Comparing old Vocaloid songs with their remakes
Музыка
I tried to pick a mix of popular songs and less known songs.
Cendrillon www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm4410647
Cendrillon (ReRec Ver.) • サンドリヨン (feat. Hatsune ...
Cendrillon 10th Anniversary • サンドリヨン(Cendrillon) 10t...
Hm? Ah, yes. www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm10122021
Hm? Ah, yes. (Glorious World ver.) : No official upload
Hm? Ah, yes. - 10th Anniversary - • え?あぁ、そう。- 10th Anniver...
Hyper Reality Show • Utsu-P - ハイパーリアリティショウ ...
Hyper Reality Show -HAPPYPILLS ver : No official upload
Albino • 【初音ミク】 アルビノ 【オリジナル!】 /...
Albino Re : No official upload
Albino revive • アルビノ -revive- / 初音ミク A...
The Intense Voice of Hatsune Miku (LONG VERSION) www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm11328911
The Intense Voice of Hatsune Miku (2018 Remake) • 初音ミクの激唱(2018Remake) - ...
Tranquilizer • [Hatsune Miku] トランキライザ...
Tranquilizer (2019 ver) • [Hatsune Miku] トランキライザ...
POP ENTRANCE • 【Hatsune Miku】POP ENTR...
POP ENTRANCE (iceQuarium mix) • POP ENTRANCE (iceQuari...
potato-head in wonderland • Utsu-P - potato-head i...
potato-head in wonderland (PTSD ver) open.spotify.com/intl-fr/trac...
potato-head in wonderland (Your Best ver) utsup.bandcamp.com/track/pota...
Mozaik Role • DECO*27 - モザイクロール feat...
Mozaik Role (Reloaded) • DECO*27 - モザイクロール (Rel...
Frontier www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm16788378
Frontier (2015 Rerecording ver.) piapro.jp/content/q4rdypstaok6...
Пікірлер: 61
Dios made more versions of Cendrillon but they're remixes, not remakes so they're not shown here. papiyon also made a MAYU version of Hm? Ah, yes. but it uses the instrumental of the Glorious World version so it counts as a cover, not a remake. There is a 3rd version of Hyper Reality Show published in February 2023 but I didn't show it here because it's almost identical to the original. irucaice made a Kotonoha Akane version of POP ENTRANCE but it uses the instrumental of the iceQuarium version so it counts as a cover, not a remake. The voicebank version used isn't confirmed for some of these songs and it's my guess based on how it sounds and what was available at the time. I initially was going to put the BPM only for songs where it changed but it felt weird to have it for only some of them so I ended up putting it for every song since I was counting it anyway to see if it changed.
@JacobLeviathan
8 ай бұрын
love ur vids sm, I can see the time and effort u put into these and it's clear you have a lot of love for vocaloid music! keep up the good work ❤
cendrillon remake sounds more well rounded, but ngl the old one was SOO iconic
@Kiki-mi1et
5 ай бұрын
The instrumental is pretty nice and it's well produced but i don't like the tuning for the remake :/ old rerec version>>>>>>.
@LeonLisowskii
3 ай бұрын
I actually really like a classical feel with the techno instrumentals that the older one had. It gave it more personality
@Kiki-mi1et
2 ай бұрын
@@LeonLisowskii Yeah, the previous iterations incorporated a strange fusion of techno and faux-operatic elements that would've clashed had Dios P been a lesser producer. That's the thing I love about Vocaloid music. Producers aren't afraid to take risks and, like you said, give songs a bit of personality.
@Lume_Loves_Chocolate
Ай бұрын
The remake is more ball dance accurate, but the og makes you feel like you're in the ball
@rei_hsym
21 сағат бұрын
I really hate the og, the 10th anniversary is so much better for me This song sounds better without techno beat stuff
initially i thought using Miku for mosaik role was a bit silly considering how iconic GUMI was for that song, but looking back i suppose Miku is kind of DECO*27's most used vocaloid nowadays so it makes sense
@nandi9902
7 ай бұрын
Yeah, but personally, it lost its old charm and kinda remade it using the mold that most of his songs how use. Still like him as an artist, but I personally find the original better
@phoenixwright824
7 ай бұрын
@@nandi9902 based opinion, i respect
@ikhwannuttaqwa5439
7 ай бұрын
i honestly forgot the original one was GUMI's "most used vocaloid nowadays" seems like understatement. i don't think he even touched any other vocaloid than miku in greater half of the decade
@dream-r8306
6 ай бұрын
@@nandi9902agreed
@dream-r8306
6 ай бұрын
Yea, I'll always prefer the original version just cause I love his tuning with GUMI, but the Miku version existing makes sense
My fav remake has got to be deep sea girl(yuuyu-p). The tuning and overall instrumental in the 2022 one had improved so much from the 2010 and it feels so much more emotional
My favorite glow-up is definitely Pop Entrance! It sounds so much fuller and well-balanced! The effect on Miku's voice works perfectly with the song, too.
i'm addicted to cendrillon help
Eh? A, Sou: *BLEEP* Glorious Version of "Eh? A, Sou": *MEOW* LOOLLLLL LMAO
@moronx_.1
23 күн бұрын
Fr😂
I actually really love the rough sound of the original E Aa Sou. The remade versions just don’t hit as hard
Fun fact: There’s a jazz/bossanova version of No Gekishou in Magical Mirai 2015 album! It’s for Miku’s 8th anniversary and honestly the song is so fun to listen to given the clashing of the smooth instrumental and Miku singing at the speed of light.
two breaths walking had a really good reloaded ver! i was wondering if you could cover it in another video
@yabe-kfptentacultist
7 ай бұрын
Thing is that one has entirely different lyrics. So it's more of a remix.
@mikagediary
7 ай бұрын
@@yabe-kfptentacultist deco only changed the lyrics for the last part and majority of the song has the same lyrics as before!
Why did nobody tell me the absolute masterpiece that is Albino?? Especially the 2019 version?? It immediately went into my playlist and I've been playing it on repeat ever since.
recently i listended to the original version of Anti Digitalism after only hearing the greatest shits version a certafied "damn bitch you loved like this" its not the same without the dramatic echo in the chorus man
@samgungsmartfridge
7 ай бұрын
I don't know if ppl doing this to other youtubers is annoying (if it is, please feel free to say it rlly) but hiiii thrdragongirl27!!1!!1!1!1!
Old Deco hit so much harder
Maybe if this gets a sequel you can include Paired Wintry Winds.
@tomatuteee
8 ай бұрын
there's a remake of wintry winds? do you have a link?
@Arysha_
8 ай бұрын
And a Masa song! this guy remade so many of his old works
@abraham-kun4144
8 ай бұрын
@@Arysha_ Yeah, The Fox's Wedding, Bunker Buster, Encantada, Chinese Dogma, Bannen, Impact Death Entity, Star Lily Dance Perfomance, etc.
@Rubidiium
8 ай бұрын
@@Arysha_YES
@bluestar3939
8 ай бұрын
@@tomatuteee Wintry Winds 2019 remake kzread.info/dash/bejne/gX9h28SpYNS4nJM.html
You should add Moon feat. Miku if you make a sequel. Iroha made another new version. And sadistic music factory too
Thank you for your work
I got better at telling which voicebank is used now so here is a comment that I write a few months after I made the video to correct some mistakes. Keep in mind that like I said in the pinned comment they aren't confirmed. Intense Voice remake is still V2 POP ENTRANCE original may be V3 Potato-head in wonderland remakes (both of them) are append solid For Hyper Reality Show (original and remake) I said V4X without precising, it's original, solid and English
i love both mozaik roles so much
7:20 I heard this song back when it was first released!
@Gatattooelle
6 ай бұрын
Me toooooo, and I hate the remake ;-; The original is more strong and I love it, but on Spotify there's only the remake Q^Q
UtsuP and cosMo@BousouP don't remake a song for 5 seconds challenge (impossible) (said with love tho)
You should make more cuz i actually discover many new producer from this
@Not_Kaitlyn
4 ай бұрын
Same
Okay imma comment which version I like most for each Original: Tranquilizer, Potato-Head In Wonderland, Mozaik Role Remake: Cendrillon, Hm? Ah Yes, Hyper Reality Show, Albino, The Intense Voice Of Hatsune Miku, Pop Entrance, Frontier Okay I did expect to prefer the remakes on most occassions since well the producer has more experience later on so it's usually more polished
MOZAIK ROLE IS BY DECO????!!
@fuck_youtube_handles
7 ай бұрын
RIGHT like it sounds so different from his current stuff, its so rock!
Où est-ce que tu as trouvé Albino Re ? J'ai pas réussi à trouver autre chose qu'un extrait dans le crossfade Gemini sur soundcloud 😥
@bluestar3939
8 ай бұрын
C'est un assez vieux CD donc je crois qu'il n'est plus en vente. Sinon il était dispo sur Amazon www.amazon.co.jp/Gemini-E-P-buzzG/dp/B00JTG5DAI
@Arysha_
8 ай бұрын
@@bluestar3939 Bon dieu maintenant je me demande comment tu fais pour être aussi précis.e dans tes vidéos ! Ce remake est bien caché 🫣 Merci 👍🏻
Olivia: 1:42 7:19 9:54 10:23
Omg i forgot this song existed!! 😩 5:51
Tbh I think ReRec Cendrillion is better than the other versions, I just like the vibrato in it
no aspirin? 😔
@bluestar3939
8 ай бұрын
I'll think about it for the next time
my favorite remake is the Electrostatic Human by Crusher
@bluestar3939
7 ай бұрын
Electrostatic Human is a song by Kairiki bear. If you're talking about a remix by a different artist then that's not what the video is about since it's about artists who reworked their own songs.