool testing will further reduce costs

@shashimoghe3920

4 жыл бұрын

Useless idea industry is already suffocating due to corona stop of establishment no demand, inventories are already piling , more over industry already required share huge burden the CSR corporate social responsibility mandatory provision, how they van expected to bear this cost of testing @ 4500/- rupees per head Small companies are on the way to bankruptcy and other are starving for oxygen even at the govt level the country is going into an unprecedented recession with virtually negative growth

@pratimap.m.4785

4 жыл бұрын

Very true, and why should the employers bear this extra burden?

your table lamp is really good, where can i buy one from?

As facts change - I change my mind. What a statement

Sir conditions in ICU is very grim people are dying due to hunger and lack of drinking water , nursing is worst in ICU please make videos on icu condition of government hospitals..😢😢😢😢

What is the use of icmr and national disease center if they can't develop a high specificity criteria of testing after2.5 months of lockdown?

Also please address the issue of the high cost of treatment. I got some news about the bills being as high as 3,00,000 per week to 16,00,000 per month depending on how long they decide to keep you under monitoring.

I still don't understand how monopolies are even legal. Makes no sense. Any monopoly at any time during any situation either by the state or a pvt company is harmful.

gupta ji aapne apna herman miller chair kitne ka liya?

@RajaHindustaniEkNumber

4 жыл бұрын

Got it for free i bet...

@user34274

4 жыл бұрын

its a fake herman

"Asymptomatic people who are tested might be asymptomatic " jumbled words.

@yogeshwagh1731

4 жыл бұрын

Seriously... Taklu talks too much..

Subtitles kidhar hai...?

Sir, i have 1 rebute against this statement. Is it possible that Delhi has higher death cases as its one of the hubs of medicine in North India and has a lot of serious patients from other parts of India coming here for treatment? Apollo has 30 percent outstation patients admitted for COVID. Are these numbers also being taken in consideration?

@ayanangshunayak6731

4 жыл бұрын

With such harsh lockdown not so long ago, how were patients reaching Delhi hospitals from outside?

@akshatagarwal286

4 жыл бұрын

@john doe Ahmedabad leads India with 115 deaths per million! Nobody is talking widely about it.

@pruthvibharateeya

4 жыл бұрын

See there was a patient from Mysore in a very citical stage, patient was shifted to Bangalore for better medication. Despite being shifted to Bangalore, patient is included under Mysore. Initially few positive cases from Kasargodu (Kerala) were treated in Mangalore (Karnataka) due to easy accessibility of health services. Those cases were counted under Kerala, not under Karnataka. I assume same is with Delhi.

@mithildave5172

4 жыл бұрын

@@akshatagarwal286 Ture, lesser death rate of the whole state of Gujarat is overshadowing Ahmedabad's Fatalities. Otherwise, the fatalities in Ahmedabad is very high.

@akshatagarwal286

4 жыл бұрын

@@mithildave5172 110 per million. Highest in the country.

Major problems citizens facing 1. No immediate testing available. Patients not tested unless they develop symptoms. Symptoms develop after 5 days. Patient waits for 2-3 days for getting tested. Report takes another 2 days. Sometimes patient has lost 8_10 days before he is admitted and gets treatment. This is the reason majority deaths have occurred within 4 days of admission. The main reason of illness/ death is hypoxia or less oxygen. With the cases number rising there is shortage of deaths. Is it possible to arrange for something like portable oxygen cylinders or something of this sort which the patient can take at home till he gets a bed in the hospital?

YOU HAVE STILL NOT CLEARED THE ISSUE OF "YES NO YES" YOUR ANALYSIS OF OF ICMR DECISIONS WHY ?????

Excellent reporting Sir...hope the state and central government can hear your voice for more testing....why are they not allowing private companies to test their own employees...why only testing reserved for people with power??... I want this video to be seen by those politicians

Mumbai didn't open 8 days ago. It opened today on 8th June. So post lockdown study of Mumbai is a little premature

@patrickdsouza1780

4 жыл бұрын

hohoho MUMBAI is a disaster and staring down the wrong end of the barrel It’s going from bad to worse.

@user34274

4 жыл бұрын

8th June you mean

you missed chennai with 23298 cases , active 11817 with daily increase of 1000

@pruthvibharateeya

4 жыл бұрын

TN has better recovery rate and mortality rate compared to Maharashtra. Moreover TN has a more flexible and resilient government, whereas Maharashtra government which had indulged in promoting its own CM looks lost for sometime now.

@joyal876

4 жыл бұрын

@@pruthvibharateeya Still better than supreme leader ModiG's state of Gujrat. Gujarat model. Lol

@himanshutrivedi9370

4 жыл бұрын

@@joyal876 Gujrat numbers are consisitent. TN doubling in 5 days.

@joyal876

4 жыл бұрын

@@himanshutrivedi9370 Testing rate is much lower than TN. Gujarat have the highest fatality rate in India, Ahemadabad have the highest positivity rate.

Like how the hand sanitizer quantity is decreasing!

is there any compulsion to acheive certain no. as positive patient outcome ? i doubt !!!

Early detection is the key to avoid death as less lung virus load at the time. Nobody is safe until everybody is safe against this deadly global pandemic. Stay safe Hindustan. Best wishes from Colombo.Thanks

Sir, can you please raise issue regarding resuming international air travel.

Sir my simple question- Is it possible for a asymptomatic patient to recover out of corona without any medicine and gain herd immunity. Please answer.

Hmmm, I feel like this is this CTC, he was very assertive and it felt like it was directed at someone in particular. Like he knew people of importance were listening to what he is saying, or maybe I'm just imagining it.....

There are many covid patients who are not getting admitted in hospital due to lack of bed....Are these cases taken into consideration while providing data of per day covid patients???

Happy to hear some thoughts on finding some solutions!

Talk about Bengal it's in absolute misgovernance it's like a ticking time bomb

@APEXMACHCORPORATION

4 жыл бұрын

Its happening all over india leaving 2 - 3 small states , so west bengal is not a exception , even gujrat , mumbai , hyderabad ( Low testing as SG points out ) all have high uncontrollable cases across party lines.

@acercbox4373

4 жыл бұрын

@@APEXMACHCORPORATION Does KA, PA, and TN look like small states to you?

@acercbox4373

4 жыл бұрын

@@APEXMACHCORPORATION Does KA, AP, and TN look like small states to you?

@siddhantjaiswal4231

4 жыл бұрын

Shh ur not supposed to talk about kolkata ull be labelled as BJP man or maoist

@joyal876

4 жыл бұрын

Atul better than ModiG's Gujarat, one of the highest fatality rate in the WORLD

Kindly request you to not switch between reporting in lakhs (indian system) and millions(western system). Pls stay with any one format.

Where is lav Agarwal now. Hiding where,??? Such a same.

sir what's about drugs and medication.

Episode of cut the clutter should made mandatory for all our lawmakers & civil servants.

"Mumbai's deaths per million is considerably higher and not coming down" - How will deaths per million come down? It's a cumulative figure.

@nishanthnellutla

4 жыл бұрын

I think he meant the graph of deaths per million, not the cumulative deaths per million.

@AM-te1ff

4 жыл бұрын

🤣🤦‍♂️👍

Testing must increase 10 lakhs per day, with focus on Mumbai Delhi Chennai and Ahmedabad

Sir CIL is functioning as usual for opencast mines(96% of total production). As coal come under essential commodity so production is not halted for 1 day.

2 cents: 1. Set up testing kiosks area-wise across the country & govt has to bear the cost (don't worry about cost of peanuts, when you are dealing in diamonds). 2. Accept the fact, the Modi has screwed up covid management(learn from mistake).

But would these states give up to center???

Sir in your opinion what is the reason behind difference in death rate between developed states likeGujrat, Maharashtra, madhya pradesh and poor state like Bihar and odisha

While the country is opening up a small state like Mizoram is going into a 2 week lock down. Strange but true.

@ddleivang6297

4 жыл бұрын

N dat too wen all the positive cases detected so far r from quarantine centres meant for returnees. Its like putting a tiger in a cage & locking down the whole state fearing that the tiger may escape. The same goes for Manipur.

@ddleivang6297

4 жыл бұрын

@john doe if protocols r strictly followed in quarantine centres from where all the positive cases r detected, it doesnt matter wat happened outside - whether lockdown was violated or not as there was no +ve cases locally

Shekhar ji , according to Worldometer data which you yourself refer to sometimes - India's Test Positivity Rate (TPR) is 5.44 % (267K positive out of 49 Lakhs tested till date). but in the last few days, you've referred to India's TPR as 8% . Is there another source of data which suggests this ? thanks

8:12 All the coal mines under Coal India Limited have been operational throughout the lockdown. They were exempted under the Essential Commodities Act.

Evacuation Evaluation and Evaluation of congested area should have been started long ago.

can u please advise why fuel price is hike by rs.2 in 2 days ?

Great efforts on analysis

Sir agree with you, however there is acute shortage of hospital beds and all the government's are in self denial. Also employer's are busy firing people how can we trust the companies where profit matters more than lives? We pray and celebrate lord Ram but internally we are Ravan.

We can have an acronym "BAD" for cities that are performing badly. B for Bombay (the way Shekhar Gupta prefers it), A for Ahmedabad and D for Delhi

Please do include the north eastern states in your analysis. I have hardly seen any mention of the NE states in your videos

As we used to reiterate with this virus, that its incubation period is of 2-14 days. Now, where does this statement stand when we say asymptomatics only shed virus for 5 days. That virus might just be in its incubation period inside that patient and we test him as a corona positive patient and ask him to leave the hospital after 10 days without a test(based on, you know, ICMR studies). My question is how can we can categorize a patient as an asymptomatic patient and conclude that he might shed less if we are not seeing him for 14 days.

but the infection did balloon ...we are having 10k new infections each day

Basic thing like those who doubted Covid positive on self at least should be tested.

What's that behind the sanitizer bottle on table....Standing magnifying Glass,☺

So what is the fatality rate of Mumbai? It was not on the screen

I wonder if there's a way to measure all non-injury based deaths by state and by city and compare if this has increased from pre-corona times.

Sirji ..time for a few non corona CTC. Makes us feel normal again

Congratulations for opening up the subject of "Babugiri". I as a doctor strongly opposite the stand taken by bureaucrats. I feel we should have IMS (Indian Medical Services) now, where epidemiologist and people from preventive medicine to take control of health sector.

Media houses should also focus on case fatality rate and test positivity rate.

Shekhar sir not using sanitiser regularly which is placed over his table.

Shekharji, May I request you to do one video on statistical predictive analysis on the peak India might reach to straighten out the curve post lockdown? I’m extremely curious and look forward for it, especially coming from you, who has the good track record of disseminating facts based on authentic data! Please let me know

*This pandemic has really shown the rotten and rusty structure of the govt that it runs on.*

Great insight again.. Slight editing error in the end where the Mumbai vs delhi death rate was inserted abruptly.. Instead at the appropriate start.. Can re - edit n insert a fresh video

Right comment.

Sir please make a episode on small states like Goa & NE

Sir please explain about the anti body test results conducted by govt of india

Arrey chacha ji numbers haven't ballooned up because people are not using any public transport and has substantially cut the non essential travel , if you consider the local shops as a case in the point there is hardly any customer . There is fear among people plus they are aware of the situation .

Good work sir. This is one of the most important issues in the fight against the virus. And you have brought this out with numbers and apt examples. Hope the govt takes notice.

when the best media has no idea about what's happening in Telangana,Just imagine the plight of Telangana citizens, telangana govt is just like mini ccp.

Sir, There is said to be some error in the testing kits ...the results are not 100 percent accurate..can you pls shine some light on this...Thanks

Sir , I suppose you have missed 📍kolkata.

Are the 20,000 odd railway isolation coaches being used in these cities? How are they being managed?

@ric_yo

4 жыл бұрын

Yes we don't even if they are being used or not. Railway did a great job there but don't know if they are being used or not

The problem is that civil servants do not want to shed any powers. And they get attached to their previous decisions and try to defend it at all costs. The problem is that civil servants do not want to shed any powers. And they get attached to their previous decisions and try to defend it at all costs.

Well said Sir, even Hon’ ble Delhi CM has been saying to Delhi people that asymptomatic people or people with very mild symptoms should not get themselves tested - now when he showed mild symptoms, he got him selves tested. By god grace he was not tested positive - having said so should our politicians or civil servants not walk the talk ?

Coal India has never been shut for a single day since lockdown 1

@sasidharankarthikeyan3798

4 жыл бұрын

So is HAL. And Both make no difference if they were shut or open.

@pradeepra

4 жыл бұрын

@@sasidharankarthikeyan3798 HAL nowdays producing its own fighter jets with ADA and lchs

My husband looks forward to hear cut the clutter every night. I request you to not bring it out at 11:30 pm. Its almost end of day

Delhi # are going up as patients from adjoining states come to Delhi for treatment.

Shekhar Gupta Sir, please make a video on Privatization of Public Sector Banks

I think we will see the surge on infection rate after 14-25 days. Hope for the best.

@niranjanbalu6817

4 жыл бұрын

This month end will be horrific

@ayanangshunayak6731

4 жыл бұрын

Where? Bombay or MH or India as a whole?

Sir, Why Chennai leftout in this discussion? No data with you?

Thanks for info!!

Good points... However, the critical questions is how do we get state governments and the local authorities to test more? There has to be some accountability. Can’t believe a city like Mumbai can get away with ~4000 tests/day when the test positivity rate is so high and enough testing kits available. Can the Federal government force the states to test more? Or in the worst case scenario impose medical emergency in these cities?

How come our test positivity rate is 8%, I think it is 5.6% - 2.6 lac confirm cases for 46 lac tests - can you please clarify the way you measure positivity rate

Policy makers must made Cut the clatter compulsory..

A lot of people in Delhi do not cremate their loved ones in Delhi. Many go to places near Ganga such as Brijghat in UP but since state borders were closed until very recently, cremations had to happen in Delhi. That could explain the extra spike in deaths reported by crematoriums. And Ahmedabad alone has more deaths than Delhi while it only has a population of 55.7 Lakhs against Delhi's 1.9 crores.

Not sure private employers will be willing to spend 5000 Rs per person to test their employees. Agree though that the govt should increase testing with the opening.

Thought the Delhi LG has allowed testing of asymptomatic patients too....also sir can your team run a story on the production of vaccines developed by oxford. One of the channels did run a story on production having begun. What's the update???

how will tests help if these cities don't have infrastructure to handle the cases already coming up with limited testing...

Yet some private companies are insisting that their employees return to Mumbai/ Delhi and work from home in these cities. Those employees who moved to safer locations and are either already working online, or are willing to commence work online, need not be called to Mumbai or Delhi unless job entails physical presence. This would unnecessarily expose people to infections through travel. The concept of work from home needs to be understood by management. Govt needs to reiterate that only those who are physically required at work place are recalled. Or else public transport like mumbai locals and delhi metro will become additional vectors of spread.

Hearing Gupta ji giving his opinion after many "fact" driven videos. I hope some sensible person in the government having power to create a change is taking some notes.

Shekhar has avoided mentioning about the low testing in Ahmedabad ...

How come no politicians are dying? I find that puzzling.

Sir i thank you for highlighting Ahmedabad. There is a ton of mismanagement here. Also please mention deaths per million as it is the highest in the country here. Story of ahmedabad needs to be heard.

Sir study on Mumbai is definitely pre mature, things opened up yesterday i.e 8th June, were need data after 10 days from today.

Can we also know the total number of deaths happening in india, so that we get a perspective of covid versus other reasons of death in india

Sir... Always a pleasure hearing to your episodes and analysis. Also would like to Thank you for the "Mumbai and not Bombay" effort. Really appreciate the fact that you actually do read the comments... Keep up the good work....

What about chennai?. It has the second largest amount of cases in India, Is the situation under control there?.