Plot twist - we get a third album but it’s just a solid hour of them reading every comment they can find asking for a third album.

@porchcollapse8612

4 жыл бұрын

Well, better than no album

@goldie1943

4 жыл бұрын

Oh, I would listen religiously

@JarperTheWolf

3 жыл бұрын

I feel like this might happen

@Gone._.

2 жыл бұрын

I HAVE A TRACKLIST!!!

@Gone._.

2 жыл бұрын

1. Intro 2. Please Please Please 3. Easy to Find 4. I’m Beggin’ You 5. What Happened? 6. Long Rant (Interlude) 7. Live Now 8. Where We’ve Been. 9. Green Ugly Profile Picture 10. Hard To Find 11. We Are Tryin’ 12. Outro

We want... Hawaii: part I

@kazooplayer3

3 жыл бұрын

funny story im actually working on a hawaii part 1. since im not joe it probably wont be on par with the original, but its something.

@SAM_ARTHUR_CL0VVNDOLL

3 жыл бұрын

hawaii part i is just irl hawaii

@papajhonsreal

3 жыл бұрын

Joe has stated that he doesn't intend on making Hawaii Part I

@bubbles4131

3 жыл бұрын

Petty much

@MacheTheFerret

3 жыл бұрын

wouldn't hawaii: part i in THIS context just be Pearl Harbor?

Tally hall is like valve... They don't know how to count to 3

@quadkanix

3 жыл бұрын

Lol

@weirdeadz

2 жыл бұрын

And we've been waiting forever for something new.

@kitsune630

2 жыл бұрын

And they got people excited when they released minor stuff making people think they would finally make a third instalment only for it to be another ref herring. Still there is hope for at least touring.

YES, they gotta have another big finish for the album like Fate Of The Stars, though.

@PT55644

3 жыл бұрын

Fate of the stars is my favorite song from Good & Evil. The chorus is just so... Amazing! Its so good

@ElementFreakYT

3 жыл бұрын

It’s great

@clemclemclemclemcl

Жыл бұрын

@@PT55644 IN THE FATE OF THE STTTAAARRRRRSSSS

@DontYouDareToCallMePolisz

11 ай бұрын

If they're going to make their 3rd album the last, Color Be Gone should be the last song

We should call the demo for greener “green”, then have the finished song “greener”, then complete the trilogy with “greenest”

Have you listened to Miracle Musical? You didn't mention it- EDIT: lmao nvm

@snazzycactus6748

4 жыл бұрын

Bruh

@perfidiousprophet

4 жыл бұрын

@@snazzycactus6748 serious bruh moment

@Siggney1

3 жыл бұрын

the 9/11 album?

@RandomPerson-qd9gj

3 жыл бұрын

there's pingry ep

@drchoccymilk3223

3 жыл бұрын

@@Siggney1 the 9/11 song isnt in the album edit: nevermind

Tally Hall: Write that down, write that down!

I will only be interested in a 3rd album if it's just 40 minutes of Sea Cucumber from Admittedly Incomplete Demos in various genres.

@EmeraldFox11

4 жыл бұрын

YOU HAVE THE LARGEST BRAIN OF ALL OF US

@mooniethemew

4 жыл бұрын

I HAVE HAD THAT SONG STUCK IN MY HEAD FOR DAYS NOW AND I CANT STOP SINGING IT

@hayleynoharmony

3 жыл бұрын

post-hardcore emo Sea Cucumber

It's about time we get another Tally Hall album. The world needs more fabloo.

Me realizing it probably won't happen while crying my ass off in the bathroom:😃

I can't exactly remember where this was said, but (i think Andrew) mentioned how they had just a SLEW of unfinished songs that havent even been released on the incomplete demos album, that will probably be making a good portion of a possible third album, if it happens ............................ even if it takes centuries, i think we WILL be getting another album/show, it is simply INEVITABLE, even if the tally hall men (and me) are old and greying when it happens

I thought only Variations on a Cloud was about 9/11, while Hawaii: Part II was its own seperate thing

@ElementFreakYT

4 жыл бұрын

PanzerDragon The lyrics listing on Genius says that Joe wrote the entire album with 9/11 in mind. I haven’t done much research to back that, but it would make sense

@uranium404

4 жыл бұрын

I recall Joe (or someone else, can't remember) saying that the album didn't have one definite meaning or a storyline and that everyone who worked on miracle musical had their own interpretations

@panzerdragon1121

4 жыл бұрын

@@ElementFreakYT I suppose the best course of though for now would be to keep my mind open to either interpretation, personally I just can't see the theme of 9/11 outside of Variations, but it's entirely possible that that's just me

@LingusDaDingus

3 жыл бұрын

He mentioned it in dream sweet in sea major

Mucka blucka is so deep, really hits me in the feels, with its amazing lyrics

I really want a Break It Down remake where all the members (including Ross and maaaaybe Bora) sing.

Hawaii part || lore: JoeJoe's tropical adventure

Holy shit, this was an amazing video, as Andrew said "keep up the good work!" You're giving me even more hope for a reunion...

@gary.mp5

4 жыл бұрын

I'd like to become a chair

That was a beutiful ending. Describing what the best album that can ever be made would be like, and then realizing, it already exists, and is basically Tally Hall's third album.

@outerspaceproduction

3 ай бұрын

❤ yessss 😭🤣

the other day, joe retweeted something about a reunion, so we know he was either joking or wants it back. but the question is, do the others?

Hawaii Part I:(The Mind) Electric Boogaloo

0:27 Zubin also said Poggers on a livestream with Andrew

Even tally hall can’t count to three *valve crying in the back*

Hawaii: Part II is an interesting album, and not very many people seem to talk about it. Do you think you'll discuss it in length another time? Or is it just not worth it? It's seemingly spiked in popularity lately and I'm waiting for someone to talk about it and the songs. This video was really great though, keep up the good work :)

i love how it starts ok, then it somehow turned into a jojo reference

Yes, a new Tally Hall album would be nice, but what about more episodes of Tally Hall’s Internet Show? Or, maybe some sort of re-creation of an already existing episode? Dont get me wrong, I would die for a new TH album, but I also love the Internet Show :)

“Minimum Horowitz” Me: NOOOOO WE NEED ANDY

@ElementFreakYT

2 жыл бұрын

It’s just cause he’s not in that album (from the songwriting credits I saw). We Standrew Andrew

The third album has just become the Half Life 3 of Indie bands

when he said colour i was like bruh hawaii?? but now im like hawaii.

In the outro: “We been waiting forever” in Time Machine really rubs the salt in the wounds right?

I seriously wish i could live the dream with a Time Machine and go back to when tally hall toured

How did we go from tally hall to c o l o u r s to freaking NINE ELEVEN???

at 3:13 i was barely listening. I could only notice how andrew and joe are screaming in ross’ ears *HEY ROSS, WHATS UP?*

What about the 2019 single just a friend? I know its not an album but shouldnt that be at least mentioned as a possibility of a new album?

@ElementFreakYT

4 жыл бұрын

It’s not my favorite, so I didn’t include it. Also, it’s a cover

@Crimson_Dusk

4 жыл бұрын

It was recorded a while ago in the studio around the time of G&E and they just decided to release it now although again, it's not new

@psvmjohn

3 жыл бұрын

Didn’t they release the just a friend ep?

Great video ! Also I know it’s a joke, but TELL me a tally hall sea shanty wouldn’t be amazing

@ElementFreakYT

4 жыл бұрын

You’re telling me

i need greenest in my life

It's Joever

ok but that first idea was *amazing*

Still waiting in 2022... Never lose hope guys ✊

the last song of the album should be called Good Night because *YES* and it's just a reprise of Good Day lol

A light is out in my office

3 years and still waiting

Listen, all I'm saying is if we get new music videos I will no longer accept that this place as my mortal coil

It’s coming right guys… right guys?

bro it’s be golden if they came back with a 26 song long album and it’s just the saying every letter of the alphabet and it’s auto tuned

Hey I got news for you. Needlejuice opened pre orders for a vinyl of a good & evil And… *LIGHT AND NIGHT* yes light and night is now getting an official vinyl release

@ElementFreakYT

Жыл бұрын

Noice!

can't wait for tally hall to drop the 9/11 sea shantie track

2020? Tally Hall kpop perhaps?,that would be scary.

One of my favorite songs is A Lady because it is kinda a reprise of & because it uses its same melody (& is my first favorite but I first heard of them when I heard The Bidding on TikTok)

just let them do what they want. That's how we got good albums from them before

Cody from alternate history hub discusses indie band from 10 years ago. Excellent vid lol

great video! i’d love to see more tally hall related videos!

We need this.

Brilliant! I wouldn’t have thunk to expect a well thought essay on Tally Hall matters from an iFAC member, but I am pleasantly surprised (and subscribed!). This is great, brother; keep up the good work!

@ElementFreakYT

3 жыл бұрын

Glad you appreciate, welcome to the channel!

Imagine a better version of the Punk Rock version of The Whole World & You

4:24 if we got more than 15 seconds of bora the world would explode

When he started talking about 9/11 I instantly thought about variations on a cloud

i just found your channel, but i absolutely love your content. i like how well your humour blends in with more serious analysis and theories, also everything is very well put together

I hope tallyhall continues

I just want G&E and HPII pressed to cd I don't care who does it at this point I'd do it if I could

I really enjoyed this!

Banana woman

G R E E N E S T

I mean, a sea shanty would be neat

hally tall

Finish all of my friends! Do it! (no I'm Gonna Win doesn't count as the finished version )😠

2 is company but 3 is weezer

Welp.tally hall ain't returning. Time to make a fabloo band

I’m so happy I’m not the only one that listens to this

Wish they did all of my friends got a reprise, instead of robs new version.

hawaii part ii went unmentioned in this video. sinful. Edit: Oh wait a minute

The ending was hilarious!

not anymore 🥲

MAXIMUM Horowitz

@ElementFreakYT

4 жыл бұрын

The joke is, he wasn’t in that album

there will never be a 3rd tally hall album because they never learned how to count 😢

It sucks the last thing was in 2018, christs second coming hasnt happened so that means tally hall hasnt come yet. Lets hope that we get something, anything! Also yeah i would be happy to see welcome to tally hall again

tally halls record label posted a date/time 082622

ANOTHER MINUTE ANOTHER MINUTE ANOTHER MINUTE ANOTHER MINUTE ANOTHER MINUTE ANOTHER MINUTE

if you want more orange tie check out cojum dip im pretty sure its his band

@furiousmagician5912

3 жыл бұрын

it is!!!! cojum dip is really cool!!! ^_^

Lol Hawaii part 3 mabye???

poggers

WE MIGHT BE GETTING ONE #rallyhall

Ok I'm watching the last part of the video be4 it ends the joke is gonna be something like "oh wait that's just miracle musical" right? Edit ok I called it I just forgot what Hawaii part ii was called that's why it was just the name of the band but still it counts

@ElementFreakYT

3 жыл бұрын

Congrats on guessing the joke, I might’ve forecasted that too much

I think Color Be Gone would be cool for a third album also (I know) It's Just The Same

Yes

I swear I love TALLY HALL

how did i know you were just describing hawaii part II

I wish

god i hope so

i wonder if they still have the ties

@ElementFreakYT

3 жыл бұрын

Legitimate question

All I ask for is Color Be Gone

Wait a second

Psyched for hawaii: Part II Part III

I don’t think so bro

Isn't Hawaii part 2 a tallyhall album?

@ElementFreakYT

4 жыл бұрын

Technically not, it was a side project with only 4/5ths of the band. Still under the same sort of “family,” and it was created relatively shortly after good and evil, so a lot of people consider it as the third album

What about Just a friend?

@ElementFreakYT

3 жыл бұрын

Just a cover

@ausdorian3252

3 жыл бұрын

@@ElementFreakYT ok

please watch something besides jojo

@ElementFreakYT

4 жыл бұрын

No

Wow the ending was sad lol

Tally Hall come back!!!

but like they have five albums already 4 on the website and i forgot where the fifth was

I've seen a small album named just a friend from 2019.

@ElementFreakYT

3 жыл бұрын

It was a cover

they songsn will be very random with werid deep meanings every once in a while