Came here for the e4 reaction, but I also enjoyed watching/listening to you three guys discuss in depth the issues concerning the SW community. Don't be afraid to speak your mind. May all naysayers find peace within. Cheers to those who find joy in this series. We are all fragile lifeforms with limited time on this rock floating in this vast space. Lets enjoy our short time together in peace.

@Beef_Unit_Supreme

Ай бұрын

Fuq u, I'ma go bang ur mum, maybe give her a kid she can be proud of....mong.

@majinvegeta3181

Ай бұрын

What in the hell are you talking about. It is a TV series not Armageddon 😂. Some people like it and some people don't.

@kathyjumper6991

Ай бұрын

@@majinvegeta3181 But those who have turned to the darkside ARE acting like it is Armageddon. They remind me of Chicken Little running around screaming "the sky is falling!". I hope in life they never have to face a REAL crisis.

I am really appreciating the commentary for that reason! I feel like I learn a lot of helpful context but also just lean into the fun aspects

I absolutely support your beginning chat! I love SW & even when things don't 100% gel with me, I still try to watch till the end & keep an open mind. The level of hyperbolic bull out there is ridiculous. Let it just run it's course & at the end we can decide for ourselves if it was good, bad or mediocre. Thanks guys ❤

@Danielandthecat

Ай бұрын

Thank you! It’s surprising how many people there are every week saying this show, described as a mystery, doesn’t make sense as if we’re meant to already have all the answers. There are clearly a thousand things we’re not supposed to know yet, just let it play out!

Thank you. It hurts seeing the comments and videos being thrown at this. I stopped and unfollowed many KZreadrs, but found new reviewers and fascinating new fan channels that are ligit fun to watch! I love seeing Star Wars grow. And witches were in the Ewoks: Battle for Endor movie. And if you don't know what that is, don't throw hate.

@kevinreinhardt7216

Ай бұрын

I love you guys! You seriously make me smile

Great review, reaction, and opinions. Keep up the good work. My son and I had the same reaction you guys had when the credits rolled. Great show so far. Don't listen to those who have turned to the darkside.

Ki-Adi mundi is here to exist to be wrong as he usually is about all of his statements "The Sith have been extinct for a millenia!" (they haven't), "He's a political Idealist, not a murderer" (yes he is), and here he is saying something dumb and stupid because that's what he's known for

Saddest thing is that all Star Wars Theory ever does now is complain. Should change his name to Star Wars Complaints… He speaks about how the prequel haters are “bullies”, but he’s doing the exact same thing with The Acolyte and recent Star Wars shows

@OrionInSpace

Ай бұрын

There have been so many instances where that guy has shown his true colors over the last several years. He is not to be on the nose, but literally turning to the dark side. He’s becoming what the worst parts of KZread have become. In his case because of the fact that his views have demonstrably decreased recently, he has to find a way to get them back up. In doing so he’s literally become just another grifter. One of the more common things that he complains about nowadays is that he says “we just want good stories” but then goes and complains about Andor. Like dude is so stuck up his own ass about what he wants Star Wars to be.

@user-pv2sl2nq2d

Ай бұрын

Pretty sure 90% of sw fans think the acolyte is s hit. You're just out of touch.

@user-pv2sl2nq2d

Ай бұрын

​@@OrionInSpace i agree there're two sides in yt corners. Ones that see things for what it is and call out bs. And some that are simply mindless.

@OrionInSpace

Ай бұрын

@@user-pv2sl2nq2d I can tell you right now through what I watch and what I see on the Internet I know who the ones are that are fake. The only people who are out of touch, are the ones who have sold their soul to the KZread algorithm, which has prioritized them to make certain kinds of videos and content that will financially benefit them, but not actually make them speak the truth about how they actually feel. There is a lot of fake on KZread these days and this is why someone like me keeps a circle small with what kind of creators he follows. People certainly need to wake up, and this is coming from the point of view of thinking that the acolyte is decently underwhelming. It is by no means a good show, but it also by no means a bad one. I’ve seen enough on the Internet recently to make my mind up on that and not let my opinion be influenced by someone else.

@revan.3994

Ай бұрын

If it stinks like shite and looks like shite, who the hell are you to claim it isn't shite? In other words, it is our duty as human thinking beings to speak out if something is good or something is bad. >> So does Star Wars Theory if I may remind you IF you even follow him and watch his content. (because if you did, then you know that he is also praising something if it is well written and executed)... but opportunistic narcissists do what they do.

I understand the reason for Mae not wanting to continue her mission, but I think the way it was portrayed in the writing made it seem like a sudden switch rather than a gradual realisation that what she was doing was for nothing because Osha is alive. Also I agree that Kelnacca being killed off was a waste, especially doing it off screen. Tbh, for this series you guys are one of the two channels I watch because most channels seem to dislike the show based on a complete misunderstanding of the storytelling. This is a show of perspectives, with each side having a skewed version of events; both not knowing the full truth. I could be wrong, but I genuinely think the hate for this show comes from a place of misunderstanding. Correct me if I’m wrong though. Also yes, Star Wars Theory sucks haha. He’s arrogant af. Bro “just wants good stories” but shat on Andor for having bricks and the wrong type of screws (in a galaxy of infinite possibilities).

@Lemmiwings

Ай бұрын

The last time Mae saw Osha, she wanted her dead. So why does her being alive change her motivation to kill the Jedi? You could argue, that she only does what her master says, because he is her only acquaintance and that Osha being alive potentially changes that fact. But that is not portrayed in the writing at all. Her motivation to kill the Jedi seems very intrinsic and based on deep rooted hatred and a need for revenge. And yes episode 3 seems to be showing the events from Oshas pov, but it's still very flawed. Oshas reason why she wants to leave the coven and why her view of the Jedi is very different from the rest of the coven is not explained at all, for example. You learn basically nothing new. The only new information is that the twins were made with some kind of magic by witches, who probably use the dark side. The whole episode could have been condensed to a five minute flashback without missing any important detail. The same is true about episode 4. You get very little plot development, but also no meaningful character progression. Things just happen out of convenience and characters don't seem to be consistent. When you combine all of this with the lore breaking stuff, I can understand the hate.

Guess what, it was Ki-Adi Mundi, confirmed in the credits

NO BC I LITERALLY PUT THIS OFF UNTIL YESTERDAY CUZ I SWEAR IT WAS ASS BUT NOOO ITS SOOOOOOO GOOOD

THANK you for acknowledging the review bombing I feel like I'm being gas lit by the internet with the folks denying it just screaming it's trash

A little fun fact, we do actually know what Oppo Rancisis sounds like. I believe he had one line of dialogue in The Clone Wars, and his voice is heard in a force-echo in Jedi Survivor

Subbed bc of ur opinions on SW

Sorry for commenting so much today, but seriously I am glad you all took the time to address that hard topic at the beginning. I seriously had lost faith in people, and started wondering why isnt anyone addressing this. I'm so scared that voices of hate are louder than the voices of support, scaring off future projects.

We'll see more Kelnacca in flashbacks.

@xDarthSTYXx

Ай бұрын

Kelnacca has to be who blinded Torbin. More witch possession?

They sabered!!!! lmao

It’s not Ezra Miller behind the mask and it’s not a Sith Lord, it’s Mother Aniseya having her revenge. No, she didn’t die that day and she is pissed because those four Jedi took her child away and killed Mother Koril.

@mkhud50n

Ай бұрын

Actually it was Anisaya they showed dead on the ground. And Koril was the darker of the two that was more antagonistic towards the Jedi. Anisaya is their Yoda and Koril is their Mace.

@gantz0949

Ай бұрын

​@@mkhud50nyea it's koril

Most of the negative reactions I’ve seen aren’t really about woke, but the script. Take ep2 to ep4. Mae goes to the third Jedi. Sol is forced to go to Coruscant (because they can’t do a meeting with holograms?). The meeting between Osha and Jecki implies they’ve been there for a few days. Yet both Mae and Sol arrive at the same time? While the end of EP2 implies Mae and Qimir go there right away.

ki adi mundi is there. All the legend fans are mad because all their information is useless 😂😂 he also doesn’t go to the mission so he is still not aware of the sith as of right now… let the ride continue 🥳🥳

Congrats guys getting close to that Disney gift bag coming ur way😂

@maulok8441

Ай бұрын

Disney gift bag? Get over yourself 😂

Oh look it the consuuuuumers

Ki - adi- mundi was master of the order before , windu in Ep 1 In canon.

Guys try not to talk so much over reactions and you won't have problems like 14:55 where you blatantly have to say "I missed what happened" lol! :P PAY MORE ATTENTION. You guys were also talking so much at 21:40 that the guy on the left had to cut himself off just to pay attention to what was going on again! You gotta get a little better about this lol... Maybe save all your theorizing and discussions for AFTER the episodes air, instead of getting hardcore into it MID EPISODE?

@thesovereign6996

Ай бұрын

Yet they're good at being loud and meat riding this god awful series (In my opinion) bad acting and otherwise but atleast stay true to yourself and not some muppet, these kind of reactors are hilarious clown material though~

Many thanks to Jack, Julien, Jordan and Christian! 🌑 Wookieepedia says that was 'Ki-Adi-Mundi' but that's not 'Plo Koon'... must be another Kel Dor.

It makes alot of sense ki adi mundi is in it since he said the sith haven't been around for a millennium. Heck I don't even know if he was alive for it. It was confirmed ki adi mundi in credits

“Master Ki-Adi-Mundi” is listed in the Guest Staring credits. Played by Derek Arnold.

I really think he will now try to convert Osha and try to kill Mae for betraying him

I don't get why Lucasfilm can't hire people that respect the source material.

@xDarthSTYXx

Ай бұрын

There is no source material. The EU was never canon.

@ItsDume

Ай бұрын

How about you stop crying about it online? 🤷‍♂️ It’s a show on Disney Plus, not a death sentence.

@1spence923

Ай бұрын

most you people crying are dumber than fucking rocks

@kimshlongunnhh9994

Ай бұрын

Explain what the source material is? If you’re talking about the EU well George broke that rule since heir to the empire

@Em-ne4gk

Ай бұрын

"put a chic in it and make her gay and lame!" -Cartman Kennedy 🌈✂️✂️

Qimir: "I'm going to find more water." Translation: "I'm going to go kill a Wookie Jedi."

If the 2 dudes on the left started their own channel, I'd totally support them and be a patreon supporter. Love their energy and banter etc

@gantz0949

Ай бұрын

Yea dude on right total shill

This show just got interesting. I am excited for ep. 5 now and can rest easy knowing that fellow TRUE fans agree with me that the hatred for this show is overblown

@famousmortimer7933

Ай бұрын

The power of many! Turbo cringe🤡😂💩

@majinvegeta3181

Ай бұрын

This guy 😮 ✊

Meh. I just am waiting for a reason to care about any of these characters

22:49... What happened to having an opinion? :)

@koyapol

Ай бұрын

did he just? Fuck everybody who says this show sucks? LMFAO

I love the reaction! MORE 😂

R.i.P Star Wars

22:49 fuck everybody who says this show sucks? LOL

The color of the sash behind their belt tells us if they’re a Padawan (green), Knight (brown), or Master (white).

guys your reaction at the end is priceless :D

This show is exposing how many Star Wars fans don’t even know Star Wars. They aren’t even trying to figure it out and gave in to hate. Disappointing.

hope you'll get better someday. god bless ya and please stop lying, most of teh fanbase didn't hate Andor, didn't hate Mandolorian 1st, 2nd seasons, didn't hate Clone Wars by Tartakovsky guess why? just cause that was not a stupid fanfic poorly written content

Come on guys, one simple argument annihilates all your hot air babble: The frickin SAME fans gave Ahsoka even 60+%, Mando 80+%, and so on. Even House of the Dragon, with another strong female lead, with lots and lots of diversity and LGBT cast got 80+%, more or less from the same demographic of fans! ...Or do you really believe that miraculously, the Acolyte is watched by completely different people? So please, apply some critical thinking and ask yourself: how did the 14% come to be? The answer is easier than you might think: Racism and toxicity is not even needed to review bomb this dumpster fire because simply, The Acolyte is a bad show, badly written, badly executed, and certainly badly directed. And even if we forget about all the lore breaking aspects, the aforementioned is already enough to justify that the fans are upset about this... and I don't even go into the financial part here, because what?, 180 millions for a walk in the forest? OMG, you just can't invent this.

I am enjoying the series so far but sadly the episodes are to short, I had the same exact reaction when it ended 😂

I’m 99.9% sure, Mae “changed her mind” when she realized that Qimir was playing her. She states that the final test is something you learn yourself. Qimir appears to be more invested in her mission than he should. And now that Osha is alive, she knows whatever she’s been led to believe is a lie.

@undeenwrites

Ай бұрын

Exactly! I think she was "testing" him the whole way & only kept up the pretense until they where close enough for her to find him alone. There were some strange editing choices in this ep, but that ending was 10/10! Cannot wait for next week

Exactly, his hubris is what's great about Ki-Adi-Mundi being in this series. I personally don't want to see a bunch of the Jedi we are already familiar with.

I think RT should only count reviews toward audience scores if the user has reviewed a minimum (20 or even 50) of shows/series.

Wow you guys are straight hypocrites you sit there and rant at the beginning about all the opinions people have and talk about acceptance but you completely dismiss hat guy like he can’t have his own opinions. He voiced his opinion on characters but you completely jumped down his throat when he said he wasn’t accepting the fact. I also don’t like how the non ginger bearded guy keeps trying to take everything over and constantly talks over people. You guys need to take a hard look at your productions. You are inconsistent. I come here for Star Wars content to see if my thoughts and theories are same as others not for your opinions to be slammed down my throat or to be lectured like you did with hat guy. Other then you doing hat guy dirty reactions were exactly how I felt. Also Jack the ginger guy you are awesome with your reactions definitely the best one to watch in my opinion. Walmart kanan you are cool but need to be more vocal. Hat guy you don’t show enough emotion but I see why you wouldn’t want to. Love you guys keep up the good work

The writing is atrocious. Spend 180million on this show, more than Dune btw, and couldn't spend a little more for competent writers.

@tylerschofield8299

Ай бұрын

It's really not but okay

@CheesySalmon

Ай бұрын

If you so clearly don’t like the show. Why are you still sticking around in the comments for episode 4??. You people have nothing better to do with your lives.

This show is terrible...honestly wasn't expecting much but its worse than i feared...poor acting, poor story and script...just total garbage

@discobroccoli198

Ай бұрын

Wrong

@BasefordNFFC

Ай бұрын

@@discobroccoli198 right...this show is total garbage

@discobroccoli198

Ай бұрын

@@BasefordNFFC Nah

@BasefordNFFC

Ай бұрын

@@discobroccoli198 yep

@discobroccoli198

Ай бұрын

@@BasefordNFFC nah

Bad writing, bad acting, the costums just look like cheap cosplay. 180.000.000 😂😂😂