🚀 neetcode.io/ - A better way to prepare for Coding Interviews

@jchakrab

Жыл бұрын

think of a directed graph 0->1->2->3->4, isn't your solution's time complexity O(E * N**2)...you will start the same loop for 1, 2, 3, 4 after doing it for 0

The .remove(crs) was so confusing but I finally understood it. Simplest explanation: if we exit the for-loop inside dfs, we know that crs is a good node without cycles. However, if it remained in the visited set, we could trip the first if-clause in the dfs function if we revisit it and return False. That's what we don't want to do, because we just calculated that crs has no cycles. So we remove it from visited so that other paths can successfully revisit it. Basically we can visit the node twice without it being a cycle due to it terminating multiple paths.

@yashjakhotiya5808

Жыл бұрын

and the reason it terminates at 'twice' is because of preMap[crs] = []

@tiffanychan6272

Жыл бұрын

thank you! i was pulling out my hair trying to figure out why

@wayne4591

Жыл бұрын

Actually you can see this trick in many graph, binary tree or other problems using back tracking. Because the visit set is only used to contain the current visit path. So whenever you exit the sub-function you create on this level, you have to pop the info you passed in before.

@sidazhong2019

Жыл бұрын

in every dfs, pop() or remove() after a call, is a standard process. you will see.

@netraamrale3850

Жыл бұрын

Do you have any example?

The setting of preMap[crs]=[] before return true is so smart!!! Absolutely love it

@yuemingpang3161

2 жыл бұрын

Pretty smart! He removes all pre-courses at once after iterate through one adjacency list. In the drawing solution, he removes the pre-courses one by one. To align with the codes, the list can only be "cleaned out" if all pre-courses returns true. Actually, I was a little bit confused when I first saw the codes.

@alfahimbin7161

Жыл бұрын

@@yuemingpang3161 what is the time and space complexity of this solution??

@yashjakhotiya5808

Жыл бұрын

And necessary for time complexity to be O(num_nodes). If we didn't do it, the last for loop would have us visiting nodes as many times as it required by other courses, making the overall complexity O(n^2).

@minepotato7126

4 ай бұрын

It's too smart

@EranM

2 ай бұрын

not only smart, but essential for a good running time.. hell I fell there!!!

Your channel is soo helpful! If I get stuck on a LC question I always search for your channel! Helped me pass OAs for several companies. Thank you so much.

Great explanation, I was doing the adj list pre->course and confused myself in the coding step. Thanks for the video, smart ideas. I definitely was not thinking of the fully connected graph case

Thank you so much pal! I was able to crack it myself after seeing your visualizations of the graph, with ease. Words can't describe my happiness.

@alfahimbin7161

Жыл бұрын

what is the time and space complexity of this solution??

Thank you so much for all of these videos. Very well explained and also well put together and displayed. Really fantastic material, it's been absolutely invaluable in helping me to learn and improve my skills.

this was so so helpful, thank you so much for being so clear!

@NeetCode

2 жыл бұрын

Glad it's helpful!

Thank you! Great explanation! And you have a magical voice, such a pleasure to listen to your explanations.

What a lucid explanation! Keep this up!

@alfahimbin7161

Жыл бұрын

what is the time and space complexity of this solution??

this is a clever solution. not something i would ever come up with haha, i had a similar idea, but it kind of just broke down during the dfs step. i had a lot of trouble trying to figure out how to detect cycles in a directed graph...in the end when i was looking in the discussion i saw that you could just do a topological sort so i felt silly after that haha. gotta work on graph problems more :-)

@alfahimbin7161

Жыл бұрын

what is the time and space complexity of this solution??

@frida8519

Жыл бұрын

@@alfahimbin7161 O(n + p) where n is the number of courses and p the prerequisites. The explain it at around 08:37

If you move the line 13 `if preMap[crs] == []` before the line 11 `if` check, then you don't need the `visitedSet.remove(crs)` in line 19, because you will never traverse the visited path that way. Thanks for great explanation.

@Alex-tm5hr

19 күн бұрын

You can actually just remove it all together and it still passes lol

He is speaking the language of god.🔥🔥

LintCode imposes the memory constraint such that recursive DFS will fail. The intended solution should be iterative based topological sort.

Brilliant Solution!! It took me a while to think it through but finally understood it, really appreciate your help!

clear solution, thank you! Wish you could also go over BFS 😄

Hey man, thanks a lot for your description. You probably have the best explanation on this this problem compared to other KZreadrs. There’s a girl that’s pretty good too her names jenny

I meet this question today, thank you so much.

SO clear! Thanks a lot

Phenomenal explanation! Thank you so much!

I have a hard time envisioning visited.remove(crs). I cannot connect this to the "Drawing Solution" earlier. I can see when preMap[crs] is set to 0 @7:44, but I cannot see any part where visisted.remove(crs) corresponds to. I understand to detect a cycle, we need to visisted.add(crs), But I cannot see where visited.remove(crs) fits. Can someone help?

@RanjuRao

3 жыл бұрын

Lets say course 3 is dependent on 2 and 2 is on 1, while traversing for 3 you make dfs(2) which in turn is dfs(1) but dfs(1) does not have pre-req so u mark it as [] (initially) and similarly you need to mark dfs(2) to [] which is done using set.remove() and map.append([] ) for key =2 .

@akinfemi

3 жыл бұрын

Same. What helped me was thinking about it as setting the course node to a "leaf node". If you notice the leaf nodes (courses with no prerequisites) are never added to the visited set. So setting it to [] and removing it from the set does that.

@sudluee

2 жыл бұрын

I think it makes more sense if you replace visitSet.remove() with visitSet.clear(). visitSet.clear() also works for our purpose, which is basically to give us a new visitSet for each course so we don't get false positives from earlier runs.

@jessepinkman566

2 жыл бұрын

When the graph is not fully connected. 1->2->3, 4->3. If you should not remove 3, 4->3 would be false because 3 is already in the set. However, you can also choose to change the order of the two ifs in the start of the bfs to avoid removing.

@tonyz2203

2 жыл бұрын

feel the same thing.

To simplify this problem This is based on finding if the directed graph has a cycle. If yes then return false(cannot complete all courses) else return true.

@tonyiommisg

4 ай бұрын

I feel the way the problem is worded, I never realized that it was asking this question lol

@NeetCode Thank you so much for your work! I'am going through collection of your solutions and litterally feeling smarter) I don't really understand one thing in this problem - why do they provide numCourses at all? I mean, when given number is less then total number of courses provided in prerequisites - like (1, [[0, 1]]) the algorithm fails. And of course you dont realy need this number to create preMap (you could use defaultdict, or check if key exists on string 14 before comparing to empty list). Iteration through length of preMap also will work when running dfs.

we dont need to travese 4 from 1 if we are keeping track of the visited nodes. cross edge iterations can be eliminated to increase the speed of the algorithm, right?

I have taken Neetcode's Course Schedule 2 idea and implemented this on those lines: Personally I found that idea more intuitive and easier to follow. class Solution { HashMap prereq = new HashMap(); // hashset to mark the visited elements in a path HashSet completed = new HashSet(); // we use a hashset for current path as it enables quicker lookup // we could use the output to see if the node is already a part of output, // but the lookup on a list is O(n) HashSet currPath = new HashSet(); public boolean canFinish(int numCourses, int[][] prerequisites) { // base case if (numCourses

Simplest and easiest explanation. Thankyou!

Intuitively I was thinking of this solution and gave myself 30 mins to solve it, I got to the part of DFS but then confused myself because I was like "I feel like I need DFS here but where should I start it, how should I call it" and then the time was up xD, I'm happy I almost came up with it alone though. Thanks for the video, it clarified what I was having trouble with.

Thank you for this awesome video! I am wondering if you could do a video about a BFS version of the same problem? Thank you very much!

in the example case [1,0], why is it out reach arrow 1-> 0 ? I thought in order to get 1, you need to get 0 first, so, it's 0->1 ? am i right? it's a little anti-intuitive ?

I literally looked at this question yesterday and couldn’t get it, thanks for making this vid!

@NeetCode

3 жыл бұрын

A nice coincidence! Thanks for watching

Your explanation is super clear, thanks

@alfahimbin7161

Жыл бұрын

what is the time and space complexity of this solution??

When I did this exercise for the first time, I actually created a whole complete graph data structure from scratch. Then created 2 visited maps to resolve the circular issue. So much memory required

Very nice. Thanks for making this

Thanks for your explanation! it is clean and easy to percept. I really appreciate your coding style. Just a heads up that the if perMap[crs] == [] return True can be omitted since if we have an empty array for prerequisites for crs, the for loop afterwards will just end and return True at the end!

@pacomarmolejo3492

Жыл бұрын

Yes, though, you save "some time" by handling it that way.

you are the very best one for explain leetcode problems, and I am not even a python user

@NeetCode

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks! =)

You explanaition is amazing, I love it !

@NeetCode

2 жыл бұрын

Glad it's helpful!

Thank you!!! Such a great teacher

thanks for the n = 5 expample, cleared the ques for me !

Thanks for this wonderful video!

@NeetCode

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks!

If you want to take course 1, you have to take course 0 first.

Killer explanation. Thank you.

why do we have to remove the crs from the visited set at line 19? what is the purpose?

Thanks Neetcode! Is this playlist supposed to be followed sequentially? Thanks

Love your videos! Would love to see the code included as well, especially in Javascript as converting can be tough. Thanks NeetCode :)

So amazing brother. Thank you

I don’t quite understand. Is it about topological sort or some other kind of algorythm? Like finding cycles for example

I came up with the same idea but didn't know how to code. How should I improve?

Quick question: I was trying to solve this using the Ailen Dictionary method you also made a video of. I can't get it to pass all test cases. May I ask if the method for the alien dictionary can be applied to this one?

Bro, you are just GOLD!

Forgot the remove part. You are amazing

you dont need to remove crs from visited at the end if you just check adj==[crs] before checking crs in visitSet

@user-j5ja95

10 ай бұрын

huh ?

Awesome solution!

good explanation on dfs, thanks! and i like the name of your channel :)

@NeetCode

2 жыл бұрын

Happy it's helpful :)

Nice explanation. Curious - why/how did you zero in on using DFS instead of BFS?

@hillarioushollywood4267

2 жыл бұрын

@rahul, to check if a particular course completion can be possible. And we can do it if and only if we can check all its prerequisite.

You draw edge incorrectly. If it's [0, 1] meaning you first have to take course 1 before 0, edge is gonna be 1->0, not 0->1, because first we need to take 1 and only then we will have access to the 0.

@chrisgeorge2420

2 жыл бұрын

his solution models the graph in the other direction, it is still correct because he is consistent with it

@yynnooot

2 жыл бұрын

I was thinking the same thing, the arrows threw me off

@mostinho7

2 жыл бұрын

The arrows/wording is messed up, he’s using the word prerequisite to actually mean postrequisite, but good video still

@lemonke8132

Жыл бұрын

yeah all his arrows are backwards I don't know how that makes sense to him.

Could you also go through the space complexity in your videos?

@pacomarmolejo3492

Жыл бұрын

Given N = number of courses, P = prerequisites; TC: O(N + P), because we are visiting each "node" once, and each "edge" once as well. SC: O(N+P), as our hashmap is of size N + P, and the recursive call stack + visited set are of size N.

Thanks for the very clear explanation. I have a suggestion for direction of arrows that may be less confusing. For example, prerequisites = [[1,0]] means that if we have to take course 0 before course 1. So my graph would be pictured like: 0------->1 instead of 1------>0.

@ua9091

2 жыл бұрын

Depends on how we see it. In his case, the concept is like 1 has a dependency on 0, hence drew an edge from 1 pointing towards 0.

@halahmilksheikh

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah that was so confusing

looking sharp thanks

Wow... The best explaination... ❤️

I don’t really get what If not dfs(pre): Return false Is doing. I understand it’s checking if the statement is false but what is it doing specifically?

Not able to do the BFS solution of this problem, got stuck in thinking how it will be approached, tried with one problem getting TLE in 29th test case. Can anyone help!

Thank you so much!

how come you don't use a set instead of a list for the visitedSet? One would need to use the nonlocal keyword but the lookup times are much quicker. Couldn't there be an edge case where your last node in the dfs loops back to the second to last and then you are searching the whole array. This could potentially happen a couple times no? Thanks for any clarity you can provide!

so isnt it just a detect cycle problem? if cycle exists return false else true ?

can someone tell me why are we removing elements from visitSet? Thanks

You are legend man!!!

Great video. I wonder if you could solve this problem with a tortoise & hare algorithm?

What is the space complexity ? Since we are using HashMap and Set?

Brilliant explanation, wow.

I tackled this problem as cycle detection.

this question is currently being asked at Amazon. My brother is one of the interviewers who asks it hehe

Why can't your map be an integer as the key and an integer as the value? Why does the value have to be a list? I thought it would be okay to declare the map as int, int since you have one prereq for each course

I implemented DFS via a stack. I also tried a similar approach with BFS using a deque queue but it was a lot slower. class Solution: def canFinish(self, numCourses: int, prerequisites: List[List[int]]) -> bool: graph = defaultdict(list) for prereq in prerequisites: graph[prereq[0]].append(prereq[1]) for i in range(numCourses): if i in graph: stack = graph[i] seen = set() while stack: node = stack.pop() if node == i: return False if node not in seen: for j in graph[node]: stack.append(j) seen.add(node) return True

I am not understanding why we set preMap[crs] = [], in the drawing solution we just removed one by one after checking. Why are we just removing all the prereqs after one is checked?

@derilraju2106

Жыл бұрын

the for loop will remove all its neighbors first

In the beginning you show the edge going the wrong way for [1,0] the direction of the arrow should be from 0 to 1

@NeetCode Can you please explain the time complexity in detail.

its been almost three months i am doing leetcode but still cannot come up with my own solution, can anybody tell me exactly what is thats wrong i am doing? :(

I feel using Kahn's algorithm for detecting cycles in the directed graph is the simplest solution for this, even though logically not 100% right as we use indegree in Kahn's algorithm, as soon as I see cycle and undirected graph I solved it with this method. Then I got to know we are supposed to deal with outdegree to deal with independent nodes in this case! Though Kahn's algo works !

without the empty list optimization this will get TLE, pretty smart to figure that out

Thank you neetcode guy

Great explanation. I understood it so clear . Awesome work..

Could another solution be just detecting if the graph contains a cycle or not? You would use 2 pointers and make one move by one position and the other by 2. If the nodes encounter each other then you will have a cycle therefore you can’t complete the courses. Could someone tell me if there is a flaw in this solution? Thanks :)

@d4ntoine134

Жыл бұрын

You wouldn't detect isolated courses

I was really confused about the direction of the edges. Intuitively, I would think precourse -> course, but you have the arrows going backwards from course -> precourse. By switching the arrows around to: precourse -> course, and having your adjacency list as: { precourse: [ course ] } instead of: { course: [ precourse ] }, your DFS solution still works. The benefit to doing it this way is that you can use the same adjacency list pattern for a BFS topological sort approach, which needs access to the neighbors of nodes with zero in-degrees.

This was good!

Is this considered topological sort?

Hello everyone, this is YOUR daily dose of leetcode solutions

Can someone please explain why the time complexity of this is V+E. I cant understand for the life of me. Thanks

Dude this literally SAVED me!

what is the space complexity?

I understand the preMap[crs] == [] purpose. But, does that mean when we find out that a course's prerequisite is [], we directly conclude that this course can be completed and return true for that course, without checking if the other prerequisites of that same course can all be completed as well? In other words, do we consider that a course can be completed if at least one of its prerequisites can be so?

@nihilnovij

6 ай бұрын

preMap[crs] == [] is outside of the loop so by then we ensured all prerequisites can be completed

what's the space complexity?

I like ur solution to this problem and I understand it the most but when i converted this code to javascript it runs bottom 10% of javascript leetcode submissions. Any idea why?

@Asmrnerd10

10 ай бұрын

var canFinish = function(numCourses, prerequisites) { let hashMap = {} let visited = new Set() let result = true // Fill in hashmap for(let i = 0;i let array = prerequisites.filter( (e) => e[0] === i) if(array.length > 0){ let tempArray = [] array.forEach( (e) => tempArray.push(e[1])) hashMap[i] = tempArray } else hashMap[i] = [] } for(let i = 0; i if(!dfs(i)) return false } return result function dfs(course){ if(visited.has(course)) return false if(hashMap[course].length === 0) return true visited.add(course) for(let i = 0; i if(!dfs(hashMap[course][i])) return false } visited.delete(course) hashMap[course] = [] return true } }

Smart solution ✨

Explanation on WHY/HOW cycle was detected(The crux of the problem) -As we perform dfs, we add node to 'visited' set if it does not exist. -Once we have exhausted all its neighbors/prerequisites AND return back to it from call stack, we pop it from call stack and we remove from 'visited' set. -A cycle is detected when the node we are popping off of call stack still exists in 'visited' set. BUT WHY?? In the last example he provides @ 10:50, while we have/are visiting the last neighbor/prepreq of node 0, unfortunately we have not returned back to it due to its order in call stack. Hence a cycle was detected before we we're able to remove node 0 from call stack.

This is very clear explanation, but I met Time Limit Exceeded problem, so I made the follow changes to met the requirements: class Solution(object): def canFinish(self, numCourses, prerequisites): """ :type numCourses: int :type prerequisites: List[List[int]] :rtype: bool """ adjacency_list = [[] for _ in range(numCourses)] for crs, prec in prerequisites: adjacency_list[crs].append(prec) visited = [0] * numCourses def dfs(crs): if visited[crs] == 1: return False if visited[crs] == 2: return True visited[crs] = 1 for prec in adjacency_list[crs]: if not dfs(prec): return False visited[crs] = 2 return True for crs in range(numCourses): if not dfs(crs): return False return True

does any one have c++ code for the same approach?

this channel is great

I think you have it backwards around 1:19 but no big deal. 1 is a prereq of 0

much clear than leetcode sol

I have to say if you didn't realize this was a graph problem or to just think about it literally initially about courses and prerequisites you can get pretty stuck with where to go. :(